Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on : 27.01.2026
Date of decision: 12.02.2026
%
+
W.P.(C) 19835/2025, CM APPL. 82791/2025
AVANTHA HOLDINGS LIMITED
.....Petitioner
Through:
Mr. Sandeep Bajaj, Ms. Shruti
Kanodia, Mr. Rishabh Dua, Mr.
Kshitij Ujala, Mr. Maya Bihani,
Advs.
versus
ICICI BANK LIMITED AND ORS.
.....Respondents
Through:
Mr. Sanjiv Kakra, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. Bhamsen Jain, Mr. Akash
Madan, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIVEK CHAUDHARY
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE RENU BHATNAGAR
JUDGMENT
1.
The present writ petition has been filed under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India, assailing the Order dated 16.12.2025 passed by the Debts
Recovery Appellate Tribunal, Kolkata (holding Additional Charge of Debts
Recovery Appellate Tribunal, Delhi) [“DRAT”] in Miscellaneous Appeal No.
222 of 2024, rejecting its appeal. In the appeal, the petitioner had challenged
the Order dated 03.07.2024 passed by the Debts Recovery Tribunal-III, Delhi
(“DRT”) dismissing the application filed by the petitioner seeking condonation
Signed By:ROHIT SAIN
03:05:13
W.P.(C) 19835/2025
of delay of 14 days in filing the written statement in Original Application
No.7/2024 (“O.A.”).
2.
The essential facts are that respondent no.1/Bank granted a Letter of
Credit facility of US$ 50 million to respondent no.2, which is a subsidiary of
the petitioner. To secure this facility, the petitioner and respondent no.2
executed the necessary loan and security documents, and the facility was
revised and renewed over time with fresh documents being signed. Respondent
no.2 committed repeated defaults in making payments under the Letter of
Credit, leading the Bank to issue several demand notices to the petitioner,
respondent no.2 and respondent no.3. Later, on 11.07.2018, the Facility
Agreement was modified at the request of respondent no.2, and respondent no.3
executed a guarantee on 13.07.2018 agreeing to repay respondent no.2’s dues.
As the outstanding amounts still remained unpaid, respondent no.1/Bank filed
O.A. No. 7/2024 before DRT seeking recovery of ₹558,60,99,519.70/- from the
defendants.
3.
By Order dated 19.03.2024, the DRT directed issuance of summons to the
defendants therein, requiring filing of their written statement including claim
for set off or counter-claim, if any, within 30 days of service, failing which
their right to file written statement and defence evidence would stand closed.
The summons were given under the seal of DRT on 22.03.2024.
4.
While the Speed Post article addressed to the petitioner was returned, the
complete paperbook, including summons, was admittedly served by the
respondent no.1/ bank on 17.04.2024 through e-mail.
Signed By:ROHIT SAIN
03:05:13
W.P.(C) 19835/2025
5.
The petitioner filed its written statement on 31.05.2024 along with an
application seeking condonation of delay of 14 days. The DRT dismissed the
application for condonation of delay of 14 days in filing the written statement
to the O.A. 7/2024.
6.
The DRAT vide the impugned Order dated 16.12.2025, has affirmed and
held that Section 19(5)(i) of the Recovery of Debts and Bankruptcy Act, 1993
(“RDB Act”) mandates filing of the written statement within 30 days,
extendable by a further period not exceeding 15 days in exceptional cases and
in special circumstances. The DRAT found that the petitioner had not shown
such circumstances warranting extension. This order is under challenge before
us.
7.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
8.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the hard copy of the O.A.
was never served upon the petitioner and, therefore, service through e-mail
could not be treated as service of summons in the manner contemplated under
Section 19(4) of the RDB Act read with the applicable DRT Rules. It is urged
that in absence of proper service, the statutory period of 30 days did not
commence, and consequently, the delay of 14 days in filing the written
statement was liable to be condoned.
9.
Learned counsel for respondent no.1/Bank, on the other hand, submits
that the petitioner never disputed receipt of the entire paperbook, including the
summons, by e-mail on 17.04.2024. Attention is drawn to the Order of the DRT
dated 19.03.2024, which expressly permitted service through registered
Signed By:ROHIT SAIN
03:05:13
W.P.(C) 19835/2025
post/speed post/courier/electronic mode/Dasti, failing which through affixation.
It is therefore submitted that electronic service was not only permissible but
was specifically contemplated.
10.
He submits that the complete paperbook, including summons, was served
by the respondent no.1/Bank on 17.04.2024 through e-mail. There is no denial
on the part of the petitioner, and admittedly the summons and paperbook were
served through e-mail on 17.04.2024. Relying on Section 19(5)(i) of the RDB
Act, he further submits that no exceptional case and special circumstance were
demonstrated for extending such 30 days period for a further period not
exceeding 15 days to file the written statement of its defence as the essential
ground raised by the petitioner is that the hard copy of the O.A was not
supplied to the petitioner.
11.
A perusal of the DRT’s Order dated 19.03.2024 shows that the
Authorized Officer/Authorized Representative of the Bank was directed to
collect the summons on the next working day and to promptly supply the
summons and paperbook so that the petitioner could avail the statutory 30-day
period before the next date, i.e. 04.05.2024. The relevant portion of the said
order:“3. Directions for Registry: Registry is directed to issue
notice / summons against the defendants to file show
cause, in the form of Written Statement, within 30 days
of the service of Notice as to why the relief(s) prayed for
should not be granted in favour of Applicant Bank. The
Notice / Summons shall be served by the officials of the
applicant through the prescribed modes including the
Signed By:ROHIT SAIN
03:05:13
W.P.(C) 19835/2025
registered post/ speed post / Courier / Electronic Mode /
Dasti failing which through Affixation. The Registry
shall prepare the Notice / Summons for onward service
to the defendants by the applicant bank. After service,
the applicant bank shall file affidavit for the same
before the Registry.
4. Direction for Authorised officer / Authorized
Representative (A.R.) of applicant bank: Authorized
Officer of Applicant Bank is directed to comply the
following directions
a) A.R. has to collect the notice on next working day of
passing the order and shall supply the notice along with
paper book promptly so that defendant can avail 30
days' time to file WS along with documentary evidence
before next date fixed in this case.
xxx
xxx
xxx xxx
xxx
xxx
9. List the matter on 04.05.2024 before Registrar.”
(emphasis added)
12.
The summons were, however, issued under the seal of the DRT only on
22.03.2024 i.e., two days after the date on which they were required to be
collected. The next working day was 20.03.2024.
13.
As per the order, the petitioner ought to have been served promptly, even
otherwise, by or before 04.04.2024, so that the petitioner can avail the statutory
period of 30 days to file written statement before the next date fixed in the case
i.e., 04.05.2024.
14.
As per the affidavit of service filed on behalf of respondent no.1/Bank
dated 02.05.2024, the summons were dispatched by Speed Post only on
Signed By:ROHIT SAIN
03:05:13
W.P.(C) 19835/2025
06.04.2024, even though it was directed to be promptly served by Order dated
19.03.2024. Moreover, the status of service shows that it to be “Item Returned”
with respect to the petitioner. Although the affidavit states that Dasti service was
attempted, but no date and time is disclosed as to when this was done.
15.
Ultimately, the petitioner was admittedly served with the complete
paperbook along with the documents and the summons dated 22.03.2024,
through the e-mail on 17.04.2024. Notably, the next date fixed by the DRT was
04.05.2024.
16.
The sequence of events clearly shows that respondent no.1/Bank itself took
around 28 days to take steps for effective service on the petitioner, despite the
DRT having directed that the summons and paperbook were to be supplied
promptly so that the defendants could avail the full statutory period before the
next date fixed. Ultimately, the petitioner was served only on 17.04.2024. In
contrast, the petitioner sought condonation of a delay of only 14 days in filing
the written statement. When viewed together, it is evident that the respondent
no.1/Bank enjoyed a far longer period in complying with the DRT’s directions
than the petitioner now seeks.
17.
In such circumstances, the requirement of maintaining parity between the
parties becomes important. It is the duty of the Court or the tribunal, as the case
may be, to maintain parity. A litigant must be able to trust that the Court or
Tribunal will adopt the same approach towards both sides. If substantial delay on
the part of one party is overlooked without any adverse consequence, while a
shorter delay by the other is treated strictly, it creates an imbalance which must
Signed By:ROHIT SAIN
03:05:13
W.P.(C) 19835/2025
be avoided. Fairness requires that similar conduct not be judged by different
standards.
18.
In these circumstances, the DRT and the DRAT in appeal, ought to have
taken a balanced view and allowed the petitioner’s request for condonation of
delay, particularly when respondent no.1/Bank was granted considerable latitude
without any adverse order.
19.
The DRT did not examine whether its Order dated 19.03.2024 was fully
complied with timely, nor was any cost imposed upon respondent no.1/Bank for
the delay on their part.
20.
Once the principle of parity is applied, the conclusion becomes evident.
Both parties were required to act within respective timelines. If nearly a month’s
delay on one side did not attract adverse consequence, the petitioner’s delay of
14 days cannot be placed in a more disadvantageous position. To do so would
undermine confidence in the fairness of the adjudicatory process.
21.
The delay of 14 days in filing the written statement is condonable under
proviso to Section 19(5)(i) of the RDB Act in special circumstances. In the facts
of the present case, the special circumstance, particularly when respondent
no.1/Bank itself was granted latitude in complying with the directions of the
DRT without any adverse consequence, are made out. Application of the
principle of parity precludes adoption of a stricter standard against the petitioner
for a shorter delay.
Signed By:ROHIT SAIN
03:05:13
W.P.(C) 19835/2025
22.
Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed. The delay of 14 days in filing the
written statement is condoned, and the written statement shall be treated as duly
filed before the DRT.
23.
Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
VIVEK CHAUDHARY
(JUDGE)
RENU BHATNAGAR
(JUDGE)
FEBRUARY 12, 2026
nc
Signed By:ROHIT SAIN
03:05:13
W.P.(C) 19835/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review