Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:12347-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
Cr. A (DB) No.1236 of 2025
----Baban Bhokta @ Baban Ganjhu @ Baban Ji @ Baban Singh Bhokta aged
about 32 years, Son of Chandar Ganjhu Resident of Vill- Hara, P.O. and
P.S.- Pratappur, District- Chatra
… … …Appellant
Versus
The State of Jharkhand
… … … Respondent
--------CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SUJIT NARAYAN PRASAD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PRASAD
----------
For the Appellant
For the State
: Mr. Abhay Kr. Chaturvedy, Advocate
: Mr. Abhay Kumar Tiwari, A. P. P.
----------
Order No.09/Dated 27th April, 2026
1.
The instant appeal under section 21(4) of the National Investigation
Agency Act, 2008 has been directed against the order dated 17.07.2025 passed
by the learned Additional Sessions Judge-III, Chatra whereby and whereunder
the prayer for regular bail of the appellant in connection with Pratappur P.S. Case
No. 152 of 2023 corresponding to S.T. No. 09 of 2025 registered for the offences
under Sections 307/34, 120(B) of the Indian Penal Code, Section 4/5 of the
Explosive Substance Act, 17 (1) and 17 (2) CLA Act and Section 10/13 of UAP
Act, has been rejected.
Submission of the learned counsel for the appellant
2.
Learned counsel appearing for the appellant has submitted that although
the prayer of regular bail of the appellant has been rejected on earlier occasion
vide order dated 27.03.2025 passed in Cr. Appeal (DB) No. 1193 of 2024 on
merit and the prayer for bail has been renewed on ground of the long
incarceration, since, the appellant is in custody since 25th November, 2023.
2026:JHHC:12347-DB
3.
It has been submitted that so far as the ground which has been agitated
on behalf of the State that the appellant is having eight criminal antecedents is
concerned, the appellant has already been directed to be released on bail in all
the pending criminal cases against him.
4.
The submission has been made that taking into consideration, the long
incarceration of the appellant, the impugned order may be interfered with so that
the appellant may be released from judicial custody.
Submission of the learned Counsel for the state:
5.
Mr. Abhay Kumar Tiwari, learned Additional Public Prosecutor
appearing for the State has vehemently opposed the prayer of bail of the
appellant.
6.
It has further been submitted that, altogether, eight chargesheet witnesses
are cited, out of whom five have already been examined. The submission,
therefore, is that, if at this stage the appellant is directed to be released on bail,
then, having regard to his involvement in eight criminal cases of like nature, the
trial would stand prejudiced.
7.
It has further been submitted that mainly because the bail has been
granted in the several pending criminal cases that does not amount that the
appellant is having no criminal antecedent.
8.
Learned Additional Public Prosecutor, therefore, on aforesaid grounds,
has submitted that the impugned order may not be interfered with.
Analysis
9.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and gone through the
findings recorded by the learned court in its impugned order, the case diary and
the objection filed on behalf of the State on 04.02.2026.
2026:JHHC:12347-DB
10.
The case has been instituted under Sections 307/34 and 120-B of the
Indian Penal Code, Sections 4 and 5 of the Explosive Substances Act, Section
17(i)(ii) of the CLA Act, and Sections 10 and 13 of the Unlawful Activities
(Prevention) Act. The prayer for bail of the appellant had already been rejected
by this Court in Criminal Appeal (D.B.) No. 1193 of 2024, vide order dated
27.03.2025, on merits. For ready reference, the relevant paragraphs of the order
dated 27.03.2025 passed in Criminal Appeal (D.B.) No. 1193 of 2024 are quoted
hereinbelow.
“ 11. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and gone across
the finding recorded by the learned trial Court in the impugned order
as also the case diary, as has been called for vide order dated
22.11.2024 and based upon the affidavit-in-objection filed on behalf of
the respondent-State.
12. It is evident from the case diary that the appellant has been
apprehended from the spot and on his disclosure, cane bombs of 2 Kg
each, 20 pieces electric detonator etc. had been recovered.
13. The appellant is having 8 criminal cases of like nature and he has
been shown to be the member of banned extremist organization.
14. This Court, considering the aforesaid fact, is of the view that it is
not a case where the order impugned needs to be interfered with.
15. In the result, the instant appeal fails and is dismissed.”
11.
It is evident from the aforesaid order that while rejecting the prayer for
bail, this Court had taken into consideration the culpability of the appellant in
the alleged commission of crime, particularly the fact that, on his disclosure, one
cane bomb of 2 kg each, twenty pieces of electric detonators, etc., had been
recovered. In addition, thereto, this Court had also taken into account that eight
criminal cases of like nature are pending against the appellant and he has been
shown to be the member of banned extremist organization.
2026:JHHC:12347-DB
12.
In the instant appeal, two-fold grounds have been urged for renewing the
prayer for bail by assailing the impugned order. The first ground relates to the
incarceration of the appellant since 25.11.2023, and the second ground is that, in
other eight criminal cases which has been instituted against him, the appellant
has already been directed to be released on bail.
13.
So far as the incarceration is concerned this Court is of the view that
merely on account of long incarceration i.e. about two years and six months in
the instant case, the prayer for bail of the appellant cannot be acceded to. Rather,
the nature of the crime alleged to have been committed by the appellant/accused
must be considered, so as to maintain the balance of justice and uphold the rule
of law.
14.
The Hon'ble Apex Court in its recent judgment in the case of Gulfisha
Fatima versus State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi) 2026 LiveLaw (SC) 1 has
categorically observed that Prosecutions under the UAPA may allege varying
degrees of participation, ranging from peripheral acts to strategic, organizational,
or ideological centrality. The constitutional significance of prolonged
incarceration cannot be assessed uniformly for all accused regardless of role.
Where the attribution suggests a central or organising role in the alleged design,
the need for circumspection before constitutional intervention displaces a
statutory embargo is correspondingly greater. Conversely, where the role is
peripheral or episodic, prolonged incarceration may more readily assume a
punitive character.
15.
It requires ton refer herein that There is no dispute and it cannot be
disputed that the jurisprudence of Article 21 has, as it develops, recognized
various facets to be intrinsic to the right to life and liberty such as speedy trial,
2026:JHHC:12347-DB
timely completion of investigation, fair trial etc. but at the same time
circumspection in granting the relief of bail in offences that harmful to society
such as in this case, stems from a place of concern, understandably legitimate at
that, about public order, societal security, overall peace and the general deterrent
force in criminal law.
16.
The scales of justice must balance on the one hand-the constitutionally
consecrated and jealously guarded right under Article 21 and on the other, the
recognition that individual liberty is not absolute and is subject to just exceptions
i.e. the paramount considerations of national interest and societal interest.
17.
There can be no manner of doubt on the proposition that Article 21 rights
are placed on a pedestal, and rightly so, at the same time, though, the individual
cannot always be the centre of attention. We observe, therefore, that while
Article 21 rights must always be protected, but however, in cases where the
security of the society and nation is called into question, the long incarceration
cannot be the sole ground of consideration.
18.
The act of the accused persons must be looked at, on the whole, and all
relevant factors must be given due consideration while granting or denying bail.
Needless to add, any Court seized of bail application(s) arising out of such
offences must record, in their order the reasons and factors that weighed with
them in the ultimate outcome.
19.
In view of the discussion made above it is the settled fact that the rights
of an individual are always subservient to the nation/societal interest.
20.
Further, while considering the issue of incarceration, this Court has
perused the case diary and found at paragraph 5 that the appellant has been
2026:JHHC:12347-DB
referred to as the Zonal Commander of the CPI (Maoist), which is a banned
organization in the State of Jharkhand.
21.
Further, it is evident from the record that the appellant’s involvement has
been shown in altogether eight criminal cases of like nature. Although it has been
urged that in all such cases the appellant has been directed to be released on bail,
but it is well settled that the grant of bail is distinct from acquittal in a criminal
case. Merely because the concerned accused has been granted bail in those cases,
it cannot lead to the conclusion that he is having no criminal antecedents.
22.
The details of all the cases instituted against the appellant have been
referred to in the counter affidavit, as is evident from Annexure-A annexed
thereto and after going through the same, it has been found that the cases are like
nature i.e under the UAPA, Explosive Substance Act, Crime Control Act etc. for
reference, the detail of the cases have been referred herein:
“चतरा जिला 1. ्ቚतापपुर थाना काांड सां0-152/2023, जिनाांक-24.11.2023. घारा307/120बी/34 मा०ि०जि०. 4/5 जि्ቢोटक पिाथथ अजिजनयम, 17 (i) (ii)
सी०एल०ए० ए्ሴ एिां 10/13 यू०ए०पी० ए्ሴ ।
2. ्ቚतापपुर थाना काांड सां0-88/2022. जिनाांक-24.06.2022, िारा-17(i) (ii)
सी०एल०ए० ए्ሴ ।
3. ्ቚतापपुर थाना काांड सां0-119/2022, जिनाांक-19.09.2022, िारा147/148/149/332/333 /353/326/307 भा०५०जि०, 27 आኚथ ए्ሴ, 17(1) (ii)
सी०एल०ए० ए्ሴ एिां 10/13/16(ii) /20 यू०ए०पी० ए्ሴ।
4. ्ቚतापपुर थाना काां ड सां0-03/2019. जिनाांक-07.01.2019, िारा147/148/149/323/307 /386/387/436 भा०ि०जि०, 17(i) (ii) सी०एल०ए०
ए्ሴ एिां 27 आኚथ ए्ሴ ।
5. कु्ा थाना काांड सां0-16/2019, जिनाांक-03.03.2019, िारा-120ए/121
भा०ि०जि०, 3/4/5 जि्ቢोटक पिाथथ अजिजनयम एिां 17 (i) (ii) सी०एल०ए०
ए्ሴ।
6. कु्ा थाना काांड सां0-56/2022, जिनाांक-07.12.2022, िारा385/387/435/427/506/34 भा०ि०जि० एिां 17 (ⅰ) (ii) सी०एल०ए० ए्ሴ।
2026:JHHC:12347-DB
7. हांटरगांि थाना काांड सां0-102/2023, जिनाांक-01.06.2023, िारा341/342/323/307/386 / 34 भा०ि०जि०। (अ्ቚाथजमकी अजभयु्ሹ)
8. चतरा सिर थाना काांड सां0-390/2022, जिनाांक-13.12.2022, िारा147/148/149/427/435/387/506 भा०ि०जि०, 10/13 यू०ए०पी० ए्ሴ एिां 17
सी०एल०ए० ए्ሴ ।
पलामू जिला :-
1. छतरपुर थाना काांड सां0-161/2023,
23.
This Court has further found from the status report called for by this
Court vide order dated 30.03.2026, wherefrom it is evident that out of the eight
charge sheeted witnesses altogether five charge sheeted witnesses have already
been examined up to17.04.2026.
24.
Learned State Counsel has submitted that only three witnesses remain
to be examined and, as such, at the fag end of the trial, allowing the prayer of the
appellant for bail would prejudice the trial, particularly in view of the criminal
antecedents of the appellant.
25.
This Court is in agreement with the aforesaid submission, particularly
taking into consideration the culpability of the present appellant in the alleged
crime and his criminal antecedents.
26.
On the basis of the discussion made hereinabove, and particularly taking
into consideration the culpability of the present appellant in the alleged crime,
as well as the fact that his earlier prayer for bail has already been rejected, and
further bearing in mind that only three chargesheet witnesses remain to be
examined, this Court is of the considered view that the instant appeal is not fit to
be allowed.
27.
Accordingly, this Court is of the view, that the impugned order dated
17.07.2025 passed by learned Additional Sessions Judge-III, Chatra, in Misc.
2026:JHHC:12347-DB
Criminal Application no. 1321 of 2025 by which prayer for bail of the appellant
has been rejected, requires no interference.
28.
Accordingly, the instant Appeal being Criminal Appeal (DB) No.1236
of 2025 is, hereby, dismissed.
29.
The State is directed to ensure production of the remaining witnesses
without fail, so that the learned Trial Court may conclude the trial at the earliest.
(Sujit Narayan Prasad, J.)
(Sanjay Prasad, J.)
Date : 27.04.2026
Kamlesh/ Nishant/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review