Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
23.09.2026
Sl. No.: 20
Court No.10
BM
WPA 27123 of 2026
BABAR ALI BISWAS
VS
STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.
Mr. Debabrata Saha Ray, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Pingal Bhattacharyya
Mr. Subhankar Das
... for the petitioner
1.
Affidavit of service filed in court today be taken
on record.
2.
The petitioner in the present case challenges,
inter alia, the entire procedure of suspension and
termination initiated against the petitioner which is not
sustainable in the eye of law.
3.
Apropos, the facts of the case, are that the
respondent no.5, being the Sub Divisional Controller,
F&S, Medinipur Sadar, being the respondent no.5
herein, by order dated 20.05.2026 transferred the entire
stock of one suspended dealership of Pathik Mallick and
tagged 8,500 ration cards with the dealership of the
petitioner on 22.05.2026 by handing over the following
articles namely1) Entire commodities of all category
2) EPOS machine(2)
3) Charger of both the EPOS
4) Weighing Scale
5) Cluster Details of defunct FPS of Pathik
Mallick.
4.
Pursuant to the order of the respondent no.5, the
petitioner continued to distribute ration articles of the
suspended dealer, in addition to his own 7300 approx
tagged ration cards.
5.
By
informed
a
letter
the
dated
8.6.2026
respondent
no.5
the
petitioner
regarding
his
incapacitation, in running the FPS dealership with
regard to stock of the suspended dealer owing to
disturbance and chaos created by the beneficiaries and
the local residents of the suspended dealer.
6.
Thereafter, on 12th June, 2026 an enquiry was
conducted by the Area Inspector (F&S), Medinipur Sadar
and a report was filed before the respondent no.5, from
which it appears that ‘expired Atta’ had been distributed
to the beneficiaries but subsequently the same were
returned by all the beneficiaries and replaced with
wheat.
7.
Thereafter, on 13.6.2026, the respondent no.5
issued a show cause cum suspension notice in favour of
the petitioner as per Clause 45 and 46 of the West
Bengal
Targeted
Public
Distribution
System
MNC
Control Order, 2024(hereinafter referred to as ‘Control
Order, 2024’). In response to the same a reply was given
by the petitioner on 17.6.2026.
8.
By an order dated 14.07.2026 termination was
ordered for alleged violation of Clauses 45 and 46 of the
Control Order, 2024 on the ground of ‘Atta’ of 4.20
quintals and 9.3155 quintals were found unfit for
human consumption.
9.
Being aggrieved thereby, the petitioner preferred
a statutory appeal under Clause 57 of the Control
Order, 2024 dated 27.7.2026, inter alia, on the following
grounds:
(A) No proceedings has been drawn up against my
license or in respect of my original dealership, even if
there is any allegation that is in respect of my tagged
second counter for which no punishment can be
imposed in respect of my dealership license having no
allegation against the said license.
(B) Licensing Authority should not have forced me,
despite my unwillingness, to distribute ration articles
to the ration card holders tagged with dealership of
suspended dealer Pathik Mullick.
(C) By way of not supplying copy of the enquiry report,
relying on which proceeding has been drawn up
against me, entire proceedings and outcome thereof
has been vitiated for violation of rule of natural justice.
(D) Although on 12.06.2026, when I distributed two
packets of expired atta to the concerned ration card
holder, I immediately took back those expired atta
packets and distributed the same amount of wheat to
the concerned consumer, accordingly not a single
consumer has been distributed a single quota expired
atta, however such facts has not even been taken note
of.
(E)
No specific provisions of WBPTDS (M&C) Control
Order, 2024, has (E) been invoked at the time of
initiating the proceeding and on that sole ground entire
proceedings and outcome thereof vitiates from noncompliance of statutory Control Order, 2024.
(F) Although there was no charge in the show cause
notice for violation of clause 46 of the Control Order,
2024, however my license has been terminated
invoking clause 46 of the Control Order, 2024 with
utter violation of the settled law that without framing
any charge no punishment can be imposed.
(G) There is no charge or allegation of siphoning or
misappropriation of food grains by me, on the other
hand not a single consumer has been delivered a
single quota of expired atta by me as such imposition
of capital punishment of termination of license is
shockingly disproportionate and not sustainable in the
eye of law.
(H) Relying on previous minor offences, which has not
been recorded in the show cause notice meaning
thereby without providing any opportunity to defend
such allegations, imposition of capital punishment is
not sustainable in the eye of law.
(I)
Order terminating the license is non-speaking,
unreasoned an cryptic one and on the sole ground the
same is not sustainable in the eye of law.
(J)
Entire proceedings and its outcome vitiates for
non-compliance natural justice and on that sole ground
order of termination is required to be struck down.
10.
Thereafter, on 25.08.2026, a personal hearing
was granted to the petitioner by the respondent no.4
and on 3.9.2026 the appeal was disposed of remanding
the matter back to licensing authority, being the
respondent no.5, for further proceeding, with a direction
to issue a fresh, clear and comprehensive show cause
notice to the petitioner specifying all relevant clauses
and provisions of the Controller Order, 2024 and to reexamine the entire matter including all relevant records
and evidences and submissions of the petitioner. The
relevant portion of the operative part of the order is
reproduced as follows :“It is, therefore, ordered as follows:a. The case is remanded to the Licensing
Authority for further proceeding.
b. The Licensing Authority shall issue a fresh,
clear and comprehensive Show Cause Notice to
the
appellant,
specifying
all
relevant
clauses/provisions WBTPDS of the (M&C)
Order, 2024, Licensing condition and other
relevant Government order in force.
c. The Licensing Authority shall re-examine the
entire matter including all relevant records,
evidence and submissions of the appellant.
d. Thereafter, the Licensing Authority shall pass
a reasoned and speaking order strictly in
accordance with the provisions of West Bengal
Targeted
Public
Distribution
System
(Maintenance Order and Control) Order, 2024
and other relevant Govt. orders in force.
e. The entire exercise shall be completed within
02(two) weeks from the date of communication
of this order
Accordingly, the appeal is disposed of and let a copy
of this order be served to all concerned.”
11.
Pursuant to direction of respondent no.4, a fresh
show cause notice dated 15.09.2026 was accordingly
issued by the respondent no.5 to the petitioner.
12.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
submits that the entire procedure of terminations as per
the
enquiry
conducted
by
the
Area
Inspector
is
arbitrary, illegal in excess of jurisdiction and not
permissible in the eye of law.
13.
Impugned order dated 11th September, 2026
suffers from gross material and procedural irregularity
by remanding the matter back to the concerned
Licensing Authority without setting aside the order of
termination and interpolating stock transfer certificates,
(dated 17.6.2026 at page 54 and 36 of the writ petition),
in violation of clauses 45 and 46 of the Control Order,
2024.
14.
Learned counsel submits that such action of the
authorities is highly condemnable and warrants serious
interference by this Court.
15.
Despite informing department about chaos and
disturbances and requesting for de-tagging the ration
cards of the suspended dealer to a nearby dealer in
order to run his own business with his own ration cards
in a seamless manner, the authority concerned took
stringent decision without adhering to the request.
16.
The decision of terminating the petitioner is ex-
facie bad, illegal and shows high handedness and
arbitrariness on the part of the authority concerned.
Due to conduct of the suspended dealer, the petitioner
has been penalised by way of termination which is
violative of the principle of natural justice and such
action culminating into order of suspension cum
termination is liable to be set aside.
17.
Learned counsel for the State strenuously argued
and submitted that the petitioner was suspended and
terminated on the basis of report of the Area Inspector
from which it transpires that expired ‘Atta’ had been
distributed from the stock to the beneficiaries which was
found to be unfit for human consumption, in violation of
the Control Order, 2024.
18.
Having heard the parties and upon perusing the
records made available, this Court finds that the
petitioner has been able to make out a prima facie case
warranting interference at this stage. This Court has
taken judicial note of all the relevant documents
annexed to the writ petition including the relevant
provisions of the Control Order, 2024 and is of the
considered view that the action of the respondent
authority in suspending and terminating is de-hors the
statutory mandate.
19.
From
the
impugned
order
passed
by
the
respondent no.4 & 5 this Court finds that the same
suffers from gross irregularities and illegality and are
perse unsustainable in the eye of law.
20.
Despite notice of helplessness in running FPS
dealership after tagging 8500 ration cards of the
suspended dealer with the dealership of the petitioner,
authority took stringent decision without adhering to the
request made by the petitioner for de-tagging the ration
cards of the suspended dealer to a nearby dealer.
21.
Respondent no.4 has passed the impugned order
which is palpably wrong and not sustainable in the eye
of law and is inviolation of principles of natural justice
since there is a gross irregularity in a decision making
process by not setting aside the order of termination,
and remanded the matter back to the Licensing
Authority with certain directions mentioned in the order
dated 11.9.2026 which is liable to be quashed and set
aside.
22.
In view of the above, the show cause notices
dated
13.06.2026,
15.09.2026
along
with
all
consequential orders and notices are hereby quashed
and set aside.
23.
This court directs the respondent no.4 being the
appellate authority to re-visit the issue upon considering
the letter dated 8.6.2026 being Annexure at P-3 of the
page 33 of the writ petition along with Stock Transfer
Certificate dated 17.6.2026 being Annexure P-5 at page
36 and 54 of the writ petition and to take independent
decision, if required and independent enquiry may be
conducted to arrive at logical and conclusive finding
with regard to issue involved herein.
24.
Respondent no.4 shall also take necessary steps
against the respondent no.5, seeking clarification with
regard to interpolation and discrepancies with regard to
transfer of certificates dated 17.6.2026 annexed at page
36 and 54 in accordance with law.
25.
In the meantime, till decision attains its finality,
the authority concerned is directed to re-tag and allot
stocks to the petitioner within 48 hours from the date of
communication of this order.
26.
However, it is made clear that the entire exercise
shall be completed on or before 30th November, 2026 by
the respondent no.4.
27.
With the above observations and directions the
writ petition is disposed of.
28.
Since, affidavits are not being filed the allegation
made in the writ petition are deemed to have not been
admitted and denied.
(Smita Das De, J. )
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review