Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on
Pronounced on
Uploaded on
+
: 16.12.2025
: 09.01.2026
: 10.01.2026
CRL.A. 995/2016
ASHOK
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Aly Mirza, Advocate (Amicus
Curiae, Pro Bono)
versus
THE STATE
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Pradeep Gahalot, APP for State
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
JUDGMENT
1.
By way of the present appeal filed under Section 374 Cr.P.C., the
appellant seeks to assail the judgment of conviction dated 24.08.2016,
whereby he was convicted for the offences punishable under Sections
395/397 IPC, and the order on sentence dated 30.08.2016, whereby he was
sentenced to undergo RI for a period of 14 years along with a fine of
Rs.10,000/-, in default whereof he would undergo SI for 1 year, for the
offence under Section 395 IPC, and further sentenced to undergo RI for a
period of 10 years along with a fine of Rs.10,000/-, in default whereof he
would undergo SI for 1 year, for the offence under Section 397 IPC. Both
sentences were directed to run concurrently and the benefit under Section
428 Cr.P.C. was granted to the appellant.
CRL.A. 995/2016
Digitally
Signed
Page
1 of
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:59:35
2.
The co-convicts, namely Sikandar, Irshad Ali, and Ekant Bansal had
preferred their individual criminal appeals bearing CRL.A. Nos. 951/2016,
1157/2016, and 126/2017 respectively. The first two appeals came to be
disposed of by the Coordinate Bench of this Court vide common judgment
dated 24.03.2025 by considering the plea of sentence being commuted to the
period already undergone by them. The other convict, namely Ekant Bansal,
also did not press his appeal on merits and pleaded that his sentence be
modified to the period already undergone by him. This Court, vide order
dated
23.07.2025, while upholding
the
co-convict/Ekant
Bansal’s
conviction, partly allowed the said appeal in view of the sentence of 10
years and 8 months undergone by him.
3.
Insofar as the present appellant is concerned, he had preferred an
application seeking suspension of sentence on the ground that he had to
urgently repair his house as well as perform the marriage of his daughter.
The Coordinate Bench of this Court, vide order dated 17.03.2017, on a
Status Report filed verifying the aforesaid facts, suspended his sentence for
a period of 4 weeks; however, the appellant did not surrender thereafter and
all efforts to serve him remained futile. Even the NBWs issued against him
remained unserved. In light of the decision in Bani Singh & Ors. Vs. State of
U.P.1, this Court appointed Mr. Aly Mirza, Advocate, as Amicus Curiae to
represent the appellant.
4.
The facts as emerging from the record are that the appellant along
with his associates committed dacoity by overpowering the driver as well as
conductor of a truck, and stole the vehicle as well as its cargo, i.e., 230 bags
of betel nuts (supari). It was further alleged that the accused also gave
(1996) 4 SCC 720
CRL.A. 995/2016
Digitally
Signed
Page
2 of
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:59:35
beatings to the victims, tied them up, and forced them to consume some
tablets due to which they lost consciousness.
5.
On completion of investigation, the charge-sheet was filed against the
appellant herein as well as the co-accused persons. The appellant, along with
other co-accused, was charged for the offences punishable under Section
395 IPC read with Section 34 IPC, and Section 328 IPC read with Section
34 IPC. The appellant was additionally charged for the offence under
Section 397 IPC. The appellant as well as the other co-accused pleaded not
guilty and claimed trial.
6.
Manzoor Alam, the driver of the stolen truck, was examined as PW-1.
He deposed that he was employed as a driver with “Hyderabad Road
Carriers”, the office of which was at Sanjay Gandhi Transport Nagar, Delhi.
He was driving the truck bearing no. RJ14 GA 6283. One Ram Avtar was
the conductor. They were bringing the cargo of betel nuts (supari) from
Bangalore to Delhi. Another truck, bearing no. HR47 B 0420, driven by one
Rohtash and also loaded with betel nuts, was coming along with their truck
from Bangalore to Delhi. At about 1.30 am, when they were on NH-1 and
had crossed the Shahjahanpur border, he received a call on his mobile
number from Rohtash (the driver of other truck), who told that his truck had
developed a snag. The witness stopped his truck and went towards the truck
of Rohtash, leaving the key in the ignition. Ram Avtar, the conductor,
remained in the witness’ truck. The witness noticed one black-coloured car
(make Mahindra Scorpio) behind his truck. The truck of Rohtash was parked
behind the said Scorpio car. The witness asked Rohtash to take diesel from
his truck, but Rohtash stated that he would send his conductor to a nearby
petrol pump to bring diesel. His conductor left with a bucket to bring diesel.
CRL.A. 995/2016
Digitally
Signed
Page
3 of
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:59:35
At that time, the witness noticed that his truck had been started by someone.
As the conductor Ram Avtar did not know how to drive, the witness,
suspecting foul play, asked Rohtash to call the police as well as the owner.
The witness started running towards his truck, but two persons came out,
one of whom put a pistol on the witness’ head, and threatened him not to
make any noise. He was taken towards his truck, and he found 2/3 persons
already sitting inside. The conductor Ram Avtar, who had already been
overpowered, had been made to lie down in the truck and was covered with
a sheet. The witness was made to sit in the truck, beaten up, and made to
consume some intoxicating material after which he fell unconscious. When
he regained consciousness, he found himself lying in the Narela-Bawana
area in the fields near J. J. Colony. The witness’ driving licence and
Rs.7,000/-, which he was carrying, were also missing. He left the spot and
reached the office, where he met with the owner and told the entire story.
The witness identified the present appellant as the person who had put a
pistol on his head. He also identified the other convicts.
In cross-examination, he denied knowing any official by the name
Kanhiya or that he informed Kanhiya upon reaching Delhi. He stated that he
met the owner in the morning of 12.12.2009. He denied the suggestion that
he contacted the owner on 19.12.2010. A suggestion was given that the
witness, along with the owner, Tarun Jain, had misappropriated the goods
and concocted a false story, and the same was denied. He stated that the
Scorpio car was of black colour, but that he couldn’t notice the number. A
suggestion was given that the appellant was already known to the
complainant prior to the incident as the appellant had been working as a
mistri in Sanjay Gandhi Transport Nagar, and the same was denied. A
CRL.A. 995/2016
Digitally
Signed
Page
4 of
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:59:35
suggestion to the effect that photographs and videos of the accused were
shown to the witness at the police station was given, which was also denied.
He stated that he came to know that the betel nuts had been recovered from a
place near Banaras and that he was with the police at that time.
7.
Ram Avtar, the conductor of the truck, was examined as PW-2. His
testimony is cumulative to the testimony of Manzoor Alam, the driver of the
truck. He deposed that Manzoor Alam had stopped the truck when he
received a call from Rohtash, who stated that he had no diesel in the truck.
When Manzoor Alam went towards the truck of Rohtash, 2/3 persons
boarded the truck that the witness was sitting in; one of them put a pistol on
his head and forced him to eat something, after consuming which he fell
unconscious. When he regained consciousness, he found himself in the
Bawana Area. He made a call to the police, who came and took him to a
hospital, and thereafter to the owner. He disclosed the facts to the owner.
The witness identified Irshad Ali and Sikander as the accused who had
boarded the truck. He stated that it was the accused Sikander who had forced
him to take the pills. When he regained consciousness, he found Manzoor
Alam at a distance. He also identified the present appellant.
During cross-examination by the learned APP for the State, he
admitted that he had seen Manzoor Alam be brought inside the truck, but his
face was covered with a blanket thereafter. His hands and legs were tied
with the help of tape and his mobile phone was also robbed. The accused
had further also taken away Manzoor Alam’s mobile phone.
In cross-examination by the appellant, he stated that he had not seen
any of the accused prior to the incident. They had gone to P.S. South Rohini,
where they had seen the accused persons. He again said that though they had
CRL.A. 995/2016
Digitally
Signed
Page
5 of
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:59:35
gone to the police station, the accused persons were not shown to them.
8.
Tarun Jain, the owner of the trucks, was examined as PW-8. He
deposed about running the concerned transport company. He further
deposed that on 05.12.2009, one transport company had booked two trucks,
on which they had sent trucks bearing nos. RJ14 GA 6283 and HR47 B
0420. The trucks were loaded with betel nuts for delivery in Delhi. He stated
that one Kale was the driver of the truck bearing no. HR 47 B 0420. Kale
was mixed up with some criminals, as a consequence of which the truck
bearing no. RJ14 GA 6283 was looted. The full name of the driver was
Rohtash.
9.
One Kultaran Singh was examined as PW-9. He stated that he was
also running a transport company, in the name and style of “Maha Ganesh
Transport Carrier” in Sanjay Gandhi Transport Nagar. One Parveen Jain
and one Arvind Mishra were his partners. On 05.12.2009, M/s Rashid
Traders, Heroor, Siddapur, Mangalore, had booked 320 gunny bags of betel
nuts. These bags were looted. These bags were in total weighing about 16
tons. The bags were loaded in truck bearing No. RJ14 GA 6283. Bilty was
issued on the said date and a photocopy of the same was handed over to the
I.O. Relevant documents including the copy of the Bilty were seized by the
I.O. vide seizure memo (Ex. PW-9/A) and the copy of the Bilty was
exhibited as Ex. PW-9/B.
10.
One Nishant Arora was examined in the context of the Scorpio car.
He appeared as PW-10 and stated that his father is the registered owner of
the concerned Scorpio car bearing No. DL3C AJ 4215. He stated that on
05.12.2009, he had parked the car in the gali outside his house; however, the
next morning he found his car to be missing. The ownership documents
CRL.A. 995/2016
Digitally
Signed
Page
6 of
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:59:35
were lying in the car itself. FIR No. 61/2009 under Section 379 IPC was
lodged at P.S. Ranjit Nagar in this regard. A copy of the FIR was exhibited
as Ex. PW-5/A.
11.
Parveen Jain was examined as PW-11. He deposed that on
03.01.2010, he had joined the investigation in the present case and gone to
District Azamgarh, U.P., with the I.O. concerned. The I.O. had seized 220
gunny bags of red supari lying in one room of SGRY Khadyan Vitran
Kendra, Jiyapur, P.S. Mehnazpur. He identified the said bags as belonging
to him and exhibited the seizure memo as Ex. PW-11/A. The supari was
taken on superdari through his partner, Kahniya Lal. He stated that the
premises from where the bags of betel nuts were recovered, was in the
possession of one Brijesh Singh @ Guddu Pradhan of village Jiyapur.
In cross-examination, he denied the suggestion of identifying the case
property at the instance of police.
12.
SI Mohd. Saleem Javed, examined as PW-12, deposed that on
03.01.2010, on the basis of secret information received, 220 bags of betel
nuts were recovered from the room of SGRY Khadyan Vitran Kendra,
Sahayak Sahkari Limited, Mehlaulpur, Jiyapur, Mehnazpur, U.P.
13.
One Subhash Chander Mishra was examined as PW-13, and he
deposed that he was employed as a Sachiv in the office of Sahakari Samiti
Ltd., Behlaulpur, District Azamgarh, U.P. The office of the Samiti had a
hall, which was used to store fertilisers for disbursement among the villagers
later. At the relevant time, one Brijesh Singh was the Pradhan of village
Jiyapur. On 18/20/22.01.2010, two police officials reached the witness’
house and told him about the recovery of 220 bags of supari from the
godown of SGRY.
CRL.A. 995/2016
Digitally
Signed
Page
7 of
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:59:35
14.
Insofar as the arrest of the accused is concerned, the prosecution
examined HC Surender/PW-15, who deposed that on receipt of secret
information by HC Rohtash on 24.12.2019 that a truck loaded with rice from
Alipur would come from Mangol Puri industrial area and pass through
Rohini, a raiding party was formed and the truck was stopped. The appellant
was one of occupants in the truck. He was found carrying a pistol of 7.65
mm. The other accused, namely Irshad, Ekant Bansal, Rafiq, and Sikander,
were also apprehended and 193 bags of rice were seized.
15.
HC Rohtash, examined as PW-16, deposed on similar lines as PW-15.
16.
PW-17, a seller of betel nuts, deposed as to getting the concerned two
trucks loaded with bags of betel nuts in Karnataka and the same being sent
to Delhi. PW-18 booked the concerned trucks for delivery of betel nuts from
Karnataka to Delhi. PW-19, a Commission Agent for transports in
Bangalore, deposed as to receiving a call inquiring about the availability of
trucks and then deploying the concerned two trucks, driven by Manzoor
Alam and Rohtas @ Kale, for loading of goods.
17.
In his statement recorded under Section 313 Cr.P.C., the appellant
denied the prosecution case and examined himself as DW-2. As DW-2, he
deposed that in the intervening night of 22/23.12.2009, while he was
sleeping, 5/6 persons came in civil dress and forcibly took him to P.S.
Rohini, where other accused were already present. He also examined his
wife, Kiran, as DW-3 and she deposed on the same lines.
18.
Mr. Aly Mirza, learned Amicus Curiae for the appellant has
contended that the prosecution failed to prove any PCR call. The Trial Court
also failed to appreciate that Tarun Jain (PW-8) and Parveen Jain (PW-11)
were the real culprits who had framed the appellant. The identification of the
CRL.A. 995/2016
Digitally
Signed
Page
8 of
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:59:35
appellant is also of no use as he was shown at the police station.
19.
Learned APP for the State has repelled the contentions put forth on
behalf of the appellant, stating that the driver of the truck concerned, i.e., the
complainant Manzoor Alam (PW-1) has fully supported the prosecution
case. The complainant duly identified the appellant in Court and attributed
to him the specific role of pointing a pistol at his temple during the truckjacking in question. Learned APP further submits that the conductor of the
said truck, i.e., Ram Avtar/PW-2, has lent corroboration to the complainant’s
testimony on all material particulars. He further submits that all the material
background facts also stand established in view of the testimonies of the
other prosecution witnesses.
20.
I have heard the learned counsels for the parties and carefully
examined the record.
21.
The appellant, in his statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C. and in his
examination as DW-2, has professed his innocence and claimed false
implication. He has stated that he was lifted from his house by the police and
subsequently implicated in the present case; however, no credible material
has been placed on record to illustrate why the complainant, who the
appellant has admitted to not knowing in his statement under Section 313
Cr.P.C., would falsely implicate the appellant. Similarly, no credible reason
has been put forth as to why the conductor of the truck (PW-2), or the police
officials for that matter, would falsely implicate him.
22.
With respect to the contention that the appellant’s TIP stands vitiated
since the concerned witnesses visited the police station and saw him there,
the Trial Court has noted that the witnesses went to the police station only
during police custody remand after the TIP had already been conducted. A
CRL.A. 995/2016
Digitally
Signed
Page
9 of
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:59:35
perusal of the appellant’s statement dated 09.04.2013 reveals that he has not
disputed his TIP, which was conducted on 12.01.2010.
23.
Pertinently, the Trial Court has noted the fact that while the appellant
has claimed that he was lifted from his house on 22.12.2009, the incident in
question statedly occurred in the intervening night of 11/12.12.2009. The
Trial Court has held this defence put forth by the appellant of being lifted
from his house to have no bearing on the case in light of the fact that no
defence has been produced by the appellant as to where he was on the
intervening night of 11/12.12.2009.
24.
PW-1 and PW-2 are the star witnesses of the prosecution. Both
supported the prosecution version, correctly identified the appellant in
Court, and withstood the test of lengthy cross-examination. They have
unflinchingly corroborated each other on all material particulars, and their
testimonies are cumulative to each other. Together, the two have painted a
clear, cogent, and trustworthy picture of the incident in question and no
material inconsistencies were elicited in their testimonies to discredit the
prosecution version. This Court is of the view that both the said witnesses
are credible and reliable.
25.
It is also pertinent to note that the complainant has attributed to the
appellant the specific role of pointing a pistol at his head when he was
approaching his truck after alighting from the truck driven by Rohtash. It is
settled law that simple exhibition, brandishing, or even holding a weapon
openly to generate fear or apprehension in the victim’s mind is sufficient to
secure a conviction under Section 397 IPC. Reference in this regard may be
made to the decision of the 3-Judge Bench of the Supreme Court in Ram
CRL.A. 995/2016
Digitally
Page
10 Signed
of 11
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:59:35
Ratan v. State of M.P.2, wherein it was held as under:“17. From the position of law as enunciated by this Court and noted
above, firstly, it is clear that the use of the weapon to constitute the offence
under Section 397 IPC does not require that the “offender” should
actually fire from the firearm or actually stab if it is a knife or a dagger
but the mere exhibition of the same, brandishing or holding it openly to
threaten and create fear or apprehension in the mind of the victim is
sufficient. The other aspect is that if the charge of committing the offence
is alleged against all the accused and only one among the “offenders” had
used the firearm or deadly weapon, only such of the “offender” who has
used the firearm or deadly weapon alone would be liable to be charged
under Section 397 IPC.”
It is also worth mentioning that HC Rohtash, examined as PW-15, has
deposed that a 7.65 mm pistol was recovered at the instance of the appellant
at the time of his apprehension.
26.
In light of the above discussion, this Court has no hesitation in
upholding the appellant’s conviction under Sections 395/397 IPC. The wellreasoned impugned judgment and order on sentence passed by the Trial
Court do not warrant interference. The same are accordingly upheld and the
present appeal is dismissed.
27.
Before parting, this Court places on record its appreciation for Mr.
Aly Mirza, Advocate, the learned Amicus Curiae appointed to represent the
appellant, for the valuable assistance rendered by him.
28.
A copy of this judgment be communicated to the Trial Court as well
as the concerned Jail Superintendent.
MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
(JUDGE)
JANUARY 09, 2025/nb
2021 SCC OnLine SC 1279
CRL.A. 995/2016
Digitally
Page
11 Signed
of 11
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:59:35
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review