The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
19. Before parting, the technical objections raised regarding the misapplication of Section 228 and non-compliance with the stipulation in Section 281 need to be dealt with. Regarding the first contention qua Section 228 of the Act, this Court is of the opinion that the mere nomenclature of a petition ought not to vitiate the entire proceedings before the Trial Court, considering that the Court otherwise possessed the inherent jurisdiction to grant the relief that was sought. It is also worth mentioning that the underlying petition was filed in the year 1993, i.e., over 30 years ago, and this objection was raised for the first time only before this Court. It is trite law that procedure is the handmaiden of justice and procedural technicalities should not be allowed to defeat the cause of substantive justice. Insofar as the contention regarding Section 281 of the Act is concerned, it is sufficient to note that a bare reading of the provision reveals that it only states that where an application is made for probate, the petition shall also be verified by at least one of the witnesses to the Will „when procurable‟. The inclusion of the qualifier „when procurable‟ clearly indicates that the requirement is directory in nature and not mandatory. Notably, this plea, too, was never raised by the objectors before the Trial Court. In the opinion of this Court, having failed to agitate this p…
20. Considering all the above, I find no infirmity or illegality in the impugned order and the present appeal is accordingly dismissed.
21. The present appeal, along with pending application(s), is disposed of in the above terms.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Reserved on
Pronounced on
Uploaded on
: 04.02.2026
: 14.05.2026
: 14.05.2026
FAO 137/2008 and CM APPL. 3872/2011 (stay)
BANWARI LAL (DECEASED) THROUGH L.R'S MAYA DEVI
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Akshit Mago and Mr. Vipul
Saini, Advocates.
versus
SHIV CHARAN & ORS
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Raghunandan Sharma, Advocate
for Respondent No.1.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
JUDGMENT
1.
The present appeal challenges the order dated 30.11.2007 passed by
the learned ADJ in PC No. 56/06. Vide the impugned order, the Trial Court
allowed the underlying petition and granted letters of Administration qua the
registered Will dated 03.03.1989 executed by late Sh. Jhullu Mal.
2.
The said petition was filed by the testator‟s children, namely Sh. Shiv
Charan, Smt. Urmila Devi, and Smt. Harwati Devi (hereinafter referred to as
the “petitioners”). The same was opposed by the testator‟s remaining two
sons, Sh. Banwari Lal and Sh. Prem Shankar (hereinafter referred to as the
“objectors”).
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:04:09
FAO 137/2008
3.
The present appeal has been preferred by the legal heirs of the
objector/late Sh. Banwari Lal. Neither the co-objector/late Sh. Prem Shankar
nor his legal heirs have joined in challenging the impugned order.
4.
Briefly stated, the facts relevant for the adjudication of the present
appeal are as follows:
Late Sh. Jhullu Mal (hereinafter referred to as the “testator”) passed
away at the age of about 90 years on 30.12.1990. A registered Will dated
03.03.1989, of which the petitioners are the beneficiaries, was propounded
and the underlying petition under Section 228 of the Indian Succession Act,
1925 (hereinafter the “Act”) was filed regarding the same. The objectors
challenged the petition, stating that the aforesaid Will was not the last Will
of the testator. They instead produced an unregistered Will dated
28.11.1990, which bequeaths the immovable properties concerned in favour
of the three brothers, namely the objectors and the petitioner/Sh. Shiv
Charan, while bequeathing only certain quantities of gold and silver in
favour of the sisters, namely the remaining petitioners, Smt. Urmila Devi,
and Smt. Harwati Devi.
5.
Learned counsel appearing for the objector/late Sh. Banwari Lal‟s
heirs, while assailing the impugned order, contends that the unregistered
Will dated 28.11.1990 is the last Will and testament of the testator. It is
contended that the mode and manner of the execution of the propounded
Will dated 03.03.1989 are highly doubtful, pointing to material
contradictions in the testimonies of the petitioner/Sh. Shiv Charan (PW-2)
and the attesting witness/Sh. Tilak Raj (PW-3). Learned counsel also calls
into question the credibility of the attesting witness, stating that he was an
interested witness who had known the family for 35 years and had
purchased an adjacent property from the testator. It is further submitted that
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:04:09
FAO 137/2008
the mandatory provisions of Section 63 of the Act and Section 68 of the
Indian Evidence Act, 1872 have not been satisfied as the second attesting
witness was not even examined. Furthermore, he contends that the testator‟s
signatures in the concerned Will are inconsistent. Learned counsel also
argues that the Trial Court erroneously observed that the probate petition
filed by the objector qua the subsequent unregistered Will dated 28.11.1990
was dismissed on merits, as no such document was placed on record. Lastly,
it is contended that the underlying petition failed to comply with the
verification requirements under Section 281 of the Act, and was improperly
filed and decided under Section 228 of the Act, which provision applies
strictly to Wills executed abroad.
6.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner/Sh. Shiv
Charan, while supporting the impugned order, submits that the Will dated
03.03.1989 is a registered document which specifically records the testator's
dissatisfaction with the objectors. It is submitted that the credibility of the
attesting witness/Sh. Tilak Raj (PW-3), is not diminished merely because he
knew the family or purchased property from the testator, nor is the nonexamination of the second attesting witness fatal since the execution and
attestation of the registered Will were sufficiently proved through the
examined attesting witness. Furthermore, the dismissal of the probate
proceedings qua the unregistered Will dated 28.11.1990 has attained finality
due to the same not being assailed, and as such, the legal heirs of the
objector are merely attempting to grab the concerned properties by raising
frivolous grounds in the present appeal. Regarding the technical objection
concerning Section 228 of the Act, it is submitted that the nomenclature of
the provision used in the petition may be ignored as the substantive
requirements for the grant of letters of Administration were duly satisfied.
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:04:09
FAO 137/2008
Lastly, in respect of the stipulations under Section 281 of the Act not being
met, it is submitted that this plea was not raised before the Trial Court and
cannot be introduced belatedly at the present appellate stage.
7.
I have heard the learned counsels for the parties and carefully
examined the record.
8.
The impugned order notes that the registered Will dated 03.03.1989
was attested by two individuals: Sh. Ramesh Kumar, who was not examined,
and Sh. Tilak Raj, who was examined as PW-3. It has been contended that
PW-3 was an interested witness, having close professional and financial
connections with the petitioner, Sh. Shiv Charan. To substantiate this
contention, the deposition of PW-3 needs to be referred to.
PW-3 deposed that he was familiar with the family of the testator as
he had purchased a property from him and was his neighbour. He stated that
the petitioner/Sh. Shiv Charan‟s son, namely Sh. Kewal Kishan, had been
working with him for the past 8-9 years. He also stated that at the time of the
execution of the concerned Will, the testator had asked him to accompany
the testator to the chambers of the scribe of the Will, namely Sh. S.S.
Dhingra, Advocate, and the witness had obliged. He denied the suggestion
that he was deposing at the instance of the petitioner/Sh. Shiv Charan as he
was having business relations with him and his son. He also denied the
suggestion that he was in close contact with the petitioner, being his
immediate neighbour. During cross-examination, he denied the suggestion
that he was working in partnership with the petitioner‟s son and was
therefore deposing falsely.
In the opinion of this Court, it is but natural to expect a testator to call
upon familiar and trusted individuals from his immediate neighbourhood to
witness the execution of his Will, rather than relying on complete strangers
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:04:09
FAO 137/2008
for the fear that the former may be deemed „interested‟. On a careful perusal
of the testimony of PW-3, nothing has come on record to show that PW-3 is
a direct or indirect beneficiary of the propounded Will. On the contrary, the
testimony of PW-3 reads as consistent, credible, and natural. Therefore,
there appears to be no reason to discard the same.
9.
Section 63 of the Act deals with the execution of unprivileged Wills
and mandates attestation of the same by two or more witnesses. Section 68
of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 deals with the proof of execution of a
document required by law to be attested and states that such a document
shall not be used as evidence until at least one attesting witness has been
called for the purpose of proving its execution, subject to certain conditions.
In the present case, PW-3 was examined to prove the execution of the Will.
PW-3 deposed that, in his presence, the scribe of the Will explained the
contents of the Will to the testator and inquired whether he wanted any
changes made to the Will, to which the testator replied that it had been
drafted as per his instructions. Thereafter, the testator signed the Will in
PW-3‟s presence at point „A‟. The witness then signed the Will at point „B‟,
whereafter the second attesting witness, Sh. Ramesh Kumar, also signed the
Will at point „C‟. Subsequently, they went to the Office of the Sub-Registrar
to get the Will registered, where the testator signed the document before the
Sub-Registrar and also affixed his thumb impression on it. PW-1 proved the
Will as Ex. PW-3/1. During cross-examination, he denied the suggestions
that the Will was not executed by the testator and that the testator had not
signed it in his presence. The Trial Court was correct in holding that the
attesting witness had proved the execution of the Will satisfactorily. Having
held the testimony of the attesting witness PW-3 to be reliable, this Court is
of the opinion that the contention regarding non-compliance with Section 63
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:04:09
FAO 137/2008
of the Act and Section 68 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 due to the nonexamination of the second attesting witness, is meritless. There is no
requirement in law to examine both attesting witnesses if one is available
and proves the due execution.
10.
A specific contention has been raised that the Trial Court erroneously
assumed that the probate petition regarding the subsequent unregistered Will
dated 28.11.1990 was dismissed on merits without its judicial record being
on file. In this regard, the impugned order notes that both the objectors had
admitted that the petition for grant of letters of Administration/probate qua
the said Will was dismissed after trial, and no review/revision or appeal was
preferred against that judgment. The Trial Court further observed that
although the concerned judgment was not placed on record by the objectors,
the dismissal had attained finality due to the conduct of the parties in not
preferring any appeal against the same. Notably, the said judgment has not
been placed on record before this Court, either. The Court of Probate is only
concerned with the question as to whether the propounded Will of a
deceased person was duly executed and attested in accordance with the law
and whether at the time of such execution the testator had a sound disposing
mind. This Court, while seized of the present appeal, is only concerned with
determining whether the Trial Court was justified in granting letters of
Administration based on the registered Will dated 03.03.1989 or not.
11.
It may also be worthwhile to mention at this stage that one of the two
objectors, Sh. Prem Shankar, had filed a suit bearing no. 699/2002 seeking
cancellation of the testator‟s Will dated 03.03.1989, and the same was
dismissed vide judgment dated 08.09.2015. An appeal against the said
decision was filed, bearing no. RCA 1152/16, and the same was also
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:04:09
FAO 137/2008
dismissed vide judgment dated 13.07.2018. It has been stated that a second
appeal has been filed and notice is yet to be issued in the same.
12.
Although the issue of the testator‟s sound disposing mind was argued
before the Trial Court and is dealt with in detail in the impugned order,
neither have any grounds on this aspect been pleaded in the present appeal,
nor have any arguments on this point been included in the short note of
contentions that has been filed.
13.
It has been contended that the mode and manner of execution of the
concerned Will is suspicious due to material contradictions in the testimony
of the petitioner/Sh. Shiv Charan (PW-2) and the attesting witness/Sh. Tilak
Raj (PW-3).
14.
The first specific allegation in this regard is that the attesting witness
stated that the contents of the Will were narrated by the testator, while
simultaneously admitting that the testator had lost his voice nearly 2 years
prior due to surgery.
In this regard, the scribe of the Will, Sh. S.S. Dhingra, Advocate (PW1) has deposed that the testator had instructed him to draft a Will on his
behalf and, accordingly, he did so. After getting the Will typed, he read over
the contents of the same to the testator and explained them to him in the
vernacular. After understanding the same, the testator signed the Will in the
advocate‟s office in the presence of two attesting witnesses. The attesting
witness/Sh. Tilak Raj (PW-3) deposed that the Will was prepared prior to
him and the testator visiting the advocate‟s chambers, where the advocate
explained the contents of the Will to the testator in the witness‟ presence.
PW-1 inquired from the testator as to whether he wanted any changes made
to the Will, to which the testator replied that it was made as per his
instructions.
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:04:09
FAO 137/2008
The petitioner/Sh. Shiv Charan (PW-2) deposed that the testator was
operated upon in 1987 and after the operation, the voice of the testator „went
down‟ but he was still able to „perform all jobs‟. He denied that the testator
was unable to move and was not able to speak and hear. Further, PW-3
deposed that while the testator had undergone surgery in 1987, he had not
„completely‟ lost his voice. Furthermore, the Trial Court has noted that the
record shows that despite the surgery in 1987, the testator actively
participated in the proceedings of Suit No. 889/1989. He had been appearing
in person in that suit on every date until 07.08.1990. His presence is marked
in person even on 07.08.1990, whereas he died on 30.12.1990. On
26.11.1990 he did not appear in person, and only on 01.02.1989 a request
was made for adjournment on the ground that he was not feeling well.
Otherwise, the record shows that after framing of issues he was appearing in
the Court on each and every date and the suit abated due to his death and not
due to his incapability to lead evidence in that case.
Thus, the contention that he was unable to communicate or make his
wishes known qua the Will is not supported by the record.
15.
The next specific allegation is that the attesting witness gave mutually
destructive versions regarding the place of execution, by stating at one stage
that the Will was signed at the advocate‟s office and at another that it was
signed before the Sub-Registrar. I find no merit in this contention. It is very
normal and believable that a Will is first signed at the office of the advocate
who is the scribe and then signed again at the office of the Sub-Registrar for
the purpose of registration. The process of registration involves this
sequence of events and there is nothing contradictory about these statements.
A perusal of the deposition of the attesting witness clearly shows that he has
stated that the testator signed the Will at the office of PW-1, and then „also‟
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:04:09
FAO 137/2008
signed the said document before the Sub Registrar. PW-1, too, has deposed
that the testator first affixed his signature to the Will in PW-1‟s office, and
later in the office of the Sub-Registrar.
16.
Regarding the allegation that the signatures of the testator are
different from one another, the Trial Court relied on the testimony of the
scribe/Sh. S.S. Dhingra (PW-1), who identified the signature of the testator
at three places at points „A‟, put in his chamber, and the signatures at points
„C‟, put at the time of registration. PW-1 also identified the thumb
impression of the testator at point „D‟. This was further corroborated by the
attesting witness/Sh. Tilak Raj (PW-3), who identified the signature of the
testator at point „A‟ as having been put in his presence, as well as the
signature and thumb impression at points „C‟ and „D‟ put before the SubRegistrar. The Trial Court after perusing the testimonies of the scribe and
the attesting witness, found the execution of the Will to be duly proved. I
find no reason to interfere with this finding, as the minor alleged differences
in signatures, especially considering the testator‟s advanced age at the time,
do not override the consistent ocular evidence of the witnesses who were
present at both the time of execution and registration.
17.
Further, the Trial Court noted that the testator had been residing with
the petitioner/Sh. Shiv Charan for about 21 years prior to his death, during
which period the petitioner served and looked after the testator, whereas
relations with the objectors were so strained that they had even filed
partition suits against their father during his lifetime. The Trial Court also
correctly observed that if the testator had any intention to give any property
to the objectors, he would have compromised those suits or partitioned the
properties during his lifetime. This strained relationship is explicitly
reflected in the registered Will dated 03.03.1989 itself, wherein the testator
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:04:09
FAO 137/2008
recorded his dissatisfaction with the conduct of the objectors as the reason
for executing a fresh Will.
18.
The Trial Court also rightly emphasized that the Will dated
03.03.1989 was a registered document, which specifically revoked an earlier
registered Will of 1981. It noted that while registration by itself does not
prove genuineness, it is an additional factor that cannot be ignored,
particularly when the subsequent Will dated 28.11.1990 produced by the
objectors is unregistered. Furthermore, the scribe/Sh. S.S. Dhingra,
Advocate, had been representing the testator in his previous litigations
against the objectors, and there was no reason to disbelieve his testimony
that he drafted the Will on the instructions of his old client. Since the
execution of the Will was fully established by the statements of the scribe
and the attesting witness, the Trial Court rightly held that there was nothing
unnatural in the testator bequeathing his properties to the petitioners.
19.
Before parting, the technical objections raised regarding the
misapplication of Section 228 and non-compliance with the stipulation in
Section 281 need to be dealt with. Regarding the first contention qua Section
228 of the Act, this Court is of the opinion that the mere nomenclature of a
petition ought not to vitiate the entire proceedings before the Trial Court,
considering that the Court otherwise possessed the inherent jurisdiction to
grant the relief that was sought. It is also worth mentioning that the
underlying petition was filed in the year 1993, i.e., over 30 years ago, and
this objection was raised for the first time only before this Court. It is trite
law that procedure is the handmaiden of justice and procedural technicalities
should not be allowed to defeat the cause of substantive justice. Insofar as
the contention regarding Section 281 of the Act is concerned, it is sufficient
to note that a bare reading of the provision reveals that it only states that
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:04:09
FAO 137/2008
where an application is made for probate, the petition shall also be verified
by at least one of the witnesses to the Will „when procurable‟. The inclusion
of the qualifier „when procurable‟ clearly indicates that the requirement is
directory in nature and not mandatory. Notably, this plea, too, was never
raised by the objectors before the Trial Court. In the opinion of this Court,
having failed to agitate this procedural grievance at the initial stage, the plea
cannot be permitted to be raised for the first time at the appellate stage.
Consequently, both the technical objections raised as above are rejected.
20.
Considering all the above, I find no infirmity or illegality in the
impugned order and the present appeal is accordingly dismissed.
21.
The present appeal, along with pending application(s), is disposed of
in the above terms.
(MANOJ KUMAR OHRI)
JUDGE
MAY 14, 2026
nb
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:04:09
FAO 137/2008
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review