Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
M.A. No. 30 of 2026
Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Company Limited, Address- Pranami
Heights, 5th Floor, Circular Road, Near Lalpur Chowk, PO & PSLalpur, Ranchi-834001, represented through Rimpi Banerjee, (aged
about 27 years), d/o Sri U.K. Banerjee, its duly authorized signatory
posted as Legal Executive, Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Company
Ltd., 501, 502, 5th Floor, Pranami Heights, Circular Road, near Lalpur
Chowk, Lalpur, P.O. & P.S. Lalpur, Ranchi – 8340011.
(Insurer of Vehicle JH-19D-5854)
...
Opposite Party No.2/Appellant
-Versus1. Karmi Devi, W/o Late Devmohan Korba,
2. Sandeep Korwa, S/o Late Devmohan Korba,
3. Sanoj Korba, D/o Late Devmohan Korba,
4. Raj Korwa, S/o Late Devmohan Korba,
5. Muskan Kumari, D/o Late Devmohan Korba,
6. Mangaldev Korwa, S/o Late Atwa Korwa,
7. Mulli Devi, W/o Mangaldevi Korwa,
(Respondent nos. 2 to 5 being minors and thus are represented
through their mother and natural guardian i.e. respondent no. 1
herein)
Respondent nos. 1 to 7 are residents of Village- Chulhamati,
P.O. Sarango, P.S. Ghaghra, Sarango, Bishunpur Ghaghra,
District-Gumla.
……. Claimants/Respondents
8. Md. Ekuram, S/o Hanif Miya,
Resident of Tilaiya Tand, P.O. & P.S.- Chandwa, District- Latehar,
Pin Code- 829 203.
(Owner of Vehicle bearing registration no. JH-19D-5854)
Jharkhand.
……. Opposite Party No.1/Respondent
CORAM:
For the Appellant:
For the Respondents:
03/Dated: 08.05.2026
--------HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
--------Mr Pratyush Kumar, Advocate
Ms Taru Gupta, Advocate
Mr Vishwajeetjee Chaturvedi, Advocate
Mr Abhijeet Kumar Singh, Advocate
Mr Vikas Kumar, Advocate
Mr Agnivesh, Advocate
---------
1. Heard the learned counsel for the parties.
2. With the consent of and at the request of learned counsel for the
parties, the appeal is taken up for final disposal. This is more so
because records and proceedings have been called and are
available.
3. This appeal challenges judgment and award dated 25th August of
2025 made by Motor Accident Claims Tribunal at Ranchi, awarding
the respondents-claimants compensation of Rs. 31,08,000/- with
interest @ 7.5% per annum from the date of filing of the claim
petition i.e. 21.02.2023 till the date of actual payment.
4. Mr Pratyush Kumar learned counsel for the appellant-Insurance
Company firstly submitted that there was clear evidence of the
deceased Devmohan Korba being intoxicated at the time of the
fatal accident with the insured vehicle. He submitted that this was
admitted by AW.1, the deceased's widow, during her crossexamination.
5. Mr Pratyush Kumar submitted that, given the above admission, no
liability should have been fixed on the driver of the insured vehicle
and, consequently, the appellant Insurance Company. In any
event, without prejudice, Mr Pratyush Kumar submitted that this
was a case of contributory negligence by the deceased and the
compensation awarded should be proportionately reduced.
6. Mr Pratyush Kumar further submitted that there was no evidence
about the deceased having a monthly income of Rs. 15,000/-. He
submitted that the Minimum Wages Notification, which was
referred to in the impugned judgment and award, refers to the
monthly income of Rs. 11987.40/- He submitted that the Tribunal
erred in rounding off this figure to Rs. 15,000/- per month.
Accordingly, he submitted that the compensation determined is
excessive and does not represent ‘just compensation’.
7. Mr Pratyush Kumar submitted that the deduction of only 1/5th or
20% towards personal expenses of the deceased is also improper
and contrary to the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the Case of Sarla Verma and Others Versus Delhi Transport
Corporation and Anr, (2009) 6 SCC 121. He submitted that in the
present case, the father of the deceased should not have been
counted as a dependent. In any event, since there were six
dependent family members, the deduction should have been 1/4th,
not merely 1/5th.
8. On the above grounds and no others, Mr Pratyush Kumar
submitted that the impugned judgment and award warrant
interference.
9. Mr Abhijeet Kumar Singh, learned counsel for the respondents-
claimants, defended the impugned judgment and award based on
the reasoning reflected therein. However, he pointed out that
towards loss of consortium, only Rs. 48,000/- had been awarded.
Relying on Magma General Insurance Co. Versus Nanu Ram,
(2018) 18 SCC 130, he submitted that a compensation of Rs.
48,000/- should have been awarded to each of the claimants and
not merely Rs. 48,000/- towards loss of consortium for all the six
claimants.
10. Mr Abhijeet Kumar Singh submitted that the deceased was merely
crossing the road and received fatal injuries on account of the
insured motor vehicle driver driving the motorcycle in a rash and
negligent manner. He pointed out that the FIR, followed by a
charge sheet, was filed against the driver of the motorcycle.
11. Mr Abhijeet Kumar Singh submitted that the widow’s evidence
must be read holistically. He submitted that she had admitted that
she was not present at the accident site. He also pointed out that
Ext. 3 – The post-mortem report did not show any traces of alcohol
and other intoxicating substances. Therefore, he submitted that the
finding of rashness and negligence on the part of the motorcycle
driver warrants no interference. He submitted that it was not a case
of any contributory negligence as now urged.
12. For all the above reasons, Mr Abhijeet Kumar Singh submitted that
this appeal may be dismissed but only after modifying the award
and awarding additional compensation of Rs. 2,40,000/-.
13. The rival contentions now fall for my determination.
14. The present claim petition has been filed by the widow (aged about
32 years), her four minor children (aged about 15, 07, 04, and 11
months, respectively), and the parents, aged about 58 and 52
years. This claim petition was filed on account of the demise of late
Devmohan Korba, who was aged about 39 years when the
accident took place on 08.11.2022, when the deceased was
crossing the road and the insured motorcycle bearing Registration
No. JH-19D-5854 dashed against Devmohan Korba, resulting into
the fracture of his right leg and severe multiple injuries on the head
and body. Devmohan Korba succumbed to the injuries while on the
way to the hospital.
15. Given the rival contentions, the following points arise for
determination in this appeal: (i)
Whether the accident took place on account of the
intoxication of Devmohan Korba, or due to the rash and
negligent driving by the driver of the insured motorcycle?
(ii)
In any event, has the appellant made out any case of
contributory
negligence
on
the
part
of
deceased
Devmohan Korba?
(iii)
Whether the income of late Devmohan Korba was
correctly assessed at Rs. 15,000/- per month by the
Tribunal?
(iv)
Whether the deduction towards personal expenses of the
deceased should have been 1/4th and not 1/5th as
determined by the Tribunal?
(v)
Whether the amount of Rs. 48,000/- awarded to the
claimants towards loss of consortium is required to be
enhanced in view of the judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of Magma General
Insurance Company (supra)?
16. So far, points nos. (i) and (ii) for determination are concerned, the
Tribunal framed issue no. 3, which reads as follows:“3. Whether death of Deo Mohan Khotwa @ Devmohan
Korwa
was
result
of
road
traffic
accident
dated
08/11/2022 involving a motorcycle bearing Reg. No. JH19D-5854? Is it a case of contributory negligence?”
17. The appellant has relied upon the deposition of AW.1, who is the
widow of deceased Devmohan Korba. From her deposition, it is
apparent that she was a rustic housewife who was admittedly not
present at the time of the accident. AW.1, in her chief, has
deposed that her husband had a licence to drive a heavy vehicle.
She also deposed that he used to carry his smart card driving
licence. She deposed that her husband must have been carrying
such a licence with him at the time of the accident, but, owing to
the accident, she could not trace it. She has also deposed that she
searched for the licence at home and could find an old driving
licence, which she was producing before the Tribunal.
18. The issue of a deceased possessing a licence is not very relevant
in this matter. Admittedly, the accident took place when the
deceased was crossing the road on foot. AW.1, in her chief
deposed, that the accident took place due to the negligence of the
motorcycle driver.
19. In her cross-examination, however, AW.1 admitted that she was
not present at the accident site. She deposed that her husband
used to occasionally have a drink, and even on the date of the
accident, he may have had a drink. She also stated that at the time
of the accident, her husband did not have a driving licence.
However, she denied the suggestion that the accident occurred as
a result of any mistake on her husband’s part.
20. Now the evidence of AW.1 must be considered holistically. Firstly,
she is a rustic widow. Upon the conjoint reading of her chief and
cross-examination, there is no scope to conclude that the
deceased had no licence. In any event, the licence issue is quite
irrelevant because at the time of the accident, the deceased was
not driving any vehicle; he was merely crossing the road on foot.
21. Based on the statement that the deceased used to occasionally
drink or that he may have had a drink on the date of the accident,
no case of either negligence on the part of the deceased or even
contributory negligence can be said to have been made. The postmortem report was produced in this matter and marked as Ext. 3.
This post-mortem report, which is a part of records and
proceedings, does not refer to any traces of alcohol or other
intoxicating substances.
22. Admittedly, AW.1, the widow, was not present at the accident site.
Therefore, her statement, which speaks about her honesty, cannot
be elevated to the status of her husband being a drunk or habitual
drunkard and being drunk at the time of the accident.
23. The burden of establishing contributory negligence lay with the
party asserting it. Here, even the driver of the motorcycle (insured
vehicle) was not examined. There is evidence that an F.I.R. was
lodged against the driver of the motorcycle (insured vehicle),
followed by his prosecution for rash and negligent driving. The
Tribunal accordingly relied on the decisions in National Insurance
Company Ltd. Versus Pushpa Ram, 2007 SCC OnLine Del
1700, and United India Insurance Company Ltd Versus Dipak
Goyal and Others, (2014) 2 AIC 846 Delhi, in which it was held
that when an F.I.R. is lodged and a charge-sheet is filed, such
documents are ordinarily sufficient to establish that the driver of the
vehicle was driving rashly and negligently.
24. The evidence in this case shows the impact of the accident on the
deceased, who sustained multiple injuries, including fractures. The
deceased died while being transferred to the hospital. The Tribunal
has therefore correctly invoked the principle of res ipsa loquitur. All
this, coupled with the fact that the driver of the motorcycle who
caused the accident was not examined, is more than sufficient to
hold that the accident in this case was caused solely by the rash
and negligent driving of the driver of the insured motorcycle, and
that there is no material to conclude any contributory negligence.
25. Accordingly, point nos. (i) and (ii) for determination are liable to be
answered against the appellant.
26. So far, point no. (iii) for determination, AW.1 has deposed that her
husband used to drive a heavy vehicle, and further, she has also
disclosed the name of the Truck owner for whom the deceased
used to drive the Truck. In the chief, she has stated that her
husband was a proficient truck driver earning Rs. 35,000/- per
month. Significantly, in the cross-examination, there was not even
any challenge to this statement. Even in the impugned judgment
and award, there was no serious challenge to the income of the
deceased. The Tribunal, after accepting that no documentary
evidence was produced regarding the income, held that there was
sufficient evidence on the record to indicate that the deceased was
a professional driver who possessed a driving licence.
27. After all this, it is not as if the Tribunal accepted that the deceased
was drawing a monthly salary of Rs. 35,000/- but has assessed the
monthly salary at only Rs. 15,000/- per month. In such matters,
some amount of guesswork is inevitable. Similarly, the mere
absence of documentary evidence, particularly regarding persons
working in the unorganised sector, cannot be held against such
persons or their dependents.
28. The accident occurred in 2022. The Minimum Wages Notification,
no doubt, referred to a monthly salary of Rs. 12,000. The Tribunal,
upon cumulative consideration of the material on record, has
determined the monthly salary to be Rs. 15,000/- per month. There
is nothing unreasonable in such a determination. In fact, such
determination is well within the bounds and range of reasonability.
Accordingly, no case is made out to interfere with the Tribunal's
determination.
29. This point no. (iii) for the determination is also answered against
the appellant.
30. As regards point no. (iv) for determination, Mr Pratush Kumar
relied upon paragraphs 30 and 31 of Sarla Verma (supra) which
read as follows: “30. Though in some cases the deduction to be made towards
personal and living expenses is calculated on the basis of units
indicated in Trilok Chandra [(1996) 4 SCC 362], the general practice
is to apply standardised deductions. Having considered several
subsequent decisions of this Court, we are of the view that where the
deceased was married, the deduction towards personal and living
expenses of the deceased, should be one-third (1/3rd) where the
number of dependent family members is 2 to 3, one-fourth (1/4th)
where the number of dependent family members is 4 to 6, and onefifth (1/5th) where the number of dependent family members exceeds
six.
31. Where the deceased was a bachelor and the claimants are the
parents, the deduction follows a different principle. In regard to
bachelors, normally, 50% is deducted as personal and living
expenses, because it is assumed that a bachelor would tend to spend
more on himself. Even otherwise, there is also the possibility of his
getting married in a short time, in which event the contribution to the
parent(s) and siblings is likely to be cut drastically. Further, subject
to evidence to the contrary, the father is likely to have his own income
and will not be considered as a dependant and the mother alone will
be considered as a dependant. In the absence of evidence to the
contrary, brothers and sisters will not be considered as dependants,
because they will either be independent and earning, or married, or
be dependent on the father.”
31. In this case, the number of dependent family members exceeds
six. Therefore, there was nothing wrong in the Tribunal deducting
1/5th of the annual or monthly income for the purposes of
determining compensation towards dependency.
32. Mr Pratyush Kumar, however, submitted that paragraph 31 of the
Sarla Verma (supra) provides that a father cannot be regarded as
a dependent and therefore, the number of dependents should be
taken at six and not seven.
33. In paragraph 31, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that, subject to
evidence to the contrary, the father's own income will not be
considered as dependent, and the mother alone can be considered
as dependent. In this case, there is no evidence that the father had
any
independent
income.
Neither
the
appellant-Insurance
Company nor any other respondents to the claim petition asserted
that the father had any independent income and, therefore, would
not qualify as a dependent. If such assertions had been made in
the pleadings, the father might have been required to step into the
witness box and show that he had no independent income and
was dependent on the deceased's income. On this basis, even
point (iv) for determination will have to be decided against the
appellant-Insurance Company.
34. Point No. (v) for determination, however, will have to be answered
in favour of the claimants. In the case of Magma General
Insurance Company (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court held
that compensation for consortium must be awarded to each of the
claimants. Here, the Tribunal has awarded only Rs. 48,000/- as
compensation to the consortium. This means that compensation
has been awarded to only one of the claimants, not to all. An
amount of Rs. 2,88,000/- must therefore be further awarded to
ensure consortium compensation for each of the claimants.
35. It is the duty of the Tribunal and, consequently, this Court, to
determine and award 'just compensation’. Such an award does not
depend upon any claim by the claimants. It is well settled that the
Tribunal may award compensation in excess of what may be
claimed by the claimants, because it is the duty of the Tribunal to
determine and award just compensation.
36. This court, hearing an appeal against the Tribunal’s judgment and
award, is also not precluded from awarding just compensation to
the claimants. Accordingly, the appellant-Insurance Company’s
appeal is liable to be dismissed and is hereby dismissed. However,
the compensation amount is enhanced from Rs. 31,08,000/- to Rs.
33,96,000/-. The appellant-Insurance Company is directed to
deposit the enhanced compensation amount in this Court within
four weeks from today. The statutory deposit amount can be
adjusted while making such a deposit. The other directions in the
impugned award remain unaltered.
37. The appellant-Insurance Company has deposited the already
awarded amount in this Court. Accordingly, the Registry should
transfer this amount to the respondents-claimants via bank
transfers, i.e., RTGS/NEFT.
38. The learned counsel for the respondents-claimants must furnish
bank and identity details to enable the Registry to transfer this
amount, together with interest, if any, that shall have accrued on
this amount.
39. The
directions
for
apportionment
and
investment
remain
unchanged. The same will have to be complied with. The Registry,
when transferring this amount, must take note of such directions in
the impugned award dated 25.08.2025.
40. The Registry should also allow the respondents-claimants to now
withdraw the statutory amount and enhanced compensation
amount once the same is deposited in this Court within four weeks
from today. Necessary intimation should be given to the learned
counsel for the respondents-claimants when depositing this
additional amount.
41. The registry should transfer the original amount and any additional
amount to the respondents-claimants via bank transfers. In this
matter, under no circumstances should the amount be transferred
to the claimants other than through regular banking channels.
42. The appeal is disposed of in the above terms without any order for
costs.
(M. S. Sonak, C.J.)
May 08, 2026
A.F.R.
Manoj/Sharda/Cp.2
Uploaded on 11.05.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review