Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
ORISSA HIGH COURT : CUTTACK
CMP No.1273 of 2022
An application under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
***
Bhagabati Tarai
…
Petitioner.
-VERSUSKalpana Tarai
…
Opposite Party.
Counsel appeared for the parties:
For the Petitioner
: Mr. S.K. Dash, Senior Advocate
Along with Ms. P. Mohanty, Advocate.
For the Opposite Party
: Mr. S. Mohanty, Advocate.
(For the Opp. Party)
P R E S E N T:
HONOURABLE
MR. JUSTICE ANANDA CHANDRA BEHERA
Date of Hearing : 12.01.2026 :: Date of Judgment :22.01.2026
CIV. Misc. Petition No.1273 of 2022
J UDGMENT
ANANDA CHANDRA BEHERA, J.—
1.
This Civil Misc. Petition under article 227 of the
Constitution of India, 1950 has been filed by the petitioner
praying for quashing the impugned order dated 20.07.2022
(Annexure-4) passed in I.A. No.66/2022 by the learned Senior
Civil
Judge,
Kujanga
and
the
impugned
order
dated
31.10.2022 (Annexure-5) passed in F.A.O. No.25 of 2022 by
the learned Addl. District Judge, Kujanga.
2.
The factual backgrounds of this Civil Misc. Petition,
which promoted the petitioner for filing of the same is that,
the Opp. Party (Kalpana Tarai) being the sole plaintiff filed a
suit vide C.S. No.84/2022 against the petitioner of this CMP
(Bhagabati Tarai) arraying her as defendant No.1 along with
others in the Court of learned Senior Civil Judge, Kujanga
praying for declaration of her right, title, interest and
possession over the properties described in Schedule “C” of
the plaint and also to declare the R.S.D. No.733 dated
22.04.2006 executed by the defendant No.2 Srikrushna Das
CIV. Misc. Petition No.1273 of 2022
in favour of the defendant
No.1 (petitioner in this CMP
Bhagabati Tarai) as illegal, invalid, void and the same is not
binding upon her and to injunct the defendant
No.1
(petitioner in this CMP) permanently from interfering in the
peaceful possession of the plaintiff over “C” schedule suit
properties stating in her plaint in nutshell that,
the suit properties along with other properties originally
belonged to one Satish Chandra Das. After the death of Satish
Chandra Das, the suit properties along with other properties
left by him devolved upon his widow wife and his children
including her vendor Subhadra Das. After the death of Satish
Chandra Das, his all successors including her vendor
Subhadra
Das
partitioned
to
their all
joint properties
including the suit properties and in such partition, the suit
properties described in Schedule “C” along with some other
properties fell in the share of Subhadra Das and accordingly,
Subhadra Das became the exclusive owner over the suit
properties. The said Subhadra Das (defendant
No.5 in the
suit vide C.S. No.84/2022) sold her schedule “C” suit
properties in her favour i.e. in favour of the plaintiff executing
CIV. Misc. Petition No.1273 of 2022
and registering Sale Deed No.731 dated 14.03.2001 after
receiving
the
due
consideration
amount
and
delivered
possession thereof. As such, since the date of purchase i.e.
since 14.03.2001, she (plaintiff) is in exclusive possession over
the Schedule “C” suit properties. When the defendant No.1
created
disturbances
in
her
possession
over
the
suit
properties and claimed claiming her title thereon, then, she
(plaintiff-Kalpana Tarai) filed the suit vide C.S. No.84/2022
against the petitioner in this CMP arraying her as defendant
No.1 along with others including her vendor Subhadra Das
praying for the aforesaid reliefs i.e. declaration and permanent
injunction.
3.
In the said suit vide C.S. No.84/2022, the plaintiff (Opp.
Party in this CMP) filed an I.A. vide I.A. No.66/2022 under
Order 39, Rule 1 & 2 read with Section 151 CPC, 1908 against
the defendant
No.1 (petitioner in this CMP) praying for
injuncting her temporarily from coming upon the suit land
and from interfering in her peaceful possession and from
causing any damage to the standing vegetable crops and from
making any type of construction over the same and from
CIV. Misc. Petition No.1273 of 2022
changing the nature and character of the same till the final
disposal of the suit vide C.S. No.84/2022 stating the above
things.
4.
Having been noticed from the Court in I.A. No.66/2022,
the defendant No.1 thereof (petitioner in this CMP) challenged
the same by filing her objection taking her stands that, the
suit properties along with other properties were the selfacquired properties of Satish Chandra Das. During the
lifetime of Satish Chandra Das, he had divided his all
properties including the suit properties between his 3 sons
including the defendant
No.2 Srikrushna Das on dated
28.08.1992 by executing a Will. Then, after the death of
Satish Chandra Das, his 3 sons including the defendant No.2
amicably divided all the movable and immovable properties
including the suit properties left by Satish Chandra Das in 3
equal shares on dated 18.12.1996. In the said partition, the
suit properties described in Schedule “C” of the plaint along
with other properties were allotted in favour of Srikrushna
Das
(defendant
(defendant
No.2)
No.2).
became
CIV. Misc. Petition No.1273 of 2022
Accordingly,
the
exclusive
Srikrushna
Das
owner
in
and
possession over the suit properties along with other properties
those had fallen in his share. While, Srikrushna Das
(defendant No.2) was in possession over the suit properties,
he sold the same through R.S.D. No.733 dated 22.04.2006 to
the defendant
possession
No.1 (petitioner in this CMP)
thereof.
Accordingly,
since
and delivered
22.04.2006,
he
(defendant No.1) is in possession over the suit properties
being the owner thereof.
The Will dated 28.08.1992 executed by Satish Chandra
Das in favour of his 3 sons including the Defendant No.2 has
already been probated in a Probate Misc. Case No.24/2001,
for which, the sale of the suit properties made by the
defendant No.5 Subhadra Das in favour of the plaintiff (Opp.
Party in this CMP-Kalpana Tarai) through R.S.D. No.731
dated 14.03.2001 cannot be held as legal. Because, the Will
dated 22.08.1992, which was executed by the original owner
Satish Chandra Das in favour of the vendor of the Opp. Party
along with his two other brothers has already been probated
and as such, the vendor of the Opp. Party (defendant No.2)
was the owner of the suit properties, for which, the petitioner
CIV. Misc. Petition No.1273 of 2022
has no prima facie case and she has also no possession over
the suit properties. Therefore, the I.A. under Order 39, Rule 1
& 2 read with Section 151 of the CPC, 1908 filed by the
petitioner/plaintiff for temporary injunction against the Opp.
Party/defendant No.1 is liable to be dismissed.
5.
After hearing from both the sides, the learned Senior
Civil Judge, Kujanga allowed that I.A. No.66/2022 on dated
20.07.2022 on contest in favor of the petitioner/plaintiff and
restrained the Opp. Party (defendant No.1) temporarily from
interfering
in
the
peaceful
possession
of
the
plaintiff
(petitioner) over the suit properties and from causing any
damage to the standing vegetable crops and house and also
from making any type of construction over the same and from
changing the nature and character of the same in any manner
till the final disposal of the suit vide C.S. No.84/2022
assigning the reasons that,
When the suit properties were the properties of Satish
Chandra Das and when the vendor of the petitioner (defendant
No.5 in the suit) is one of the successors of Satish Chandra Das
and when the defendant No.5 has alienated the suit properties
CIV. Misc. Petition No.1273 of 2022
in favour of the petitioner through R.S.D. No.731 dated
14.03.2001 prior to the sale deed No.733 dated 22.04.2006 in
favour of the Opp. Party executed by the defendant No.2 and
when the so called Will was probated on 10.12.2010 by the
learned District Judge, Cuttack much after the execution of
R.S.D. No.731 dated 14.03.2001 in favour of the petitioner and
when the said probation of the Will in Probate Misc. Case
No.24/2001 is under challenge before the High Court, then, on
the basis of delivery of possession of the suit properties through
the earlier sale deed No.731 dated 14.03.2001 in favour of the
petitioner, the Opp. Party is restrained temporarily from
interfering in the peaceful possession of the plaintiff (petitioner)
over the suit properties and from causing any damage to the
standing vegetable crops and house and also from making any
type of construction and from changing the nature and
character of the same in any manner till the final disposal of
the suit vide C.S. No.84/2022.
6.
On being aggrieved with the above order of temporary
injunction passed on dated 20.07.2022 in I.A. No.66 of 2022
against the Opp. Party, the Opp. Party challenged the same by
CIV. Misc. Petition No.1273 of 2022
preferring an appeal vide F.A.O No.25/2022 under Order 43,
Rule 1(r) of the CPC, 1908 before the learned Addl. District
Judge, Kujanga being the appellant against the petitioner in
the I.A. No.66/2022 arraying her as respondent.
After hearing from both the sides, the learned Addl.
District Judge, Kujanga dismissed to that F.A.O. No.25/2022
of the Opp. Party as per its Judgment dated 31.10.2022 on
contest concurring/accepting the findings and observations
made by the learned Senior Civil Judge, Kujanga in I.A.
No.66/2022.
7.
On being dissatisfied with the aforesaid dismissal of the
F.A.O No.25/2022 of the Opp. Party in the I.A. No.66/2022
passed on dated 31.10.2022 by the learned Addl. District
Judge, Kujanga, the Opp. Party in I.A. No.66/2022 (appellant
in F.A.O. No.25/2022) challenged the same by filing this CMP
under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, 1950 being the
petitioner arraying the plaintiff as Opp. Party.
8.
I have already heard from the learned counsel for the
petitioner and the learned counsel for the Opp. Party.
CIV. Misc. Petition No.1273 of 2022
9.
On the basis of the rival submission of the learned
counsels of both the sides, the crux of this CMP is that,
Whether the findings arrived by the two Courts
i.e. learned Trial Court and learned First
Appellate Court in I.A. No.66 of 2022 and
F.A.O. No.25 of 2022 arising out of the suit
vide C.S. No.84 of 2022 are interferable in this
CMP under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India,
exercising
its
supervisory
jurisdiction?
10. Both the parties are claiming possession over the case
land described in Schedule “C” of the plaint on the basis of
their respective registered sale deeds.
When the Opp. Party (plaintiff) is claiming title and
possession over the suit properties on the basis of the sale
deed No.731 dated 14.03.2001 executed by Subhadra Das
(defendant
No.5, daughter of Satish Chandra Das) in her
favour, but, at the same time, the petitioner (defendant No.1
in the suit) is claiming title and possession over the suit
CIV. Misc. Petition No.1273 of 2022
properties on the basis of the R.S.D. No.733 dated 22.04.2006
executed by Srikrushna Das, son of Satish Chandra Das.
Out of the aforesaid two sale deeds of the aforesaid
parties in respect of the suit properties, the sale deed in
favour of the Opp. Party is prior to the sale deed of the
petitioner.
11. As per Section 48 of the T.P. Act, 1882 a prior sale
prevails over the subsequent sale even if the confirmation of
the prior sale was after the subsequent sale.
It is the settled propositions of law that, High Court in
exercise
of
its
jurisdiction
under
Article
of
the
Constitution of India ought not to interfere with the findings
arrived at by the two Courts below.
On this aspect, the propositions of law has already been
clarified in the ratio of the following decisions:
I.
In a case between S.P. Deshmukh Vs. Shah
Nihal Chand Waghajibai Gujarati
reported
in (1977) 3 SCC 515 that, High Court in
exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 227 of
the Constitution of India ought not to have
interfered with the findings arrived at by the
two Courts below.
CIV. Misc. Petition No.1273 of 2022
II.
In a case between Kesharlal H. Pardeshi Vs.
Vithal S. Patole (dead) by LRs reported in
(2005) 10 SCC 249 that, High Court in
exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 227 of
the Constitution of India ought not to have
interfered with the findings arrived at by the
two Courts below.
III.
In a case between Surya Dev Rai Vs. Ram
Chander Rai & Others reported in (2003) 6
SCC
jurisdiction
that,
exercise
under
Article
of
supervisory
of
the
constitution of India is not available to correct
mere errors of fact or of law unless the following
requirements are satisfied : (i) the error is
manifest and apparent on the face of the
proceedings such as it is based on clear
ignorance or utter disregard of the provisions of
law, and (ii) a grave injustice or gross failure of
justice has occasioned thereby.
IV.
In a case between M/s. Estralla Rubber Vs.
Dass Estate (P) Ltd. reported in
SCC 97
(2001)
that, High Court while acting under
this Article cannot exercise its power as an
appellate court or substitute its own judgment
in place of that of the subordinate court to
correct an error, which is not apparent on the
face of the record. The High Court is not vested
with any unlimited prerogative to correct all
kinds of hardship or wrong decisions made
within the limits of the jurisdiction of the courts
subordinate or Tribunals.
CIV. Misc. Petition No.1273 of 2022
12. Here in this matter at hand, when the learned Senior
Civil Judge, Kujanga and the learned Addl. District Judge,
Kujanga
both
have
passed
the
order
for
temporary
injunction against the petitioner (defendant No.1) and in
favour of the Opp. Party (plaintiff) on the basis of the prior
sale deed in respect of the suit properties executed by one of
the successors of the original owner i.e. Subhadra Das
(defendant No.5), then, at this juncture, it cannot be held
that, the impugned order and Judgment passed by the
learned Senior Civil Judge, Kujanga and the learned Addl.
District Judge, Kujanga in I.A. No.66/2022 and F.A.O
No.25/2022 respectively against the petitioner in this CMP
suffers from any error apparent on the face of the proceeding
or the same are based on clear ignorance or utter disregard
of the provisions of law, then, at this juncture, in view of the
principles of law enunciated by the Apex Court in the ratio of
the aforesaid decisions, the intereference by this Court
exercising the supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of
the constitution of India, 1950 with the impugned order &
Judgment dated 20.07.2022 and 31.10.2022 respectively
CIV. Misc. Petition No.1273 of 2022
passed in I.A. No.66/2022 and F.A.O. No.25 of 2022 do not
warrantable. For which, this CMP filed by the petitioner
cannot be allowed.
13.
Therefore, there is no merit in the CMP filed by
petitioner. The same must fail.
14.
In result, this CMP filed by the petitioner is dismissed
on contest.
15. The learned Senior Civil Judge, Kujanga is directed to
dispose of the suit vide C.S. No.84/2022 pending before him
as expeditiously as possible.
16. As such, this CMP filed by the petitioner is disposed of
finally.
(ANANDA CHANDRA BEHERA)
JUDGE
High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
The 22.01.2026// Rati Ranjan Nayak
Sr. Stenographer
Digitally Signed
Signed by: RATI RANJAN NAYAK
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 22-Jan-2026 16:48:42
CIV. Misc. Petition No.1273 of 2022
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review