Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[33011
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE TWENW FOURTH DAY OF APRIL
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRl JUSTICE PULLA KARTHIK
WRIT PETITION NO: 279520F 2025
Between:
Banoth Sunil Nayak, S/o (Late) B.Chandmal, aged 41 years, Occ ;unemployee,
FUo Bhojya Thanda, Garla Mandal, Mahabubabad District.
.....PETITlONER
AND
. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Revenue
Departamemt, Dr.BR Ambedkar Secretariat, Hyderabad.
2. The District Collector, Mahabubabad District. Mahabubabad.
3. The District Registrar, Registration Department, Mahabubabad,
Mahabubabad District.
4. The Sub-Registrar, Mahabubabad, Mahabubabad District.
5. The Tahsildar and Joinl Sub Registrar, Garla Mandal, Mahabubabad District.
6. Tejavath Devamma, D/o Topa and W/o Banoth Chandmal, aged 63 years,
REtd. Govt. Servant, Fi/o H.No.15-7-372, Rotary Nagar, Khanapur Haveli,
Khammam Urban, Khammam District.
.....RESPONDENTS
Petition Under Article 226 ot lhe Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue WRIT OF MANDAMUS or any other appropriate writ, order or direction to
official Respondents in not refunding Stamp duty received by the Respondent No.3
and 4 dated O4lO7l2O'19 is illegal, arbitrary, unjust, biased and against Article 14 and
21 of Constitution of lndia and also against the violative of principle of natural justice
and consequently direct the Respondent No.3 and 4 to refund the Stamp duty
amount of Rs.76,020lalong with interest if applicable to the Petitioner herein in the
interest of justice.
l.A.NO:l OF 2025
Petition Under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
DIRECT the Official Respondents No.3 to 4 to refund the Stamp duty paid by the
Petitioner dated 04.07.2019 with immediate effect to the Petitioner SB NC
No.339830151511., State Bank of lndia, IFSC . SB1N0012906, Rotary Nagar Colony
branch, Khammam in the interest of justice pending disposal of the above writ
petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner : SRl. JOGRAM TEJAVAT
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.l to 5 : AGP FOR STAMPS & REGISTRATION
Counsel for the Respondent No.6 : ..
The Court made the following ORDER
.l
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE PULLA I(AR'THIK
WRIT PBTITION
0.27952 0F 2025
24th APRTL, 20/26.
Between:
Banoth Sunil Nayak
...Petitioner
AND
The State of Telangana,
Rep. by its Principal Secretary,
Revenue Department,
Dr. BR Ambedkar Secretariat, Hyderabad
and (5) others
... Respondents
ORDER:
This Writ Petition is filed seeking the following relief:
"... direction to oflicial Respondents in not refunding
Stamp Duty received by the Respondent No.3 & 4 dated
04.O7.2O 19 is illegal, arbitrary, unjust, biased and against
Article 14 and 2L of Constitution of India and also against
the violative of principle of natural justice and consequently
direct the Respondent No.3 & 4 to refund the Stamp duty
amount of Rs.76,02O/- along with interest if applicable to
the Petitioner herein in the interest ofjustice ...."
2l
Heard Sri Jogram Tejavath, learned counsel for the
petitioner, and learned Government Pleader for Stamps &
Registration, appearing for respondents I to 5.
3)
Leerrned counsel for the petitioner submits that petitioner's
entire village comes under Scheduled Area (Agency Area) covered
under 1170 Act and in respect of such Agency Scheduled Area, a
procedure is laid down under the Agency Rules 1924 as well as
Scheduk:d Area Act, 1959. Further, I l70 Act mandatorily
prescribt:s that whoever purchases the land in schedule area
beneficia.ry must be a scheduled tribe only or transaction must be
between Tribal to Tribal only or from bonalide non-tribal to tribal
beneficiztry and all other transactions amount to void in the
schedult:d area. In case of the petitioner, vendor and vendee both
belong ,:o scheduled tribe. Further, as per law, whenever the
registral ion papers are presented before the Sub-Registrar
concerned, Lhe officer will receive the papers along with stamp duty
and in this case, the Stamp Duty paid by the petitioner herein
towards registration charges is Rs.76,O20/- dated 03.O7.20L9.
After presentation of the document for registration, at the time of
receipt of such paper, the Sub-Registrar is supposed to submit
Form-K under Agency Rules, 1924 to the District Collector
concerrred and District Collector, after receipt of Form-K, shall
enquire the bonafides of transaction i.e. vendor and vendee and
about r:he land background. After due verification, the District
Collect<>r having satisfied with regard to bonafides of the vendor
and vendee, as per mandatory provision of Agency Rules, shall
/
/
e--
issue Form-L to the concerned Sub-Registrar permitting to register
the document, as per Agency Law.
3.1) Learned counsel further submits that as per the above
mandatory law, Form-K shall be submitted by the sub-Registrar to
the District collector and within a period of 6o days from the date
of receipt of Form-K from the Sub-Registrar concerned, the District
Collector shall either permit or reject registration, as per law. But,
in the present case, the District Collector neither responded nor
given any reply to the concerned Sub-Registrar about authorization
under Form-L and date of submission of Form-K by the SubRegistrar, Mahabubabd, is 04.O7.2O19, but, till date, there is no
response from the District Collector to the Sub-Registrar,
Mahabubabad. The onus of getting the Form-L from the District
collector rests on the sub-Registrar. Despite the same, the SubRegistrar has issued the notice dated 14.08.2025 to the petitioner
seeking explanation about the delay in getting the Form-L from the
District collector. on receipt of such notice, the petitioner
submitted his explanation .on 30.08.2025 seeking refund of
Rs.76,0201 - paid by him on 03.07.2019. Further, in an earlier
occasion, a similar letter dated 04.1 1 .2023 was addressed to the
District Collector, Mahabubabad, and Project Oflicer, ITDA,
Eturnagaram, and the copy of the same was marked to the
petitioner, for which also, the petitioner had submitted an
I
I
i
application on 22.11.2023 seeking refund of the amount. However,
there is rro response from the respondents. After introduction of
Dharani PorLal, the registration was entrusted to Tahsildar. As
such, the petitioner got registered the land by paying separate fee
through the Tahsildar vide application No.2OOOO68224 dated
26.11.2O2O. Therefore, the authorities are required to refund the
amount of Rs.76,O2Ol- paid by the petitioner on 03.07.2019.
Thereforr:, the learned counsel prays this Court to issue suitable
directions to the respondent authorities for refund of the amount
to the petitioner.
4)
Per contra, the learned Government Pleader submits that a
sale dee,d document was executed on O3.O7.2O19 by Tejavath
Devamrrra D/o.Thopa (W/o.Banoth Chandmal) in favour of Banoth
Sunil Neryak i.e. the petitioner herein in respect of agricultural dry
land a<lmeasuring Acs.3.07 guntas in survey No.156l lD I I
(1561|E',ElIl of Garla Revenue Village, duly paying the deficit
stamp duty of Rs.5O,5O0/-, transfer duty of Rs.19,050/registralion fee of Rs.6,350l-, user charges of Rs.l2Ol- totalling
Rs.76,O2O/- through e-challan dated O3.O7.2019 and the same
was admitted and kept pending vide No.P37/2O19 for want of
Form-L as the property belongs to Scheduled Area covered under
llTO Act. Subsequently, the Sub-Registrar, Mahabubabad, has
addressied letter No.130/2019 dated ll.O7.ZOL} to the District
/
,
.)
Collector, Mahabubabad, for issuance of Form-L. Further, as per
the instructions of the higher authorities as regards disposal of
pending documents, the respondent Office has addressed the
concerned authorities for issuance of Form-L vide letter dated
04.1 1 .2023 and a copy of the same was .communicated to the
petitioner. However, the petitioner replied to the same on
22.1L.2023 stating that he already got registered the tand in the
local Mandal Revenue Office and requested for refund of payment,
but there is no such procedure for refund of duties as the petition
is pending in anticipation of receipt of Form-L from the authorities.
Hence, no reply is given to the petitioner.
4.1) Learned Government Pleader further submits that inspite of
addressing for several times, Form-L was not received and as such
the impugned notice has been issued to the petitioner to show
cause as to why the document should not be refused flor
registration, for which, the petitioner has submitted a letter on
30.08.2025 stating that he has already got registered the land in
his favour through the Mandal Revenue Officer and sought for
refund of the amount. But, since no decision is taken either to
register or refuse the document, no reply is issued to the petitioner.
However, finally the registration was refused vide refusal
No.2a 12025 dated 18. I 1 .2025 and the refusal has been
communicated to the executant as well as the petitioner. But, the
:.,,{
petitioner has not chosen to lile any appeal against the refusal
order. According to the learned Government Pleader, once the
documen: is executed and presented before the Sub-Registrar and
admitted flor execution, the very purpose is served irrespective of
registrati(fn or refusal of such document as the stamps are already
utilized. Therefore, the allowance under Section 49 (d) (2) of the
Indian Stamp Act, 1899, is not applicable in the case of the
petitioner as the refusal is not due to spoiled stamps and there is
no provis;ion in the Stamp Act, 1899, for refund of stamp duty paid
in respe<:t of the refused document and thus prays to dismiss the
Writ Pet:ition. Reliance has been placed on the order dated
O4.lO.2Cr24 passed by this Court in W.P. No.21723 of 2023.
5)
In reply, the learned counsel for the petitioner submits that
the Government has issued instructions in G.O.Ms.No.222, dated
L9.O2.2OOS directing to
refund the stamp duty and other
registra':ion fee after deducting 1O%o as per terms and conditions of
refund of Stamp Duty as per Section 2 (91 of the Indian Stamp Act,
1899, through the Sub-Registrar under whose jurisdiction
designated Bank branch is situated duly mentioning the reasons
seeking the refund along with proof of identity, challan in original
and re,:eipt in original issued by the designated Bank branch
enclosireg sale deed executed as evidentiary material and refund
shall b,: accompanied by the certificate. Therefore, in the present
J
)
case, the petitioner is eligible for refund of the amount. Reliance is
placed on the order dated L2.o5.2023 passed in w.p. No.19329 of
2Ol9 by the High Court of the Andhra Pradesh.
6)
This Court has taken note of the submissions made by
respect counsel and perused the material on record.
7)
As can be seen from the record, admittedly, the petitioner
has presented the document on 03.o7.2019 and paid registration
charges of Rs.76,o2ol- for registration of the land admeasuring
Acs.3.07 guntas in survey No. 156 | lD I I (156 L lEEl \ of Garla
Revenue Village and the document was admitted and kept pending
vide document No.P.37/2019 for want of Form-L as the property
belongs to Scheduled Area covered under Act | /70. Subsequently,
respondent No.4 has addressed a letter to respondent No.2 for
issuance of Form-L vide letter No.r3ol2ot9 dated lt.oT.2oi9 and
233 /2023 dared 04. 1 1 .2023 and rhe said letter was also
communicated to the petitioner, for which, the petitioner has
submitted an application on 22.1t.2O23 stating that as per new
Revenue Act, he got registered the property in the local Mandal
Revenue oflice by paying required registration fee and thereby
requested to refund Lhe amount paid on 03.07.2019. Thereafter,
respondent No.4 has again issued notice dated L4.o8.2o25 to the
petitioner calling explanation for non-submission of Form-L since
I
',: ..:.H
six yeant, for which also the petitioner has submitted his
explanation narrating the same facts as stated in his earlier
application dated 22.1I.2023. Since no action is taken by the
respondents, the petitioner has filed present writ petition seeking
to direct the respondents to refund the amount to the petitioner.
8)
As can be seen from the record, during the pendency of the
Writ Petition, the respondents have passed the refusal order dated
18.11 .2025 rejecting the claim of the petitioner for refund, but the
petitioner has not taken any steps to challenge the same either by
filing an appeal or separate writ petition or filing an application in
the prest:nt writ petition seeking amendment of the prayer.
9)
To adjudicate the /is in this writ petition, this Court deems it
necessary to reler relevant portion of the order dated 04.1O.2024
passed try the Coordinate Bench of this Courr in W.P. No.21723of
2023, wrich reads as under:
"1{}. In the case on hand, the petitioner did not challenge the refusal order in
which it was reasoned that the petitioner has not complied with the provisions
of the Registration Act, 1908 and thereafter, the petitioner did not choose to
prefer any appeal thereon. That apart, the petitioner himself has chosen to
with<lraw the proposal of registration and has submitted a representation for
returning of the stamp duty etc. Admittedly there is no dispute on the execution
of th,: document and utilisation of the stamp duty.
19. Having regard to thc facts and circumstances o[ the case and the
subrrissions made by the learned counsel on either side, this court is of the
considered opinion that the impugned order bearing proceedings
No.Refunds/8087/2021 , dated 26.10.2022 passed by rhe 3rd respondent,
/?-
r>)
District Registrar, do not suffer from any legal inlirmity and as such, there is no
reason to interfere with the impugned order dated 26.1O.2022."
i0) In the instant case also, the document presen
by the
petitioner on 03.07.2019 before respondent No.4 was admitted for
registration, which goes to show that there is no dispute on the
execution of the document and utilisation of
'the stamp duty.
Further, except responding to the notices issued by the authorities,
the petitioner has not taken any independent steps to seek refund
after he got the land registered in his favour through Dharani
Portal. That apart, as statr:d supra, the petitioner has failed to
challenge the refusal order dated 18. t I .2025.
11) For the afore-mentioned reasons, the Court linds that the
Writ Petition is devoid of merits and therefore liable to be
dismissed
l2l
Accordingly, the Writ Petition is dismissed.
Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending shall stand closed.
There shall be
to costs
SD/- A.H.S. GOWRI
ASSISTANT
/TRUE COPYII
SECTION OFFICER
To
\
1. Two CCs to GP FOR, STAMPS &
State of Telangana at Hyderabad. [OUTI
2. One CC to SRI JOGRAM TEJAVAT, Advocate
3. Two CD Copies
SA
?e(
High Court for the
,, .D
C.C. TODAY
HIGH COIJRT
DATED: 2,410412026
t
lr
inL
-i'i
{.)
(
ORDER
*
AP R
2tlz$
*-
WP.No.27l952 of 2025
DISMISSING THE W.P
WITHOUT COSTS
,ilg\
q {\-,
o
.t
. ,.:
;ii*i[fr.
.#*F-+'-..ir:
.ffiRli":
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review