Judgments
LegalFirms.in Judgments · legalfirms.in/judgments/aziz-musabhai-bandi-vs-state-of-gujarat-20260310/ · Printed 22 Nov 2026
Civil

Aziz Musabhai Bandi vs State of Gujarat

Add to a compilation

Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans

Court
Gujarat High Court
Date
10 March 2026
Case No.
SCA 3192/2026
Result
Dismissed
Bench
Honourable Mr. Justice Nirzar S. Desai
Cite this judgment
Citation
Link for your website or blog
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.

The court's order

The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.

10. Further, the facts of the decision cited in the case of Vegada Varsha Revashankar (Supra) and the reason for which the transfer was held to be bad and quashed and the petitioner was re-transferred are di>erent, and the terms of contract are also di>erent as well and Mr. Dave could not point out that the terms of contract were identical in the case of Vegada Varsha Revashankar (Supra) and in the case of the petitioner. Therefore, the said decision relied upon by learned advocate Mr. Dave would not help the petitioner.

11. Considering the fact that though it is termed as transfer, it is actually an o>er of new contract to the petitioner. The same cannot be treated or viewed as if it is a case of transfer and it is for the petitioner if he wants to join as per the new contract at a new place as per his choice and volition and if the petitioner Bnds that practically, economically or socially, it is not viable for him to accept the above o>er, the Court cannot force the State Government or the appropriate respondent authority to o>er a new contract to the petitioner at a place of his choice. C/SCA/3192/2026 JUDGMENT DATED: 10/03/2026 Accordingly, the petition is required to be dismissed and the same stands dismissed. (NIRZAR S. DESAI,J) Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judge.

Full Judgment Text

Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs, CC BY 4.0). The court's own copy is the authoritative text.

C/SCA/3192/2026 JUDGMENT DATED: 10/03/2026 IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO.3192 of 2026 FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE : HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE NIRZAR S. DESAI ========================================= Approved for Reporting Yes No NO ========================================= AZIZ MUSABHAI BANDI Versus STATE OF GUJARAT & ORS. ========================================= Appearance : MR ASHUTOSH S DAVE for the Petitioner. MS KINJAL VYAS, AGP for the Respondents. ========================================= CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE NIRZAR S. DESAI Date : 10/03/2026 ORAL JUDGMENT 1. By way of the present petition, the petitioner has challenged the order dated 31.12.2025 passed by the State Project Engineer, Gujarat Council of School Education, Vidhya Samiksha Kendra, Gandhinagar whereby upon completion of petitioner’s old contract, the petitioner was o>ered a new contract as TRP, Padra, Dist. Vadodara instead of petitioner’s earlier place of working as per old contract which had already lived its life as TRP, Mahemdabad. The petitioner has also prayed for quashing and setting aside the order dated 21.1.2026 whereby the petitioner was relieved from Mahemdabad, Kheda zone by respondent No.3. C/SCA/3192/2026 2. JUDGMENT DATED: 10/03/2026 At the outset, learned advocate Mr. Ashutosh Dave appearing for the petitioner submitted that though it is a well settled law that transfer is an incident of service, looking to the peculiar facts of the case, the present petition is required to be entertained. According to Mr. Dave, the petitioner was appointed as Civil Engineer on contractual basis under Sarva Sikshan Abhiyan on 4.2.2010 and he was posted at various places. Every time, upon completion of petitioner’s contract, new contract used to be o>ered to the petitioner in a di>erent District and the petitioner had already served in various districts. But this fact must end at some day and, therefore, when the petitioner was o>ered new contract at Padra, Dist. Vadodara vide order dated 3.1.12.2025, the petitioner has challenged the same by way of this petition. Mr. Dave further submitted that the petitioner has already been relieved from his duty as TRP, Mahemdabad vide order dated 21.1.2026 and, therefore, that order is also required to be quashed and the petitioner is required to be o>ered a new contract as TRP, Mahemdabad. 3. Mr. Dave also relied upon terms of the contract which was Brst time o>ered to the petitioner in the year 2010 and pointed out that terms do not state anything about the fact that the nature of the job of the petitioner would be a transferable job and, therefore, the petitioner’s transfer cannot be said to have been made legally or for any justiBable reason in absence of there being any speciBc clause about the fact that the nature of the petitioner’s job is transferable job. 4. In support of his submissions, Mr. Dave relied upon the decision of the coordinate Bench of this Court in the case of C/SCA/3192/2026 JUDGMENT DATED: 10/03/2026 Vegada Varsha Revashankar (Supra) v. State of Gujarat and others, delivered on 5.8.2015 in Special Civil Application No.12419 of 2015 wherein while allowing the petition and quashing and setting aside the impugned order of transfer, the coordinate Bench directed the State to re-transfer the petitioner to the place where she was earlier appointed after being selected to the post of Deputy Mamlatdar. Mr. Dave also relied upon paragraph 3 of the said decision which is based on a decision dated 11.6.2015 passed in Special Civil Application No.9191 of 2015 wherein in paragraph 15, the coordinate Bench observed that as the petitioner while having been o>ered a contractual job had no option but agree to the appointment on contractual basis on Bxed pay. The petitioners, therefore, were left with no choice but to compromise and work on a Bxed pay basis for a pittance, without any other beneBts associated with the Government services. Mr. Dave further submitted that in that case also, as the transfer was not done as per the ratio of 3 : 1 between the promotees and direct recruits, considering the totality of the facts and circumstances of the case, the coordinate Bench of this Court had quashed the order of transfer and ordered to re-transfer the said petitioner. Except the above submission and decision, no other submission/decision was made/cited by learned advocate Mr. Dave. 5. Ms. Kinjal Vyas, learned Assistant Government Pleader appearing for the respondents vehemently opposed the petition and submitted that the petitioner though is terming the action under challenge as transfer, as such, it is not a transfer and the petitioner, upon completion of old contract which had lived its life, was o>ered job by way of new contract at a di>erent place. She C/SCA/3192/2026 JUDGMENT DATED: 10/03/2026 further submitted that it was an admitted position which was even admitted by Mr. Dave also that in the past also, the petitioner was transferred to various Districts as he was o>ered contract in various Districts and the petitioner had accepted the same and there is nothing exceptional which the petitioner could point out in the present contract dated 31.12.2025. She further submitted that the petitioner has already been relieved on 21.1.2026 and, therefore, the relieving order has also been issued and once the petitioner is already relieved, the petitioner ought not to have prayed for quashing of the said order. 6. Ms. Vyas further submitted that new contract was o>ered vide order dated 31.12.2025 and it is for the petitioner to decide whether to accept the aforesaid o>er or not. The contract would complete only upon petitioner’s acceptance of the contract and no one can force the petitioner to accept the aforesaid contract if the petitioner does not want to serve at a place for which the contract is o>ered and it is a matter of petitioner’s own choice, but the petitioner cannot insist that he may be o>ered a contract at a place where he was serving earlier. She further submitted that as the petitioner has not accepted the contract till date, there is no accrued or vested right in favour of the petitioner to prefer a petition and seek a relief that the petitioner should be o>ered contract to serve at a particular place of his own choice. 7. Ms. Vyas further submitted that even if the order of o>ering new contract may be termed as transfer by the petitioner, in that case also, the distance between Mahemdabad and Padra would be around maximum 80 Kms. which cannot be said to be a transfer at a very distance place which may cause great hardship to C/SCA/3192/2026 JUDGMENT DATED: 10/03/2026 the petitioner. Ms. Vyas further submitted that in the past also, the petitioner had served to various Districts and, therefore, unless some exceptional circumstances are pointed out, it cannot be said that the order o>ering new contract to the petitioner as TRP, Padra is unreasonable or illegal. 8. Ms. Vyas thereafter drew attention of this Court to the decision relied upon by Mr. Dave and pointed out that the coordinate Bench of this Court quashed the order of transfer on account of the fact that the ratio between the promotees and direct recruits in that transfer was violated. Ms. Vyas further submitted that the posts on which the petitioner is serving and the post on which the case of Vegada Varsha Revashankar (Supra) was considered are di>erent and both the posts are governed by di>erent service conditions and considering the fact that every contract has its own terms, when the petitioner is o>ered new contract and when he is not transferred in the midst of the contract, the petitioner cannot raise a grievance that he has been transferred and he should have been o>ered a new contract at his earlier place of work only. She, therefore, prayed for dismissal of the petition. 9. I have heard learned advocates appearing for the respective parties and perused the record. On perusal of the record, I Bnd that the language of the order dated 31.12.2025 is absolutely clear and unambiguous. The aforesaid communication is, in fact, an o>er whereby a new contract is o>ered to the petitioner and other persons to work as TRP Padra, Dist. Vadodara at various places. It also indicates that the petitioner’s term of earlier contracts has already been over and, therefore, it is not a C/SCA/3192/2026 JUDGMENT DATED: 10/03/2026 case that in the midst of the contract, the petitioner has been transferred at a di>erent place. Therefore, even if the present case is considered, from the view point of whether a person can be transferred in the midst of contractual period and if there is no condition about the transfer, whether such transfer can be said to be illegal or not. But that question also would have no signiBcance in the facts and circumstances of the present case upon completion of earlier contract. Now, the petitioner is o>ered another contract at a di>erent place and, therefore, those questions are not required to be considered by this Court. 10. Further, the facts of the decision cited in the case of Vegada Varsha Revashankar (Supra) and the reason for which the transfer was held to be bad and quashed and the petitioner was re-transferred are di>erent, and the terms of contract are also di>erent as well and Mr. Dave could not point out that the terms of contract were identical in the case of Vegada Varsha Revashankar (Supra) and in the case of the petitioner. Therefore, the said decision relied upon by learned advocate Mr. Dave would not help the petitioner. 11. Considering the fact that though it is termed as transfer, it is actually an o>er of new contract to the petitioner. The same cannot be treated or viewed as if it is a case of transfer and it is for the petitioner if he wants to join as per the new contract at a new place as per his choice and volition and if the petitioner Bnds that practically, economically or socially, it is not viable for him to accept the above o>er, the Court cannot force the State Government or the appropriate respondent authority to o>er a new contract to the petitioner at a place of his choice. C/SCA/3192/2026 JUDGMENT DATED: 10/03/2026 Accordingly, the petition is required to be dismissed and the same stands dismissed. (NIRZAR S. DESAI,J) SAVARIYA Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judge.

This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.

Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review

All Gujarat HC judgments →