Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:29443
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CMPMO No. 765 of 2024
Date of decision: 15.07.2026.
Basanti Devi
...Petitioner.
Versus
Bhagmal
...Respondent.
Coram:
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Romesh Verma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the petitioner
:
Mr. Sandeep Panday, Advocate.
For the respondent
:
Mr. Prakash Chand, Advocate.
Romesh Verma, Judge (Oral):
The instant petition arises out of the judgment as
passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, CBI Court,
Shimla, H.P. dated 17.09.2024, whereby the appeal filed by the
present petitioner was allowed and the order as passed by the
learned Judicial Magistrate 1st Class, Chopal, District Shimla,
H.P., was modified, whereby the amount of maintenance was
enhanced from Rs. 3,000/- to Rs. 6,000/-.
2.
The facts that emerge in the present case are that
the present petitioner/wife filed a complaint under Section 12
of the Domestic Violence Act, 2005. In the application, it was
averred that she got married to the respondent, however, he
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the
judgment?
-2has failed to maintain her in a proper manner. She stated that
after the death of the first wife of the respondent in the year
2009, he solemnized marriage with the present petitioner and
she started living with the respondent at Gram Panchayat,
Dasholi.
3.
It is the case of the petitioner that the children of
the respondent maltreated and ill-treated her and they treat her
like their servant. It has been stated in the application that the
children of the respondent abuse the petitioner.
It has been
averred that the petitioner has been kept by the respondent at a
place called Jubbar, where he is having his house and land.
4.
It has been averred in the application that after
consuming liquor, the respondent gives beating to petitioner.
He neither gives any money nor maintains her in a proper
manner. Further, it has been stated in the application that the
respondent gives threatening to her that he shall kill her.
Therefore, the application was filed under the provisions of
Domestic Violence Act to take appropriate action against the
respondent.
5.
The respondent contested the application as filed by
the petitioner by refuting and denying all the averments as
made in the application. In reply to the application, it has been
stated that he never leveled any accusation against the
-3petitioner and all the allegations as leveled against him are
afterthought, incorrect, and misleading.
It has been stated
that the petitioner is habitual of marrying and prior to
solemnizing the marriage with the respondent, she was married
to one Liak Ram, son of Sh. Khitu Ram, resident of village
Tiprog. Thereafter, she married to Saku Khagta, resident of
village Gianh, Poma, Tehsil Chopal. Further, she married to one
Sh. Balbir, who was a technician in a Telephone Exchange,
Bharanoo, Bilaspur. Then, thereafter, she married to one Sh.
Pratap of Majhgaon, Kawanoo in Uttarakhand, and one Ramesh
of Kangra District. It has been admitted that after the death of
his first wife, he got married to the present petitioner as there
was no one to look after him.
6.
As per respondent, the petitioner married him and
demanded rupees one lakh and the said amount was given by
him to the petitioner. Thereafter, the respondent purchased
ornaments to the tune of Rs. 2.25 lakhs, which are in the care
and custody of the petitioner.
The
respondent
is
looking
after the present petitioner and he also got treated her when
she fell ill and spent a sum of rupees one lakh on her treatment
as her uterus was removed. It is the case of the respondent that
the petitioner is residing in the newly constructed house of the
respondent,
which
is
situated
in
village
Jubbar,
Gram
-4Panchayat, Makrog. The house has been constructed for the
family of the respondent and he is residing with his two sons
and daughter and he requires this house for his son as his
another son is residing in village Dasholi.
7.
As per respondent, the petitioner is a quarrelsome
lady and picks up fights with the respondent without any
rhyme or reason. She is insisting that respondent should
purchase gold bangles for her and that the allegations of giving
beating to the petitioner are false and incorrect.
It has been
stated that the respondent has no source of income, as he has
only four bighas of land in his name, which is in the possession
of the petitioner and she is earning from the orchard.
8.
The learned trial court framed the issues in the
matter in the following manner:-
9.
“1.
Whether the petitioner is entitled to the relief
provided under Sections 18, 19, 20 & 22 of the
Domestic Violence, as prayed? OPP
2.
Relief.”
The learned Judicial Magistrate 1st Class, Chopal,
District Shimla, H.P., vide its order dated 24.06.2022, allowed
the petition filed by the present petitioner and directed that the
petitioner is entitled for protection and the respondent was
prohibited from committing or abetting any act of domestic
-5violence against the petitioner.
He was directed to provide
rented accommodation to the petitioner and that the level of
accommodation should be as enjoyed by her in the shared
household or to provide her rent which is assessed at Rs.
3,000/- per month.
Further, the respondent was directed to
pay maintenance to the tune of Rs. 3,000/- to the petitioner.
Further, the petitioner was also awarded compensation of Rs.
15,000/- to be paid by the respondent.
10.
Feeling dissatisfied against the order as passed by
the learned Judicial Magistrate, 1st Class, Chopal, dated
24.06.2022, the petitioner instituted an appeal under Section
29 of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act,
2005, for the enhancement of amount of the maintenance. The
learned Additional Sessions Judge, CBI Court, Shimla, vide its
judgment dated 17.09.2024, partly accepted the appeal and the
amount of maintenance was enhanced to Rs. 6,000/- instead of
Rs. 3,000/-.
Further, the respondent was prohibited from
dispossessing the applicant from one room, one kitchen, one
washroom and one toilet being occupied by her in village
Jubbar. The respondent was directed not to disconnect the
electricity and water connections of the petitioner in the
accommodation which is being occupied by her. Further, the
respondent was directed not to alienate the land wherein the
-6aforesaid house of the respondent is situated at village Jubbar
and wherein the petitioner is residing, so that she can use the
same for her day-to-day living.
11.
That still feeling aggrieved, the petitioner/wife has
approached this court by filing the instant petition under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
12.
It is contended by the learned counsel for the
petitioner that the orders as passed by the learned trial court as
well as the learned First Appellate Court are being assailed on
the limited ground that the amount of maintenance which has
been granted by the learned courts below is inadequate and the
amount of maintenance deserves to be enhanced.
13.
It is contended by the learned counsel for the
petitioner that at least Rs. 15,000/- be awarded in the form of
maintenance to the petitioner so that she could look after and
maintain her, in her old age.
14.
On the other hand, the impugned judgment as
passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, CBI Court,
Shimla, has been defended by the learned counsel for the
respondent. He has submitted that the impugned judgment
does not suffers from any infirmity and the amount of Rs.
6,000/- which has been awarded is legal, valid and it does not
require any enhancement.
-715.
In order to substantiate her case, the present
petitioner has filed her affidavit, Ext. PW1/A. She has stated
that the respondent is her husband and she is residing with
him as his wife. She has stated that the respondent and his
family members torture and ill-treat her and they treat her like
their servant. She stated that the respondent has kept her in
village Jubbar just to harass her. The respondent in the state
of intoxication gives beating to her and he never maintains her
or gives money for her day-to-day expenses.
She has stated
that respondent usually threatens her to oust her from the
house and he also threatens her that she shall be killed.
16.
In her affidavit, the petitioner has stated that the
present respondent has got the landed property in two villages
consisting of one orchard and he is also having four houses. It
has been stated that the annual income of the respondent is
more than Rs. 80 lakhs from the orchard. She stated that since
the respondent is not maintaining her, therefore, appropriate
directions be issued to the respondent to pay the amount of
maintenance and other reliefs as envisaged under the Domestic
Violence Act.
17.
In the cross-examination of the PW-1, she has
denied the suggestions as made by the learned counsel for the
respondent that she has instituted a false case against him in
-8order to grab his property. It has been denied that neither the
respondent nor his family members ill-treat or maltreat her in
the house.
18.
In order to substantiate the case of the present
petitioner, PW2 Shyam Singh has filed his affidavit Ext. PW2/A.
In the affidavit, he has also reiterated the averments as made
by the petitioner. He has stated that the respondent gives
beating to the present petitioner and in order to harass her, she
has been kept at village Jubbar. He has further stated that the
respondent is not maintaining her and his endeavour is always
to turn the petitioner out of his house. It has been stated that
the present respondent is the owner in possession of an
orchard and he is a man of means. He has stated that since
the petitioner cannot earn her livelihood, therefore, appropriate
orders may be passed by the court.
19.
In order to rebut the case of the petitioner,
respondent has filed his affidavit Ext. RW-1/A, whereby he has
reiterated the averments as made in the reply. He has stated
that he has taken all steps to keep the petitioner happy and
after the marriage, he has constructed a two storied house
wherein they both are living. He has stated that he deposited a
sum of rupees one lakh on 30.10.2012 in UCO Bank, Baragaon
and after maturity, the amount was withdrawn by the petitioner
-9on 05.11.2016 and she has purchased the gold ornaments for a
sum of Rs. 2,25,000/-. He has stated that he is having only 9
bighas of ancestral land, but the brothers of the respondent
have given him three and half bighas of land and a fruit-bearing
apple orchard has been planted by him thereon and crop worth
rupees 2 to 3 lakhs is harvested from it by the petitioner since
2017. It has been stated that petitioner is a quarrelsome lady
and she demands money, gold, house, land and orchard from
the respondent. He has got no other source of income except
the earning from this small apple orchard. He has stated in the
affidavit that he has two sons and a daughter from his deceased
wife and they are living on the agricultural land, gifted to them
by their maternal grandmother. In the cross-examination, he
has denied the suggestion that he used to maltreat and ill-treat
the present petitioner.
He has denied that after consuming
liquor, he gives beating to the petitioner. He admitted that the
present petitioner remains ill and she was also operated.
20.
In
order
to
corroborate
the
versions
of
the
respondent, Sh. Liaq Ram filed his affidavit Ext. RW2/A. In the
affidavit, he has stated that the petitioner is living in the newly
constructed house of the respondent, but now she does not
allow the respondent to use the remaining portion of the house
and she wants to grab the entire house and property of the
-10respondent. He has stated that the respondent is an old man
and suffering from
various ailments and is undergoing
treatment at PGI, Chandigarh.
In the cross-examination, he
has admitted that the petitioner has got no independent source
of income.
21.
RW-3 Narinder Azta has been examined by the
respondent. RW-3 filed his affidavit Ext. RW3/A. He has stated
that the petitioner is guilty of cruel behavior towards the
respondent. He has stated in the affidavit that the respondent
has no source of income and remains ill. He denied the
suggestion that the respondent used to ill-treat the present
petitioner.
22.
Respondent has examined RW-4, Jai Ram in order
to corroborate his case, who filed his affidavit Ext. RW4/A. He
has stated that the petitioner picks up quarrel with the
respondent every day and lodges false complaints with the
SDM, Police Station and other Departments of H.P. In his
cross-examination he admitted that the petitioner was operated
and on that account, she could not earn anything. He denied
the suggestion that he is deposing falsely.
23.
Except the oral evidence as placed on record,
nothing has been placed on record by the respective parties to
show the total annual income of the respondent.
-1124.
The learned counsel for the petitioner has fairly
conceded
that
he
has
approached
this
court
only
for
enhancement of the amount of maintenance, which has been
awarded by the learned courts below. He submits that as far as
the other part of the orders are concerned, he is not aggrieved
by the same. However, he has filed the present petition only for
the enhancement of amount of maintenance. It is contended by
the learned counsel for the petitioner that in view of the
increase in the price index, a sum of Rs. 6,000/- which has
been awarded by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, CBI
Court, Shimla, is inadequate, and the same cannot be
presumed to be a handsome amount for the maintenance and
for sustaining the present petitioner.
25.
On
the
other
hand,
learned
counsel
for
the
respondent has submitted that the respondent has no source of
income and he is totally dependent on his children.
26.
Chapter IV of the DV Act, 2005, lays down
what
kind of reliefs can be granted to a person aggrieved who has
been subjected to any act of domestic violence.
There are
different categories of reliefs which can be granted under the
DV Act, 2005. These reliefs can be sought either by making
an application
under Section 12 of the DV Act, 2005 or by
making an application in pending legal proceedings affecting
-12aggrieved
person before a Civil Court, Family Court or a
Criminal Court. One of the reliefs provided under Section 20
reads as follows:“Monetary reliefs.-(1) While disposing of an application under
sub-section (1) of Section 12, the Magistrate may direct the
respondent to pay monetary relief to meet the expenses
incurred and losses suffered by the aggrieved person and any
child of the aggrieved person as a result of the domestic
violence and such relief may include, but is not limited to,—
(a) the loss of earnings;
(b) the medical expenses;
(c) the loss caused due to the destruction, damage or
removal of any property from the control of the aggrieved
person; and
(d) the maintenance for the aggrieved person as well as
her children, if any, including an order under or in
addition to an order of maintenance under Section 125
of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974) or
any other law for the time being in force.
(2) The monetary relief granted under this section shall be
adequate, fair and reasonable and consistent with the
standard of living to which the aggrieved person is accustomed.
(3) The Magistrate shall have the power to order an appropriate
lump sum payment or monthly payments of maintenance, as
the nature and circumstances of the case may require.
(4) The Magistrate shall send a copy of the order for monetary
relief made under sub-section (1) to the parties to the
application and to the in-charge of the police station within the
local limits of whose jurisdiction the respondent resides.
(5) The respondent shall pay the monetary relief granted to the
aggrieved person within the period specified in the order under
sub-section (1).
(6) Upon the failure on the part of the respondent to make
payment in terms of the order under sub-section (1), the
Magistrate may direct the employer or a debtor of the
respondent, to directly pay to the aggrieved person or to deposit
with the court a portion of the wages or salaries or debt due to
or accrued to the credit of the respondent, which amount may
be adjusted towards the monetary relief payable by the
respondent.”
27.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Criminal Appeal
No. 2688 of 2025 in case titled Shaurabh Kumar Tripathi
vs. Vidhi Rawal, decided on19.05.2025 has held that the
-13Domestic Violence Act is a welfare legislation specially enacted
to give justice to those women, who suffer from domestic
violence and for preventing the acts of domestic violence.
28.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in case titled Satish
Chander Ahuja vs. Sneha Ahuja (2021) 1 SCC 414 has held
as under:
“41.As noticed above, from the Statement of Objects and
Reasons, the Act was enacted to fulfill the definite objectives for
protection of women. This Court had occasion to examine the
purpose of enactment of Act, 2005 in Kunapareddy Alias
NookalaShanka Balaji Vs. Kunapareddy Swarna Kumari and
Anr., (2016) 11 SCC 774 wherein paragraph 12 following was
stated:“12.In fact, the very purpose of enacting the DV Act was
to provide for a remedy which is an amalgamation of
civil rights of the complainant i.e. aggrieved person.
Intention was to protect women against violence of any
kind, especially that occurring within the family as the
civil law does not address this phenomenon in its
entirety. It is treated as an offence Under Section 498-A
of the Penal Code, 1860. The purpose of enacting the law
was to provide a remedy in the civil law for the
protection of women from being victims of domestic
violence and to prevent the occurrence of domestic
violence in the society. It is for this reason, that the
Scheme of the Act provides that in the first instance, the
order that would be passed by the Magistrate, on a
complaint by the aggrieved person, would be of a civil
nature and if the said order is violated, it assumes the
character of criminality…..”
42. The Act, 2005 is a further step to secure social justice by
legislation. There has been several earlier measures for
protection of women like Section 125 Cr.P.C. and 498-A of India
Penal Code. Justice Krishna Iyer in Captain Ramesh Chander
Kaushal Vs. Mrs. Veena Kaushal and Ors., (1978) 4 SCC 70
noted the objectives of enacting Section 125 Cr.P.C. in following
words in paragraph 9:“9. This provision is a measure of social justice and
specially enacted to protect women and children and
falls within the constitutional sweep of Article
15(3) reinforced by Article 39. We have no doubt that
-14sections of statutes calling for construction by Courts are
not petrified print but vibrant words with social functions
to fulfil. The brooding presence of the constitutional
empathy for the weaker sections like women and
children must inform interpretation if it has to have social
relevance. So viewed, it is possible to be selective in
picking out that interpretation out of two alternatives
which advance the cause--the cause of the derelicts.”
29.
For the grant of maintenance, the financial capacity
of the husband, his actual income, reasonable expenses for his
own maintenance and dependent family members whom he is
obliged to maintain under the law, liabilities if any, would be
required to be taken into consideration to arrive at the
appropriate quantum of maintenance to be paid. The plea of the
husband that he does not possess any source of income ipso
facto does not absolve him of his moral duty to maintain his
wife if he is able- bodied person. The test for determination of
maintenance in matrimonial dispute depends on the financial
status of the lady and the standard of living that she was
accustomed to in her matrimonial home.
The maintenance
amount awarded must be reasonable and realistic and avoid
either of the two extremes i.e. maintenance awarded to the wife
should neither be so extravagant
which becomes oppressive
and unbearable for the respondent nor should it be so meager
that it drives the wife to penury.
30.
Sub-section 2 of Section 20 of the D.V. Act provides
that the monetary relief granted to the aggrieved woman and/or
-15the children must be adequate, fair, reasonable and consistent
with the standard of living to which the aggrieved woman was
accustomed to in her matrimonial home.
31.
After examining the oral evidence as placed on
record it reveals that both the parties are in the advanced stage
of their life. As has been submitted by the learned counsel for
the parties, the present petitioner is more than 64 years old
and the respondent is more than 75 years old. Though, no
substantial proof or evidence has been placed on record for the
enhancement of the amount of maintenance, but keeping in
view the totality in the facts and circumstances of the case and
the evidence on record that the respondent is owner in
possession of an orchard and he is also owning four houses in
the native place, therefore, taking into consideration the age of
the petitioner and the fact that she is residing all alone and she
has no children to look after her and in view of increase in price
index, this court modifies the order as passed by the learned
Additional Sessions Judge, CBI Court, Shimla, by enhancing
the amount from Rs. 6,000/- per month to Rs. 8,000/- per
month. The said amount shall be paid by the respondent to the
petitioner from the date of passing of the order by the learned
Additional Sessions Judge, CBI Court, Shimla.
-1632.
With these observations, the present petition as filed
by the petitioner/wife is partly allowed and the impugned order
as passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, CBI Court, Shimla
is modified to the above extent. Pending applications, if any,
also stand disposed of.
(Romesh Verma)
Judge
15th July, 2026.
(kck)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review