Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:1017
WP No. 100119 of 2026
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 28TH DAY OF JANUARY 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE K.S.HEMALEKHA
WRIT PETITION NO. 100119 OF 2026 (S-REG)
BETWEEN:
1.
BHAIRU S/O. KRISHNA AMBOLE
AGE: 60 YEARS, OCC: CLEANER,
CITY MUNCIPAL COUNCIL NIPPANI,
R/O. ASHRAYA NAGAR, NIPPANI,
TQ: NIPANI, DIST: BELAGAVI-591237.
2.
SUBHAS S/O. ATMARAM KAMBLE
AGE: 47 YEARS, OCC: ASSISTANT,
CITY MUNCIPAL COUNCIL NIPPANI,
R/O. NIPPANI, TQ: NIPANI,
DIST: BELAGAVI-591237.
3.
MADHUKAR S/O. TUKARAM MADALE
AGE: 63 YEARS, OCC: POURA KARMIKA,
CITY MUNCIPAL COUNCIL NIPPANI,
R/O. ASHRAYA NAGAR, NIPPANI,
TQ: NIPANI, DIST: BELAGAVI-591237.
4.
HIMMATSINGH S/O. VIJAYSINGH RAJPUT
AGE: 48 YEARS, OCC: DRIVER,
CITY MUNCIPAL COUNCIL NIPPANI,
R/O. SHINTRE COLONY, NIPPANI,
TQ: NIPANI, DIST: BELAGAVI-591237.
MANJANNA
E
MANJANNA E
Location: HIGH COURT
OF KARNATAKA
DHARWAD BENCH
Date: 2026.02.02
10:00:21 +0530
…PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. SHIVARAJ P. MUDHOL AND
MISS. SANJANA S.MUDHOL, ADVOCATES)
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:1017
WP No. 100119 of 2026
HC-KAR
AND:
1.
THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY,
DEPARMENT OF HOUSING AND URBAN
DEVELOPMENT, M.S.BUILDING, BENGALURU-1.
2.
THE DIRECTOR OF MUNCIPAL ADMINISTRAION
VISVESWARAYYA TOWER,
DR. AMBEDKAR VEEDI, BENGALURU-1.
3.
THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
BELAGAVI, DIST: BELAGAVI-590001.
4.
THE CITY MUNCIPAL COUNCIL
NIPANI, REPRESENTED BY ITS COMMISSIONER,
TQ: NIPPANI, DIST: BELAGAVI-591237.
5.
THE PROJECT DIRECTOR
DISTRICT URBAN DEVELOPMENT CELL,
BELAGAVI-590001.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SMT. NANDINI B.SOMAPUR, AGA FOR R1 TO R3 AND R5;
SRI. R.K.KULKARNI, ADVOCATE FOR R4)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227
OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO ISSUE WRIT IN THE
NATURE OF CERTIORARI TO QUASH THE IMPUGNED ENDORSEMENT
DATED 5/11/2025 IN NO. 1268234/DMA/EST2/DWE/53/2023/3038
ISSUED BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT VIDE ANNEXURE-Q AND IMPUGNED
ENDORSEMENT DATED 5/11/2025 IN NO. 1268234/DMA/EST2/ DWE/
53/2023/3037 ISSUED BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT VIDE ANNEXURE-Q1
AND ETC.
THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING THIS
DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM:
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE K.S.HEMALEKHA
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:1017
WP No. 100119 of 2026
HC-KAR
ORAL ORDER
The petitioners are before this Court seeking to quash
the
impugned
respondents
endorsement/
authorities,
order
whereby
the
passed
by
the
claim
of
the
petitioners for regularization of service has been rejected.
Brief Facts;
2.
The petitioners were appointed on daily basis for
the posts under respondents as a City Municipal Council
several
decades
ago
and
have
been
continuously
discharging duties against the sanction and perennial post.
It is the case of the petitioners that they have rendered
uninterrupted service for more than two decades and, in
fact has put in more than 25-30 years of service. The
nature of work performed by the petitioners is permanent in
nature and essential to the functioning of the local body.
The petitioners were extended the benefit of equal pay for
equal work, thereby acknowledging the long standing and
continuous nature of employment. It is submitted that
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:1017
WP No. 100119 of 2026
HC-KAR
despite earlier directions issued by this Court to consider
the petitioners’ claim for regularization, the respondents’
authorities have rejected the claim by the impugned
endorsement, solely on the ground that the petitioners have
not completed 10 years of service as on 10.04.2006.
Placing reliance on the judgment of the Apex Court in the
case of Secretary, State of Karnataka and Others Vs.
Umadevi and Others1 (Umadevi). Aggrieved by the said
rejection, the petitioners have approached this Court in this
petition.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that
the impugned endorsement is vitiated by a total nonapplication of mind and suffers from arbitrariness. It is
contended
that
the
respondents
authorities
are
mechanically relied upon Umadevi, ignoring subsequent
authoritative pronouncement of the Apex Court and this
Court, which have clarified that 10.04.2006 is not a rigid or
inflexible cut-off date. The petitioners have placed reliance
(2006) 4 SCC 1
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:1017
WP No. 100119 of 2026
HC-KAR
on the judgment of this Court in the case of Nagesh S/o.
Hanamant Pujeri and Others Vs. State of Karnataka
and Others2 (Nagesh) and in the case of Ramu S/o.
Hanumanth
Kurbar
Vs.
State
of
Karnataka
and
Others3 (Ramu). As well as the judgment of the Apex Court
in the case of Shripal Vs. Nagar Nigam4 (Shirpal),
wherein it has been categorically held that the long serving
daily wage employees appointed against sanctioned post
and
discharging
perennial
duties
are
entitled
to
consideration for regularization, notwithstanding the date of
completion of ten years of service. Learned counsel submits
that the petitioners' case stands on a very strong footing, as
the length of service exceeds 25 years, the employment
was
not
protected
by
any
interim
order
and
the
respondents-local body itself has admitted the continuous
service. It is contended that denial of regularization in such
W.P. No.105364/2025 & connected Matters D.D. 15.10.2025
W.P. No.107918/2023 D.D. 26.11.2025
2025 SSC OnLine SC 221
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:1017
WP No. 100119 of 2026
HC-KAR
circumstances amounts to exploitation and violates Articles
14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
4.
Learned counsel for the respondents justifies the
impugned order.
5.
This Court has given its anxious consideration to
the submission made by the learned counsel for the parties
and has carefully perused the material placed on record.
6.
The particulars of appointment of the petitioners
as follows:
Sl.
No.
Name of the
Petitioners
Date of
appointment
Date and years
completion of 10
years of service from
the date of initiation
appointment.
Bhairu Ambole
(cleaner)
01/09/1991
1/9/2001.
(35 years of service)
Subhas kamble
(Assistant)
01/08/1998
1/8/2008.
(28 years of service)
Madhukar Madhule
(sweeper/poura
karmika)
01/6/1997
1/6/2007.
(29 years of service
now retired.)
Himmatsingh
Rajput (driver)
01/09/1996
1/9/2006.
(30 years of service)
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:1017
WP No. 100119 of 2026
HC-KAR
7.
The foundational facts are not in dispute. The
petitioners have rendered long and continuous service for
more than two decades under the respondents-Municipal
Council. The work performed by the petitioners is perennial
in nature and essential for the functioning of the local body.
The respondents themselves have extended the benefit of
equal pay for equal work, thereby acknowledging the
continuity and indispensability of petitioners’ service. The
sole ground on which the petitioners’ claim have been
rejected is that the petitioners have not completed 10 years
of service as on 10.04.2006, the date of the judgment in
Umadevi.
It
is
germane
circumstances this Court
to
notice
in WP
that
in
identical
No.107774/2023
and
connected matters concerning a different Municipal Council
has directed regularization of those petitioners by following
order;
12. “The afore-narrated facts are not in dispute,
they are all a matter of record, the dates link in the chain
of events, the appointment of the petitioners, are all
again a matter of record and undisputed facts. The
petitioners have as on today rendered 33, 29, 28 & 26
years respectively in the 4th respondent - Municipality,
be it in the cadre of cleaner, sweeper, poura karmika or a
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:1017
WP No. 100119 of 2026
HC-KAR
driver, nonetheless they are all working in the 4th
respondent-Municipality, from the respective dates of
their appointment. Uninterruptedly, till 2025
i.e.,
today, the employment of these petitioners, are not
litigious as their services are never continued on the
basis of any interim order granted at the hands of this
Court. They are in continuous employment owing their
necessity in the 4th respondent- Municipality and the
necessity still prevails. The 4th respondent has filed its
statement of objections, where it is admitted that the
petitioners are working from the dates of the respective
engagements till today. The contention of the State that
regularization orders should not be passed for the
asking is noted only to be rejected as these petitioners
have toiled in the 4th respondent - Municipality at their
prime luth right from 33 years, 26 years respectively.
Today, they are all aged between 56 to 60 years. If today
they are sent home without any benefit of regularization,
they would be wondering in their retired life.
13. In identical circumstances, the Apex Court in
the case of Shripal vs. Nagar Nigam reported in 2025
SSC OnLine SC 221 has held as follows:
“3. The factual matrix leading
the appeal before us is as follows:
up
to
The Appellant Workmen claim to have
been engaged as Gardeners (Malis) in the
Horticulture
Department of the Respondent
Employer, Ghaziabad Nagar Nigam, since the year
1998 (in some instances, since 1999). According
to them, they continuously discharged horticultural
and maintenance duties— such as planting trees,
maintaining parks, and beautifying public spaces—
under the direct supervision of the Respondent
Employer. They further allege that no formal
appointment letters were ever issued to them, and
that they were persistently denied minimum wages,
weekly offs, national holidays, and other statutory
benefits.
In 2004, the Appellant Workmen,
along
with
many
other
similarly
situated
employees, raised an industrial dispute (C.B. Case
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:1017
WP No. 100119 of 2026
HC-KAR
No. 6 of 2004) before the Conciliation Officer at
Ghaziabad, seeking regularization of their services
and the requisite statutory benefits. They contend
that, upon learning of this demand, the
Respondent Employer began delaying their salaries
and subjected them to adverse working conditions.
Eventually, around mid-July 2005, the services of
numerous workmen were allegedly terminated
orally, without any notice, written orders, or
retrenchment compensation.
Since the above termination took place
during
the
pendency
of
the
conciliation
proceedings, the Appellant Workmen argue it
violated Section 6E of the U.P. Industrial Disputes
Act, 1947. Consequently, the State Government
referred the
disputes
concerning both (i)
regularization and
(ii) legality of the alleged termination, to the
Labour Court, Ghaziabad for adjudication.
The Labour Court proceeded to decide
the references vide two orders:
(i)
Order dated 03.06.2011 : In numerous
adjudication cases (e.g., Adjudication Case
Nos. 448, 451, 467 of 2006, etc.), the Labour
Court
passed
awards
holding
the
terminations illegal for want of compliance
with Section 6N of the U.P. Industrial
Disputes
Act,
1947,
and
directed
reinstatement with 30% back wages.
(ii)
Order dated 11.10.2011 : However, in
about 41 other adjudication cases (e.g.,
Adjudication Case Nos. 269, 270, 272,
etc.), the Labour Court arrived at a
contrary conclusion, dismissing the claims
on the finding that the concerned workmen
had not been engaged directly by the Nagar
Nigam but rather through a contractor, and
hence
had
no
enforceable
right
to
reinstatement or regularization against the
Respondent Employer.
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1017
WP No. 100119 of 2026
HC-KAR
Aggrieved by the adverse portion of the
awards (i.e., those granting reinstatement), the
Respondent Employer, Ghaziabad Nagar Nigam,
filed several writ petitions before the High Court of
Judicature at Allahabad, challenging the Labour
Court's findings. On the other hand, the workmen
whose claims were dismissed by the other set of
awards also approached the High Court by filing
their own writ petitions. All these writ petitions
were heard together, culminating in the common
judgment dated 01.03.2019, which partly modified
the Labour Court's conclusions.
Through the impugned judgment, the
High Court held that while the Labour Court
was correct in exercising jurisdiction under
the U.P. Industrial Disputes Act (since
municipalities could be treated as “industry”),
there remained factual complexities as to
whether the workmen were genuinely on the
rolls of the Nagar Nigam or were provided by
contractors. The High Court also noted that
the
State
Government
had,
by
notifications/orders, placed a ban on fresh
recruitments
in
Municipal
Corporations,
thereby restricting direct appointments to any
post.
Ultimately, the High Court partially
modified the relief granted, directing reengagement of the workmen on daily wages,
with pay equivalent to the minimum in the
regular pay scale of Gardeners, while allowing
future consideration of their regularization if
permissible by law.
4.
Both the Appellant Workmen and the
Respondent Employer have now approached this
Court by way of Special Leave Petitions. The
workmen primarily seek full reinstatement with
back wages and a direction to secure their
regularization, whereas the Respondent Employer
seeks to quash the modifications ordered by the
High Court on the ground that the High Court
exceeded its jurisdiction by granting partial relief
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1017
WP No. 100119 of 2026
HC-KAR
akin
to
regular
employees,
contrary
to
constitutional provisions and the State's ban on
recruitment.
5.
Learned counsel for the Appellant
Workmen made the following submissions:
I.
Continuous Service & Comparable Duties
: The Appellant Workmen had continuously
discharged horticultural and maintenance
duties— like planting trees, upkeep of public
parks, and general beautification—under the
direct supervision and control of the
Respondent Employer for periods often
exceeding a decade. They insist such
longstanding, continuous work parallels that
of permanent Gardeners.
II.
Direct
Engagement
&
Wage
Disbursement : They aver that their
wages, though inadequate, were paid
directly by the Horticulture Department of
the Respondent Employer, nullifying the
Employer's claim of contractual hiring.
Muster rolls and internal notes are cited to
show direct employer-employee relations.
III. Illegal Termination : Alleging violation of
Sections 6E and 6N of the U.P. Industrial
Disputes Act, 1947, the Appellant Workmen
maintain their abrupt termination in July
2005 (during pendency of conciliation
proceedings) was devoid of due process and
statutory payments, rendering it patently
illegal.
IV.
Entitlement
to
Reinstatement
&
Regularization : Given their long service
and the principle of “equal pay for equal
work,” the Appellant Workmen submit they
deserve full reinstatement with back wages
and a legitimate pathway to regularization,
as opposed to the partial relief of mere dailywage re-engagement prescribed by the High
Court.
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1017
WP No. 100119 of 2026
HC-KAR
6.
On the other, the learned counsel for
the Respondent Employer, Ghaziabad Nagar Nigam
made the following submissions:
I.
Compliance
with
Constitutional
Requirements:
Emphasizing
the
constitutional scheme of public employment,
it is urged that there was (and remains) a
ban on fresh recruitment in Municipal
Corporations, and no proper selection
process was ever followed to appoint the
Workmen on any sanctioned posts.
II.
No
Direct
Employer-Employee
Relationship : The Respondent Employer
contends that all horticulture work was
carried out through independent contractors
appointed via tender processes. It claims any
partial wage documentation cited by the
Workmen
fails
to
establish
direct
engagement.
III.
Inapplicability
of
Regularization :
Relying on Secretary, State of Karnataka v.
Umadevi1, it is asserted that no daily
wager can claim permanent absorption
without
adherence
to
constitutional
requirements and availability of duly
sanctioned vacancies.
IV.
Inadequate Proof of 240 Days' Service
: The Respondent Employer points out that
the
Workmen
did
not
convincingly
demonstrate they completed 240 days of
continuous work in any calendar year, thus
undermining
the
assertion
that
their
cessation from service was illegal.
V.
Challenge to Modified Relief: Finally, it
argues that the High Court's direction to pay
minimum-scale wages and to consider the
Workmen for future regularization oversteps
legal boundaries, disregards the recruitment
ban, and fosters an impermissible avenue of
public
employment.
The
Respondent
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1017
WP No. 100119 of 2026
HC-KAR
Employer, therefore, seeks the quashing of
the impugned judgment.
7.
Having heard the arguments and
submissions of the learned counsel for the parties
and having perused the record, this Court is of
the considered opinion that the nature of
engagement of the Appellant Workmen, the
admitted shortage of Gardeners, and the
circumstances under which their services were
brought to an end, merit closer scrutiny.
8.
It is undisputed that, while the
Appellant
Workmen
were
pressing
for
regularization and proper wages through pending
conciliation proceedings, the Respondent Employer
proceeded to discontinue their services, without
issuing prior notice or granting retrenchment
compensation. At this juncture, it is to have a look
at the requirements of Section 6E of the U.P.
Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 which has been
reproduced hereunder:—
“6E. [Conditions of service, etc. to remain
unchanged in certain circumstances during the
pendency of proceedings. [Inserted by U.P. Act No.
1 of 1957.]
(1)
During the pendency of any conciliation
proceeding before a Conciliation Officer or a Board
or of any proceeding before a Labour Court or
Tribunal in respect of an industrial dispute, no
employer shall,
(a)
in regard to any matter connected with the
dispute, alter, to the prejudice of the
workmen concerned in such dispute, the
conditions of service applicable to them
immediately before the commencement of
such proceeding, or
(b)
for any misconduct connected with the
dispute, discharge or punish, whether by
dismissal
or
otherwise
any
workman
concerned in such dispute save with the
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1017
WP No. 100119 of 2026
HC-KAR
express permission in writing of the authority
before which the proceeding is pending.
(2)
During the pendency of any such proceeding
in respect of an industrial dispute, the employer
may, in accordance with the standing orders
applicable to a workman concerned in such dispute,
(a)
alter, in regard to any matter not connected
with the dispute, the conditions of service
applicable
to
that
workman
immediately before the commencement of
such proceeding, or
(b)
for any misconduct not connected with the
dispute, discharge or punish, whether by
dismissal or otherwise:
Provided that no such workman shall be
discharged or dismissed, unless he has been paid
wages for one month and an application has been
made by the employer to the authority before
which the proceeding is pending for approval of
the action taken by the employer.
(3)
Notwithstanding anything contained in subsection (2) no employer shall during the pendency
of any such proceeding in respect of an industrial
dispute, take any action against any protected
workman concerned in such dispute, (a)
by altering, to the prejudice of such protected
workman, the conditions of service applicable
to
him
immediately
before
the
commencement of such proceeding, or
(b)
by discharging or punishing, whether by
dismissal or otherwise, such protected
workman, such with the express permission
in writing of the authority before which the
proceeding is pending. Explanation. - For the
purposes of this sub-section, a ‘protected
workman’ in relation to an establishment,
means a workman who, being an officer of a
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1017
WP No. 100119 of 2026
HC-KAR
registered trade union connected with the
establishment, is recognized as such in
accordance with rules made in this behalf.
(4)
In every establishment, the number of
workmen to be recognized as protected workmen
for the purposes of sub-section (3) shall not exceed
one per cent of the total number of workmen
employed therein subject to a minimum number of
five protected workmen and a maximum number
of one hundred protected workmen and for the
aforesaid purpose, the State Government may
make rules providing for the distribution of such
protected workmen among various trade unions, if
any, connected with the establishment and the
manner in which they may be chosen and
recognized as protected workmen.
(5)
Where an employer makes an application to
a Board, Labour Court or Tribunal under the proviso
to sub-section (2) for approval of the action taken
by him, the authority concerned shall, without
delay,
hear such application and pass, as
expeditiously as possible, such order in relation
thereto as it deems fit.”
9.
On a plain reading of this section,
we can deduce that any unilateral alteration
in service conditions, including termination, is
impermissible during the pendency of such
proceedings unless prior approval is obtained
from the appropriate authority. The record in
the present case does not indicate that the
Respondent Employer ever sought or was
granted the requisite approval. Prima facie,
therefore, this conduct reflects a deliberate
attempt to circumvent the lawful claims of
the workmen, particularly when their dispute
over regularization and wages remained sub
judice.
10. The Respondent Employer consistently
labelled the Appellant Workmen as casual
employees (or workers engaged through an
unnamed contractor), yet there is no material proof
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1017
WP No. 100119 of 2026
HC-KAR
of adherence to Section 6N of the U.P. Industrial
Disputes Act, 1947, which mandates a proper
notice or wages in lieu thereof as well as
retrenchment compensation. In this context,
whether an individual is classified as regular or
temporary is irrelevant as retrenchment obligations
under the Act must be met in all cases attracting
Section 6N. Any termination thus effected without
statutory safeguards cannot be undertaken lightly.
11.
xxxx
12.
xxxx
13.
xxxx
14. The Respondent Employer places
reliance on Umadevi (supra)2 to contend that
daily-wage or temporary employees cannot
claim permanent absorption in the absence of
statutory rules providing such absorption.
However,
as
frequently reiterated, Uma
Devi
itself
distinguishes
between
appointments that are “illegal” and those that
are “irregular,” the latter being eligible for
regularization if
they
meet
certain
conditions.
More importantly, Uma Devi
cannot serve as a shield to justify exploitative
engagements persisting for years without the
Employer undertaking legitimate recruitment.
Given the record which shows no true
contractor-based
arrangement
and
a
consistent need for permanent horticultural
staff the alleged asserted ban on fresh
recruitment, though real, cannot justify
indefinite daily-wage status or continued
unfair practices.
15. It is manifest that the Appellant
Workmen
continuously
rendered
their
services over several years, sometimes
spanning more than a decade. Even if certain
muster rolls were not produced in full, the
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1017
WP No. 100119 of 2026
HC-KAR
Employer's failure to furnish such records—
despite directions to do so—allows an
adverse inference under well-established
labour jurisprudence. Indian labour law
strongly disfavors perpetual daily-wage or
contractual engagements in circumstances
where the work is permanent in nature.
Morally and legally, workers who fulfil
ongoing municipal requirements year after
year cannot be dismissed summarily as
dispensable, particularly in the absence of a
genuine contractor agreement. At this
juncture, it would be appropriate to recall the
broader critique of indefinite “temporary”
employment practices as done by a recent
judgment of this court in Jaggo v. Union of
India3 in the following paragraphs:
“xxxxxxxxx”
16.
xxx
17.
xxx
18. The impugned order of the High Court,
to the extent they confine the Appellant Workmen
to future daily- wage engagement without
continuity or meaningful back wages, is hereby set
aside with the following directions:
I.
The
discontinuation
of
the
Appellant
Workmen's
services,
effected
without
compliance with Section 6E and Section 6N
of the U.P. Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, is
declared
illegal.
All
orders
or
communications terminating their services
are quashed. In consequence, the Appellant
Workmen shall be treated as continuing in
service from the date of their termination,
for all purposes, including seniority and
continuity in service.
II.
The Respondent Employer shall reinstate the
Appellant Workmen in their respective
posts (or posts akin to the duties they
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1017
WP No. 100119 of 2026
HC-KAR
previously performed) within four weeks
from the date of this judgment. Their entire
period of absence (from the date of
termination until actual reinstatement) shall
be counted for continuity of service and all
consequential benefits, such as seniority
and eligibility for promotions, if any.
III. Considering the length of service, the
Appellant Workmen shall be entitled to
50% of the back wages from the date of
their discontinuation until their actual
reinstatement.
The
Respondent
Employer shall clear the aforesaid dues
within three months from the date of
their reinstatement.
IV.
The Respondent Employer is directed to
initiate a fair and transparent process
for regularizing the Appellant Workmen
within six months from the date of
reinstatement, duly considering the fact
that they have performed perennial
municipal duties akin to permanent
posts. In assessing regularization, the
Employer shall not impose educational
or procedural criteria retroactively if
such requirements were never applied
to the Appellant Workmen or to
similarly situated regular employees in
the
past.
To
the
extent
that
sanctioned vacancies for such duties
exist or are required, the Respondent
Employer shall expedite all necessary
administrative processes to ensure
these long-time employees are not
indefinitely retained on daily wages
contrary to statutory and equitable
norms.
19. In view of the above, the appeal(s)
filed by the workmen are allowed, whereas the
appeal(s) filed by the Nagar Nigam Ghaziabad are
dismissed.”
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1017
WP No. 100119 of 2026
HC-KAR
(Emphasis supplied)”
The Apex Court was considering the cases of those
persons, who are appointed on work charged
establishment, the petitioners are similarly situated. The
Apex Court was considering the cases where services
were terminated, re-instated, pursuant to the orders of
the Labour Court therein. Nonetheless, the Apex Court
observes that they are in continuous employment for over
3 decades there and directs regularization. The
petitioners in the case at hand are in service for more
than 3 decades in certain cases and close to 3 decades in
certain cases. In that light, the claim of the petitioners
could not have been denied on a spacious plea that there
is no resolution of the Town Municipal Council appended
to the requisition to the Deputy Commissioner.
14.
The Town Municipal Council has filed its
objections accepting the fact that the petitioners are in
employment throughout. If that be so, the very reason
rendered by the Deputy Commissioner may be inter
alia. But one of the reasons rendered is unacceptable, nor
the rejection of the applications of the petitioners, is
acceptable.
15.
For the aforesaid reasons, the following:
ORDER
i.
Petitions are allowed.
ii.
The impugned order dated 24.03.2023
passed by the 3rd respondent vide
Annexure-S in W.P.No.107774/2023,
the impugned order dated 27.10.2022
passed by the 3rd respondent vide
Annexure-S in W.P.No.100470/2023,
the impugned order dated 27.10.2022
passed by the 3rd respondent vide
Annexure-P in W.P.No.100471/2023 &
the impugned order dated 27.10.2022
passed by the 3rd respondent vide
Annexure-S in W.P.No.100477/2023
stand quashed.
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1017
WP No. 100119 of 2026
HC-KAR
iii.
8.
Mandamus
issues
directing
the
respondents Nos.1 to 4 to consider
regularization of the services of the
petitioners, with all consequential
benefits, within 3 months from the
date of receipt of a copy of the order.”
The aforesaid direction in W.P. No.107774/2023,
the impugned endorsement hinges upon the judgment of
the Apex Court in the case of Umadevi stated supra, which
has stood distinguished by subsequent judgment of the
Apex Court.
9.
This Court in Nagesh and again in Ramu, has
categorically held that the cut-off date 10.04.2006 cannot
be treated as an absolute bar to regularization, particularly
in cases where the employees have rendered long years of
continuous service against sanctioned posts. The said view
stands fortified by the judgment of the Apex Court in
Shirpal
stated
supra,
wherein
it
has
observed
that
Umadevi cannot be used as a shield to perpetuate
exploitative employment and that irregular appointments as
- 21 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1017
WP No. 100119 of 2026
HC-KAR
opposed
to
illegal
appointments,
are
amenable
to
regularization when the conditions are satisfied.
10.
In the present case, the petitioners satisfies all
the parameters laid in the aforesaid judgment.
i.
Appointment against sanctioned post.
ii.
Performance of perennial duties on a permanent
basis.
iii.
Long and uninterrupted service extending over
decades and
iv.
Absence of any protective interim orders.
11.
The impugned endorsement reflects a mechanical
exercise
undertaken
without
considering
the
binding
precedents cited by the petitioners. Such an action is
arbitrary, suffers from non-application of mind and is liable
to be interfered with under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India. This Court is therefore of the considered view that
the rejection of the petitioners’ claim for regularization is
illegal and unsustainable. The petitioners are entitled to
- 22 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1017
WP No. 100119 of 2026
HC-KAR
have a case considered for regularization in terms of the
law laid down by this Court and the Apex Court. For the
foregoing reasons, this Court pass the following:
ORDER
i.
The writ petition is allowed.
ii.
The
impugned
endorsement
Nos.1268234/DMA/EST2/DWE/53/2023/3038
dated
05.11.2025
(Annexure-Q),
1268234/DMA/EST2/DWE/53/2023/3037
(Annexure-Q1),
KRA.SUM:BGM:DUDC:1:CR:8:2025-26/1297
dated
19.11.2025
(Annexure-R)
and
KRA.SUM:BGM:DUDC:1:CR:8:2025-26/1298
(Annexure-R1) are hereby quashed.
iii.
The petitioners are held to be entitled
for regularization on which date they have
completed the 10 years of service with all
- 23 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1017
WP No. 100119 of 2026
HC-KAR
consequential benefits in accordance with
law.
Sd/JUSTICE K.S.HEMALEKHA
AT/Ct:VH
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 23
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review