Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 16.12.2025
Pronounced on: 07.01.2026
+
W.P.(C) 9147/2018
ASHOK KUMAR
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr.M. Bhardwaj, Ms.Priyanka
M.
Bhardwaj,
Mr.Praveen
Kumar Kaushik, Advs.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF POLICE AND ORS. .....Respondents
Through: Mr.Syed Abdul Haseeb, CGSC
with Mr.Tanveer Zaki and
Mr.Amir Kha, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE NAVIN CHAWLA
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MADHU JAIN
JUDGMENT
NAVIN CHAWLA, J.
1.
This petition has been filed, challenging the Order dated
19.12.2017 passed by the learned Central Administrative Tribunal,
Principal Bench, New Delhi (hereinafter referred to as, the ‘Tribunal’)
in O.A. No. 4265/2014, titled Ashok Kumar (Ex-Constable) v.
Commissioner of Police & Ors., whereby the said O.A. filed by the
petitioner herein was dismissed.
FACTS OF THE CASE:
2.
To give a brief background of the facts in which the present
petition arises, the petitioner faced a criminal prosecution in FIR
No.146/1994, registered at Police Station Mehrauli, New Delhi, under
Sections 307 and 324 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code,
Digitally Signed
WP(C) 9147/2018
By:REYMON VASHIST
18:17:52
1860 (in short, ‘IPC’), in relation to an incident which took place on
11.06.1994.
3.
On the registration of the above FIR, the petitioner was placed
under suspension vide order dated 15.06.1994, and was later reinstated
in service vide order dated 25.03.1996.
4.
He was convicted in the said criminal case by an order dated
16.02.2006 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, New
Delhi. He was sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for seven
years and to pay a fine of Rs.1000/- for commission of the offence
punishable under Section 307 of the IPC, and in default of payment of
fine, to undergo simple imprisonment for two months. He was further
sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for five years and to pay
a fine of Rs.1,000/- for the commission of the offence under Section
326 of the IPC, and in default of payment of fine, to undergo simple
imprisonment for two months.
5.
Aggrieved by the said conviction order, the petitioner filed an
appeal, being Criminal Appeal No. 123/2006, against his conviction
and sentence.
6.
Upon his conviction, a departmental inquiry was initiated
against him vide order dated 01.08.2009, under the provision of the
Delhi Police (Punishment and Appeal) Rules, 1980 (in short, ‘Delhi
Police Rules’) on the allegation that while posted at Police Station
Naraina, he was convicted in a criminal case and was sentenced to
undergo imprisonment, and he had thus failed to maintain his conduct
and integrity as a member of a disciplined Force like Delhi Police.
Digitally Signed
WP(C) 9147/2018
By:REYMON VASHIST
18:17:52
7.
The Enquiry Officer found the petitioner guilty of the charges,
and by an order dated 01.10.2013, the petitioner was visited with the
punishment of forfeiture of four years of approved service
permanently, entailing proportionate reduction in his pay. This
punishment was subject to the decision of the Appellate Court in the
appeal filed by him against the conviction order in the aforementioned
criminal case. Further, the period of suspension of the petitioner, that
is from 15.06.1994 to 24.03.1996, was also directed to be treated as
period not spent on duty for all intents and purposes and which may
not be regularized in any manner.
8.
In the appeal filed by the petitioner against his conviction and
sentence, being Criminal Appeal No.123/2006, this Court, by its
Order dated 05.03.2014, while maintaining the conviction of the
petitioner under Section 326 of the IPC, reduced the sentenced by
observing as under:
“22. The nominal roll of the appellant shows
that he has suffered incarceration of 7 months.
Keeping in view the fact that the offence
relates to the year 1994 i.e. almost two
decades old, the appellant having no other
criminal background; having suffered agony
of trial for almost 20 years and the appellant
also not having abused the process of bail
since his release; his conduct in jail also being
satisfactory during the period when he was
incarcerated, it would be in the fitness of the
things to modify the sentence. Accordingly
while sustaining the conviction of the
appellant under Section 326 of the IPC, he is
sentenced to undergo RI for a period of 1 year.
The fine of Rs.1000/- imposed under Section
326 of the IPC by the Sessions Judge shall
remain unaltered. Bail bonds of the appellant
Digitally Signed
WP(C) 9147/2018
By:REYMON VASHIST
18:17:52
are cancelled. Surety discharged. The
appellant be taken into custody to serve his
remaining sentence.”
9.
Therefore, the sentence of the petitioner for conviction under
Section 326 of the IPC was reduced from seven years to one year and
his conviction under Section 307 of the IPC was set aside.
10.
In spite of the above relief being granted to the petitioner in his
Criminal Appeal, the Disciplinary Authority, by invoking Rule 11(1)
of the Delhi Police Rules, vide order dated 03.04.2014, directed
removal of the petitioner from service with effect from the date of his
conviction, that is, 05.03.2014. The appeal filed by the petitioner
against this order of the Disciplinary Authority was also dismissed by
the Appellate Authority vide an order dated 26.08.2014, on the ground
that the appeal was barred by limitation.
11.
Aggrieved by the said orders of the Disciplinary and Appellate
Authority, the petitioner filed the above O.A. before the learned
Tribunal.
12.
The learned Tribunal dismissed the said O.A. filed by the
petitioner, by observing a under:
“6. In the instant case, as already noted, the
applicant had preferred Criminal Appeal
before the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi
against the judgment of conviction and order
of sentence passed by the learned Additional
Sessions Judge. In view of the provisions
contained in Rule 11(1) of the Delhi Police
(Punishment & Appeal) Rules, 1980, an order
either removing or dismissing the applicant
from service consequent to the judgment of
conviction and sentence passed by the learned
Additional Sessions Judge could not have been
Digitally Signed
WP(C) 9147/2018
By:REYMON VASHIST
18:17:52
passed under Rule 11(1) of the Delhi Police
(Punishment & Appeal) Rules, 1980, till such
time the result of the Criminal Appeal filed by
the applicant was known to the Disciplinary
Authority. But considering the nature and
gravity of the offence, the Disciplinary
Authority decided to take departmental action
by initiating regular departmental proceedings
against the applicant under Rule 11(3) of the
Delhi Police (Punishment & Appeal) Rules,
1980 and imposed upon applicant the
punishment of "forfeiture of four years of
approved service permanently" during
pendency of the Criminal Appeal filed by the
applicant before the Hon'ble High Court.
When the conviction of the applicant under
Section 326 IPC was upheld by the Hon'ble
High Court of Delhi in the Criminal Appeal
filed by the applicant, the Disciplinary
Authority again considered the nature and
gravity of the offence and passed the impugned
order of removal from service with effect from
5.3.2014, i.e., the date of judgment passed by
the Hon'ble High Court, by invoking the
provisions of Rule 11(1) of the Delhi Police
(Punishment & Appeal) Rules, 1980. No rule
has been brought to our notice by Shri
M.K.Bhardwaj, the learned counsel appearing
for the applicant, which debars the
Disciplinary Authority from exercising the
power under Rule 11(1) of the Delhi Police
(Punishment & Appeal) Rules, 1980, in view of
its having either exercised the power under
Rule 11(3) of the Delhi Police (Punishment &
Appeal) Rules, 1980 while initiating regular
departmental action and imposing upon a
convicted police officer the punishment during
pendency of the Criminal Appeal filed by
him/her. In the above view of the matter, we
find no substance in any of the contentions of
Shri M.K.Bhardwaj, the learned counsel
appearing for the applicant.”
13.
Challenging the same, the petitioner filed the present petition.
Digitally Signed
WP(C) 9147/2018
By:REYMON VASHIST
18:17:52
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER:
14.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner
had already been punished departmentally vide the order dated
01.10.2013 passed by the Disciplinary Authority, on the basis of his
conviction by the learned Trial Court. Therefore, only on the ground
of reduction of his sentence and exoneration from one of the offences
in the criminal appeal, the Disciplinary Authority could not revisit the
punishment under Rule 11(1) of the Delhi Police Rules. He contends
that imposing penalty twice, on the same incident, amounts to double
jeopardy.
15.
He submits that though the order dated 01.10.2013 had been
passed subject to the outcome of the Criminal Appeal filed by the
petitioner, the same can only mean that in case the conviction of the
petitioner had been set aside in the Criminal Appeal, the punishment
awarded to him would also need to be recalled by the Department. It
could never mean that even though the sentence of the petitioner is
reduced, the petitioner could be visited with an enhanced punishment
in the departmental proceedings.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENTS:
16.
On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondents
submits that the order of the Disciplinary Authority dated 01.10.2013,
imposing the original punishment on the petitioner, was subject to the
outcome of the appeal. Once the conviction under Section 326 of the
IPC had been confirmed by the High Court in appeal, the respondents
were within their rights, under Rule 11(1) of the Delhi Police Rules, to
Digitally Signed
WP(C) 9147/2018
By:REYMON VASHIST
18:17:52
initiate departmental inquiry against the petitioner and dismiss him
from service.
17.
He submits that the principle of double jeopardy has no
application in the facts of the present case. In support, he places
reliance on the judgment of this Court in Tariq Ali Khan v. Govt. of
NCT of Delhi & Ors., 2017:DHC:968-DB.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS
18.
We have considered the submissions made by the learned
counsels for the parties.
19.
It is not disputed that the first enquiry proceeding against the
petitioner was also on the basis of his conviction in the above criminal
case. Having considered the conviction and sentence imposed on the
petitioner in the criminal trial, where the petitioner had been found
guilty of the offences under Sections 307 and 326 of the IPC, the
Disciplinary Authority imposed the punishment of forfeiture of four
years of approved service permanently, entailing proportionate
reduction in his pay. Though the said order was made subject to the
outcome of the Criminal Appeal, which was then pending against the
conviction and sentence of the petitioner, it could only mean that in
case the petitioner succeeds in the appeal, the punishment imposed on
the petitioner would be revisited. It could also mean that in case the
High Court found the petitioner guilty of an even more severe offence
or enhanced the sentence of the petitioner, the Department may revisit
the punishment awarded to him in the departmental proceedings.
However, it can never mean that though the petitioner partially
Digitally Signed
WP(C) 9147/2018
By:REYMON VASHIST
18:17:52
succeeds in his criminal appeal, by having his sentence under Section
307 of the IPC set aside and his sentence under Section 326 of the IPC
reduced from five years to one year, the Department can still enhance
his punishment in the departmental proceedings and now dismiss him
from service.
20.
Rule 11(1) of the Delhi Police Rules, which was relied upon for
the impugned action by the respondents for enhancing the petitioner’s
punishment, reads as under:
“11. Punishment on judicial conviction(1)When a report is received from an official
source, e.g., a court or the prosecution agency,
that a subordinate rank has been convicted in
a criminal court of an offence, involving moral
turpitude or on charge of disorderly conduct
in a state of drunkenness or in any criminal
case, the disciplinary authority shall consider
the nature and gravity of the offence and if in
its opinion that the offence is such as would
render further retention of the convicted police
officer in service, prima facie, undesirable, it
may forthwith make an order dismissing or
removing him from service without calling
upon him to show cause against the proposed
action provided that no such order shall be
passed till such time the result of the first
appeal that may have been filed by such police
officer is known.
(2) If such police officer is acquitted on second
appeal or revision, he shall be reinstated in
service from the date of dismissal or removal
and may be proceeded against departmentally.
(3) In cases where the dismissal or removal
from service of the convicted police officer is
not considered necessary, the disciplinary
authority may examine the judgment and take
such departmental action as it may deem
proper.
(4) When a police officer is convicted judiciary
Digitally Signed
WP(C) 9147/2018
By:REYMON VASHIST
18:17:52
and consequently dismissed or removed from
service, and it is desired to ensure that the
officer dismissed or removed shall not be reemployed elsewhere, a full descriptive roll
with particulars of punishments, shall be sent
for publication in the Delhi Police Gazette.”
21.
The above Rule provides that where an officer of a subordinate
rank has been convicted in a criminal court for an offence involving
moral turpitude, or on a charge of disorderly conduct in a state of
drunkenness, or in any criminal case, the disciplinary authority shall
consider “the nature and gravity of the offence and if in its opinion
that the offence is such as would render further retention of the
convicted police officer in service, prima facie, undesirable”, it may
forthwith make an order dismissing or removing him from service.
Sub-Rule 3 of Rule 11 further provides that in cases where the
dismissal or removal from service of the convicted police officer is
not considered necessary, the disciplinary authority may examine the
judgment and take such departmental action as it may deem proper.
Therefore, on conviction of a police officer, it is the discretion of the
Disciplinary Authority, on consideration of the facts of the case, to
visit such officer with either dismissal or removal from service or take
such departmental action against such officer as it may deem
appropriate.
22.
In the present case, upon conviction of the petitioner under
Sections 307 and 326 of the IPC, the Disciplinary Authority exercised
such discretion and visited the petitioner with the penalty of forfeiture
of four years of approved service permanently, entailing proportionate
Digitally Signed
WP(C) 9147/2018
By:REYMON VASHIST
18:17:52
reduction in his pay. For the same conviction, the Disciplinary
Authority could not revisit its decision only because, in the appeal, the
conviction of the petitioner under Section 307 of the IPC was not
sustained while his conviction under Section 326 of the IPC was
sustained by the High Court. If anything, the nature and gravity of the
case against the petitioner was diluted and not aggravated by the
decision in the appeal and the sentence of the petitioner had been
reduced. Rule 11 of the Delhi Police Rules does not allow the reopening of the case in such a case where the earlier punishment was
also on the basis of the conviction of the delinquent employee.
23.
For the reasons stated hereinabove, we are unable to sustain the
order of the learned Tribunal and also the order dated 03.04.2014 of
the Disciplinary Authority visiting the petitioner with the penalty of
removal from service; and the order of the Appellate Authority dated
26.08.2014 dismissing his departmental appeal. The said orders are
accordingly set aside.
24.
The petitioner shall be entitled to reinstatement in service and
all the consequential benefits, which must be released to him within a
period of eight weeks from today.
25.
The petition is allowed in the above terms. There shall be no
order as to costs.
NAVIN CHAWLA, J.
MADHU JAIN, J
JANUARY 7, 2026/Arya/Yg
Digitally Signed
WP(C) 9147/2018
By:REYMON VASHIST
18:17:52
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review