Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:3582
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
Cr. MMO No. 49 of 2026
Reserved on: 08.01.2026
Date of Decision: 23.02.2026.
Ashok Kumar
...Petitioner
Versus
Monika Sharma
...Respondent
Coram
Hon’ble Mr Justice Rakesh Kainthla, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1 No
For the Petitioner
:
M/s Raj Kumar and
Mandhotra, Advocates.
For the Respondent
:
None
Avnish
Rakesh Kainthla, Judge
The present petition has been filed against the order
dated November 28, 2025, passed by the learned Judicial
Magistrate First Class, Jhandutta, District Bilaspur, H.P. (the
learned Trial Court) vide which the application for recall of the
witness and placing the documents on record was dismissed.
2.
It has been asserted that the respondent filed a
petition under Section 12 of the Protection of Women from
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes.
2026:HHC:3582
Domestic Violence Act (in short, DV Act). The present petitioner
moved an application under Section 311 Cr.P.C. for placing
additional documents on record, and to summon the proprietor
of Diamond Jewellery House, Ghumarwin, to verify the sale
record and recall the complainant for the production of original
bills. These documents are necessary for the just adjudication of
the dispute. The learned Trial Court dismissed the application.
Learned Trial Court failed to record any finding regarding the
relevance of the documents and exceeded its jurisdiction while
dismissing the application. Hence, the present petition.
3.
M/s Raj Kumar and Avnish Mandhotra, learned
counsel for the petitioner, submitted that the learned Trial Court
erred in dismissing the application. The production of the
document was necessary for the just adjudication of the dispute.
The documents did not bear any GST number, and it was
necessary to cross-examine the complainant and the owner of
Diamond Jewellery House regarding this aspect. Therefore, they
prayed that the present petition be allowed and the order passed
by the learned Trial Court be set aside.
2026:HHC:3582
4.
I have given considerable thought to the submissions
made at the bar and have gone through the records carefully.
5.
The
application
(annexure
P2)
mentions
that
production of the document and recall of the witnesses were
essential in the interest of justice. No prejudice would be caused
to the other side in case the application is allowed, and the
witnesses are ordered to be recalled. The application is silent as
to why the documents could not be produced on record earlier,
or the questions which are sought to be asked in the crossexamination were not put when the witnesses were being crossexamined. Thus, the application could not have been allowed
without asserting the necessary facts.
6.
It was submitted that the applicant had changed his
counsel, and the questions were not asked by the earlier counsel.
This submission will not help the petitioner. It was laid down by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in State (NCT of Delhi) v. Shiv Kumar
Yadav, (2016) 2 SCC 402: 2015 SCC OnLine SC 799 that a witness
cannot be recalled on the change of counsel. It was observed at
page 416:
“15. The above observations cannot be read as laying
down any inflexible rule to routinely permit a recall on
2026:HHC:3582
the ground that cross-examination was not proper for
reasons attributable to counsel. While advancement of
justice remains the prime object of law, it cannot be
understood that recall can be allowed for the asking or
reasons related to mere convenience. It has normally to
be presumed that the counsel conducting a case is
competent, particularly when counsel is appointed by
choice of a litigant. Taken to its logical end, the principle
that a retrial must follow on every change of counsel can
have serious consequences on the conduct of trials and
the criminal justice system. The witnesses cannot be
expected to face the hardship of appearing in court
repeatedly, particularly in sensitive cases such as the
present one. It can result in undue hardship for the
victims, especially in cases of heinous crimes, if they are
required to repeatedly appear in court to face crossexamination.”
7.
A similar view was taken by the Allahabad High Court
in Girish v. State of U.P., 2020 SCC OnLine All 1063, wherein it was
observed:
6. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case,
arguments advanced, and after going through the entire
judgment, this court is of the view that the arguments
advanced by the counsel are not sustainable and that the
plea cannot be taken by the revisionist's counsel that he
has been subsequently engaged; therefore, one more
opportunity may be given to him. It is within the rights of
the litigant to engage any counsel at any stage, but the
engagement of the new counsel and the dawn of fresh
wisdom upon the first informant cannot be allowed to
further delay the matter. The circumstances under which
the application was rejected are sufficiently shown in the
impugned order. The impugned order does not reflect any
element of inconsistency or any abuse of the court's
2026:HHC:3582
process, which may persuade this Court to interfere in the
same.”
8.
Madhya
Pradesh
High
Court
also
held
in
Veerendradas Bairagi v. Shreekant Bairagi, 2019 SCC OnLine MP
7006: ILR 2019 MP 1318 that a witness cannot be recalled on the
change of counsel. It was observed at page 1331:
“9. In the present case, it appears from the application
filed under section 311, Cr.P.C., that a request for reexamination has been made solely on the ground that
Senior Counsel has been engaged in place of a Junior
Counsel, as the Junior Counsel, according to the
petitioner, has not conducted the cross-examination of
witnesses in an effective manner. However, in the light of
the legal position, as discussed above, it is certainly not
within the scope of section 311 Cr.P.C. to countenance
such a prayer. No illegality or perversity has been
committed by the trial Court in passing the impugned
order.”
9.
Delhi High Court also took a similar view in Sushil
Ansal v. State (NCT of Delhi), 2021 SCC OnLine Del 4388 and
observed:
16. Thus, the consistent view of this Court is that a mere
change of counsel would not suffice to recall the witness
to put certain suggestions in the manner the new counsel
desires. The petitioner had engaged earlier counsel of his
choice. He made a decision not to cross-examine, not one
but 18 witnesses, probably, because the petitioner is
facing a charge of conspiracy only, and hence such a
decision, viz, not to cross-examine 18 witnesses, cannot
be said to be an inadvertent act but may be a part of his
strategy. Since a considerable delay has taken place, the
2026:HHC:3582
plight of the victim can also not be ignored. 12. Karnataka
High Court also held in Steel Rocks Inc. v. Bangalore
Elevated Tollway (P) Ltd., 2024 SCC OnLine Kar 27021
that a change of counsel does not entitle a party to recall a
witness. It was observed: “12. On a coalescence of the law
elucidated by the Apex Court, what would unmistakably
emerge is that it is not a matter of course that an
application under Section 311 of the Cr. P.C. should be
permitted. Mere change of counsel cannot be a ground to
recall the witness. The application must contain details as
to why the witness is required to be recalled. Recalling of
witnesses should not be permitted at the fag end of the
trial. These are the broad principles laid down by the Apex
Court
in
the
aforesaid
judgments.
Therefore,
consideration of the application under Section 311 of the
Cr. P.C. can be only on a case to case basis, depending
upon the failure of justice that would emerge, if the
witness is not recalled. I fail to see any of the postulates
enunciated by the Apex Court being present in the case at
hand. It is not the case that PW-1 was not crossexamined or further cross-examined. It has been done
extensively. It is not the case that the application was
filed at an earlier point in time. When the case was posted
for its judgment, the subject application was filed by the
petitioners. The reason projected by the learned counsel
for petitioners before this Court is that the earlier counsel
had fumbled, and the change of counsel has led to the
filing of the application. The Apex Court has held that a
change of counsel will not be a ground to allow the
application under Section 311 of the Cr. P.C.”
10.
Thus, the reason assigned during the hearing for
recalling the witnesses and producing the document is not
legally sustainable.
2026:HHC:3582
11.
The jurisdiction vested with this Court under Section
528 of BNSS is extraordinary and is to be exercised sparingly.
The present case does not make out any justification for
exercising the jurisdiction vested in the Court under Section 528
of the Cr.P.C. Consequently, the present petition fails and it is
dismissed.
12.
The observation made herein before shall remain
confined to the disposal of the petition and will have no bearing,
whatsoever, on the merits of the case.
23rd February, 2026.
(Nikita)
(Rakesh Kainthla)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review