The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. It is a settled principle of law, as has been held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in para 27 of the case of T.T. Antony v. State of Kerala & Others (supra) that a second F.I.R. is maintainable for a counter-case only. Now coming to the facts of the case, as already discussed above, no new fact of occurrence or offence has been alleged in FIR of Madhuban P.S. case no. 03 of 2025; which has not been mentioned either in the FIR of Madhuban P.S. case no. 01 of 2025 or in the FIR of Madhuban P.S. case no. 02 of 2025. Thus, this Court is of the considered view that FIR of Madhuban P.S. case no. 03 of 2025 is a subsequent FIR in respect of the selfsame occurrence, for which earlier, Madhuban P.S. case no. 01 of 2025 or Madhuban P.S. case no. 02 of 2025 has been registered. Accordingly, the same is not sustainable in law, being hit by the provisions of Section 181 of BNSS, 2023. Therefore, this is a fit case where the entire criminal proceeding including the First Information Report in connection with Madhuban P.S. case no. 03 of 2025 be quashed and set aside against the petitioners.
13. Accordingly, the entire criminal proceeding including the First Information Report in connection with Madhuban P.S. case no. 03 of 2025 is quashed and set aside qua the petitioners.
14. In the result, this Criminal Miscellaneous Petition is allowed. (Anil Kumar Choudhary, J.) High Court of Jharkhand, Ranchi Dated, the 09th of January, 2026 Abhiraj /AFR Uploaded on 13/01/2026 Cr.M.P. No. 25 of 2026
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[( 2026:JHHC:602 ) ]
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
Cr.M.P. No. 25 of 2026
1. Balmicky Kumar @ Balmicky Yadav, aged about 29 years,
S/o-Dashrath Yadav @ Daso Yadav, R/o-Budora,
Maheshpur, P.O.-Maheshpur, P.S.-Madhuban, DistrictDhanbad.
2. Mukesh Kumar Yadav @ Mukesh Yadav, aged about 37
years, S/o-Rajendra Yadav, R/o Central Kenduadih,
Barora, Fhulwaritand, Ashakothi Khatal, P.O.-Nawagarh,
P.S.-Madhuban, District-Dhanbad.
3. Birendra Yadav @ Billu @ Billu Yadav, aged about 43 years,
S/o-Late Basudeo Yadav @ Basudev Yadav, R/o-VillageAshakothi Khatal, P.O.-Nawagarh, P.S.-Madhuban,
District-Dhanbad.
...... Petitioners
Versus
The State of Jharkhand
….. Opposite Party
For the Petitioner : Mr. Pratiush Lala, Adv.
For the State
: Mr. V.K. Vashistha, Spl.PP
PRESENT
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KUMAR CHOUDHARY
By the Court:-
Heard the parties.
2. This criminal miscellaneous petition has been filed invoking the
jurisdiction of this Court under Section 528 of BNSS, 2023 with the
prayer for quashing and setting aside the entire criminal
proceeding including the First Information Report in connection
with Madhuban P.S. case no. 03 of 2025 registered for the offences
punishable under Sections 191 (2), 191 (3), 190, 324 (5), 326 of the
BNS, 2023, pending in the court of learned JMFC, Dhanbad on the
ground that this is the second FIR in respect of same occurrence
for which, earlier Madhuban (Dharmabandh O.P.) P.S. case no. 01
of 2025 and Madhuban P.S. case no. 02 of 2025 have already been
registered.
3. The brief fact of his case is that this case, Madhuban P.S. case no.
03 of 2025 has been registered, basing upon the written report
Cr.M.P. No. 25 of 2026
[( 2026:JHHC:602 ) ]
submitted by the Circle Inspector of Mahuda Circle office,
alleging therein that on 09.01.2025 at about 10.30 AM, there was a
fight between two groups, one led by Karu Yadav and the other
by Sheikh Guddu, to have dominance over the Babudih colliery.
There were arson, firing, assaults and counter assaults between
the members of the two groups. On getting the information, the
informant reached the place of occurrence, along with the police
force at about 11.00 AM and saw the occurrence. The fire was
extinguished by the fire engines and information was received
that the supporters of Karu Yadav have torched the AJSU party
office. The informant also saw the same. The persons present at
the place alleged that it is the supporters of Karu Yadav who have
committed the said occurrence. Madhuban (Dharmabandh O.P.)
P.S. case no. 01 of 2025 has been instituted upon written report
submitted by the Sub Inspector of Police – cum- In-charge
Dharmabandh O.P. alleging that on 09.01.2025, at 10.00 AM, the
outsourcing company of BCCL namely M/s Hilltop company for
excavation of coal started the work of demarcation of the land.
The outsourcing Hilltop company has sublet the work to Karu
Yadav. The local residents were opposing Karu Yadav for their
own reasons. The group of Karu Yadav was opposed by the group
of Sheikh Tohid @ Dablu. Subhash Singh is a AJSU supporter and
with the help of Subhash Singh and the villagers, the Hon’ble
Member of Parliament from Giridih, held meetings at the Babudih
office and BCCL area. At about 11.00 AM, about 100 persons of
Karu Yadav, 61 of whom, have been named in FIR along with
others, on motorcycle and other vehicles, armed with deadly
weapons, reached Babudih place of work. From the other side, Sk.
Tohid about 100 persons, 61 of whom have been named, also
came on motorcycles and other vehicles, armed with deadly
weapons and opposed the work. The informant along with armed
forces and other officers reached the place of occurrence. The
informant tried to pacify the parties but both the parties did not
Cr.M.P. No. 25 of 2026
[( 2026:JHHC:602 ) ]
oblige the informant and started to abuse each other, consequent
upon exchange of abuse, there was assault, counter assault, firing
and blasting of bombs. Several vehicles were damaged and
torched. Subhash Singh sustained bullet injury on his leg. More
force reached at the place of occurrence after getting the
information and after arrival of sufficient number of forces; the
miscreants and accused persons, fled away and they were chased
away by the police personnel. Madhuban P.S. case no. 02 of 2025
has been instituted on the basis of the written report submitted by
the Sub-Inspector–cum-Officer–in-Charge of Madhuban police
station. He has also stated that on 09.01.2025 at 11.00 AM, there
was fight for dominance over Babudih colliery between two
groups, there were assault and counter assault, firing and arson.
The members of Karu Yadav group torched the office of AJSU and
vandalized the same. The members of Karu Yadav group
assembled in support of Karu Yadav. After getting information,
Police force reached there and tried to arrest the members who
were present there. Police surrounded Karu Yadav and his son
Binod Yadav. They used criminal force against the police
personnel and deterred them from discharging their duty. The
wife of Karu Yadav and other persons made a murderous assault
upon the police team in an organized manner and forcibly took
away Karu Yadav and his son from the custody of police. In the
stone pelting that took place, the Sub-Divisional Police Officer,
Baghmara, sustained 2-3 stone injuries on his head and became
injured and fell down on the ground and taking advantage of the
police party paying their attention to the injured Sub-divisional
police officer, the miscreants including Karu Yadav and his son,
fled away from the place of occurrence.
4. It is submitted by learned counsel for the petitioners that the
occurrence in respect of which Madhuban P.S. case no. 01 of 2025
was registered, took place during the same course of transaction,
in which the occurrence of this case also took place. It is next
Cr.M.P. No. 25 of 2026
[( 2026:JHHC:602 ) ]
submitted that thus, the institution of Madhuban P.S. case no. 03
of 2025 is an attempt for a fresh investigation based on second or
successive FIR, not being a counter case, which is prohibited in
law. It is next submitted that FIR of Madhuban P.S. case no. 03 of
2025 is hit by the provisions of Section 181 of the BNSS, 2023.
5. Relying upon the judgment of this Court in the case of Manish
Varma and Another vs. The State of Jharkhand & Another dated
06.05.2024, it is submitted by learned counsel for the petitioners
that in that case, this Court relied upon the judgment of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of T.T. Antony v.
State of Kerala & Others reported in (2001) 6 SCC 181 paragraph27 of which reads as under:“27. A just balance between the fundamental rights of the citizens
under Articles 19 and 21 of the Constitution and the expansive
power of the police to investigate a cognizable offence has to be
struck by the court. There cannot be any controversy that
subsection (8) of Section 173 CrPC empowers the police to make
further investigation, obtain further evidence (both oral and
documentary) and forward a further report or reports to the
Magistrate. In Narang case [(1979) 2 SCC 322 : 1979 SCC (Cri)
479] it was, however, observed that it would be appropriate to
conduct further investigation with the permission of the court.
However, the sweeping power of investigation does not warrant
subjecting a citizen each time to fresh investigation by the police in
respect of the same incident, giving rise to one or more cognizable
offences, consequent upon filing of successive FIRs whether before
or after filing the final report under Section 173(2) CrPC. It would
clearly be beyond the purview of Sections 154 and 156 CrPC, nay,
a case of abuse of the statutory power of investigation in a given
case. In our view a case of fresh investigation based on the second
or successive FIRs, not being a counter-case, filed in connection
with the same or connected cognizable offence alleged to have been
committed in the course of the same transaction and in respect of
which pursuant to the first FIR either investigation is under way
or final report under Section 173(2) has been forwarded to the
Magistrate, may be a fit case for exercise of power under Section
482 CrPC or under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution.”
(Emphasis supplied)
wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India has held that
fresh investigation based on the second or successive FIRs, not
being a counter-case, filed in connection with the same or
connected cognizable offence alleged to have been committed in
the course of the same transaction and in respect of which
Cr.M.P. No. 25 of 2026
[( 2026:JHHC:602 ) ]
pursuant to the first FIR either investigation is under way or final
report under Section 173(2) has been forwarded to the Magistrate,
may be a fit case for exercise of power under Section 482 CrPC
and submits that in this case also, the FIR of Madhuban P.S. case
no. 03 of 2025 having been lodged in connection with the same
and connected cognizable offences, the same be quashed and set
aside.
6. It is next submitted that this Court in that case, also relied upon
the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of
Amitbhai Anil Chandra Shah v. Central Bureau of Investigation
& Another reported in (2013) 6 SCC 348, para 58.3 of which reads
as under :“58.3. Even after filing of such a report, if he comes into possession of
further information or material, there is no need to register a fresh
FIR, he is empowered to make further investigation normally with
the leave of the court and where during further investigation, he
collects further evidence, oral or documentary, he is obliged to
forward the same with one or more further reports which is evident
from sub-section (8) of Section 173 of the Code. Under the scheme
of the provisions of Sections 154, 155, 156, 157, 162, 169, 170 and
173 of the Code, only the earliest or the first information in regard
to the commission of a cognizable offence satisfies the requirements
of Section 154 of the Code. Thus, there can be no second FIR and,
consequently, there can be no fresh investigation on receipt of
every subsequent information in respect of the same cognizable
offence or the same occurrence or incident giving rise to one or
more cognizable offences.” (Emphasis supplied)
7. It is then submitted that in that case, this Court further relied
upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the
case of Upkar Singh v. Ved Prakash and Others reported in
(2004) 13 SCC 292 paragraph-17 of which reads as under:“17. It is clear from the words emphasised hereinabove in the above
quotation, this Court in the case of T.T. Antony v. State of Kerala
[(2001) 6 SCC 181 : 2001 SCC (Cri) 1048] has not excluded the
registration of a complaint in the nature of a counter-case from the
purview of the Code. In our opinion, this Court in that case only
held that any further complaint by the same complainant or others
against the same accused, subsequent to the registration of a case,
is prohibited under the Code because an investigation in this
regard would have already started and further complaint against
the same accused will amount to an improvement on the facts
mentioned in the original complaint, hence will be prohibited
under Section 162 of the Code. This prohibition noticed by this
Court, in our opinion, does not apply to counter-complaint by the
Cr.M.P. No. 25 of 2026
[( 2026:JHHC:602 ) ]
accused in the first complaint or on his behalf alleging a different
version of the said incident.” (Emphasis supplied)
8. It is next submitted that in that case, this Court also relied upon
the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of
Tarak Dash Mukharjee & Others vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and
Others reported in 2022 SCC OnLine SC 2121.
9. Learned counsel for the petitioners next relies upon the judgment
of this Court in the case of Ranjeet Kumar Rawani @ Ranjit
Rawani & Another vs. State of Jharkhand passed in Cr.MP no.
2367 of 2023 wherein this Court took note of Krishna Lal Chawla
& Ors. vs. State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr. reported in (2021) 5 SCC
435, wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India has reiterated
the settled principle of law that the second FIR in respect of an
offence or different offences committed in the course of the same
transaction, is not only impermissible but it violates Article 21 of
the Constitution of India, hence, it is submitted that the prayer as
prayed for in the instant Criminal Miscellaneous Petition, be
allowed.
10. Learned Spl.P.P appearing for the State fairly submits that the
occurrence for which, Madhuban P.S. case no. 03 of 2025 has been
registered, also finds place either in the FIR of Madhuban P.S. case
no. 01 of 2025 or Madhuban P.S. case no. 02 of 2025 and no new
fact has been alleged in the present case, though the informant is a
different person, but it is submitted that at this nascent stage, the
prayer as prayed for by the petitioners ought not be allowed and
this Criminal Miscellaneous Petition being without any merit, be
dismissed.
11. Having heard the rival submissions made at the Bar and after
going through materials available in the record, it is pertinent to
mention here that the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India has laid
down the consequence test in its judgment in the case of C.
Muniappan & Others v. State of Tamil Nadu reported in (2010) 9
SCC 567 according to which, if an offence forming part of the
Cr.M.P. No. 25 of 2026
[( 2026:JHHC:602 ) ]
second F.I.R. arises as a consequence of the offence alleged in the
first F.I.R.; then the offences covered by both the F.I.Rs are the
same and accordingly the second F.I.R. will be impermissible in
law or in other words, the offence covered in both the F.I.Rs shall
have to be treated as part of the first F.I.R.
12. It is a settled principle of law, as has been held by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India in para 27 of the case of T.T. Antony v.
State of Kerala & Others (supra) that a second F.I.R. is
maintainable for a counter-case only. Now coming to the facts of
the case, as already discussed above, no new fact of occurrence or
offence has been alleged in FIR of Madhuban P.S. case no. 03 of
2025; which has not been mentioned either in the FIR of
Madhuban P.S. case no. 01 of 2025 or in the FIR of Madhuban P.S.
case no. 02 of 2025. Thus, this Court is of the considered view that
FIR of Madhuban P.S. case no. 03 of 2025 is a subsequent FIR in
respect of the selfsame occurrence, for which earlier, Madhuban
P.S. case no. 01 of 2025 or Madhuban P.S. case no. 02 of 2025 has
been registered. Accordingly, the same is not sustainable in law,
being hit by the provisions of Section 181 of BNSS, 2023.
Therefore, this is a fit case where the entire criminal proceeding
including the First Information Report in connection with
Madhuban P.S. case no. 03 of 2025 be quashed and set aside
against the petitioners.
13. Accordingly, the entire criminal proceeding including the First
Information Report in connection with Madhuban P.S. case no. 03
of 2025 is quashed and set aside qua the petitioners.
14. In the result, this Criminal Miscellaneous Petition is allowed.
(Anil Kumar Choudhary, J.)
High Court of Jharkhand, Ranchi
Dated, the 09th of January, 2026
Abhiraj /AFR
Uploaded on 13/01/2026
Cr.M.P. No. 25 of 2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review