The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. Accordingly, the present Appeal is allowed. The matter is remanded back to the learned Executing Court for fresh consideration of the objections filed by the Appellant/Objector, particularly in the aforesaid factual context, within a period of one year from today.
16. It is clarified that this Court has not expressed any opinion on the title or ownership claimed by the Appellant/Objector in respect of the aforesaid 25 Square Yards, and all questions in that regard are left open for consideration by the learned Executing Court in accordance with law.
17. The present Appeal is accordingly allowed and disposed of in the aforesaid terms, along with all pending Application(s), if any.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 15.09.2026
#
CNR No. DLHC010612872023
+
EX.F.A. 7/2024, CM APPL. 8331/2024 (Stay), CM APPL.
8333/2024(Delay of 30 days in filing the appeal), CM APPL.
8334/2024 (Delay of 21 days in Re-filing the appeal) & CM
APPL. 8423/2025 (Stay)
BADAL DEVI
.....Appellant
Through:
Mr. Pradeep Kumar Kar and
Ms. M.Vidhya, Advs.
versus
SHEELA DEVI & ORS.
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Naveen Bansal, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARISH VAIDYANATHAN
SHANKAR
%
1.
JUDGEMENT (Oral)
The present Execution First Appeal, under Section 96 read with
Order XLI Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, seeks to
assail the Order dated 21.08.20231 passed by the learned Additional
District Judge, South District, Saket Courts, Delhi2 in Execution
Petition No.3089/2016.
2.
Learned counsel for the Appellant submits that the Impugned
Order is patently illegal insofar as there is no consideration of the
objections that were filed by the Appellant herein. He further submits
Impugned Order
Executing Court
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:40
EX.F.A. 7/2024
that the same is apparent from the fact that the learned Executing
Court has proceeded on the premise that if the Appellant had attained
possession of the property in the year 2014 and the Judgment Debtor
therein had alienated the entire property in the year 2014, there was no
plausible explanation as to how the said Judgment Debtor or his wife
could have thereafter received summons/notices in respect of the
proceedings at the very same premises. He submits that the learned
Executing Court has, on this erroneous premise, doubted the
Appellant's claim of having acquired possession of the property in the
year 2014.
3.
It is further submitted that the learned Executing Court has
erred in so holding, since, admittedly, the Appellant/Objector herein
was only residing in part of the premises, which is 25 Square Yards of
the property bearing No. K-I/18/156-A, Sangam Vihar, New Delhi110080, whereas the Plaint was in respect of property bearing No. KI-A/156, Sangam Vihar, measuring 60 Square Yards. He, therefore,
submits that the Appellant's case was not that the entire property
measuring 60 Square Yards had been alienated to him, but that he was
in possession of only a portion thereof measuring 25 Square Yards. He
submits that, in these circumstances, the mere fact that the summons
in the proceedings were received by the Judgment Debtor or his wife
at the said premises in the year 2017 could not, by itself, lead to the
conclusion that the Appellant could not have been in possession of the
aforesaid portion since the year 2014. He, therefore, submits that the
conclusion arrived at by the learned Executing Court, on the basis of
subsequent service of summons at the premises, is clearly not
sustainable.
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:40
EX.F.A. 7/2024
4.
Per Contra, learned counsel for the Respondents submits that
the Appellants are only indulging in forum shopping. He further
submits that the jurisdiction of this Court is extremely limited in an
Execution First Appeal and that none of the grounds as have been laid
down in various judgments are made out in the present case; therefore,
this Court should not interfere in the present Appeal.
5.
This Court has heard learned counsel for the parties at length
and, with their able assistance, gone through the relevant documents.
The relevant portion of the impugned Order reads as follows:
“6. The present petition has been filed for execution of a decree of
possession, injunction, damages and mesne profit passed by the
Hon'ble Delhi High Court dated 29.06.2015. The decree was
passed exparte and defendants were directed to vacate and hand
over vacant, physical and peaceful possession of the suit property
to the plaintiff. Decree for recovery was also passed in favour of
plaintiff in the sum of Rs. 1,80,000/- towards arrears of user
charges and the Hon'ble Delhi High Court also passed decree in
favour of the plaintiff restraining the defendants from creating third
party interest in the suit property. The defendants went against the
exparte decree in which order was passed on 10.07.2018. They
moved an application under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC alongwith
application seeking condonation of delay of 675 days in filing the
said application.
7. The plaintiff filed execution proceedings to execute the decree
subsequent to which the defendants filed the application before the
Hon'ble Delhi High Court wherein they pleaded that the defendants
acquired knowledge of the decree only in July, 2017 when the
Bailiff visited the suit premises and hence, the delay should be
condoned and they deserved an opportunity to put forth their
defence on merits hence, the exparte judgment and decree should
be set-aside.
8. It was observed by the Hon'ble Delhi High Court in IA
No.8902/2017 that the defendant was served on 19.11.2014 and
when the defendants did not appear despite service they were
proceeded exparte on 28.11.2014.
9. The Hon'ble Delhi High Court while dismissing both the
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:40
EX.F.A. 7/2024
applications i.e. condonation of delay and under Order 9 Rule 13
CPC observed that the summons were served upon the defendant
on 19.11.2014 and again on 31.0.12017 when Bailiff visited the
suit property for serving the warrants of possession.
10. The Hon'ble Delhi High Court observed that on both the
occasions, defendants acquired the knowledge of the suit and also
the decree which was passed against them as the summons were
served upon Smt. Kamlesh Nagar, wife of the defendant, as per the
report of the Bailiff. Therefore, the court observed that the
submission of the defendants that they acquired knowledge on
12.07.2017 was contrary to the court record and could not be
accepted. In view of the observations, the Hon'ble Delhi High
Court dismissed both the applications i.e. condonation of delay and
under Order 9 Rule 13 СРС.
11. The objector in her objections has submitted that she was in
possession of the suit property and came to know about the present
proceedings on 24.12,2021. She further stated that she had
purchased the suit property on 25.10.2014 by way of GPA,
Agreement to Sell Will, Affidavit etc. The court observes that all
the documents annexed by the objector are unregistered
documents. Moreover, the judgment debtor was silent all the time
with respect to not being in possession or selling out the suit
property to a third person. In fact on 27.11.2018 he even made a
statement before the court undertaking to handover the possession
of the decretal property to the decree holder within 45 days.
Moreover, it has been categorically held by the Hon'ble Delhi High
Court that the warrants of attachment were served upon the wife of
defendant namely Kamlesh Nagar on 31.01.2017 and had the
possession been with the objector on the said date, which the
objector submits in her objections that she had purchased the
property on 25.10.2014, there was no question of Kamlesh Nagar
being served the warrants of possession. Further, the fact that the
defendants approached the Hon'ble Delhi High Court for settingaside the exparte decree in 2017 further goes to show that they
were still interested in the suit property.
12. It is a settled principle of law and Section 47 CPC also holds
that that the executing court cannot go behind the decree. It must
take the decree as it stands for the decree is binding and conclusive
between the parties to the suit. Hence, this court cannot go into
legality of the decree passed in favour of the decree holder
however as far as the objections of the objector are concerned, this
court finds it difficult to believe that when summons were served
upon the property twice how they were received by the wife of the
defendant/defendant when the property had been sold out to the
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:40
EX.F.A. 7/2024
objector. The court also finds it hard to believe that when the
property had been transferred in 2014 why this fact was never
disclosed before the court till the year 2019 and on what basis the
defendant even made a statement before the court that he would
hand over the property to the decree holder within 45 days of
27.11.2018. All the documents filed by the objector are
unregistered and do not inspire the confidence of the court. I,
therefore, find no merit in the objections of the objector and the
objections stand dismissed with cost of Rs.10,000/- to be paid to
the decree holder as the objector has not come to the court with
clean hands.”
(emphasis supplied)
6.
This Court finds that the entire conclusion of the learned
Executing Court is based on the foundational as premise that the entire
property came to be transferred to the Objector herein and therefore
took into account the version of the Judgment Debtor and on that basis
held that the version of the Objector herein would not be plausible.
7.
This Court finds that the learned Executing Court has
principally relied upon the observation that the Judgment Debtor had
been served with summons on two occasions, i.e., on 19.01.2014 and
31.01.2017, which had been noticed by the Co-ordinate Bench of this
Court. The said fact had been relied upon to negate the objection
raised by the Appellant/Objector therein that he had acquired
knowledge of the present proceedings only on 24.12.2021. The
learned Executing Court has further taken into consideration the fact
that the Judgment Debtor had not disclosed before the Court that he
was no longer in possession of the suit property or that the same had
been sold to a third person and had, in fact, made a statement before
the Court undertaking to hand over possession of the decretal property
within a period of 45 days.
8.
However, this Court is of the opinion that the aforesaid
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:40
EX.F.A. 7/2024
reasoning proceeds on the premise that the entire property, which was
the subject matter of the decree, had been transferred to the
Appellant/Objector herein in the year 2014. The said premise,
however, does not appear to be in consonance with the case set up by
the Appellant/Objector. The Appellant/Objector has categorically
maintained that he had acquired possession only in respect of a part of
the premises, measuring 25 Square Yards, whereas the property
forming the subject matter of the plaint was stated to measure 60
Square Yards. Thus, the case set up by the Appellant/Objector was not
that the entire decretal property had been alienated in his favour, but
that only a portion thereof had been transferred to him.
9.
In this context, the fact that the Judgment Debtor or his wife
had received summons at the premises on 31.01.2017 could not, by
itself, have been treated as conclusive of the fact that the Objector
could not have acquired possession of the aforesaid 25 Square Yards
in the year 2014. The reasoning of the learned Executing Court, that
the service of summons upon the Judgment Debtor in the year 2017
was inconsistent with the Appellant/Objector's claim of having
purchased the property on 25.10.2014, again proceeds on the
assumption that the entire property had been transferred to the
Appellant/Objector. The distinction between the 25 Square Yards
claimed by the Appellant/Objector and the entire property measuring
60 Square Yards, which was the subject matter of the proceedings, has
not been examined by the learned Executing Court.
10.
Court
This Court, therefore, is of the view that the learned Executing
has
not
considered
the
objections
taken
by
the
Appellant/Objector in their entirety and has proceeded to examine the
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:40
EX.F.A. 7/2024
same on the basis of a premise which does not constitute the case set
up by the Appellant/Objector. The subsequent service of summons
upon the Judgment Debtor may be a circumstance to be considered
while examining the objections, but the same, by itself, cannot
conclusively determine the Appellant/Objector's claim in respect of
the 25 Square Yards allegedly purchased by him. The objections,
therefore, require reconsideration by the learned Executing Court after
taking into account the specific case of the Appellant/Objector with
regard to the extent and identity of the portion claimed by him.
11.
This Court is also conscious of the settled principle that an
Executing Court cannot go behind the decree and cannot sit in appeal
over the decree sought to be executed. However, the objections raised
by a third party/Objector claiming an independent right in respect of
the property in execution are required to be considered in accordance
with law.
12.
In the present case, the learned Executing Court does not appear
to have examined the objections from the aforesaid perspective.
Instead, the conclusion that the Appellant/Objector's claim was not
believable has substantially proceeded on the assumption that the
Appellant/Objector was claiming the transfer of the entire decretal
property. Such an assumption is contrary to the specific case set up by
the Appellant/Objector and, therefore, vitiates the consideration of his
objections.
13.
Insofar as the learned Executing Court has also relied upon the
fact that the documents relied upon by the Appellant/Objector were
unregistered and did not inspire confidence, this Court is of the view
that the said aspect can be considered by the learned Executing Court
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:40
EX.F.A. 7/2024
while re-examining the objections. This Court does not consider it
appropriate, at this stage, to return any finding on the validity,
sufficiency or legal effect of the documents relied upon by the
Appellant/Objector, as the same would be a matter for consideration
by the learned Executing Court in the first instance.
14.
Consequently, this Court is of the view that the impugned Order
dated 21.08.2023 cannot be sustained insofar as it rejects the
objections of the Appellant/Objector in respect of the 25 Square Yards
claimed by him, without considering their objections in their entirety
and in the context of the specific case set up by the objector.
15.
Accordingly, the present Appeal is allowed. The matter is
remanded back to the learned Executing Court for fresh consideration
of the objections filed by the Appellant/Objector, particularly in the
aforesaid factual context, within a period of one year from today.
16.
It is clarified that this Court has not expressed any opinion on
the title or ownership claimed by the Appellant/Objector in respect of
the aforesaid 25 Square Yards, and all questions in that regard are left
open for consideration by the learned Executing Court in accordance
with law.
17.
The present Appeal is accordingly allowed and disposed of in
the aforesaid terms, along with all pending Application(s), if any.
HARISH VAIDYANATHAN SHANKAR, J
SEPTEMBER 15, 2026/rk/va
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
15:00:40
EX.F.A. 7/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review