Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 13th July, 2026
Uploaded on: 16th July, 2026
+
RFA(COMM) 383/2025 & CM APPL. 42158/2025
BHAGWAN SINGH
Through:
.....APPELLANT
Mr. Sanjay Shisodia, Adv.
versus
ANMOL BHASIN
.....RESPONDENT
Through:
CORAM:
JUSTICE PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUSTICE VIKAS MAHAJAN
Vikas Mahajan, J. (Oral)
1.
This hearing has been done through hybrid mode.
2.
The present appeal has been preferred by the Appellant under
Section 96 read with Order XLI Rule1 of the Civil Procedure Code
[hereinafter, ‘CPC’] against the final judgment and decree dated 19th April,
2025 passed by the learned District Judge (Commercial Court-01), Dwarka
in CS (COMM) 13/2024 whereby the suit of the Plaintiff for recovery of
Rs.5,23,999/- along with pendent lite and future interest @ 24% per annum,
was dismissed.
3.
The brief facts of the case as borne out from the plaint are that the
Appellant/Plaintiff, proprietor of the concern “Vishal Fastener” is engaged
in
manufacturing
and
selling
of
fasteners
nut-bolts
etc.
The
Respondent/Defendant, proprietor of “Anmol Enterprises”, approached the
Appellant and placed the orders for washers [the goods] upon him.
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:48:36
RFA(COMM) 383/2025
Between April, 2022 and March, 2023, Appellant supplied goods to the
Respondent and raised the invoices for a total amount of Rs.11,56,721/- as
detailed below:
S. No.
Date of Invoice
1.
23.04.2022
Rs.2,48,956/-
2.
07.06.2022
Rs.2,85,560/-
3.
08.09.2022
Rs.1,63,442/-
4.
28.01.2023
Rs.1,25,000/-
5.
02.02.2023
Rs.1,72,150/-
6.
07.03.2023
Rs.1,61,613/-
Total
4.
Invoice No.
Amount
Rs.11,56,721/-
It is stated that the Respondent made part payment from time to time
and the last amount of Rs.35,631/- was paid by the Respondent on
16.06.2023. The plaint also states that Rs.5,23,999/- is outstanding against
the Respondent, which he failed to pay despite repeated requests. Hence,
the suit was filed for claiming the said amount with interest.
5.
The Respondent filed his written statement pleading, inter alia, that
the Appellant supplied the goods at a belated stage, due to which the
Respondent could not meet the commitment made by him to his clients, who
in turn cancelled the orders. Further the goods supplied by the Appellant
against aforesaid three invoice nos. 1833, 1902 and 2074 were of
substandard/inferior quality, thus, those goods were rejected by the
Respondent’s clients. The goods supplied by the Respondent against other
three invoice nos. 2312, 2328 and 2380 were defective and higher rates were
charged. But, despite that, the Respondent made part payments and advance
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:48:36
RFA(COMM) 383/2025
payments to the Plaintiff.
6.
The Respondent also denied the statement of account filed by the
Appellant and claimed that he has already made the entire payment against
six invoices raised by the Appellant. The Respondent also pleaded in the
written statement that he had made the advance payment of Rs.3,94,941/for the goods to be supplied in future. It is also stated that the Appellant
never took back the delivery of defective goods, nor adjusted the amount
paid by the Respondent against invoice nos. 2312, 2328 and 2380. It was
thus, averred in the written statement that the Respondent is not liable to pay
any amount to the Appellant.
7.
In the evidence, the Appellant/Plaintiff examined himself as PW-1
and, inter alia, proved – (i) four original invoice nos. 2380, 2328, 2312 and
2072 as Ex.PW-1/A (colly); (ii) a computer generated e-way bills as
Ex.PW-1/B (colly), and; (iii) a computer generated ledger account statement
Ex.PW-1/C (colly).
8.
The Respondent/Defendant examined himself as DW-1, but no
document was either filed or proved by the Respondent.
9.
The learned Trial Court in the light of evidence that had come on
record, returned a finding that the Respondent has failed to prove that - the
Appellant supplied the defective goods; the goods were of inferior quality;
the goods supplied by the Appellant were not as per the specification; or that
the delivery of goods was delayed. The findings in this behalf from the
impugned judgment read thus:
“18.
Counsel for the defendant pleaded that the
goods supplied by the plaintiff were not as per the
specification provided by the defendant.
19.
In the present case, the defendant has failed
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:48:36
RFA(COMM) 383/2025
to produce any document to prove that he ever
furnished any specification of the goods to the plaintiff.
Further, DWI in his cross-examination, deposed that
he did not remember the specification of the goods
ordered by him and the specification of the goods
supplied by the plaintiff. In view of the foregoing
discussion, it can be held that the defendant has failed
to prove what specification of the goods was provided
by him to the plaintiff and what was the specification of
the goods supplied by the plaintiff to him to ascertain
as to whether there was any difference in the
specification of the goods supplied to him.
20.
The defendant has failed to lead any evidence
to prove that the plaintiff supplied the defective and
inferior quality goods to him. DWI in his crossexamination even failed to disclose the value of the
defective goods supplied by the plaintiff as alleged. The
defendant has also failed to prove that he ever made
any request to the plaintiff to take back the defective
goods and supply fresh goods against the same. The
defendant, in his cross-examination, admitted that the
defective/ damaged goods are still lying with him. The
defendant also failed to lead any evidence to show that
he ever tried on his end to return those defective goods
to the plaintiff. Hence, it can be held that the defendant
has failed to prove that the plaintiff supplied the
defective goods and goods of inferior quality to him.
21.
Counsel for the defendant pleaded that in the
invoices mentioned at serial no. 4 to 6, the plaintiff
claimed a rate on the higher side than what was
agreed between the parties.
22.
The defendant has failed to lead any evidence
to prove what rate was agreed on initially. The
defendant, in his cross-examination, deposed that he
could not tell the terms and conditions agreed upon
between the parties related to the subject transaction.
Further, the defendant admitted a suggestion given by
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:48:36
RFA(COMM) 383/2025
counsel for the plaintiff that whatever payment he
made against those invoices, it was made because the
invoice value was correct. Further, the defendant has
failed to lead any evidence to prove that he ever
objected to the rate mentioned in those invoices.
Further, the case of the defendant is that he had
already made the payment against those invoices. As
discussed below, the defendant has fully paid against
the invoices mentioned at serial no. 4 to 6. The
defendant has failed to explain, if the goods supplied
by the plaintiff were defective and of inferior quality
and the plaintiff charged the rates on the higher side,
then as to why he made the payment to the plaintiff
without any protest to that effect.
23.
Counsel for the defendant pleaded that the
plaintiff delayed in delivering the goods to the
defendant, due to which he could not supply the same
to his customers in time due to which the said
customers cancelled the contract.
24.
The defendant has failed to lead any evidence
to prove what period was fixed between the parties
within which the plaintiff had to supply the goods to
the plaintiff to him and that his alleged customers had
cancelled the contract executed between them on
account of the delayed delivery of the goods.
25.
In view of the foregoing discussion, it can be
held that the defendant has failed to prove that the
goods supplied by the plaintiff were not as per his
specification and were of inferior quality.”
10.
Insofar as the claim of the Appellant is concerned, the learned Trial
Court noted that though the Appellant/Plaintiff while examining himself as
PW-1 has proved only four invoices as Ex.PW-1/A (Colly), but since in the
written statement the Respondent has admitted that the Appellant issued six
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:48:36
RFA(COMM) 383/2025
invoices, it accordingly, held that Appellant supplied the goods to the
Respondent and raised six invoices aggregating Rs.11,56,721/-, and the
same were duly received by the Respondent.
11.
The learned Trial Court on the basis of the Appellant’s admission in
his cross-examination that the suit has been filed to recover the amount due
against total 06 invoices, and further admission of payments in the ledger
account, observed that against all the six invoices, which were the subject
matter of the suit, the Respondent made the payment either equivalent to the
amount of the invoice or in excess of the invoice value, and accordingly held
that the ledger account, Ex.PW-1/C (colly), is not a regular statement of
account. The learned Trial Court further held that the payment made to the
Appellant by the Respondent during the period 23.04.2022 to 16.06.2023 is
more than the aggregate value of six subject invoices. The suit of the
Plaintiff was thus, dismissed. The relevant findings of the learned Trial
Court in this regard are as under:
“30.
Now, the first question arises whether the
ledger account Ex. PW-1/C (colly) maintained by the
plaintiff in the name of the defendant concerning
subject 06 invoices between 23.04.2022 and
07.03.2023 is a regular statement of account or not.
31.
PW-1 in his cross-examination admitted one
suggestion given by counsel for the defendant that he
has filed the present suit to recover the amount due
against total 06 invoices including the invoices Ex.
PW-1/A (colly). It is own case of the plaintiff that he
raised the said invoice between 23.04.2022 and
07.03.2023 for the total value of Rs. 11,56,731/-.
32.
Perusal of the ledger account Ex. PW-1/C
(colly) reveals that between 23.04.2022 and
16.06.2023, the plaintiff raised 06 invoices only upon
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:48:36
RFA(COMM) 383/2025
the defendant which are the subject matter of the
present suit and the defendant made the payments as
follows:
(i) the plaintiff raised the invoice no. 1833 dated
23.04.2022 for Rs.2,48,956/-, and between 03.05.2022
and 04.06.2022, the defendant paid the total amount of
Rs. 2,74,590/-;
(ii)
the plaintiff raised the invoice no. 1902 dated
06.06.2022 for Rs.2,85,560/-, and between 06.06.2022
and 07.09.2022, the defendant paid the total amount of
Rs.3,45,500/-;
(iii)
the plaintiff raised the invoice no. 2072 dated
08.09.2022 for Rs.1,63,482/-, and between 11.10.2022
and 27.01.2023, the defendant paid the total amount of
Rs.2,64,696/-;
(iv)
against the invoice no. 2312 dated 28.01.2023
for Rs.1,25,000/-, the defendant paid Rs.1,25,000/- on
01.02.2023;
(v)
against the invoice no. 2328 dated 02.02.2023
for Rs.1,72,150/-, the defendant paid the total payment
of Rs.1,72,150/- between 17.02.2023 and 04.03.2023;
and
(vi)
against the invoice no. 2380 dated 07.03.2023
for Rs.1,61,613/-, the defendant paid total amount of
Rs.1,61,613/- between 19.04.2023 and 16.06.2023.
33.
In view of the foregoing discussion, it can be
held that once the plaintiff raised the subject invoices
against the defendant, the defendant either paid the
total amount due against a particular invoice value or
an amount more than the invoice value. Accordingly,
it can be held that the ledger account Ex. PW-1/C
(colly) maintained by the plaintiff from 23.04.2022 to
07.03.2023, is not a regular statement of account. As
such, there is no substance in the plea raised by
counsel for the plaintiff.
34.
Perusal of ledger account Ex. PW-1/C (colly)
reveals that between 23.04.2022 and 16.06.2023, the
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:48:36
RFA(COMM) 383/2025
plaintiff raised the invoices for the total amount of Rs.
11,56,721/-. During the said period, the defendant
made the payment of the total amount of Rs.
13,93,549/- to the plaintiff, i.e., Rs.2,36,828/- more
than the invoice value. It is nowhere the case of the
plaintiff that there was any transaction between the
parties after 16.06.2023. As such, the plaintiff has
failed to explain on what account, he received
Rs.2,36,828/- in excess from the defendant.
35.
It is the case of the defendant that he used to
make the advance payment to the plaintiff. The plaintiff
has denied the said fact. However, in the crossexamination of DW-1, counsel for the plaintiff has
given one suggestion that the defendant used to make
the advance payment to the plaintiff to build trust and
confidence with him. The said suggestion substantiates
the plea raised by the defendant that he used to make
the advance payment to the plaintiff. In view of the
foregoing discussion, it can be held that the amount of
Rs.2,36,828/- was paid by the defendant to the plaintiff
as an advance payment.
36.
Counsel for the plaintiff strenuously pleaded
that in para no. 14 and 15 of the plaint, the plaintiff
specifically pleaded that Rs. 5,23,999/- is outstanding
against the defendant, which he failed to pay.
However, in WS, the defendant has not replied to the
contents of para no. 14 of the plaint at all. Further, in
reply to para 15 of the plaint, the defendant has not
specifically denied his liability to pay Rs.5,23,999/-.
Hence, it amounts to an admission of the defendant
that Rs. 5,23,999/- is the outstanding amount against
him.
37.
As per the record, the defendant has not
replied to the contents of para no. 14 of the plaint, and
in reply to para no.15 of the plaint, the defendant has
not specifically denied the outstanding amount claimed
by the plaintiff. However, it is a settled law that the
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:48:36
RFA(COMM) 383/2025
pleading has to be read as a whole. In WS, the
defendant in reply to para no. 9, 10 and 12 of the
plaint, has specifically denied that there is an
outstanding amount of Rs. 5,23,999/- against him.
Further, in the cross-examination of PW-1, counsel for
the defendant has given the suggestion to PW-1 that no
amount was outstanding against the defendant. Also,
DW-1 in his cross-examination specifically deposed
that he has paid the total amount due against the
subject invoices. Further, as discussed above, between
23.04.2022 and 16.06.2023, the defendant made
payments to the plaintiff higher than the invoice
value raised by the plaintiff during the said period.
Therefore, there is no substance in the plea raised by
counsel for the plaintiff.
38.
In view of the foregoing discussion, it can be
held that the plaintiff has failed to prove that Rs.
5,23,999/- is outstanding against the defendant.
Hence, the plaintiff is held not entitled to the decree
as prayed for. Accordingly, the issue no. l is decided in
favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant. The
issues no. 2 and 3 are decided against the plaintiff and
in favour of the defendant.
ISSUE No.4 (RELIEF)
39.
In view of the foregoing discussion, the suit
of the plaintiff is dismissed. No order as to cost.
Decree sheet be prepared accordingly.”
12.
The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the Appellant has not
challenged the finding of the learned Trial Court as regard the payments
made by the Respondent against the six subject invoices. He has confined
his submission only to the finding of the learned Trial Court as regard the
ledger account, Ex.PW-1/C (colly). Inviting attention of the Court to the
said ledger account, he contends that the learned Trial Court erred in holding
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:48:36
RFA(COMM) 383/2025
that the ledger account is not a regular statement of account. Referring to
the opening balance of the ledger account for the financial year 2022-2023,
he contends that there was already an opening outstanding amount of
Rs.8,83,327/- as on 01.04.2022, therefore any payment made by the
Respondent subsequent thereto is to be first adjusted against the said
opening outstanding balance besides the amount of six invoices in question
which were issued after 01.04.2022. It is his case that this opening balance
has been completely ignored by the Trial Court.
13.
During the course of hearing, a specific query was posed to the
learned counsel for the Appellant as to whether any invoice, other than six
subject invoices, or any other material, has been placed and proved on
record for establishing the entries recorded in the ledger account, Ex.PW1/C (colly), his answer is clearly in the negative.
14.
He, however, contends that an application under Order XLI Rule 27
CPC has been separately filed along with the present appeal to place on
record additional evidence viz.,
(i) invoices issued by the Appellant for the goods from the financial
year 2020-2021 till 2023-2024 along with their e-way bills and
acknowledgement receipt of the transporter (Annexure A-2);
(ii) forms GSTR-1 for all the invoices issued by the Appellant from
the financial year 2020-2021 till 2023-2024 (Annexure A-3);
(iii) form GSTR-3B to claim input tax credit for inter alia the invoice
issued by the Appellant to the Respondent from the financial year
20202-2021 to 2023-2024 (Annexure A-4); and
(iv) bank account statement for the calendar year 2021 to 2024 of the
bank account of the Appellant maintained with the Indian Bank at
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:48:36
RFA(COMM) 383/2025
Janak Puri (Annexure A-5).
15.
It is urged by the learned counsel for the Appellant that the above
documents would establish beyond any shadow of doubt that the entries
made in the ledger statement filed by the Appellant are true and correct and
the same are sought to be proved only to substantiate the entries of the
ledger account.
16.
The Respondent was proceeded against ex-parte in the present appeal
vide order dated 04.02.2026 as there was no appearance on behalf of the
Respondent despite repeated issuance of notices through speed post as also
on his mobile number.
17.
Having heard the learned counsel for the Appellant, the Court notes
that in the plaint, the Plaintiff has predicated its claim only on six invoices as
detailed in para 3 hereinabove. The supply of material and raising of said
six invoices by the Appellant is not in dispute. The finding of payment
made by the Respondent against such invoices has also not been assailed.
The submission of the Appellant is that the payment made by the
Respondent against the six invoices ought to be adjusted against the opening
balance in the ledger account for the financial year 2022-2023 and that the
observation of the learned Trial Court to the effect that the ledgers account is
not a regular statement of account. This Court does not find merit in the
said submission, inasmuch as the entries of sale in the ledger account, other
than six transactions which are subject matter of the suit, are not supported
by any invoice or other corroborative evidence establishing transaction of
sale.
18.
The law is well settled that no liability can be fastened on a person
merely on the basis of entries in books of account, even where such books of
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:48:36
RFA(COMM) 383/2025
account are kept in the regular course of business, without their being further
evidence to prove such entries. Reference in this regard may be had to the
decision of the Supreme Court in Chandra Dhar Goswami v. Gauhati Bank
Limited, 1966 SCC OnLine SC 255, wherein it was observed as under:
“The main question urged before us is that there is no
evidence besides the certified copy of the account to
prove that a sum of Rs. 10,000 was advanced to the
appellants and therefore in view of section 34 of the
Evidence Act the appellants cannot be saddled with
liability for that amount. Section 34 is in these terms :
“Entries in books of account, regularly kept in the
course of business, are relevant whenever they refer
to a matter into which the court has to inquire, but
such statements shall not alone be sufficient
evidence to charge any person with liability.”
It is clear from a bare perusal of the section that no
person can be charged with liability merely on the
basis of entries in books of account, even where such
books of account are kept in the regular course of
business. There has to be further evidence to prove
payment of the money which may appear in the books
of account in order that a person may be charged with
liability thereunder, except where the person to be
charged accepts the correctness of the books of
account and does not challenge them. In the present
case, however, the appellants did not accept the
correctness of the books of account. ….”
19.
Likewise, the Coordinate Bench of this Court in Harish Mansukhani
v. Ashok Jain, 2008 SCC OnLine Del 1242, while confronted with similar
question, observed as under:
“15. Mere raising of a bill and reflecting the same in a
statement of account is not good evidence without
establishing delivery of the goods under the bills. We
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:48:36
RFA(COMM) 383/2025
may hasten to add that in the instant case there is no
evidence to even establish that the bills were raised
upon the defendant, in that, were ever delivered to the
defendant. There is no contemporaneous letter proved
on record in which the plaintiff made a grievance upon
the defendant that a huge outstanding amount was due
from the defendant to the plaintiff.
xxx
xxx
xxx
23. A plaintiff has to prove his case and stand on his
own legs. No doubt, the defendant did not produce his
books of account but that does not mean that the
plaintiff must succeed on said account.”
20.
Insofar as the submission of the learned counsel for the Appellant for
bringing on record additional evidence, is concerned, this Court cannot be
unmindful of the fact that it is a commercial suit under the Commercial
Courts Act, 2015 [hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’] which provides for a
stricter regime of filing of all documents at the time of filing of suit when
such documents are in power, possession, control or custody of the Plaintiff,
failing which the Plaintiff cannot be allowed to rely on those documents,
save and except by leave of Court. The Court, however, has the discretion
to grant such leave only upon Plaintiff establishing reasonable cause for
non-disclosure of documents along with the plaint. The relevant part of the
Order XI which was substituted by virtue of Section 16 of the Act and made
applicable to the commercial disputes, insofar it relates to filing of
additional documents, reads as under:
“
ORDER XI
DISCLOSURE, DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION OF
DOCUMENTS IN SUITS BEFORE THE
COMMERCIAL DIVISION OF A HIGH COURT OR A
COMMERCIAL COURT
1. Disclosure and discovery of documents.
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:48:36
RFA(COMM) 383/2025
……
(5) The plaintiff shall not be allowed to rely on
documents, which were in the plaintiff’s power,
possession, control or custody and not disclosed along
with plaint or within the extended period set out above,
save and except by leave of Court and such leave shall be
granted only upon the plaintiff establishing reasonable
cause for non–disclosure along with the plaint.”
21.
A perusal of the above quoted provision shows that the Appellant has
to establish “reasonable cause” for non-disclosure of documents which
were in Appellants power, possession, control or custody and were still non
disclosed along with the plaint. However, there would be no requirement of
establishment of reasonable cause qua the documents that have been found
subsequently.
22.
It is not the case of the Appellant that the documents sought to be
produced as additional evidence were not within his possession, control or
custody, rather the only reason that has been put forth in the application for
not producing the said evidence before the learned Trial Court is that the
Appellant was advised by his counsel that there was no necessity to file the
same and the Appellant being an illiterate person solely relied upon the legal
advice that was rendered. If such a contingency is read into the expression
“reasonable cause”, the very purpose of the requirement of disclosure of
documents at the time of filing of plaint as envisaged in Order XI Rule 1(5)
would become meaningless.
23.
Incidentally, the documents sought to be filed as additional evidence
at this appellate stage were not only not filed along with the plaint, but no
application was moved by the Appellant to bring the same on record in the
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:48:36
RFA(COMM) 383/2025
suit, anytime, before or after the commencement of trial. The Appellant also
had an opportunity even at the stage of evidence to confront the
Respondent’s witness with such documents during his cross examination,
but such a course was also not adopted.
24.
In the aforesaid circumstances, the justification given by the
Appellant for not filing the additional evidence/document before the learned
Trial Court, in the considered opinion of this Court, does not pass the muster
of "reasonable cause" as contemplated under order XI Rule 1(5).
25.
The present application has since been filed by the Appellant under
Order XLI Rule 27 CPC, it would be apposite to advert to the said provision
as well, which reads thus:
“27. Production of additional evidence in Appellate Court.—(1)
The parties to an appeal shall not be entitled to produce
additional evidence, whether oral or documentary, in the
Appellate Court. But if —
(a) the Court from whose decree the appeal is preferred has
refused to admit evidence which ought to have been admitted,
or
(aa) the party seeking to produce additional evidence,
establishes that notwithstanding the exercise of due diligence,
such evidence was not within his knowledge or could not, after
the exercise of due diligence, be produced by him at the time
when the decree appealed against was passed, or
(b) the Appellate Court requires any document to be produced
or any witness to be examined to enable it to pronounce
judgment, or for any other substantial cause, the Appellate
Court may allow such evidence or document to be produced,
or witness to be examined.
(2) Wherever additional evidence is allowed to be produced by
an Appellate Court, the Court shall record the reason for its
admission.”
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:48:36
RFA(COMM) 383/2025
26.
A perusal of the above provision shows that the parties are not entitled
as right to the admission of additional evidence in the appellate, save and
except, in the circumstances expressly enumerated in Order XLI Rule 27
CPC.
27.
In Union of India v. Ibrahim Uddin and Anr. (2012) 8 SCC 148, the
Supreme Court while analyzing the scope and object of Order XLI Rule 27
CPC observed that the Appellate Court may permit additional evidence only
in the event conditions laid down in the Rule are found to exist. The parties
are not entitled, as of right, to admission of such evidence. The matter is
clearly within the discretion of the Court and is to be utilized sparingly. The
party who had ample opportunity to produce certain evidence in the lower
court but failed to do so or elected not to do so, cannot have it admitted in
appeal. The relevant extract from the decision is reproduced hereinbelow:
“36. The general principle is that the appellate court
should not travel outside the record of the lower court
and cannot take any evidence in appeal. However, as
an exception, Order 41 Rule 27 CPC enables the
appellate court to take additional evidence in
exceptional circumstances. The appellate court may
permit additional evidence only and only if the
conditions laid down in this Rule are found to exist.
The parties are not entitled, as of right, to the
admission of such evidence. Thus, the provision does
not apply, when on the basis of the evidence on record,
the appellate court can pronounce a satisfactory
judgment. The matter is entirely within the discretion
of the court and is to be used sparingly. Such a
discretion is only a judicial discretion circumscribed
by the limitation specified in the Rule itself. (Vide K.
Venkataramiah v. A. Seetharama Reddy [AIR 1963 SC
1526], Municipal Corpn. of Greater Bombay v. Lala
Pancham [AIR
SC
1008], Soonda
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:48:36
RFA(COMM) 383/2025
Ram v. Rameshwarlal [(1975) 3 SCC 698 : AIR 1975
SC
479]
and Syed
Abdul
Khader v. Rami
Reddy [(1979) 2 SCC 601 : AIR 1979 SC 553] .)
37. The appellate court should not ordinarily allow
new evidence to be adduced in order to enable a party
to raise a new point in appeal. Similarly, where a
party on whom the onus of proving a certain point
lies fails to discharge the onus, he is not entitled to a
fresh opportunity to produce evidence, as the court
can, in such a case, pronounce judgment against him
and does not require any additional evidence to
enable it to pronounce judgment. (Vide Haji
Mohammed Ishaq v. Mohd. Iqbal and Mohd. Ali and
Co. [(1978) 2 SCC 493 : AIR 1978 SC 798])
38. Under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC, the appellate court
has the power to allow a document to be produced and
a witness to be examined. But the requirement of the
said court must be limited to those cases where it found
it necessary to obtain such evidence for enabling it to
pronounce judgment. This provision does not entitle
the appellate court to let in fresh evidence at the
appellate stage where even without such evidence it
can pronounce judgment in a case. It does not entitle
the appellate court to let in fresh evidence only for the
purpose of pronouncing judgment in a particular
way. In other words, it is only for removing a lacuna
in the evidence that the appellate court is empowered
to
admit
additional
evidence.
(Vide Lala
Pancham [AIR 1965 SC 1008].)
39. It is not the business of the appellate court to
supplement the evidence adduced by one party or the
other in the lower court. Hence, in the absence of
satisfactory reasons for the non-production of the
evidence in the trial court, additional evidence should
not be admitted in appeal as a party guilty of
remissness in the lower court is not entitled to the
indulgence of being allowed to give further evidence
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:48:36
RFA(COMM) 383/2025
under this Rule. So a party who had ample
opportunity to produce certain evidence in the lower
court but failed to do so or elected not to do so,
cannot have it admitted in appeal. (Vide State of U.P.
v. Manbodhan Lal Srivastava [AIR 1957 SC 912] and
S. Rajagopal v. C.M. Armugam [AIR 1969 SC 101] .)
40. The inadvertence of the party or his inability to
understand the legal issues involved or the wrong
advice of a pleader or the negligence of a pleader or
that the party did not realise the importance of a
document does not constitute a “substantial cause”
within the meaning of this Rule. The mere fact that
certain evidence is important, is not in itself a sufficient
ground for admitting that evidence in appeal.
28.
41. The words “for any other substantial cause” must
be read with the word “requires” in the beginning of
the sentence, so that it is only where, for any other
substantial cause, the appellate court requires
additional evidence, that this Rule will apply e.g. when
evidence has been taken by the lower court so
imperfectly that the appellate court cannot pass a
satisfactory judgment.”
(emphasis supplied)
The present is not a case where the Trial Court refused to admit any
evidence which ought to have been admitted nor it is the case of the
Appellant that the additional evidence sought to be produced was not within
the knowledge of the Appellant or could not have been produced before the
Trial Court. The reasons articulated by the Appellant that he was not
properly advised by his counsel for filing of the documents/evidence, now
sought to be produced, does not constitute a “substantial cause” as held by
the Apex Court in Ibrahim Uddin (supra).
29.
Further, a reading of the plaint shows that the claim of the
Appellant/Plaintiff in the suit is for supply of goods against only six invoices
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:48:36
RFA(COMM) 383/2025
specifically pleaded in the plaint. However, the Appellant now wish to rely
on various other invoices and contemporaneous documents related to such
invoices to prove the entries in the ledger account, Ex.PW1/C (colly.). Such
an attempt, at the appellate stage and in the absence of foundational
pleadings, is not permissible in law, all the more when such documents were
in the possession of the Appellant even when the suit was filed.
30.
For the aforesaid reasons, there is no merit in the application of the
Appellant under Order XLI Rule 27 CPC and, accordingly, CM
No.42158/2025 is dismissed. There is also no infirmity in the impugned
judgment of the Trial Court warranting any interference by this Court.
Consequently, the appeal is also dismissed.
31.
The pending applications, if any, shall also stand disposed of.
VIKAS MAHAJAN
JUDGE
PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUDGE
JULY 13, 2026/jg
Digitally Signed
By:DEEPAK SINGH
18:48:36
RFA(COMM) 383/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review