Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
%
&
"
#
"$
#
"
' &
!"
#
$
&
%
'
(
) '
'
Digitally signed
by RENUKA
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
'
*
'
+
"
'
'
!
'
'
,
(
-2-
'
!
'
(
'
!
&
'
'
&!&
'
-
,
'
!"
'
+
!
&!
'
&&
!
'
.
-3-
&
'
"!
.
&"
"
&
+
&
!
&
!"
#
$
(
*
!" &
.
&
**
/
!
& / ,.
"
/
*
.
&
%
*
,
*
*
(
, !& !
**
'
*
'*
* '
*
'
!
!
%
*
*
*
-4-
$
''
% *
'
'
*
'
'
*
'
-
'
'
234 56737389 34 :3;6< => <6:69<?97
4B37 ?9< CB<AD697 <6=78@
39 726 8@3A39?;
39 726 6E6FB7389 56737389
*8@ 6?4> B9<6@47?9<39A 726 5?@7364 42?;; =6
@6:6@@6< 78 ?4 CB<AD697 <6=78@ ?9< <6F@66 28;<6@
"
26 5@?>6@ 48BA27 39 7234 56737389 =>
CB<AD697 <6=78@
34 ?4 B9<6@
! "
#
&'()*(&)&+
-
.
$
./
%
-
$
%
!
,
% $ 0
!!
-5-
1(2 (&)3&)&& 0 "
!4
" (
! /
"
!
"
"
!
$
$
!
$
"
"
$
-
"
!
$
"
!4
" (
"
!
" "
"
!
$
"
!
" (6
@36: :?F74 8: 726 F?46 ?@6 72?7
26 <6F@66 28;<6@4 :3;6< ? 4B37 ?4 5;?3973::4 39
,
!&
89 726 :3;6 8: 726
?4?G?9?
?A6H?<3
<<37389?;
?A?3947
3G3;
B<A6
CB<AD697
<6=78@4 <6:69<?974 726@639 466I39A @6;36: 8: @6F8G6@> 8:
5844644389
26 4B37 F?D6 78 =6 <6F@66< G3<6 CB<AD697
<?76<
! ! ?9< 726 CB<AD697 <6=78@4 H6@6 <3@6F76<
!+
78 2?9<8G6@ &
H23F2
AB97?4 69F@8?F26< ?@6? 3 6
5?@7
?9<
5?@F6;
8:
J
K ?@6?
;?9<4
=6?@39A
-6-
>
+
&L L L ! "
D6?4B@39A && ?F@64 !+ AB97?4
>
+
&L
L
D6?4B@39A
"
?F@64
>
+
&L L L &
D6?4B@39A
"
?F@64
>
+
&L
L
"
D6?4B@39A
CB<AD697 ?9< <6F@66
56737389 39
!
?F@64
B@4B?97 78 726
<6F@66 28;<6@4 :3;6< 6E6FB7389
!
78 6E6FB76 726 CB<AD697 ?9<
<6F@66 5?446< => 726 ;6?@96<
3G3; B<A6
56737389 G3<6 8@<6@ <?76< "! &! !
9 726 6E6FB7389
? 58;3F6 5@876F7389
H?4 8@<6@6< :8@ @6F8G6@> 8: 5844644389 8: 726 5@856@7>
:@8D 726 CB<AD697 <6=78@4 ?9< 5844644389 H?@@?97 H?4
344B6<
, !&
B@4B?97 726@678
!
726 =?3;3:: G3<6 8@<6@ <?76<
:3;6< ? @658@7 8: F8D5;3?9F6 47?739A 72?7
5844644389 8: &
AB97?4 8: ;?9< 2?< =669 4BFF644:B;;>
@6F8G6@6< :@8D 726 CB<AD697 <6=78@4
@658@7
37 34 47?76< 72?7 726@6 ?@6 47?9<39A F@854 ?9<
=8@6H6;; ?;89A H372 6MB35D697
4&
?7
9 726 =?3;3::-4
!!!
26 F@854 ?@6 G?;B6< ?7
?9< =8@6H6;; ?;89A H372 6MB35D697 ?@6 G?;B6<
4 & !! !!!
FF8@<39A;> 726 =?3;3:: 4B=D3776< ? @658@7
47?739A 72?7 726 47?9<39A F@854 ?4 H6;; ?4 =8@6H6;; ?9<
-7-
6MB35D697 G?;B6 34 ?7
4&&
!!!
?9< 72?7 726 <6F@66
28;<6@4 ?@6 @6?<> 78 D?I6 726 5?>D697 8: 726 4?D6
7 34 726 F897697389 8: 726 ;6?@96< F8B946; :8@
CB<AD697 <6=78@
72?7 726 =?3;3:: 2?4 :?;46;> :3;6< ?
@658@7 ?4 98 5844644389 H?4 2?9<6< 8G6@ 8@ <6;3G6@6< ?9<
98 9873F6 8: D6?4B@6D697 8: ?;;6A6< 69F@8?F26< 58@7389
H?4 A3G69 78 CB<AD697 <6=78@
H372 @6A?@< 78 726
G?;B?7389 8: 47?9<39A F@854 8@ 6MB35D697 6E34739A 39 726
58@7389 ?;;6A6< 78 =6 69F@8?F26<
26@6:8@6 ?AA@36G6< =>
726 @658@7 4B=D3776< => 726 =?3;3:: <?76<
567373896@ CB<AD697 <6=78@
F2?;;69A39A
46G6@?;
4?D6
F89769<39A 72?7 726
E6FB739A
, !&
34 =6:8@6
!
8B@7
A@8B9<4
8B@7 H?4 B9CB473:36< 39
?FF65739A 726 @658@7 8: 726 =?3;3:: ?9< 72?7 963726@ 39 726
8@3A39?; 4B37 98@ 39 726 6E6FB7389 5@8F66<39A4 726
8DD3443896@
H?4
?5583976<
?4F6@7?39
8B@7
?F7B?;
69F@8?F2D697 8: 726 ;?9< ?9< 72?7 726@6 34 98 @658@7 8: 726
44347?97
3@6F78@ 8: ?9<
6F8@<4 $
% 4B=D3776< =6:8@6
8B@7 H372 @6A?@< 78 D6?4B@6D697 8: 726 ;?9< ?;89A
-8-
H372 726 @658@7
26@6:8@6 37 34 F8976976< 72?7 H269 726@6
34 98 D6?4B@6D697 37 H8B;< 2?G6 =669 3D58443=;6 :8@ 726
<6F@66 28;<6@4 8@ 726 =?3;3:: 78 ?4F6@7?39 H2?7 34 726 ?F7B?;
69F@8?F2D697
7 34 ?;48 F8976976< 72?7 726 G?;B?7389 48
5B7 :8@72 => 726 =?3;3:: H372 @6A?@< 78 726 47?9<39A F@854
?9<
=8@6H6;;
8:
4&&
FF8@<39A;> CB<AD697 <6=78@
!!!
CB473:36<
466I4 78 467 ?43<6 726
8@<6@ ?9< ?;;8H 7234 56737389
@64589<697
"
84 &
;6?@96<
F8B946;
?9< , <6F@66 28;<6@
?556?@39A
:8@
84 & ?9< ,
G626D697;> F89769<4 72?7 726 5;6? 8: 989 3<6973:3F?7389 8:
726 69F@8?F26< 5@856@7> H?4 987 7?I69 B5 39 726 8@3A39?;
4B37 ?9< <645376 CB<AD697 <6=78@
@3?;
F897647
?556?@39A =6:8@6
8B@7 26 <3< 987 F28846 78 :3;6 ? 47?76D697 8@
F?46
D6@374
:76@
<6F@66
5;?3973::4 <6F@66 28;<6@4 :3;6< 6E6FB7389 56737389
726 6E6FB7389 5@8F66<39A4
G69 39
726 CB<AD697 <6=78@4 2?G6
963726@ ?556?@6< 98@ :3;6< ?9> 8=C6F73894 78 726 6E6FB7389
56737389 8@ 78 726 ?55;3F?7389
?9<
:3;6< => 726
-9-
<6F@66 28;<6@4 :8@ 344B?9F6 8: H?@@?97 8: <6;3G6@> 8:
5844644389 8: 4B37 5@856@7> H372 726 ?44347?9F6 8: 726
?;BI?
B@G6>8@ ?9< H372 726 ?3< 8: 58;3F6 F8947?=;64 ?9<
H8D?9
58;3F6
F8947?=;6
8:
'?9?AB;3
8;3F6
7?7389
26@6:8@6 H269 726 CB<AD697 <6=78@4 2?G6 987 F8976476<
726 4B37 <3;3A697;>
4B37 2?G39A =669 <6F@66<
6E6FB7389
56737389 F?D6 78 =6 :3;6< H23F2 34 ?;48 987 8=C6F76< 78 8@
46@38B4;> F8976476< => CB<AD697 <6=78@
8: 2?G39A :3;6<
?9<
?9< 39 45376
466I39A <6;3G6@> 8:
5844644389 H372 726 ?44347?9F6 8:
?;BI?
726 ?3< 8: 726 58;3F6 F8947?=;64
8=C6F73894 78 726 4?3<
?55;3F?73894 H?4
B@G6>8@ ?9< H372
?;48 987 :3;6< => 726 CB<AD697 <6=78@4
726@6 34 987239A 89 @6F8@< :8@ 726 CB<AD697 <6=78@4
8=C6F739A 78 ?9>7239A @3A27 :@8D :3;39A 726 4B37 73;; 726 @658@7
8: 726 =?3;3:: H23F2 2?4 A896 B9F8976476<
,
6 :B@726@ F89769<4 72?7 726 CB<AD697 <6=78@4
2?G6 987 6G69 =8726@6< 78 :3;6 8=C6F73894 78 726 =?3;3::-4
@658@7 ?9< CB<AD697 <6=78@
?55@8?F26< 7234
8B@7
H23F2 34 5@3D?@3;> 5@6D?7B@6 ?9< =6;?76< 3: 37 34 7?I69 :@8D
- 10 -
726 <?76 8: :3;39A 8: 726 4B37
26@6:8@6 26 F89769<4 72?7
726@6 34 98 3;;6A?;37> 8@ ?@=37@?@39644 8@ 56@G6@437> 39 726
8@<6@ 5?446< => 726
726 =?3;3::
E6FB739A
8B@7 ?9< 39 726 @658@7 8:
8H H2?7 34 MB6473896< => CB<AD697 <6=78@
34 H372 @6A?@< 78 726 =?3;3:: @658@7 <?76<
26@6:8@6
26 F89769<4 72?7 726 8@<6@ 8: 726
8B@7 89 ?55;3F?7389
?9<
, !&
!
E6FB739A
47?9<4 397?F7 H3728B7
=639A <347B@=6< ?9< ?55?@697;> 726@6 34 98 F2?;;69A6 78 726
4?D6 ?4 H6;;
9<6@ 72646 F3@FBD47?9F64
26 466I4
<34D344?; 8: 7234 56737389
2?G6 26?@< 726 ;6?@96< F8B946; :8@ CB<AD697
<6=78@
?9< <6F@66 28;<6@
+
84 & ?9< ,
26@6 34 98 <345B76 78 726 :?F7 72?7 726 4B37
F?D6 78 =6 <6F@66< => H?> 8: ? CB<AD697 ?9< <6F@66
<?76<
7@3?;
!+
! !
9 726 4?3< CB<AD697 ?9< <6F@66 726
8B@7 2?4 <3@6F76< 726 <6:69<?974 78 2?9< 8G6@ &
AB97?4 69F@8?F26< ?@6? 3 6
J
K H23F2 34 ? 5?@7 ?9<
5?@F6; 8: 726 4B37 4F26<B;6 5@856@7>
26 69F@8?F26<
58@7389 2?4 =669 456F3:3F?;;> D6973896< 39 726 CB<AD697
- 11 -
3746;:
B@4B?97 726@678 ?9 6E6FB7389 56737389 F?D6 78 =6
:3;6< => 726 <6F@66 28;<6@4 726 4BFF644:B; 5;?3973::4 H23F2
F?D6 78 =6 :3;6< 89 !
&!
!
!"
!
CB<AD697 <6=78@
645376 :3;39A
?I?;?72 89
2?4 987 :3;6< ?9>
8=C6F73894 78 726 6E6FB7389 56737389 8@ 7?I69 ?9> 5;6? H372
@6A?@< 78 726@6 =639A 98 3<6973:3F?7389 8: 726 69F@8?F26<
58@7389 8: 726 5@856@7> H23F2 34 48BA27 78 =6 6E6FB76<
"! &!
!
<6F@66 28;<6@4 :3;6< 7H8 ?55;3F?73894 :8@
344B?9F6 8: H?@@?97 8: <6;3G6@> 8: 5844644389 8: 4B37
4F26<B;6 5@856@7> H372 726 ?44347?9F6 8:
?;BI?
B@G6>8@
?9< :8@ 5@8G3<39A 726 58;3F6 ?3< 5@876F7389 ?;89A H372
H8D?9 F8947?=;6 8: '?9?AB;3 58;3F6 47?7389
G69 78 7234
?55;3F?7389 728BA2 726 CB<AD697 <6=78@4 H6@6 5@64697
=6:8@6 726
<645376
E6FB739A
4B::3F3697
8B@7 72@8BA2 7263@ F8B946; ?9<
8558@7B937364
2?G39A
=669
A@?976<
8=C6F73894 H6@6 987 :3;6< ?9< ?FF8@<39A;> 8=C6F73894 78
?9<
H6@6 7?I69 ?4 987 :3;6<
4?3< ?55;3F?73894 F?D6 78 =6 ?;;8H6<
26@6?:76@ 726
B=46MB697 726@678
726 5844644389 H?@@?97 H?4 @6 344B6< 78 =6 F?@@36< 8B7 89
- 12 -
8@ =6:8@6 "& &
!
?9< 78 4B=D37 ? @658@7
726 =?3;3:: 2?4 4B=D3776< ? @658@7
26@6?:76@
645376 726 4B=D344389
8: @658@7 => 726 =?3;3:: ?9< 726 D?776@ =639A 58476< =6:8@6
E6FB739A
8B@7 726 8=C6F73894 ?@6 987 :3;6< => 726
CB<AD697 <6=78@4 78 726 4?3< @658@7 8: 726 =?3;3:: 6G69 73;;
<?76
B<AD697 <6=78@
2?4 ?55@8?F26< 7234
8B@7
H3728B7 6G69 :3;39A 8=C6F73894 78 726 4?3< @658@7 8: 726
=?3;3:: ?9< => H?> 8: ?9 3976@3D 8@<6@ A@?976< => 7234
89 !" &
!
8B@7
34 69C8>39A 726 3976@3D 8@<6@ ?9< 2?4 987
=8726@6< 78 ?556?@ =6:8@6 726
E6FB739A
8B@7 78 :3;6 ?9>
8=C6F73894 78 726 =?3;3:: @658@7 8@ 6G69 78 726 ?55;3F?73894 8@
@?346 234 ;377;6 :39A6@ H372 @6A?@< 78 726 3<6973:3F?7389 8: 726
5@856@7> H23F2 2?4 98H =669 7?I69 B5 :8@ 726 :3@47 73D6 39
7234 H@37 56737389
&!
3G3;
26 5@8F6<B@6 F8976D5;?76< B9<6@ 726
8<6 8:
@8F6<B@6 34 5B@4B?97 78 726 CB<AD697 ?9< <6F@66
34 726 ;3=6@7> ?9< <34F@67389 8: 726 4BFF644:B; 5?@7> 39 726
5@64697 F?46 726 5;?3973::4 78 :3;6 726 6E6FB7389 56737389 78
6E6FB76 726 CB<AD697 ?9< <6F@66 ?9< 78 69C8> 726 :@B374 8:
- 13 -
726 CB<AD697 ?9< <6F@66
?55?@697;>
=?FI 89
9 726 6E6FB7389 56737389
728BA2 726 CB<AD697 <6=78@4 ?556?@6< H?>
&!
!
726> 2?G6 987 =8726@6< 78 :3;6 7263@
8=C6F73894 78 726 6E6FB7389 56737389 ?9< 78 726 ?55;3F?73894
:3;6< => 726 <6F@66 28;<6@4 78 7?I6 <6;3G6@> 8: 5844644389 8:
726 4B37 5@856@7> 39F;B<39A ?44347?9F6 8: 726 4B@G6>8@ ?9<
726 58;3F6 ?3< ?9< ?;48 78 726 =?3;3:: @658@7
F3@FBD47?9F64
6F7389
37 34 96F644?@> :8@ 7234
, 8: 726
8<6 8:
3G3;
9<6@ 726
8B@7 78 6E7@?F7
@8F6<B@6 H23F2 @6?<4 ?4
B9<6@
*
#
$
0 "
"
"
$
$
! "
1 "
!
1 "
"
$
"
(
&
?
9:::;
8" *)< ! *='>(
#
-
!
"
- 14 -
#
!
!
"
(
9 1
(@
"
!
!! 0
!
$
(
(@
"
"
1 "
!
!
!
"
0 "
"
#
!
$
"
"
"
&&
!
! "
!
"
$
-
#
1 "
"
$
$ !
7 34 :8@ 726
E6FB739A
"
(;6
8B@7 78 F8943<6@ ?9>
8=C6F73894 ?9< ?;; MB6473894 ?@3439A =67H669 726 5?@7364 39
726 6E6FB7389 5@8F66<39A4 ?@3439A 8B7 8: 726 4B37 H23F2 34
98H 5B7 :8@H?@< 78 6E6FB7389 @6;?739A 78 726 6E6FB7389 ?9<
<34F2?@A6 8@ 4?734:?F7389 8: 726 <6F@66
26@6:8@6 H269 726
567373896@ CB<AD697 <6=78@
?556?@ =6:8@6 726
8B@7 78 :3;6 8=C6F73894 78 726
E6FB739A
2?4 987 =8726@6< 78
- 15 -
D?39 56737389 8@ 78 726 ?55;3F?73894 :3;6< 26 H3;; 987 2?G6
?9> @3A27 78 ?55@8?F2 7234
8B@7 B9<6@
@73F;6
, 8: 726
894737B7389 8: 9<3? 466I39A 78 467 ?43<6 726 8@<6@ 5?446<
=> 726
8B@7
9 :?F7 CB<AD697 <6=78@
MB64738939A ?9> 8@<6@ 8: 726
34 987 6G69
8B@7 39 7234 56737389
2?7 34
MB6473896< 34 ? @658@7 4B=D3776< => 726 =?3;3:: <?76<
, !&
!
=6:8@6 726
E6FB739A
8B@7
<8 987 :39< ?9>
3;;6A?;37> 8@ 56@G6@437> 8@ 5@8F6<B@?; 6@@8@ F8DD3776< => 726
E6FB739A
8B@7 F?;;39A :8@ 3976@:6@69F6 39 7234 56737389
CB<AD697 <6=78@
:
34 3976@6476< 39 @?3439A ?9> 8=C6F7389
H372 @6A?@< 78 ?9> 3<6973:3F?7389 8: 726 69F@8?F26< 58@7389
26 34 ?7 ;3=6@7> 78 <8 48 =6:8@6 726
E6FB739A
E6FB739A
8B@7 ?9< 726
8B@7 42?;; F8943<6@ 3: ?9> 8=C6F7389 34 @?346< 8@
:3;6< 78 726 @658@7 8: 726 =?3;3::
63726@ 726 F;8FI =6 467
=?FIH?@<4 98@ 726 F?@7 =6 5B7 39 :@897 8: 726 28@46
26@6:8@6
<8 987 :39< ?9> A88< A@8B9< 8@ F8A697 @6?489
78 3976@:6@6 39 726 H@37 CB@34<3F7389 B9<6@
@73F;6
, 8: 726
894737B7389 8: 9<3? H23F2 34 ;3D376< 78 726 56@G6@437> 8@
- 16 -
3;;6A?;37> F8DD3776< => 726
E6FB739A
8B@7 39 726 5@64697 F?46 726 E6FB739A
&
8B@7 8@ 726 7@3?;
8B@7
6?@96< F8B946; :8@ CB<AD697 <6=78@
2?4
@6;36< B589 726 :8;;8H39A CB<AD6974.
!
" #
$ %& '(()
-
.
!
* )+,
/ 0#
$'('
%3
4+
-
/
7 0
$ %& 894) :2-: ;
&
'
+
!
!
26 ?=8G6 4?3< CB<AD6974 ?@6 987 ?55;3F?=;6 78 726
5@64697 :?F74 ?9< F3@FBD47?9F64 8: 726 F?46
9 726 F?46 8:
37 34 F;6?@;> 47?76< => 726
8B@7 ?7 5?@?A@?52
8 &, 72?7 ?;76@9?73G6;>
89-=;6
56E
726 6E?F7
<64F@357389 8: 726 <6F@67?; 5@856@7> D?> =6 ?4F6@7?396< =>
E6FB739A
8B@7 ?4 ? MB647389 @6;?739A 78 6E6FB7389
- 17 -
<34F2?@A6 8@ 4?734:?F7389 8: <6F@66 H37239 726 D6?939A 8:
6F7389
, 8: 726
8<6 8:
&"
FF8@<39A;>
$3%
3G3; @8F6<B@6
5@8F66< 78 5?44 726 :8;;8H39A
@37 6737389 34 <34D3446<
)*
'
"
#
&
;
&
(
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review