Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 13th October, 2026
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010496922026
W.P.(C) 15244/2026 & CM APPL. 71636/2026, CM APPL.
71637/2026
BALESHWAR SHARMA
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Tushar Jarwal, Advocate with
Mr. Vivek Malik, Advocates
versus
DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX .....Respondent
Through: Mr. Ruchir Bhatia, SSC with Mr.
Anant Mann and Mr. P. Gupta, JSCs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE DINESH MEHTA
HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE ADITI CHOUDHARY
JUDGMENT
DINESH MEHTA, J. (ORAL)
1.
By way of the instant writ petition, the petitioner has challenged the
Assessment Order dated 22.09.2026 passed under Section 143(3) of the
Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act of 1961’) on the
ground of the same being contrary to principles of natural justice and in
breach of the directions issued by this Court.
2.
It may be noted that the petitioner had earlier preferred a writ petition
W.P.(C) 5921/2026, inter alia challenging the Assessment Order dated
31.03.2026 passed under Section 143(3) of the Act of 1961, whereby the
respondent No.1 had raised a demand against the petitioner essentially on
Signature
Not Verified
Signed
By:PRATI
MA
Signing
Date:15.10.
2026 15:16
W.P.(C) 15244/2026
the basis of slip recovered from one Pradeep Kumar Sehgal in which a sum
of Rs.10,000/- was written. The Assessing Officer (hereinafter referred to as
‘AO’) alleged to have recorded the statement of said Pradeep Kumar Sehgal
who reportedly deposed that the amount of Rs.10,000/- had been written in
place of Rs.1,00,00,000/- and three zeros were intentionally not mentioned
in the slip. The AO, thus, added such amount (Rs.1,00,00,000/-) in
petitioner’s hands, inspite of the petitioner’s objection.
3.
The petitioner sought an opportunity to cross-examine the said
Pradeep Kumar Sehgal but the AO refused to grant such an opportunity, for
which the petitioner approached this Court by way of the aforesaid writ
petition. The said writ petition came to be allowed by this Court vide order
dated 30.04.2026, whereby the assessment order under challenge was
quashed and set aside and the AO was directed to grant an opportunity to
cross-examine the said Pradeep Kumar Sehgal. The operating part of the
above order dated 30.04.2026 reads thus:“8. We, therefore, set aside the assessment order dated 31.03.2026, which
essentially hinges upon the seized document (Kachchi Parchi) and the
statement of the said Mr. Pradeep Kumar Sehgal for want of opportunity of
cross examination. Because, since the entire addition is edified on the
statement and slip recovered from Pradeep Kumar Sehgal.
9. The AO shall fix any date of hearing between 18.05.2026 to 20.05.2026
and inform the petitioner at least 7 days in advance and provide an
opportunity to cross-examine Pradeep Kumar Sehgal. It shall be incumbent
upon the AO to ensure that said Pradeep Kumar is available for cross-
examination at the time of hearing so fixed and after the cross
examination being so done, the AO shall pass a fresh assessment
order in accordance with law, giving due regard to the crossexamination.”
4.
Mr. Jarwal, learned counsel for the petitioner informed that in
Signature
Not Verified
Signed
By:PRATI
MA
Signing
Date:15.10.
2026 15:16
W.P.(C) 15244/2026
furtherance of the directions so issued by this Court, the AO did issue a
notice dated 08.05.2026, requiring the petitioner to appear on 19.05.2026
and also called said Pradeep Kumar Sehgal to remain present at 11:30a.m.
for the purpose of cross-examination but on the very same date, the
petitioner had a matter in the High Court, for which his presence (in the
High Court) was necessary. After attending the hearing at High Court, when
the petitioner reached the office of the AO, it was already 12:20 p.m. Then,
the Assessing Officer informed that Pradeep Kumar Sehgal, the witness had
left the office at 12:10 p.m.
5.
The petitioner requested the AO to call said Pradeep Kumar Sehgal
but his request was turned down. The petitioner immediately made a
representation to the Additional Commissioner in this regard, perhaps at
whose intervention, the AO acceded to petitioner’s request and called the
said witness Pradeep Kumar Sehgal on 26.05.2026, on the said date the
petitioner was present alongwith his Counsel at the scheduled time but said
witness (Pradeep Kumar Sehgal) did not show up.
6.
In the meantime, the incumbent in the chair of AO got transferred and
the new officer who resumed charge refused to grant any indulgence and
proceeded to pass impugned order by observing that the High Court’s order
had been complied with and that it was the petitioner’s fault in not showing
up at the time fixed by the AO on 19.05.2026.
7.
While observing so, the AO proceeded to pass an assessment order,
obviously on the same lines as the earlier assessment order dated 31.03.2026
and raised identical demand.
8.
Signature
Not Verified
Signed
By:PRATI
MA
Signing
Date:15.10.
2026 15:16
Learned counsel for the petitioner argued that the petitioner had
reached the office of the AO at 12:20 p.m., just 10 minutes after the witness
W.P.(C) 15244/2026
Pradeep Kumar Sehgal had left the office of the AO. He contended that the
AO could have called the witness back so as to facilitate cross-examination
but he refused to do so and submitted that by not providing an opportunity to
cross examine, the AO has not followed the order of this Court in its true
spirit and has thus breached the directions passed by this Court. He argued
that the impugned order not only suffers from violation of principles of
natural justice but the same is also contrary to the order of this Court and
thus liable to be quashed and set aside.
9.
He further argued that the entire basis of the demand as raised against
the petitioner is, the slip which records an amount of Rs.10,000/- which too
incorrectly records petitioner’s name. He submitted that in the facts of the
present case, unless the petitioner is given an opportunity to cross-examine
the said Pradeep Kumar Sehgal, whom the petitioner does not even know,
such amount cannot be added in petitioner’s income, when there is no other
incriminating material. He, therefore, submitted that the impugned demand
raised against the petitioner is liable to be quashed on this ground as well.
10.
Mr. Mann, learned counsel for the respondent, on the other hand,
argued that the AO has complied with the directions contained in the order
dated 30.04.2026 in both letter and spirit. He highlighted that admittedly he
had given 10 days’ prior intimation to the petitioner and call the witness
Pradeep Kumar Sehgal for cross-examination, who remained in the office
from 11:30 p.m. to 12:10 p.m. waiting for the petitioner, but when the
petitioner did not come he had no other option but to leave.
11.
Learned counsel submitted that neither the petitioner nor his Counsel
had the courtesy to even inform the AO that they would be late, so that the
Signature
Not Verified
Signed
By:PRATI
MA
Signing
Date:15.10.
2026 15:16
AO could have asked the witness to wait for some time.
W.P.(C) 15244/2026
12.
Mr. Mann further submitted that in the interest of justice, the AO had
called not only Pradeep Kumar Sehgal but also Yogesh Jain to ensure that
complete justice was done and hence, it cannot be said that the AO had acted
arbitrarily or vindictively in any manner.
13.
Inviting the Court’s attention towards the assessment order, learned
counsel submitted that it was the petitioner himself, who did not want to
cross-examine the witnesses so as to take undue advantage of the situation
and thus no indulgence be granted.
14.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
15.
On appraisal of the facts on record, we are of the view that the
petitioner has been indolent and negligent so far as taking up the
proceedings with due diligence and requisite seriousness is concerned.
When this Court had set aside the assessment order and directed the AO to
grant an opportunity to cross-examine, it was imperative for the petitioner to
be ready for cross-examination. The petitioner’s approach of not keeping
himself or his counsel available for the purpose of cross-examination, when
the AO had given him atleast 10 days notice in advance cannot be
countenanced. His plea that he was busy attending the hearing in the High
Court is a lame excuse. An assessee has to prioritise his cases.
16.
Be that as it may. What persuades us to intervene is, the AO’s own
action of acceding to petitioner’s request. Indisputably, at petitioner’s
request the then AO had issued another notice to the petitioner and to the
witnesses (Pradeep Kumar Sehgal and Yogesh Jain) to appear on
26.05.2026, on which date they (witnesses) did not appear but the petitioner
and his counsel did come. Therefore, by his own action, the AO had
Signature
Not Verified
Signed
By:PRATI
MA
Signing
Date:15.10.
2026 15:16
condoned petitioner’s fault or negligence of not appearing on 19.05.2026.
W.P.(C) 15244/2026
Such being the position, the AO in our opinion could not have backtracked
and said that the petitioner had failed to avail opportunity to cross examine
on 19.05.2026.
17.
Despite holding above opinion, we feel that the witnesses cannot be
called again and again to serve the cause of the petitioner. Their time also
has its own value. Therefore, while allowing the present petition and setting
aside the impugned assessment order dated 22.09.2026, we hereby direct
that the petitioner shall have to pay costs of Rs.25,000/- to each of the
witnesses, when they come for cross-examination.
18.
The AO shall fix a suitable date of hearing preferably between
16.11.2026 to 30.11.2026 and inform the petitioner and witness(es) atleast
07 days in advance and provide an opportunity to cross-examine Pradeep
Kumar Sehgal and Yogesh Jain. It shall be incumbent upon the AO to
ensure that said Pradeep Kumar Sehgal and Yogesh Jain are available for
cross-examination at the time of hearing, so fixed. In case the witness(es) do
not appear on the date fixed, the AO shall fix another date. But if on 3
occasions, the witness(es) do not come, the AO shall pass order in
accordance with law without waiting any further.
19.
In case, the cross-examination is done, the AO shall pass fresh
assessment order in accordance with law, giving due regard to the crossexamination.
20.
The petitioner shall keep pay order/Banker’s cheque of Rs.25,000/-
each drawn in the name of Pradeep Kumar Sehgal and Yogesh Jain ready
with him to be handed over to the respective witness(es) as and when they
appear for cross examination; their cross-examination shall be allowed only
Signature
Not Verified
Signed
By:PRATI
MA
Signing
Date:15.10.
2026 15:16
on payment of the aforesaid cost(s).
W.P.(C) 15244/2026
21.
With the aforesaid observations, the petition stands allowed. Pending
application(s) stands disposed of.
DINESH MEHTA
(JUDGE)
ADITI CHOUDHARY
(JUDGE)
OCTOBER 13, 2026
p’ma
Signature
Not Verified
Signed
By:PRATI
MA
Signing
Date:15.10.
2026 15:16
W.P.(C) 15244/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review