Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:1313
INDRAJEET
SAHU
Digitally signed
by INDRAJEET
SAHU
Date: 2026.03.16
18:53:25 +0530
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CRA No. 1955 of 2024
1 - Sahamat Ali S/o Haider Ali Aged About 30 Years R/o Atal Awas Ghughari
Road, Village Ghugharikala, Kawardha, Police Station, Kawardha, District
Kabirdham (C.G.) Pin - 491995,,...(Accused No. 01).
--- Appellant
versus
1 - State of Chhattisgarh Through The Police Station Pipariya, District
Kabirdham (C.G.)
--- Respondent(s)
CRA No. 2285 of 2024
1 - Ashok Pandey S/o Late Babuji Pandey Aged About 62 Years R/o Village
Belsari, Police Station- Takhatpur, District Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh. Pin
495330. (Accused No. 02)
---Appellant
Versus
1 - State of Chhattisgarh Through The Police Station Pipariya, District
Kabirdham, Chhattisgarh.
--- Respondent(s)
CRA No. 1964 of 2024
1 - Arjun Suryawanshi S/o Shri Horilal Surywanshi Aged About 26 Years R/o
Bade Bazar Takhatpur, Police Station Takhatpur, District Bilaspur (C.G.)
(Accused No. 03).
---Appellant
Versus
1 - State of Chhattisgarh Through The Police Station Pipariya, District
Kabirdham (C.G.).
--- Respondent(s)
For Appellants
For State
:
:
Shri Vijay K. Deshmukh, Advocate.
Shri Ashish Tiwari, Dy. Govt. Advocate.
Hon’ble Shri Justice Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, J
Judgment on Board
08.01.2026
These three appeals are arising out of same sessions trial and
common judgment, therefore they are being heard and decided
together by this common judgment.
The appellants Sahamat Ali (in CRA No.1955 of 2024),
Arjun
Suryawanshi (in CRA No.1964 of 2024) and Ashok Pandey (in CRA
No.2285 of 2024) have challenged the impugned judgment of
conviction and order of sentence dated 05.10.2024 passed by the
Special Judge (NDPS), Kawardha, in Special Criminal Case (NDPS)
No.106 of 2024 whereby the appellants have been convicted for the
offence under Section 21(C) of the NDPS Act and sentenced for RI for
10 years with fine of Rs.1,00,000/- each, in default of payment of fine
amount, additional RI for one year.
3 The prosecution case in brief is that, on 15.02.2024 the Investigating
Officer Rajnikant Deewan, PW-10 received a secret information that
opposite Pipariya Garden, beside Nishad Egg Role Centre, the
accused Sahamat Ali and his other friends Arjun Suryawanshi and
Ashok Pandey are selling Drug (Injection) to the young person of the
vicinity. The secret information was reduced in Rojnamcha Sanha
Ex.P/50 at 8:45 hours. Two independent witnesses Durgesh, PW-5
and Sant Ram Chandravanshi, PW-6 were called through Constable
Hemant Sharma and his departure was also recorded in Rojnamcha
Sanha Ex.P/51. The arrival of independent witness were recorded in
Rojnamcha Ex.P/52. Notice under Section 160 CrPC Ex.P/7 and P/41
were given to the witnesses and Secret information Panchnama
Ex.P/8 was prepared. Necessity to search without warrant Panchnama
was also prepared Ex.P/9 in presence of witnesses and copies of both
these Panchnamas were forwarded to DSP, Kawadha, which was also
recorded in Rojnamcha Ex.P/53 & P/54. The police party along with
investigation kit and laptop with printer proceeded towards the place of
incident by Govt. vehicle No.CG-03-5651 and their departure was also
reduced in writing in Rojnancha vide Ex.P/55. They apprehended the
suspended accused persons and then they disclosed their names as
Sahamat Ali, Arjun Suryawanshi and Ashok Pandey. Notices under
Section 50 of the NDPS Act was given to them vide Ex.P/10,11&12
and they were informed their right to be searched by the Gazetted
officer, Magistrate or by the police himself. The accused persons gave
their consent to be searched by the police officers vide Ex.P/13,14
&15. Thereafter the police party also gave their own search to the
accused persons but nothing incriminating articles were seized from
police party and Panchnama Ex.P/16 to P/18 were prepared. On being
search, from accused Sahamat Ali total 40 ampules of NRX
Buprenorphine injection 2 ml each and cash of Rs.500/-were
recovered which were kept in right pocket of his jacket. From accused
Arjun Suryawanshi, 30 ampules of NRX Buprenorphine injection 2 ml
each and cash of Rs.300/- and one mobile phone including two SIM
Cards were seized. From accused Ashok Pandey, 30 ampules of NRX
Buprenorphine injection 2 ml each and cash of Rs.200/-were
recovered.
Talashi
Panchnama
Ex.P/19,20&21
and
recovery
Panchnama Ex.P/22,23&24 were prepared. Notices under Section 67
of NDPS Act was also given to the accused persons vide
Ex.P/25,26&27. A letter Ex.P/56 was issued to Drug Inspector for
identification of the psychotropic drug/injection and obtained its
examination report Ex.P/6. Seizure memo Ex.P/28,29&30 and its
sealing Panchnama Ex.P/31,32&33 were prepared. The accused
persons were arrested under Section 21(C) of the NDPS Act and their
arrest were informed to their family members. With the consent of
proprietor of Nishad Egg Roll Centre, electricity connection were
obtained and computer & printer were operated. Sealing Panchnama
Ex.P/38 was prepared. Spot map Ex.P/39 was also prepared and
Dehati Nalishi Ex.P/60 for the offence under Section 21-C of the NDPS
Act was prepared on spot. The police party along with accused
persons and seized articles including the contraband (injection) were
taken to police station and their arrival was recorded in Rojnamcha
Sanha No.24. The seized articles were kept in safe custody of
Malkhana through Malkhana Mohrir Oman Meravi, PW-9. Based on
Dehati Nalishi, an FIR Ex.P/44 was registered in the police station. The
details of the proceeding Ex.P/61 was forwarded to DSP, Kawardha. A
letter for conducting inventory Ex.P/62 was also forwarded to Chief
Judicial Magistrate Kawardha on 16.02.2024. On 23.02.2024 a letter
Ex.P/63 was also forwarded to Drug Inspector, Kawardha for inventory
proceeding. The seized drugs were obtained from Malkhana through
Malkhana Moharir Oman Meravi and Panchnama Ex.P/49 was
prepared and thereafter the seized contraband were produced before
the Judicial Magistrate First Class for its inventory proceeding where it
was physically verified and sampling were done. The JMFC prepared
the inventory report Ex.P/64 in presence of Drug Inspector. The
samples drawn during inventory proceeding were sent to FSL Durg
along with memo of Superintendent of Police Kabirdham Ex.P/66 and
obtained its acknowledgment Ex.P/67. After chemical examination,
report was obtained from FSL Durg which is Ex.P/68. Statement of
witnesses under Section 161 CrPC were recorded and after
completion of usual investigation, charge sheet was filed against the
appellants before the trial court for the offence under Section 21(C) of
the NDPS Act. The trial court framed charge against the appellants for
the offence under Section 21(C) of the NDPS Act. The appellants
denied the charge and claimed trial.
4 In order to prove the charge against the appellants, the prosecution
has examined as many as 12 witnesses. Statement of the appellants
under Section 313 CrPC have also been recorded in which they
denied the circumstances that appears against them, pleaded
innocence and have submitted that they have been falsely implicated
in the offence.
After appreciation of oral as well as documentary evidence led by the
prosecution, the trial court has convicted the appellants and sentenced
them as mentioned in the earlier paragraph of this judgment. Hence
these appeals.
Learned counsel for the appellants would submit that the prosecution
has failed to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt. There are
material omissions and contradictions in the evidence of prosecution
witnesses which cannot be made basis to convict the appellants for
the alleged offence. There is non compliance of the mandatory
provisions of Section 42, 50, 52, 52-A, 55 and 57 of the NDPS Act.
The inventory and sampling was also not drawn in accordance with
law and the samples of the seized contraband were tampered before
sending it to FSL. The trial court has considered the entire quantity of
the mixture of the injection allegedly seized from the accused persons
whereas, only contents of the contraband is to be considered for
determining the quantity of contraband and thereby they put the
quantity of contraband under the commercial quantity whereas the
actual quantity is small quantity. In support of his submissions, he
would rely upon the judgments passed by coordinate Bench of this
court in Narendra Bhushan Dubey Vs. State of MP (Now CG),
2011(1) CGLJ 259, judgment dated 16.06.2023 passed in CRA
No.1775 of 2019 (Hariom Dhakad & Others Vs. State of
Chhattisgarh), judgment passed by the Division Bench of this court
on 16.01.2025 in CRA No.260 of 2021 (Ambika Vishwakarma Vs.
State of Chhattisgarh) and other connected appeal, judgment dated
28.03.2025 passed by this court in CRA No.26 of 2016, Harkesh
Gupta Vs. State of Chhattisgarh, and judgment passed by Supreme
Court in E. Micheal Raj Vs. Intelligence Officer, Narcotic Control
Bureau, 2008(5)SCC 161.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the State opposes and have
submitted that the prosecution has proved its case beyond reasonable
doubt, but for minor omissions and contradictions the evidence of
prosecution witnesses are fully reliable. The entire procedure as
prescribed under the NDPS Act and Rules have been followed in its
letter and spirit and after considering the evidence available on record,
the learned trial Court has rightly convicted and sentenced the
appellants for the alleged offence. The accused persons were found in
possession of illegal drugs i.e. NRX Buprenorphine Injection. The
quantity of alleged drugs comes under commercial quantity and the
entire quantity of mixture is to be considered to determine the quantity
of mixture and not the actual contents. The right to search were duly
informed to the accused persons. The senior police officers were
communicated about the incident and their search and seizure
proceeding have been proved by the investigating officer. The
inventory was also drawn by JMFC Kawardha and samples were
drawn which were sent for its chemical examination to FSL Durg.
Thus, all the mandatory provisions of NDPS Act have duly been
complied with which does not affect the prosecution’s case. Though
minor discrepancies reflected from preparation of Panchnamas, but
the same does not affect its credibility. Thus, considering all these
facts, the trial court has rightly convicted the accused persons for
illegal possession of said NRX Buprenorphine injection as they failed
to produce evidence how they came in possession of same.
I have heard the counsel for the parties and perused the record of trial
court with utmost circumspection.
PW-10, Rajnikant Deewan, is the Investigating officer of the case. He
stated in his evidence that on 15.02.2024 at about 8:35 hours he
received a secret information that opposite Pipariya Garden, beside
Nishad Egg Role Centre, the accused Sahamat Ali and his other
friends Arjun Suryawanshi and Ashok Pandey are selling illegal Drug
(Injection). The secret information was reduced in writing in
Rojnamcha Sanha Ex.P/50 and called the independent witnesses
Durgesh, PW-5 and Sant Ram Chandravanshi, PW-6 through
Constable Hemant Sharma and his departure was also recorded in
Rojnamcha Sanha Ex.P/51. The arrival of independent witness were
also recorded in Rojnamch Ex.P/52. Notice under Section 160 CrPC
Ex.P/7 and P/41 was given to the witnesses and Secret information
Panchnama Ex.P/8 was prepared. The necessity to search without
warrant Panchnama was also prepared Ex.P/9 in presence of
witnesses and copies of both these Panchnamas were forwarded to
DSP (Kawardha) through Constable Narayan Patel in compliance of
Section 42 of the NDPS Act. The acknowledgment obtained by said
Constable is Ex.P/2 and his duty certificate is Ex.P/3. The departure of
said Constable is Ex.P/9 and his arrival is Ex.P/54. Thereafter, they
along with investigation kit and laptop with printer proceeded towards
the place of incident by police vehicle and their departure was also
reduced in writing in Rojnancha vide Ex.P/55. On the spot, they found
three suspected persons who disclosed their names as Sahamat Ali,
Arjun Suryawanshi and Ashok Pandey. Notices under Section 50 of
the NDPS Act was given to them vide Ex.P/10,11&12 and they were
informed their right to be searched by the Gazetted officer, Magistrate
or by the police himself. The accused persons gave their consent to be
searched by the police officers vide Ex.P/13,14 &15. Thereafter the
police party also gave their own search to the accused persons
however nothing incriminating articles were seized from police party
and Panchnama Ex.P/16 to P/18 were prepared. On being search,
from accused Sahamat Ali total 40 ampules of NRX Buprenorphine
injection 2 ml each and cash of Rs.500/-were found which were kept
in right pocket of his jacket. From accused Arjun Suryawanshi, 30
ampules of NRX Buprenorphine injection 2 ml each and cash of
Rs.300/- were found which were kept in his right pocket of lower, one
mobile phone including two SIM Cards were also seized. From
accused Ashok Pandey, 30 ampules of NRX Buprenorphine injection
2 ml each and cash of Rs.200/-have been recovered from front pocket
of his pant. Search Panchnama Ex.P/19,20&21 and recovery
Panchnama Ex.P/22,23&24 were also prepared. Notices under
Section 67 of NDPS Act was also given to the accused persons but
they failed to produce any valid license of its possession. A letter
Ex.P/56 was issued to Drug Inspector for identification of the
psychotropic drug/injection. The Drug Inspector, after its examination
gave a report Ex.P/6. Seizure memos of seizure of alleged contraband
were prepared vide Ex.P/28,29&30 and its sealing Panchnama
Ex.P/31,32&33 were prepared. Considering prima facie offence
against the appellants, they were arrested and their arrest were
informed to their family members. With the consent of proprietor of
Egg Roll Centre, electricity connection were obtained and computer &
printer were operated. The seized articles were sealed on spot and
specimen Seal Panchnama Ex.P/38 was prepared. Spot map Ex.P/39
was also prepared and Dehati Nalishi Ex.P/60 for the offence under
Section 21(C) of the NDPS Act was prepared on spot. The police party
along with accused persons and seized articles including the
contraband (injection) were taken to police station and their arrival was
recorded in Rojnamcha Sanha No.24. The seized articles were kept in
safe custody of Malkhana through Malkhana Mohrir Oman Meravi,
PW-9. Based on Dehati Nalishi, an FIR Ex.P/44 was registered in the
police station. On the same day the details of proceeding Ex.P/61 was
forwarded to DSP, Kawardha. A letter for conducting inventory Ex.P/62
was also forwarded to Chief Judicial Magistrate Kawardha on
16.02.2024. On 23.02.2024 a letter Ex.P/63 was also forwarded to
Drug Inspector, Kawardha for inventory proceeding. The seized drugs
were obtained from Malkhana Oman Meravi and Panchnama Ex.P/49
was prepared and thereafter the seized contraband were sent to
Judicial Magistrate First Class for its inventory proceeding where it
was physically verified and sampling were done. The JMFC prepared
the inventory report Ex.P/64 in presence of Drug Inspector. The
samples drawn during inventory proceeding were sent to FSL Durg
along with memo of Superintendent of Police Kabirdham Ex.P/66 and
obtained its acknowledgment Ex.P/67 and its examination report is
Ex.P/68. The samples which were sent for its examination to FSL were
also produced before the court in sealed condition which are Article A1,B-1 and C-1. After completion of usual investigation he filed the
charge sheet against the appellants. In cross examination, he stated
that in the FSL report Ex.P/68, the contents of injection were found
Buprenorphine which is a manufactured drug. As per the report of
Drug Inspector, the contents of contraband is substantive drug in the
mixture and as per the label annexed in the injection, it is schedule H1 drug under the Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940 (in short, The Act,
1940). He also stated that 1ml=1gram, however he is not the expert.
He admits that he considered 1gram=1ml and investigated the case.
10 From his detailed cross examination, the defence could not extract any
circumstances which makes his evidence doubtful that he has not
conducted search and seizure proceeding and falsely implicated the
accused persons in the offence. He remain firm in search and seizure
proceeding which he conducted on the date of incident.
11 PW-1, Shyam Lal Sahu, is that Patwari who prepared spot map
Ex.P/1. PW-2, Narayan Patel, is the Constable who took the secret
information Panchnama to the office of DSP Kawarda and obtained its
acknowledgment Ex.P/2. He also proved his duty certificate Ex.P/3.
PW-3, Hemant Sharma, is Constable who called the independent
witnesses. He is also witness of service of summons to the
independent witnesses and duly proved the prosecution case.
12 PW-4, Jitendra Patidar, is the Drug Inspector, who have stated in his
evidence that the Sub Inspector of Police Rajnikant Deewan have sent
100 ampules of NRX Buprenorphine injection 2 ml each for its physical
identification and other relevant information. He appeared on the spot
and gave detailed information about the seized injection. The seized
injection were
NRX Buprenorphine having 2 ml each and total
quantity of 100 ampule was 200 ml and as per the Act, 1940, the said
injection is Schedule H-1 Drug and he issued the information which is
Ex.P/6. In cross examination, he admits that schedule H-1 Drug can
only be purchased from Medical store only after producing medical
prescription. He admits that he has not chemically examined the said
injection.
13 PW-5, Durgesh Sahu and PW-6 Sant Ram Chandravanshi are the
independent witnesses. Though they have not fully supported the case
of prosecution, but they admit their signature over documents Ex.P/7
to P/39. PW-7, Bhanu Prasad, is the Head Constable posted as
Reader at the office of DSP, Kabirdham. He received the copy of
secret information Panchnama and issued acknowledgment Ex.P/2.
The dispatch register is Ex.P/43.
14 PW-8, Balram Nishad, is the person who runs Nishad Egg Roll Centre
from where the electricity connection was taken for operating
Computer and Printer. PW-9, Oman Meravi, is the Head Constable
and Malkhana Moharrir at Police Station Pipariya. He proved safe
custody of seized articles which were endorsed in document Ex.P/45.
He also registered the FIR Ex.P/44 on the basis of Dehati Nalisi. He
stated in his evidence that the seized injection ampules and mobile
phones were kept in safe custody of Malkhana and he issued
acknowledgment Ex.P/46 and thereafter on 23.02.2024 he has taken
out the seized injections from Malkhana for its inventory proceeding. It
was sealed at that time and it was recorded in Rojnamcha Sanha
No.6. Their departure of inventory was recorded in Rojnamcha Sanha
No.7 and their arrival was also recorded at Sanha No.37. The three
sealed packets were taken out from Malkhana to send it to FSL Durg
and after its chemical examination he again received three sealed
packets to keep it in safe custody of Malkhana.
15 From the evidence of this witness, it is quite vivid that the seized
articles were kept in safe custody of Malkhana and there was no
tempering with the samples.
16 PW-11, Dinesh Jhariya, is Assistant Sub Inspector, who was the
member of search party and proved the search and seizure
proceeding
from
the
accused
persons. Though
some
minor
discrepancies were found in his evidence, but that itself was not
sufficient to disbelieve the search and seizure proceeding.
17 PW-12, Yogendra Verma is the Constable who has taken the sample
plackets of injection to FSL Durg and obtained acknowledgment
Ex.P/67. He also proved that sample packets were intact and sealed
and there was tampering with the sample packets.
18 From all these evidences, there is nothing on record to say that there
was any substantial flaw in the search or seizure proceeding or the
accused persons have been falsely implicated in the offence. The
mandatory provisions of Section 42,50,52,52-A,55 and 57 of NDPS
Act appears to be complied with by the prosecution agency at the time
of search and seizure proceeding. Thus, the search and seizure of
alleged contraband from the accused persons is found proved.
19 So far as the quantity of seized drugs are concerned, this court
examine the legal provisions as has been settled in various judgments
of High Courts as well as Supreme Court.
20 The submission of the counsel for the appellants that the composition
of salt,presence of narcotic or psychotropic substance if are calculated
separately, it would fall within the ambit of small quantity and in cases
it below the commercial quantity. At the very outset, one cannot loose
sight of the fact that NDPS Act was legislated to amend the existing
law relating to narcotic drug and psychotropic substance and to control
the menace of the drug, as it was adversely affecting the social fabric
including the young children of the schools and colleges. In order to
carry out the purpose, further the Central Government has issued the
notification on 18.11.2009 with respect to the presence of drug which
reads as under :
“Notification dated 18.11.2009 has replaced the part of the
Notification dated 19.10.2001 and reads as under : “In the Table at
the end after Note 3, the following Note shall be inserted, namely :
(4) The quantities shown in Column 5 and Column 6 of the Table
relating to the respective drugs shown in Column 2 shall apply to
the entire mixture or any solution or any one or more narcotic
drugs or psychotropic substances of that particular drug in
dosage form or isomers, esters, ethers and salts of these drugs,
including salts of esters, ethers and isomers, wherever existence
of such substance is possible and not just its pure drug content.”
21 The language of statute is clear, the only duty of the Court is to give
effect to it and the Court has no business to look into consequences of
such interpretation. The Court is under an obligation to expound the
law as it exists and leave the remedy to the legislature, even if harsh
conclusions result from such exposition.
22 Admittedly, in this case, if the total mass of the mixed mixture of Salt
and injection are taken into account, the total mass of goods
recovered from the appellants will have to be taken into account
without calculating the percentage of narcotic drug and psychotropic
substance separately to calculate the small and commercial quantity
limit. Therefore, by application of the aforesaid notification, the
percentage of narcotic drug and psychotropic substance shall be
inseparable and the whole contraband seized has to be taken into
consideration that whether the same falls within the small quantity or
commercial quantity or an intermediate quantity. The said notification
was further upheld by their Lordship in case of Harjit Singh v. State
of Punjab, (2011) 4 SCC 441, wherein it is held that under the
notification, the whole quantity of material recovered in form of mixture
has to be considered for the purpose of imposition of punishment.
Therefore, the percentage of narcotic drugs i.e. NRX Buprenorphine
injection would be immaterial to calculate presence of psychotropic
substances from the goods seized at mass.
23 In case of Hira Singh & Another Vs. Union of India, 2020 (20)SCC
272, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has considered the judgment of E.
Micheal (Supra) and answered the reference as follows.
“12. In view of the above and for the reasons stated above, Reference
is answered as under:
12.1. The decision of this Court in the case of E. Micheal Raj
(Supra) taking the view that in the mixture of narcotic drugs
or psychotropic substance with one or more neutral
substance(s), the quantity of the neutral substance(s) is not
to be taken into consideration while determining the small
quantity or commercial quantity of a narcotic drug or
psychotropic substance and only the actual content by
weight of the offending narcotic drug which is relevant for
the purpose of determining whether it would constitute small
quantity or commercial quantity, is not a good law;
12.2 In case of seizure of mixture of Narcotic Drugs or
Psychotropic
Substances
with
one
or
more
neutral
substance(s), the quantity of neutral substance(s) is not to
be excluded and to be taken into consideration along with
actual content by weight of the offending drug, while
determining the “small or commercial quantity” of the
Narcotic Drugs or Psychotropic Substances;
12.3. Section 21 of the NDPS Act is not stand-alone
provision and must be construed along with other provisions
in the statute including provisions in the NDPS Act including
Notification
No.S.O.2942(E)
dated
18.11.2009
Notification S.O 1055(E) dated 19.10.2001;
and
12.4. Challenge to Notification dated 18.11.2009 adding
“Note 4” to the Notification dated 19.10.2001, fails and it is
observed and held that the same is not ultra vires to the
Scheme and the relevant provisions of the NDPS Act.
Consequently, writ petitions and Civil Appeal No. 5218/2017
challenging the aforesaid notification stand dismissed.”
24 With respect to compliance of Section 42 of NDPS Act is concerned,
PW-10, Rajnikant Diwan, the Investigating Officer, have proved the
compliance of Section 42 of the NDPS Act. He has stated in his
evidence that accused Sahamat Ali and his two friends Arjun
Suryawanshi and Ashok Pandey are engaged in selling NRX
Buprenorphine near Nishad Egg Role Centre, Pipariya Garden and
then he recorded it in writing in Rojnamcha Sanha Ex.P/50 and called
the
independent
witnesses
Durgesh,
PW-5
and
Sant
Ram
Chandravanshi, PW-6 through Constable Hemant Sharma. He issued
his duty certificate. When the Constable took two independent
witnesses, he served them notice. The secret information Panchnama
Ex.P/8 and necessity to search without warrant Panchnama was
prepared. A copy of the same were forwarded to DSP, Kawardha and
issued the duty certificate Ex.P/3 which was also recorded in
Rojnamcha Sanha Ex.P/53. The arrival of Constable was also
recorded in Rojnamcha Ex.P/54. The Constable Narayan Patel, PW-2,
took the said Panchnamas to the office of DSP, Kawardha, who proved
the service of copy of said Panchnamas to the office of DSP Kawardha
and obtained acknowledgment.
25 PW-7, Bhanu Prasad Dahire is the Reader posted at the office of DSP
Kabirdham, who also proved that he received the copies of information
under Section 42 of the NDPS Act though Constable Narayan Patel,
PW-2 on 15.02.2024. He entered it in the register Ex.P./43. Though it is
not mentioned in the register as to who has served the said
Panchnamas to the office of DSP, Kawardha, but in the opinion of this
court, that itself is not sufficient to disbelieve that no information were
served to the office of DSP Kawardha in compliance of Section 42 of
the NDPS Act. Considering the entire documents, the trial court has
also found that there is substantial compliance of Section 42 of the
NDPS Act.
26 With respect to compliance of Section 52 of the NDPS Act, the trial
court has also considered the evidence available in the record that the
Investigating Officer has served three separate notices Ex.P/10,11&12
to the accused persons and informed their right to be searched either
Gazetted officer, Magistrate or Police authority and in the document
Ex.P/13,14&15 they gave their consent to be searched by the police
authority. The trial court has also considered that the police party also
gave their own search to the accused persons, but nothing
incriminating were found and Panchnama Ex.P/16,17&18 were
prepared. On being search, from accused Sahamat Ali total 40
ampules of NRX Buprenorphine injection 2 ml each were seized which
were kept in right pocket of his jacket. From accused Arjun
Suryawanshi, 30 ampules of NRX Buprenorphine injection 2 ml each
were seized which were kept in his right pocket of lower and from
accused Ashok Pandey also, 30 ampules of NRX Buprenorphine
injection 2 ml each were seized from front pocket of his pant. Search
Panchnama Ex.P/19,20&21 and recovery Panchnama Ex.P/22,23&24
were prepared. The injections were seized vide Ex.P/28,29&30 and its
sealing
Panchnama
Ex.P/31,32&33
were
prepared.
Thereafter,
specimen seal Panchnama Ex.P/38 was also prepared. Thus,
compliance of Section 50 of the NDPS Act also found proved by the
prosecution.
27 So far as the compliance of Section 52-A of the NDPS Act is
concerned, the investigating Officer Rajnikant Diwan, PW-10, called
the Drug Inspector through Constable Hemant Sharma and issued the
duty certificate Ex.P/5. The Drug Inspector, PW-4 Jitendra Patidar,
appeared on the spot and after its examination, gave report Ex.P/6 that
the said injection contains with contraband NRX Buprenorphine. He
physically verified and examined the injection that it was NRX
Buprenorphine injection which comes under Schedule H-1 Drug. The
said inventory proceeding was also conducted by the JMFC,
Kawardha. PW-9, Omen Meravi have proved that the said seized
injections from the accused persons were kept in safe custody of
Malkhana and took out the said injection from Malkhana for inventory
and handed over to Investigating Officer Rajnikant Diwan which was
entered in Rojnamcha Sanha No.6. After the inventory proceeding, its
incoming was again recorded in Rojnamcha Sanha No.7. The
inventory report is Ex.P/64 which was prepared by the JMFC,
Kawardha. The trial court after considering the evidence available on
record and also in view of the judgment passed by the Supreme Court
in case of Usuf @ Asif Vs. State, 2023 SCCOnline SC 1328, has held
that the prosecution has proved the inventory proceeding and drawn
the sample of the seized injection in compliance of Section 52-A of the
NDPS Act.
28 Further, the trial court has also considered the compliance of Section
55 of the NDPS Act on its detailed discussions from paragraph 44 of
the impugned judgment. From a close scrutiny of the consideration of
the trial court, this court does not find any perversity or infirmity in the
consideration of the provisions of Section 55 of the NDPS Act.
29 The FSL report Ex.P/68 clearly demonstrate that the samples drawn
were found to be contained with Buprenorphine and thus, it has been
found proved that the injections seized from the accused persons were
of NRX Buprenorphine which was contraband Drugs under the NDPS
Act.
30 The judgments cited and relied upon by the counsel for the appellants
are distinguishable in the facts and evidence of present case and
therefore no benefit could be extended to the appellants by those
judgments.
31 After having considered the submissions of counsel for the appellants
and the evidence available on record, this court is of the considered
opinion that the trial court has rightly considered the evidence available
on record and after its meticulous and detailed examination held the
appellants guilty for the offence under section 21(c) of the NDPS Act in
which this court does not find any perversity or infirmity in their
conviction or sentence.
32 Consequently, the appeals filed by the appellants are dismissed. The
appellants are reported to be in jail since 15.02.2024. They shall serve
the entire sentence awarded by the trial court.
33 Registry is directed to send a copy of this judgment to the concerned
Superintendent of Jail where the appellants are undergoing their jail
sentence to serve the same on the appellants informing them that they
are at liberty to assail the present judgment passed by this Court by
preferring an appeal before the Hon’ble Supreme Court with the
assistance of High Court Legal Services Committee or the Supreme
Court Legal Services Committee.
Let a copy of this judgment and the original records be transmitted to
the trial Court concerned forthwith for necessary information and
compliance.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
inder
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review