Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Date of Decision: 27.03.2026
FAO 382/2018
BHANU PRATAP SINGH & ANR
.....Appellants
Through: Mr. Rohit Nagar, Advocate
versus
UNION OF INDIA
Through:
+
.....Respondent
Ms. Ridhima Gaur, SP for UOI
FAO 543/2018
BHANU PRATAP SINGH & ANR
.....Appellants
Through: Mr. Rohit Nagar, Advocate
versus
UNION OF INDIA
Through:
.....Respondent
Ms. Ridhima Gaur, SP for UOI
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
CM APPL. 32618/2018 in FAO 382/2018 (delay of47 days in filing the
appeal)
1.
This is an application filed by the appellant seeking condonation of
delay of 47 days in filing of the appeal.
2.
For the reasons stated in the application, the delay of 47 days in filing
of the appeal is condoned.
3.
The application is disposed of accordingly.
CM APPL. 49919/2018 in FAO 543/2018 (delay of 01 day in filing the
appeal)
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:41:58
FAO 382/2018 & FAO 543/2018
1.
This is an application filed by the appellant seeking condonation of
delay of 01 day in filing of the appeal.
2.
For the reasons stated in the application, the delay of 01 day in filing
of the appeal is condoned.
3.
The application is disposed of accordingly.
FAO 382/2018&FAO 543/2018
1.
The present set of appeals arise out of the judgment/ order dated
22.03.2018, passed by the learned Railway Claims Tribunal, Principal
Bench, Delhi (hereinafter referred to as the “Tribunal”), in OA No.
167/2017, as well as the consequential order dated 27.06.2018. While FAO
382/2018 has been filed by the appellants assailing the dismissal of the
claim petition, the connected appeal, i.e., FAO 543/2018 challenges the
initiation of proceedings under Section 340 of Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973 (hereinafter “CrPC”) arising out of the same proceedings.
As common submissions have been addressed, both the appeals are taken
up together for consideration, and are being dealt with by way of a common
judgment.
2.
Briefly, the appellants had preferred a claim petition before the
learned Tribunal seeking compensation on account of the death of one Atul
Pratap (hereinafter referred to as the “deceased”), who was stated to have
died in an incident of accidental fall from a running train while travelling
from Lucknow to New Delhi. It was the case of the appellants that the
deceased was travelling as a bona fide passenger on a valid journey
ticketand, on account of a sudden jerk, while he was standing near the door
of the compartment, he fell from the train and sustained fatal injuries, due to
which, he died on spot.
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:41:58
FAO 382/2018 & FAO 543/2018
3.
The claim petition came to be dismissed by the Tribunal vide
judgment/order dated 22.03.2018, on the ground that the appellants had
failed to establish the genuineness of the journey ticket, as well as the
circumstances in which the alleged incident had occurred. While returning
the said findings, the Tribunal also issued a show cause notice to the
appellants as to why proceedings under Section 340 CrPC should not
initiated against them.
Pursuant to the reply submitted by the appellants, and after due
consideration, the Tribunal, vide order dated 27.06.2018, directed initiation
of proceedings by lodging a complaint before the concerned Judicial
Magistrate.
4.
Insofar as the challenge to the dismissal of the claim petition is
concerned, the principal issue that the Tribunal dealt with was the
inconsistency as to how the journey was undertaken, as pleaded by the
appellants, and the location where the body of the deceased was recovered.
The appellants had set up a case that the deceased was travelling from
Lucknow to New Delhi on the strength of a journey ticket bearing No.
46359950.A perusal of the said ticket, however, revealed that the route
reflected therein was via Kanpur - Ghaziabad - Tilak Bridge, whereas the
body of the deceased was found between Pilkhuwa and Dasna, which does
not fall on the said route, and this discrepancy was not a minor irregularity
but went to the root of the matter, as the very foundation of the claim rested
upon the deceased being a bona fide passenger travelling on the said ticket.
5.
It is further evident from the record that an attempt was made to
suggest that the deceased may have travelled through an alternate route.
However, no such assertion finds mention in the claim application and also,
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:41:58
FAO 382/2018 & FAO 543/2018
no amendment was sought at any stage to incorporate such a plea, nor was
any material placed on record to substantiate the same. The appellants
remained confined to the original case as set up before the Tribunal.
6.
In these circumstances, the Tribunal cannot be faulted for examining
the case strictly on the basis of the pleadings and evidence as presented. It is
trite that a party cannot be permitted to travel beyond its pleadings, or
improve its case at a later stage without laying the necessary foundation. The
suggestion of an alternate route in the absence of any pleading or supporting
materialwas therefore rightly not accepted, as the said submission cannot be
permitted to be raised for the first time at this stage in the absence of any
such case having been set up before the Tribunal. Hence, accepting such a
contention would amount to allowing the appellants to reconstruct their case
at the appellate stage, which is impermissible.
7.
Apart from the aforesaid discrepancy, the Tribunal has also taken note
of other surrounding circumstances, including the absence of any clear
particulars regarding the train by which the deceased was travelling and the
manner in which the identity of the deceased was established at the site. The
Tribunal has, on a cumulative appreciation of these factors, returned a
finding that the appellants failed to establish that the deceased was travelling
as a bonafide passenger or that the incident in question was an “untoward
incident” within the meaning of the Railways Act, 1989.
8.
Having considered the reasoning of the Tribunal in the light of the
material placed on record, this Court finds that the view taken is a plausible
one. The discrepancy relating to the route of travel, coupled with the
absence of pleadings regarding any alternate route constitutes a valid basis
for the conclusions that are drawn by the Tribunal. It cannot, therefore, be
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:41:58
FAO 382/2018 & FAO 543/2018
said that the findings suffer from perversity or warrant interference in
appellate jurisdiction.
9.
In view of the above, this Court finds no ground to interfere with the
dismissal of the claim petition, and remains confined to the correctness of
the said order. The appeal, insofar as it assails the impugned order dated
22.03.2018 on merits, is accordingly dismissed.
10.
This then brings the Court to the challenge laid to the initiation of
proceedings under Section 340 CrPC. A perusal of the orders dated
22.03.2018 and 27.06.2018 would show that after dismissing the claim
petition, the Tribunal proceeded to issue notice to the appellants and
thereafter, upon considering their reply, formed a prima facie view that the
journey ticket relied upon by them was fabricated, and that its production
amounted to a deliberate attempt to mislead the Court.
11.
The reasoning of the Tribunal in this regard is essentially founded on
the discrepancy relating to the route of travel. The Tribunal has also referred
to the availability of specific trains on the said route, and has rejected the
explanation offered by the appellants that the deceased may have boarded
another train by mistake observing that there was no scope for such an
eventuality.
12.
While these aspects were undoubtedly relevant for the purpose of
examining the validity of the claim petition, and were sufficient to
disbelieve the case set up by the appellants, the question that arises is
whether the samecould justify a finding of deliberate fabrication of evidence
so as to warrant initiation of proceedings under Section 340 CrPC.
13.
The scope of Section 340 CrPC is well settled. It is not every incorrect
or inconsistent statement which would warrant initiation of prosecution,
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:41:58
FAO 382/2018 & FAO 543/2018
rather there must be material to indicate a deliberate and conscious attempt
to give false evidence and, even then, the Court must form an opinion that it
is in the interest of justice to proceed in the matter. There is a word of
caution inbuilt in that provision itself that the action to be taken should be
expedient in the nature of justice. Therefore, it is incumbent that the power
given by Section 340 CrPC should be used with utmost care and after due
consideration. (Ref:K.T.M.S. Mohd. and Anr. vs. Union of India)1.
14.
In the present case, the appellants are the parents of the deceased and
were not accompanying him at the time of the journey. Their case, as set up
in the claim application, is evidently based on their understanding of the fact
that the deceased might have taken an alternative route, and the surrounding
information available to them. The same, though not accepted by the
Tribunal for the purpose of sustaining the claim, cannotbe construed as a
deliberate attempt to fabricate evidence. The conclusion regarding
fabrication of the ticket is not based on any independent material, but is
essentially an inference drawn from the discrepancy in the route of travel
and the attendant circumstances noticed by the Tribunal.In such
circumstances, the appellants would be entitled to the benefit of doubt,
insofar as initiation of proceedings under Section 340 CrPC are concerned.
15.
In these circumstances, this Court is of the considered view that the
requirement of forming an opinion that it is expedient in the interest of
justice to initiate proceedings under Section 340 CrPC has not been
satisfied. The directions issued by the Tribunal, therefore, cannot be
sustained.
(1992) 3 SCC 178
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:41:58
FAO 382/2018 & FAO 543/2018
16.
Accordingly, the appeals challenging the orders dated 22.03.2018 and
27.06.2018 respectively, to the extent they direct initiation of proceedings
under Section 340 CrPC, are allowed and the said directions are set aside.
(MANOJ KUMAR OHRI)
JUDGE
MARCH 27,2026
kk
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:41:58
FAO 382/2018 & FAO 543/2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review