Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
WP(Crl) No.1215/2024
2025:KER:27890
:1:
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE DR. JUSTICE KAUSER EDAPPAGATH
THURSDAY, THE 3RD DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 13TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(CRL.) NO. 1215 OF 2024
PETITIONER:
BALU
AGED 42 YEARS
S/O. MANIKYAN, THONDAYAR STREET., PANAYAKOTTAI,
MOORTHYAMBALAPURAM, P.O., TANJORE, LCT NO.17604,
CENTRAL PRISON, TRICHY TAMIL NADU, PIN - 620020
BY ADVS. SMRUTHI SASIDHARAN
V.P.BRIJESH
ASWATHY AMBY
RESPONDENTS:
STATE OF KERALA,
REPRESENTED BY THE ADDITIONAL CHIEF SECRETARY,HOME
(PRISONS) DEPARTMENT, ROOM NO.62G' A, IST FLOOR,
SOUTH BLOCK, 8503.THIRUVANANTHAPURAM,
KERALA,, PIN - 695001
THE STATE LEVEL ADVISORY BOARD (JAIL)
SICA CAMPUS, THE KERALA PRISONS HEADQUARTERS,
POOJAPPURA, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM,
KERALA,, PIN - 695012
THE CHAIRMAN/CHAIRPERSON
(NOT APPOINTED BY THE GOVT) THE STATE LEVEL
ADVISORY BOARD (JAIL), SICA CALNPUS, THE KERALA
PRISONS HEADQUARTERS, POOJAPPURA,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, KERALA,, PIN - 695001
BY ADVS. P.NARAYANAN, SENIOR PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
SHRI.SAJJU.S., SENIOR G.P.
THIS WRIT PETITION (CRIMINAL) HAVING COME UP FOR
ADMISSION ON 21.03.2025, THE COURT ON 3.04.2025 DELIVERED
THE FOLLOWING:
WP(Crl) No.1215/2024
2025:KER:27890
:2:
“C.R.”
JUDGMENT
The petitioner, a life convict, who has been serving more
than 22 years at Central Prison, Trichy, challenges Ext.P4 order
passed by respondent No.1, rejecting his claim for premature
release.
2. The petitioner was convicted and sentenced to life for
the offence under Section 302 of IPC by the III rd Additional
Sessions Court (Adhoc), Fast Track Court-I, Thrissur in SC
No.441/2002 for having murdered a lady named Suvarna by
drowning her in a pond and robbed her gold chain. The conviction
and sentence were confirmed by this Court in Crl. Appeal
No.418/2021 on 26/8/2021. He has completed 22 years and 5
months of actual term of imprisonment as of 13/12/2023.
3. The police authorities and the probation officer have
recommended the premature release of the petitioner. The Jail
Advisory Committee of the Viyyur Central Prison and Correctional
Home had on 10/7/2023 also recommended the premature
release of the petitioner. The Director General of Prisons and
Correctional Services forwarded the said recommendation to the
1st respondent for further action.
However, the State Level
Advisory
14/8/2024
Committee
held
on
rejected
the
WP(Crl) No.1215/2024
2025:KER:27890
:3:
recommendation. Thereafter the Government had also considered
the request of the petitioner for premature release.
The
Government, after examining the matter in detail, found that this
was not a fit case which required any intervention on the decision
taken by the State Level Advisory Committee and rejected the
claim of the petitioner for premature release as per Ext.P4 order.
The said order is under challenge in this writ petition.
4.
I have heard Smt. Smruthi Sasidharan, the learned
counsel for the petitioner and Sri. P. Narayanan, the learned
Senior Public Prosecutor.
5. The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that
the rejection of the claim of the petitioner for premature release is
against statutory provisions which govern the premature release
of a convict and the guidelines given by the Supreme Court. The
learned counsel further submitted that the State Level Advisory
Committee, as well as the Government, did not consider the
recommendations of the probation officer, police authorities and
Jail Advisory Committee for the release of the petitioner. Reliance
was placed on Joseph v. State of Kerala and others [2023 (4) KLJ
903]. On the other hand, the learned Public Prosecutor submitted
that the State Level Advisory Committee considered the matter in
detail and did not recommend the premature release of the
petitioner, considering the heinous nature of the crime. The
WP(Crl) No.1215/2024
2025:KER:27890
:4:
learned Senior Public Prosecutor submitted that even though the
State
Level
Advisory
Committee
did
not
recommend
the
premature release of the petitioner, the Government also
considered the request of the petitioner for premature release and
after examining the matter in detail, it was found that no
intervention was required on the decision taken by the State Level
Advisory Committee. It was also submitted that a convict does
not have an indefeasible right to get a remission of sentence, and
the grant of remission is solely at the executive’s discretion.
Reliance
was
placed
on
Rajan v. Home Secretary, Home
Department of Tamil Nadu and Others [(2019) 14 SCC 114] and
Bilkis Yakub Rasool v. Union of India and Others [(2024) 5 SCC
481].
6.
Ext.P1, the copy of the conviction certificate dated
13/12/2023, issued by the Superintendent of Prison, Central
Prison, Trichy would show that the petitioner had undergone 22
years and 5 months of actual imprisonment.
The Probation
Officer, in his report dated 31/3/2023 [Ext.R1(a)] submitted before
the Jail Advisory Committee, had recommended the premature
release of the petitioner. The Superintendent of Police, Thanjavur,
in his report dated 17/7/2018 [Ext.R1(c)], had expressed no
objection
to
release
the
petitioner.
The
conduct
and
recommendation certificate issued by the Superintendent of
WP(Crl) No.1215/2024
2025:KER:27890
:5:
Prisons, Central Prison, Trichy [Ext.R1(d)] would show that the
petitioner's conduct inside the prison was satisfactory. In the said
letter, recommendation was made for the premature release of
the petitioner. The first half-yearly Jail Advisory Committee
Meeting of the year 2023 held at Viyyur Central Prison and
Correctional Home on 10/7/2023 recommended the premature
release of 16 life convicts, including the petitioner. However, the
State Level Advisory Committee held on 14/8/2024 decided to
reject the premature release of the petitioner on the sole ground
that he was involved in the brutal murder of a poor lady.
7. Premature release of a convicted prisoner is based on
the concept of reformation, rehabilitation and reintegration of
prisoners back into society. There are three kinds of premature
release: constitutional, statutory and remissions in accordance
with jail manuals - Constitutional power under Articles 72 and 161
of the Constitution; statutory power of remission available to the
appropriate Government under Section 432 of Cr.P.C or under
laws framed by the State; power of commutation under Section
433 of Cr.P.C; remission earned under a statutory rule framed by
the appropriate Government or under the Jail Manual.
8. Article 72 of the Constitution of India empowers the
President of India to grant pardons, reprieves, respites, or
remissions of punishment or to suspend, remit or commute the
WP(Crl) No.1215/2024
2025:KER:27890
:6:
sentence of any person convicted of any offence in all cases, inter
alia, where the punishment is for an offence against any law
relating to a matter to which the executive power of the Union
extends. The President acts on the advice of the Home Minister.
His power is absolute and cannot be limited in scope by statutory
provisions. It may be limited, though by judicial review in case of
arbitrary decision making. The Governor of a State has similar
power under Article 161 of the Constitution relating to a matter to
which the executive power of the State extends.
Section 432 of
Cr.P.C empowers the appropriate Government to suspend or remit
the sentence of a prisoner. Broadly, this Section statutorily
empowers the appropriate Government to suspend the execution
of a sentence or to remit the whole or any part of the punishment
of a convict [sub-section (1)].
Sub-section (2) of Section 432
provides that the Government may seek the opinion of the Judge
who convicted the prisoner on whether the application for
remission must be accepted or rejected. Section 433 provides that
life imprisonment may be commuted to imprisonment for a term
not exceeding 14 years.
But Section 433 A provides that a
prisoner shall not be released before 14 years of undergoing
sentence in the case of two kinds of life convicts- those life
convicts who have been guilty of an offence punishable with death
and those convicts whose death sentences were commuted to life
WP(Crl) No.1215/2024
2025:KER:27890
:7:
imprisonment under Section 433. A convict serving a definite term
of imprisonment is entitled to earn a period of remission or even
be awarded a period of remission under a statutory rule framed by
the appropriate Government or under the Jail Manual based on
his/her good behaviour or such other stipulations prescribed
therein. This period is then offset against the term of punishment
given to him.
9. Since ‘Prisons’ is a state subject under Entry 4 of List II
of the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution, the laws governing
the process of premature release are framed by the States as
well. In Kerala, the Kerala Prisons and Correctional Services
(Management) Act, 2010 (for short, Kerala Prisons Act) was
enacted. Section 99 of the Kerala Prisons Act empowers the State
Government to make rules consistent with the Act. Accordingly,
the Kerala Prisons & Correctional Services (Management) Rules,
2014 (for short, Kerala Prisons Rules) was framed. Section 77 of
the Kerala Prisons Act deals with premature release. Section 77
provides that well–behaved, long-term convicted prisoners may be
prematurely released with the objective of their reformation and
rehabilitation, by the Government, either suo motu or on the
recommendations of the Jail Advisory Committee. Chapter 36 of
the Kerala Prisons Rules also deals with premature release. Rule
462 creates an Advisory Committee. Rules 462 to 469 detail the
WP(Crl) No.1215/2024
2025:KER:27890
:8:
procedure to be followed by the Advisory Committee while
considering premature release of convicts.
The said body,
referred to as ‘The Jail Advisory Committee’ is to recommend to
the State Government the release of prisoners prematurely. The
State Government is empowered under Rule 468 to admit or
reject the said recommendation. As per G.O.(P).No.17/2021 Home
dated
12/2/2021
Government
of
issued
Kerala
as
has
per
S.R.O.No.171/2021,
amended
Kerala
Prisons
the
and
Correctional Services (Management) Rules, 2014 by constituting a
State Level Advisory Committee to consider and review the
complaints/applications made against the recommendations of the
Jail Advisory Committee, constituted under Section 77(1) of the
Kerala Prisons Act and to submit recommendation to Government
to confirm or quash or reverse or modify the same.
10.
The factors that guide premature release are
manifold. The age of the accused at the time of the commission of
the offence, the period of imprisonment already undergone, and
the nature of reformation that has come upon the convict are all
significant
supervening
factors
that
should
be
taken
into
reckoning while considering cases for premature release. The
circumstances in which the crime was committed, the convict's
attitude in prison, and even his penchant for personality
development
as
reflected
by
his
character,
conduct
and
WP(Crl) No.1215/2024
2025:KER:27890
:9:
acquisition of educational qualifications can all be mitigating
factors
enabling
the
consideration
of
premature
release
favourably (Thressiamma Jose v. State of Kerala, 2023 (5) KHC
460). The Supreme Court in Laxman Naskar v. State of W.B and
Another [(2000) 7 SCC 626] laid down five important factors for
considering the case of premature release, which are as follows:
(i) Whether the offence affects the society at large.
(ii) The probability of the crime being repeated.
(iii) The potential of the convict to commit crimes in the future.
(iv) If any fruitful purpose is being served by keeping the
convict in prison and;
(v) The socio-economic conditions of the convict's family.
In State of Haryana and Others v. Jagdish [(2010) 4 SCC 216], the
Supreme Court outlined several aspects to be taken into account
for premature release. It was held as follows:
“At the time of considering the case of pre-mature
release of a life convict, the authorities may require to
consider his case mainly taking into consideration
whether the offence was an individual act of crime
without affecting the society at large; whether there was
any chance of future recurrence of committing a crime;
whether
the
convict
had
lost
his
potentiality
in
committing the crime; whether there was any fruitful
purpose of confining the convict any more; the socioeconomic condition of the convict's family and other
similar circumstances”.
11. Rule 465(2) of the Kerala Prisons Rules deals with the
WP(Crl) No.1215/2024
2025:KER:27890
:10:
factors to be taken into account for the premature release of the
convicts. The Rule says that while considering premature release,
the response and opinion of the victim have to be taken into
consideration. The Rule mandates that enquiry has to be
conducted with the relatives of the victim's family, neighbours and
the people’s representative of the Local Self Government.
It
further says that the reports of the police officer and probation
officer have to be obtained.
12. On 14/6/2022, the State Government issued an order
containing general guidelines on premature release, classifying
prisoners such as those who had committed certain offences who
could not be released prematurely, while others could only be
considered
after
years.
This
Government
Order
also
incorporated an executive instruction, which excluded those
involved in the murder of a woman, among other crimes, from the
grant of premature release.
13.
As stated already, the State Level Advisory
Committee, as well as the Government, rejected the petitioner's
request for premature release, for the reason that the petitioner
was convicted for the murder of a poor woman. It was specifically
stated so in Ext.P4 order. It appears that the State Level Advisory
Committee and the Government rejected the request of the
petitioner for premature release based on the provision in the
WP(Crl) No.1215/2024
2025:KER:27890
:11:
Government Order dated 14/6/2022 that persons convicted for the
murder of a woman are not eligible for premature release. The
said Government Order came up for consideration before the
Supreme Court in Joseph (supra). It was held that blanket
exclusion of certain offences from the scope of the grant of
remission, especially by way of an executive policy, is not only
arbitrary, but turns the ideals of reformation that run through our
criminal justice system, on its head. It was further held that
statutory discretion cannot be fettered by self-created rules or
policy.
14. Even though the decision of premature release of a
convict is the prerogative of the State Government, the exercise
of such a plenary power cannot be left to the whims and fancies of
the Government, but must be entwined with reason, after
considering the relevant parameters. A blanket stance that all
persons who have murdered a woman or a child shall not be
prematurely released de hors any other circumstances is not
conducive to a welfare State [ Thressiamma Jose (supra)]. The
State Level Advisory Committee and the Government, while
rejecting the petitioner's request for premature release and
passing Ext.P4 order, did not take into account Rule 465 (2) of the
Kerala Prisons Rules, the recommendation of the prison officials,
police authorities, probation officers, and the guidelines of the
WP(Crl) No.1215/2024
2025:KER:27890
:12:
Supreme Court mentioned above. In State of Haryana and Others
v. Mohinder Singh [(2000) 3 SCC 394], it was held that the power
of remission cannot be exercised arbitrarily. The decision to grant
remission has to be well-informed, reasonable, and fair to all
concerned. Therefore, the rejection of the petitioner's request for
premature release only on the ground that the petitioner was
convicted for the murder of a woman cannot be justified.
15. Premature release has been recognized as one of the
facets of the human rights of prisoners. The remission policy
manifests a process of reshaping a person who, under certain
circumstances, has indulged in criminal activity and is required to
be rehabilitated. It is based on the principles of reformation and
intended to bring the convict back to society as a useful member.
It was specifically mentioned in the probation report that the
convict could lead a normal life after release by doing agricultural
labour work in his own village. The murder was committed when
the petitioner was only 18 years of age, and he is now around 42
years. The police authorities, the probation officer and the
Superintendent of Prisons have recommended the premature
release of the petitioner. The Jail Advisory Committee has also
recommended the premature release of the petitioner. These
factors that have a bearing on the concept of reformation cannot
be ignored on the bare premise that persons who have committed
WP(Crl) No.1215/2024
2025:KER:27890
:13:
the murder of women will not be given remission of sentence. The
grant of premature release is the power coupled with duty
conferred on the appropriate Government in terms of Section 432
of Cr.P.C, and under the provisions of State Laws which is to be
exercised by it after taking into account all the relevant factors.
Considering the entire facts and circumstances of the case, I am
of the view that it is a fit case where the Government ought to
have considered the plea of the petitioner for premature release
favourably.
However, it is well settled that this Court cannot
direct the respondents to release the prisoner forthwith or to remit
the remaining sentence [See Rajan (supra) and Bilkis Yakub Rasool
(supra)].
16. For the reasons stated above, Ext.P4 order is not
sustainable, and accordingly, it is set aside.
In the counter
affidavit filed by the 1st respondent, it is stated that in the course
of routine consideration for recommending premature release
during the first half of the year 2024, the Director General of
Prisons
and
Correctional
Services,
has
forwarded
the
recommendation of the Jail Advisory Committee, which was
convened on 15/07/2024, by which four prisoners, including the
petitioner, were recommended for the grant of premature release
and the file pertaining to it is under process. Hence, the 1st
respondent is directed to consider the recommendation of the Jail
WP(Crl) No.1215/2024
2025:KER:27890
:14:
Advisory Committee relating to the premature release of the
petitioner in the light of the observations made in this judgment,
as expeditiously as possible, at any rate, within a period of three
months from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment,
The writ petition is disposed of as above.
Sd/DR. KAUSER EDAPPAGATH
JUDGE
Rp
WP(Crl) No.1215/2024
2025:KER:27890
:15:
APPENDIX OF WP(CRL.) 1215/2024
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit -P1
TRUE COPY OF THE
DATED 13/12/2023
CUSTODY
CERTIFICATE
Exhibit -P2
TRUE COPY OF THE WP(CRL) 412/2024 DATED
8/4/2024 OF THE HON'BLE COURT WITH EXTS
Exhibit- P3
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT IN WP(CRL) 412
/2024 DATED 11/6/2024 OF THE HON'BLE
COURT
Exhibit -P4
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
ORDER
G.O.(RT)
NO.2900/2024/HOME DATED 8/10/2024
Exhibit -P5
TRUE COPY OF THE REPORT
OFFICER DATED 11.10.2017
Exhibit P6
THE LETTER GIVEN BY THE KERALA PRISONS
AND
CORRECTIONAL
SERVICES
DATED
16/05/2024
Exhibit P7
THE
DEPARTMENT
OF
PRISONS
AND
CORRECTIONAL SERVICES TRICHY RANGE,ALONG
WITH HIS ENGLISH TRANSLATION IS PRODUCED
AND MARKED AS EXHIBIT P7 SERIES DATED
21/5/2024
Exhibit P8
A COPY OF THE APPLICATION SUBMITTED BY
THE PETITIONER’S MOTHER IS PRODUCED AND
MARKED AS THAT EXHIBIT P8 DATED 16/10/
2024.
OF
PROBATION
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT R1(a)
A COPY OF THE REPORT OF THE PROBATION
OFFICER,
DEPARTMENT
OF
PRISONS
AND
CORRECTIONAL SERVICES THANJAVOOR DATED
31-03-2023
EXHIBIT R1(b)
TRUE COPY OF THE PROFORMA DATED 08-082024 FORWARDED BY THE SUPERINTENDENT,
CENTRAL PRISON, VIYYUR
WP(Crl) No.1215/2024
2025:KER:27890
EXHIBIT R1(c)
:16:
TRUE COPY OF THE POLICE REPORT DATED 1707-2018 ISSUED BY THE SUPERINTENDENT OF
POLICE, THANJAVUR
EXHIBIT R1(d)
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
CONDUCT
AND
RECOMMENDATION CERTIFICATE DATED 18-072024 ISSUED BY THE SUPERINTENDENT OF
PRISONS, CENTRAL PRISON TRICHY
EXHIBIT R1(e)
A COPY OF THE INTERIM ORDER DATED 17-122024 IN W.A 1245-2024
EXHIBIT R1(f)
A COPY OF THE COMMUNICATION DATED 26-092024 FORWARDED BY THE DIRECTOR GENERAL
OF PRISON AND CORRECTIONAL SERVICES TO
ADDITIONAL CHIEF SECRETARY, HOME
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review