The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
27. 08.2025 and not some additional duties in form of teaching discharged by the incumbent whose post otherwise does not fall under the teaching faculty. Therefore, assuming for the sake of arguments that petitioner had been imparting teaching as asserted that would not make the post of HCM occupied by her to fall under teaching faculty to enable her to have the benefit of notification dated 27.08.2025 in order - 11 - 2026:HHC:903 to continue to serve beyond her superannuation. Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner had also urged the fact that Headmasters and Principals serving in Government Schools and Colleges had been extended the benefit of notification dated 27.08.2025 and their services had been continued even after superannuation till the currency of ongoing academic session. This argument will not advance the case of the petitioner. As has already been observed, neither the post of HCM falls under the teaching faculty nor the HCM can be said to be a respondents have categorically teacher. The pleaded in the reply that neither any Principal nor any Supervisory Cadre Officer in any Government ITI has been granted sessional re- employment under notification dated 27.08.2025. Thus, respondents have uniformly not considered the posts of Principals as also the posts belonging to Supervisory Cadre in Govt. ITIs as Teaching faculty posts. Petitioner has not been discriminated w…
5. In view of above, petitioner’s claim of reemployment till the currency of academic session 2025-26 lacks merits. Accordingly, present writ petition is dismissed. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, also stand disposed of. January 5, 2026 R.Atal Jyotsna Rewal Dua Judge
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:903
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA
CWP No.18558 of 2025
Decided on: 05.01.2026
_________________________________________________________________
Beasa Thakur
....Petitioner
Versus
State of H.P. & Ors.
…Respondents
_________________________________________________________________
Coram
Ms. Justice Jyotsna Rewal Dua
1 Whether approved for reporting?
_________________________________________________________________
For the petitioner:
Mr. Sanjeev Bhushan, Sr. Advocate
with
Mr.
Sparsh
Bhushan,
Advocate.
For the respondents:
Mr. Rajat Chaudhary,
Advocate General.
Assistant
Jyotsna Rewal Dua, Judge
Petitioner superannuated on 30.11.2025. She
seeks applicability of notification dated 27.08.2025 in order
to continue to serve the respondent till currency of ongoing
academic session 2025-26.
2.
The facts.
2(i)
Petitioner served as Junior Tailor Mistress (JTM)
w.e.f. 04.02.2000 in the Industrial Training Institute (Women)
(ITI) Mandi. She was promoted
as Head Craft Mistress
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment? yes
-2-
2026:HHC:903
(HCM) on 07.06.2022 in the pay level-12, in the Pay Band of
Rs.10300-34800 + 4200 (Grade Pay).
2(ii)
Respondents-State
27.08.2025,
ordering
teachers/teaching
faculty
issued
a
sessional
posted
notification
on
re-employment
of
in
the
Government
Educational Institutions of Education Department, Technical
Education,
AYUSH
Education
and
Medical
Education
Departments of the State for ongoing academic session 202526. The relevant portion of the notification reads as under: “GOVERNEMNT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH
FINANCE(REGULATIONS) DEPARTMENT
No. Fin (C)-A(3)-2/2013 Dt., Shimla-171002, the 27 th August 2025
NOTIFICATION
The Governor, Himachal Pradesh is pleased to order
that the teachers/teaching faculty posted in Government
educational institutions of Education Department, Technical
Education,
AYUSH
Education
and
Medical
Education
departments of the State Government shall be sessional reemployed for ongoing academic session 2025-2026 as per
following criteria: 1. All such teachers/teaching faculty who would otherwise
have retired from service on completing normal age of
superannuation on any day falling between the date of this
notification and the last day of the previous month of the
ending month of the ongoing academic session, shall, except
in case of their otherwise voluntary opt out option, continue
in service, and shall be deemed to be sessional re-employed
after the date of superannuation up to the specified date of
the end of the ongoing academic session as per the
ANNEXURE A.
2. Provided that during the aforesaid period of
re-
-3-
2026:HHC:903
employment, such teachers shall be paid remuneration
equivalent to the difference between their last pay drawn
and the full pension admissible to them.
3. Further provided that, other than regular monthly pension
starting from the normal age of superannuation, all other
retiral benefits due on the date of actual superannuation,
such as gratuity, leave encashment, final General Provident
Fund, commutation of pension etc. as the case maybe, shall
be payable and settled only after the completion of such
sessional re-employment.
4.
The voluntary option to opt out of this sessional re-
employment shall be submitted to the Head of Office or
Head of Department, well before 60 days of attaining the
normal age of superannuation. This opt out option is to be
submitted in four copies on a form of option/undertaking as
per the proforma at ANNEXURE-B.
5. The teachers/teaching faculty in whose cases the date of
superannuation is before the expiry of 60 days from the
date of this notification, they may exercise opt out option at
any time before the date of their superannuation and after
the issue of this notification.
6. The end date of the ongoing academies session of each
category of educational institutions shall be deemed to be as
per ANNEXURE-A for the purpose of this notification.”
Petitioner, vide Annexure P-5, represented for
extending benefit of the aforesaid notification in her favour to
allow her to continue to serve the institute till completion of
academic session 2025-26.
2(iii)
Respondent
No.2-the
Director
Technical
Education, Vocational and Industrial Training Sundernagar,
District Mandi, vide its letter dated 19.11.2025 (Annexure P-
-4-
2026:HHC:903
2) conveyed that posts of Group Instructor and Head Craft
Mistress in ITIs are supervisory in nature, therefore, these
posts do not fall within the purview of notification issued on
27.08.2025. Feeling aggrieved, petitioner instituted this writ
petition on 24.11.2025, claiming following substantive relief:“(i)
That an appropriate writ, order or directions may kindly
be
issued
and
the
impugned
Notification
dated
19.11.2025, Annexure P-2, may kindly be quashed and
set aside with further directions to the respondent to
allow the petitioner to avail the benefit of sessional
reemployment being a part of teaching faculty in
government industrial training institutes in the interest
of law and justice.”
Petitioner retired on 30.11.2025 on attaining the
age of superannuation.
3.
Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner referred
to the documents placed on record as Annexure P-4 (colly) to
highlight that petitioner had been directed by the Principal of
the concerned ITI to take certain specific classes mentioned
in the some office letters
[part of Annexure P-4 (colly)].
Learned senior Counsel for the petitioner also invited
attention to Annexure P-6, appended alongwith the rejoinder
to support his submission that petitioner had been taking
teaching classes. It was urged that petitioner was member of
-5-
teaching faculty and thus eligible
2026:HHC:903
for continued service till
the ongoing academic session 2025-26
dated 27.08.2025.
whereunder,
notification
as per notification
Annexure P-7 was also referred to,
respondents had conferred the benefit of
dated
27.08.2025
to
the
Headmasters/
Principals serving in Government Schools/Colleges in the
Education Department.
The above submissions have been opposed by the
respondents. Learned Assistant Advocate General on the
strength of reply filed by the respondents, submitted that
though the post of JTM falls in teaching faculty, which
otherwise has now been declared as dying cadre, but post of
HCM is only a supervisory post with supervisory duties. The
post of HCM is not a teaching post.
The role and
responsibilities as also the pay level of HCM is similar to that
of Group Instructors of the ITIs. The post of HCM is created
only in the women ITIs. The said post being not a teaching
faculty post, is not covered under the notification dated
27.08.2025.
record by the
With regard to certain documents placed on
petitioner for her having rendered
duties, more particularly, during
teaching
the months August to
-6-
2026:HHC:903
October 2025, it was submitted that
temporary teaching
duties were assigned to the petitioner in the absence of
regular instructors/teachers. The arrangements were only to
ensure continuity of training for short duration.
Such
arrangements would not confer status of teaching faculty
upon the supervisory staff.
On facts, submission was made
that class training charge was thereafter, duly handed to one
Smt. Asha Devi, Instructor Sewing Technology, who was
deployed to Government ITI, Mandi having been declared
surplus due to non-admission
in second unit of Sewing
Technology Trade at ITI Chachiot, District Mandi
for
academic session 2025-26.
4.
Heard
learned
counsel
for
the
parties
and
27.08.2025,
enables
the
considered the case file.
4(i)
Notification
dated
teachers/ teaching faculty posted in Government Educational
Institutions of Education Department, Technical Education,
AYUSH Education and Medical Education Departments of the
State for sessional reemployment for ongoing academic
session 2025-26. Petitioner as Head Craft Mistress in
Government Industrial Training Institute cannot be said to
-7-
2026:HHC:903
be a teacher/teaching faculty to fall within the purview of
notification dated 27.08.2025.
4(ii)
There is no dispute that post of HCM is equivalent
to that of Group Instructor. The post of HCM carries the role
and responsibilities as also the pay level as that of Group
Instructors of ITIs. The respondents have placed on record,
duties of Principals, Supervisory and Instructional staff of
ITIs including that of Group Instructor.
Duties of Group
Instructor read as under: “(ii)
Group Instructor
The Group Instructors should ensure that
(a) proper coordination is maintained in all the
sections and the training programme is carried
out efficiently, by personal close check and
inspections:
(b) the tests are regularly carried out, the trainees'
work is correctly assessed, and proper record is
kept in the progress cards;
(c) raw material requirements of the sections are
prepared well in advance to enable supply to be
arranged in time:
(d) safety precautions are observed in the workshop;
(e) sections function strictly according to the time
schedule laid down and proper discipline
maintained; and
(f) any other additional duties assigned by the
Principal of ITI.
The Group Instructor will also conduct model lessons in
his/her own or connected subjects.
The Group Instructor will also carry out any additional
work entrusted to him/her by the Principal of the ITI
Note:
i)
The lessons prepared by the instructors should
be checked by the concerned Group Instructor for
-8-
2026:HHC:903
correct planning and accuracy. This may be done
in the beginning of each working day for which
the Group Instructor may spend about 15
minutes in each section.
(ii) The Group Instructor may also carry out a check
of a certain percentage of these lessons to ensure
proper planning of lessons and right standard.
(iii) The Group Instructor will also attend these
lectures from time to time to ensure that the
proper teaching technique is followed.”
The above make it evident that duties of Group
Instructors/HCM
are
supervisory
in
nature.
Group
Instructors are
also
to supervise
the
lessons/teaching
techniques adopted/practiced by Instructors.
The role and responsibilities of Group Instructor
in ITIs have been further delineated by the respondents in
office order dated 19.06.2025 (Annexure P-3). Relevant
portion of which, reads as under: “DIRECTORATE OF TECHNICAL EDUCATION VOCATIONAL
AND INDUSTRIAL TRAINING
HIMACHAL PRADESH SUNDERNAGAR
(Email: techedu-hp@nic.in, Phone No.01907- 266120, 267631)
No. EDNTEH-F010/2/2025-NCVET- 38512-650 Date: 19.06.2025
To
Sub:-
The Principal/DDO
All Govt. ITs of Himachal Pradesh
Regarding role and responsibilities of Group Instructor
in Industrial Training Institute.
Memo,
Refer
28.05.2025,
to
letter
received
No.
from
EDNTE)A(3)-5/2025
the
Secretary
(TE)
dated
to
the
Government of Himachal Pradesh, on the subject cited above
(copy enclosed).
In this regard, it is intimated that it has been directed
-9-
2026:HHC:903
to assign additional duties to the Group Instructors working
in the Industrial Training Institutes of the state, in addition to
the roles and responsibilities defined in the Training Manual
issued by the DGT, Ministry of Skill Development and
Entrepreneurship, Government of India, Henceforth, all the
Group Instructors will perform the following duties in addition
to their own work.
1.
2.
3.
They will be actively engaged in the direct teaching
of theoretical and practical aspects pertaining to
their respective trades in absence of concerned
trade Instructor for which they will have to
maintain all records.
If trade Instructor for all trades running in a
particular Institute are available, Group Instructors
will deliver sessions/seminars on advancement in
concerned trade/related sector. Further, they will
deliver lecture on crucial topics such as New Age
Technologies, Industry 4.0, Employability Skills,
Kaizen, 5S, Entrepreneurship, safety at workplace,
Road safety, AIDS, Natural Disaster etc. This will
be mandatory for Group Instructors of all trades.
The Group Instructor will keep records for these
classes.
They shall deliver lecture to the Instructors/
Trainers/ Trainees on National Skill Qualifications
Framework (NSQF) Implementation Manual for
NCVT Courses at the start of each new session and
at regular intervals.”
From the above it becomes clear that
duty of Group Instructors/HCM
primary
is supervisory in nature. It
is only in absence of the concerned trade instructor that they
can be directed to impart teaching of theoretical and practical
aspects pertaining to their respective trades. It is in view of
this mandate that petitioner probably took certain class as
asserted by her in terms of Annexure P-4 (colly) and
Annexure P-6. Documents on record do not suggest that post
of Group Instructor equivalent to HCM, belongs to teaching
- 10 -
2026:HHC:903
faculty.
Respondents have not disputed that post of JTM
in Government ITIs falls under the teaching faculty, but the
said post has been declared as a dying cadre. The petitioner
had been promoted to the post of HCM on 07.06.2022 from
the post of JTM. Thus, w.e.f. 07.06.2022, the petitioner had
ceased to be teacher/teaching faculty, having become part of
the supervisory cadre.
Even if the petitioner had been
assigned some additional duties of teaching certain classes
in absence of the regular incumbent as is projected for her,
then also, that factor alone would not make the petitioner
(HCM) a teacher to fall within the ambit of teacher/teaching
faculty. It is the post concerned that has to belong to teaching
faculty
to
attract
the
benefits
of
notification
dated
27.08.2025 and not some additional duties in form of
teaching discharged by the incumbent whose post otherwise
does not fall under the teaching faculty. Therefore, assuming
for the sake of arguments that petitioner had been imparting
teaching as asserted that would not make the post of HCM
occupied by her to fall under teaching faculty to enable her
to have the benefit of notification dated 27.08.2025 in order
- 11 -
2026:HHC:903
to continue to serve beyond her superannuation.
Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner had also
urged the fact that Headmasters and Principals serving in
Government Schools and Colleges had been extended the
benefit of notification dated 27.08.2025 and their services
had been continued even after superannuation till the
currency of ongoing academic session. This argument will not
advance
the case of the petitioner. As has already
been
observed, neither the post of HCM falls under the teaching
faculty nor the HCM can be said to be a
respondents have
categorically
teacher. The
pleaded in the
reply that
neither any Principal nor any Supervisory Cadre Officer in
any Government ITI
has been granted sessional re-
employment under notification dated 27.08.2025. Thus,
respondents have uniformly not
considered the posts of
Principals as also the posts belonging to Supervisory Cadre in
Govt. ITIs as Teaching faculty posts. Petitioner has not been
discriminated with any other Head Craft Mistress or Principal
of Government ITI. Merely because Head Teachers/Principles
serving in Government Schools and Colleges, who belong to
teaching faculty, and as such have been granted the benefit
- 12 -
of
sessional
re-employment
2026:HHC:903
would
not
mean
that
respondents are liable to apply the notification to nonteaching cadre in Government ITIs.
5.
In
view
of
above,
petitioner’s
claim
of
reemployment till the currency of academic session 2025-26
lacks merits. Accordingly, present writ petition is dismissed.
Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, also
stand disposed of.
January 5, 2026
R.Atal
Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review