Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 11th DAY OF MARCH 2026
BEFORE
THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE H. T. NARENDRA PRASAD
WRIT PETITION NO. 34531 OF 2025(S-RES)
BETWEEN:
1.
B LATHA
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS
W/O RAMEGOWDA B N
2.
PADMA T
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS
W/O NAGARAJA H M
3.
RAGHAVENDRA B S
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS
S/O B M SHANKAR
4.
SHYAMALA N
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS
W/O S RAMAMOHAN
5.
GAYATHRI S
AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS
W/O S V RAMGOPAL
6.
HEMALATHA R B
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS
D/O LATE BASANAGOUDA
7.
K R GANGADARAIAH
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS
S/O LATE RAMAKRISHNAIAH
8.
DHANA LAKSHMI S
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS
W/O PRAKASH
9.
SAVITHA DEVI T.E
AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
W/O MAILARAPPA K SHAVI
10.
NATARAJA S N
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS
S/O LATE NAGARAJ S
11.
J AROKIANATHAN
AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS
S/O JOSEPH
12.
GIRIDHARA M
AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS
S/O MANJUNATHA
13.
MANJUNATHA Y H
AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS
S/O LATE K HUCHEGOWDA
14.
R SIDDARAJU
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS
S/O RAMAIAH
15.
FAKIRAPPA SALI
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS
S/OMAHADEVAPPA SALI
16.
DEVIRI
AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
W/O NAGARAJ S
17.
N NAGASHREE
AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS
W/O BHARATHKUMAR S
18.
SIDDANAGOWDA N A
AGED BOUT 48 YEARS
S/O A NAGESHAPPA
19.
N SUKANYA
AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS
W/O K RAMU
20.
RAMESH K
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS
S/O KRISHNAMURTHY
21.
KARUNAKARA K S
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS
S/O LATE SANJEEVA BHANDARI
22.
DORESWAMY A N
AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS
S/O LATE NANJEGOWDA
23.
SAVITHA R S
AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS
W/O NARENDRA BABU N
24.
REVATHI M
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS
W/O RAMESH K
25.
SAMPOORNA J K
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS
W/O GIRIS B MANGANNAVAR
26.
BHARATHI S
AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS
W/O LATE JAYAPRAKASH
27.
SATISH REDDY K V
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS
S/O LATE VENKATA REDDY
28.
B S NAGARAJA
AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS
S/O B SUBRAMANYAM
29.
K SHANTHALA NAIK
AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
W/O SHRIDHAR NAIK
30.
THEJASHWINI S N
AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS
W/O N MANJUNATH
31.
VANISHREE V
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS
W/O DEVARAJU
32.
GEETHA R C
AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS
W/O GIRISH K
33.
YASHAVANTH G M
AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS
S/O LATE GOPAL RAO K
34.
ROOPA S
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS
W/O ASHWATH K R
35.
SOWMYA RANI J
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS
W/O SURESH B K
36.
BINDU R
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS
W/O SATISH BABU S
ALL THE ABOVE PETITIONERS ARE
CURRENTLY WORKING IN THE
ESTABLISHMENT OF THE
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
AS COURT OFFICERS, AT THE PRINCIPAL BENCH
BENGALURU-560001.
... PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. PRITHVEESH M K, ADVOCATE FOR
SRI SAMEER SHARMA, ADVOCATE)
AND
THE HON’BLE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
REPRESENTED BY
REGISTRAR GENERAL, HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
HIGH COURT BUILDINGS
OPPOSITE VIDHANA SOUDHA
AMBEDKAR VEEDHI, BENGALURU-560 001.
... RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. D R RAVISHANKAR, SENIOR ADVOCATE FOR
SMT. KRUTIKA RAGHAVAN, ADVOCATE )
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227
OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO ISSUE A WRIT OF
CERTIORARI OR ANY OTHER APPROPRIATE WRIT ORDER
OR
DIRECTION QUASHING INTIMATION BEARING NO. HCE 873/2013 (SO
& CO) DATED: 25.04.2025, ISSUED BY THE RESPONDENT AS BEING
ARBITRARY, ILLEGAL, AND CONTRARY TO THE HIGH COURT OF
KARNATKA SERVICE (CONDITIONS OF SERVICE AND RECRUITMENT
RULES 1973 (ANNEXURE-A).
THIS WRIT PETITION, HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED
FOR ORDERS ON 19.02.2026, COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT,
THIS DAY, THE COURT, MADE THE FOLLOWING:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.T. NARENDRA PRASAD
CAV ORDER
This writ petition is filed under Articles 226 and
227 of the Constitution of India, challenging the
intimation dated 25.04.2025 vide Annexure-A issued
by the Registrar General, High Court of Karnataka, to
the petitioners.
communicated
By the said intimation it was
that,
as
per
the
High
Court
of
Karnataka (Conditions of Service and Recruitment)
Rules, 1973 (for short, ‘1973 Rules’), promotion to the
cadre of Assistant Registrar shall initially be made only
from the feeder cadre of Section Officers until their
strength in the cadre of Assistant Registrars reaches
35 posts and that, upon achieving the ratio of 2:1,
i.e., 35 posts from the cadre of Section Officers and
18 posts from the cadre of Court Officers, future
promotions shall be maintained in the same proportion
in
the
cadre
strength.
Accordingly,
their
representations with respect to up-gradation of posts
have been rejected.
2. The facts of the case are that the petitioners
are working as Court Officers in the respondent
establishment. As per the 1973 Rules, the next
promotional avenue for Court Officers is to the post of
Assistant Registrar. The said post is to be filled by
promotion from two feeder cadres, namely, Section
Officers and Court Officers, in the ratio of 2:1,
respectively.
3.
Since
considered
for
the
petitioners
promotion,
were
they
not
being
submitted
a
representation dated 30.10.2014 vide Annexure-D1,
seeking up-gradation of their pay scale on par with
that of Assistant Registrars by re-designating them as
Court Masters. They also sought up-gradation of the
pay scale of Assistant Court Officers to the next higher
level by re-designating them as Assistant Court
Masters. Subsequently, similar representations dated
04.03.2020, 24.01.2022, 20.06.2023 and 06.08.2024
vide
Annexures
D2,
D3,
D4
and
E
were
also
submitted.
4. By the impugned intimation dated 25.04.2025
vide Annexure-A, their request has been rejected. It
was also stated that promotion to the cadre of
Assistant Registrar would be governed by cadre
strength henceforth. Being aggrieved by the same,
the petitioners are before this Court.
5. Sri Prithveesh M.K., the learned counsel
appearing for the petitioners has raised the following
contentions:
(i) Firstly, the petitioners sought up-gradation
and re-designation of the posts of Court Officers and
the Assistant Court Officers, and also sought refixation of the ratio for promotion to the post of
Assistant Registrar through multiple representations.
Contrary to their requests, the impugned intimation
vide Annexure-A has been issued.
(ii) Secondly, the Section Officers had sought
rectification of the alleged anomaly in the ratio for
promotion to the post of Assistant Registrars. The
operative portion of Annexure-A states that their
representations have been rejected. However, the
body of the intimation letter suggests that their
request was considered favourably. He contends that
the impugned order cannot simultaneously grant relief
and reject the representation.
(iii) Thirdly, as per Rule 7 of the 1973 Rules,
recruitment to a post or class of posts is by promotion
on the basis of seniority-cum-merit from the cadres of
Section Officers and Court Officers in the ratio of 2:1.
The ratio must therefore apply to the vacancies
existing at the time of appointment and not to the
overall
cadre
strength.
Therefore,
there
is
no
ambiguity in the 1973 Rules, warranting issuance of
any clarification or correction by way of an intimation.
In support of his contention, he relied upon the
judgment of the Allahabad High Court in the case of
K.K.TIWARI AND OTHERS vs. UNION OF INDIA
AND OTHERS reported in
2001 SCC Online All
1024, which has been affirmed by the Apex Court in
(2008) 5 SCC 741. Therefore, he contends that the
intimation issued by the respondent vide Annexure-A
is unsustainable in law.
(iv) Fourthly, until issuance of the impugned
intimation vide Annexure-A, promotions to the post of
Assistant Registrar were being made in the ratio of
2:1 on the basis of vacancies arising at the time of
recruitment or promotion. The 1973 Rules specifically
provide that the post of Assistant Registrar shall be
filled by promotion from the feeder cadres in the ratio
of 2:1 based on the ‘vacancies’ available at the time of
recruitment or promotion. If the respondent intends to
change the 1973 Rules, the same must be done by
amending the 1973 Rules in accordance with the
procedure prescribed by law. The respondent has no
authority to alter the method of recruitment by issuing
an
intimation
letter
as
per
Annexure-A.
Hence,
Annexure-A has been issued without authority of law.
(v) Lastly, by a plain reading of Rule 7 and
Schedule III of the 1973 Rules, it is seen that there is
no ambiguity in the 1973 Rules. If the quota is
prescribed for recruitment to a post or class of posts,
the quota rule will have to be observed at the
recruitment stage. The quota would be then correlated
to the vacancies to be filled in by recruitment. Once
the recruitment is made from two different sources,
they will have to be integrated into a common cadre.
In support of his contention, he has relied on the
Judgment of the Apex Court in the case of STATE OF
PUNJAB AND OTHERS vs. DR.R.N.BHATNAGAR
AND ANOTHER reported in (1999) 2 SCC 330.
Hence, he sought for allowing the writ petition.
6. Sri D.R.Ravishankar, the learned Senior
Counsel appearing for the respondent raised the
following contentions:
(i)
Under the Schedule III, Item No.6 of the
1973 Rules, recruitment to the posts of Assistant
Registrar and Assistant Registrar (Protocol) is by
promotion on the basis of seniority-cum-merit from
the cadres of Section Officers and Court Officers in the
ratio of 2:1. The Rule does not specify whether such
ratio is to be applied on the basis of roster, vacancy,
or cadre strength. When there is ambiguity in the
Rules, the decision of the Chief Justice is final.
Therefore, Annexure-A has been issued in conformity
with the 1973 Rules. In support of his contention, he
relied
on
the
order
passed
by
this
Court
in
W.P.No.4808/2022 and connected matter disposed of
on
26.11.2024,
as
well
as
W.A.No.4411/2011
disposed of on 12.10.2011.
(ii) Secondly, under the proviso to Rule 7 of the
1973 Rules, the Chief Justice has the power to amend
the Rules. Accordingly, the Committee constituted by
the Chief Justice has taken a decision that, for
recruitment to the post of Assistant Registrar, the
ratio has to be maintained with reference to cadre
strength. Further, the Committee’s decision has been
approved
by
the
Chief
Justice.
Accordingly,
the
impugned intimation has been issued and the same is
in conformity with the proviso to Rule 7 of the 1973
Rules.
(iii) Thirdly, the judgment cited by the learned
counsel for the petitioner, i.e., DR.R.N.BHATNAGAR
(supra), relates to an issue concerning roster points.
Therefore, the said case is not applicable to the facts
of the present case.
(iv) Fourthly, the order passed by the Allahabad
High Court in K.K.TIWARI (supra) is distinguishable,
as in that case, the Rule itself provided for filling up of
the vacancies, and the same was affirmed by the Apex
Court in (2008) 5 SCC 741. Therefore, the said
judgment is not applicable to the facts of the present
case.
Hence, he sought for dismissal of the writ
petition.
7.
By
way
of
rejoinder,
learned
counsel
appearing for the petitioners submitted that even if
the Chief Justice intends to amend the 1973 Rules
with respect to fixing the ratio based on cadre
strength, such amendment has to be notified in the
Official Gazette, and only thereafter would it come
into force. No such Gazette Notification has been
published. In furtherance of the same, he also relied
on Section 21 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 to
contend that the “power to issue,
rescind
notifications,
orders,
amend, vary or
rules
or
bye-laws,
includes a power, exercisable in the like manner and
subject to the like sanction and conditions if any, to
add to, amend, vary or rescind any notifications,
orders, rules or bye-laws so issued” and hence the
prescribed procedure must be followed. Therefore, he
sought allowing of the writ petition.
8. Heard the learned counsel for the parties.
Perused the writ petition papers.
9. The main contention of the learned counsel
for the petitioners is that there is no ambiguity in the
1973 Rules. He submits that the Rules governing
promotion to the post of Assistant Registrar are clear
and unambiguous and that as per the 1973 Rules, the
2:1 ratio has to be applied at the time of filling up of
vacancies and not for maintaining the cadre strength
in the ratio of 2:1.
10. To consider this point, it is necessary to
extract certain portions of the 1973 Rules. In exercise
of the powers conferred under Article 229(2) of the
Constitution of India, the Chief Justice, with the
approval of the Governor of Karnataka, except in
respect of the Rules related to salaries, allowances,
leave, and pension, has framed the 1973 Rules. In
1973 Rules, Rule 2(a) defines, “Chief Justice” as the
Chief Justice of the High Court of Karnataka, and Rule
2(d), “Court servant” means a member of the High
Court Service. Rule 5 deals with the “Appointing
Authority” and provides that all appointments to the
service shall be made by the Chief Justice. Rule 7
deals with the “method of recruitment” and states that
recruitment to a post or class of posts shall be made
by the Chief Justice as enumerated in Schedule III of
these Rules. In Schedule III, the relevant provision for
consideration in this case pertains to the cadre of
Assistant Registrars. The relevant portion of the Rule
is extracted below:
“Assistant
Registrar
By promotion on the basis of seniority-cumefficiency from the cadres of Section
Officers, Court Officers and Senior Judgment
Writers.
(i) The quota of Senior Judgment Writers
has been increased from 5 to 6;
(ii) The ratio between Court Officers and
Sections Officers for promotions to the
remaining 18 posts shall be maintained at
2:1 respectively for a period of three years.
At the end of three years, the ratio shall
stand reverted to 1:1 between Court Offices
and Section Officers.
(iii) Cadre review shall be done at the end of
three years.”
11. Subsequently, Schedule-III of the 1973
Rules was amended on 28.05.2009 in respect of
Assistant Registrar/ Assistant Registrar (Protocol).
The relevant portion of the Rules is extracted below:
“SI.
No
Cadre
Existing
method
recruitment
of
Assistant Registrar/
Assistant Registrar
(Protocol)
By promotion on the basis
seniority-cum efficiency from the
cadres of Section Officers, Court
Officers and Senior Judgement
Writers.
(i) The quota of Senior Judgement
Writers has been increased from 5
to 6;
(ii) The ratio between Court
Officers and Section Officers to
promotions the remaining 18 posts
shall be at 2:1 maintained
respectively for a period of three
years, the ratio shall stand
reverted to 1:1 between Court
Officers and Section Officers.
Amendment substituted in the
place of existing method of
recruitment
By promotion by selection on
basis of Merit-cum-efficiency
from the cadre of Section
Officers, Court Officers Senior
Judgment
Writers
who
possess Degree in Law from
the University established
under Law in the ratio of 2:1:1.
Explanation: 1. The present
members who do not possess
Law Degree, shall qualify
themselves, without affecting
the regular work, with prior
permission of Hon'ble the
Chief Justice, within a period
of five years, failing which they
shall not be entitled for further
promotion.
(iii) Cadre review shall be done at
the end of three years.
The
permission
is
not
automatic, but subject to the
(Out of the total number of posts interest of the Institution. Such
of Assistant Registrar, 1/5th posts permission shall not take away
shall be reserved for being filled the rights of the senior
up from the cadres of Senior employees and does not
Judgement Writers. However, confer the undue privileges on
initially the existing and future the junior employees. The
vacancies shall be filled up in the qualification obtained without
ratio 2:2:1 from the cadres of following the above norms
Section Officers, Court Officers would not be taken into
and Senior Judgement Writers, consideration, till they come
respectively,
till
the
quota within
the
zone
of
reserved for senior judgement consideration.
writers is realised and thereafter
whenever a post held by an Note:1)
For
securing
incumbent coming from the cadre minimum
qualification
of senior judgement writers fall prescribed for this cadre within
vacant, such vacancy shall be stipulated time, the permission
filled up only from the cadre of may be liberally granted.
Senior Judgement Writers. The
other vacancies shall be filled up 2) The period of time
from the cadres of Section prescribed
for
securing
Officers and Court Officers by minimum qualification (i.e., five
rotation.
years) starts from the date of
permission.”
NOTE:- The seniority of Senior
Judgement Writers posted as
Section Officers of Judicial Wing
Typing pool. Paper Book Section
and copying Branches I and II, if
any, shall be counted for purpose
of seniority in the cadre of Senior
Judgement Writers.
12. Again, the said Rule was amended on
15.02.2013. The relevant amended Rule in respect of
Assistant Registrar & Assistant Registrar (Protocol) is
extracted below:
“SI.
No
Cadre
Existing
method
recruitment
of
Assistant Registrar/
Assistant Registrar
(Protocol)
By promotion by selection on
basis of Merit-cum-efficiency
from the cadre of Section Officer,
Court
Officer
and
Senior
Judgment Writer who possess
Degree in law from the University
established under Law in the
ratio of 2:1:1
OR
If no eligible candidate is
available among the Section
Officers/Court
Officers/Senior
Judgment Writers, by deputation
among the Judicial Officers in the
cadre of Civil Judge (Sr.Dn.)
Explanation: 1. The present
members who do not possess
Law
Degree,
shall
qualify
themselves, without affecting the
Amendment substituted in the
place of existing method of
recruitment
By Promotion on the basis of
Seniority-cum-merit from the
cadres of Section Officers and
Court Officers in the ratio of 2:1,
provided
that
they
have
completed
two
years
satisfactory service in the
feeder cadre
regular
work,
with
prior
permission of Hon'ble the Chief
Justice, within a period of five
years, failing which they shall not
be entitled for further promotion.
The permission is not automatic,
but subject to the interest of the
Institution. Such permission shall
not take away the rights of the
senior employees and does not
confer the undue privileges on
the
junior
employees.
qualification obtained without
following the above norms would
not be taken into consideration.
till they come within the zone of
consideration.
The
Note:- 1) For securing minimum
qualification prescribed for this
cadre within stipulated time, the
permission may be liberally
granted.
2) The period of time prescribed
for
securing
minimum
qualification (i.e., five years)
starts from the date of permission
13. Additionally, Rules 23 and 25 are extracted
below:
“23. Residuary Powers.-Nothing in these
rules shall be deemed to affect the power of
the Chief Justice to make such orders, from
time to time, as he may deem fit in regard to
all matters incidental or ancillary to these rules
(not specifically provided for herein or in
regard to matters as have not been sufficiently
provided for:
Provided that if any such order relates to
salaries, allowances, leave or pensions of Court
Servants the same shall be made with the
approval of the Governor.
………..
25. Interpretation.-All questions relating to the
interpretation of these rules shall be referred
to the Chief Justice, whose decision thereon
shall be final”:
14. Rule 23 of the 1973 Rules provides that, in
matters not specifically provided for therein or in
matters not sufficiently provided for, the Chief Justice
may issue orders from time to time as he may deem
fit, except in respect of salaries, allowances, leave, or
pension of Court servants, for which prior approval of
the Governor is required. Further, under Rule 25,
where
any
doubt
or
ambiguity
arises
in
the
interpretation of the 1973 Rules, the Chief Justice is
empowered to take a decision, and such decision of
the Chief Justice shall be final.
Therefore, it is very
clear that if there is an ambiguity in the Rules, the
decision of the Chief Justice is final.
15. However, in the rule under consideration in
the present case, there is no ambiguity. The rule is
clear and unambiguous. On a plain reading of Rule 7
along
with
‘recruitment’
Schedule
to
Registrar/Assistant
III,
the
it
is
post
Registrar
seen
that
of
Assistant
(Protocol)
is
the
by
promotion from the cadre of Section Officers and
Court Officers in the ratio of 2:1. Therefore, it is clear
that the 1973 Rules governing recruitment to the post
of Assistant Registrar states that the ratio has to be
maintained in respect of the arising vacancies.
The
expression “Recruitment” employed in Rule 7 r/w.
Schedule III of the 1973 Rules necessarily refers to
the act of filling up of vacancies to the concerned post.
16. The vacancies available at the time of
promotion have to be considered for the purpose of
applying the prescribed ratio of 2:1. The 1973 Rules
does not mention that ratio of 2:1 has to be
maintained
with
reference
to
the
overall
cadre
strength. Therefore, when the rule is clear and
unambiguous,
impugned
the
interpretation
intimation
at
adopted
Annexure–A
in
the
cannot
be
sustained. The decision to maintain the 2:1 ratio in
the cadre strength is contrary to Rule 7 read with
Schedule III of the 1973 Rules and cannot be upheld.
17. In R.K. SABHARWAL AND OTHERS
VS.
STATE OF PUNJAB AND OTHERS, reported in
(1995) 2 SCC 745, the issue arose in the context of
Article 16(4) of the Constitution of India. The Apex
Court
in
DR.
distinguished
R.N.
the
BHATNAGAR
judgment
in
(supra)
has
R.K.SABHARWAL
(supra), and held that once the recruitment is made
from two sources and once the candidate enters into
any cadre through an entry point reserved for them,
they get fused and blended into a single cadre and
their
birth
marks
get
obliterated,
while
further
distinguishing the applicability of the quota in terms of
Articles 16(1) and 16(4) of the Constitution of India.
The relevant portion is extracted below:
“8.
In
the
light
of
the
aforesaid
rival
contentions, the following points arise for our
determination:
(i) whether the interpretation of Rule 9(i)(d),
which appealed to the High Court, is a correct
one;
(ii) even if the roster operates on vacancies in
such a way that from the very inception of the
roster, vacancies on the first three roster
points will go to promotees and the vacancy on
the fourth roster point will go to a direct recruit
and similarly, in future for further vacancies,
whether the disputed 16th vacancy should go
to a direct recruit or a promotee;
(iii) if the answer to the first point is in the
negative, whether the ultimate decision of the
High Court can be sustained on the conjoint
reading of Rule 3 and Rule 9(i)(d) of the
statutory
rules
as
submitted
by
learned
counsel for the respondent; and
(iv) what final order?
We shall deal with the aforesaid points in the
same
sequence
in
which
they
are
noted
hereinabove.
Point 1
9. So far as the first point is concerned, the
High Court in the impugned judgment, has
heavily relied upon the Constitution Bench
decision of this Court in the case of R.K.
Sabharwal [(1995) 2 SCC 745 : 1995 SCC
(L&S) 548 : (1995) 29 ATC 481] . Now it has
to be kept in view that the Constitution Bench
of this Court in the aforesaid decision was
concerned with entirely a different question,
namely,
as
to
how
the
roster
indicating
reserved points in connection with reservation
of posts in a cadre to be filled in by Scheduled
Caste (for short “SC”), Scheduled Tribe (for
short “ST”) and Backward Class (for short
“BC”) candidates could be operated. Para 4 of
the Report lays down that: (SCC p. 750)
“4. When a percentage of reservation
is fixed in respect of a particular cadre
and the roster indicates the reserve
points, it has to be taken that the posts
shown at the reserve points are to be
filled from amongst the members of
reserve categories and the candidates
belonging to the general category are
not entitled to be considered for the
reserved posts.”
In this connection, reliance was placed by
the Constitution Bench on Article 16(4) of the
Constitution of India which permits the State
Government
to
make
any
provision
for
reservation of appointments or posts in favour
of any backward class of citizens which, in the
opinion of the State, was not adequately
represented in the services under the State. In
the light of the aforesaid scheme of the
Constitution,
the
Bench
had
to
consider
whether reservation of posts for SCs, STs and
BCs when sought to be secured by way of
operation
of
the
roster
could
permit
the
operation of the roster qua the posts or
vacancies in the cadre. It was noted in this
connection that if the roster operated on
vacancies, then it may happen that at a given
point of time, the percentage of reservation of
posts for SCs, STs and BCs may exceed the
permissible percentage of reservation. In para
of
the
Report,
it
was
observed
that
reservations provided under the impugned
government instructions permitted 16% of the
posts to be reserved for members of SCs and
BCs and it could be achieved by the roster to
be maintained in each Department. The roster
had to be implemented in the form of running
account from year to year. In connection with
“16% of the posts…” to be reserved for
members of SCs and BCs in promotional posts,
it was held as under: (SCC p. 751, para 5)
“When recruitment to a cadre starts then 14
posts earmarked in the (100 points) roster are
to be filled from amongst the members of the
Scheduled Castes. … When the total number of
posts in a cadre are filled by the operation of
the roster then the result envisaged by the
impugned instructions is achieved. In other
words, in a cadre of 100 posts when the posts
earmarked in the roster for Scheduled Castes
and
the
Backward
Classes
are
filled
the
percentage of reservation provided for the
reserved categories is achieved. We see no
justification to operate the roster thereafter.
The ‘running account’ is to operate only till the
quota
provided
under
the
impugned
instructions is reached and not thereafter.
Once the prescribed percentage of posts is
filled
the
numerical
test
of
adequacy
is
satisfied and thereafter the roster does not
survive.”
The
aforesaid
observations
which
were
heavily relied on by the High Court and are
also relied upon by the respondent's (writ
petitioner's) counsel before us, cannot be of
any assistance to the appellant-State on the
facts of the present case. The result is obvious.
As per Article 16(4) which carves out a
separate field for itself from the general sweep
of Article 16(1) which guarantees equality of
opportunity in matters of appointments in
government services to all citizens of India, the
reservation for these categories in employment
has to be achieved by earmarking the requisite
percentage of posts for the reserved category
of candidates and by pitchforking these posts
on roster points on requisite points' roster and
when such a roster takes a full cycle, posts
earmarked on reserved points will enable the
requisite reserved category of candidates to fill
up these posts. After that is done, the roster
would be treated to have achieved its purpose.
Whenever a reserved candidate vacated a
reserved post, the said post was liable to be
filled only by a candidate belonging to the
reserved category. If after the roster is first
operated and thereafter it is again operated on
future vacancies also, a situation may arise
wherein a cadre may get reserved category
exceeding the permitted quota of reservation.
It
is
to
avoid
this
contingency
that
the
Constitution Bench laid down in the aforesaid
decision as indicated therein. So far as Rule 9
of the Rules in the present case is concerned,
it has nothing to do with reservation of posts in
the cadre of Professors. It is not a rule of
reservation envisaged for a specified category
of persons as permitted by Article 16(4) of the
Constitution. On the contrary, it is a rule of
recruitment
from
two
different
sources,
namely, in case of Professor's cadre, 75% of
the posts has to be filled in by promotion while
25% by direct recruitment. These two sources
of recruitment permit departmental promotees
and direct recruits from the open market to get
absorbed in the cadre. They merely serve as
two entry points for the cadre. Rule 9 deals
with reservation of appointment to the posts of
Professor and does not deal with reservation of
posts of Professor for any special class or
category of candidates. It is well settled that
once recruitment is made from two sources,
i.e.,
departmental
promotees
and
direct
recruitment from the open market and once
the candidates concerned enter into any cadre
through entry point reserved for them, they
get fused and blended into one single cadre
and their birthmarks get obliterated. In this
connection,
we
may
usefully
refer
to
a
Constitution Bench decision of this Court in
State of J&K v. Triloki Nath Khosa [(1974) 1
SCC 19 : 1974 SCC (L&S) 49] . Chandrachud,
J.
(as
he
Constitution
then
was),
Bench
speaking
while
for
dealing
the
with
recruitment to a cadre from two sources,
namely, direct recruits and promotees in the
light of an earlier judgment of this Court in
Roshan Lal Tandon v. Union of India [AIR 1967
SC 1889 : (1968) 1 SCR 185] made the
following pertinent observations: (SCC p. 38,
paras 44-45)
“44. The key words of the judgment
are: ‘The recruits from both the sources
to Grade ‘D’ were integrated into one
class and no discrimination could
thereafter be made in favour of recruits
from one source as against the recruits
from the other source in the matter of
promotion to Grade ‘C’.' (emphasis
supplied) By this was meant that in the
matter of promotional opportunities to
Grade ‘C’, no discrimination could be
made between promotees and direct
recruits by reference to the source from
which they were drawn. That is to say,
if apprentice Train Examiners who were
recruited directly to Grade ‘D’ as Train
Examiners formed one common class
with skilled artisans who were promoted
to Grade ‘D’ as Train Examiners, no
favoured treatment could be given to
the former merely because they were
directly recruited as Train Examiners
and no discrimination could be made as
against the latter merely because they
were promotees. This is the true
meaning of the observation extracted
above and no more than this can be
read into the sentence next following:
‘To put it differently, once the direct
recruits and promotees are absorbed
into one cadre, they form one class and
they cannot be discriminated for the
purpose of further promotion to the
higher Grade ‘C’.' In terms, this was
just a different way of putting what had
preceded.
45. Thus, all that Roshan Lal case
[AIR 1967 SC 1889 : (1968) 1 SCR
185] lays down is that direct recruits
and promotees lose their birthmarks on
fusion into a common stream of service
and they cannot thereafter be treated
differently
by
reference
to
the
consideration that they were recruited
from different sources. Their genetic
blemishes disappear once they are
integrated into a common class and
cannot be revived so as to make equals
unequals once again.”
It has, therefore, to be appreciated that
when posts in a cadre are to be filled in from
two sources, whether the candidate comes
from the source of departmental promotees or
by way of direct recruitment, once both of
them enter a common cadre, their birthmarks
disappear and they get completely integrated
in the common cadre. This would be in
consonance with the thrust of Article 16(1) of
the Constitution of India. No question of
exception to the said general thrust of the
constitutional provision would survive as Article
16(4) would be out of the picture in such a
case. Consequently, the decision rendered by
the Constitution Bench in R.K. Sabharwal case
[(1995) 2 SCC 745 : 1995 SCC (L&S) 548 :
(1995) 29 ATC 481] in connection with Article
16(4) and the operation of roster for achieving
the reservation of posts for SCs, STs, and BCs
as per the scheme of reservation cannot be
pressed into service for the present scheme of
Rule 9(1) is not as per Article 16(4) but is
governed by the general sweep of Article
16(1). The attempt of learned counsel for the
respondent
to
treat
a
quota
rule
as
a
reservation rule would result in requiring the
State authorities to continue the birthmarks of
direct recruits and promotees even after they
enter the common cadre through two separate
entry points regulating their induction to the
cadre. Therefore, the roster for 3 promotees
and one direct recruit is to be continued every
time a vacancy arises and there is no question
of filling up a vacancy arising out of a
retirement of a direct recruit by a direct recruit
or on the retirement vacancy of a promotee by
a promotee. Consequently, the question of
rotating the vacancies as posts or for treating
the posts mentioned in the rules of recruitment
as necessarily referable to total posts in the
cadre at a given point of time in the light of
R.K. Sabharwal [(1995) 2 SCC 745 : 1995 SCC
(L&S) 548 : (1995) 29 ATC 481] judgment,
therefore, cannot survive for in the case of a
quota
rule
between
direct
recruits
and
promotees, the same is to be judged on the
touchstone of Article 16(1) and the statutory
rules governing the recruitment to the posts of
Professor
constituting
the
Punjab
Medical
Education Service (Class I) and not on the
basis of Article 16(4). The Division Bench in
the impugned judgment with respect wrongly
applied the ratio of R.K. Sabharwal case
[(1995) 2 SCC 745 : 1995 SCC (L&S) 548 :
(1995) 29 ATC 481] governing Article 16(4) to
the facts of the present case which are
governed by Article 16(1).”
18. The Rule 7 r/w. Schedule III of the 1973
Rules nowhere provides that the total cadre strength
of
Assistant
Registrars
has
to
be
consistently
maintained in 2:1 ratio from Section Officers and
Court Officers, respectively.
On the other hand, the
Rules are very clear that the ratio has to be
maintained at the time of filling up the vacancies. This
view is fortified by the Apex Court in the case of
K.K.TIWARI (supra).
The relevant paragraphs are
extracted below:
“23. Rule 7 on its bare reading does not
make reference to Schedule I, which provides
that 445 numbers of posts are to be held by
civilian officers in the cadre of EEs. The Rules
nowhere provide that the total strength of the
cadre of EEs has to be consistently maintained
in a manner that 2/3rd cadre is manned by
those who are promoted from the posts of
AEEs and 1/3rd cadre is manned by those who
have been promoted from the post of AEs. It
appears from the record that the entire basis
for issuing the Circular dated 29-7-1997 by
Respondent 2 was that in the cadre of EEs the
ratio of such officers who had been promoted
from the post of AEs had been depleted and
after calculation of the posts, the deficiency
has been found to the extent of 58 vacancies
and, therefore, the vacancies should be filled in
from amongst AEs only for a particular year
1997-1998.
24. The High Court, in our opinion, was
right in holding that such a direction in terms
of the circular of Respondent 2 did not find
support from the Rules as Rule 7 neither refers
to
Schedule
I
which
prescribes
the
total
strength of the cadre nor it provides anywhere
further that recruitment shall be made in a
manner so as to maintain the ratio of 2/3rd
and 1/3rd in the entire cadre for a particular
year. The language of Rule 7 is very clear and
unambiguous and it emphasises that after the
commencement of the Rules which came into
force on 9-7-1991, the vacancies shall be filled
in a manner provided in Schedule III. Schedule
III, as earlier noticed, prescribes that the post
of EEs shall be filled in the ratio of 66-2/3
posts to be filled on non-selection basis from
the grade of AEEs and 33-1/3 posts have to be
filled on selection basis from the post of AEs.
The expression “posts to be filled” used in the
rule clearly indicates and means that whenever
any selection is made to the post of EE, the
ratio, the criteria and the essential minimum
qualifying service in terms of Schedule III shall
have to be strictly followed and adhered to and
any promotion in excess of the quota will result
in breaking down the prescribed quota. Thus,
the language of Rule 7 read with Schedule III
governing the service conditions has to be read
harmoniously with meaningful construction. It
is not possible or advisable to interpret the
ratio of 2/3rd and 1/3rd as prescribed in
Schedule IV of Rule 7 in the manner that all
the 58 posts of EEs for the year 1997-1998
should be filled in by promotion from the cadre
of AEs only. If the claim of the appellants that
all 58 posts of EEs for the year 1997-1998 are
to be filled in by promotion from amongst the
AEs cadre only is accepted, then the quota rule
as prescribed by Rule 7 read with Schedule IV
shall break down with the result that the ratio
of 2/3rd and 1/3rd prescribed in the Rules for
AEEs and AEs has to be ignored and resultantly
a situation may arise when one cadre will get
excess quota as compared to other feeder
cadre. If we construe the Service Rules in right
perspective and read their provisions in a
harmonious manner then the desired result
can be achieved. If the interpretation which is
sought to be given by the learned Senior
Counsel for the appellants is to be accepted,
then it is likely to disturb the ratio in the cadre
strength of sanctioned strength. When the
Rules say that posts of EEs shall be filled in
from two channels i.e. AEEs and AEs in the
proportion of 66-2/3 and 33-1/3 respectively
we cannot ignore the intention of the Rules.”
19. From the above discussion, it is very clear
that Rule 7 r/w. Schedule III of 1973 Rules mandates
that a ratio of 2:1 has to be applied to the vacancies
that arise at the time of appointment or promotion to
the post in the cadre of Assistant Registrars. Once the
Section Officers and Court Officers enter the common
cadre of Assistant Registrar, they get fused and
blended into a single cadre and their source of
recruitment
loses
significance.
Unless
the
rules
specifically provide for maintaining the said ratio with
reference to the cadre strength, such requirement
cannot be read into the Rules. In the absence of any
such provision in the Rules, the prescribed ratio is
required to be maintained at the time of filling up the
vacancy.
20. As per the records made available to the
Court, before the amendment of the 2013 Rules,
recruitment to the post of Assistant Registrar from the
cadres of Section Officers, Court Officers, and Senior
Judgment Writers was in the ratio of 2:1:1. As per the
said quota, promotions were accorded to the eligible
Section Officers, Court Officers, and Senior Judgment
Writers in the ratio of 2:1:1 until the year 2013.
21. After the Rule was amended on 15.02.2013,
the promotion to the cadre of Assistant Registrar was
made from Section Officers and Court Officers in the
ratio of 2:1. Since 2013 till today, the same ratio has
been maintained and at no point of time has any
excess promotion been made either from the cadre of
Section Officers or Court Officers.
22. With respect to the judgment relied upon by
the respondent in W.P. No. 4808/2022, disposed of on
26.11.2024, the Karnataka Administrative Service
(Recruitment)
Rules
provided
that
50%
of
the
vacancies in KAS Group-A (Junior Scale) posts were to
be filled by promotion and the remaining 50% by
direct recruitment. The said rule was amended in
1995, whereby the expression “arising vacancies” was
specifically omitted with the intention of applying the
quota against the fixed cadre strength. In compliance
with the object of the amendment, the Government
issued an Official Memorandum dated 23.03.2016.
Therefore,
this
Memorandum.
challenged
Court
upheld
the
said
The
said
matter
has
before
the
Apex
Court
Nos.8261/2025,
7030/2025,
Official
also
been
in
SLP
23831/2025
and
19819/2025, in which leave has been granted and the
matters are pending consideration.
23.
In
view
of
the
above,
the
impugned
intimation is liable to be quashed.
24. Accordingly, the following order:
(i) The writ petition is allowed.
(ii)
The
impugned
intimation
dated
25.04.2025 vide Annexure-A is quashed.
Sd/(H. T. NARENDRA PRASAD)
JUDGE
CM/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review