Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 24th November, 2025
%
Pronounced on: 18th February, 2026
CRL.MC. 5484/2025
+
AVIATION SERVICES LLC
Regd. Office at TVARDOVSKOGO UL,
12-2IV/13, 123458, MOSCOW, RF 123458
Through its Authorized Representative
Mr. Himanshu Shekhar
R/o N-212, 2nd Floor,
Greater Kailash-1,
New Delhi -110048
Email: himanshu108@gmail.com
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. B.K Singh, Mr. Narendra Kumar
and Ms. Shattika Haldar, Advocates
versus
1.
STATE (NCT OF DELHI)
Through Deputy Commissioner of Police,
Economic Offences Wing,
Mandir Marg,
New Delhi-110001
Email: dcp.eow@delhipolice.gov.in
2.
MR. SUMIT AHLUWALIA @ SUNNY WALIA
S/o Harminder Singh
R/o 19, Central Drive, DLF Chhatarpur,
Delhi-110074
& Farm No.2, Shilver Oak Lane,
Satbari New Delhi-110074
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Utkarsh, APP for the State with
SI Sanjeet Singh
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:20:33
CRL.MC. 5484/2025
J
U D
G M E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
Petition under Section 528 of Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita,
2023 (hereinafter referred to as “BNSS”) / Section 482 of Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as “Cr.P.C.”) read with Section
483(3) BNSS/Section 439(2) Cr.P.C. filed on behalf of the Petitioner/State
(NCT of Delhi) seeking cancellation of Anticipatory Bail of Respondent,
Sumit Ahluwalia @ Sunny Walia granted vide Order dated 29.03.2025
passed by Ld. ASJ-05, New Delhi District, Patiala House Courts in FIR No.
41/2024 under Sections 420/406/468/471/120B of the Indian Penal Code,
1860 (hereinafter referred to as “IPC”), at P.S. EOW.
2.
It is submitted that the Petitioner was cheated for Rs. 6,05,99675.58/-
on the basis of false representation/forged documents, etc. and was induced
to bank transfer this amount in the accounts of M/s Mangalam Traders,
Proprietor Ankit Srivastav, to export aviation goods and automobile parts to
the Petitioner.
3.
The Petitioner thereafter, lodged a detailed Complaint dated
20.12.2023, which culminated into registration of FIR No. 41/2024, under
Section 406, 420, 468, 471 and 120-B IPC, at P.S. EOW, New Delhi. The
names of all the accused, illegal beneficiaries were disclosed in the FIR.
However, in the last 2 years neither any accused/illegal beneficiaries were
arrested, nor any amount was attached/seized.
4.
The following Chart describes the trail of misappropriated money as
apparent from the ATRs filed by the I.O.:
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:20:33
CRL.MC. 5484/2025
5.
It is submitted that all the accused persons, including the Respondent,
Sumit Ahluwalia @ Sunny Walia, is still holding and enjoying the
misappropriated money for more than two years, while on court Bail.
6.
During investigation, it was clearly established that the accused
persons, in active connivance and conspiracy, opened bank accounts in the
names of employees viz. Ankit Srivastava, Rajveer Singh, to receive cheated
amounts of Rs.6,05,99,675.58/- and divert the same to illegal beneficiaries
for unlawful enrichment.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:20:33
CRL.MC. 5484/2025
7.
The I.O. stated that despite Notices under Section 41A Cr.P.C., the
accused did not join investigation; instead filed Anticipatory Bail
Applications.
8.
It is submitted that the Ld. Sessions Court granted Bail to the
Respondent, Sumit Ahluwalia @ Sunny Walia by observing that he had not
directly dealt with or induced the Complainant and was not the first layer
beneficiary.
9.
Despite the accused holding misappropriated funds, Bail was granted.
Interim bail was also granted to Ankit Srivastav to join investigation, vide
Order dated 29.03.2025. However, subsequently, Bail of Ankit Srivastav
was rejected on 04.07.2025, considering the huge cheating amount of Rs.
6.05 Crores received in his account.
10.
Accused, Ankit Jhamb filed Anticipatory Bail and was granted
interim Bail to join investigation. Though Ankit Jhamb joined investigation,
he failed to produce any documents/material justifying receipt of Rs. 3.15
Crores. He was nevertheless, granted Bail on grounds of parity and joining
investigation.
11.
Co-accused, Vishal Oberoi filed Anticipatory Bail No. 1178/2025.
The I.O. opposed the Bail Application by stating that he had received Rs.
2.89 Crores from M/s Mangalam Traders, Proprietor: Ankit Srivastav in the
account of M/s AV Global, Proprietor: Vishal Oberoi, and had not joined
investigation despite Notice.
12.
The I.O. further submitted that he may abscond, tamper evidence,
threaten witnesses, and that cheated money is yet to be recovered.
13.
During arguments, Vishal Oberoi admitted receiving Rs. 2.89 Crores
but claimed to have paid Rs. 48 Lakhs and Rs. 1.80 Crores in cash to
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:20:33
CRL.MC. 5484/2025
Respondent, Sumit Ahluwalia @ Sunny Walia without any supporting
documents or proof of payments.
14.
It is stated that despite incriminating material, the Ld. Sessions Judge
granted Anticipatory Bail to Vishal Oberoi on 23.07.2025, by observing that
he had not personally dealt with the Complainant nor induced the
complainant to transfer the said cheated account and he was not the first
layer of illegal beneficiaries. The Bail has been granted
15.
The Ld. Session judge vide the impugned Order dated 29.03.2025,
granted Anticipatory Bail to Respondent, Sumit Ahluwalia merely on parity
with co-accused.
16.
The impugned Order ignored material facts and I.O.’s submissions
and is ex-facie contrary to record. The Respondent, Sumit Ahluwalia has
illegally received above Rs. 2.89 crores of the misappropriated money and
had deliberately avoided to account the same. The Ld. Court has permitted
accused persons to enjoy the fruits of admitted misappropriated money,
causing grave injustice to the complainant.
17.
It is submitted that the Petitioner requested the I.O. to seek
cancellation of Bail, but no action was taken. More than two years have
passed; no recovery has been made and no accused has been
arrested/detained for effective investigation.
18.
Reliance is placed on Puran vs. Rambilas, (2001) 6 SCC 338 held that
bail granted by ignoring material evidence in serious offences, is perverse
and liable to be set aside in the interest of justice.
19.
Hence, a prayer is made that the present Petition be allowed and the
Order granting Bail granted to Respondent, Sumit Ahluwalia be set aside.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:20:33
CRL.MC. 5484/2025
20.
A Status Report has bene filed on behalf of the Respondent, State
wherein the facts of the case have been elaborated.
21.
The brief facts of the case are that the present FIR was registered on
the Complaint of Mr. Himanshu Shekhar, Authorized Representative of
M/s Aviation Service LLC, a Russian Company. It was alleged that in
2022, Ms. Olga Basha, senior official VTB Bank introduced one, Mr. Rohit
Jain to the Complainant. On 28.11.2022, Mr. Igor Malyshknov, Senior
representative of the Complainant Company had a meeting with Rohit Jain
regarding providing of services to various foreign Companies to do business
with India.
22.
Upon discussion, Rohit Jain advised to facilitate the supply of car
spare parts and aviation goods through M/s Mangalam Traders, a
proprietorship of Ankit Srivastav. A Delivery Agreement dated 30.01.2023
was executed. The Complainant further stated that Mr. Rohit Jain shared the
Proforma Invoice of purported supplier’s M/s Impex International FZE and
Aerojet Baltic, UAB, as stated to be obtained by Mangalam Traders for rates
of the goods as required by the Complainant Company. On the basis of
proforma Invoices forwarded by Rohit Jain, believing it to be genuine, the
Complainant paid Rs.6,05,99,675.58/. However, no goods were delivered.
23.
Subsequently,
FIR
No.
41/2024
under
Sections
420/406/468/471/120B IPC at P.S. EOW, was registered.
24.
Investigation revealed that although the Complainant’s account was
not maintained with JSC VTB Bank, intermediary transactions totalling Rs.
6,05,99,625.28 were routed through VTB Bank (PJSC), Russia, between
20.02.2023 and 17.03.2023.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:20:33
CRL.MC. 5484/2025
Date
20.02.2023
06.03.2023
06.03.2023
15.03.2023
17.03.2023
Total
25.
Amount
3366633.28
1821493.00
41174640.00
11015600.30
3221309.50
6,05,99,625.28
Notice under Section 91 Cr.P.C were issued to concerned persons
and banks, namely, Ms. Olga Basha (the then head of JSC VTB Bank),
Branch Manager ICICI Bank. Analysis of the account of M/s Mangalam
Traders (ICICI Bank, A/c No. 036705501542) revealed that the account said
Current Bank A/c has been opened as proprietorship Firm, M/s Mangalam
Traders, Proprietor namely Ankit Srivastava. The said account was opened
on 24.11.2021 and closed on 13.10.2023. As per the scrutiny of the
statements of the aforesaid bank account, the information regarding further
transfer of funds into the accounts of beneficiaries have been identified.
26.
The analysis further revealed that the cheated amount exceeding Rs. 6
crore was credited into this account and subsequently transferred to five
entities, including M/s AJ Steel, Account Holder: Ankit Jhamb; M/s RJ
Enterprises, Account Holder: Rajbir Singh; M/s BRISK Traders, Account
Holder: Himanshu; M/s AV Global Trading, Account Holder: Vishal
Oberoi; and M/s Invergise Global Pvt. Ltd, Account Holder: Deepak
Kumar and Vinod Maherkar.
27.
The analysis of beneficiary accounts revealed further diversion of
funds. The bank accounts were debit frozen and further beneficiary details
are under verification.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:20:33
CRL.MC. 5484/2025
28.
Notice under Section 41A Cr.P.C was issued to Rohit Jain to join
the investigation, to which he responded that he was introduced to Mr. Igor
Malyshkov by Ms. Olga Basha and as a lawyer, he could benefit by their
contractual Agreements and rending legal opinion.
29.
Mobile number 7303340418, linked to Mangalam Traders’ account
since inception, was registered in the name of one Jatin (since deceased).
CDR analysis showed it was used only for receiving bank SMS alerts and
was primarily operational near the residence of Ankit Jhamb.
30.
Notice under Section 41A Cr.P.C was issued to Ankit Srivastav
who stated that the opening the Account of M/s Mangalam Traders at the
instance of Respondent, Ankit Jhamb and his brother Ankur Jhamb, and that
they operated the account. He acknowledged signing cheques and being
aware of the linked mobile number.
31.
Further investigation revealed that M/s AJ Steel received Rs. 53.34
lakhs from 20.02.2023 to 06.03.2023 from M/s Mangalam Traders. A sum
of Rs. 50 lakh was transferred to M/s AV Global on 13.03.2023.
32.
M/s AJ Steel received Rs. 2.21 crores from M/s RJ Enterprises from
06.03.2023 and 14.03.2023. M/s RJ Enterprises received Rs. 2.38 crores
from M/s Mangalam Traders from 06.03.2023 and 18.03.2023.
33.
During further investigation, Ankit Jhamb stated that on the
instructions of Respondent, Sumit Walia, he had received the payment of
Rs. 53.34 lakhs (between 20.02.2023 and 06.03.2023 in 11 tranches) from
the account of M/s Mangalam Traders, in the account of his firm M/s AJ
Steel and further transferred Rs. 50 lakhs (on 13.03.2023) to M/s AV Global
Company. However, the Respondent denied this fact during his
interrogation.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:20:33
CRL.MC. 5484/2025
34.
Further, the analysis of account of M/s AJ Steel revealed a total of Rs.
3.15 crores was received by M/s AJ Steel in its Account, during the
siphoning off the cheated money and Ankit Jhamb could not justify the
receipt of such amount. Ankit Jhamb had stated that he had received the
payment from M/s Mangalam on the instructions of the Respondent, Sumit
Walia and further transferred the same to AV Global on his instructions.
Further, Rs. 1,04,92,000/- (during the period between 20.02.2023 and
15.03.2023) has been transferred to the Respondent, Sumit Walia from the
account of M/s AJ Steel. Again, during the interrogation, the Respondent
denied this fact.
35.
The Status Report further elaborated that on the interrogation of the
other accused persons, namely, Sachin Jindal, Proprietor: M/s Citizen
Enterprises; Manish, Accountant of Ankit Jhamb; Sumit Ahluwalia; Rajbir,
Proprietor: M/s RJ Enterprises; and Vishal Oberoi.
36.
The Status Report elaborates on investigation pertaining to the
Respondent, Sumit Walia. During investigation, a Notice under Section 91
Cr.P.C was issued to the Respondent, Sumit Walia S/o Harminder Singh
Walia, R/o 19, Central Drive, DLF Chhatarpur, Delhi and Farm No. 2,
Silver Oak Lane, Satbari, New Delhi, who was named in the Complaint/FIR.
It was revealed that certain transactions were made from the account of M/s
AJ Steel to his account. In response to the Notice, the Respondent joined the
investigation and submitted a Reply stating that Ankit Jhamb, Proprietor:
M/s AJ Steel and his brother had taken money from his father (denied by
Ankit Jhamb) and repaid it in 2023. He denied any connection with M/s
Mangalam or other alleged firms.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:20:33
CRL.MC. 5484/2025
37.
It is stated that the Respondent, Sumit Walia received Rs.
1,04,92,000/- from M/s AJ Steel between 20.02.2023 and 15.03.2023 in 34
tranches, and Rs. 15,50,000/- from M/s AV Global.
38.
The Respondent, Sumit Walia was granted Bail vide Order dated
29.03.2025. He joined the investigation on 04.04.2025, 05.04.2025,
07.04.2025, 11.04.2025, 12.04.2025, 19.05.2025, 21.05.2025, 18.07.2025,
04.08.2025, 12.08.2025, 18.08.2025 and 28.08.2025, reiterating that he has
no knowledge of M/s Mangalam Traders. Further investigation in the matter
is in progress.
39.
A Reply has been filed on behalf of Respondent No.2, Sumit
Ahluwalia wherein the present Petition is vehemently opposed.
40.
At the outset, it is submitted that that the Bail can be cancelled only
when the Order dated 29.03.2025 has been violated by the Respondent.
There is neither any Complaint against him nor an averment regarding noncooperation during investigation.
41.
It is submitted that the Petitioner cannot invoke two separate
provisions simultaneously, one to challenge the order on the ground of
breach of the conditions imposed in the Bail Order, and the other to seek
setting aside of the order on merits. The present Petition, being filed in such
a dual form, is itself liable to dismissal on that ground alone.
42.
It is also pertinent to note that the Petitioner has not moved any
Application before the Ld. ASJ seeking cancellation of Bail.
43.
It is submitted that the Petitioner has been falsely implicated in the
present FIR, at the behest of the Complainant. Ld. ASJ in the impugned
Order has rightly noted that the present FIR is a Complaint against Rohit
Jain and Ankit Srivastav of Mangalam Traders. There is no role of the
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:20:33
CRL.MC. 5484/2025
Respondent as well as there is no direct involvement with the Complainant,
and even otherwise the entry in the account is documented.
44.
It is submitted that the Petitioner cannot simultaneously invoke two
separate provisions, one to challenge the order on the ground of breach of
the conditions imposed in the Bail Order, and the other to seek setting aside
of the order on merits. The present Petition, being filed in this dual form, is
itself liable to be dismissed on that ground alone.
45.
It is submitted that the Respondent had no involvement in any
transaction, whereby a sum of Rs. 6 crores was allegedly transferred by the
Complainant, to the account of Mangalam Traders. He is not the first-layer
beneficiary.
46.
It is further stated that Ankur Jhamb, the employer of Ankit Srivastav,
had claimed that an amount of Rs. 1 crore was paid to him; however, the
counter version is that the said amount represented his legitimate dues,
which were duly settled. The Prosecution itself asserts that the relevant
entries are documented.
47.
It is categorically denied that the Respondent had any role in the
alleged cheating, and the essential ingredients of the offence are not made
out against him. The Respondent received certain amounts from Ankur
Jhamb only towards discharge of liabilities owed by Ankur Jhamb to him.
48.
Furthermore, the Respondent has always cooperated during
investigation and has also provided his HDFC Bank account details.
49.
It is also submitted that no Chargesheet has been filed in the present
matter despite the FIR being registered on 19.04.2024.
50.
Reliance is placed on Arnesh Kumar vs. State of Bihar, (2014) 8 SCC
273; Satender Kumar Antil vs. CBI, (2022) 10 SCC 51; Mahipal vs. Rajesh
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:20:33
CRL.MC. 5484/2025
Kumar alias Polia, (2020) 2 SCC 118; Y vs. State of Rajasthan, (2022) 9
SCC 269; P vs. State of M.P., (2022) 15 SCC 211; Bhagwan Singh vs. Dilip
Kumar @ Deepu @ Depak, 2023 INSC 761; Ajwar vs. Waseem, (2024) 10
SCC 768.
51.
Hence, the present Petition is liable to be dismissed.
Submissions heard and record perused.
52.
Essentially, the facts of the case demonstrate that an amount of
approximately Rs. 6.05 Crores was allegedly induced from the Complainant
on the basis of forged documents and false representations, which was
credited to the account of M/s Mangalam Traders and subsequently routed
through multiple beneficiary accounts. The Respondent, Sumit Ahluwalia @
Sunny Walia, is alleged to have received certain amounts from the said trail
of transactions.
53.
The core issue that falls for determination is whether the Order dated
23.07.2025 granting Anticipatory Bail to the Respondent, Sumit Ahluwalia
warrants interference by this Court?
54.
Before considering the contentions on merit, it is significant to
observe that there is a distinction between recall and cancellation of Bail.
While recall can be made only if it is established that Bail has been granted
by not considering the relevant facts on merits, cancellation is prompted by
subsequent events and violation of terms of Bail by the Respondent.
55.
In the case of Mahipal vs. Rajesh Kumar, (2020) 2 SCC 118, the
Apex Court observed, “An appellate court is empowered to set aside a bail
order if it is found to be based on a misapplication of legal principles or
where relevant considerations have been ignored. On the other hand,
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:20:33
CRL.MC. 5484/2025
cancellation of bail typically arises from post-bail conduct or supervening
circumstances.”
56.
The Apex Court in Y vs. State of Rajasthan, (2022) 9 SCC 269
underscored that an order granting bail can be tested on illegality, perversity,
arbitrariness and being based on unjustified material.
57.
In recent judgement of Ashok Dhankad vs. State of NCT of Delhi and
Another, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1690, Apex Court reiterated that while
considering as to whether bail ought to be granted in a matter involving a
serious criminal offence, the Court must consider relevant factors like the
nature of the accusations made against the accused, the manner in which
the crime is alleged to have been committed, the gravity of the offence, the
role attributed to the accused, the criminal antecedents of the accused, the
probability of tampering of the witnesses and repeating the offence, if the
accused are released on bail, the likelihood of the accused being
unavailable in the event bail is granted, the possibility of obstructing the
proceedings and evading the courts of justice and the overall desirability of
releasing the accused on bail.
58.
The Apex Court has succinctly explained and summarized the factors
for consideration for setting aside of Bail Orders as under:
“19.
The principles which emerge as a result of the
above discussion are as follows:
(i)
An appeal against grant of bail cannot be
considered to be on the same footing as an application for
cancellation of bail;
(ii)
The Court concerned must not venture into a thread
bare analysis of the evidence adduced by prosecution. The
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:20:33
CRL.MC. 5484/2025
merits of such evidence must not be adjudicated at the stage
of bail;
An order granting bail must reflect application of
(iii)
mind and assessment of the relevant factors for grant of bail
that have been elucidated by this Court.
(iv)
An appeal against grant of bail may be entertained
by a superior Court on grounds such as perversity; illegality;
inconsistency with law; relevant factors not been taken into
consideration including gravity of the offence and impact of
the crime;
(v)
However, the Court may not take the conduct of an
accused subsequent to the grant bail into consideration while
considering an appeal against the grant of such bail. Such
grounds must be taken in an application for cancellation of
bail; and
(vi)
An appeal against grant of bail must not be allowed
to be used as a retaliatory measure. Such an appeal must be
confined only to the grounds discussed above.”
59.
In the light of aforesaid principles, the contentions raised in the
present Petition be now considered.
60.
Firstly, in the present case, it is not the stand of the Petitioner,
Complainant Company that the Respondent has violated any condition of
Bail or failed to join investigation. On the contrary, the record reflects that
the Respondent joined investigation on multiple occasions.
61.
Secondly, in the impugned Order dated 29.03.2025, it is evident that
the Ld. ASJ made a detailed analysis while granting Bail to the Respondent.
It was noted as under:
“Insofar as the role of applicant/accused Sumit Alhuwalia @
Sunny Walia is concerned, again as mentioned above, he had
not dealt with the complainant in any manner whatsoever. He
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:20:33
CRL.MC. 5484/2025
…
was not involved in any transaction whereby a sum of Rs.6
Crore was transferred to the account of Manglam Traders by
the complainant. He is not the first layer beneficiary. Ankur
Jhamb who is the employer of Ankit Shrivastav had stated
that Rs.1 Crore was paid to him to which the counter version
is that the said was the dues were his and the same were
liquidated.
As far as the applicant/accused Sumit Ahluwalia @ Sunny
Walia is concerned, as mentioned above, there is no direct
involvement qua the complainant and otherwise also, the
entry in the account is documented.”
62.
It cannot, therefore, be characterized as mechanical or passed in
disregard of material on record.
63.
Thirdly, the mere fact that co-accused persons have been granted or
denied Bail subsequently cannot, by itself, constitute a supervening
circumstance justifying cancellation of Bail already granted to the
Respondent, in the absence of misuse of liberty.
64.
Lastly, the primary emphasis of the Petitioner is on the seriousness of
the alleged offence and the substantial monetary amount involved. While
such considerations are relevant at the stage of initial grant of Bail, they do
not, by themselves, furnish a valid ground for recall, once Bail has been
granted after careful judicial scrutiny of the facts.
65.
The Petition, in essence, seek a re-appreciation of the merits of the
case, but the detailed consideration as above, does not reflect any manifest
unjust, perverse, or findings based on extraneous considerations.
Conclusion:
66.
There is no merit in the present Appeal, which is hereby, dismissed.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:20:33
CRL.MC. 5484/2025
67.
Pending Applications are also disposed of accordingly.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
FEBRUARY 18, 2026
N
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:20:33
CRL.MC. 5484/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review