Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
W.P.(C) 7880/2018
ASHUTOSH KUMAR
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Ajay Kumar Singh, Mr. Yatharth
Singh and Ms. Shrishti Gautam,
Advocates.
versus
NATIONALS SCHEDULED CASTES FINANCE AND
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Rakesh Sinha, Mr. Md. Ghulam
Akbar, Mr. Jeemon Raju K. & Ms.
Suman Lata, Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
ORDER
03.02.2026
%
1.
This writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution assails the
decision of National Scheduled Castes Finance and Development
Corporation (NSFDC or “the Corporation”) of not selecting the Petitioner to
the post of Manager (Information Technology), pursuant to the recruitment
process initiated through the vacancy notification published in Employment
News dated 19th August, 2017 to 25th August, 2017. The Petitioner seeks, in
substance, a direction to set aside the decision of non-selection and to
appoint him to the said post.
Facts in brief
2.
The vacancy notification advertised, inter alia, one post of Manager
(IT) in the E-3 level (Group ‘A’) in the middle managerial cadre of the
Corporation. The “Mode of Selection” clause stipulated that selection to the
posts of Chief Managers and Managers would be through an online written
test followed by interview, and that appointment would be issued on the
W.P.(C) 7880/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 11/02/2026 at 11:28:49
basis of “order of merit” in the online written test and interview.
3.
The Corporation received five online applications for the post of
Manager (IT) by the closing date, 15th September, 2017. An online written
examination was conducted on 13th October, 2017 through an independent
agency, namely the Institute of Banking Personnel Selection (IBPS),
Mumbai. Only three candidates appeared.
4.
As per the Corporation, candidates securing 33% marks and above in
the written examination were to be called for the interview. On that basis,
only the Petitioner, having secured 85.86 marks out of 250 (34.34%), was
called for interview held on 19th February, 2018.
5.
The interview was conducted by a Selection Committee comprising
six members, including senior officers representing reserved categories and
women, and two external experts. One external expert was from the National
Informatics Centre (NIC) with domain expertise in IT. The interview carried
44 marks (15% weightage), while the written test carried 250 marks (85%
weightage), making a total of 294 marks.
6.
The Petitioner was awarded 8 marks out of 44 in the interview
(18.18%). His aggregate thus stood at 93.86 out of 294, that is 31.93%. The
Corporation asserts that the minimum required aggregate score for a Group
‘A’ post of Manager (E-3) was 33%, and since the Petitioner fell below that
threshold, the Selection Committee found him “not suitable”. The competent
authority accepted that recommendation. The post remains vacant.
7.
By communication dated 5th August, 2018, the Corporation informed
the Petitioner of these details and the basis for non-selection. The
Corporation also recorded, in the same communication, that at the stage of
document scrutiny it noticed a discrepancy in the Petitioner’s claim of PwD
W.P.(C) 7880/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 11/02/2026 at 11:28:49
(Low Vision) status, inasmuch as the disability certificate produced
indicated 20% disability whereas the online application reflected 40%.
Submissions
8.
The Petitioner makes the following submissions in support of the
reliefs sought:
8.1.
He satisfies the essential qualifications and experience prescribed for
the post and, on that basis, was admitted to the selection process.
8.2
Five candidates applied, three appeared in the online written
examination, and he alone was called for interview. The Petitioner being the
only candidate found eligible to be interviewed, coupled with the fact that
the post has remained vacant even thereafter, reinforces that the process
ought to have culminated in his appointment. The Corporation could not
have treated the interview as a device to defeat a selection process that had
otherwise found him fit to be considered.
8.3
The selection criteria is arbitrary and contrived. No minimum
aggregate benchmark was disclosed in the advertisement. The only disclosed
criteria was that selection would be through online written test followed by
interview and that appointment would be on the basis of “order of merit” in
those components. In the absence of an explicit qualifying benchmark, the
Corporation could not introduce a cut-off after the examination and
interview had taken place.
8.4
The Selection Committee travelled beyond the remit of the notified
process. Once the written examination was treated as the principal filter and
the Petitioner was called for interview as the sole qualifying candidate, the
interview could only test suitability of the candidates. It could not be used to
superimpose an undisclosed disqualifying threshold that nullifies the process
W.P.(C) 7880/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 11/02/2026 at 11:28:49
and renders the earlier exercise otiose. The Committee could not, by its own
assessment, set a “minimum required score” at the final stage unless such a
condition was part of the advertised rules or duly notified recruitment rules
placed on record.
8.5
No weightage was accorded to Petitioner’s past experience, although
he has substantial work exposure in the relevant field. For a managerial post
in IT, practical experience is central, and a selection that effectively reduces
the decision to a low interview score, without an explanation is plainly
arbitrary. The interview marks (8 out of 44) are ex facie disproportionate and
have been assigned without disclosing any objective criteria, marking rubric,
or interview record reflecting evaluation parameters, rendering the decision
vulnerable to challenge under Article 14.
8.6
The criteria governing selection cannot be altered midstream or at the
end of the process, as that would amount to changing the rules of the game.
Reliance is placed on the judgements in Hemani Malhotra v. High Court of
Delhi,1 and the subsequent reaffirmation of that principle in Sureshkumar
Lalitkumar Patel v. State of Gujarat,2 to contend that an advertisement
binds the recruiting body and any qualifying norms must be declared
upfront. A post facto benchmark is arbitrary, introduces uncertainty, and
permits unguided discretion.
8.7
The Corporation’s averments regarding his PwD declaration are being
pressed only as a justificatory afterthought. Petitioner maintains that any
discrepancy in stating “40%” disability in the online form as against a
certificate reflecting “20%” was a bona fide mistake and not deliberate. He
(2008) 7 SCC 11
(2023) 19 SCC 596
W.P.(C) 7880/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 11/02/2026 at 11:28:49
has not claimed or derived any advantage under the PwD category in this
process. The Corporation cannot deflect scrutiny from the core illegality in
selection by relying upon an alleged clerical mistake which did not confer
any tangible benefit in the recruitment.
8.8
On the overall conspectus, the non-selection is arbitrary, opaque, and
founded on undisclosed norms. The decision declaring him “not suitable”
should be quashed and Petitioner should be appointed to the post of
Manager (IT), or in the alternative, a direction be issued to redo the
interview/selection on clearly declared and lawful criteria.
9.
On the other hand, the Respondent makes the following submissions
opposing the present petition:
9.1
The selection process was conducted strictly in accordance with the
mode of selection notified in the vacancy advertisement and the governing
(NSFDC) Recruitment, Promotion And Seniority Rules, 20163 applicable to
Group ‘A’ posts.
9.2
The post of Manager (IT) is a Group ‘A’ post in the E-3 level in the
middle managerial cadre, carrying significant responsibilities and requiring
domain competence, decision-making ability, and communication skills.
The recruiting body is therefore entitled, and indeed obligated, to ensure that
only suitable candidates are appointed to such a position.
9.3
The online application handling, scrutiny, and conduct of the written
examination were entrusted to an independent agency, IBPS, Mumbai,
thereby insulating the written examination stage from any allegation of
internal manipulation.
9.4
In terms of the Corporation’s recruitment framework for Group ‘A’
W.P.(C) 7880/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 11/02/2026 at 11:28:49
posts, 85% weightage is allotted to the written examination and 15% to the
interview. For the post of Manager (IT), the written examination carried 250
marks and the interview carried 44 marks, totalling 294.
9.5
On receipt of the written examination results from IBPS, only those
candidates who secured 33% and above in the written test were called for
interview. Of the three candidates who appeared, only the Petitioner secured
34.34% and was, therefore, the sole candidate called for interview. The fact
that the Petitioner was the only interviewee, however, does not translate into
an enforceable right to appointment. Selection entails an assessment of
suitability; if the candidate fails to meet the minimum benchmark, the
employer may lawfully decide to keep the post unfilled.
9.6
The interview was conducted by a duly constituted Selection
Committee comprising six senior members in line with Government
guidelines,
including
reserved
categories,
minority,
and
women
representation. Two external experts were also included, one being a domain
expert from NIC. The Respondent submits that this Committee structure
itself demonstrates institutional safeguards and expertise, and the marking
was done by the Committee members independently, with the final
interview score being the average.
9.7
The Committee assessed the Petitioner on domain knowledge in IT,
communication skills, general awareness, and his understanding of the
objectives and work of the Corporation, including his reasons for seeking
the position. On that assessment, the Petitioner scored 8 marks out of 44 in
the interview (18.18%). When combined with the written score, his
aggregate was 93.86 out of 294, that is 31.93%, which is below the
“governing rules”
W.P.(C) 7880/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 11/02/2026 at 11:28:49
minimum required benchmark of 33% for a Group ‘A’ managerial post. On
that basis the Selection Committee found him “not suitable” and
recommended that he not be appointed.
9.8
The Petitioner’s challenge essentially invites the Court to reassess
interview performance and substitute its own view for the Selection
Committee which is impermissible in writ jurisdiction. Suitability in
interview is a matter of expert assessment and the Court does not sit as an
appellate body over marks awarded, absent proof of mala fides, bias,
extraneous considerations, or a patent procedural violation.
9.9
The Petitioner’s grievance that the minimum benchmark was “not
mentioned” in the advertisement is misconceived. The mode of selection
clause clearly indicated written examination followed by interview and
selection based on merit in those components. A merit-based scheme
necessarily presupposes suitability standards and minimum benchmarks for
managerial posts. In any event, the same benchmark operated at the stage of
calling candidates to interview, and the Petitioner himself benefited from
that benchmark as the sole candidate called. There is no midstream change
and the Petitioner merely failed to secure the minimum standard in the
interview and in the aggregate.
9.10 The “General Information” clause in the advertisement clearly warned
that incorrect information and/or process violations detected at any stage
would lead to disqualification and even retrospective cancellation if detected
subsequently. The Petitioner declared a visual disability percentage of 40%
in the online application, whereas the disability certificate produced at
scrutiny indicated 20% low vision. Under Government norms, PwD benefit
in low vision is admissible only at 40% impairment and above. This
W.P.(C) 7880/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 11/02/2026 at 11:28:49
amounts to incorrect information on a material aspect, contrary to the
declaration given by the candidate, and is sufficient in itself to disentitle the
Petitioner from discretionary relief.
9.11 The Corporation acted transparently and fairly. The Petitioner’s
representations and RTI applications were responded to with details of his
marks and the reasons for non-selection. There is no arbitrariness, and the
petition is an attempt to convert participation in a selection process into a
right to appointment, which the law does not recognise.
9.12 Reliance is placed upon decisions including Union of India v.
Mahendra Singh4 and State of Rajasthan v. Chetan Jeff5 to submit that
incorrect declarations in recruitment processes have serious consequences
and courts should not grant relief that undermines the integrity of
recruitment
Issues
10.
The petition, on the above pleadings, throws up three questions:
10.1. whether the Corporation unlawfully introduced a fresh, undisclosed
“33% minimum aggregate” criterion at the end of the process;
10.2. whether the Petitioner, being the only candidate called for interview,
acquired any enforceable right to appointment; and
10.3. whether, on the overall record, the decision of non-selection warrants
interference in writ jurisdiction.
Analysis
11.
The settled limits of judicial review in recruitment must be kept in
view at the threshold. A writ court examines legality, procedural fairness,
2022 SCC OnLine SC 909
(2022) 19 SCC 366
W.P.(C) 7880/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 11/02/2026 at 11:28:49
and adherence to the governing framework. It does not sit in appeal over
comparative merit, nor does it substitute its own assessment for that of an
expert selection body, unless the process is shown to be vitiated by mala
fides, patent arbitrariness, or a demonstrable breach of binding norms.
Shankarsan Dash v. Union of India6 reiterates the governing discipline:
selection does not create an indefeasible right to appointment, and the
assessment of suitability lies primarily with the employer.
12.
The Petitioner’s submission that the insistence on a minimum
aggregate of 33% introduced a new eligibility condition midstream is
misconceived. The advertisement prescribed a two-stage selection consisting
of written test followed by interview, with appointment to be made on order
of merit in the combined assessment. It did not promise appointment upon
mere participation in the interview, nor did it stipulate that any candidate
securing positive marks would necessarily be appointed.
13.
The Court also takes note of the Constitution Bench judgment in Tej
Prakash Pathak v Rajasthan High Court,7 which is relevant to the present
controversy. The decision clarifies that while eligibility criteria cannot
ordinarily be altered once the recruitment process commences, the same
inflexibility does not automatically extend to the manner of evaluation or
fixation of a suitability benchmark, provided the change does not introduce
arbitrariness or violate the governing framework. The Selection Committee
merely applied a threshold to determine whether the candidate before it met
the minimum acceptability for appointment, which the employer was
entitled to insist upon. The benchmark thus operated only as a minimum
(1991) 3 SCC 47
2024 INSC 847
W.P.(C) 7880/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 11/02/2026 at 11:28:49
standard of suitability at the final stage of selection and was applied
uniformly. The process was not recast.
14.
Tej Prakash Pathak cautions that if a benchmark is to operate at a
particular stage of recruitment it ought ordinarily to be fixed before that
stage is reached, so that neither candidates nor evaluators are taken by
surprise. However, that principle is attracted only where a new qualifying
parameter or altered criterion is introduced midstream. No such situation
arises here. The governing Rules prescribed a combined assessment with
85% weightage to the written test and 15% to the interview, and that
structure remained unchanged throughout. The marking scheme was known
and applied uniformly. The 33% aggregate functions only as a minimum
threshold of overall suitability within the declared framework; it does not
create a new stage or alter the evaluative criteria. There is no “surprise” of
the kind contemplated in Tej Prakash Pathak.
15.
Similarly, the court also places reliance on the decision in Yogesh
Yadav v. Union of India8 which concerned the fixation of an overall merit
benchmark after the written test and interview had been held. In the said
case, the advertisement contemplated selection by a written test (80 marks)
and an interview (20 marks) and prescribed only minimum qualifying marks
for the written test. It did not stipulate any aggregate cut-off for final
selection. After completion of both stages, the employer fixed an aggregate
benchmark (70% for unreserved candidates and 65% for reserved
candidates), with the result that certain candidates who had met the writtentest minimum were not selected. The challenge, founded on the plea that this
altered the “rules of the game” midstream, was rejected. The Supreme Court
W.P.(C) 7880/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 11/02/2026 at 11:28:49
held that the method of selection remained written test plus interview and
that no fresh qualifying cut-off was introduced at the interview stage. The
aggregate benchmark was treated as a permissible device to restrict
appointment to candidates meeting a higher overall standard of merit.
Hemani Malhotra and K. Manjusree were distinguished.
16.
In Yogesh Yadav, the Court also emphasised that, absent any statutory
compulsion to appoint all candidates who merely meet minimum eligibility,
the employer may prescribe a higher overall benchmark to secure efficiency
and maintain standards in service. Where such benchmark is applied
uniformly and is not shown to be tainted by mala fides, it does not attract the
charge of arbitrariness and does not offend Articles 14 or 16 of the
Constitution.
17.
The present case stands on analogous footing. The method of
selection remained constant: written examination, followed by interview,
with merit drawn from the combined score. The 33% aggregate does not
introduce a new eligibility requirement or a separate interview cut-off. It
functions as a minimum threshold of overall suitability within the declared
composite evaluation.
18.
Nor is this a case of a benchmark being devised after the event to
exclude a particular candidate. The record shows that 33% operated at the
shortlisting stage itself, since only candidates securing 33% and above in the
written test were called for interview. The Petitioner entered consideration
on that basis. The insistence on a 33% aggregate at the final stage is
therefore a continuation of an existing minimum-performance standard, not
the introduction of a new disqualifying condition at the end of the process.
(2013) 14 SCC 623
W.P.(C) 7880/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 11/02/2026 at 11:28:49
19.
The reliance on Hemani Malhotra and K. Manjusree is misplaced.
Those cases involved the introduction of a minimum qualifying cut-off for a
stage where none had been prescribed earlier, thereby shifting the criteria
after participation. Here, there was no such alteration. The selection
framework remained the same, and the 33% aggregate operated only as a
minimum standard of suitability within the declared composite assessment.
20.
The fact that the 33% aggregate was not expressly mentioned in the
advertisement does not, by itself, vitiate the selection. The governing rules
prescribed a combined assessment with 85% weightage to the written test
and 15% to the interview, and that structure was scrupulously adhered to.
The aggregate benchmark neither introduced a new stage nor altered
eligibility; it operated within the declared 85:15 framework as a minimum
standard of overall suitability.
21.
The character of selection to a Group ‘A’ managerial post must be
kept in view. The appointing authority is not bound to fill a vacancy
irrespective of suitability. A duly constituted Selection Committee,
comprising members with relevant expertise and acting within the governing
regulations, is entrusted with assessing comparative merit and suitability. In
that setting, it is permissible to adopt a rational and uniform marking
methodology, including a minimum benchmark for appointment, provided it
does not rewrite eligibility, introduce a fresh stage of selection, or operate in
an arbitrary or discriminatory manner. On these parameters, the benchmark
cannot be described as a change in the “rules of the game”; it is only a
uniform standard applied within the declared selection framework.
22.
Pertinently, Rule 12(B) of the governing Rules expressly provides that
the Selection Committee shall assess the suitability of candidates on the
W.P.(C) 7880/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 11/02/2026 at 11:28:49
basis of their qualifications, professional knowledge, experience and
performance in interview and/or tests, and recommend a select list in order
of merit. The Rule thus vests the Committee with evaluative discretion to
determine comparative merit and suitability, and does not reduce the process
to a mechanical tabulation of marks. The prescription of a minimum
aggregate standard operates within this statutory mandate. It neither alters
eligibility nor modifies the selection structure; it merely reflects the
Committee’s assessment of the level of performance considered adequate for
recommendation in order of merit. The exercise, therefore, falls squarely
within the authority conferred by Rule 12(B).
23.
Assessment of merit and suitability, including interview performance,
lies primarily with the duly constituted Selection Committee. A writ court
does not sit in appeal over marks or re-evaluate suitability unless the process
is shown to be tainted by mala fides, bias, manifest perversity, or breach of
an essential norm. Here, the Petitioner secured 8 out of 44 in the interview.
That score supports the Committee’s conclusion that he did not meet the
level of competence and suitability expected for an E-3, Group ‘A’ post. In
the absence of any cogent plea or proof of bias or extraneous motive, the
interview assessment cannot be reopened merely because the Petitioner
claims he deserved higher marks.
24.
The purpose of selection is to identify the most suitable candidate, not
to appoint merely because someone is eligible. Even where only one
candidate reaches the interview stage, the Selection Committee is entitled to
assess whether that candidate meets the minimum level of suitability for the
post. The fact of being the sole interviewee cannot compel appointment,
since that would remove the distinction between eligibility and suitability
W.P.(C) 7880/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 11/02/2026 at 11:28:49
and make the interview a formality. In any event, the call letter dated 25 th
January, 2018 made it clear that the interview call did not constitute any
commitment to appoint. The Petitioner participated with notice of that
position; no enforceable right to appointment could arise solely because he
was the only candidate called for interview.
25.
The Petitioner’s emphasis on experience also does not advance the
case. Experience is an eligibility condition and a factor that may contribute
to performance. It does not replace performance. Once the selection is
structured as a written test plus interview, experience does not automatically
translate into marks unless the rules expressly provide for such weightage.
No such provision has been pointed out.
26.
In view of the above conclusions, it is not necessary to render a
determinative finding on the issue relating to the Petitioner’s declaration of
PwD status. Suffice it to observe that accuracy of disclosures in recruitment
processes is of material significance. However, since the non-selection
stands justified on independent grounds of suitability, this Court does not
rest its decision on that aspect.
27.
For these reasons, no ground is made out to invoke writ jurisdiction to
compel appointment or to set aside the non-selection decision.
Conclusion
28.
The writ petition is dismissed. Pending applications, if any, also stand
disposed of.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
FEBRUARY 3, 2026/ab
W.P.(C) 7880/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 11/02/2026 at 11:28:49
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review