Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC:33915
RFA No. 2129 of 2010
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 7TH DAY OF JULY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE JYOTI M
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO. 2129 OF 2010 (RES)
BETWEEN:
B.RAJANNA,
S/O. LATE BETTAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
R/AT NO.4-15, GANESH BLOCK,
SHESHADRIPURAM,
BENGALURU-560053.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. M.RAMAMOHAN, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
SMT. NARAYANAMMA,
D/O. LATE BETAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS,
R/AT NO.199, AGARA VILLAGE,
BOMMANAHALLI C.M.C.,
BENGALURU-560 034.
2.
SMT. JAYALAXMI,
D/O. LATE BETAPPA,
W/O. VENKATASWAMY,
AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS,
R/O. KALLASWAMANA HALLI,
NEAR ASIAN BEARING FACTORY,
BAGALUR POST, TAMILNADU STATE.
3.
SRI. MUNIRAJU,
S/O LATE BETAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS,
PREMCHANDRA M R
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
-2NC: 2026:KHC:33915
RFA No. 2129 of 2010
HC-KAR
R/AT NO.199, AGARA VILLAGE,
BOMMANAHALLI C.M.C.,
BENGALURU- 560 034.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. VENKATESHWARA BABU, ADVOCATE FOR
SRI. A.SHIVARAMA, ADVOCATE)
THIS REGULAR FIRST APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION
96 OF THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE.
THIS REGULAR FIRST APPEAL HAVING BEEN HEARD AND
RESERVED FOR JUDGMENT ON 02.07.2026, THIS DAY, AN
JUDGMENT IS PRONOUNCED AS UNDER:
CAV JUDGMENT
Sri.M.Ramamohan,
counsel
for
the
appellant
and
Sri.Venkateshwara Babu, counsel on behalf of Sri.A.Shivarama,
for the respondents have appeared in person.
2.
The
present
appeal
is
filed
challenging
the
Judgment and Decree dated 21.09.2010 passed by the Court of
XLIII Addl. City Civil and Sessions Judge, Bengaluru, in
O.S.No.903/2003.
-3NC: 2026:KHC:33915
RFA No. 2129 of 2010
HC-KAR
3.
For convenience's sake, the parties are referred to
as per their status and ranking before the Trial Court.
4.
The plaint averments are these:
It is stated that the plaintiff and the defendants are joint
family members and are governed by the Hindu Mitakshara
Law.
The father, having disposed of the ancestral properties
situated at Telagarahalli in Anekal Taluk, Bangalore Urban
District, purchased Property No.199 at Agara Village, within the
Bommanahalli Municipal limits, Bengaluru, in the year 1962.
The said property, being acquired from the joint family funds,
and is asserted to be the ancestral joint family property. After
the purchase of the suit-scheduled property, the plaintiff and
the first defendant constructed a residential house thereon to
reside with their family members. Subsequently, as the plaintiff
was employed in a factory, he was compelled to reside at
Sheshadripuram along with his wife and children.
It is stated that, upon his voluntary retirement from
service, the plaintiff was left without any source of income to
-4NC: 2026:KHC:33915
RFA No. 2129 of 2010
HC-KAR
maintain
his
family
and
was
unable
to
secure
rented
accommodation. In consequence, he approached his father, the
first defendant, seeking permission to construct a residential
portion in the vacant space available within the suit schedule
property. The first defendant, who was residing with the second
defendant, did not respond to the plaintiff’s request. Thereafter,
the plaintiff approached defendant No.2 and disclosed his plan
to raise a residential building in the said vacant portion of the
suit schedule property.
It is further stated that the plaintiff’s brother, in an
arrogant manner, asserted that the plaintiff was not entitled to
put up any construction on the suit schedule property,
contending that the entire property belonged to him by virtue
of a gift deed executed in his favor by their father. It is averred
in the plaint that the second defendant had played a fraud in
obtaining the said gift deed from the first defendant. The
plaintiff
immediately
approached
his
father
and
sought
partition, contending that the first defendant had no right to
execute the gift deed in favor of the second defendant, since
the suit schedule property constituted joint family property.
-5NC: 2026:KHC:33915
RFA No. 2129 of 2010
HC-KAR
Alleging fraud on the part of the second defendant, the plaintiff
has
approached
the
Court
of
law
seeking
shelter
and
appropriate relief.
Upon service of summons, the defendants entered an
appearance and filed their written statement, wherein they
denied the plaint averments. They specifically contended that
the suit-scheduled property was not joint family property but
the self-acquired property of their father, Bettappa. It was
further asserted that, in exercise of such ownership, the first
defendant had executed a gift deed in favor of the second
defendant. Urging other contentions, they prayed for dismissal
of the suit.
Based on the pleadings, the Trial Court framed issues, the
parties adduced evidence, and documents were exhibited. The
Trial Court, by its Judgment and Decree dated 21.09.2010,
dismissed
the
suit.
Aggrieved
thereby,
the
plaintiff
has
preferred the present appeal under Section 96 of the Code of
Civil Procedure.
5.
Counsel for the respective parties urged several
contentions.
-6NC: 2026:KHC:33915
RFA No. 2129 of 2010
HC-KAR
Counsel for the appellant submits that the Judgment and
Decree of the Trial Court are opposed to the facts, the law, and
the probabilities of the case. It is next submitted that the first
defendant purchased the suit schedule property in 1962,
utilizing joint family funds. To facilitate the purchase, he had
availed an advance of Rs.150/- in 1962 from one Muniyappa,
the purchaser of the ancestral property situated at Telagarahalli
Village. However, the Trial Court erred in failing to appreciate
this material fact. It is further contended that the Trial Court
did not properly consider the evidence of PW-2 and PW-3, who
categorically deposed that the father had purchased the suit
schedule property by selling joint family property. Counsel
vehemently argued that the Trial Court erred in concluding that
the plaintiff had failed to prove the suit-schedule property to be
joint family property.
Lastly, it is submitted that the Trial Court's finding with
respect to the gift deed is also unsustainable. Urging additional
grounds, counsel submits that the Judgment and Decree of the
Trial Court are liable to be set aside.
-7NC: 2026:KHC:33915
RFA No. 2129 of 2010
HC-KAR
Counsel for the respondents submits that the Trial Court
was justified in dismissing the suit. It is contended that the
suit-scheduled property was the self-acquired property of the
father, Bettappa, who had every right to deal with the same
and, in exercise of such right, executed the gift deed in favor of
the second defendant. Counsel vehemently argued that the
Trial Court, after extensively referring to the material on
record, rightly dismissed the suit. It is therefore submitted that
the appeal is devoid of merit and is liable to be dismissed.
Counsel for the respondents placed reliance on the
following decisions:
ANGADI CHANDRANNA V/S. SHANKAR AND OTHERS
REPORTED IN [2025] 4 SCR 1417.
SMT.USHA N.SWAMY V/S. SRI.M.VENKATASWAMY AND
OTHERS IN RFA NO.1568/2018 DISPOSED OF ON 16.06.2026.
6.
Heard the arguments, perused the papers and also
records with care.
7.
The point that requires consideration is whether the
Trial Court is justified in dismissing the suit.
-8NC: 2026:KHC:33915
RFA No. 2129 of 2010
HC-KAR
8.
not
The facts having been sufficiently stated, they do
warrant
repetition.
The
plaintiff
contends
that
the
suit-scheduled property was acquired by the first defendant in
1962 utilizing joint family funds, and therefore it must be
treated as ancestral property. Being governed by Mitakshara
law, the plaintiff asserts that he has a share in the said
property. Consequently, the first defendant could not have
validly gifted the property in favor of the second defendant. On
this premise, the plaintiff approached the Court of law seeking
relief.
The plaintiff contended that there existed a joint family
and that the suit-scheduled property was joint family property.
To substantiate this contention, reliance was placed upon oral
evidence, coupled with the allegation that the father had
utilized joint family funds by selling property under Ex.P9.
Before this Court, the plaintiff adhered to the same contention.
However, such contention cannot be sustained. The
record discloses that there was no joint family, much less a
joint
family
fund,
available
for
the
purchase
of
the
suit-scheduled property. The oral evidence indicates that the
-9NC: 2026:KHC:33915
RFA No. 2129 of 2010
HC-KAR
plaintiff was residing separately. An attempt was nevertheless
made to contend that, owing to the distance between his
workplace and the family residence, he had to reside at
Sheshadripuram, which was nearer to his place of employment.
The evidence further establishes that, at the time of
purchase of the suit-scheduled property in 1962, no joint family
property was in existence. The plaintiff himself admitted that
his father had no landed property at Telagarahalli. Apart from
stating that the house property belonged to his grandfather,
that it was joint family property, and that his father sold the
said house property to purchase the suit-scheduled property,
the plaintiff has failed to substantiate his claim. Consequently,
he has not established that the suit-scheduled property was
joint family property in which he had a right. The plaintiff
cannot place reliance upon the oral testimony of PWs.2 and 3,
who were merely residents of the village. Since they are not
members of the family, they would have no knowledge of the
nature of the property or of its disposal by the father in 1962.
A considerable argument was advanced regarding the
sale deed at Ex.P9 and the alleged advance amount received by
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC:33915
RFA No. 2129 of 2010
HC-KAR
the father for purchasing the suit-scheduled property. Except
for the bare assertion that the advance amount was utilized for
such purchase, there is no material on record to demonstrate
that there was an agreement for the sale of the house, or that
the father had indeed received such amount and applied it
towards the purchase.
Under Mitakshara law, the general presumption is that
property standing in the name of an individual is his separate
property, unless it is shown that it was acquired from joint
family funds or by utilizing income from ancestral property.
Therefore, if the
plaintiff claims
that
the
suit-scheduled
property is joint family property, he must establish this fact by
producing cogent evidence. Mere assertions or oral testimony
without documentary proof (such as records showing the
existence of a joint family nucleus or income from ancestral
property) are insufficient. The Apex Court, in a catena of
decisions, has consistently held that the person who alleges
that a property is joint family property must prove the
existence of a joint family nucleus and its utilization in
acquiring the property. Without such proof, the property is
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC:33915
RFA No. 2129 of 2010
HC-KAR
presumed to be self-acquired. Thus, the settled position of law
is
that,
whenever
a
suit
is
filed
asserting
that
the
suit-scheduled property is joint family property and that the
plaintiff has a share therein, the burden lies upon the plaintiff
to prove the existence of a joint family and a nucleus sufficient
for the acquisition of the property. In the present case, both
these essential elements are absent.
The contention that the second defendant committed
fraud upon the first defendant in obtaining a gift deed is equally
untenable. It is pivotal to note that the first defendant himself
executed the gift deed in the year 2001 and thereafter died in
2004. If indeed there had been any fraud, nothing prevented
the first defendant from seeking cancellation of the gift deed
during his lifetime. Section 31 of the Specific Relief Act also
contemplates such relief. Accordingly, the plea of fraud raised
by the plaintiff cannot be sustained. The point is answered
accordingly.
9.
The appeal is devoid of merit, and hence it is to be
dismissed. Resultantly, the Regular First Appeal is dismissed.
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC:33915
RFA No. 2129 of 2010
HC-KAR
Because of dismissal of the appeal, interim order granted
if any stands discharged and pending interlocutory applications
if any are disposed of.
SD/(JYOTI M)
JUDGE
SS/MRP
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 1
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review