Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
#
+
#
+
#
+
#
+
Reserved on: 24.07.2026
Date of decision: 05.10.2026
CNR No : DLHC010492542019
W.P.(C) 13468/2019
MANOJ DHIRYAN
versus
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
CNR No : DLHC010493792019
W.P.(C) 13469/2019 & CM APPL. 28229/2020
ANSHU KAPOOR
versus
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
CNR No : DLHC010492852019
W.P.(C) 13471/2019 & CM APPL. 1483/2023
VAIBHAV MISHRA AND ORS.
versus
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
#
+
.....Respondents
.....Petitioner
.....Respondents
.....Petitioners
.....Respondents
CNR No : DLHC010491902019
W.P.(CRL) 3522/2019, CRL.M.A. 147/2020, CRL.M.A. 6521/2020
& CRL.M.A. 3809/2023
NABILA HASAN & ORS.
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ANR.
#
+
.....Petitioner
CNR No : DLHC010496652019
W.P.(CRL) 3539/2019
BAHADUR ABBAS NAQVI & ORS.
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
.....Petitioners
.....Respondents
.....Petitioners
.....Respondents
CNR No : DLHC010100702019
W.P.(CRL) 414/2020
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
MD. MINHAJUDDIN
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
.....Petitioner
.....Respondents
#
+
CNR No : DLHC010126682020
W.P.(CRL) 472/2020 & CRL.M.A. 5667/2020
SHAYAAN MUJEEB
.....Petitioner
versus
STATE & ORS.
.....Respondents
#
+
CNR No : DLHC010141192020
W.P.(CRL) 575/2020
MD MUSTAFA
versus
STATE & ORS.
.....Petitioner
.....Respondents
MEMO OF APPEARANCE FOR PETITIONER(S)
Mr. Salman Khurshid, Sr. Adv. with Mr. Bilal Anwar Khan, Adv.
with Petitioner in Person. In W.P.(C) 13469/2019
Ms. Indira Jai Singh, Sr. Adv. with Ms. Nanita Sharma, Mr. Vivek
Sharma, Mr. Deepak Sinha & Mr. Paras Nath Singh, Advs., Mr. K.K.
Mishra, Additional Standing Counsel for JMI in W.P.(C) 13471/2019
Mr. Kushal Bhattacharya with Mr. Meherdeep Chaurasia, Advs.
Mr. K.K. Mishra, Additional Standing Counsel for JMI. In W.P.(C)
13471/2019
Mr. Colin Gonsalves, Sr. Adv. with Mr. Kamran Khwaja, Advs. in
W.P.(CRL) 3522/2019, W.P.(CRL) 3539/2019, W.P.(CRL) 414/2020,
W.P.(CRL) 472/2020 & W.P.(CRL) 575/2020
MEMO OF APPEARANCE FOR RESPONDENT(S)
Mr. S.V. Raju, ASG with Mr. Rajat Nair (SPP), Mr. Dhruv Pande &
Mr. Shivanshu Tripathi and Mr. Akshaja Singh, Advs. for State in
W.P.(C) 13469/2019, W.P.(C) 13471/2019, W.P.(CRL) 3522/2019,
W.P.(CRL) 3539/2019, W.P.(CRL) 414/2020, W.P.(CRL) 472/2020,
W.P.(CRL) 575/2020
Mr. K.K. Mishra, Additional Standing Counsel for JMI. in W.P.(C)
13469/2019, W.P.(CRL) 3539/2019, W.P.(CRL) 3522/2019,
W.P.(CRL) 414/2020, W.P.(CRL) 472/2020, W.P.(CRL) 575/2020
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
Mr. Harsh Prabhakar, Mr. Yash Kotak and Mr. Dhruv Choudhary,
Advs. for R-23 in W.P.(C) 13469/2019
Insp. Kamal Kumar with SI Gulab Singh, ISC, Crime Branch, New
Delhi. in W.P.(C) 13469/2019, W.P.(C) 13471/2019, W.P.(CRL)
3522/2019, W.P.(CRL) 3539/2019
Mr. Rakesh Kumar, SPC, with Mr. Sunil, Adv. for UOI. In W.P.(C)
13471/2019
Mr. Sandeep Kumar Mahapatra, (CGSC) with Ms. Mrinmayee Sahu,
Mr. Tribhuvan & Mr. Abhimanya Asija, Advs. for R-1. In W.P.(CRL)
3522/2019
Mr. B. Badrinath & Mr. Dhruv Bhardwaj, Advs. for R- 6 in
W.P.(CRL) 414/2020, W.P.(CRL) 472/2020
Mr. B. Badrinath, Adv. for R-5 in W.P.(CRL) 575/2020
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIVEK CHAUDHARY
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ JAIN
JUDGMENT
INTRODUCTION
1.
The present batch of petitions invoke writ jurisdiction of this Court,
seeking appropriate directions against the respondents. Though instituted by
different petitioners and seeking diverse reliefs, all the petitions arise out of
the events that occurred at and around Jamia Millia Islamia University in the
backdrop of the enactment of the CAA1 and proposed NRC2, and raise
substantially common questions, thus, all these petitions are being disposed
of by this common judgment.
2.
There are eight petitions that forms part of the present batch. Certain
part of the petitions also refers to the events of violence occurred at the
Aligarh Muslim University. However, in the aftermath of the incidents at
Jamia Millia Islamia University and Aligarh Muslim University, the
Citizenship Amendment Act, 2019.
National Register of Citizens.
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
aggrieved approached the Supreme Court, wherein, vide Order dated
17.12.2019 in W.P. (Criminal) No.370/2019 titled as Alumni Association,
Jamia Millia Islamia University & Ors. vs. Union of India & Ors., the
Supreme Court declined to constitute a single committee to inquire into the
incidents, as they took place at different places and involved different sets of
facts and circumstances, and that it would be inappropriate for the Supreme
Court to undertake such a fact-finding exercise in exercise of its writ
jurisdiction. The Court accordingly left it open to the petitioners to approach
the concerned High Courts having territorial jurisdiction over the respective
incidents.
3.
In pursuance thereof, the aggrieved persons of the Aligarh Muslim
University approached the Allahabad High Court in Criminal Misc. Writ
Petition No. 26085 of 2019, titled as Mohd. Aman Khan v. Union of India
& Ors., against the alleged police action at the University campus on
15.12.2019. The Division Bench declined to constitute a Special
Investigating Team at that stage and the NHRC3 was requested to undertake
a complete inquiry/investigation into the issues raised in the writ petition,
with the petition itself being treated as a complaint before the Commission.
Thus, we do not find it appropriate to interfere with the proceedings in
respect of those incidents that occurred at Aligarh Muslim University. The
present proceedings, therefore, are examined on the basis of the material
relating to the incidents at Jamia Millia Islamia University and the
subsequent developments concerning those incidents.
4.
There are various reliefs prayed for in the present batch of petitions.
The gist of such reliefs sought are stated below:
National Human Rights Commission.
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
Sr.
Details of the
No.
Petitions
A.
W.P. (C) No.
13468
of
B.
W.P. (C) No.
13469
of
C.
W.P. (C) No.
13471
of
D.
W.P. (C) No.
3522 of 2019
Reliefs Sought
1.
To direct the Respondent No. 1 to withdraw the
excessive force from the JMI campus.
2.
To establish a judicial commission to enquire
into the JMI tragic episode dated 15.12.2019,
14.12.2019 and 16.12.2019.
3.
To restrain the Respondent No. 1 from taking
any coercive action against the JMI students.
4.
To direct the Respondent No. 1 to compensate
the injured adequately.
1.
An independent judicial Inquiry into the incident
dated 15.12.2019.
2.
Inquiry by the National Human Rights
Commission into the incident dated 15.12.2019.
3.
Medical and financial assistance to the injured
persons and direct the Police not to enter the
University campus without the written permission of
University authorities.
4.
Grant compensation to the victim and direct the
respondents to pay towards the renovation costs of the
damaged University property.
5.
Frame guidelines on use of force that would
govern the conduct of police personnel in such cases.”
1.
Provide free medical aid and humanitarian
assistance to the injured.
2.
Abstain the Respondents from entering the
University without permission of the University
Administration.
3.
No coercive action against the students studying
in Jamia Millia Islamia, New Delhi.
4.
Grant of transportation facilities or alternate
accommodation to the students stranded in University.
5.
Constitute a fact finding committee to probe into
the incidents of violence at the subject University.
1. Respondents to declare on their website the full list
with names of students and residents that were
detained by State Police and paramilitary forces.
2.
Direction to the Respondents to provide detained
persons access to their family members and to legal
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
counsel;
3.
Direction to the Respondents to release all the
students and residents so detained.
4.
Direction to the Respondents to provide instant
and quality medical care to students and staff
detained.
5.
Direction to the Respondents to immediately
cease the violence being inflicted on to the students
and residents of Universities.
6.
Direction to the Respondents to quash any and
all criminal proceedings initiated against students of
the Universities.
7.
Direction to the Respondents to preserve the
CCTV footage of all cameras in and around the
Universities.
8.
Direction to the Respondents to provide
adequate monetary compensation to all persons
detained and/or injured by the Police and paramilitary
forces.
9.
Direction to the Respondents to set up a courtmonitored committee that shall conduct judicial
inquiry into the acts of violence in a time bund
manner.
10. Direction to the Respondents to ensure the safety
of all students within JMI university campuses and to
ensure that no student is forced to leave the campuses.
11. Direction to the Respondents to ensure
reopening of the University.
E.
W.P.
(Crl.)
No. 3539 of
1.
Direction for inquiry against the erring officials
including police personnel conducted by an
independent committee.
2.
Direction
to
the
concerned
State
Government/UT Administration/ Police to forthwith
remove the-illegal blockades in Jamia Millia Islamia
University and Jawaharlal Nehru University.
3.Direction
to
the
State
Government/UT
Administration/Police to immediately withdraw from
the campus of Jamia Millia Islamia University and
Jawaharlal Nehru University.
4.
Direction to the State Government/UT
Administration/Police to not enter any university
campus without the written permission/authorization.
5.
Direction to the State Government/UT
Administration/Police to strictly comply with the
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
requirements of arrest.
6.
Direction to the State Government/UT
Administration/Police- to ensure that proper medical
attention, and care all students injured.
7.
Direction to the State Government/UT
Administration/Police to compensate the students and
protestors injured in the protests.
F.
W.P.
(Crl.)
No. 414 of
G.
W.P.
(Crl.)
No. 472 of
H.
W.P.
(Crl.)
No. 575 of
1.
Direction to the Respondents to bear all the
expenses required in the treatment.
2.
Direction to the Respondents to pay exemplary
compensation commensurate with the qualifications
and future well-being of the petitioner.
3.
Direction to the Respondents to register an FIR
Into the offences committed by police forces.
4.
To set up a court monitored Investigation
committee and/or set up a Special Investigation team
In the present case.
5.
To direct the respondents to provide permanent
job commensurate with the educational qualifications
of the petitioner;
6.
To direct the respondents to pay the costs for the
petition.
1.
Direction to the Respondent herein to pay a
compensation of at least 2 Crore Rupees.
2.
Direction to the Respondents herein to
reimburse the Petitioner.
3.
Direction to the Respondents to bear all the
expenses of the Petitioner required in the treatment in
the future.
4.
Direction to Respondents to register an FIR into
the offences committed by police forces.
5.
Direction to the Respondent to pay the costs of
this petition.
1.
Direction to the Respondent to pay a
compensation of at least 1 Crore Rupees for physical
and mental losses suffered.
2.
Direction to the Respondents to reimburse the
Petitioner.
3.
Direction to the Respondents to bear all the
expenses of the Petitioner required in the treatment in
the future.
4.
Direction to Respondents to immediately register
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
an FIR into the offences committed by police forces.
5.
Direction to the Respondent to pay the costs of
this petition.
5.
A perusal of the reliefs claimed in the present petition shows that,
several prayers no longer survive for adjudication.
6.
At the outset, Mr. S.V. Raju, the learned Additional Solicitor General
for the State stated that a lot of initially sought reliefs have rendered
infructuous. Our attention was also brought to the Order dated 29.11.2022 of
this Court in W.P. (C) 3522 of 2019, wherein Court records:
“Mr. Colin Gonsalves, learned Senior Advocate appearing
on behalf of Ms. Nabila Hasan, the petitioner herein, on
instructions, states that in so far as the prayer clauses a, b,
c, d, e, f, j and k are concerned, the same have been
rendered infructuous, owing to the passage of time. The
said prayers are reproduced herein below:“a. For a writ of mandamus or any other
writ, order, directing the Respondents to
declare on their website the full list with
names of students and residents of Jamia
Milia Islamia University and Aligarh
Muslim University that were detained by
State Police and paramilitary forces;
b. For a writ of mandamus or any other
writ, order, directing the Respondents to
provide detained persons access to their
family members and to legal counsel;
c. For a writ of mandamus or any other
writ, order, directing the Respondents to
release all the students and residents so
detained;
d. For a writ of mandamus or any other
writ, order, directing the Respondents to
provide instant and quality medical care to
students and staff detained and others
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
injured during the violence;
e. For a writ of mandamus or any other
writ, order, directing the Respondents to
immediately cease the violence being
inflicted on to the students and residents of
Universities,
f. For a writ of mandamus or any other writ,
order, directing the Respondents to quash
any and all criminal proceedings initiated
against students of the Universities;
j. For a writ of mandamus or any other writ,
order, directing the Respondents to ensure
the safety of all students within JMI
university campuses and to ensure that no
student is forced to leave the campuses.
k. For a writ of mandamus or any other
writ, order, directing the Respondents to
ensure reopening of the University.”
In this view of the matter, the reliefs that survive for
consideration are as under:“g. For a writ of mandamus or any other
writ, order, directing the Respondents to
preserve the CCTV footage of all cameras in
and around the Universities.
h. For a writ of mandamus or any other
writ, order, directing the Respondents to
provide adequate monetary compensation to
all persons detained and/or injured by the
Police and paramilitary forces.
i. For a writ of mandamus or any other writ,
order, directing the Respondents to set up a
court-monitored committee headed by a
retired High Court or Supreme Court Judge
that shall conduct judicial inquiry into the
acts of violence and arbitrary detentions by
the State Police and Paramilitary Forces in
a time-bound manner;
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
l. For any other order/ direction that this
Hon'ble Court may deem fit.”
Re-notify on 13.12.2022.”
7.
Acceding to the aforesaid, Mr. Colin Gonsalves, Ms. Indira Jaisingh,
Mr. Salman Khurshid and other counsels appearing for the petitioners
submitted that they are confining their arguments to the surviving prayers
seeking (i) constitution of an independent judicial commission, courtmonitored committee, Special Investigation Team (SIT), fact-finding body,
or any other appropriate independent mechanism to inquire into the
incidents in question, particularly the allegations of police excesses and
arbitrary use of force, and to investigate and take appropriate criminal action
in respect of the allegations levelled against police personnel and other
public officials in connection therewith; (ii) compensation, reimbursement
of medical expenses, or any other monetary relief on account of the injuries
suffered, alleged unlawful detentions, damage caused, or violation of their
fundamental and legal rights; (iii) regulation of police action during public
protests and demonstrations within educational institutions, and (iv) any
consequential, incidental, or ancillary directions required to be issued in the
facts of the present case, including relief for preservation of evidence.
8.
It is imperative to note that except the aforesaid, no other relief is
sought or arguments are raised on behalf of the petitioners.
9.
Before adverting to the rival contentions and issues arising in the
petitions, we may take note of the facts, giving rise to the present
proceedings.
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
10.
The CAA was passed by both the Houses of Parliament and received
assent of the President of India on 12.12.2019. It resulted in several
demonstrations and protests in different parts of the country. While the
majority of these protests were peaceful, few such incidents resulted in
violence, damage to public property and disturbance to law and order.
11.
As per petitioners, on 13.12.2019, Members of the Jamia Teachers
Association called for a protest against CAA and the proposed NRC.
Students gathered within the campus of University after Friday prayers,
where members and office-bearers of the Association addressed the
gathering. At around 3:00 p.m., when students sought to march towards
Parliament, police personnel resorted to tear-gas shelling within the vicinity
of university campus. The petitioners allege that several students suffered
injuries and respiratory distress, requiring medical exigency. Students
continued to assemble within the campus to express their opposition to the
CAA and proposed NRC, while protests were also held by local residents
outside the University premises. It is stated that in view of the prevailing
circumstances the University suspended classes and examinations for fifteen
days.
12.
The petitioners further state that on 15.12.2019, when there were no
protest or demonstrations organized by students and the campus was
peaceful, at about 4:00 p.m. police and paramilitary personnel entered the
University campus without any authorization and proceeded to use force
against students present in various academic buildings, including library,
reading rooms and departmental premises. Tear-gas shells were discharged
within the enclosed spaces, causing panic, injuries and breathing difficulties
amongst students and staff. It is further alleged that force was used, in and
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
around the hostels, and even the members of the University’s security staff
were not spared. The police personnel entered student hostels and residential
localities in Jamia Nagar and Batla House, resulting in several students
being subjected to physical assault and intimidation. Furthermore, some
students were publicly paraded on the roads, adjoining the University.
13.
It is further the petitioners’ case that students were detained and taken
to Kalkaji and New Friends Colony Police Stations. They allege that many
of them faced physical violence while being transported and that the
advocates, who arrived at the police stations to render legal assistance, were,
initially, denied access to them. The petitioners further allege that certain
advocates were manhandled and that electronic recordings, allegedly
documenting police conduct were deleted. Reference is made to a social
media post attributed to the Chief Proctor of the University, wherein it was
stated that police personnel had entered the campus without permission and
that students and staff were assaulted.
14.
The petitioners, thus, contended that the police action of 15.12.2019
involved use of excessive and unlawful force within the University campus
and surrounding areas and the entry of police and paramilitary personnel
into the campus was neither authorised by nor undertaken at the request of
the University administration.
15.
It is in this aforesaid backdrop that the present batch of petitions is
placed for consideration before this Court. During the pendency of the
present petitions, the factual and legal backdrop has also gone through
significant developments.
16.
The incidents of 15.12.2019 resulted in registration of criminal cases.
FIR No. 242/2019 was registered at Police Station New Friends Colony
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
under Sections 143, 147, 148, 149, 186, 353, 332, 308, 427, 435, 323, 341,
120B and 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860, along with Sections 3 and 4 of
the Prevention of Damage to Public Property Act, 1984. Likewise, FIR No.
298/2019 was registered at Police Station Jamia Nagar under the same
provisions. Both these matters were subsequently transferred for
investigation to the Special Investigation Team of the Crime Branch, Delhi
Police. Upon completion of the investigation to the extent carried out,
charge-sheets were filed before the competent courts. It has also been
brought to the notice of this Court that arrests were made in connection with
the aforesaid cases and certain facets of the matter are stated to be pending
for further investigation.
17.
Simultaneously, the NHRC received complaint from Ms. Mangal and
Mr. Mathew Jacob regarding detention of 34 students of Jamia Milia Islamia
University. Similar complaints were filed by various person on 16.12.2019,
alleging that one student had died and the police had forcefully entered
University Campus and had brutally beaten up the students. On 20.12.2019,
the officials of the NHRC visited the campus and assessed the alleged
violations.
18.
On 16.01.2020, the petitioner in W.P. (Crl.) No. 3522 of 2019 also
filed a complaint before NHRC having subject as “Representation before
NHRC on behalf of the students of Jamia Milia Islamia, New Delhi”
accompanied with statements of 91 students. After giving due consideration
to the material placed on record, the NHRC vide its report dated 18.05.2020,
found that the protests against the CAA had escalated into large-scale
violence involving arson, destruction of public and private property, and
attacks on police personnel. It found that the assembly had ceased to remain
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
peaceful, thereby necessitating police intervention to restore public order. At
the same time, the Commission noted that certain actions of police and RAF
personnel, particularly within the university library premises, reflected a
lack of restraint, including the use of force against students and the
deployment of tear-gas shells in enclosed spaces. It also recorded lapses on
the part of the university administration in managing the situation and
coordinating with law-enforcement agencies, as well as deficiencies in
intelligence gathering and crowd-control measures by the local police.
Reiterating that the right to protest under Article 19 of the Constitution does
not extend to acts of violence or vandalism, the Commission accepted the
findings of its investigation team and recommended, inter alia,
compensation for injured students, appropriate action against personnel
found responsible for excesses, specialized police training, expeditious
completion of investigations and inquiries and institutional measures to
improve coordination between the University, students and law-enforcement
authorities.
19.
Furthermore, an application under Section 156(3) of the Cr.P.C. was
preferred by Jamia Milia Islamia University on 20.01.2020, which was
dismissed by the learned Court by way of Order dated 03.02.2021, primarily
for want of sanction under Section 197 of Cr.P.C. The said Order remained
unchallenged and, thus, attained finality.
20.
The State vide its affidavit dated 05.05.2023 stated on oath that the
entire CCTV footage of the cameras in and around the university campus
has already been preserved by the state and portions thereof, also formed
part of the chargesheets filed in respect of the cases registered.
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
SUBMISSIONS AND DISCUSSION
21.
We have heard the learned counsel for the parties on the surviving
prayers and perused the material placed on record.
22.
Mr. S.V. Raju, learned ASG, raised a preliminary objection to the
maintainability of the present batch of petitions submitting that except for
the petitioners in W.P. (Crl.) Nos. 414/2020, 472/2020 and 575/2020, none
of the petitioners claim to be direct victims of the incidents in question. He
further submitted that the petitions have been instituted in the form of public
interest litigations and the reliefs sought therein essentially pertained to
criminal investigation, registration of FIRs, prosecution of police officials
and constitution of investigative bodies, which fall squarely within the realm
of criminal law and cannot be agitated through PIL jurisdiction, when such
petitioners are not directly affected.
23.
Learned ASG contended that one of the petitioners i.e. Ms. Nabila
Hasan had herself approached the NHRC raising substantially similar
grievances concerning the incidents of 15.12.2019 and seeking substantially
similar reliefs. Despite actively participating in the proceedings before the
NHRC, the petitioners did not fairly disclose the same while pursuing the
present petitions. It was thus argued that the present proceedings is an
attempt to reagitate issues already examined by a competent statutory body
and are liable to be dismissed on the grounds of suppression of material
facts, misuse of PIL jurisdiction and the availability of alternative statutory
remedies.
24.
Undisputedly, a significant number of petitions have been instituted in
the nature of public interest litigation and the reliefs claimed are not
confined to the enforcement of individual rights of the petitioners but they
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
seek broader directions relating to registration of criminal cases against
public officials, their prosecution, and judicial oversight of such criminal
investigations. The maintainability and scope of such prayers must,
therefore, be examined in light of the settled principles governing the
exercise of public interest jurisdiction in matters arising out of criminal law.
25.
In Janata Dal v. H.S. Chowdhary & Ors., (1992) 4 SCC 305, the
Supreme Court held as under:
“45. ………However, with regard to the various questions
of law, we expressed our view in our earlier order as
follows: (SCC p. 768, para 26)
“Even if there are million questions of law
to be deeply gone into and examined in a
criminal case of this nature registered
against specified accused persons, it is for
them and them alone to raise all such
questions and challenge the proceedings
initiated against them at the appropriate
time before the proper forum and not for
third parties under the garb of public
interest litigants.”
26.
Likewise, in Simranjit Singh Mann v. Union of India & Anr., (1992)
4 SCC 653, the Supreme Court held as below:
“7. …….On first principles we find it difficult to accept Mr
Sodhi's contention that such a public interest litigation
commenced by a leader of a recognised political party who
has a genuine interest in the future of the convicts should
be entertained. In S.P. Gupta v. Union of India [1981 Supp
SCC 87] , Bhagwati, J. observed : (SCC p. 219, para 24)
“But we must be careful to see that the
member of the public, who approaches the
court in cases of this kind, is acting bona
fide and not for personal gain or private
profit or political motivation or other
oblique consideration. The court must not
allow its process to be abused by politicians
and others ….”
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
These observations were made while discussing the
question of „locus standi‟ in public interest litigation. These
words of caution were uttered while expanding the scope of
the „locus standi‟ rule. These words should deter us from
entertaining this petition. This accords with the view
expressed by this Court in Krishna Swami v. Union of India
[(1992) 4 SCC 605 : JT 1992 (5) SC 92].”
27.
The same principle was reiterated by the Supreme Court in Rajiv
Ranjan Singh ‘Lalan’ (VIII) & Anr. v. Union of India & Ors., (2006) 6
SCC 613. The Court cautioned against the tendency to invoke public
interest jurisdiction for the purpose of overseeing criminal investigations or
prosecutions. It found that the criminal justice system is founded upon a
detailed statutory framework which provides its own safeguards, remedies,
and avenues of redress. Ordinarily, criminal law must be allowed to take its
course through the procedures prescribed by law without judicial
intervention in the guise of public interest litigation. The decision serves as a
reminder that the extraordinary jurisdiction of constitutional courts is not
intended to convert them into supervisory authorities over every stage of the
criminal process.
28.
The aforesaid principles also find support from the decision of the
Supreme Court in Tehseen Poonawalla v. Union of India & Anr., (2018) 6
SCC 72. While considering petitions seeking independent investigation and
the constitution of SIT, the Supreme Court sounded a note of caution against
invoking the extraordinary writ jurisdiction of constitutional courts in a
manner that would bypass or supplant the investigative process
contemplated under the ordinary criminal law. The Court declined to
countenance the creation of a parallel investigative mechanism in the
absence of cogent and credible material indicating that the statutory
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
machinery had failed, or was otherwise incapable of discharging its
functions in accordance with law. The decision reiterates that allegations
disclosing the commission of criminal offences, and grievances concerning
their investigation, must ordinarily be pursued through procedures provided
under the criminal law. Recourse to an extraordinary, judicially supervised
investigation cannot be founded merely on apprehensions, conjectures or
assertions in the public domain.
29.
Having noted the aforesaid, we shall now examine the surviving
prayers.
PRAYER SEEKING CONSTITUTION OF AN INDEPENDENT
JUDICIAL COMMISSION, COURT-MONITORED COMMITTEE,
SPECIAL INVESTIGATION TEAM (SIT), FACT-FINDING BODY,
OR ANY OTHER APPROPRIATE INDEPENDENT MECHANISM
30.
The petitioners raised serious concerns with the alleged police
excesses and disproportionate use of force on 13.12.2019 and 15.12.2019 at
Jamia Millia Islamia University. In substance, the prayer is for constitution
of an independent judicial commission, court-monitored committee, Special
Investigation Team, fact-finding body or any other independent mechanism
to inquire into the incidents, particularly the allegations of excessive and
arbitrary use of force by the police, as well as for registration of criminal
cases and independent investigation into the allegations against police
personnel and other public officials.
31.
Ms. Indira Jaising and Mr. Colin Gonsalves, learned senior counsels,
submitted that even according to the stand taken by the Delhi Police in its
counter affidavit, the assembly of protestors was pushed back from the
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
public roads and once the gathering had retreated into the university campus,
there was no occasion for the police to pursue the students inside the
institution. The subsequent entry into the university premises, particularly
the library and other academic facilities, was neither necessary nor justified.
Relying on the statement of the Chief Proctor of Jamia Millia Islamia, who
had stated that no permission had been sought before the police entered the
campus, they submitted that the police entered the university campus
without obtaining permission from the university authorities. They further
submitted that there was no material to demonstrate promulgation of any
order under Section 144 of the Cr.P.C. and that the safeguards governing
dispersal of assemblies and use of force had not been followed. Reliance
was placed upon Sections 46 and 47 of the Cr.P.C., the Model Police
Manual and the judgments of the Supreme Court in Anita Thakur & Ors. v.
State of J&K & Ors., (2016) 15 SCC 525 and Ramlila Maidan Incident, In
Re (2012) 5 SCC 1.
32.
Learned senior counsels further submitted that the NHRC itself had
found that the use of force within the library premises was avoidable and
that the use of tear gas inside the library could have been withheld.
Moreover, the allegations are directed substantially against the police
personnel themselves and, therefore, permitting the police machinery to
inquire into its own conduct would violate the settled principle as no person
can be a judge in his own cause. It was, accordingly, urged that an
independent fact-finding committee headed by a retired Judge of the
Supreme Court or this Court, or alternatively a Special Investigation Team,
be constituted to ascertain the true facts surrounding the incidents.
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
33.
Mr. Mohd. Umar Iqbal Khan, learned counsel appearing for certain
petitioners, adopted these submissions and submitted that the seriousness of
the allegations warrants for an independent inquiry by a neutral body.
34.
Learned ASG, opposing the prayer, submitted that the criminal law
machinery has already been set in motion in respect of the incidents in
question. FIR Nos. 242/2019 and 298/2019 were registered in relation to the
aforesaid incidents, investigation was thereafter entrusted to the Special
Investigation Team of the Crime Branch and charge-sheets have been filed
before the competent criminal courts. The criminal proceedings arising from
the said incidents are presently pending adjudication. It was, therefore,
submitted that directing a parallel or fresh investigation into the same
incidents at this stage would necessarily overlap with proceedings already
pending before jurisdictional courts.
35.
Learned ASG further submitted that although constitutional courts
possess the power to direct investigation by an independent agency, such
power is extraordinary and is to be exercised sparingly, cautiously and only
in exceptional situations where such intervention is necessary to provide
credibility to the investigation, instil confidence in the public mind, do
complete justice or enforce fundamental rights. It was submitted that the
allegations concerning police excesses were also examined by the NHRC,
which submitted its report dated 18.05.2020, and that the said report has not
been challenged by any of the petitioners. It was, therefore, contended that
there was no justification for constituting another fact-finding mechanism
into substantially the same incidents.
36.
Learned ASG also submitted that the question whether the force
employed by the police at any particular stage was justified, would depend
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
upon the circumstances prevailing at the relevant time and could not be
determined merely on the basis of isolated CCTV footage, photographs or
video recordings. It was further submitted that the mere fact that allegations
are directed against police personnel does not render an investigation
incapable of being fair and that no material showing the investigation
conducted was tainted, biased, malafide or incapable of inspiring public
confidence is placed before the Court. On these grounds, learned ASG
submitted that the present prayer be rejected.
37.
We have considered the rival submissions advanced by the parties.
38.
At the outset, it is imperative to note that the power of this Court
under Article 226 to direct an investigation by an independent agency is
undoubtedly wide. However, such power is extraordinary and is to be
exercised sparingly. The law on the subject stands authoritatively settled by
the Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court in State of West Bengal &
Ors. v. Committee for Protection of Democratic Rights, West Bengal &
Ors., (2010) 3 SCC 571. While affirming that the powers conferred upon the
Supreme Court under Article 32 and upon the High Courts under Article 226
are wide enough to direct an investigation by an independent agency, the
Constitution Bench simultaneously cautioned that such extraordinary
jurisdiction is not to be invoked as a matter of course. The said principle has
been consistently reaffirmed in subsequent decisions. In K.V. Rajendran v.
Superintendent of Police, CBCID South Zone, Chennai & Ors., (2013) 12
SCC 480, the Court held as under:
“13. The issue involved herein, is no more res integra. This
Court has time and again dealt with the issue under what
circumstances the investigation can be transferred from the
State investigating agency to any other independent
investigating agency like CBI. It has been held that the
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
power of transferring such investigation must be in rare
and exceptional cases where the court finds it necessary in
order to do justice between the parties and to instil
confidence in the public mind, or where investigation by
the State police lacks credibility and it is necessary for
having “a fair, honest and complete investigation”, and
particularly, when it is imperative to retain public
confidence in the impartial working of the State agencies.
Where the investigation has already been completed and
charge-sheet has been filed, ordinarily superior courts
should not reopen the investigation and it should be left
open to the court, where the charge-sheet has been filed, to
proceed with the matter in accordance with law. Under no
circumstances, should the court make any expression of its
opinion on merit relating to any accusation against any
individual. (Vide Gudalure M.J. Cherian v. Union of India
[(1992) 1 SCC 397] , R.S. Sodhi v. State of U.P. [1994
Supp (1) SCC 143 : 1994 SCC (Cri) 248 : AIR 1994 SC 38]
, Punjab and Haryana High Court Bar Assn. v. State of
Punjab [(1994) 1 SCC 616 : 1994 SCC (Cri) 455 : AIR
1994 SC 1023] , Vineet Narain v. Union of India [(1996) 2
SCC 199 : 1996 SCC (Cri) 264] , Union of India v. Sushil
Kumar Modi [(1996) 6 SCC 500 : AIR 1997 SC 314] ,
Disha v. State of Gujarat [(2011) 13 SCC 337 : (2012) 2
SCC (Cri) 628 : AIR 2011 SC 3168] , Rajender Singh
Pathania v. State (NCT of Delhi) [(2011) 13 SCC 329 :
(2012) 1 SCC (Cri) 873] and State of Punjab v. Davinder
Pal Singh Bhullar [(2011) 14 SCC 770 : (2012) 4 SCC
(Civ) 1034 : AIR 2012 SC 364] .)
14. In Rubabbuddin Sheikh v. State of Gujarat [(2010) 2
SCC 200 : (2010) 2 SCC (Cri) 1006] this Court dealt with
a case where the accusation had been against high officials
of the Police Department of the State of Gujarat in respect
of killing of persons in a fake encounter and Gujarat Police
after the conclusion of the investigation, submitted a
charge-sheet before the competent criminal court. The
Court came to the conclusion that as the allegations of
committing murder under the garb of an encounter are not
against any third party but against the top police personnel
of the State of Gujarat, the investigation concluded by the
State investigating agency may not be satisfactorily held.
Thus, in order to do justice and instil confidence in the
minds of the victims as well of the public, the State police
authority could not be allowed to continue with the
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
investigation when allegations and offences were mostly
against top officials. Thus, the Court held that even if a
charge-sheet has been filed by the State investigating
agency there is no prohibition for transferring the
investigation to any other independent investigating
agency.
15. In State of W.B. v. Committee for Protection of
Democratic Rights [(2010) 3 SCC 571 : (2010) 2 SCC
(Cri) 401] a Constitution Bench of this Court has clarified
that extraordinary power to transfer the investigation from
State investigating agency to any other investigating
agency must be exercised sparingly, cautiously and in
exceptional situations where it becomes necessary to
provide credibility and instil confidence in investigation or
where the incident may have national and international
ramifications or where such an order may be necessary for
doing complete justice and enforcing the fundamental
rights. (See also Ashok Kumar Todi v. Kishwar Jahan
[(2011) 3 SCC 758 : (2011) 2 SCC (Cri) 75 : AIR 2011 SC
1254] .)
16. This Court in Sakiri Vasu v. State of U.P. [(2008) 2
SCC 409 : (2008) 1 SCC (Cri) 440] held : (SCC p. 416,
para 31)
“31. … this Court or the High Court has
power under Article 136 or Article 226 to
order investigation by CBI. That, however,
should be done only in some rare and
exceptional case, otherwise, CBI would be
flooded with a large number of cases and
would find it impossible to properly
investigate all of them.”
(emphasis supplied)
17. In view of the above, the law can be summarised to the
effect that the Court could exercise its constitutional
powers for transferring an investigation from the State
investigating agency to any other independent investigating
agency like CBI only in rare and exceptional cases. Such
as where high officials of State authorities are involved, or
the accusation itself is against the top officials of the
investigating agency thereby allowing them to influence the
investigation, and further that it is so necessary to do
justice and to instil confidence in the investigation or
where the investigation is prima facie found to be
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
tainted/biased.”
39.
Similarly, a three-judge bench in Romila Thapar v. Union of India,
(2018) 10 SCC 753, reiterated that constitutional courts should be cautious
in replacing the investigative mechanisms established under law merely
because allegations of bias have been raised and held as under:
“27. This Court in Divine Retreat Centre v. State of Kerala
[Divine Retreat Centre v. State of Kerala, (2008) 3 SCC
542 : (2008) 2 SCC (Cri) 9], has enunciated that the High
Court in exercise of its inherent jurisdiction cannot change
the investigating officer in the midstream and appoint an
investigating officer of its own choice to investigate into a
crime on whatsoever basis. The Court made it amply clear
that neither the accused nor the complainant or informant
are entitled to choose their own investigating agency, to
investigate the crime, in which they are interested. The
Court then went on to clarify that the High Court in
exercise of its power under Article 226 of the Constitution
can always issue appropriate directions at the instance of
the aggrieved person if the High Court is convinced that
the power of investigation has been exercised by the
investigating officer mala fide.”
40.
Equally, the criminal justice system itself contains mechanisms both
for investigation and for redressal against inaction. The Supreme Court
while examining the statutory provisions in Sakiri Vasu v. State of Uttar
Pradesh & Ors., (2008) 2 SCC 409, held as under:
“25. We have elaborated on the above matter because we
often find that when someone has a grievance that his FIR
has not been registered at the police station and/or a
proper investigation is not being done by the police, he
rushes to the High Court to file a writ petition or a petition
under Section 482 CrPC. We are of the opinion that the
High Court should not encourage this practice and should
ordinarily refuse to interfere in such matters and relegate
the petitioner to his alternating remedy, first under Section
154(3) and Section 36 CrPC before the police officers
concerned, and if that is of no avail, by approaching the
Magistrate concerned under Section 156(3).
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
26. If a person has a grievance that his FIR has not been
registered by the police station his first remedy is to
approach the Superintendent of Police under Section
154(3) CrPC or other police officer referred to in Section
36 CrPC. If despite approaching the Superintendent of
Police or the officer referred to in Section 36 his grievance
still persists, then he can approach a Magistrate under
Section 156(3) CrPC instead of rushing to the High Court
by way of a writ petition or a petition under Section 482
CrPC. Moreover, he has a further remedy of filing a
criminal complaint under Section 200 CrPC. Why then
should writ petitions or Section 482 petitions be
entertained when there are so many alternative remedies?
27. As we have already observed above, the Magistrate has
very wide powers to direct registration of an FIR and to
ensure a proper investigation and for this purpose he can
monitor the investigation to ensure that the investigation is
done properly (though he cannot investigate himself). The
High Court should discourage the practice of filing a writ
petition or petition under Section 482 CrPC simply
because a person has a grievance that his FIR has not been
registered by the police, or after being registered, proper
investigation has not been done by the police. For this
grievance, the remedy lies under Sections 36 and 154(3)
before the police officers concerned, and if that is of no
avail, under Section 156(3) CrPC before the Magistrate or
by filing a criminal complaint under Section 200 CrPC and
not by filing a writ petition or a petition under Section 482
CrPC.
28. It is true that alternative remedy is not an absolute bar
to a writ petition, but it is equally well settled that if there
is an alternative remedy the High Court should not
ordinarily interfere.”
41.
The present case has to be examined in the aforesaid backdrop. The
incidents that form the basis of the present proceedings took place in
December 2019. More than six years have passed since then. In respect of
incidents, criminal investigation has undertaken pursuant to FIR Nos.
242/2019 and 298/2019. The investigation was conducted by a Special
Investigation Team of the Crime Branch, following which charge sheets
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
have been filed before the competent courts and the proceedings are
presently pending adjudication.
42.
Equally significant is the fact that the allegations relating to police
excesses at Jamia Millia Islamia University were not left without scrutiny.
The NHRC received complaints concerning the incidents of 15.12.2019,
including allegations of unlawful police action against students. The
petitioner in W.P. (Crl.) No. 3522 of 2019 had also approached the NHRC
and submitted detailed representations, accompanied by statements of
students and other supporting material. Pursuant to the receipt of the said
complaints, the NHRC constituted an investigation team, conducted spot
inspections, examined the material placed before it, and eventually
submitted a detailed report dated 18.05.2020. The Commission did not
simply accept the stand of either side. Rather, the Commission took on its
own to investigate the matter and on an assessment of the material collected
during the course of its inquiry, found that the protests had, at certain places,
turned violent, resulting in damage to public property, attacks on police
personnel, and serious disturbances of law and order. At the same time, the
Commission also examined the conduct of the police and RAF personnel
and observed that certain actions reflected a lack of restraint and specifically
noted that the use of tear-gas shells inside the library premises could have
been avoided. The Commission accordingly made recommendations relating
to compensation, accountability, police training, and broader institutional
reforms.
43.
Moreover, the report submitted by the NHRC is not challenged by any
of the petitioners. Neither proceedings have been initiated seeking judicial
review of the findings recorded therein, nor has any relief been sought for
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
setting aside the report. As the matters stand, the findings recorded by the
Commission continue to operate and remain undisturbed.
44.
We deem it appropriate to clarify that report of NHRC cannot be
treated as a substitute either for judicial adjudication or for criminal
investigation. Equally, the findings recorded therein are not binding upon
this Court.
45.
In addition, Jamia Millia Islamia University had invoked Section
156(3) Cr.P.C. seeking initiation of criminal proceedings against police
officials in relation to the incident of 15.12.2019. The application was
dismissed on 03.02.2021 and the order was not challenged and has,
therefore, attained finality.
46.
We are conscious that the remedy under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. and
the jurisdiction under Article 226 are not mutually exclusive. However, once
the statutory remedy has been invoked and adjudicated upon, the same
grievance cannot ordinarily be reopened through a parallel constitutional
proceeding in the absence of circumstances warranting such intervention,
and no such circumstances are set-up before us.
47.
The petitioners have relied upon CCTV footage, video recordings,
photographs, medical records and statements of students. Such material may
be relevant to the allegations. However, whether the force employed at a
particular stage was necessary or excessive would require examination of
the circumstances prevailing at that time, including the conduct of persons
present, the nature of the perceived threat and the sequence of events. These
are matters involving appreciation of evidence and cannot be concluded in
exercise of writ jurisdiction.
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
48.
The reliance placed by learned senior counsel on Ramlila Maidan
Incident, In Re (supra) and Anita Thakur (surpa), insofar as the necessity,
proportionality and reasonableness of use of force are concerned, is not in
dispute. The question, however, is whether their alleged violation in the
present case warrants constitution of a fresh fact-finding or investigative
mechanism.
49.
We find no material revealing the same. The allegations were
examined by the NHRC, criminal cases were registered, investigation was
undertaken by a Special Investigation Team of the Crime Branch, chargesheets were filed, the criminal proceedings are pending before competent
courts and the application under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. seeking criminal
action against police officials was considered and dismissed by the
competent Magistrate.
50.
The cumulative effect of these circumstances is significant. This is not
a case where the State machinery remained wholly inactive, where no
investigation was undertaken, where the allegations were ignored by
statutory forum, or where the petitioners were denied access to the remedies
provided by law. The material shows that processes of multiple institutions
have been set in motion and have operated in relation to the incidents in
question.
51.
The fact that the petitioners remain dissatisfied with the outcome or
adequacy of those processes cannot justify their displacement. Constitutional
courts undoubtedly possess the power to intervene where an investigation is
demonstrably tainted or where the existing process is incapable of inspiring
public confidence. But that power is an exceptional constitutional safeguard
and it is not a means of obtaining a second investigation merely because the
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
first investigation or statutory proceeding has not produced the result sought
by a party.
52.
We are also unable to accept the submission that the mere fact that
allegations were made against police personnel renders the investigation
institutionally incapable of being fair. Such a proposition, if accepted in
absolute terms, would mean that every allegation against a police officer
would necessarily require investigation by an outside agency. That is not the
law. The relevant consideration is whether the circumstances show actual or
demonstrable institutional bias, malafides, deliberate suppression of
material, failure to investigate material allegations, or such other defect as
would render the existing process fundamentally unreliable. However, no
material to prove such a situation is placed before us.
53.
The authorities relied upon by the petitioners, including Delhi
Judicial Service Association, Tis hazari Court, Delhi vs State of Gujarat &
Ors., (1991) 4 SCC 406, Monica Kumar (Dr.) & Anr. vs State of Uttar
Pradesh & Ors., (2008) 8 SCC 781, and In Re: Lakhimpur Kheri (U.P.)
Leading to Loss of Life, W.P.(Crl.) No. 426/2021, recognise the power of
constitutional courts to direct independent mechanisms where the
circumstances of the case demonstrate a compelling need to preserve the
credibility of the process and ensure justice. They cannot, however, be
understood as laying down an inflexible rule that every allegation of police
misconduct must result in constitution of an independent commission or
transfer of investigation.
54.
The present case also has to be considered against the passage of time.
The incidents occurred in December 2019. More than six years have
elapsed. During this period, criminal proceedings have progressed before
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
competent courts. A fresh inquiry at this stage would necessarily involve reexamination of events and material which have already formed part of
statutory and judicial processes.
55.
Judicial restraint in such circumstances is not just a matter of
prudence. The criminal justice system assigns distinct functions to
investigation, prosecution and adjudication. Constitutional courts ordinarily
do not substitute their own investigative processes for those created by
statute unless compelling circumstances demonstrate that the existing
framework has failed to secure justice.
56.
Having regard to the criminal investigation already undertaken, the
proceedings pending before competent courts, the independent scrutiny
undertaken by the NHRC, the Section 156(3) proceedings by the University
itself culminated in an order dated 03.02.2021 and remained unchallenged,
and the absence of material demonstrating a pervasive or fundamental
failure of the existing mechanisms, we are unable to hold that the present
case falls within the narrow category of exceptional cases warranting
exercise of the extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court. This conclusion does
not amount to any finding on the merits of the allegations or the culpability
of any individual. Those questions, wherever pending, shall be determined
by the competent forum in accordance with law.
57.
For the same reason, the prayer seeking constitution of an
independent judicial commission, court-monitored committee, SIT, factfinding body or any other independent mechanism to inquire into the
incidents in question, and the consequential prayer for registration and
independent investigation of criminal offences against police personnel and
other public officials, is rejected.
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
58.
Nothing contained in this judgment shall preclude any competent
authority or court from taking such action as may otherwise be permissible
in law in respect of any specific offence or individual grievance, where the
statutory requirements for such action are independently satisfied.
PRAYER SEEKING COMPENSATION, REIMBURSEMENT OF
MEDICAL EXPENSES, OR ANY OTHER MONETARY RELIEF
59.
The petitioners have further sought relief for compensation,
reimbursement of medical expenses and other consequential monetary
reliefs on account of the injuries allegedly sustained during the incidents
occurred in December, 2019.
60.
Mr. Colin Gonsalves, learned senior counsel, submitted that numerous
students sustained grievous injuries during the incidents in question,
including fractures, serious head injuries and permanent disabilities.
Particular emphasis was placed on the case of a student (also himself a
petitioner herein) who allegedly suffered permanent loss of vision in one eye
as a consequence of the injuries sustained during the police action. He
further submitted that no compensation was paid by the State authorities. It
was contended that any financial assistance received by certain students
from private individuals could not be treated as compensation for violation
of constitutional rights. He further submitted that the injured students had
borne their medical expenses personally and continued to suffer the
consequences of the injuries sustained. Relying on the observations
contained in NHRC report, as well as the medical records, it was argued that
the alleged use of excessive force constituted a violation of fundamental
rights and that this Court, in exercise of its public law jurisdiction, is
empowered to award monetary compensation independent of any private
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
law remedy. To buttress their arguments, petitioners have placed further
reliance on the decisions of the Supreme Court in Rudul Sah v. State of
Bihar & Anr., (1983) 4 SCC 141, Bhim Singh, MLA v. State of J&K &
Ors., (1985) 4 SCC 677 and Nilabati Behera (SMT) Alias Lalita Behera
(Through the Supreme Court legal & Committee v. State of Orissa & Ors.,
(1993) 2 SCC 746.
61.
Opposing said submissions, learned ASG submitted that no case for
grant of compensation is made out in the present proceedings. It was
submitted that the circumstances in which the alleged injuries were
sustained remain matters of dispute and cannot be conclusively determined
on the basis of the material before the Court. Moreso, the issue of
compensation was specifically examined by the NHRC and appropriate
recommendations were issued by the Commission, however, despite the
recommendations made by the NHRC, none of the alleged victims pursued
such remedies. Thus, the conduct of the petitioners in this regard itself casts
doubt upon the claims now sought to be projected before the Court. He,
accordingly, submitted that no further directions for grant of compensation
are warranted.
62.
We have heard the learned counsels for the parties.
63.
There can be no quarrel with the proposition advanced on behalf of
the petitioners that constitutional courts possess the power, in an appropriate
case, to award compensation as a public law remedy for the violation of
fundamental rights. The principle is now firmly embedded in our
constitutional jurisprudence. Where State action results in a clear
infringement of rights guaranteed under the Constitution, particularly the
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
right to life and personal liberty, courts are not powerless to grant monetary
compensation as a means of affording effective and meaningful redress.
64.
In Rudul Sah (supra), while dealing with an admitted case of
unlawful detention extending far beyond the period authorized by law, the
Supreme Court held as under:
“10. We cannot resist this argument. We see no effective
answer to it save the stale and sterile objection that the
petitioner may, if so advised, file a suit to recover damages
from the State Government. Happily, the State's counsel
has not raised that objection. The petitioner could have
been relegated to the ordinary remedy of a suit if his claim
to compensation was factually controversial, in the sense
that a civil court may or may not have upheld his claim.
But we have no doubt that if the petitioner files a suit to
recover damages for his illegal detention, a decree for
damages would have to be passed in that suit, though it is
not possible to predicate, in the absence of evidence, the
precise amount which would be decreed in his favour. In
these circumstances, the refusal of this Court to pass an
order of compensation in favour of the petitioner will be
doing mere lip-service to his fundamental right to liberty
which the State Government has so grossly violated. Article
21 which guarantees the right to life and liberty will be
denuded of its significant content if the power of this Court
were limited to passing orders of release from illegal
detention. One of the telling ways in which the violation of
that right can reasonably be prevented and due compliance
with the mandate of Article 21 secured, is to mulct its
violators in the payment of monetary compensation.
Administrative sclerosis leading to flagrant infringements
of fundamental rights cannot be corrected by any other
method open to the judiciary to adopt. The right to
compensation is some palliative for the unlawful acts of
instrumentalities which act in the name of public interest
and which present for their protection the powers of the
State as a shield. If civilisation is not to perish in this
country as it has perished in some others too well known to
suffer mention, it is necessary to educate ourselves into
accepting that, respect for the rights of individuals is the
true bastion of democracy. Therefore, the State must repair
the damage done by its officers to the petitioner's rights. It
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
may have recourse against those officers.”
(emphasis supplied)
65.
The said principle was elaborated in Bhim Singh (supra) where the
Supreme Court awarded compensation to a person who had been unlawfully
arrested and detained, thereby depriving him of his constitutional rights. It
was then subsequently explained in greater detail in Nilabati Behera
(supra). The Supreme Court clarified that the power to award compensation
and found as under:
“34. The public law proceedings serve a different purpose
than the private law proceedings. The relief of monetary
compensation, as exemplary damages, in proceedings
under Article 32 by this Court or under Article 226 by the
High Courts, for established infringement of the
indefeasible right guaranteed under Article 21 of the
Constitution is a remedy available in public law and is
based on the strict liability for contravention of the
guaranteed basic and indefeasible rights of the citizen. The
purpose of public law is not only to civilize public power
but also to assure the citizen that they live under a legal
system which aims to protect their interests and preserve
their rights. Therefore, when the court moulds the relief by
granting “compensation” in proceedings under Article 32
or 226 of the Constitution seeking enforcement or
protection of fundamental rights, it does so under the
public law by way of penalising the wrongdoer and fixing
the liability for the public wrong on the State which has
failed in its public duty to protect the fundamental rights of
the citizen. The payment of compensation in such cases is
not to be understood, as it is generally understood in a civil
action for damages under the private law but in the
broader sense of providing relief by an order of making
„monetary amends‟ under the public law for the wrong
done due to breach of public duty, of not protecting the
fundamental rights of the citizen. The compensation is in
the nature of „exemplary damages‟ awarded against the
wrongdoer for the breach of its public law duty and is
independent of the rights available to the aggrieved party
to claim compensation under the private law in an action
based on tort, through a suit instituted in a court of
competent jurisdiction or/and prosecute the offender under
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
the penal law.
35. This Court and the High Courts, being the protectors of
the civil liberties of the citizen, have not only the power
and jurisdiction but also an obligation to grant relief in
exercise of its jurisdiction under Articles 32 and 226 of the
Constitution to the victim or the heir of the victim whose
fundamental rights under Article 21 of the Constitution of
India are established to have been flagrantly infringed by
calling upon the State to repair the damage done by its
officers to the fundamental rights of the citizen,
notwithstanding the right of the citizen to the remedy by
way of a civil suit or criminal proceedings. The State, of
course has the right to be indemnified by and take such
action as may be available to it against the wrongdoer in
accordance with law — through appropriate proceedings.
Of course, relief in exercise of the power under Article 32
or 226 would be granted only once it is established that
there has been an infringement of the fundamental rights of
the citizen and no other form of appropriate redressal by
the court in the facts and circumstances of the case, is
possible. The decisions of this Court in the line of cases
starting with Rudul Sah v. State of Bihar [(1983) 4 SCC
141 : 1983 SCC (Cri) 798 : (1983) 3 SCR 508] granted
monetary relief to the victims for deprivation of their
fundamental rights in proceedings through petitions filed
under Article 32 or 226 of the Constitution of India,
notwithstanding the rights available under the civil law to
the aggrieved party where the courts found that grant of
such relief was warranted. It is a sound policy to punish
the wrongdoer and it is in that spirit that the courts have
moulded the relief by granting compensation to the victims
in exercise of their writ jurisdiction. In doing so the courts
take into account not only the interest of the applicant and
the respondent but also the interests of the public as a
whole with a view to ensure that public bodies or officials
do not act unlawfully and do perform their public duties
properly particularly where the fundamental right of a
citizen under Article 21 is concerned. Law is in the process
of development and the process necessitates developing
separate public law procedures as also public law
principles. It may be necessary to identify the situations to
which separate proceedings and principles apply and the
courts have to act firmly but with certain amount of
circumspection and self-restraint, lest proceedings under
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
Article 32 or 226 are misused as a disguised substitute for
civil action in private law. Some of those situations have
been identified by this Court in the cases referred to by
Brother Verma, J.”
66.
The legal position that emerges from these decisions is clear that
where a violation of fundamental rights is established, constitutional courts
possess the jurisdiction to award monetary compensation as a public law
remedy. At the same time, these decisions are equally instructive for what
they do not say. These do not lay down that compensation must follow
whenever an allegation of constitutional violation is made before a court.
The power has generally been exercised in cases where the violation was
either admitted, established, or capable of being determined without
undertaking a detailed inquiry into the disputed facts.
67.
The present case, in our view, stands on a different footing as there
are two sharply divergent narratives. The petitioners have consistently stated
that students, who were peacefully assembled within educational
institutions, were subjected to excessive and disproportionate force. The
respondents, however, contend that the incidents took place in the backdrop
of widespread violence, destruction of public property, arson, and attacks on
police personnel. The material placed before us reflects these competing
versions and does not permit a simple or summary determination of where
the truth lies.
68.
Even the inquiry conducted by the NHRC did not wholly accept either
account. While the Commission made certain observations regarding the
need for greater restraint in police action and identified specific instances
where the response could have been more measured, it also recorded
findings regarding violence, damage to property, and attacks upon law-
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
enforcement personnel. The report, therefore, presents a neutral picture
rather than one-sided. It cannot, by itself, furnish a definitive basis for fixing
liability in writ proceedings.
69.
More importantly, the question of compensation in the present case
cannot be decided in the abstract. It would require examination of several
factual issues relating to each individual claimant, what injuries were
suffered, how serious those were, in what circumstances those were
sustained, whether those were attributable to unlawful acts of the authorities,
and whether a constitutional violation can be said to have been established
in a given case. These are not matters that can ordinarily be determined on
the basis of affidavits and documents alone. They would require
appreciation of evidence and resolution of disputed questions of fact, an
exercise which lies outside the normal contours of proceedings under Article
226 of the Constitution.
70.
In Chairman, Grid Corporation of Orissa Ltd. (GRIDCO) & Ors. v.
Sukamani Das (SMT) & Anr., (1999) 7 SCC 298, the Supreme Court found
that where the determination of liability depends upon disputed questions of
fact requiring appreciation of evidence, writ proceedings may not constitute
the appropriate forum for adjudication of such claims. Constitutional courts
exercising writ jurisdiction are not ordinarily equipped to undertake a triallike inquiry into contested factual issues.
71.
That said, we do not consider it necessary to rest our conclusion
solely on the existence of disputed questions of fact. In our view, a
circumstance of considerable significance, in the present case, is that the
issue of injuries allegedly suffered during the incidents, and the
consequential question of compensation were specifically examined by the
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
NHRC. The Commission, in its report dated 18.05.2020, did not stop at
recording its findings regarding the events in question. It also made
recommendations concerning compensation and other remedial measures for
persons who were found to have suffered injuries or adverse consequences
arising from the incidents. Despite such recommendations made by the
Commission regarding compensation, no material has been placed before us
to show that the petitioners, who now seek monetary relief, ever pursued
those recommendations or took steps to seek their implementation.
72.
In our considered opinion, this aspect cannot be overlooked. The
petitioners cannot, on the one hand, rely upon portions of the NHRC report
that support their case and, on the other, permit the report to attain finality
without
challenge,
refrain
from pursuing
the
remedial
measures
contemplated therein, and thereafter seek compensation directly from this
Court. The position becomes even more compelling in the case of those
petitioners who claim to have personally suffered injuries. Unlike public
interest litigants, such petitioners have an independent and personal cause of
action. The law provides them with procedure to pursue compensation and
other remedies in respect of their individual grievances. Yet, there is nothing
on record to indicate that they sought enforcement of the recommendations
made by the NHRC or otherwise pursued the remedies available to them
under law.
73.
The extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 is
intended to advance the cause of justice where existing remedies prove
ineffective or inadequate. It is not ordinarily exercised in a manner that
bypasses or renders redundant a remedial framework that has already been
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
considered and recommended by a competent statutory body entrusted with
the protection of human rights.
74.
For the reasons stated hereinabove, we are unable to accept the
submission that the present case falls within the category of cases illustrated
in Rudul Sah (supra), Bhim Singh (supra) or Nilabati Behera (supra). In
those cases, violation of constitutional rights was either established or
undisputed, and the award of compensation was considered necessary to
provide immediate and effective redress. The present matters do not present
a similar situation.
75.
Having regard to the totality of circumstances, the disputed factual
backdrop,
the
inquiry
already
conducted
by
the
NHRC,
the
recommendations made therein regarding compensation, the failure of the
petitioners to pursue the remedial measures contemplated by those
recommendations, and the considerable passage of time, we do not consider
this to be a fit case for exercise of writ jurisdiction for grant of
compensation.
76.
The prayer seeking compensation, reimbursement of medical
expenses, and other consequential monetary reliefs is, accordingly, rejected.
It is, however, clarified that this judgment shall not preclude any person
claiming entitlement to compensation or any other relief from pursuing such
remedies as may otherwise be available in law before the appropriate forum.
PRAYER SEEKING REGULATION OF POLICE ACTION DURING
PROTESTS WITHIN EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS
77.
The petitioners have prayed for issuance of directions regulating
police action during public protests and demonstrations, particularly those
taking place within educational institutions.
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
78.
Mr. Salman Khurshid, learned Senior Counsel, submitted that the
events of 15.12.2019 at Jamia Millia Islamia University shows the need for
safeguards governing police entry into university campuses, use of force,
coordination with the University authorities and the manner in which such
intervention is to be carried out. Reliance was placed on the decisions of the
Supreme Court in D.K. Basu v. State of West Bengal, (1997) 1 SCC 416,
Ramlila Maidan Incident, In Re (supra) and Anita Thakur (supra) as also
on the Model Police Manual and various international and comparative
standards relating to regulation of protests. According to learned Senior
Counsel, these authorities emphasise the requirements of necessity, restraint
and proportionality in the exercise of police powers.
79.
Learned ASG on behalf of the State submitted that no fresh guidelines
are required. It is submitted that police action is already governed by the
Constitution, statutory provisions, binding judgments, police manuals,
standing instructions and human rights safeguards. As regards the events of
15.12.2019, he submitted that the protest has escalated into violence,
involving damage to public and private property and attacks upon police
personnel, and that police intervention was consequently required to restore
law and order.
80.
We have considered the rival submissions advanced on behalf of the
parties.
81.
The circumstances in which the police entered the University
premises are relevant. As noticed earlier, the protests on 15.12.2019 had, in
and around the University escalated into violence and was not confined to
the University campus. There were incidents of stone-pelting, burning of
buses and other vehicles, damage to public property and attacks upon police
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
personnel. The NHRC, after examining the material placed before it, found
that the protesters blocked traffic, damaged property and attacked the police
with stones and other objects. The police attempted to push the protesters
back. A number of protesters thereafter entered the University campus,
following which the police also entered the campus.
82.
Thus, the police did not enter the University premises at the outset to
deal with an otherwise peaceful assembly confined to the campus. The entry
took place after the situation outside and around the University had escalated
and the crowd had moved into the campus. The police intervention,
therefore, has to be viewed in the prevalling law-and-order situation which
had developed at that time.
83.
At the same time, the Commission also found shortcomings in the
manner in which the intervention was carried out. It specifically found that
the use of tear-gas shells inside the library premises could have been
avoided. The report also noticed lapses on the part of the University
administration. Thus, the report does not place the entire responsibility on
one side and it records shortcomings both in the conduct of the protesters
and in the response of the authorities. Significantly, the report has not been
challenged before us or, as brought to our notice, before any other
appropriate forum. We refer to it as contemporaneous material relevant to
the circumstances in which the intervention took place. We do not treat its
findings as conclusive of any individual criminal or other proceedings.
84.
The right to peaceful protest is not in dispute. Articles 19(1)(a) and
19(1)(b) protect freedom of speech and expression and the right to assemble
peacefully and without arms, subject to the restrictions contained in Articles
19(2) and 19(3). These rights do not, however, extend to cause any violence
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
or destruction of property. Once a gathering ceases to remain peaceful and
the circumstances disclose violence, commission of cognizable offences or a
threat to life or property, the police cannot be expected to remain inactive or
as mute spectator merely because the gathering is taking place within a
University campus
85.
Equally, the fact that the premises are those of a University is
nevertheless a relevant consideration. A University is a place of learning and
academic activity, and this crucial aspect must always be kept in mind while
exercising police powers. That consideration cannot, however, be taken to
mean that the police are prohibited from entering a University campus in all
circumstances. Where the situation requires immediate intervention, the
police cannot be expected to remain outside merely because the premises
belong to an educational institution.
86.
Ordinarily, the University authorities should be informed and,
wherever the circumstances permit, consulted before police intervention.
The Model Police Manual also contemplates informing the head of an
educational institution, as far as possible, before entering the premises. This
requirement cannot, however, operate as an absolute condition in every
situation. An immediate threat to life or property, an unlawful assembly, the
commission of cognizable offences or a rapidly developing law-and-order
situation may leave no time for prior communication or permission. The
police may also receive information from sources other than the institution.
This, however, does not place police action beyond scrutiny.
87.
The decisions relied upon by the petitioners already lay down the
principles which govern these questions. In Ramlila Maidan Incident, In
Re (supra), the Supreme Court emphasised on reasonableness and
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
proportionality in the exercise of State power affecting fundamental
freedoms. In Anita Thakur (supra), the Court reiterated that the force
employed by the State should not exceed what is reasonably required in the
circumstances. D.K. Basu (supra) lays down safeguards governing the
exercise of coercive police powers, particularly in matters concerning arrest
and detention. These principles do not cease to apply merely because the
police intervention takes place within an educational institution.
88.
In these circumstances, we do not find it necessary to create a separate
set of rules governing police action only within educational institutions. The
constitutional and statutory framework, together with the binding decisions
of the Supreme Court, already requires police action to remain within the
bounds of necessity, reasonableness and proportionality. If those
requirements are not observed in a particular case, the conduct reported can
be examined on its own facts. The alleged violation of an existing safeguard
does not, by itself, establish that the safeguard is inadequate or that a new
framework is required.
89.
The international and comparative material relied upon by the
petitioners does not require a different approach. The principles of necessity,
proportionality, restraint and minimum use of force reflected in those
materials are broadly the same as the principles already recognised in our
constitutional and legal framework. They may be of assistance in
understanding the manner in which protests and assemblies should
ordinarily be dealt with. They cannot, however, be read as requiring police
intervention within an educational institution to await permission or formal
communication in every case.
90.
More importantly, the prayer for general directions has to be
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
considered in the facts of the present case. The events of 15.12.2019 arose
out of a particular and rapidly developing situation. A protest taking place in
and around the University escalated into violence and the crowd moved into
the campus. The police entered thereafter in the course of dealing with the
situation. These circumstances are materially different from a case where a
peaceful assembly is confined to the premises of an educational institution.
The facts of the present incident cannot, without more, be made the basis for
prescribing a uniform procedure for police intervention in all educational
institutions and in every kind of situation.
91.
There is also the considerable passage of time. The incidents took
place on 15.12.2019 and more than six years have since passed. The NHRC
has completed its inquiry. Criminal proceedings were also initiated in
respect of the incident, with FIRs registered and charge-sheets filed in the
cases referred to in the report. No subsequent incident or material has been
brought to our notice to show that the violations of guidelines as alleged in
these petitions have continued or have been repeated. Thus, we are of the
considered opinion that no fresh guidelines for regulation of police action
during protests within educational institutions are required to be framed.
92.
This conclusion should not be understood as an approval of every act
attributed to the police on 15.12.2019. Nor does it in any manner dilute the
right to peaceful protest or the obligation of the police to act with restraint
and proportionality. The legality of a particular intervention, including the
extent of force used, has to be examined in the facts and circumstances of
that case.
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
93.
The prayer seeking formulation of fresh guidelines regulating police
action during protests within educational institutions is, accordingly,
rejected.
PRAYERS
SEEKING
CONSEQUENTIAL,
INCIDENTAL,
OR
ANCILLARY DIRECTIONS
94.
The petitioners have also prayed for various consequential and
ancillary directions, including directions for preservation of CCTV footage,
electronic records and other material relating to the incidents in question.
Considerable reliance had been placed upon CCTV footage, video
recordings,
photographs,
medical
records,
complaints
and
other
contemporaneous material generated in the aftermath of the incidents and it
was contended that these materials possess significant evidentiary value and,
therefore, require preservation, while ensuring that no material evidence was
lost, tampered with or destroyed.
95.
Mr. Colin Gonsalves, learned senior counsel, in particular referred to
the CCTV footage, video recordings and photographic material placed on
record and submitted that the same constituted direct evidence of the events
that occurred within the university premises. It was argued that such
material ought to be preserved and duly examined while considering the
allegations of police excesses and determining accountability.
96.
On the issue of preservation of evidence, learned ASG submitted that
the CCTV footage and other relevant material relating to the incidents had
already been preserved and formed part of the records collected during
investigation of the criminal cases arising out of the events in question. He
submitted that the relief sought by the petitioners in that regard already
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
stands satisfied and, therefore, no further directions are required to be issued
by this Court.
97.
The prayer concerning preservation of evidence appears to have been
made in view of the apprehension expressed by the petitioners that material
relevant to the events of December 2019 may be lost, destroyed or otherwise
rendered unavailable. During the course of these proceedings, however, the
State have consistently stated on affidavit that the CCTV footage and other
electronic records available with the authorities were preserved and formed
part of the material collected during investigation.
98.
Apart from the aforesaid apprehension, no material has been placed
before us to indicate any deliberate destruction, suppression or
disappearance of evidence after such statements came to be made before this
Court. Nor has any specific circumstance been brought to our notice
necessitating further directions in that regard. It is also not in dispute that
investigations arising out of the incidents have progressed substantially and
that criminal proceedings in connected matters are presently pending before
competent courts. Questions concerning the admissibility, authenticity,
evidentiary value or reliance to be placed upon any particular electronic
record are matters that fall within the jurisdiction of the courts before whom
such proceedings are pending and are required to be determined in
accordance with law.
99.
In these circumstances, we are satisfied that no further directions are
called for with regard to preservation of evidence.
100. The petitioners have also sought such other orders and directions as
may be considered necessary in the interests of justice. We have, however,
examined each of the surviving prayers independently and have found no
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
ground warranting constitution of a fresh inquiry mechanism, transfer of
investigation, registration of criminal cases, award of compensation or
formulation of additional guidelines. The ancillary reliefs sought by the
petitioners are, in substance, dependent upon the grant of one or more of the
surviving reliefs claimed in the petitions. Once those substantive prayers
have not been found fit for acceptance, no separate basis survives for
issuance of consequential directions.
101. We may also state that the jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226
of the Constitution is exercised for enforcement of legal and constitutional
rights and to provide remedy for proven legal wrongs. It is not intended to
be invoked for issuance of open-ended or abstract directions unconnected
with an enforceable legal entitlement.
102. Having regard to the totality of the present case and the conclusions
recorded by us on the preceding issues, we are of the considered view that
no further or ancillary directions are warranted in the facts of the present
case.
CONCLUSION
103. Constitutional courts are entrusted with the duty of safeguarding
fundamental rights and ensuring that public power is exercised within
constitutional bounds. Equally, the exercise of that jurisdiction must remain
guided by constitutional discipline and bound by the boundaries established
by the Constitution and the law.
104. The events of December 2019 undoubtedly generated considerable
public concern and gave rise to serious allegations regarding the conduct of
various stakeholders. Those allegations have received detailed consideration
in the course of the present proceedings. However, the jurisdiction of this
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
Court cannot be invoked to undertake a fresh fact-finding exercise years
after the events in question, particularly where the allegations have already
been examined by a competent statutory body, investigations have been
carried out under the ordinary criminal law framework, and proceedings
arising therefrom have progressed before courts of competent jurisdiction.
105. For the reasons recorded while dealing with the issues framed
hereinabove, we find no ground warranting constitution of an independent
inquiry mechanism, transfer of investigation, registration of criminal cases,
award of compensation, formulation of fresh guidelines or issuance of any
further consequential directions.
106. The writ petitions are, accordingly, dismissed.
107. Pending applications, if any, shall stand disposed of.
108. There shall be no order as to costs.
VIVEK CHAUDHARY
(JUDGE)
MANOJ JAIN
(JUDGE)
OCTOBER 05, 2026/kp
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
15:47:24
W.P.(C) 13468/2019 & connected matters
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review