The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
17. Consequently, the present application fails and is dismissed. Cr. MP No. 21609 of 2026
18. has Since the application for condonation of delay been dismissed, the present application for restoration/recalling of order dated 22.12.2008, vide which RSA No. 368 of 2006 has been dismissed for want of prosecution, is dismissed as barred by limitation. 11th September, 2026 (Nikita) (Rakesh Kainthla) Judge
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Avtar Chand & Anr vs. Satwinder Singh and
Anr.
CMP(M) No. 1368 of 2026 in RSA
No. 368 of 2006
Reserved on: 03.09.2026
Decided on: 11.09.2026
__.09.2026 Present:
Mr B.P. Sharma, Senior Advocate, with
Mr
Arun Kumar, Advocate for
appellants/applicants.
The
applicants/appellants
have
the
filed
the
present application for condonation of delay in filing an
application for restoration of RSA No. 368 of 2006, which
was dismissed on 22.12.2008 for non-prosecution by this
Court.
2.
It has been asserted that applicant no. 1 was a
minor at the time of the passing of the order as his date of
birth is 03.08.1994. The applicant no. 2, Smt. Sita Devi, is
an illiterate and rustic lady, who could not understand the
implications of the order due to misunderstanding and a
communication gap. The applicants came to know about
the outcome of RSA No. 365 and 366 of 2006, and they filed
a Special Leave to Appeal (Civil) No. 22673 of 2026 before
the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India. The Hon'ble Supreme
Court of India granted liberty to the applicants to restore
the appeal dismissed-in-default. The registry objected to
the application for restoration on the ground of limitation.
The applicants have a rustic background, and they did not
know the technicalities of law. They could not file an
application for restoration within time. The applicants
were ready to deposit the cost of ₹700/- and the certified
copy of the learned Trial Court's judgment. Therefore, it
was prayed that the present application be allowed and the
delay in filing the application be condoned.
3.
I have heard Mr B.P. Sharma, learned Senior
Advocate, assisted by Mr Arun Kumar, Advocate, learned
counsel for the appellants.
4.
Mr B.P. Sharma, learned Senior Advocate for
the applicants/appellants, submitted that this Court erred
in dismissing the appeal for non-prosecution because the
provisions of Order XVII Rules 2 and 3 enable the Court to
pass the judgment forthwith and do not enable the Court to
adjourn the matter. In the present case, the matter was
adjourned and was not dismissed forthwith. He relied upon
the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in
Prakash Chander Manchanda and another Smt. Janki
Manchanda AIR 1987 SC 42 in support of his submission.
5.
I have given considerable thought to the
submissions made at the bar and have gone through the
records carefully.
6.
Chapter 1 of Volume V of the Rules and Orders
of the Punjab High Court as applicable to the State of HP
reads as follows: —
PART A. Paragraph 2(b):
2. Every memorandum of appeal shall be
accompanied by copies of the decree and judgment,
as prescribed by Order XLI, Rule 1 of the Civil
Procedure Code. In the case of Second Appeals, in
addition to the documents prescribed by Order XLI,
Rule 1 of the Code, the memorandum shall be
accompanied by a copy of the judgment of the
Court of First Instance unless the appellate court
dispenses therewith.
7.
Rule 2 was added to Order 41 CPC by the Punjab
High Court, which reads as follows: —
“R. 2. In addition to the copies specified in 0.41 R-1,
the memorandum of appeal shall be accompanied
by a copy of the judgment of the Court of first
instance, unless the Appellate Court dispenses
therewith.”
8.
The record of the present appeal shows that an
appeal was filed before this Court without the judgment
and decree of the learned Trial Court, which is required as
per Punjab High Court Rules and Orders as applicable to the
State of HP. An application for seeking exemption from
filing the certified copy of the judgment and decree of the
learned Trial Court was filed, which was allowed by the
Court on 12.12.2007 and 4 weeks were allowed to file the
certified copy. However, the certified copy was not filed till
22.12.2008, and the Court passed an order that a last
opportunity was granted to file the certified copy of the
judgment within 8 weeks, subject to deposit of ₹700/- with
Himachal Pradesh High Court Bar Association and in case
of non-payment of the cost or non-compliance, the appeal
would stand dismissed for non-prosecution. The order was
not complied with, and the appeal stood dismissed for
non-prosecution.
9.
The effect of not filing the certified copy of the
judgment and decree of the learned Trial Court was that the
appeal was not a competent appeal before this Court, and
the Court accepted the appeal subject to filing the certified
copy within the time granted by it. When the certified copy
was not filed, the exemption stood withdrawn, and the
appeal became non-existent. Dealing with almost a similar
situation wherein the printed copy as required under the
rules was not filed, it was laid down by Kerala High Court in
Vediyeri Chandroth Reghunathan Nambiar v. Alora Janu, 1995
SCC OnLine Ker 97: AIR 1995 Ker 334 that the appeal is not
competent in the absence of the printed copy of the
judgment and if the printed copy is not filed within the
time provided by the Court, the appeal is non-existent. It
was observed at page 335:
4. As held by this court in Muthukaruppan v.
Chellayi, 1973 KLJ 265 the acceptance of the earlier
appeal A.S. 80 of 1991 filed along with the certified
copy of the judgment of the trial court was only a
provisional acceptance in terms of R. 258 of the
Civil Rules of Practice and the plaintiff was obliged
to produce the printed copy of the judgment of the
trial court within the time granted by the appellate
Court for that purpose or within any extended time
that may be obtained for that purpose. The plaintiff
did not produce the printed copy of the judgment,
and consequently the dismissal of A.S. 80 of 1991
for non-production of the printed copy of the
judgment was clearly justified…..
5. Under Order 41, Rule 1 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, a Memorandum of Appeal has to be
accompanied by a copy of the decree appealed from
and a copy of the judgment on which it is founded
unless, of course, the appellate Court dispenses
with the production of the judgment. Rule 258 of
the Civil Rules of Practice insists that when a copy
of the judgment is applied for, for the purpose of
appeal, the copy shall be printed if the length of the
judgment exceeds 700 words. Rule 258(2) provides
that in a case where the party who is bound to
produce a printed copy of the judgment files an
appeal without production of the printed copy, he
was obliged to file a petition for the provisional
acceptance of the manuscript or typed copy of the
judgment he produced with the appeal particularly
stating that he had applied for a printed copy of the
judgment but had not received the same. It is
therefore clear that the acceptance of the appeal
A.S. 80 of 1991 filed in the first instance by the
plaintiff was only a provisional acceptance of that
appeal and the dismissal of that appeal on the
ground that the plaintiff did not produce the
printed copy of the judgment within time was
perfectly justified in terms of the provisions
noticed above. But the dismissal of that appeal for
non-production of the printed copy of the
judgment cannot be treated as a final adjudication
of the appeal in view of the fact that the appeal
itself had not been finally accepted but had only
been provisionally accepted in terms of R. 258(2) of
the Civil Rules of Practice. When an appeal is
dismissed for default for non-production of the
printed copy of the judgment, it can only mean that
the appellate Court has withdrawn the provisional
permission given by it to the appellant to appeal
against the decree of the trial court without
producing the printed copy of the judgment along
with the Memorandum of Appeal…….
10.
In the present case also, the certified copy of
the judgment and decree passed by learned Trial Court was
not filed and the appeal was incompetent on the date of its
presentation. The Court had granted time, but the order
was not complied with, which means that the appeal
remained incompetent, and the order of the Court merely
stated the obvious that the appeal would stand dismissed
as incompetent, even though the word non-prosecution
was used. Hence, it is impermissible to restore an
incompetent appeal.
11.
No.
It is undisputed that two other appeals, RSA
of
2006,
were
also
filed
by
the
appellants/applicants against the same judgment and
decree, which were taken up for hearing by the Court. An
objection was raised by the respondent that the appeal is
not maintainable in view of the dismissal of the present
appeal, and the Court framed a substantial question of law
on 15.10.2024. When the appeal was taken up for final
hearing on 10.03.2026, a submission was made on behalf of
the appellant that the dismissal of the present appeal will
not have any effect on the other appeal because one of the
plaintiff's/defendants can obtain the reversal of the whole
decree as per Order 41 Rule 4 of the CPC. This Court negated
the submission and held that the dismissal of the present
appeal would have the effect of confirming the decree and
would constitute res judicata. Hence, the Court dismissed
the other appeals preferred by the applicants/appellants.
Thereafter, the appellants/applicants filed an appeal before
the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, and when the
applicants/appellants were confronted with the finding of
this Court, the Special Leave to Appeal was withdrawn with
liberty to take steps for the restoration of the appeal
dismissed in default.
12.
Therefore,
it
is
apparent
that
the
applicants/appellants were aware of the fact that the
present appeal stood dismissed. The applicants/appellants
were also aware of the fact that the Court had framed a
substantial question of law regarding the dismissal of the
present
appeal
in
the
year
2024.
However,
the
applicants/appellants failed to take any steps for the
restoration of the appeal, and they awaited the decision of
the RSA No. 366 of 2006 preferred by them. They
challenged the judgment and decree of this Court before
the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, and when they were
unsuccessful before the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India,
they filed the present application. This conduct does not
show any bona fide intention but an attempt to wait for the
outcome of another appeal and, after being unsuccessful,
to revive the present appeal, which was dismissed-indefault in the year 2008.
13.
It was submitted that applicant no. 1 was a
minor and he was born in the year 1994. This plea will not
help the applicants because applicant no. 1 had attained
majority in the year 2012 and could have taken steps
immediately after attaining the majority to get the appeal
restored. However, he failed to do so and continued to
prosecute the RSA No. 366 of 2006, contending that the
dismissal of the present appeal will not affect RSA No. 366
of 2006. Therefore, he cannot take advantage of his
minority.
14.
The judgment in Prakash Chander Manchanda
(supra) deals with Order 17, which is not involved in the
present matter. Hence, the cited judgment does not apply
to the present case.
15.
The application has not mentioned any reason
for the condonation of delay except that applicant no. 1 is a
minor and applicant no. 2 is a rustic old lady. These are no
considerations
because
the
applicants
were
duly
represented by Senior Advocates before this Court, and it is
not the case of the applicants that competent legal advice
was not provided to them.
16.
Therefore, the application does not constitute
any cause, much less a sufficient cause for the condonation
of delay. Hence, the delay in filing the application for
restoration cannot be condoned.
17.
Consequently, the present application fails and
is dismissed.
Cr. MP No. 21609 of 2026
18.
has
Since the application for condonation of delay
been
dismissed,
the
present
application
for
restoration/recalling of order dated 22.12.2008, vide which
RSA No. 368 of 2006 has been dismissed for want of
prosecution, is dismissed as barred by limitation.
11th September, 2026
(Nikita)
(Rakesh Kainthla)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review