Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:39390
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH SHIMLA
CMPMO No. 542/2025
Reserved on: 08.09.2026
Decided on: 15.09.2026
Balkrishan (deceased) through LRs
& anr.
…..Petitioners
Versus
Shanti Swaroop & anr.
…Respondents
________________________________________________________________
Coram:
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Romesh Verma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the Petitioners:
Mr. Ajay Sharma, Sr. Advocate with Mr.
Atharv Sharma, Advocate.
For the Respondents: Mr. Mukul Sood, Advocate, for respondent
No.1.
Romesh Verma, Judge
The instant petition arises out of order, dated
05.08.2025, as passed by the learned
Senior Civil Judge,
Palampur, District Kangra, H.P., whereby an application filed by
defendant/respondent No.1 for summoning
of witnesses and
depositing the process fee and diet money has been allowed.
2.
Facts, as emerge in the present case, are that the
plaintiffs/petitioners have filed a suit before the learned trial
1Whether reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes.
court for the grant of decree of declaration to the effect that the
plaintiffs and defendants have inherited land in equal shares, as
entered in Khata No. 18, Khatouni No. 25 Khasra Kita 11, land
measuring 00-63-99 hectares, Khata No. 20 Khatouni No.28
Khasra Kita 6 land measuring 00-03-53 hectares, Khata No. 26
Khatouni No. 35 Khasra Kita 4 land measuring 0-03-60
hectares, Khata No. 27 Khatouni No.37, Khasra No. 235 land
measuring 00-06-93 hectares, Khata No. 28 Khatouni No. 38
Khasra No. 236 land measuring 00-02-50 hectares, Khata No.
115 Khatouni No. 127 Khasra No. 242, land measuring 00-02-62
Khasra No. 239 land measuring 00-04-75 hectares, Khata No.
342 Khatouni No. 445 Khasra Nos. 884 and 883, land measuring
00-12-39 hectares of Mohal Tanda, Tehsil Palampur and Khata
No. 292 Khatouni No. 564, Khasra No. 1942, land measuring 021-86 hectares, Khata No. 297, Khatouni Nos. 570, 571 Khasra
Nos. 1944, 1971 Kita 2 land measuring 00-01-58 hectares,
Khata No.857, Khatouni No. 1342 Khasra Nos. 3429, 3107/1978
land measuring 0-11-73 hectares, Khata No. 290 Khatouni No.
562 Khasra Kita 3, land measuring 0-21-10 hectares, Khata No.
291 Khatouni No. 563 Khasra Nos. 1938, 2836/1941 Land
measuring 0-14-81 hectares of Mohal Ghuggar Tehsil Palampur
vide jamabandi for the years 2011-12 and 2012-13 alongwith
house situated in the above Khasra numbers as entered in the
name of plaintiff, defendants and others co-shares. As per case,
as set up by the plaintiffs/petitioners, the plaintiffs and
defendants are sons and daughter of late Smt. Rattani Devi, wife
of Sohan Lal and have inherited the suit land along with house
in equal shares after death of Rattani Devi, who expired on
10.06.2014. Late Rattani Devi
during her life time did not
execute any will dated 01.04.1998 as registered on 02.04.1998
before Sub Registrar, Palampur and the Will, as set-forth by
defendant No.1 is result of fraud and misrepresentation. It has
been averred that in case defendant No.1 succeeds in proving
the execution of the alleged will, then also suit land along with
house is ancestral one and the same has been inherited by the
parties from their forefathers. Since the suit property is ancestral
one, therefore, the alleged will cannot be executed qua the suit
property. Therefore, it was prayed that decree for declaration, to
the effect that the plaintiffs and defendants have inherited suit
property in equal shares and the alleged will
is not genuine
document, be passed in favour of the plaintiffs and against the
defendants.
3.
The
aforesaid
suit
has
been
contested
by
the
defendants by filing written statement, wherein preliminary
objections qua maintainability,
cause of action, locus standi,
valuation etc. have been raised. As per the case of the
defendants, they have inherited the suit property as per
registered will executed by Rattani Devi vide registration No. 53,
dated 2.4.1998 and the said will became operative after the
demise of Rattani Devi and the same is outcome of love and
affection and services rendered by the defendants.
4.
The
learned
trial
court
framed
04.12.2018 and thereafter additional issues
the
issues
on
were framed on
08.12.2021.
5.
fixed
It would be noticed that on 04.12.2018, the case was
for 09.04.2019 for plaintiffs’ evidence. However,
on
account of filing of miscellaneous applications, the case was
adjourned
repeatedly. Thereafter, the plaintiffs
closed their
evidence on 20.11.2023 and the matter was listed for leading
evidence of the defendants on 26.12.2023.
The defendant
/respondent No.1 filed an application under Section 63 of the
Indian Evidence Act for summoning or examining the witnesses
to lead secondary evidence, wherein it was prayed that following
witnesses be summoned to prove the Will dated 01.04.1998 and
registered on 02.04.1998 of Rattani Devi in connection with the
unavailability and/or existence of the original witnesses i.e. the
Scribe and marginal witnesses due to their death to prove the
legal necessities by their deposition as secondary evidence:
i.
Vishal Rana, son of late Kuldip Singh Rana
ii.
Anup Kumar, son of late Jagishar
iii.
Registration Clerk of the office of Sub Registrar,
Palampur
iv.
S.C. Saklani, the then Sub Registrar, Palampur.
Defendant No.1 also sought permission to lead secondary
evidence upon examination of the said witnesses, in accordance
with Section 65 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872.
6.
The aforesaid application, as filed by defendant No.1,
was duly resisted by the petitioners/plaintiffs by filing a detailed
reply.
7.
The learned trial Court vide order dated 28.07.2025
Annexure P-3, dismissed the aforesaid application being not
maintainable. Thereafter, defendant No.1 filed an application for
summoning of witnesses, Annexure P-4 i.e. Vishal Rana, son of
late Kuldip Singh Rana; Anup Kumar, son of
late Jagishar;
Registration Clerk of the office of Sub Registrar, Palampur; and
S.C. Saklani, the then Sub Registrar, Palampur. The said
application was allowed by the learned trial Court on 05.08.2025
and the defendants were directed to deposit travel allowances
and diet money of the witnesses. Thereafter, on the very same
day, it was observed that steps are stated to have been taken
except for diet money. Be deposited and put up on 13.08.2025.
8.
Feeling
dissatisfied
with
the
orders,
dated
05.08.2025, the plaintiffs/petitioners have approached this
Court by filing instant petition under article 227 of the
Constitution of India.
9.
It is contended by Mr. Ajay Sharma, learned Senior
Advocate, duly assisted by Mr. Atharv Sharma, Advocate, for the
plaintiffs/petitioners that once the application under Section 63
of the Indian Evidence Act came to be dismissed being not
maintainable by the learned trial court, on the same and similar
grounds, application for summoning of the witnesses, as filed by
defendant No.1, is neither maintainable nor it could have been
allowed by the learned trial court. He has further contended that
once prayer of defendant No.1 for leading secondary evidence
especially for summoning similar persons in the form of
secondary
evidence
was
declined,
therefore,
under
such
circumstances, same prayer, which has been made in the
subsequent application for summoning of the witnesses, could
not have been accepted by the learned trial court.
10.
On the other hand, Mr. Mukul Sood, learned counsel
for defendant/respondent No.1, has defended the impugned
order and
submitted that since the impugned order does not
suffer from any illegality or infirmity, therefore, while invoking
provisions of article 227 of the Constitution of India, this Court
will not interfere with the same.
11.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and
have also gone through the material available on record.
12.
As observed above, the petitioners/plaintiffs have
filed suit for declaration on the ground that will dated
01.04.1998 and registered on 02.04.1998 before Sub Registrar,
Palampur, as set-forth by defendant No.1, is result of fraud and
misrepresentation, thus, the same is not binding on the rights of
the plaintiffs/petitioners. It is the case of the plaintiffs that the
plaintiffs and defendants
are sons and daughter of late Smt.
Rattani Devi and have inherited the suit land along with house
in equal shares after death of Rattani Devi, who expired on
10.06.2014. Since the suit property is ancestral one, therefore,
the alleged will cannot be executed qua the same.
13.
On the other hand, the suit has been contested by the
defendants by taking stand that the suit property
has been
inherited by them as per registered will dated 2.4.1998 executed
by Rattani Devi on account of love and affection and services
rendered by them.
14.
Provisions of Section 63 of the Indian Evidence Act
read as under:
“63. Secondary evidence.
Secondary evidence means and includes
-(1)[ certified copies given under the provisions hereinafter
contained;]
(2)copies made from the original by the mechanical
processes which in themselves insure the accuracy of the
copy, and copies compared with such copies;
(3)copies made from or compared with the original;
(4)counterparts of documents as against the parties who
did not execute them;
(5)oral accounts of the contents of a document given by
some person who has himself seen it.
Illustrations
(a)A photograph of an original is secondary evidence of its
contents though the two have not been compared, if it is
proved that the thing photographed was the original.
(b)A copy compared with a copy of a letter made by a
copying machine is secondary evidence of the contents of
the letter, if it is shown that the copy made by the copying
machine was made from the original.
(c)A copy transcribed from a copy, but afterwards compared
with the original, is secondary evidence; but the copy not so
compared is not secondary evidence of the original although
the copy from which it was transcribed was compared with
the original.
(d)Neither an oral account of a copy compared with the
original nor an oral account of a photograph or a machine
copy of the original, is secondary evidence of the original.”
15.
Court
The defendants had approached the learned trial
by filing an application for summoning and examining
the witnesses to lead secondary evidence on the ground that
defendant No.1 has to prove
the will, dated 01.04.1998, but
scribe of Will namely Kuldeep Rana and two marginal witnesses
to the Will, namely, Jagisar Singh and Prem Chand, had died.
Therefore, defendant No.1 intended to summon and examine
their sons Vishal Rana and Anup Kumar respectively to prove
handwriting and signatures of their respective fathers on the Will
apart from Clerk of the office of Sub Registrar, Palampur and
S. C. Saklani, the then Sub Registrar, Palampur.
16.
Learned counsel for respondent/defendant No.1 has
drawn attention of this Court to provisions of Section 68 and 69
of the Indian Evidence Act. He has contended that since will has
been set up by defendant/respondent No.1, therefore, in order
to prove contents of the same as primary evidence, defendant
No.1 is supposed to lead evidence in support of his contentions.
He has also drawn attention of this Court to the order, as passed
by the learned trial Court in the application under Section 63 of
the Indian Evidence Act, whereby the said application was held
to be not maintainable observing therein that since basic burden
to prove genuineness
of the Will is on the
propounder i.e.
respondent/defendant No.1, therefore, he in his wisdom can call
any witness to prove the Will. It was further observed that more
over Anup Kumar, proposed witness has already been cited as
one of the defence witnesses.
17.
This Court is in agreement
with the contention as
raised by the learned counsel for respondent No.1 that once the
application under Section 63 of the Indian Evidence Act was held
to
be not maintainable by the learned trial Court and the
learned trial court itself has observed that in order to prove Will,
defendant No.1 can call any witness to prove the same, the
impugned order, as passed by the learned trial Court, is
sustainable in the eyes of law.
18.
After perusing the original records, as summoned by
this Court, it reveals that the application for summoning of the
witnesses was filed by defendant No.1 on 17.01.2024 and in the
said application,
it was prayed that apart from examining
himself, he intended to
examine Prem Chand Namberdar,
Jageesar Singh, Namberdar and Kuldeep Singh Rana, Document
Writer, Tehsil Compound Palampur, however when the summons
were issued for their service, it was found that they had died.
19.
Though in the opinion of this Court, the learned trial
Court has rightly come to conclusion that the application, which
was filed
by defendant No.1 under Section 63 of the Indian
Evidence Act was not maintainable, however after receiving the
report and after passing of order by learned trial court on the
application being not maintainable, the only remedy which was
available to defendant No.1 was to summon the witnesses
by
way of application at hand, which came to be allowed by the
learned trial court vide the impugned order.
20.
The records reveal that the evidence of the plaintiffs is
complete and now the case is fixed for evidence of the
defendants. The onus (burden of proof) to prove a Will lies
primarily on the propounder.
21.
In the present case, in the form of primary evidence,
defendant No.1 is well within his right to examine the witnesses
which have been cited in the subsequent application, filed on
05.08.2025. Merely that an application under Section 63 of the
Indian Evidence Act was dismissed
cannot preclude
being not maintainable
defendant No.1 to examine the proposed
witnesses to prove his case in accordance with law.
22.
As rightly pointed out by the learned counsel for
respondent/defendant No.1 that by merely summoning
and
examining the proposed witnesses will not automatically prove
the case of defendant No.1 and the petitioners/plaintiffs shall
have right and get opportunity to cross-examine them.
23.
This Court
sees no reason to interfere with the
impugned order as no prejudice has been caused to the
plaintiffs/petitioners by allowing
the application, as filed by
defendant No.1, for summoning and examining the proposed
witnesses.
24.
The procedure of law is handmaid of justice and
no one can be deprived of his right on account of technicalities
of law. In the considered opinion
order
does not
suffer
from
of this Court the impugned
any
illegality, irregularity
or
jurisdictional error.
25.
The power under Article 227 is limited to see that the
Courts below function within the limits of their authority or
jurisdiction. The High Court cannot interfere with the findings of
fact recorded by the subordinate Court or Tribunal while
exercising its jurisdiction under Article 227. The Hon’ble Apex
Court has held that, over the last 50 years, it has consistently
been observed that the limited jurisdiction of the High Court
under Article 227 cannot be exercised by interfering with
findings of fact or by setting aside the judgments of the courts
below on merits.
26.
Hon’ble Apex Court in Civil Appeal No. 2226 of
2010, titled State of Haryana & others vs. Manoj Kumar,
decided on 09.03.2010 has held as follow:“23. More than half a century ago, the Constitution Bench
of this court in Nagendra Nath Bora and Another v.
Commissioner of Hills Division and Appeals, Assam &
Others AIR 1958 SC 398 settled that power under Article
227 is limited to seeing that the courts below function
within the limit of its authority or jurisdiction.
24. This court placed reliance on Nagendra Nath's case in
a subsequent judgment in Nibaran Chandra Bag v.
Mahendra Nath Ghughu AIR 1963 SC 1895. The court
observed that jurisdiction conferred under Article 227 is not
by any means appellate in its nature for correcting errors in
the decisions of subordinate courts or tribunals but is
merely a power of superintendence to be used to keep them
within the bounds of their authority.
25. This court had an occasion to examine this aspect of the
matter in the case of Mohd. Yunus v. Mohd. Mustaqim &
Others (1983) 4 SCC 566. The court observed as under:"The supervisory jurisdiction conferred on the High
Courts under Article 227 of the Constitution is limited
"to seeing that an inferior Court or Tribunal functions
within the limits of its authority," and not to correct an
error apparent on the face of the record, much less an
error of law. for this case there was, in our opinion, no
error of law much less an error apparent on the face of
the record. There was no failure on the part of the
learned Subordinate Judge to exercise jurisdiction nor
did he act in disregard of principles of natural justice.
Nor was the procedure adopted by him not in
consonance with the procedure established by law. In
exercising the supervisory power under Article 227, the
High Court does not act as an Appellate Court or
Tribunal. It will not review or reweigh the evidence
upon which the determination of the inferior court or
tribunal purports to be based or to correct errors of law
in the decision."
26. This court again clearly reiterated the legal position in
Laxmikant Revchand Bhojwani & Another v. Pratapsing
Mohansingh Pardeshi (1995) 6 SCC 576. The court again
cautioned that the High Court under Article 227 of the
Constitution cannot assume unlimited prerogative to correct
all species of hardship or wrong decisions. It must be
restricted to cases of grave dereliction of duty and flagrant
abuse of fundamental principles of law or justice, where
grave injustice would be done unless the High Court
interferes.
27. A three-Judge Bench of this court in Rena Drego (Mrs.)
v. Lalchand Soni & Others (1998) 3 SCC 341 again
abundantly made it clear that the High Court cannot
interfere with the findings of fact recorded by the
subordinate court or the tribunal while exercising its
jurisdiction under Article 227. Its function is limited to
seeing that the subordinate court or the tribunal functions
within the limits of its authority. It cannot correct mere
errors of fact by examining the evidence and reappreciating
it.
28. In Virendra Kashinath Ravat & Another v. Vinayak N.
Joshi & Others (1999) 1 SCC 47 this court held that the
limited power under Article 227 cannot be invoked except
for ensuring that the subordinate courts function within its
limits.
29. This court over 50 years has been consistently
observing that limited jurisdiction of the High Court under
Article 227 cannot be exercised by interfering with the
findings of fact and set aside the judgments of the courts
below on merit.”
27.
To the similar extent, the Hon’ble Apex Court in Civil
Appeal No. 3072 of 2022, titled as Ibrat Faizan vs. Omaxe
Buildhome Private Limited, decided on 13.05.2022 has held as
follows: -
“14. In view of the above, in the present case, the High
Court has not committed any error in entertaining the writ
petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India
against the order passed by the National Commission
which has been passed in an appeal under Section 58 (1)
(a) (iii) of the 2019 Act. We are in complete agreement with
the view taken by the High Court. However, at the same
time, it goes without saying that while exercising the
powers under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, the
High Court subjects itself to the rigour of Article 227 of the
Constitution and the High Court has to exercise the
jurisdiction under Article 227 within the parameters within
which such jurisdiction is required to be exercised.
14.1 The scope and ambit of jurisdiction of Article 227 of
the Constitution has been explained by this Court in the
case of Estralla Rubber v. Dass Estate (P) Ltd., (2001) 8
SCC 97, which has been consistently followed by this Court
(see the recent decision of this Court in the case of Garment
Craft v. Prakash Chand Goel, 2022 SCC Online SC 29).
Therefore, while exercising the powers under Article 227 of
the Constitution, the High Court has to act within the
parameters to exercise the powers under Article 227 of the
Constitution. It goes without saying that even while
considering the grant of interim stay/relief in a writ petition
under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, the High
Court has to bear in mind the limited jurisdiction of
superintendence under Article 227 of the Constitution.
Therefore, while granting any interim stay/relief in a writ
petition under Article 227 of the Constitution against an
order passed by the National Commission, the same shall
always be subject to the rigor of the powers to be exercised
under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.”
28.
Consequently, in view of aforesaid exposition of law
and discussion, the present petition, being devoid of any merit,
deserves
to
be
dismissed.
Ordered
accordingly.
Pending
miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
29.
Before parting, it is made clear that any observation
made here-in-above shall not be taken as an expression of
opinion on the merits of the main case and the same shall be
adjudicated upon uninfluenced by any observations made herein-above, which are only for the purpose of the instant petition.
15th September, 2026
(pankaj)
(Romesh Verma)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review