Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~77 & 78
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 09th January, 2026
%
+
RSA 5/2026, CM APPL. 1377/2026, CM APPL. 1378/2026, CM
APPL. 1379/2026 & CM APPL. 1380/2026
BALA DUTT SHARMA
C-888, DDA LIG Flats
East of Loni Road,
Delhi-110093
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Pawan Sharma, Advocate
versus
DAV PUBLIC SCHOOL
East of Loni Road,
Delhi-110093
Through:
.....Respondent
Counsel for Respondent (Appearance
not given)
+
RSA 6/2026, CM APPL. 1381/2026, CM APPL. 1382/2026, CM
APPL. 1383/2026 & CM APPL. 1384/2026
BALA DUTT SHARMA
C-888, DDA LIG Flats
East of Loni Road,
Delhi-110093
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Pawan Sharma, Advocate
versus
DAV PUBLIC SCHOOL
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:27:12
RSA 5/2026 & RSA 6/2026
East of Loni Road,
Delhi-110093
Through:
.....Respondent
Counsel for Respondent (Appearance
not given)
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M E N T (oral)
1.
Regular Second Appeals under Section 100 read with Section 151 of
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as ‘CPC’) has
been filed on behalf of the Appellant against the Judgment dated 14.08.2025
in RCA DJ No. 60/2025 whereby the learned District Judge has upheld the
Order of the learned Senior Civil Judge dated 20.01.2012 whereby a decree
in the sum of Rs.1,44,008/- has been passed, against the Appellant, and
similarly, against the Judgment dated 14.08.2025 in RCA DJ No.
20/2024,whereby the learned District Judge has upheld the Order of the
learned Civil Judge dated 21.11.2023 whereby a decree in the sum of
Rs.36,236/- has been passed, against the Appellant.
2.
Briefly stated, two Suits for Recovery in the sum of Rs.1,44,008/-
and Rs.36,236/- alongwith pendente lite interest, were filed by the
Respondent-DAV Public School against the Appellant. As per the Plaintiff,
Masters Rishabh Bharadwaj and Yash Bhardwaj, sons of the Appellant were
studying in the school of the Plaintiff since 2009-10 and 2006 respectively,
and had been getting regular education. It was claimed that the DefendantAppellant was a chronic defaulter in payment of school fees and had not
deposited the fee for the last five years in the case of Master Rishabh and six
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:27:12
RSA 5/2026 & RSA 6/2026
years in case of Master Yash. The sums of Rs.2,64,223/- and Rs.2,48,878/had become due from the Appellant which he had failed to pay despite
repeated requests; rather, he abused the Principal of the school and
pressurised her to admit his son in class XI. When the Principal refused to
do so, he threatened her with the consequences.
3.
Notices for dues was served upon the Appellant, despite which he
failed to make the payment and, therefore, the Suits for Recovery of
Rs.1,44,008/- and Rs.36,236/- alongwith interest, were filed.
4.
The summons of the Suits were served upon the Appellant on
03.11.2019, despite which he failed to file his Written Statement within the
statutory period of 30 days, as per Order VIII Rule 1 CPC. Consequently,
vide Order dated 18.02.2020, the right of the Defendant to file the Written
Statement was closed and the defence was struck off.
5.
Subsequently, the Defendant moved an Application under Section
151 CPC on 12.03.2021 seeking recall of Order dated 18.02.2020 and for
restoration of his right to file the Written Statement. However, this
Application also got dismissed by the learned Trial Court vide Order dated
25.11.2021.
6.
The Plaintiff in his evidence, examined the Principal of the school
as PW-1 who proved the Chart showing pending payment of fee of Master
Rishabh which is Ex. PW-1/2. Legal Notice dated 03.05.2019 is Ex. PW1/3.
7.
PW-2 Sh. Dilip Kumar Rai, Clerk in Accounts Department of the
Plaintiff School, proved the Fee Bill of the student for the year 2017-18 Ex.
PW-2/1 and proved the Chart showing the pending school fee which is
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:27:12
RSA 5/2026 & RSA 6/2026
already Ex. PW-1/2. Both the witnesses were cross-examined at length by
the Counsel for the Defendant.
8.
Even though the defence of the defendant had been struck off on
18.02.2020, the Defendant No. 1 was permitted to examine himself as DW1. He tendered his evidence and was duly cross-examined by the Plaintiff. In
case pertaining to fees of Master Yash, the learned Civil Judge, had taken
into consideration the submissions of the Counsel appearing on behalf of the
Defendant.
9.
After considering the evidence on record, the learned Trial Court
vide Judgment and decree dated 20.04.2023 and 21.11.2023, decreed the
Suit of the Respondent School.
10.
Aggrieved, the Appellant filed the RCA No. 60/2025 and RCA No.
20/2024 wherein the learned District Judge considered all the rival
contentions of the parties and noted that despite receiving the summons of
the Suit on 02.11.2019 and 03.11.2019, he failed to file the Written
Statement and his defence had been struck off.
11.
It was further observed that the Defendant on the dismissal of his
Application for recall of the Order striking off his defence, failed to
challenge the same before the superior Court and the Order dated
25.11.2021 therefore, attained finality. It was further noted that the
testimony of PW-1 and PW-2 fully established the case of the Plaintiff and
therefore, upheld the judgement of the learned SCJ.
12.
Aggrieved by the impugned judgement, the Second Regular Appeal
has been filed wherein it is submitted that there are substantial questions of
law raised in the Second Appeal which are that the first Appellate Court did
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:27:12
RSA 5/2026 & RSA 6/2026
not appreciate the fact of the Appellant’s right to defence had been struck off
and he could not lead evidence in his proof; that the Appellant had not been
supplied with the documents alongwith the plaint in terms of Order dated
18.02.2020 and that the purpose of Order VIII Rule 1 had not been
construed properly as it is directory and not mandatory.
13.
The rules of procedure had been ignored which has led to a
miscarriage of justice. By striking off the defence of the Appellant, his right
to defend the case and to produce evidence was curtailed and that once the
defence of the Appellant was struck off, he could neither cross-examine the
witnesses of the Plaintiff or lead evidence in his defence.
14.
The grounds of challenge are that it has not been appreciated that
the Appellant is the father of the school student and his right to education
being a fundamental right, the defence of the Appellant was not to have been
struck off.
15.
Reliance is placed on Sushil Kumar Sen vs. State of Bihar (1975) 1
SCC 774 wherein it was held that the rules are hand-made to justice.
Moreover, the timeframe for filing the written statement as given in Order
VIII Rule 1 CPC is directory and not mandatory as held in the judgement of
Kailash vs. Nanhku, (2005) 4 SCC 480 and State of Punjab vs. Shamlal
Murari (1976) 1 SCC 719.
16.
Because the defence of the Appellant was struck off, he was not able
to produce evidence in defence and the statements were in the nature of
factual assertions and could not be proved by leading evidence. The limited
right of cross-examination of the witnesses which was availed by the
Defendant was only to demonstrate that they were not speaking the truth and
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:27:12
RSA 5/2026 & RSA 6/2026
to demolish the case of the Plaintiff as has also been held by the Supreme
Court in Kanchhu vs. Prakash in Civil Appeal No. 5319/2025.
17.
The Suit itself was defective and not maintainable since the school
Principal failed to produce any Board Resolution authorising her to institute
the Suit. Moreover, the documents annexed with the Plaint, were not
supplied ever to the Appellant which is mandatorily required to be served
alongwith the plaint at the time of service of summons, as held by Gujarat
High Court in Yogi Infrastructure vs. RMC Readimix (Special Civil
Application No. 15878 of 2021).
18.
It has not been considered that the right to education is a
fundamental right and such practice of witch-hunting ought to have been
discouraged. The Appellant was a layman and cannot be made to suffer for
the fault of the lawyer. Hence, the prayer is made that the impugned
Judgment and the Order of learned District Judge dated 14.08.2025 be set
aside and an opportunity be given to the Defendant to adduce his evidence.
Submission heard and record perused.
19.
It is a simple case where the school fee of Master Rishabh was not
paid by the Appellant for five years, and more than 6 years in case of Master
Yash Bhardwaj, resulting in filing of the Suit for Recovery of legally
recoverable school fees for three years, by the Respondent School.
20.
The first objection taken by the Appellant was that his defence was
struck off erroneously merely on account of non-filing of Written Statement
within 30 days in terms of Order VIII Rule 1. However, it is pertinent to
note that the defence got struck off on 18.02.2020 and thereafter, his
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:27:12
RSA 5/2026 & RSA 6/2026
Application under Section 151 CPC for recall of this Order was also
dismissed on 25.11.2021.
21.
Pertinently, there is nothing shown on record placed by the
Appellant to explain his reason for not filing the Written Statement in time
except putting a blame on his Counsel. There is no cogent reason shown
even in this Appeal as to why Written Statement was not filed in time.
Merely putting the blame on the Counsel, is not sufficient to challenge the
correctness of the Order dated 18.02.2020.
22.
It is further significant to note that even though the defence of the
Appellant had been struck off, he was given full opportunity to crossexamine PW-1 as well as PW-2 and he also led his own evidence as DW-1,
in the case pertaining to Master Rishabh Bhardwaj. He had absolute
opportunity to challenge the testimony of the Plaintiff witnesses and also to
lead his defence. His assertion that he has been adversely impacted because
his Written Statement was not permitted to be taken on record, is completely
fallacious. Even in the case pertaining to Master Yash, the Counsel on
behalf of the Defendant were heard.
23.
The Plaintiff had examined PW-1, the School Principal who had
proved the school Chart Ex. P-1/2 showing the pending fee of Master
Rishabh Bhardwaj, which was also corroborated by the testimony of PW-2,
Dilip Kumar Rai, the Clerk in Accounts Department of the School.
24.
It had been explained that though the school fee had not been paid
for last five years from 2019 onwards and a sum of Rs.2,64,223/- was due
and payable, but the claim was limited to Rs.1,44,008/- for the period from
01.08.2016 to 2019 due to the limitation period in the case of Master
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:27:12
RSA 5/2026 & RSA 6/2026
Rishabh, while in case of Master Yash, the sum of Rs.2,48,878/- was
outstanding, however due to limitation, the Respondent was entitled to
recover only Rs.36,236/-.
25.
The Appellant has contended that his right to cross-examination,
cross-examination of Plaintiff witnesses was curtailed, but the learned
District Judge has observed correctly that there is nothing to indicate that
any objection was raised during the trial nor does it reflect that Application
was filed by the Appellant to seek recall of the witnesses or for further
cross-examination. The PW-1 and PW-2 were not only cross-examined, but
Appellant even led his evidence as DW-1. The striking of his defence, has
not resulted in any curtailment to prove his defence. These are general
allegations of denial of fair opportunity, which is not demonstrable from the
material on record.
26.
The learned Civil Judge had relied upon the Account Statement Ex.
PW-1/2 to conclude that there was an outstanding fee which had not been
paid. The Defendant on the other side, claimed that he had paid the fee, but
candidly admitted in his cross-examination that he was not in possession of
any fee Receipt. Moreover, he never ever pleaded at any forum about the
Fees having been paid by him. In the Reply to the Legal Notice dated
03.05.2019 Ex.PW-1/5 as well, there was no averment about payment of fee
or non-issuance of the Fee Receipts.
27.
The learned District Judge further noted that the contention that the
contention of the Appellant that the Suit was bad for non-rejoinder of Master
Rishabh Bhardwaj, was devoid of merit as the obligation to pay the school
fee was of the father and not of the child. A minor student being
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:27:12
RSA 5/2026 & RSA 6/2026
incompetent to contract under law, cannot be treated as a independent
contracting party to such an arrangement. The liability to discharge
outstanding fee rested squarely with the Appellant.
28.
The Appellant had further taken a defence that the Transfer
Certificate was issued in the name of the child. It was contended that no
Transfer Certificate could have been issued without clearance of school fee.
However, PW-1 in her testimony deposed that the Transfer Certificate was
an act of fairness aimed at ensuring academic continuity of the child and did
not in any way signify a waiver of the Plaintiff school’s claims. In the
absence of any evidence produced by the Appellant of having paid the
school fee as claimed by him, it was rightly concluded that the Plaintiff
school was entitled to the suit amount.
29.
Another contention was raised on behalf of the Appellant that PW-1,
School Principal had no authority to institute the suit. However, the
Authority letter Ex. PW-1/1 was proved in the testimony of PW-1. This
objection of the Appellant is also without merit.
30.
In the end, the learned Counsel for the Appellant has vehemently
contended that this Suit amounts to infringement of the fundamental right of
the child to education. The right to education is a fundamental right, but it is
subject to reasonable restrictions. The school had undertaken to provide the
education subject to payment of school fee. When there is no School Fee
paid, the Appellant cannot claim an absolute right. Rather, it emerges that
the School being cognizant of the Child’s right to Education and that he may
not unnecessily suffer, had continued the children in the School for five and
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:27:12
RSA 5/2026 & RSA 6/2026
six years respectively, despite non payment of School Fees; so much so that
Transfer Certificate was also issued despite the outstanding Fees.
31.
It was also contended that there was an unreasonable fee hike done
by the School against which various Complaints had been filed by the
Appellant and the Suit for Recovery is a counterblast to his multiple
Complaints. The Appellant may have filed various complaints, but he has
not been able to in any way prove that he had paid the school fee thereby
entitling the school to recover the Fee by way of the Suit.
32.
The learned District Judge has rightly appreciated the entire
evidence to uphold the judgement of the learned Civil Judge dated
20.04.2023 and 21.11.2023 whereby the Suits of Plaintiff has been decreed
in the sum of Rs.1,44,008/- and Rs.36,236/- respectively, along with interest
and costs.
33.
There is no merit in the present Appeals, which are hereby
dismissed alongwith pending Applications.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
JANUARY 9, 2026
N
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:27:12
RSA 5/2026 & RSA 6/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review