Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010601542012
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3457]
MONDAY,THE NINTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE HARINATH.N
WRIT PETITION NO: 5102/2012
Between:
1. B. NELAKANTA, S/O YANGAMUNI, DRIVER R/O D.NO.4-2-692,
SOMANATH NAGAR, ANANTAPUR
2. S. MADAR,, S/O S. DASTAGIRI, DRIVER R/O D.NO.19-110-A-28744, S.K.D.NAGAR ANANTAPUR
3. A PRASAD,, S/O KARIBASAPPA, DRIVER R/O UPPARAPALLI,
ANANTAPUR DISTRICT,
4. C.C.S.RAYUDU,, S/O SUBBA RAYUDU, DRIVER R/O D.NO.6-17,
GANESH NAGAR, ANANTAPUR
5. K. DASTA GIRI,, S/O BABIA, DRIVER R/O 2-2-296, GARLADINA
MANDA & POST, ANANTAPUR DISTRICT.
6. P.V. NARAYANA,, S/O VENKATESULU, DRIVER R/O 11-310,
ARAVIND NAGAR, ANANTAPUR
7. P. CHALAPATHI,, S/O P. LAKSHMANNA, DRIVER R/O D.NO.5/208A,
OPP: ENGINEERING COLLEGE, CHINMYANAGAR, ANANTAPUR
8. N. SHANKARAYYA,, S/O N. SUBBARAYUDU, DRIVER
D.NO.286-7, OPP: RDT OFFICE, 9TH CROSS, ANANTAPUR
R/O
9. S. BASHA,, S/O S.K.DIVAN SAHEB, DRIVER R/O 1/2/20-H, BEHIND
MRO OFFICE, B.K.S. ANANTAPUR
10. C. VENKAT NARAYANA SWAMY,, S/O C NARAYANA SWAMY,
DRIVER R/O D.NO.1-3-676, SOMANATH NAGAR, ANANTAPUR.
11. S. MAHABOOB BASHA,, S/O S KHADAR BASHA, DRIVER R/O
D.NO.28/1-273, BUDDAPA NAGAR, ANANTAPUR DISTRICT.
12. S. GANGE REDDY,, S/O NARASIMHA REDDY, DRIVER D.NO.7/322,
GANDHI ROAD, NARPALA ROAD, BUKARAYASAMUDRAM,
ANANTAPUR DISTRICT.
13. V.J.S.ACHARI,, S/O ESWARAIAH ACARI, DRIVER R/O TELIKI
POST, PEDDAVADUGURU MANDAL, ANANTAPUR DISTRICT.
14. ALIPERA, S/O PEDHA LALEPPA, DRIVER R/O D.NO.4-953,
K.L.D.ROAD, PAPAMPETTA, ANANTAPUR.
15. P. SHIVA KUMAR,, S/O SHANKARARAO, DRIVER
GARLADENNI POST OFFICE STREET, ANANTAPUR
R/O
16. P. AYUBKHAN,, S/O P. SOHEBKHAN, R/O D.NO.10-1092-12-1A,
OPP: IOC PETROL BUND, GAJJALA REDDYPALLI, KADIRI,
17. P.V.SUKUMAR REDDY,, S/O P. RAMALINGA REDDY, DRIVER R/O
POOLAVANDLLAPALLI VILLAGE, PEDDANNAVARIPALLI POST,
TALUPULA MANDAL, KADIRI,
18. P. ANJANEYULU,, S/O P. CHANDRA RAYUDU, DRIVER R/O
NALLACHERUVU
MANDAL,
G.MALLIREDDYPALLI
POST,
ANANTAPUR DISTRICT.
19. S.MADHAR VALI,, S/O HYDERVALI, DRIVER R/O D.NO.2-57,
MALLAMEDEPALLI POST :& :VIL;LA;G;E, GANDLAPENTA MANDAL,
ANANTAPUR DISTRICT.
20. P.V.REDDY,,
S/O
P.
OBJESH
REDDY,
DRIVER
R/O
GOVENDARAJUPALLI VILLAGE, PANIYANICHERUVU POST,
N.P.KUNTA MANDAL,
21. E.BALU NAIK,, S/O E. BADDE NAIK, DRIVER R/O GOLLAPALLI
THANDA VADALAPALLI POST, TALUPULA MANDAL, ANANTAPUR
DISTRICT.
22. G. VENKATA RAMANA,, S/O G. GANGI SETTY, DRIVER, R/O NEAR
MRO OFFICERS, TALUPALA POST & MANDAL, ANANTAPUR
DISTRICT.
23. B. KESHAVA,, S/O B. VEMANNA, DRIVER, R/O D.NO.2-8-189,
ROTARIPURAM, PULIVENDULA, Y.S.R. DISTRICT.
24. S. ALLABAKASH,, S/O S. MASTAN, DRIVER R/O YEGUVALINGELE
POST, PULIVENDULA, Y.S.R.DISTRICT.
...PETITIONER(S)
AND
1. THE VICE CHAIRMAN
MANAGING
MUSHIRABAD, HYDERABAD.
DIRECTOR,
APSRTC.,
2. THE REGIONAL MANAGER, APSRTC., ANANTAPUR REGION,
ANANTAPUR.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Counsel for the Petitioner(S):
1. P NAGENDRA REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. ARAVALA RAMA RAO(SC FOR APSRTC KKAC)
2. K VISWANATHAM (SC FOR APSRTC)
The Court made the following:
ORDER:Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners, submits that the petitioners
were recruited as casual drivers after having successfully completed the selection
process in pursuance of notification dated 22.11.1999. The respondents initially
notified the vacancies of 160 casual drivers and thereafter, 40 more vacancies were
added to the notification. The petitioners were recruited on casual basis in the year
1999 and have joined the respective place of postings soon after the selection
process was completed.
2.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners submits that the respondent
authorities had regularized the services of several casual drivers, except the
petitioners and the regularization was in the year 1999-2002. It is further submitted
that though the petitioners were disengaged for a specified of time, they were again
re-engaged and had completed 240 days of service in a year which entitles them for
seeking regularization of their services. It is also submitted that several such casual
drivers working in the respondent organization were regularized from the date of
their initial appointment.
It is submitted that the petitioners were regularized on
05.10.2007 vide proceedings dated 15.10.2007. It is further submitted that the casual
drivers who were recruited in the same notification were regularized in the year
1999-2002. However, the petitioners were not regularized on par with the other
casual drivers who are selected along with the petitioners in pursuance of the very
same notification.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioners, places reliance on the judgment passed
by this Court in W.P.No.16379 of 2011, whereby this Court directed the respondents
therein to regularize the services of the petitioners with effect from the date of on
which they were selected in persons of the notification. A further direction to
complete the said process within a period of two months was issued to the
respondents. It is also submitted that in pursuance of the said notification and in
pursuance of the orders of this Court, the petitioners therein were regularized from
the date of their initial appointment. It is submitted that the petitioners have been
extended a different yardstick insofar as regularization of their services is concerned.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioners further submits that the casual drivers
working in Anantapur depot were regularized from the date of their initial
appointments and several employees working in the respondent organization as
casual drivers were extended the said benefits including the employees working at
Falaknuma depot. It is submitted that the respondents have chosen to deny the
regularization of the petitioners from the date of initial appointment and as such claim
that they are entitled and their services are on par with the other casual drivers who
are regularized.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioners also placed reliance on the judgment of
the Hon'ble Supreme Court in The Divisional Manager, APSRTC and others Vs.
P.Lakshmoji Rao and others1, whereby, the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that if any
casual drivers junior to the respondents in the relevant seniority list of the concerned
Division/Region, have got the benefit of seniority and regularization or are entitled to
get the same by virtue of the judgments that have become final, then the
respondents who are seniors to them, shall be given the same benefit on the same
principle.
6.
Learned Standing Counsel appearing for the respondents, submits that the
petitioners were regularized vide Proceedings dated 15.10.2007 and it is submitted
2004 (16) AIC 546
that their regularization could be possible only after a regular vacancy arose in the
said Depot/Region. It is submitted that the petitioners’ services cannot be considered
as the services on par with the other casual drivers working in other regions. Each
Depot/Region would be considered as a separate unit and recruitment and postings
would be depending on the available vacancies therein. As such, the regularization
from the date of regularization of other casual drivers working in other regions cannot
be extended to the petitioners as the regularization of those casual drivers working in
those regions was completely dependent on the available vacancies in that specific
Depot/Region.
7.
Learned counsel for the respondents also submits that mere completion of
240 days of continuous service cannot ipso facto make the petitioners eligible for
regularization. It is also submitted that the petitioners are claiming for regularization
from the year 1999 and have challenged the Proceedings issued on 15.10.2007 after
lapse of five years, as such on the delay and latches also the writ petition would
have to be dismissed.
8.
Learned counsel for the respondents placed reliance on the judgments of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in 1) Gangadhar Pillai Vs. Siemens Limited2 2) Divisional
Manager, A.P.S.R.T.C and others Vs. P.Lakshmoji Rao and others 3 and
3) Regional Manager, A.P.S.R.T.C Vs. N.Satyanarayana and others4.
9.
Heard the learned counsel for the petitioners and learned Standing Counsel
for the respondents.
10.
Perused the record.
(2007) 1 SCC 533
(2004) 2 SCC 433
(2008) 1 SCC 210
11.
The claim of the petitioners seeking regularization from the date of their initial
appointment cannot considered by this Court, as the regularization of their services
would be completely dependent on the available vacancies in all particular
Depot/Region. Petitioner Nos.4 and 15 have attained the age of superannuation
during the pendency of the writ petition.
12.
That apart, the petitioners cannot claim their services on par with the services
of other casual drivers who are regularized in the other regions. The stand of the
respondents that the petitioners were regularized soon after the vacancies arose in
that particular region cannot be found fault with as the respondents could not have
regularized the petitioners’ services from an earlier date when there were no
available vacancies. However, considering the observation of the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in Lakshmoji Rao's case, needless to mention that the petitioners will have to
be given the benefit of placing them on par with other casual drivers who are
regularized in the same depot and who are recruited in pursuance of the same
notification.
13.
It is made clear that the petitioners’ services would have to be regularized
from the date of regularization of any of the juniors working in the same division and
who are also recruited in the same notification. Any regularization of juniors to the
petitioners would indicate that the petitioners were discriminated as compared to the
juniors of the petitioners. The observation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Lakshmoji Rao’s case referred above would have to be extend the petitioners,
insofar as regularizing their services on part with any of the juniors of the petitioners
were also recruited as per the notification, dated 22.11.1999.
14.
Accordingly, the Writ Petition is disposed of. No order as to costs.
Pending miscellaneous petitions, if any, shall stand closed.
____________________
JUSTICE HARINATH.N
Date.09.03.2026
SR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review