Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:21571-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P. (C) No. 5989 of 2025
--Ashok Singh, S/o Ram Jatan Singh, R/o Village-Budhi Paimar, P.O.Goga, P.S.-Wajirganj, District-Gaya (Bihar)
…
…
Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand, through the Chief Secretary, Ranchi
2. The Secretary, Department of Mines and Geology, Government of
Jharkhand, Ranchi
3. The Commissioner of Mines, Government of Jharkhand, Ranchi
4. The Deputy Commissioner, Latehar
5. The District Mining Officer, Latehar
….
.…
Respondents
----CORAM:
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH SHANKAR
----For the Petitioner
:
Mr. Ashok Kumar Singh, Advocate
For the Respondents:
Mr. Shahbaj Akhtar, A.C. to A.A.G.-III
For the intervenor :
Mr. Prashant Kumar Rahul, Advocate
----Reserved on 15.07.2026
Pronounced on 22.07.2026
Per : Rajesh Shankar, J. :
1. Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the
materials available on record.
2. The present writ petition has been preferred for issuance of
direction upon the respondents to release the truck (hywa)
bearing registration No. OD-09P-3039 (hereinafter referred as
‘the said vehicle’) in favour of the petitioner pursuant to the
order dated 16.05.2025 passed by the Mines Commissioner,
Ranchi (respondent no. 3 herein) in Revision Case No.17 of
2023.
3. The fact of the case in brief is that the said vehicle of the
petitioner was seized by the officials of Balumath Police Station
allegedly loaded with illegal coal. Thereafter Balumath P.S Case
No. 265 of 2021 was lodged u/s 414/420/467/468/471/34 IPC,
1 | Page
2026:JHHC:21571-DB
Section 30(ii) of Coal Mines Act, Section 21 of the Mines and
Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 and Section
13 of the Jharkhand Mineral (Prevention of Illegal Mining,
Transportation
and
Storage)
Rules,
2017.
Subsequently,
Confiscation Case No. 102 of 2022 was instituted by the
Superintendent of Police, Latehar in the Court of Deputy
Commissioner-cum-District Magistrate, Latehar (the respondent
no.4 herein) for confiscation of the said vehicle and a notice
was issued to the petitioner on 22.11.2022 under the signature
of In-Charge Deputy Collector, District Legal Branch, Latehar.
4. The petitioner appeared before the court of the respondent
no.4 and replied the said notice. Finally, the respondent no.4
issued the order of confiscation of the said vehicle vide order
dated 25.02.2023 directing the District Mining officer, Latehar
(respondent no. 5) to auction the said vehicle and deposit the
auctioned amount in the Government treasury within a period
of eight weeks.
5. Aggrieved with the order dated 25.02.2023, the petitioner filed
Revision Case No.17 of 2023 before the respondent no. 3 which
was allowed vide the order as contained in Memo No. 1166
dated 16.05.2025 remanding the matter to the respondent no.
4 with an instruction to release the said vehicle after realizing
payable royalty/penalty/other tax as per provision of the
Jharkhand Mines and Mineral Rules, 2004 (in short ‘Rules,
2004’).
6. Thereafter, the petitioner made representation before the
2 | Page
2026:JHHC:21571-DB
respondent no. 4 on 18.07.2025 along with a copy of order
dated 16.05.2025 passed in Revision Case No.17/2023 for
release of the said vehicle in his favour, however the same was
not released.
7. Hence, the present writ petition.
8. The respondents filed counter affidavit on 10.11.2025 in the
present case asserting that the said vehicle was already
auctioned on 08.03.2023 itself which was purchased by one
Bhola Singh (hereinafter referred as ‘the intervenor’) at Rs.
20,78,500/- and due to the said fact, the said vehicle could not
be released by the respondent no. 4 in favour of the petitioner
in compliance of the order passed by the respondent no. 3.
9. Keeping in view the said averment of the respondents, a Coordinate Bench of this Court, vide order dated 10.11.2025
observed as under: “7. In the counter affidavit, stand inter alia
has been taken that the vehicle has already been
auctioned and transfer in favour of the 3 rd party by
the process of auction dated 08.03.2023.
8. It appears from the material on record that
the revision was to be filed within 60 days as per the
provision provided under Rule 62 of the JMMC Rules,
2004 which was to be completed on 26.04.2023, on
calculation being made and on consideration of the
fact that in the month of February, 2023, there were
only 28 days. The auction took place on 08.03.2023
that is admitted case as per the annexure appended
as Annexure-A to the counter affidavit, which was
within the period of limitation as provided under
Rule 62 of the JMMC Rule, 2004.
9. The question here which requires to be
answered by the State that when the statute
provides 60 days limitation to file revision and if
within the aforesaid period of 60 days any action
3 | Page
2026:JHHC:21571-DB
adverse to the interest of the litigant concerned, the
writ petitioner herein, will certainly prejudice the
case of the concerned litigant, exactly the same is
the case herein, since the revision which was to be
filed up to 26.04.2023, has been filed on 22.03.2023
but the vehicle in question was put on auction on
08.03.2023, i.e., within the period of 60 days.
10. In the order passed by the Deputy
Commissioner, Latehar, there is no explanation to
that effect save and except the vehicle has been
transferred by way of auction which took place on
08.03.2023.
11. The further question which requires to be
answered by the Deputy Commissioner, Latehar that
if the vehicle in question has been put on auction
within a period of 60 days, how can such auction be
justified to be proper in the eyes of law.
12. The same since has not been explained in
the counter affidavit and, as such, one more
indulgence
is
being
given
to
the
Deputy
Commissioner, Latehar to explain for passing further
necessary order.”
10. Pursuant to the aforesaid direction, a supplementary counter
affidavit was filed on behalf of the respondent nos.4 & 5 on
25.11.2025 stating that the respondent no.4 took necessary
steps to restore the said vehicle in favour of the petitioner and
accordingly vide letter No. 1220 dated 22.11.2025, the
intervenor was directed to hand over the said vehicle to the
court of the respondent no. 4. It was further averred in the said
affidavit that the respondent no. 4 and 5 took all possible steps
in view of the order passed by the respondent no. 3.
11. The matter was again placed before a Co-ordinate Bench of this
court on 25.11.2025 and the Bench being not satisfied with the
statement made in the said supplementary counter affidavit
directed the respondent no. 4 to come out with a specific stand
4 | Page
2026:JHHC:21571-DB
so as to resolve the issue.
12. Thereafter, according to the respondent no. 4, he took steps to
resolve the matter and in that process, issued notices to the
petitioner and the intervenor. The intervenor replied the notice
stating that he spent approximate Rs.22,50,000/- (Rupees
twenty two lakhs fifty thousand) in making the said vehicle
operational after purchasing it in auction and hence he could
return the said vehicle if Rs. 43,00,000/- along with interest
was paid to him.
13. The respondent no. 4 then directed the intervenor, vide his
order dated 25.05.2026 passed in Misc. Case No. 01 of 2026, to
surrender the said vehicle to the respondent no. 5 within 2 days
of the order and further took a decision that the intervenor
would be paid a sum of Rs. 20,78,500/- along with simple
interest at the prevailing bank rate.
14. Thereafter, the respondent no. 4, vide letter no. 611 dated
27.05.2026, requested the Director, Mines for allotment of
Rs.26,57,633/- in total to pay the said amount to the intervenor
as a condition to return the said vehicle. It has also been
averred in the supplementary counter affidavit that after
allotment, the said amount was paid to the intervenor.
15. It also appears that the intervenor handed over the said vehicle
to the District Administration, Latehar on 10.06.2026 and the
respondent no.4, vide letter dated 15.06.2026, asked the
petitioner to collect the said vehicle. However, the petitioner has
not collected the vehicle till date and the same has been kept in
5 | Page
2026:JHHC:21571-DB
the safe custody of Police Line, Latehar.
16. The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the said
vehicle was stolen in the night of 24.11.2021 and in this regard
an FIR being Muffasil P.S. Case No.630 of 2021 was lodged by
him.
17. It is further submitted that the said vehicle was seized by
Bariyatu
T.O.P.
In-Charge,
Balumath
Police
Station
on
21.12.2021 allegedly carrying illegal coal with fake registration
number. According to the petitioner, the said vehicle was being
used by the persons who had stolen it. Thereafter, the
petitioner filed an application in the Court of Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Gaya for release of the said vehicle, however, during
pendency of the said application, he received a notice in
Confiscation Case No.102/2022 instituted by the Superintendent
of Police, Latehar in the Court of Deputy Commissioner-cumDistrict Magistrate, Latehar.
18. It is further submitted that the petitioner appeared and filed
reply in the said confiscation case, however the said vehicle was
confiscated vide order dated 25.02.2023 passed by the
respondent no.4 directing the respondent no. 5 to auction the
said vehicle and deposit the auctioned amount in the
Government treasury within a period of eight weeks.
19. It is also submitted that pursuant to the order dated
25.02.2023, the said vehicle was put to auction hurriedly
without waiting for expiry of the statutory period for filing
revision by the petitioner against the said order.
6 | Page
2026:JHHC:21571-DB
20. It is further argued that even the auction of the said vehicle
was done without issuing any notice to the petitioner and thus
the said auction was itself in complete violation of the principles
of natural justice.
21. It is also contended that due to the said arbitrary attitude of the
respondents, the petitioner has suffered huge financial loss as
well as mental agony and as such, in addition to getting back
the said vehicle, he is also entitled to be paid adequate
compensation by the respondents.
22. The learned counsel for the Intervener submits that the
Intervener purchased the vehicle in auction sale for an amount
of Rs. 20,78,500/- however the same was not fit to be plied. As
such, he made additional expense of Rs. 22,50,000/- to make it
operational and thus the total cost incurred by him towards the
said vehicle is approximately Rs. 43,00,000/.
23. On perusal of the record, it appears that the order for
confiscation of the said vehicle was made on 25.02.2023. As
per rule 62 of the Rules, 2004, the petitioner had the right to
prefer revision before the respondent no. 3 within 60 days from
the date of information of the order dated 25.02.2023. The
petitioner had also availed the said remedy by filing revision
application on 22.03.2023 i.e. well within the period of
limitation. Despite that, the respondent no. 5 put the said
vehicle to auction on 08.03.2023 i.e., much prior to the end of
limitation period. Even, no personal notice was served to the
petitioner before putting the said vehicle to auction. Pursuant to
7 | Page
2026:JHHC:21571-DB
the auction, the said vehicle was also delivered to the
intervener being the auction purchaser of the said vehicle.
Finally, the revision filed by the petitioner was allowed vide
order as contained in memo no.1166 of 16.05.2025 i.e., after
two years of completing the auction. In the said order, the
respondent no. 3 observed that the respondent no. 4 was not
the competent authority to pass the order of confiscation in
view of the order dated 25.04.2024 passed in W.P. (Cr.) No. 751
of 2023. The respondent no. 3 thus remanded the matter back
to the respondent no. 4 with the instruction to release the said
vehicle in favour of the petitioner after realizing payable
royalty/penalty/other tax as per the provision of the Rules,
2004.
24. On the one hand, the claim of the Intervener is that in addition
to auction price of the said vehicle i.e., Rs. 20,78,500/-, he has
made additional expense of Rs. 22,50,000/- on the said vehicle
whereas Rs. 26,57,633/- has only been paid to him in lieu of
return of the said vehicle. Thus, irreparable loss and injury have
been caused to him for no fault on his part. The claim of the
petitioner on the other hand, is that the said vehicle was
illegally put to auction on 08.03.2023 and after handing over
the vehicle to the Intervener, he used the said vehicle for about
three years and the vehicle is now being handing over to the
petitioner in a dilapidated condition for which no compensation
is being paid to him. It is further claimed that the total financial
liability arising out of the loan obtained to purchase the said
8 | Page
2026:JHHC:21571-DB
vehicle is approximately Rs. 84,00,000/- inclusive of interest
and as such the petitioner must be compensated for the illegal
auction of the said vehicle.
25. So far the petitioner’s claim for compensation is concerned, we
are of the view that the said claim cannot be adjudicated by
this court under its extraordinary writ jurisdiction. Assessment
of quantum of compensation is a purely factual issue which
requires leading of evidences by the parties and the same can
only be determined by a competent fact-finding court.
26. Nonetheless, we also cannot outrightly ignore the admitted fact
that the vehicle of the petitioner was put to auction without
waiting for expiry of the statutory period for filing revision.
There is nothing on record to suggest that any personal notice
was served to be petitioner before putting the said vehicle to
auction. Had the petitioner been served with a personal notice,
he would have informed the respondents about the steps being
taken by him to file the revision against the order dated
25.02.2023 passed by the respondent no. 4. Thus, the
petitioner has suffered serious prejudice due to non-service of
personal notice to him.
27. Though, the contention of the respondents is that a general
notice for auction was published in the newspaper, the same, in
our opinion, cannot be held as a proper service of notice to the
petitioner as he could not have expected that his vehicle would
be put to auction even prior to end of the statutory period for
filing revision and thus to keep watch on the auction notice to
9 | Page
2026:JHHC:21571-DB
be published in the newspaper. Even otherwise, as observed
hereinabove, putting the said vehicle to auction sale prior to
expiry of the statutory period to prefer revision, was itself
illegal. It is well settled principle of law that the Right to
Property is a constitutional right and no one can be deprived of
his property except by following the due procedure established
by law. Thus, the respondents have committed grave illegality
in putting the vehicle to auction with unexplained haste.
28. Considering the peculiar facts and circumstance of the present
case and to meet the ends of justice, we deem it appropriate to
direct the respondents to pay a cost of Rs. 3,00,000/- to the
petitioner in addition to handing over the said vehicle to him for
the harassment suffered due to such illegality on the part of the
respondents.
29. Now, coming to the claim of the intervenor regarding demand
of Rs. 43,00,000/- in lieu of return of the said vehicle. The said
claim of the intervenor also requires factual determination by a
competent fact-finding court and thus the same cannot be
entertained
by
this
court
under
its
extraordinary
writ
jurisdiction. Moreover, it transpires from the facts of the case
that the intervenor has used the said vehicle for about three
years after purchasing it in auction and has certainly derived
commercial gains out of it for these years. Thus, we do not find
any infirmity in the order dated 25.05.2026 passed by the
respondent no. 4 in Misc. Case No. 01 of 2026 whereby it was
decided to pay Rs.20,78,500/- with simple interest at the
10 | P a g e
2026:JHHC:21571-DB
prevailing bank rate to the intervenor. As we have been
informed
that
the
intervenor
has
already
been
paid
Rs.26,57,633/- in lieu of return of the said vehicle, the said
amount, in our prima facie opinion, is reasonable for his
suffering due to such action of the respondents.
30. For the reasons as aforesaid, the respondents are directed to
deliver the said vehicle along with the compensation of
Rs.3,00,000/- to the petitioner within two weeks from the date
of receipt/production of copy of this order.
31. The petitioner as well as the intervenor are at liberty to take
appropriate recourse before the competent court of law, if they
wish to seek further compensation from the respondents.
32. The writ petition is, accordingly, disposed of with the aforesaid
observations and directions.
33. Pending interlocutory application, if any, also stands disposed of.
(M.S. Sonak, C.J.)
(Rajesh Shankar, J.)
22.07.2026
Vikas/A.F.R.
Uploaded on 22.07.2026
11 | P a g e
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review