Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH,
SHIMLA
CWP No.18908 of 2025
Reserved on:21.05.2026
Decided on : 30.05.2026
Uploaded on :30.05.2026
Balak Ram Kapil
...Petitioner
Versus
Union of India and Others
…Respondents.
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice G.S. Sandhawalia, Chief Justice.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Bipin Chander Negi, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the petitioner
: M/s Vikas Rathore and Bhupinder
Thakur, Advocates.
For the respondent(s) : Mr. Bharat Bhushan, Senior Panel
Counsel.
Bipin Chander Negi, Judge
By way of the present petition, a challenge has
been laid to the impugned judgment dated 28.04.2025,
passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Chandigarh
Bench in OA No.063/95/2021, whereby the claim of the
present petitioner qua the grant of General Pension Scheme
instead of Contributory Provident Fund (CPF) has been
rejected.
Whether the reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment? Yes
-2-
2.
Heard counsel for the parties and perused the
impugned judgment and the written submission furnished by
the writ petitioner.
3.
The petitioner was initially appointed as a Primary
Teacher in the Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan (KVS) on
21.7.1983.
The
petitioner
opted
for
the
Contributory
Provident Fund (CPF) Scheme with CPF Account No. CEC3477.
Thereafter,
in
response
to
Kendriya
Vidyalaya
Sangathan Office Memorandum dated 1.9.1988, on exercise
of option dated 27.2.1989, the petitioner continued in the
CPF Scheme under a new Account Number 2853. The said
account continued till his retirement i.e. 31.12.2014.
4.
In
the
aforesaid
facts
and
attending
circumstances, the question which arises for consideration is
as to whether the petitioner can be permitted to resile from
the option earlier exercised on 27.02.1989.
5.
The petitioner is not an illiterate person. The
petitioner
cannot
contend
ignorance
of
the
rules
and
regulations of the department. If the petitioner had not
opted for continuation of CPF as per OM dated 01.09.1988,
then the petitioner should have objected to the same, when
CPF contributions were being made in the monthly pay bills,
-3-
which were duly reflected in Form No. 16 issued regularly.
6.
The allotment of new CPF number, monthly salary
bills containing deduction towards CPF, annual statements of
every year regarding consolidated balance in CPF and Form
16 for filing income tax are pointers towards the fact that the
petitioner was in the CPF Scheme and of his own volition
enjoyed the accrued benefits of the CPF Scheme. The
petitioner woke up after the lapse of a considerable period
i.e. after his retirement, seeking to migrate to the GPF-cumPension Scheme. The petitioner kept mum for a long time.
7.
From the response filed to the writ petition, it is
evident that admissible dues under the CPF Scheme stand
paid to the petitioner on his retirement and CPF final
payment papers have been signed by the petitioner. In the
aforesaid facts and attending circumstances besides delay
there is an acquiescence and waiver on the part of the
petitioner.
8.
In the aforesaid backdrop, it is evident that an option
had been exercised by the petitioner to remain under the
CPF Scheme, a fact which was disclosed before the Central
Administrative Tribunal by the respondent by way of an
-4-
application which has been placed on record as Annexure P-7
along with the writ petition. Hence it is evident that the
petitioner post-retirement entered into a futile litigation
being fully aware of the fact that he had exercised an option
to remain in the CPF Scheme. However, the said fact was
concealed by the petitioner.
9.
The first Original Application bearing No. OA-
063/000822/2018 was filed before the CAT, Chandigarh,
which was disposed of vide order dated 09.08.2018 directing
the respondents to take a decision qua the claim being made
by the petitioner to shift from the CPF Scheme within a
period of two months. Vide memorandum dated 10.10.2018,
the said request was not accepted, thereafter the petitioner
filed a fresh OA No. 63/95/2021. It is against the dismissal of
the same that the present petition has been preferred. In
both the petitions, material fact qua option having been
exercised way back in 1989 by the petitioner to remain in the
CPF Scheme has been concealed. The petition, therefore,
deserves to be dismissed with costs on account of material
suppression of facts which has resulted in un-necessary
wastage of judicial time and that of the respondents.
However, we refrain from imposing costs keeping in view the
-5-
fact that the petitioner is a retiree and for the below
mentioned reason.
10.
The unnecessary litigation in the case at hand has
also arisen on account of the routine direction issued by the
CAT on the first original application, filed by the petitioner,
directing the respondent authority to consider the petitioner’s
representation ignoring
the
huge
delay
preceding
the
representation. Neither the Tribunal’s direction to consider
the representation without examining the merits, nor a
decision given in compliance with such direction, will extend
the limitation, or erase the delay and laches. In this respect,
it would be appropriate to refer to the Apex Court judgement
in Union of India v. M.K. Sarkar, (2010) 2 SCC 59.
Relevant extract whereof reads as follow:“14. The order of the Tribunal allowing the first
application of respondent without examining the
merits, and directing the appellants to consider his
representation
has
given
rise
to
unnecessary
litigation and avoidable complications. The ill-effects
of such directions have been considered by this
Court in C. Jacob v. Director of Geology and Mining1
: (SCC pp. 122-23, para 9).
“9.
The
courts/tribunals
proceed
on
the
assumption, that every citizen deserves a
reply to his representation. Secondly, they
assume that a mere direction to consider and
-6-
dispose of the representation does not involve
any ‘decision’ on rights and obligations of
parties.
Little
do
they
realise
the
consequences of such a direction to ‘consider’.
If
the
representation
is
considered
and
accepted, the ex-employee gets a relief, which
he would not have got on account of the long
delay, all by reason of the direction to
‘consider’. If the representation is considered
and
rejected,
the
ex-employee
files
an
application/writ petition, not with reference to
the original cause of action of 1982, but by
treating the rejection of the representation
given in 2000, as the cause of action. A prayer
is
made
for
quashing
the
rejection
of
representation and for grant of the relief
claimed
in
the
representation.
The
tribunals/High Courts routinely entertain such
applications/petitions ignoring the huge delay
preceding the representation, and proceed to
examine the claim on merits and grant relief.
In this manner, the bar of limitation or the
laches gets obliterated or ignored.”
15. When a belated representation in regard to a
“stale” or “dead” issue/dispute is considered and
decided, in compliance with a direction by the
court/tribunal to do so, the date of such decision
cannot be considered as furnishing a fresh cause of
action for reviving the “dead” issue or time-barred
dispute. The issue of limitation or delay and laches
should be considered with reference to the original
cause of action and not with reference to the date on
which an order is passed in compliance with a court’s
-7-
direction. Neither a court’s direction to consider a
representation issued without examining the merits,
nor a decision given in compliance with such
direction, will extend the limitation, or erase the
delay and laches.
16.
A
court
or
tribunal,
before
directing
“consideration” of a claim or representation should
examine whether the claim or representation is with
reference to a “live” issue or whether it is with
reference to a “dead” or “stale” issue. If it is with
reference to a “dead” or “stale” issue or dispute, the
court/tribunal should put an end to the matter and
should not direct consideration or reconsideration. If
the
court
or
tribunal
deciding
to
direct
“consideration” without itself examining the merits,
it should make it clear that such consideration will be
without prejudice to any contention relating to
limitation or delay and laches. Even if the court does
not expressly say so, that would be the legal position
and effect.”
11.
Other
than
the
aforesaid,
in
M.K.
Sarkar
(supra), it has been categorically held that once, the
petitioner chose to remain under the Contributory Provident
Fund Scheme, more importantly, received the entire PF
amount on his retirement and the validity period of the
option to switch over to pension scheme stood expired there
was
no
recurring
or
continuing
cause
of
action.
The
petitioner’s first original application filed before the Central
-8-
Administrative
Tribunal
(CAT)
and
the
subsequent
representation
made in pursuance to the order of the
Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) in the case at hand,
seeking an option to shift to pension scheme ought to have
been straightaway rejected, as barred by limitation/delay
and laches.
12.
Lastly it is contended on behalf of the writ
petitioner that on recommendations made by the 4th Central
Pay Commission, the Government of India, vide OM dated
01.05.1987 gave an option to the employees, who were in
service on 01.01.1986 to continue under the CPF Scheme or
shift to the GPF-cum-Pension Scheme, if they, so desired.
The option was to be exercised and conveyed to the
concerned Head Office by 30.09.1987. Admittedly OM dated
01.05.1987
was
only
applicable
to
Civilian
Central
Government Employees, who were subscribing to the CPF
under the Contributory Provident Fund Rules (India) 1962.
13.
KVS
is
an
autonomous
body.
Statutory/
autonomous employees were not automatically covered in
the aforesaid OM dated 01.05.1987.
It is only in 51st
Meeting of the Board of Governor of the KVS held on
-9-
31.05.1988, it was decided that KVS shall implement mutatis
mutandis the change-over from CPF to Pension Scheme in
the manner indicated in OM dated 01.05.1987. The same
was done vide OM KVS dated 01.09.1988, wherein the date
of giving option was stipulated as 31.01.1989 before the
Head Office/Principal and to reach the Sangathan Office by
28.02.1989.
14.
Before the CAT, KVS Circular Dated 14.02.1989
has been placed (Annexure R-2, Page 65 of the writ paper
book, part of Annexure P-7 filed with Writ Petition).
At
Page-66 of the writ paper book has been placed as Anneuxre
R-3 (Part of Annexure P-7) document wherefrom, it is
evident that circular dated 14.02.1989, was duly circulated
and noted by the employees.
Signature to this effect, i.e.,
acknowledgement by the petitioner, exists in the writ petition
at Page 65 of the writ paper book. It is in pursuance thereto
that option was exercised on 27.02.1989 by the writ
petitioner. Hence, from the aforesaid, it is evident that the
petitioner in the case at hand only became aware of the OM
dated 01.09.1988 after 14.02.1989, when the latter was
circulated and it is hence that an option was exercised by the
petitioner on 27.02.1989.
-10-
15.
In
the
aforesaid
facts
and
attending
circumstances, the contention of the writ petitioner that the
option in the case at hand had been exercised by the
petitioner on 27.02.1989 much later than the cut-off-date is
not correct as in the case of KVS the change over was only
implemented vide KVS OM dated 01.09.1988, wherein the
cut-off date was 31.01.1989
before the Principal and to
reach the Sangathan, the date fixed was 28.02.1989 (See
Clause 3.2 of OM Dated 01.09.1988 Annexure P-1). In the
aforesaid peculiar facts and circumstances,
whereupon
reliance
have
been
placed
judgments
are
clearly
distinguishable on facts.
16.
In
the
aforesaid
facts
and
attending
circumstances, the present petition is dismissed being devoid
of merit. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, also
stand disposed of.
(G.S. Sandhawalia)
Chief Justice
30th May, 2026
(Gaurav Rawat)
(Bipin Chander Negi)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review