Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:MLHC:802-DB
Serial Nos.01 & 02
Daily List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C). No.186/2021 with
MC (WPC). No.13/2025
MC (WPC). No.72/2021
WP(C) No.234/2021 with
MC(WPC) No.87/2021
Date of CAV: 29.08.2025
Date of Pronouncement: 04.09.2025
International Spirits and Wines Association of India a company registered
under the Companies Act, 1956 having its registered office at 2nd Floor,
Tower 1A, DLF Corporate Park, M.G. Road, Gurugram, Haryana-122002
and represented by Ms. Nita Prannath Kapoor, authorized representative
of the petitioner company.
..... Petitioner
Vs.
1. State of Meghalaya represented through Principal Secretary, Excise,
Registration, Taxation and Stamps Department, Government of
Meghalaya, Shillong, Meghalaya.
2. Commissioner of Excise, Excise, Registration, Taxation and Stamps
Department, Government of Meghalaya, Shillong, Meghalaya.
3. Umpohliew Central Bonded Warehouse, represented through its
Managing Partner, having its registered office at 9th Mile, Baridua, RiBhoi District, Meghalaya.
..... Respondents
Association of Meghalaya Bonded Warehouses, represented by its
President having registered office at Bivar Road, Shillong-793001, East
Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
..... Petitioner
Vs.
1. The State of Meghalaya, represented by the Chief Secretary to the
Government of Meghalaya, Shillong.
2. The Commissioner and Secretary to the Government of Meghalaya,
Excise, Registration, Taxation and Stamps Department, Government of
Meghalaya, Shillong.
3. The Commissioner of Excise, Government of Meghalaya, Shillong.
4. M/s Umpohliew Central Warehouse, 9th Mile, Baridua, Oppt. CRPF
Camp, Ri-Bhoi District, Meghalaya represented by its Managing Partner.
..... Respondents
2025:MLHC:802-DB
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice I.P. Mukerji, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance in WP(C). No. 186 of 2021:
For the Petitioners
:
Mr. Jishnu Saha, Sr. Adv with
Mr. A. Mukherjee, Adv
Mr. K. Tangirala, Adv
Mr. R. Kharkrang, Adv
For the Respondents : Mr. D. K. Banerjee, Sr. Adv with
Mr. A. S. Pandey, GA
Mr. A. H. Kharwanlang, Addl. Sr. GA
Ms. S. Laloo, GA
Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI with
Mr. A. P. Singh, Adv
Mr. M. L. Nongpiur, Adv for R/3
Appearance in WP(C). No. 234 of 2021:
For the Petitioner
:
For the Respondents :
Mr. K. Paul, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. Philemon Nongbri, Adv
Mr. S. Chanda, Adv
Mr. A. Kumar, Advocate General with
Mr. A. S. Pandey, GA
Mr. A. H. Kharwanlang, Addl.Sr.GA
Ms. S. Laloo, GA
Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI
Mr. A.P. Singh, Adv
Mr. M. L. Nongpiur, Adv for R/4
JUDGMENT
(Delivered by the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice)
Three writ petitions were before this Court.
One was by the International Spirits and Wines Association of India
[WP (C) No.186 of 2021] Association of Manufacturers, Bottlers and
Suppliers of liquor. The second was by the Association of Meghalaya
2025:MLHC:802-DB
Bonded Warehouses [WP (C) No.234 of 2021]. The third was by the
Umpohliew Central Bonded Warehouse [WP (C) No.430 of 2024], which
is created by the impugned Meghalaya Bonded Warehouse (Amendment)
Rules, 2020, made under the Assam Excise Act, 1910 (“the Act”).
The cause of action in the first two writ petitions is more or less
similar. The writ petitioners challenge the validity of the said rules and
seek an injunction restraining operation of the Central Bonded
Warehouse. The third writ petition called in question the authority of the
State government to establish more than one Central Warehouse in the
State in implementation of the said rules.
During the final stages of hearing of the writ petitions, Umpohliew
Central Bonded Warehouse withdraw its writ.
The trade in liquor is very substantial in this State. There is a large
market for both foreign and country liquor. These two types of liquor have
been defined in the above Act and rules. It goes without saying that this
trade involves manufacturing, supply and distribution of this product.
The Act was enacted to, inter alia, regulate this trade throughout the
State of Assam and Eastern Bengal within which now falls the present
State of Meghalaya. On creation of this State in 1972, it adopted the said
Act and the above rules thereunder amended from time to time till 1965.
2025:MLHC:802-DB
Up to then and even thereafter there was no grievance of any person
with regard to the regulation of the liquor trade in the State.
Under the said rules, the retail price of a bottle of foreign liquor is
fixed by the government. This price till the impugned rules came into
force, included the price charged by the manufacturers, bottlers suppliers,
all taxes levies thereon, the commission of the bonded warehouse and the
retailer’s margin.
A retailer on assessment of the demand would place requisition on
a bonded warehouse which would supply the goods to him upon obtaining
it from the manufacturers, bottlers suppliers etc.
The recital to the Assam Excise Act, 1910 states that it was enacted
to consolidate and amend the excise law in Eastern Bengal and Assam. It
has been made applicable to the State of Meghalaya. According to its
preamble, it relates to import, export, transport, manufacture, sale and
possession of intoxicating liquors and of intoxicating drugs.
“Intoxicant” has been defined in Section 3(12a) of the Act as
meaning any liquor or intoxicating drug.
Section 3(14) describes liquor as follows.
“3(14) “Liquor” means intoxicating liquor and includes all liquid
consisting of or containing alcohol; also tari and pachwai in any
form; and any substance which the State Government may, by
notification, declare to be liquor for the purposes of this Act.”
2025:MLHC:802-DB
Spirit is defined in Section 3(19) as follows:
“Spirit” means any liquor containing alcohol, obtained by
distillation, whether it is denatured or not.”
There is further categorisation in Section 4. The state government
is given the power to declare by notification which type of liquor would
be branded as “country liquor” and which to be branded as “foreign
liquor.”
Section 16 is important. It, inter alia, provides that the Excise
Commissioner with the sanction of the Board may establish or allow to be
run on licence a warehouse where, inter alia, liquor of any kind could be
deposited [see section 16(d)].
Now, we come to the provision which has become very contentious
in these writ petitions. It is Section 19 which is in the following terms:
“19. Executive privilege of manufacture and supply. – The State
Government may grant to any person on such conditions and for
such period as it may think fit, the exclusive privilege of
manufacturing or of supplying to licensed vendors any country
liquor or intoxicating drugs within any specified local area.”
Section 36 of the said Act conferred rule making power on the State.
It permitted it to make rules, inter alia, regulating the “deposit of intoxicant
in warehouses” and the removal of such articles from warehouses,
distilleries or breweries. The Assam Bonded Warehouses rules, 1965 were
made. These rules were amended from time to time, lastly in 2020.
2025:MLHC:802-DB
The amendment of 15th October, 2020 is the bone of contention. It
was to the following effect:
Clause ii(a) was added to rule 2 which defines Central Bonded
Warehouse as follows:
“(iia) “Central Bonded Warehouse” means a licensed Central
Warehouse where IMFL, Beer, Wine, BIO etc., imported on prepayment of Excise or Advalorem duty, Import Pass Fee or
Transport Pass Fee and Literage Fee are kept for eventual removal
to Bonded Warehouses as provided for in the Meghalaya Bonded
Warehouse Rules (The Assam Bonded Warehouse Rules,1965, as
adopted by Meghalaya), and all its extant rules.”
Rule 44 was added which provided for establishment of the Central
Bonded Warehouse to be run on licence obtained by a licensee on a
licence.
Some of the other material terms and conditions for operation of the
Central Bonded Warehouse provided in rule 44 are as follows:
“44. License for Central Bonded Warehouse shall be granted on
the following conditions: (1) A license to establish and work a
Central Bonded Warehouse in the designated area on prior approval
of Government shall be issued by the Commissioner of Excise.
(2) Selection for license to establish and work a Central Bonded
Warehouse in the State shall be based on competitive bidding
process, open to Individuals, Partnerships firms, Companies, etc.
(3) The base fee for a license to operate a Central Bonded
Warehouse shall be Rs.1,50,00,000/- (Rupees One Crore Fifty
Lakh) only annually, or as fixed by Government from time to time.
(4) The tenure of the license shall be for ten years. The
Commissioner of Excise however, reserves the right to extend the
period of the tenure, with prior approval of the State Government,
2025:MLHC:802-DB
for any additional period after expiry of the term of the license at
the same or revised terms and conditions as awarded.
(5) The Central Bonded Warehouse shall deposit a Security
Deposit of an amount equivalent to the awarded annual License fee
for a period of ten years pledged to Commissioner of Excise, which
shall be forfeited in case of failure to abide by the conditions as laid
down in the license or any breach of Meghalaya Excise Act and
Rules.
(6) The Central Bonded Warehouse shall operate on a plot of land
measuring not less than One Lakh Fifty Thousand square feet which
is fully developed for immediate use, duly surveyed and certified
by the Deputy Commissioner.
(7) The Central Bonded Warehouse must construct a warehouse or
godown having a capacity to hold at least Six Lakh cases of IMFL,
Beer, Wine, BIO etc. within a period of four months from the date
of issue of license, alongwith a building safety certification from
PWD (Building).
(8) The Central Bonded Warehouse shall be eligible to supply only
to the bonded warehouses located within the state.
(9) The Central Bonded Warehouse shall have the capacity to
supply and deliver all the registered brands of IMFL, Beer, Wine,
BIO etc. to the Bonded Warehouses within forty-five days for goods
produced in the State and sixty days for goods imported from
outside the State.
(10) The Central Bonded Warehouse shall have a minimum stock
of all types of brands for three months at any point in time, so that
continuous regular supply can be maintained for all Bonded
Warehouses throughout the State.
(11) The Central Bonded Warehouse must be made operational
within four months from the date of issue of license.
(12) The minimum profit margin eligible for bonded warehouses on
their sale to retail IMFL "OFF" and "ON" licenses shall be 8%
(eight percent) for IMFL brands only (except Bottle in Origin).
(13) The Central Bonded Warehouse or ex-bond rates of all the
imported goods shall be subject to approval by the Commissioner
of Excise during the course of annual registration of brands.
2025:MLHC:802-DB
(14) On commencement of the Central Bonded Warehouse, the
Bonded Warehouses shall lift all the liquor from the Central Bonded
Warehouse against the import permits issued by the Commissioner
of Excise and cease to import directly from the Companies, Bottling
Plants etc.”
The warehouse should have a minimum area of 1,50,000 square feet
with a godown to hold at least six lakh cases of IMFL, beer, wine, BIO
etc. to be acquired within four months from the date of issue of the license
in their favour.
The warehouse should have the capacity to supply/deliver all the
registered brands of the descriptions of foreign liquor to the bonded
warehouses within 45 days for goods produced in the State and 60 days
goods imported from outside the State. At the same time, the amended
rules provided that the Central Bonded Warehouse would have to maintain
a minimum stock of the above brands for three months at any point of
time.
A bonded warehouse would be entitled to a pocket margin and that
too a minimum pocket margin of eight per cent for IMFL brands only
(except bottle in origin).
Against the import permits issued by the Commissioner of Excise,
the bonded warehouses would have to lift the liquor from the Central
Bonded Warehouses only and would have no right to import directly from
the companies, bottling plants etc.
2025:MLHC:802-DB
The letter of the International Spirits and Wines Association of
India dated 13th May, 2021 to the Commissioner and Secretary (Excise &
Taxation Registration & Stamps), Government of Meghalaya, Shillong
pointed out that the Central Bonded Warehouse had been superimposed
over the chain of bonded warehouses without any apparent Government
control or regulation. Any commission specified by the Government to
be paid to the Central Bonded Warehouse should be borne from the
revenue collected by it. The letter implored the government to take a
decision whether to absorb the increase in price of liquor because due to
the operation of the above notification or to increase the price at the end
of the retailer.
The principal grounds on which the said rules are challenged in the
writ petitions are stated in short in the following paragraphs. In support of
or contesting these grounds, extensive arguments were made by all learned
counsel.
Mr. Jishnu Saha, learned Senior Advocate made submission for the
petitioner in WP (C) No.186 of 2021. He opened his submission by
imputing mala fide to the government. He said that the Central Bonded
Warehouse was a partnership firm which was formed on 1 st September,
2020. The said rules were promulgated on 15th October, 2020. This
2025:MLHC:802-DB
formation of the partnership firm was made in full collusion and
connivance of the partners with the government so that the rules were
framed and put it into force expeditiously creating a Central Bonded
Warehouse. The contract for its operation would be granted to this new
partnership firm.
The creation of the Central Bonded Warehouse by the impugned
rules is violative of Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution of India as it does
not pass the test of reasonableness. Article 19(6) clarifies that in no way
prevents the State or a Corporation controlled by the State to carry on any
business, to the exclusion, complete or partial of others. This provision of
the Constitution was interpreted so as to mean or imply that only the State
could carry out a monopolistic business but a private individual could not
be empowered by the State to do so.
By the impugned rules, the State was trying to create a monopoly
in foreign liquor business in the Central Bonded Warehouses for
regulation of trade in foreign liquor in Meghalaya in general with
particular reference to its importation from bottlers, distillers, suppliers,
storage in a warehouse and ultimate sale to consumers through retailers.
Relying on Section 19 of the Meghalaya Excise Act adopting the
Assam Excise Act, 1910 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”) it was
2025:MLHC:802-DB
sought to be argued by Mr. Jishnu Saha, learned Senior counsel for the
petitioner in (WP (C) No.186 of 2021) that the provision in the said
Section for the State to grant exclusive right of manufacture or supply of
any country liquor or intoxicating drug, necessarily, meant and implied
that such monopolistic trade could not be authorised by the State to be
carried out in respect of foreign liquor, by a private individual or by
corporate.
Mr. Saha invoked the legal maxim expressio unius est exclusio
alterius which means that mention of a particular “person or thing in the
law” means exclusion of any other person or thing. He cited Gram
Panchayat, Village Kanonda, Tehsil Bahadurgarh, District Rohtak,
through its Sarpanch v. Director, Consolidation of Holdings, Haryana,
Chandigarh & ors reported in 1989 Supp (2) SCC 465 where Mr. Justice
Saikia delivering a three-judge bench judgment of the Supreme Court
relied on this doctrine to say when there is mention of a “certain person or
thing in the law” an intention to exclude all others from this operation may
be inferred.
Again, relying on Union of India v. Shiv Dayal Soin & Sons (P)
Ltd. & ors reported in (2003) 4 SCC 695, a judgment by Mr. Justice Khare
for the bench where the maxim was applied in another way to infer that
2025:MLHC:802-DB
mention of a particular thing in one part of the statute its absence in
another part would imply its conscious omission from that part, Mr. Saha
argued that Section 19 referred to a monopoly which could not be granted
by the State for manufacture and supply of foreign liquor but it could only
be granted to manufacture and sale of country liquor.
Thus, the impugned rules were opposed to Section 19, violative of
it and ultra vires the Act, it was argued.
Following up this argument, he cited Kunj Behari Lal Butail & ors
v. State of H.P. & ors reported in (2000) 3 SCC 40, Additional District
Magistrate (Rev.) Delhi Admn. v. Siri Ram reported in (2000) 5 SCC 451,
State of T.N. & anr v. P. Krishnamurthy & ors reported in (2006) 4 SCC
517, U.P. Avas Evam Vikas Parishad v. Jainul Islam & anr reported in
(1998) 2 SCC 467 and Subhash Chand Aggarwal v. Union of India &
ors reported in 2011 SCC Online Del 3033, to argue that a substantive
right granted by the parent Act could not be taken away by subordinate
legislation.
It was also said that the impugned rules violated Article 14 of the
Constitution. The bonded warehouses were deprived of a “level playing
field”. They had to accept whatever liquor was made available to them by
the Central Bonded Warehouse. They would be losing their right of
2025:MLHC:802-DB
obtaining supplies from bottlers, distillers and of their autonomy in
importing foreign liquor into Meghalaya by negotiations with the vendors.
Citing Kerala Bar Hotels Association v. State of Kerala reported
in 2015 SCC Online SC 1385, it was argued that State can create a
monopoly for itself or any agency created by it for manufacture,
possession, sale and distribution of liquor but could not create a monopoly
in favour of a private entity.
The autonomy granted to the Central Bonded Warehouse was
unregulated in terms of stock to be procured, stocked and supplied. The
absence of indication of profit margin for Central Bonded Warehouse
would result in arbitrary action by the warehouses. The Central Bonded
Warehouse would only be interested in brands that gave them more
commission. This would be contrary to consumer preference. This could
result in leading brand owners to exit the market. Before the impugned
notification, the bonded warehouse used to earn a commission of eight per
cent.
Now, commission would be payable to the Central Bonded
Warehouse. This additional commission would be payable without any
corresponding increase or improvement in the service provided by the
bonded warehouses in the liquor trade. It would impact the price and
interfere with the “level playing field”.
2025:MLHC:802-DB
Mr. Saha cited a line of cases decided by the Supreme Court which
propounded the following propositions of law: Under the Constitution, the
State had the right to carry out monopoly business in liquor by itself or
through agents subject to the conditions under Article 19(6) of the
Constitution. Article 47 of the Constitution did not curtail the right of the
State to carry on liquor trade or to regulate or restrict its production, supply
and consumption. This restriction includes imposition of reasonable
restriction by the State for conduct of the trade. A citizen also enjoyed the
fundamental right to carry on trade in liquor subject to its regulation by
the State under Article 19(6) of the Constitution including its right to
monopoly business in relation to the product (see the cases in Khoday
Distilleries Ltd. v. State of Karnataka: (1995) 1 SCC 574, Kerela Bar
Hotels Association & anr v. State of Kerela & ors: (2015) 16 SCC 421,
Krishna Kumar Narula etc. v. State of Jammu and Kashmir & ors: AIR
1967 SC 1368 and M/s United Spirits Limited v. Uttarakhand
Agricultural Produce Marketing Board & ors: 2015 SCC Online Utt
2109).
That the State could itself or through an agent carry out monopoly
business was held in Akadasi Padhan v. State of Orissa & ors reported in
AIR 1963 SC 1047. In the facts and circumstances of that case, the
2025:MLHC:802-DB
authorisation of a contractor by a Municipal Board to carry on business at
a particular market place was held by the Supreme Court in Rashid Ahmed
v. Municipal Board, Kairana & ors reported in 1950 SCC 221 as creation
of an illegal monopoly by the State. The State is empowered to grant
monopoly rights to a person to carry on a particular business. It is,
however, to justify that such right granted to a particular person to the
exclusion of others as reasonable restriction of his rights in the facts and
circumstances of the case (see State of Rajasthan v. Mohan Lal Vyas:
1971 (3) SCC 705).
The exercise of powers beyond what has been delegated by the
legislature is liable to be declared invalid and set aside.
Mr. Paul, learned Senior Advocate appearing for the writ petitioner
in WP (C) No.234 of 2021 supplemented the arguments made by Mr.
Saha. He cited Kumari Shrilekha Vidyarthi & ors v. State of U.P. & ors
reported in (1991) 1 SCC 212 which followed Ramana Dayaram Shetty
v. International Airport Authority of India: (1979) 3 SCC 489 and
Kasturi Lal Lakshmi Reedy v. State of Jammu and Kashmir:(1980) 4
SCC 1. He argued while the government had an unfettered right to
formulate and implement policies, such right was conditioned by the
requirements of reasonableness and compliance with constitutional
2025:MLHC:802-DB
provisions and absence of arbitrariness. He argued citing Kavalappara
Kottarathil Kochuni & ors v. States of Madras and Kerela & ors reported
in AIR 1960 SC 1080 that any restriction imposed by the government
under Article 19(5) had to bear a reasonable relation to the object sought
to be achieved, serve public interest and should be reasonable. Any
restriction had to be gauged under Article 19(6) subjectively.
Discretionary powers granted to administrative authorities must be
exercised reasonably (see Union of India & anr v. G. Ganayutham:
(1997) 7 SCC 463 and Messrs Dwarka Prasad Laxmi Narain v. State of
Uttar Pradesh & ors: (1954) 1 SCC 1).
It was also said that the impugned rules did not respect consumer
preference. It was also said that the Central Bonded Warehouse did not
have any additional functions. It was done to accommodate a business
organization which was formed just few weeks before. No benefit to the
trade was brought by the impugned Rules. This could impact the market.
On behalf of the State, Mr. Debal Kumar Banerjee, learned senior
Advocate permitted by the learned Advocate General to make submissions
before him, made the following submission:
By the impugned rule, no monopoly trade in liquor was sought to
be created by the State by creation of the Central Bonded Warehouse. It
2025:MLHC:802-DB
only regulated part of the trade. To be a monopoly, the Central Bonded
Warehouse ought to have been given the powers of totally controlling of
the manufacture, supply, distribution and sale of liquor in the State.
The said Act and rules had a reference to “warehouse” particularly
in Section 16 (Heading) and Section 36(f) which implied that the
legislature contemplated more than one warehouse. The creation of the
Central Bonded Warehouse could not be said to be beyond the scope of
the statute. The said Act covered a wide range of subject pertaining to the
liquor trade in this State and a reservoir of powers to the government to
control that trade. One of such subjects and power concerned the
regulation of manufacture and supply of country liquor by subordinate
legislation.
In Section 19, the legislature had given power to the State
government to designate any area and grant exclusive right of
manufacturing and supplying country liquor to a person in that area. It was
only partial exercise of that reservoir of powers that the legislature had
exercised in the Act by stipulating that in a particular area, a particular
person may be designated to manufacture and supply country liquor. On a
plain and simple reading of the words of the section, there was neither
express nor any implied stipulation that this meant that the State could not
2025:MLHC:802-DB
regulate manufacture, supply and distribution of foreign liquor. Section 19
did not prevent the State from creating a Central Bonded Warehouse for
more integrated, streamline and transparent trade for foreign liquor in the
State by allotting specific functions to the Central Bonded Warehouse.
Creation of a Central Bonded Warehouse to regulate trade in liquor
under the said Act and rules was contemplated and could not be said to be
ultra vires the Act or any rule.
The government was the best judge of the nitty-gritties of an
economic policy, identifying the economic circumstances that require
attention, the detailed plan and method of tackling it, the formulation of a
policy to do so and its implementation. This was the prerogative of the
government. The work was specialised and conceptualised by the
government and consulting experts. The Courts should not ordinarily
interfere unless it was shown that it was unconstitutional or violative of
any law or most arbitrary, mala fide, unreasonable or perverse. Not falling
into any of the above categories, the said policy embodied in the impugned
Rules should not be interfered with by this Court.
With the leave of the Court, the State government filed an affidavit
affirmed on 26th August, 2025 at the close of hearing of the matter to
demonstrate that after coming into force of the impugned rules, there had
2025:MLHC:802-DB
been a dramatic increase in the sale of foreign liquor of various premium
brands between 2021 and 2024-25. A table annexed to the said affidavit
where the figures include cases of the brand, which case comprising of 12
bottles is set out below:
20-21
21-22
22-23
23-24
24-25
ISWAI
ISWAI
66268
192433
95714
269365
145972
207404
285638
259410
468514
272125
Non
ISWAI
ISWAI
ISWAI
ISWAI
412325
487916
429215
298868
206845
335263
11230
12379
634057
13450
11725
764619
16100
11317
682227
18500
18145
615668
21550”
“Brand
Imperial Blue
No.1 Reserve & No.1
luxury
Officer Choice Blue
Royal Challenge
Royal Stag
Old Monk
Hence, the introduction of the amendment according to learned
counsel had augmented the business of various bonded warehouses and
not affected it.
Learned Counsel emphasised that under the Central Warehouse
system it was obliged to keep in stock the demand made by retailers as
routed through the Bonded Warehouse. By this method the trade in foreign
liquor was open, transparent, competitive and smooth, more than it was
under the regime of Bonded Warehouses. This was so because the Bonded
Warehouses had the scope of manipulating demand and supply. He also
added that if the Central Warehouse was guilty of not attending to
requisition made by the retailers routed through the bonded warehouses,
2025:MLHC:802-DB
it would be open to any aggrieved person to make a complaint on which
the government would promptly act.
The price of a liquor bottle was fixed by the government. This price
had several components namely, the manufacturer/bottler/supplier’s price,
taxes and levies, commission to Central Bonded Warehouse and bonder
warehouse and retailer margin. The brands that could be sold were also
approved by the government.
The present sanctioned commission rate for bonded warehouse was
eight per cent minimum and ten per cent for the Central Bonded
Warehouse.
The Central Bonded Warehouse was required to maintain a
minimum stock. It was also required to obtain the stock on requisition
from the bonded warehouse which made the requisition on demand from
retailers. It was required to make supply to the bonded warehouse within
a particular time. If it did not comply with the above stipulations, it was
liable to action under the said Act and rules.
Inspite of the Central Bonded Warehouse being allowed ten per cent
commission, the record would show that as depicted in the affidavit dated
26th August, 2025 the turnover in the sale of foreign liquor increased most
2025:MLHC:802-DB
appreciably between 2021 and 2024-25. It followed that the bonded
warehouses were running larger profits.
Learned counsel submitted that a policy must be gauged from the
benefit it brought to the public at large and not from any loss or losses
caused to a particular individual. Instead of lowering the profit margin of
bonded warehouses, the creation of the Central Bonded Warehouse had in
fact increased it. It also checked “revenue leakage”, streamline supply
from manufacturers and to the Central Bonded Warehouse after payment
of taxes ensures proper and complete tax collection. Movement of stock
from manufacturers, bottlers and supply to 45 bonded warehouses gave
enough scope of clandestine supply of liquor without payment of tax and
other levies.
Mr. Banerjee, contended that a private entrepreneur had no
fundamental right to exclusively and without restriction trade in
intoxicating liquor and was always subject to reasonable restrictions
imposed under Article 19(1)(g) and Article 19(6) of the Constitution. The
State had plenary power to regulate, restrict or prohibit such trade in public
interest. He cited Cooverjee B. Bharucha v. Excise Commissioner and
the Chief Commissioner, Ajmer & ors reported in (1954) 1 SCC 18,
Khoday Distilleries Ltd. & ors v. State of Karnataka & ors: (1995) 1 SCC
2025:MLHC:802-DB
574 and International Spirits and Wines Association of India v. State of
Haryana & ors: (2019) 20 SCC 294. The right of the State to regulate
liquor trade was part of its general right to impose reasonable restrictions
on business in public interest in Article 19 of the Constitution as laid down
by the Supreme Court in T.B. Ibrahim, Proprietor, Bus Stand, Tanjore
v. Regional Transport Authority, Tanjore reported in (1952) 2 SCC 590
and Viklad Coal Merchant, Patiala & ors v. Union of India & ors
reported in (1984) 1 SCC 619. He also emphasised the basic principles
with regard to the exercise of power of courts to interfere with government
policy. Even less was the power to interfere in policy involving economic
decisions. Interference would only be made if it could be shown that any
policy was unconstitutional, illegal, arbitrary, discriminatory, mala fide or
grossly unreasonable (see Swiss Ribbons Private Limited & anr v. Union
of India & ors: (2019) 4 SCC 17, State of M.P. & ors v. Nandlal Jaiswal
& ors: (1986) 4 SCC 566, Small Scale Industrial Manufactures
Association (Registered) v. Union of India & ors: (2021) 8 SCC 511 and
Association of Registration Plates v. Union of India & ors: (2005) 1 SCC
679).
Learned Advocate General supplemented the submission of Mr.
D.K. Banerjee, learned Senior Advocate. He added that in Section 16 and
2025:MLHC:802-DB
Section 36(f) of the said Act there was mention of “warehouses”. Now,
Section 36 contained the powers granted to the State legislature to frame
rules when it referred to warehouses it necessarily implied that the
legislature conceptualised more than one warehouse. Therefore, a Central
Bonded Warehouse was not beyond the contemplation of the legislature
and hence, not beyond the scope of the Act. He further submitted that there
were ample checks and balances in the rules to ensure proper functioning
by the bonded warehouses including the Central Bonded Warehouse. He
referred to the letter of International Spirits and Wines Association of
India dated 13th May, 2021. His purpose of relying on the letter was only
to show that the Association’s apprehension was confined to reduction of
commission of bonded warehouses on the creation of the Central Bonded
Warehouse. The association urged the government to absorb the
commission in the revenue earned by it through sale of liquor. There was
no assertion of invalidity of the impugned rules.
Thereafter, Dr. N. Mozika, learned Senior counsel made submission
on behalf of the Central Bonded Warehouse. He argued that the licence
was granted to his client on 26th March, 2021. It has started operation from
26th July, 2021. It was compulsory for Central Bonded Warehouse could
only deal with registered brands with the government. There had been
2025:MLHC:802-DB
significant increase in sale in general of foreign liquor in the State. Dr.
Mozika cited paragraph 34 of Collector of Customs, Madras & anr v.
Nathella Sampathu Chetty & anr reported in AIR 1962 SC 316. He
argued that the mere apprehension that an enactment may be misused or
implemented illegally would not be a ground to declare it as ultra vires if
otherwise it was valid.
Findings, observations and conclusions:
In an Act of the legislature whether parent or amending, there are
recitals to explain the state of affairs or “mischief” which necessitated
such enactment or amendment. This is normally not the practice in the
case of framing of rules and regulations under it.
There is no recital in the impugned rules.
In the Act and parent rules there are provisions for plurality of
warehouses. (Section 16 and Section 36(f))
Article 19 (6) is clarificatory of Article 19 (1 to 5) of the
Constitution to the extent that carrying on business by the State in a
particular field to the exclusion of private entrepreneurs cannot be taken
as an unreasonable restriction on the freedom of citizens to carry on trade
and business. This provision in no way prevents the State from authorising
a private entrepreneur to do monopoly business in a particular trade if the
2025:MLHC:802-DB
facts and circumstances require. However, this kind of decision has to
satisfy the test of reasonableness because by such action the State is
preventing other private entrepreneurs from doing business in that area.
A monopoly in our opinion would refer to exclusive control of an
entire industry, business or service at all levels and in all areas of its
operation by a particular person, to the exclusion of all others. Regulation
by the legislature of a part of a business by authorising a person or entity
to carry it out more effective in public interest cannot be called creation of
a monopoly of a private person by the legislature or by the State.
Assam Bonded Warehouses Rules, 1965 (as adapted by
Meghalaya) by the Meghalaya Bonded Warehouse (Amendment) Rules,
2020 and creation of a Central Bonded Warehouse did not setup a
monopoly business but regulated a part of the trade in foreign liquor in the
State of Meghalaya.
Even if setting up of the Central warehouse is treated as setting up
of a monopoly business, still, the government in the given facts and
circumstances was entitled to authorise a private entrepreneur to do
monopoly business in the trade under the Assam Excise Act, 1910 and the
Assam Bonded Warehouse Rules, 1965 framed thereunder as amended
from time to time.
2025:MLHC:802-DB
A plain, ordinary and grammatical as well as purposeful
interpretation of Section 19 of the Assam Excise Act, 1910 makes it plain
that it only refers to the power of the government to regulate or channelise
the business or trade in country liquor. In no way does it exclude or restrict
the reservoir of powers under the said Act to frame subordinate legislation
to otherwise regulate the trade which includes creation of the Central
Bonded Warehouse for procurement, storage and distribution of foreign
liquor. The doctrine of “expressio unius est exclusio alterius” has no
application to this case.
The promulgation of the Bonded Warehouse (Amendment) Rules,
2020 has to be seen as a policy decision of the government. We have found
nothing in this policy which could be termed as unconstitutional as
violative of Articles 14, 19 or 21 or illegal or arbitrary or unreasonable or
perverse.
At least from the face of the notification, the businesses of the
bonded warehouses are not interfered with. They would only have to buy
or procure the liquor from a Central Bonded Warehouse, instead of buying
it from the open market.
2025:MLHC:802-DB
The rules contain detailed provision for the stock to be maintained
by the central bonded warehouse and the mode and manner in which it has
to supply this stock to the bonded warehouses on their demand.
The price of a bottle of liquor is fixed by the excise authority. This
price is inclusive of all taxes, levies and commissions. This is a safeguard
against misuse of the impugned rules.
The version of the government is that the demanded quantity of
liquor, of the description and quality ordered by the retailers, on the basis
of demand by consumers, would have to be adhered to by the Central
Bonded Warehouse. Creation of the Central Bonded Warehouse removes
the likelihood of bonded warehouses entering into transactions or
arrangements with select manufacturers, bottlers and brand owners to
trade only in specific brands of liquor where the margin of commission is
more.
Up to date there in nothing on record to show that any demand for
liquor made by consumers and routed through retailers and bonded
warehouses has not been fulfilled by the central warehouse.
The only legitimate grievance which the writ petitioners have
against the impugned rules is that to maintain the fixed price the
commission receivable by the bonded warehouses has to be shared with
2025:MLHC:802-DB
the Central Bonded Warehouse, resulting in diminution of the margin of
profit or earning.
It has not been shown that the earning of a bonded warehouse or
manufacturers, bottlers and the suppliers has fallen after the coming into
force of the rules. The said affidavit filed by the State, in fact shows that
sale of premium brands foreign liquor has substantially increased since
coming into force of the impugned rules.
This is a particular brand of subordinate legislation which is also a
policy statement. On the face of it, it is not invalid. However, it is possible
for the State to apply or implement this rule in derogation of the
Constitution or fail to take action against those who misuse it. In that case,
the rule itself becomes a monster and is liable to be struck down by the
Court as invalid and as an illegal and bad policy. The principle in Collector
of Customs, Madras & anr v. Nathella Sampathu Chetty & anr reported
in AIR 1962 SC 316 would not apply. It only applies when the application
of the Act causes injury. It would not apply when the Act or rule itself is
converted into an engine of oppression.
If for example, the Central Bonded Warehouse is used as an engine
to throttle the business of other bonded warehouses by the State allowing
a large commission to it and reducing the commission of bonded
2025:MLHC:802-DB
warehouses thereby causing a huge diminution in their turnover from
business, then the notification becomes a monster or arbitrary or
unreasonable promoting the business of the Central Bonded Warehouse
and causing extraordinary loss to the bonded warehouses.
Allowing the Central Bonded Warehouse to favour one bonded
warehouse against others or a group against the rest resulting in significant
detriment to the business of others would produce the same result.
Failing to absorb the extra and unreasonable amount of commission
the Central Bonded Warehouse would claim and earn against the taxes
received by the State or against a reasonably raised price would have the
same result.
We were really pleased to receive the assurance of learned counsel
for the State that it was willing to apply and work the rules out according
to the guidance and direction given by the Court below:
Directions:
The state government is to strictly monitor the business carried out
by the central bonded warehouse with the other bonded warehouses and
with the manufacturers, distillers and suppliers.
By an administrative order the State shall fairly and reasonably fix
the commission to be charged by the Central Bonded Warehouse.
2025:MLHC:802-DB
It required, this extra amount of commission is to be first absorbed
by the government by reducing its taxes on a bottle of liquor and thereafter
consider enhancing the price of a bottle, if required reasonably, so that the
enhancement in price is minimal and does not affect the commission
earned by the bonded warehouses or the market demand.
The government is to closely monitor the activities of the Central
Bonded Warehouse in relation to each of the other bonded warehouses so
that the stock and description of liquor made available by Central Bonded
Warehouse to each of the bonded warehouses is more or less the same as
it was before the introduction of the impugned rule.
The government shall ensure that the Central Bonded Warehouse
does not discriminate between the bonded warehouses and carries on its
business in a fair and transparent manner.
If the government receives any complaint from any interested
person with regard to procurement, supply and distribution by the Central
Bonded Warehouse to the bonded warehouses it shall immediately
entertain the complaint and take necessary measures to solve the problem.
Therefore, as of now, the rules stand but subject to its application
and regulation properly and reasonably by the government in accordance
with our observations and directions above.
2025:MLHC:802-DB
In those circumstances, we declare that the impugned rules are valid
and intra vires the Constitution and the laws.
In case of infraction of our directions by the State resulting in
misuse of the rules the writ petitioners shall have a fresh cause of action
to file a proceeding to declare them as invalid and ultra vires.
Both the writ petitions are disposed of declaring the Meghalaya
Bonded Warehouse (Amendment) Rules, 2020 as constitutional and valid
but subject to compliance by the respondent-State with our directions
above for implementation of the said rules. We grant liberty to the
petitioners to apply afresh for quashing of the said rules in case of
disobedience to our directions or failure to implement the rules in
accordance with our directions.
Miscellaneous applications are also disposed of.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(I.P. Mukerji)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
04.09.2025
“Lam DR-PS”
LAMPHRANG KHARCHANDY
Date: 2025.09.04 20:02:42 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review