Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT I N D O R E
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK RUSIA
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ANIL VERMA
CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1450 of 2013
BETWEEN:BANTU KUMAR S/O RADHESHYAM TAILOR,
AGED 32 YEARS, OCCUPATION LABOURER,
R/O NEAR OLD POLICE STATION SINGOLI,
P.S.
SINGOLI,
DISTRICT
NEEMUCH
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(BY SHRI A.K. SARASWAT - ADVOCATE)
AND
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH
THROUGH POLICE STATION –SINGOLI,
DISTRICT NEEMUCH (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENT
(BY SMT. VARSHA THAKUR - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE)
Reserved on
:
11/01/2024
Pronounced on
:
18/01/2024
This appeal having been heard and reserved for orders, coming on
for pronouncement this day, the JUSTICE ANIL VERMA pronounced
the following:
JUDGMENT
This appeal has been preferred on behalf of appellant under
Section 374 of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (in short 'Cr.P.C.')
against the impugned judgment dated 24.8.2013 passed by Sessions
Judge Neemuch District Neemuch (M.P.) in Sessions Trial No. 45/2012,
whereby the appellant has been convicted for the offence under Sections
302 and 201 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (in short 'IPC') and has been
sentenced to undergo Life Imprisonment and five years RI with fine of
Rs. 10,000/- and 5,000/- with usual default stipulation.
2. The facts of the case in brief are that appellant runs a tailoring
shop in a rented house in the name of Ashoka Tailors. Deceased was his
cousin. Anuradha is sister of deceased. The appellant used to do black
magic and appellant after threatening Anuradha collected some her nude
photographs from his mobile and started lackmailing her. Anuradha
narrated the whole incident to her brother deceased Ajay Kumar. On
22.1.2012, deceased Ajay went to Kota for some work and on 23.1.2012
one message came from his mobile to her cousin sister Rajni and sister
Anuradha that he is going to Indore. Thereafter during investigation, it
has been gathered that present appellant murdered him by strangulating
his neck with the help of a rope and hide his dead-body inside the
counter of his shop.The appellant himself informed SHO Singoli that he
has murdered deceased and thereafter police recovered dead body of
deceased from the counter. Accordingly FIR (Ex.P-64) has been
registered.
3. The prosecution story in further is that police prepared
Panchanama on the spot and opened lock of shutter by key which was
given by appellant and recovered dead body of deceased which was kept
inside the concrete counter of shop. The police also recovered obscene
photographs of Anuradha, mobile phone, some ash, key, some book of
black-magic from possession of appellant. He was arrested, dead body of
deceased was sent to postmortem which was conducted by Dr. Anand
Chandelwar (PW-7) and he opined that death of deceased was homicidal
in nature by strangulation. Seized articles were sent for its chemical
examination.
4.
After completion of investigation, charge sheet was filed before
the JMFC Jawad who has committed the case to the Court of Sessions.
Thereafter, trial Court on the basis of the allegations made in the charge
sheet framed charge under Section 302,201 of IPC against the present
appellant. Appellant abjured his guilt and pleaded complete innocence.
In order to bring home the charges, the prosecution has examined as
many as 21 witnesses but defence did not examine any witness. The
trial Court after appreciating the evidence available on record, convicted
and sentenced the appellant as mentioned herein above. Hence, the
appellant has preferred this jail appeal.
5.
Learned counsel for the appellant contended that the judgment of
the trial Court is contrary to law and facts on record. It is neither legal
nor proper nor correct. The key of shop was not recovered from
possession of appellant. Independent witness has not supported the case
of prosecution. There was no smell or any blood found by neighbours in
the said shop. Some unknown person killed deceased Ajay and appellant
has been falsely implicated in this case. There is material contradiction
and omission in statement of prosecution witnesses Manoj (PW-1),
Anuradha (PW-2),Om Prakash (PW-3) and Pankaj Kumar (PW-11).
Learned trial court has erred in appreciating the evidence available on
record. Hence, he prays that the appeal be allowed and the impugned
judgment of conviction and sentence passed by the trial Court be set
aside and appellant be acquitted from all the charges.
6.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent / State opposes the
prayer by supporting the impugned judgment passed by the trial Court
and prays for dismissal of this appeal by submitting that trial Court after
appreciating the entire evidence available on record in detail rightly held
that the appellant is guilty for the offence under Sections 302 and 201 of
IPC. Hence, no interference in the impugned judgment is warranted,
therefore, present appeal deserves to be dismissed.
7.
We have heard learned counsel for both the parties at length and
perused the entire record of the trial Court with due care.
8.
At this stage, it is not disputed that deceased died a homicidal
death by strangulation. We may therefore, make a passing reference to
the evidence of Dr. Anand Chandelwar (PW-7) who performed the
postmortem of deceased and his autopsy report is Ex.P-41. A perusal of
the postmortem report reveals that a three folded rope was found on the
neck of deceased and ligature mark was also found on his neck and he
has died homicidal death due to strangulation. In absence of any serious
challenge to autopsy report, we have no option but to accept the report
and oral evidence of Dr. Anand Chandelwar (PW-7) that the death of
deceased was homicidal in nature and there is no eye witness of the
incident and case of prosecution is based on circumstantial evidence.
9.
Anuradha (PW-3) who is the key witness of incident categorically
stated in her statement that when she lived for a period of two months at
Singoli, at that time appellant was doing black magic and scared her that
he will make her father ill and told that ‘if you will not ready to marry
with me I will kill your family members’. Thereafter appellant clicked
some obscene photographs from his mobile and started blackmailing her.
Appellant also shown print of her photographs then she disclosed the
whole incident to his brother deceased Ajay and Ajay told her that he
will make understand appellant. Anuradha further deposed that his
mother informed her that appellant Bantu called Ajay at Singoli and
murdered him by strangulating his neck by a rope and hide his deadbody in the counter of his shop. Anuradha Also proved her obscene
photographs (Ex.P-19 to P-27).
Manoj (PW-1) who is also cousin of Anuradha categorically stated
that his cousin appellant Bantu has murdered Ajay and kept his dead
body inside the counter of his shop by pouring sand and cement upon his
dead body and before him accused opened the shop before police and it
has been gathered that dead body was found inside the counter of the
shop and he identified that dead body belongs to deceased Ajay. Manoj
also corroborated that appellant used to blackmail his cousin Anuradha
and deceased Ajay by saying that he get some obscene photographs of
Anuradha and by that he will defame her.
Om Prakash (PW-3) who happens to be the father of deceased
stated that his son deceased Ajay left home by stating that he is going to
Kota but he never come back and police recovered dead-body of
deceased Ajay from the counter of the shop of appellant. Rajnibala
(PW-10) also corroborated the statement of witness Manoj.
Sandeep (PW-4) also disposed that appellant came on his
photography shop for taking print of the some picture which was taken
by him on his mobile phone but after seeing the photographs he refused
to take printout but appellant threatened him that he will put something
in his shop and falsely implicate him, therefore, due to fear of appellant,
he printed out the photographs (Ex.P-22 to P-27).
Although learned counsel for appellant contended that there is
material contradiction and omission in statements of Manoj (PW-1),
Anuradha (PW-2), Omprakash (PW-3) and Sandeep (PW-4) but from
perusal of the court statements of aforesaid witnesses in comparison to
their earlier police statements, it appears that there is no material
contradiction and omission in their police statement.
Inspector P.L. Kanoje (PW-20) deposed that on 30.1.2012
appellant Bantu informed him that he has murdered his cousin Ajay and
kept his body inside the show-case of his shop. Acted upon said
information first of all he lodged the FIR (Ex.P-64) and went to the shop
and in presence of panch witnesses he has prepared Panchnama (Ex.P30) and before FSL unit and Tehsildar Singoli he has opened the lock of
appellant’s shop by key which was given by appellant and recovered
dead body of deceased Ajay from a concrete show-case which was
covered with sand and cement. Dead body was identified by Om
Prakash and Kailash. He has recorded the discovery statement of
accused (Ex.P-34, P-35, P-36, P-55 and P-63) and recovered some
obscene photographs of Anuradha, certain books relating to black-magic,
Nokia mobile phone some of cloths related to appellant and key-chain.
Statement of Inspector P.L. Kanoje is well supported by statement of Om
Prakash (PW-3), Shiv Singh (PW-6), Rajkumar (PW-8), Avnish
Shrivastava (PW-9), Pankaj (PW-11), Vimal (PW-12), Shiv Prakash
(PW-13), Krishna Kumar singh (PW-14) and
Balkrishna Dhakad
(PW-15).
The Hon’ble Apex court in catena of judgments considered that
minor discrepancies on the trivial matters not touching the core of the
case is never considered to be fatal. Testimony of PW-1 to PW-4 has
been relied upon and despite being subjected to be elaborated crossexamination, nothing could be elucidated as to discard their version.
Their testimony cannot be doubted and it is not possible to hold that they
are the plant witnesses. Therefore, we do not find any illegality or
irregularity in assessing the statement of aforesaid witnesses.
After analyzing the evidence it is found that there is nothing on
record which makes the statements of Manoj (PW-1), Anuradha (PW-2),
Om Prakash (PW-3) and Sandeep (PW-4) doubtful. The appellant
himself informed police regarding the dead-body of deceased. Statement
of Investigating officer is well supported by independent witness as well
as documentary evidence available on record.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, we find that there is sufficient
evidence available on record and the circumstances are linked properly
and the guilt of the appellant has been duly established beyond
reasonable doubt. Only appellant is guilty of committing murder of
deceased. Therefore, we are not inclined to accept the contention of
learned counsel for appellant. We find that the learned trial court has
rightly convicted and sentenced the appellant for offence under sections
302 and 201 of IPC.
Hence by this judgment, we hereby extend the stamp of approval to
the judgment of conviction and sentence passed by the trial court.
Resultantly, this appeal founds to be devoid of merit and
substance, is hereby dismissed.
Registry is directed to send a copy of this judgment immediately to
the trial court alongwith the record of the trial court for necessary
compliance.
(VIVEK RUSIA)
J U D G E
BDJ
BHUNESH
WAR DATT
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
BENCH INDORE, ou=HIGH COURT OF MADHYA
PRADESH BENCH INDORE,
2.5.4.20=3fb5bcda9fd75d95d6c7cdcbd092ee5a74
a94a5534aed3a66d9385cfcfc201e0,
postalCode=452001, st=Madhya Pradesh,
serialNumber=89FD75A8D0C99E05779A327974E
46BC85102826CE0604B211E4C91102B4D1269,
cn=BHUNESHWAR DATT
Date: 2024.01.19 16:58:26 -08'00'
(ANIL VERMA)
J U D G E
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review