Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~1 (11.09.2026)
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 14th September, 2026
#
CNR No. DLHC010836892018
+
W.P.(C) 3859/2018
ASHWIN JAWAHARLAL MEHTA
Through:
.....Petitioner
Ms. Abiha Zaidi, Mr. Pritam Raman
Giriya, Mr. Aryan S. and Mr. Rohit
Rampuriya, Advocates.
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ORS
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. V.N. Koura, Mr. Aditya Sharma,
Mr. Nirbhay Narain Singh and
Ms. Paramjeet Benipal. Advocates for
IOCL.
Mr. Vikrant Nilesh Goyal,
Mr. Inderjeet Singh and Ms. Kunal
Dixit, Advocates for R-1.
Mr. Naman Saraswat and Mr. Kanav
Singhal, Advocates for R-4.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
JUDGMENT
SANJEEV NARULA, J. (Oral):
[This case is being taken up today as 11th September, 2026 was
declared a holiday vide Notification No. 86/G-4/Genl.-I/DHC]
CM APPL. 41294/2025 (condonation of delay in filing additional affidavit)
1.
For the reasons stated in the application, the same is allowed. The
delay of 40 days in filing the additional affidavit by Respondent No. 3 in
terms of the order dated 7th May, 2025 is condoned. The additional affidavit,
Dgitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
18:21:35
W.P.(C) 3859/2018
along with the accompanying annexures, is taken on record.
2.
The application stands disposed of.
W.P.(C) 3859/2018
3.
This petition arises principally out of two recruitment exercises in
which the Petitioner’s son, Bhagyadeep Ashwinbhai Mehta, participated as a
person with hearing impairment. The first was conducted by Indian Oil
Corporation Ltd. [“IOCL”] in 2014 and the second by Oil and Natural Gas
Corporation Ltd. [“ONGC”] in 2017. In both cases, he was shortlisted based
on his GATE score and proceeded to the subsequent stages of the selection
process. He was, however, not selected.
4.
What began as a challenge to these selections has, in this petition,
assumed a wider dimension. The Petitioner contends that once a post is
identified as suitable for a particular disability and a suitable candidate with
that disability is available, the candidate cannot be denied appointment
through further stages such as interview, Group Discussion [“GD”] or Group
Task [“GT”], followed by carrying forward of the vacancy. On this basis, he
seeks not only appointment of his son, but also directions concerning the use
of interviews, GD and GT in the recruitment of persons with disabilities and
the manner in which reserved vacancies are to be filled. The reliefs, thus,
extend well beyond the two selections from which the dispute arose.
The IOCL recruitment
5.
Bhagyadeep is a Mechanical Engineer. In the recruitment conducted
by IOCL through GATE-2014, he applied for the post of Officer/Assistant
Officer in the mechanical discipline under the PwD (HH) category. The
recruitment process comprised GATE, followed by GD/GT and Personal
Interview [“PI”]. A candidate was required to qualify at each stage, with the
Dgitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
18:21:35
W.P.(C) 3859/2018
final merit list prepared by reckoning performance in all the three stages.
6.
Bhagyadeep obtained 29.05 marks in GATE-2014, 44/100 in GD/GT
and 5/10 in PI. With 85% weightage assigned to GATE, 5% to GD/GT and
10% to the PI, his composite score was calculated as 31.893. He met the
individual qualifying requirements of 40 marks in GD/GT and 4 marks in
the PI but did not meet IOCL’s minimum composite score of 40 marks
prescribed for PwD candidates.
7.
There were two vacancies for HH candidates in Mechanical
Engineering. One candidate secured a composite score of 55.614 and was
empanelled against the HH category. The Petitioner contends that the other
vacancy remained unfilled.
8.
The Petitioner thereafter approached the Chief Commissioner for
Persons with Disabilities [“CCPD”]. By order dated 15th February, 2017, the
complaint was disposed of. The CCPD noted that Bhagyadeep had not
secured the minimum composite score of 40 marks and that, of the two HH
vacancies in Mechanical Engineering, one candidate had been empanelled
after meeting the minimum composite score. The CCPD concluded that no
violation of the Persons with Disabilities Act, 1995 [“1995 PwD Act”], the
Rules or the Government instructions was made out.
9.
This petition was initially disposed of on 20th April, 2018, with a
direction to reconsider the benchmark in view of the backlog of vacancies.
That order was, thereafter, set aside in LPA 373/2018 on 17 th July, 2018, as
IOCL and ONGC, against whom the primary reliefs were sought, had not
been heard. The matter was remanded for fresh consideration, with all legal
objections of the Respondents left open.
10.
On 7th May, 2025, this Court directed IOCL to place the relevant
Dgitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
18:21:35
W.P.(C) 3859/2018
recruitment material and Bhagyadeep’s assessment record on an affidavit
and, in particular, to address the question of compliance with Clause 22 of
the DoPT Office Memorandum dated 29th December, 2005. Clause 22 reads:
“RELAXATION OF STANDARD OF SUITABILITY:
If sufficient number of persons with disabilities are not available on
the basis of the general standard to fill all the vacancies reserved for
them, candidates belonging to this category may be selected on
relaxed standard to fill up the remaining vacancies reserved for them
provided they are not found unfit for such post or posts…”
11.
IOCL, in its affidavit filed in compliance with the order dated 7 th
May, 2025, indicates a series of relaxation given to PwD candidates in the
2014 recruitment: the minimum marks in the qualifying engineering degree
were reduced from 65% to 55%; the qualifying marks in GATE were
reduced from 35% to 25%; and, at the composite stage, while
General/Unreserved candidates were required to secure 45%, PwD
candidates were considered fit/suitable upon securing 40% or more. IOCL
states that these relaxations were extended to PwD candidates pursuant to,
and in keeping with, Clause 22.
12.
IOCL has, in its Counter Affidavit, stated that, over time, the 40%
composite standard did not result in sufficient recruitment of PwDs. As a
one-time measure in 2018, it therefore reduced the minimum consolidated
qualifying marks from 40% to 30% to fill the accumulated carried-forward
vacancies in respect of PwDs. According to IOCL, this resulted in the
recruitment of 60 PwD candidates, of whom 16 had secured between 30%
and less than 40%, and the backlog was thereby virtually eliminated.
13.
Bhagyadeep also participated in IOCL’s GATE-2018 recruitment
exercise. He obtained 24.97 marks in GATE, 35 marks in GD/GT and 4.5
Dgitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
18:21:35
W.P.(C) 3859/2018
marks in the PI. His consolidated marks were not calculated as he failed to
meet the separate GD/GT qualifying requirement of 40 marks. IOCL
accordingly states that he could not qualify for recruitment even with the
relaxation of the consolidated qualifying marks to 30% in 2018.
The ONGC recruitment
14.
The ONGC case concerns recruitment through GATE-2017 for the
post of Assistant Executive Engineer (Mechanical). The score sheet records
that Bhagyadeep obtained 22.2/60 marks in the GATE component, 20/25
marks for qualification and 5/15 marks in the interview, giving him an
aggregate of 47.2 marks. The qualifying interview score for PwD candidates
was 6/15. The cut-off for the PwD-HH category was 48.20, and 6 candidates
in the PwD-HH category were empanelled.
15.
The interview requirement pre-dated the GATE-2017 recruitment.
ONGC’s Office Order dated 11th September, 2003 prescribed 15 marks for
interview and required SC/ST and physically handicapped candidates to
secure 40% marks in the interview. It further stipulated that candidates were
required to qualify at each stage separately. The Working Paper for the
GATE-2017 recruitment continued this framework.
16.
Bhagyadeep himself proceeded on this basis in his representations to
ONGC. In his representation dated 1st July, 2017, he recorded that he had
secured 5 marks in the interview against the qualifying requirement of 6 and
requested one grace mark to enable his empanelment. In a subsequent
representation dated 30th September, 2017, he reiterated the request and
sought consideration against any vacancy arising due to non-joining of a
selected HH candidate. ONGC declined the request, stating that there was no
provision for grant of grace marks in the recruitment/selection process.
Dgitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
18:21:35
W.P.(C) 3859/2018
Submissions
17.
Ms. Abiha Zaidi, counsel for the Petitioner, submits that the matter
must be viewed in the context of a beneficial legislation intended to secure
actual employment for PwDs rather than merely reserve vacancies on paper.
She places reliance upon Sections 32, 33 and 36 of the 1995 PwD Act and
Sections 20, 33 and 34 of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016
[“2016 RPwD Act”]. Her principal submission is that where reserved
vacancies remain unfilled despite the availability of candidates with the
identified disability, the employer is required to relax its standards rather
than reject such candidates and add to the backlog.
18.
Particular emphasis is placed upon Clause 22 of the DoPT OM dated
29th December, 2005. According to the Petitioner, Bhagyadeep had passed
each individual component of IOCL’s 2014 selection. One of the two HH
mechanical
vacancies
nevertheless
remained
vacant.
IOCL’s
own
subsequent decision in 2018 to reduce the composite benchmark to 30%, it
is urged, shows that the figure of 40 was not an immutable standard of
fitness and could equally have been relaxed in 2014.
19.
Reliance is also placed upon UOI & Anr. v. National Federation of
the Blind & Ors.1 and Rajeev Kumar Gupta & Ors. v. UOI & Ors2. It is
submitted that once a post is identified as suitable for a particular disability,
a person with that disability who fulfils the basic eligibility requirements
must be regarded as suitable; the selection process cannot thereafter be
employed to defeat the reservation by leaving the vacancy unfilled.
20.
Mr. V.N. Koura, counsel for IOCL, contends that the Petitioner’s
(2013) 10 SCC 772.
(2016) 13 SCC 153.
Dgitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
18:21:35
W.P.(C) 3859/2018
formulation overlooks the distinction between eligibility, suitability and
selection. Clause 22 was not ignored in 2014. PwD candidates were already
competing at relaxed standards at several stages of the recruitment and the
composite benchmark itself stood reduced from 45 to 40. A candidate below
that level was treated as not suitable for appointment to the officers’ cadre.
The further reduction to 30 in 2018 was a conscious one-time decision taken
four years later to liquidate accumulated backlog. It cannot be carried
backwards into a concluded recruitment.
21.
Mr. Naman Saraswat, counsel for ONGC, similarly submits that
qualifying GATE only entitled a candidate to proceed to the next stage. The
applicable recruitment framework required separate qualification in the
interview, in which Bhagyadeep obtained 5 marks against the prescribed 6.
There was no power to award him a grace mark.
22.
Although
ONGC’s
Counter
Affidavit
at
places
refers
to
Advertisement No. 07/2017 relating to GATE-2018, whereas Bhagyadeep’s
selection arose from Advertisement No. 03/2017 through GATE-2017, the
contemporaneous 2003 Office Order and the 2017 Working Paper, read with
the recruitment record, sufficiently establish the applicable qualifying
requirement. The Court therefore does not propose to rest the decision upon
ONGC’s objection of waiver based on participation in the selection. The
case can be decided on merits.
Discussion
Questions for Consideration
23.
The case turns on the distinction between reservation of a post and
suitability for appointment to it. The first question is whether identification
of a post for persons with a particular disability means that every eligible
Dgitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
18:21:35
W.P.(C) 3859/2018
candidate with that disability is entitled to appointment, irrespective of the
prescribed standard of suitability. If not, the further question is whether
Clause 22 required IOCL to relax the 40% benchmark until the remaining
reserved vacancy was filled.
24.
The answer to both questions is negative. Identification of a post
establishes that the post is suitable for persons with the specified disability;
it does not dispense with an assessment of whether an individual candidate
meets the prescribed standard for appointment. Nor does Clause 22 require
the employer to keep lowering an already relaxed standard merely because a
reserved vacancy remains unfilled.
Identification of Posts and Individual Suitability
25.
Rajeev Kumar Gupta does not take the matter as far as the Petitioner
suggests. The issue before the Supreme Court was whether the statutory
reservation in identified Group A and B posts could be denied when such
posts were filled through promotion, on the basis of the policy which
restricted reservation in promotion to identified Group C and D posts. The
Supreme Court held that it could not. It emphasised that the identification
exercise under Section 32 of the 1995 PwD Act is crucial. Once a post is
identified, it means that a PwD is fully capable of discharging the functions
associated with that post. Reservation under Section 33 of the 1995 PwD
Act must, therefore, follow irrespective of the mode of recruitment adopted
for filling up the post.
26.
The judgment was, thus, concerned with the effect of identification of
a post and the consequent obligation to extend reservation. It did not address
the standard by which an individual candidate is to be selected for an
identified post. There is a distinction between identifying a post as one
Dgitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
18:21:35
W.P.(C) 3859/2018
which can be held by a person with a particular disability and determining
whether an individual candidate satisfies the prescribed standard for
selection to that post. Rajeev Kumar Gupta addresses the former. It does not
hold that every candidate who meets the basic eligibility requirements for an
identified post must necessarily be treated as suitable, or that an interview or
another legitimate stage of selection is, for that reason, impermissible.
27.
National Federation of the Blind dealt with the computation of
reservation under Section 33 of the 1995 PwD Act. The Supreme Court held
that the 3% reservation is to be computed with reference to the total number
of vacancies in the cadre strength and not merely on the basis of vacancies
in identified posts. It further clarified that identification under Section 32 is
not a precondition for computation of the reservation and that the scope of
identification comes into picture at the time of appointment of a person in a
post identified for PwDs. Nothing in the judgment dispenses with the
requirement that the person appointed against such vacancy must be suitable
for the identified post. Section 36 of the 1995 PwD Act, in fact, expressly
contemplates a reserved vacancy remaining unfilled where a suitable PwD is
not available and provides for its carry forward.
Relaxation of Standards Under Clause 22
28.
The question of relaxation was considered more recently in In Re:
Recruitment of Visually Impaired in Judicial Services3. The Supreme
Court first made it clear that the mere existence of vacancies cannot be a
ground to claim relaxation in marks. In this regard, the Court referred,
amongst other decisions, to Taniya Malik v. Registrar General, High Court
2025 SCC OnLine SC 481.
Dgitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
18:21:35
W.P.(C) 3859/2018
of Delhi4, wherein it was held that the mere fact that additional posts had
been advertised and remained vacant could not justify relaxation of the
minimum interview marks after the interview had already been conducted.
29.
The Supreme Court then considered the position where the governing
rules or executive instructions confer a power to relax the prescribed
standard. Referring to Clause 11 of the DoPT Office Memorandum dated
15th January, 2018, the Court held that relaxation of minimum marks is
permissible where such a power is available to the appointing authority. In
Alok Singh v. State of MP, which formed part of the same decision in In Re:
Recruitment, the appellant had fallen short of the minimum interview marks
despite vacancies being available in the PwD quota. The Supreme Court
directed that the appellant and similarly placed candidates be considered in
the light of the decision and, if otherwise eligible, for appointment against
the vacant posts after applying the applicable relaxation provided for in the
executive orders. Thus, while an unfilled vacancy does not, by itself, compel
relaxation, a specific power of relaxation available under the governing
instructions must be given due consideration.
30.
That distinction is important in the present case. IOCL’s stand is not
that Clause 22 had no application to the 2014 recruitment. Its case is that the
clause had already been acted upon: against the general composite standard
of 45%, a relaxed composite standard of 40% was prescribed for PwD
candidates. The question, therefore, is not whether IOCL was required to
consider relaxation at all, but whether Clause 22 obliged it to relax the
already reduced standard further merely because, as contended by the
Petitioner, one reserved vacancy remained unfilled.
(2018) 14 SCC 129.
Dgitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
18:21:35
W.P.(C) 3859/2018
31.
Akhilesh Kumar v. UGC & Ors.5 also requires some attention as it
concerned the same Clause 22 that falls for consideration in the present case.
This Court had held that the clause permits relaxation of suitability standards
where sufficient PwDs are not available on the basis of the general or
prescribed standard to fill the vacancies reserved for them. The petitioner
therein was the only applicant for the vacancy reserved for a visually
handicapped person and had been selected by the duly constituted Selection
Committee. Although he had not, at the time of selection, acquired the
requisite M.Phil qualification or cleared NET, UGC subsequently granted
him accommodation by allowing him time to acquire the M.Phil degree. He
acquired the qualification within the period granted and was thereafter
absorbed on a permanent basis. The Court held that, in those circumstances,
the grant of relaxation in the first instance was the appropriate approach and
that the UGC could not thereafter withdraw the approval.
32.
Akhilesh Kumar, thus, recognises the scope of Clause 22 to afford
relaxation in suitability standards as a form of reasonable accommodation. It
does not, however, address the question arising here, namely, whether
Clause 22 requires a further reduction of a quantitative qualifying
benchmark after a relaxed standard has already been prescribed.
The 40% Benchmark in the IOCL Recruitment
33.
It is true that the IOCL GATE-2014 advertisement did not mention
the composite qualifying scores of 45% and 40%. However, there is nothing
on record to suggest that the 40% benchmark was introduced after the
selection had commenced. In its affidavit filed in pursuance of the order
dated 7th May, 2025, IOCL states that, in the GATE-2014 recruitment, PwD
2014 SCC OnLine Del 935.
Dgitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
18:21:35
W.P.(C) 3859/2018
candidates were considered fit/suitable upon securing 40% or more in the
aggregate, pursuant to Clause 22. Further, as stated in IOCL’s Counter
Affidavit, the 40% benchmark was subsequently reduced to 30% in 2018 as
a one-time measure to fill accumulated carried-forward vacancies. The 40%
benchmark was, therefore, not a later addition to the 2014 selection.
34.
The line of authorities concerning the introduction or alteration of
selection criteria after a recruitment had commenced, therefore, do not apply
in the present case. The issue is whether the existing relaxed benchmark of
40% was required to be reduced further merely because one reserved
vacancy remained unfilled.
35.
IOCL had already relaxed the general composite standard from 45%
to 40% for PwD candidates. Bhagyadeep’s composite score was 31.893.
Although he cleared the separate GD/GT and interview thresholds, he did
not meet the composite standard for inclusion in the final merit list.
36.
Even assuming that one HH vacancy remained unfilled, that did not
oblige IOCL to lower the benchmark until Bhagyadeep qualified. Section 36
of the 1995 PwD Act expressly contemplates that a reserved vacancy could
remain unfilled for want of a suitable candidate and provides for its carryforward. An unfilled vacancy, therefore, attracts the statutory carry-forward
regime; it does not make every available candidate suitable.
37.
IOCL’s decision of 2018 does not alter this conclusion. Its pleading
on this aspect is worth recalling:
“...as a one-time measure the Respondent Corporation decided to
reduce the minimum consolidated qualifying marks to 30% in 2018
with view to fill up the accumulated carried forward vacancies...”
38.
That exercise resulted in 16 candidates, who had scored between 30
Dgitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
18:21:35
W.P.(C) 3859/2018
and 40, being recruited and, according to IOCL, virtually eliminated the
accumulated backlog.
39.
This shows that the standard was capable of relaxation. It does not
show that the standard applied in 2014 was unlawful. The 2018 exercise was
a policy response to the position that had developed by then. There is no
principle by which a later and expressly one-time relaxation must
retrospectively be transplanted into an earlier selection. Bhagyadeep’s
participation in the 2018 recruitment exercise also does not alter this
position. He did not meet the separate qualifying requirement in GD/GT
even in that recruitment and, consequently, could not avail of the 30%
composite benchmark introduced for that year. His participation in the 2018
exercise therefore neither affects the validity of the 40% benchmark
applicable in 2014 nor gives him any right to claim the benefit of the
subsequent 30% relaxation in the 2014 selection.
40.
IOCL has referred in its pleadings to Article 335 of the Constitution
of India while explaining its standards. We do not place our conclusion on
Article 335, which is concerned with the claims of members of the
Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. The point here is simpler.
Disability reservation does not exclude the prescription of a reasonable
minimum standard of suitability, and Clause 22 permits relaxation of that
standard without requiring the standard to be reduced indefinitely.
41.
The Court is conscious that the CCPD order dated 15th February, 2017
does not undertake this analysis and, in particular, does not discuss Clause
22. In an ordinary case, that omission might have justified reconsideration. It
would serve little purpose now. The selection is of 2014. The matter is
before us in 2026. Complete pleadings have since been filed; IOCL has
Dgitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
18:21:35
W.P.(C) 3859/2018
produced its assessment record and filed an additional affidavit specifically
pursuant to this Court’s orders; and both sides have addressed the point at
length. The issue can therefore be decided on the record before us rather
than being sent back for reconsideration.
The ONGC Recruitment
42.
This Court also does not find any ground to interfere with the ONGC
selection. Even assuming in favour of the Petitioner that the 2016 RPwD Act
governed that recruitment, Section 20 or Section 34 do not confer a right to
have marks added to a candidate’s interview score. Bhagyadeep was
required to obtain 6 marks in the interview, whereas he obtained 5. His
aggregate of 47.2 was also below the cut-off score of 48.20 reflected against
the PwD (HH) category. More importantly, his own contemporaneous
request was not that he had satisfied the prescribed standard; it was a request
that one additional mark be granted so that he could do so.
43.
There is also no provision in the applicable ONGC recruitment
framework for the award of a grace mark. The non-joining of an empanelled
candidate does not create such a power. If a reserved vacancy remained
unfilled, Section 34 of the 2016 RPwD Act provided for its treatment in
accordance with the statutory carry-forward mechanism. It did not, however,
require the marks secured by a candidate to be altered after the selection so
as to bring him within the prescribed qualifying standard.
The Other Challenges
44.
The broader challenge to interviews, GD/GT and similar stages of
selection also cannot succeed. Such processes may be open to challenge if
they disadvantage a candidate on account of disability or impose barriers
unrelated to the post. However, there is nothing on record to suggest that
Dgitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
18:21:35
W.P.(C) 3859/2018
either selection suffered from such an infirmity. Bhagyadeep cleared the
separate interview and GD/GT thresholds in the IOCL recruitment but fell
short of the composite score. In the ONGC recruitment, he did not secure
even the relaxed minimum prescribed for PwD candidates in the interview.
45.
One of the remaining prayers seeks a direction to IOCL and ONGC to
fill vacant or carried-forward posts of previous years from amongst
candidates who were eligible in the corresponding year on the basis of their
GATE results, before filling vacancies of subsequent years. The premise
underlying this prayer has already been considered and rejected.
Qualification in GATE by itself does not entitle a candidate to appointment
against a reserved vacancy without satisfying the further qualifying
standards prescribed in the relevant recruitment process.
46.
The other prayers, inter alia, seek directions to Government
Establishments/PSUs concerning the manner in which vacancies are to be
filled, as well as the creation of a Special Employment Exchange or a
Centralised Admission Committee and the appointment of an independent
medical authority. These are matters of general policy and institutional
arrangement extending beyond the two recruitment exercises in question. No
occasion therefore arises to issue such directions in the present proceedings.
Effective Implementation of Reservations for PwDs
47.
One observation is necessary. The statutory reservation for PwDs is
not satisfied merely by identifying posts and mechanically carrying
vacancies forward from year to year. National Federation of the Blind and
Rajeev Kumar Gupta emphasise the obligation to give meaningful effect to
the reservation framework. Public employers must periodically examine
whether their standards and processes are needlessly excluding persons with
Dgitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
18:21:35
W.P.(C) 3859/2018
disabilities and must use the powers of relaxation available to them where
circumstances justify it. IOCL’s 2018 exercise is itself an example of such
review. The obligation to make reservation effective, however, is not the
same thing as an individual right to appointment notwithstanding failure to
meet the standard which lawfully governs the selection.
Conclusion
48.
In view of the findings recorded above, this Court finds no ground to
direct appointment of the Petitioner’s son either in IOCL on the basis of the
2014 recruitment or in ONGC on the basis of the 2017 recruitment.
49.
The writ petition is, accordingly, dismissed.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
SEPTEMBER 14, 2026/hc/nk
Dgitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
18:21:35
W.P.(C) 3859/2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review