The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
14. Consequently, the instant writ petition is allowed. The impugned letter dated 14.10.2025( Annexure P-3) issued by respondent no.3 whereby medical claim for reimbursement has been rejected in reference with instruction dated 14.12.2007(Annexure P-4) is hereby quashed. The respondents are directed to fully release the medical claim of the petitioner amounting to Rs.1,30,073/- along with interest at 6% per annum from the date it became due till its actual realisation within a period of two months from the date of receipt of certified copy of this order. In the event the amount is not released within the aforesaid period, the same shall carry interest at 9% per annum.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CWP-38433-2025 (O&M)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
CWP-38433-2025 (O&M)
BALWANT SINGH
.....APPELLANTS
VERSUS
STATE OF HARYANA & ORS.
....RESPONDENTS
1. The date when the judgment is reserved
26.05.2026
2. The date when the judgment is pronounced
15.07.2026
3. The date when the judgment is uploaded
15.07.2026
4. Whether only operative part of the judgment is Full
pronounced or whether the full judgment is
pronounced
5. The delay, if any of the pronouncement of full Not applicable
judgment and reason thereof.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANDEEP MOUDGIL.
Present:
Mr. Sandeep Lather, Advocate
for the petitioner.
Ms. Deepak Balyan, Addl.A.G,Haryana
****
ANURADHA
2026.07.15 03:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-38433-2025 (O&M)
SANDEEP MOUDGIL, J.
The jurisdiction of this court has been invoked under Article
226/227 of the Constitution of India for issuance of writ in the nature of
certiorari for quashing the impugned letter dated 14.10.2025( Annexure P-3)
issued by respondent no.3 whereby medical claim for reimbursement has been
rejected in reference with instruction dated 14.12.2007(Annexure P-4) and
orally said Channo Devi(Mother/dependant) is not dependant upon the
petitioner as she is getting old age pension which is arbitrary in nature and
further issue a writ in the nature of mandamus directing the respondents to
reimburse amount of Rs.1,30,073/- as per bill dated 17.07.2024(Annexure P-2).
2.
Factual matrix of the case unfolds that the petitioner was appointed
as conductor in Haryana State Transport department and now posted as Sub
inspector in the office of Respondent no.3 and four family members are
dependant on the petitioner. The respondents have adopted Punjab Services
Medical Attendance Rules,1940 and have also framed policy dated 30.11.1993
whereby some of the hospitals have been approved where dependants can avail
treatment. The Health Services department Haryana has issued letter dated
27.05.2023 to all heads of all the departments and other concerned department
whereby empanelment has been approved to private hospitals for providing
medical facilities to Haryana govt employees, pensioners and their dependents.
3.
Learned Counsel for the petitioner submits that mother of the
petitioner namely Channo Devi aged about 85 years had undergone heart
surgery at max Super Speciality Hospital, Near Civil hospital, Phase VI, Mohali
on 13.07.2024 where stent was implanted and she was discharged on
17.07.2024 and the total expenditure came out to be Rs.1,30,073/-. It is
ANURADHA
2026.07.15 03:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-38433-2025 (O&M)
contended that the mother/Channo Devi is fully dependent on the petitioner and
to reimburse the medical bill, petitioner submitted an essential certificate and
the application dated 29.07.2024 vide diary no.3308 which was rejected by the
Health department in reference to instruction dated 14.12.2007 vide letter dated
14.10.2025. It is further contended that the rejection is purely arbitrary only on
the basis of the fact that mother/Channo devi is getting old age pension which is
only Rs.3000/- pe month.
4.
Per contra, State counsel at the very outset contends that the instant
petition deserves to be dismissed as the mother of the petitioner is not
dependent on the petitioner since as per the family ID, the annual income of the
petitioner’s father has been shown to be Rs.75000/- to 1,00000/- and the annual
income of the mother/Channo devi is shown as Rs.25000/- to 50,000/- therefore
the parents of the petitioner cannot be said to be dependent on the petitioner
completely.
5.
Heard counsel for the parties at length.
6.
Having perused the record at hand, this court finds merit in the
instant writ petition. It is admitted position that the claim of the petitioner has
not been rejected on the ground that the treatment was unnecessary, fabricated
or unsupported by record. The treatment undertaken by the petitioner’s mother,
hospitalisation and the expenditure incurred thereupon stand duly substantiated
from the official medical record (Annexure P-2). Indeed, the rejection rests
solely upon a technical interpretation of the instructions dated 14.12.2007 and
by treating the annual income of the parents of the petitioner as sufficient
enough to bear the medical expense in question.
ANURADHA
2026.07.15 03:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-38433-2025 (O&M)
7.
Such an approach, in the considered opinion of the court is legallu
unsustainable and contrary to the settled principles governing welfare
legislation. The Punjab Medical Attendance Rules, 1940 include wholly
dependent parents within the ambit of “family”. The relevant Rule is reproduced
hereinbelow:=
“2. Family members of employees who are also earning members
are not entitled to reimbursement of medical charges unless they
are also the State Govt. Employees. A Govt. Employee can, thus
claim reimbursement of medical charges in respect of those
members of family who are wholly dependent upon him. (Punjab
Govt. Letter No. 1491HB1/69 dated 29.12.1969)”
8.
Significantly, the statutory rules themselves do not prescribe any
rigid monetary ceiling for determining dependency. The embargo sought to be
imposed by the respondents emanates only from an executive instructions dated
14.12.2007. It is trite that executive instructions cannot override, dilute or
curtail the substantive benefit flowing from statutory rules. Once the Rules
recognise wholly dependent parents as members of the family, the concept of
dependency cannot be constricted through administrative fiat in a manner that
defeats the very object of reimbursement.
9.
An identical controversy came up for consideration before this
court in Manoj Kumar Vs State of Haryana and others, CWP-4892-2016,
wherein the claim for the reimbursement had declined on the ground that father
of the employee was allegedly earning more than Rs.3500/- per month.
10.
While interpreting the expression ‘wholly dependent’ , this court
feels apposite to mention the judgement of the Apex Court passed in State of
ANURADHA
2026.07.15 03:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-38433-2025 (O&M)
Madhya Pradesh Vs M.P.Ojha, Civil Appeal No.1368 of 1990, wherein it is has
been held that dependency is not confined merely to financial dependence but
includes physical dependence as well. It was further held that executive
instructions cannot modify statutory rules and that the question of dependency
has to be examined in the factual backdrop of each individual case.
11.
The observations made by the Apex Court in M.P. Ojha alongwith
(supra) alongwith Punjab Medical Attendance Rules, 1940 merit particular
consideration. The Apex Court held that the expression “wholly dependent” is
required to receive a purposive and flexible interpretation keeping in view the
object sought to be achieved by the Rules so framed. It was specifically
observed that for aged and ailing parents, dependence may not be merely
financial but physical as well. Receipt of a meagre pension or social welfare
allowance by an elderly parent cannot , by itself, disentitle him from being
treated as dependent upon his son or daughter, especially where serious illness
and advancing age render such parent incapable of independently sustaining
medical treatment. Relevant extract is reproduced herein below:12. The expression "wholly dependent" is not a term of art.
It has to be given its due meaning with reference to the Rules in
which it appears. We need not make any attempt to define the
expression "wholly dependent" to be applicable to all cases in all
circumstances. We also need not look into other provisions of law
where such expression is defined. That would likely to lead to
results which the relevant Rules would not have contem- plated.
The expression "wholly dependent" has to be understood in the
context in which it is used keeping in view the object of the
particular Rules where it is contained. We cannot curtail the
meaning of "wholly de- pendent" by reading into this the definition
as given in SR 8 which has been reproduced above. Further, the
ANURADHA
2026.07.15 03:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-38433-2025 (O&M)
expression "wholly dependent" as appearing in the definition of
family as given in Medical Rules cannot be confined to mere
financial dependence. Ordinarily dependence means fĩn- ancial
dependence but for a member of family it would mean other support, may be physical, as well. To be "wholly dependent" would
therefore include both financial and physical dependence. If
support required is physical “and a member of the family is
otherwise financially sound he may not necessarily be wholly
dependent. Here the father was 70 years of age and was sick and it
could not be said that he was not wholly depend- ent on his son.
Son has to look after him in his old age. Even otherwise by getting
a pension of Rs. 414 per month which by any standard is a paltry
amount it could not be said that the father was not "wholly
dependent" on his son. That the father had a separate capacity of
being a retired Gov- ernment servant is immaterial if his case falls
within the Medical Rules being a member of the family of his son
and wholly dependent on him. A flexible approach has to be
adopted in interpreting and applying the Rules in a case like the
present one. There is no dispute that the son took his father to
Bombay for treatment for his serious ailment after getting due
permission from the competent authority. It was submitted before
us that the father being a retired Government servant could himself
get sanc- tion for treatment outside the State as a special case from
the competent authority. It is not necessary for us to look into this
aspect of the matter as we are satisfied that under the relevant
Medical Rules, the father was member of the family of his son and
was wholly dependent on him and thes 2nd respondent was thus
fully entitled to reimbursement for the expenses incurred on the
treatment of his father and other travelling expenses.”
12.
Reimbursement of medical expenses is not a bounty distributed at
the whim of the administration, rather it is a welfare measure intended to secure
ANURADHA
2026.07.15 03:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-38433-2025 (O&M)
humane condition of existence for government employees and their dependent
family members.
13.
The rejection of the claim of the petitioner solely on the basis of
income ceiling prescribed under executive instructions cannot be sustained,
particularly when the treatment and expenditure incurred by the petitioner stand
duly established form the record. The amount received by the father and the
mother as pension cannot be construed as sufficient independent income so as to
deny the benefit of medical reimbursement. The action of the respondents is
thus arbitrary, unreasonable and contrary to the settled principles of law.
14.
Consequently, the instant writ petition is allowed. The impugned
letter dated 14.10.2025( Annexure P-3) issued by respondent no.3 whereby
medical claim for reimbursement has been rejected in reference with instruction
dated 14.12.2007(Annexure P-4) is hereby quashed. The respondents are
directed to fully release the medical claim of the petitioner amounting to
Rs.1,30,073/- along with interest at 6% per annum from the date it became due
till its actual realisation within a period of two months from the date of receipt
of certified copy of this order. In the event the amount is not released within the
aforesaid period, the same shall carry interest at 9% per annum.
15.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall also stand
disposed of.
16.
Ordered accordingly.
(SANDEEP MOUDGIL)
JUDGE
15.07.2026
anuradha
Whether speaking/reasoned
Whether reportable
ANURADHA
2026.07.15 03:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
:
:
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review