Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:JHHC:27165 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P(S). No. 6633 of 2023
---Avinash Chandra Deogharia, aged about 66 years, son of Late Sudhir
Chandra Deogharia, resident of House No. E-31, Sector-3, H.E.C. Township,
P.O and P.S Dhurwa, District Ranchi, Jharkhand
.......Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. Chairman, Board of Directors, Heavy engineering Corporation Ltd. having
Office at Plant Plaza Road (HEC Headquarters), Dhurwa, P.O and P.S
Dhurwa, District Ranchi Jharkhand
2.Chairman-Cum-Managing
Director,
Heavy
Engineering
office
at
Corporation Ltd., having Plant Plaza Road (H.E.C. Headquarters), Dhurwa,
P.O. and P.S. Dhurwa, District Ranchi (Jharkhand).
3. Director (Personnel), Heavy Engineering Corporation Ltd., having office
at Plant Plaza Road (H.E.C. Headquarters), Dhurwa, P.O. and P.S. Dhurwa,
District Ranchi (Jharkhand)
.....Respondent(s)
--CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK ROSHAN
--For the Petitioners
: Mr. Vijay Bahadur Singh, Advocate
For the Respondents
: Mr. Rajiv Ranjan, Sr. Advocate
: Mr. Sonal Tiwary, Advocate
--12/ Dated: 07.09.2026
1. The instant application has been preferred by the Petitioner for
following relief(s):
i.
For quashing and setting aside the order of punishment
dated 18.10.2018 issued by the 2nd Respondent whereby
and whereunder, the petitioner has been punished for
reduction by two stages in the time scale of pay (Rs.
43200-66000) as on date of superannuation i.e.
31.01.2017 reducing the pay from Rs. 55,980- 52,770/-,
and to quash the Memorandum of Charges No.
CMD/PS/2017-693 dated 18.10.2017 issued under the
signature of Sri Abhijeet Ghosh, Chairman-CumManaging Director and Disciplinary Authority and also
for quashing the entire enquiry proceeding and report
thereof. And to issue direction to the Respondent Nos. 1
and 2 to exonerate petitioner from the charges on the
lines of one of the delinquent employee Sri Jayant Kumar,
Ex-Chief of Corporate Planning by the Board of
Directors vide Communication No. HEC/CMD/18-564
dated 29.12.2018. (Annex.2)
( 2026:JHHC:27165 )
ii. For issuance of writ of certiorari for quashing of
punishment order dated 26.06.2021 Order No.
HEC/DP/Dis Mgt/2021-139 reducing to one stage lower
from basic rate on which his pay had been fixed after
implementation of which was of his punishment order,
which was effective from the time of his superannuation
i.e. on 31.01.2017 in the time scale of pay (Rs. 43,20066,000/-) in E-7 grade, whereby now his basic pay shall
reduce to Rs. 52,770/- to 51,230/- under the signature of
Respondent No.3 read with Memorandum of charges
bearing No. 221A dated 10.12.2019 and entire enquiry
report. (Annexure 6).
(iii) For issuance of writ of certiorari for quashing of
punishment order dated 18.10.2021 issued vide Order No.
HEC/DP/Dis Mgt/ACD/2021-276 reducing to one stage
lower from basic rate on which his pay had been fixed
after implementation of punishment order dated
26.06.2021 in the time scale of pay (Rs. 43,200-66,000/in E-7 grade whereby now his basic pay shall reduce from
51,230/- to Rs. 49,730/- under the signature of
Respondent No.3 read with Memorandum of charges
bearing No. DP/PS/MoC/135 dated 16.02.2019 and entire
enquiry report. Annexure 7)
(iv) To issue directions to release the consequential retiral
benefits and leave salary along with interest.
2. Briefly stated, the Petitioner was in service and served the
Respondent-HEC for 34 years and on the date of superannuation, a
release order was issued with a condition that there is a disciplinary
proceeding contemplated against the Petitioner, hence he will be
treated as on rolls for the purpose of disciplinary proceeding which
has now been revised vide office Order dated 03.08.2023.
3. After the superannuation of the Petitioner, a charge-sheet was issued
vide Annexure-2, and finally, impugned order has been passed
whereby punishment has been imposed to the effect “reduction by two
stages in the time scale of pay (Rs. 43,200-66,000) as on the date of
his superannuation i.e. 31.01.2017; whereby the basic pay shall
reduce from Rs. 55,980/- to Rs. 52,770/- under Rule 23(f) of the HEC
Employees’ Conduct, Discipline & Appeal Rules, 1981.
4. The only grievance/contention of the Petitioner is that though, the
Petitioner retired on 31.01.2017, however, the charge-sheet was issued
on 18.12.2017, and at the time of retirement, there was no pending
departmental proceeding. He further relied upon the order passed by
the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of K.V. Jankiraman and Others
( 2026:JHHC:27165 )
reported in (1991)4 SCC 109 (Para-16) and contended that since the
charge-sheet was issued after his superannuation; as such, Rule 3 (a)
of HEC Employees’ Conduct, Discipline & Appeal Rules, 1981 of the
Respondent- Company is misplaced and misconceived.
5. He further referred to Rule 3 (a) where a sentence is used “…………..
a departmental or judicial proceeding is contemplated or pending at
the time of retirement…..”. As per the learned counsel for the
Petitioner, the very meaning of contemplation is that the disciplinary
proceeding is pending and only then this Rule 3(a), will come into
play.
6. He further contended that when there was no pending departmental
proceeding at the time of his retirement, any chare-sheet issued
subsequently is non-est in the eye of law. He also submits that the law
is very clear that any disciplinary proceeding commences with the
issuance of the charge-sheet, and in the instant case it is 18.12.2017;
and admittedly, the petitioner superannuated on 31.01.2017.
7. He further submits that initially when the Respondents were not
taking any action pursuant to the letter dated 31.01.2017 (Annexure1), he moved before this Court and the case travelled up to the
Division Bench, and finally the Respondents were directed to take
final action on the charge-sheet. Learned counsel reiterated that Rule
3(a) of the HEC Employees’ Conduct, Discipline & Appeal Rules,
1981, will not protect the Respondents from initiating any action
pursuant to his superannuation, as the law is very clear that the
charge-sheet is a stage which indicates initiation of disciplinary
proceeding. Accordingly, the whole proceeding is bad in law.
8. The Ld. Counsel for the Respondents relies upon the impugned order
and submits that there is no jurisdictional error in passing the
impugned order.
9. Having heard Ld. Counsel for the parties and after going through the
documents available on record it transpires that the main thrust of
argument of the of the Ld. Counsel for the Petitioner is that when on
( 2026:JHHC:27165 )
the date of retirement i.e. 31.01.2017, merely informing the petitioner
by letter that disciplinary case is contemplated against him, will not
satisfy the requirement of law, as in any case after superannuation, the
retired employee cannot be dragged into disciplinary proceeding, and
admittedly, the charge-sheet was issued on 18.12.2017.
10. Accordingly, the sole question which is involved in the instant case is
as to whether the Respondents action in initiating the disciplinary
proceeding against the petitioner after his superannuation is valid or
not?. In this regard it would be profitable to refer Rule 3 (a) of HEC
Employees’ Conduct, Discipline & Appeal Rules, 1981, which is
extracted herein below:
“Rule 3 (a) Employee: means any person in the employment of
the Heavy Engineering Corporation Ltd (HEC), other than
casual, work-charged or contingent staff or workmen as defined
in clause (i) of Section 2 of the Industrial Employment Standing
Orders Act, 1946 and includes a person who has either retired or
superannuated from the services of the Corporation and against
whom a departmental or judicial proceeding is contemplated or
pending at the time of his retirement or superannuation.”
Emphasis Supplied
11.From bare perusal of the definition of Employee, it is crystal clear that
while framing this Discipline and Appeal Rules, the Respondents were
very much conscious and used the word “Employee means………..
and includes a person who has either retired or superannuated from
the service of the Corporation and against whom a departmental or
judicial proceeding is contemplated or pending at the time of his
retirement or superannuation.”
12.The very use of the words “contemplated or pending” itself shows
that the Respondents were having jurisdiction to initiate any
departmental proceeding after the retirement of the delinquent and
that is the reason why in the definition of employee they have added
“including a person against whom the departmental or judicial
proceeding is contemplated or pending”.
( 2026:JHHC:27165 )
13.In other words, the delinquent employee who has retired shall be
considered as an employee when any disciplinary proceeding or
judicial proceeding is pending or it is contemplated.
14. At this stage, it is profitable to refer the very meaning of
“disciplinary proceeding is contemplated”. It means that an employer
or authority is actively considering or intending to start a formal
enquiry or punishment process, but not yet officially launched it by
issuing chargesheet.
15. Learned counsel during course of argument also relied upon the
judgment of UCO Bank & Anr. v.s. Rajendra Lal Capoor reported in
(2007) 6 SCC 694 Para 21. However, this court is of the view that the
same is not applicable in view of the fact that the order in that case
solely referred the UCO Bank Officer Employee Service Regulation,
1979 and not the HEC Employees’ Conduct, Discipline & Appeal
Rules, 1981.
16. As aforesaid, in the instant case on the date of retirement an office
order dated 31.01.2017 was issued wherein the Respondents have
categorically mentioned that a disciplinary case is contemplated
against him under Rule 3(a) of the HEC Employees’ Conduct,
Discipline & Appeal Rules, 1981: the petitioner shall be deemed to be
employee of the Corporation.
17. Neither this letter has been challenged; nor the rules have been
assailed which deals with the definition of employee and empowers
the authority to initiate any proceedings after the retirement of an
employee. The sole contention of the petitioner is that the law is very
clear that a disciplinary proceeding is deemed to be initiated by the
issuance of charge-sheet.
18. There is no quarrel with the settled proposition of law that any
departmental proceeding is deemed to be initiated after issuance of
charge-sheet, but the facts in the instant case is somewhere alien to the
issue as argued by the learned counsel. The very definition of
Employee in Rule 3(a), there is a reference of contemplation/pending
( 2026:JHHC:27165 )
which itself shows that the Respondents are very much under
jurisdiction to initiate any proceeding even after superannuation.
19. Having regard to the aforesaid discussions, no interference is required
in the impugned order of punishment dated 18.10.2018 issued by the
2nd Respondent and accordingly, no relief can be granted to the
Petitioner.
20. Accordingly, this writ application stands dismissed. However, there is
no order as to cost.
(Deepak Roshan, J.)
07.09.2026
A.F.R.
Abha/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review