Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:UHC:2765
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
Writ Petition Misc. Single No.2835 of 2025
09th April, 2026
Ashish Tiwari
………….Petitioner
Versus
Government of Uttarakhand
and others
………….Respondents
---------------------------------------------------------------------Presence:Mr. Pankaj Tangwan, learned counsel for the petitioner.
Mr. N.S. Pundir, learned D.A.G. for the State.
---------------------------------------------------------------------Hon'ble Pankaj Purohit, J.
This writ petition has been filed under Article
226 of the Constitution of India by the petitioner seeking
issuance of appropriate writ, order or direction, primarily in
the nature of mandamus, commanding the respondents to
allot three rooms in newly constructed Building No.Q2/A
situated at Shri Kedarpuri, District Rudraprayag, in terms
of the agreement/affidavit dated 02.02.2023, and further
restraining the respondents from allotting the said rooms to
any third party. The grievance of the petitioner essentially
pertains to alleged non-compliance of the terms of the
rehabilitation
scheme
and
the
agreement
executed
pursuant thereto.
2.
Facts of the case in brief are that the petitioner
is a permanent resident of Village Luheda (Fegu), Tehsil
Basu Kedar, District Rudraprayag, and belongs to a family
traditionally engaged as Tirth Purohits at Shri Kedarnath.
It is stated that prior to the natural calamity of the year
2013, the petitioner’s family owned and possessed a
house/dharamshala
at
Shri
Kedarpuri,
which
was
damaged/demolished in the said calamity. Subsequent to
the disaster, the State Government initiated rehabilitation
2026:UHC:2765
and reconstruction scheme for affected persons in Shri
Kedarpuri area, pursuant to Government Orders dated
06.04.2015, 19.02.2018 and 22.01.2020. Under the said
scheme, provision was made for reconstruction of buildings
and allotment of constructed units to affected persons,
subject to execution of agreements/affidavits between the
affected
persons
pursuance
and
thereof,
agreement/affidavit
respondents,
the
the
competent
authority.
In
petitioner
executed
an
with
the
handed
over
dated
whereby
02.02.2023
the
petitioner
possession of his existing structure to the authorities for
the purposes of reconstruction under the master plan. As
per the said agreement, the petitioner claims entitlement to
allotment of three rooms in the newly constructed Building
No.Q2/A . It is the case on record that Building No.Q2/A
has since been constructed by the respondents and
comprises multiple rooms. It is also on record that certain
public
notices/advertisements
were
issued
by
the
authorities, including a notice dated 18.12.2024 inviting
objections, followed by a final allotment notification dated
31.01.2025 indicating allotment of rooms to various
beneficiaries,
including
the
petitioner.
The
petitioner
asserts that despite repeated approaches and submission
of a representation dated 22.08.2025, possession of three
rooms has not been effectively handed over to him. On the
other hand, the respondents, in their counter affidavit,
have stated that allotment has been made in accordance
with applicable Government Orders and the petitioner has
already been allotted rooms as per the final notification,
while also referring to administrative constraints and policy
considerations governing the allotment process.
3.
Learned
counsel
for
the
petitioner
has
vehemently contended that the action of the respondents in
not allotting and handing over possession of three rooms to
2026:UHC:2765
the petitioner in Building No.Q2/A is wholly arbitrary,
illegal and in clear breach of the agreement/affidavit dated
02.02.2023 executed between the parties. It is submitted
that the petitioner had, in compliance of the rehabilitation
scheme,
voluntarily
handed
over
possession
of
his
constructed premises to the respondents with a legitimate
expectation and assurance that in lieu thereof he would be
allotted three rooms in the newly constructed building.
4.
It is further argued by the learned counsel for
the petitioner that the respondents, having accepted the
petitioner’s property and acted upon the agreement, are
estopped from denying the corresponding obligation of
allotment, and their present conduct is hit by the principle
of promissory estoppel. Learned counsel further submits
that the building in-question has already been constructed
and comprises twelve rooms, out of which the petitioner is
entitled to three rooms, yet the respondents are deliberately
withholding the same and are instead attempting to allot
the rooms to other persons. It is also contended that even
in
the
public
advertisement
dated
18.12.2024
and
subsequent records, the name of the petitioner has been
reflected and his entitlement to three rooms in Building
No.Q2/A
has
been
acknowledged,
which
clearly
demonstrates that the respondents themselves recognize
the petitioner’s right. Despite such acknowledgment, no
effective possession has been delivered to the petitioner.
5.
Learned
counsel
for
the
petitioner
further
submits that the petitioner made repeated requests and
approached the respondents on several occasions, and even
submitted a detailed representation dated 22.08.2025, but
the same has not been considered, thereby violating
principles of fairness and natural justice. It is argued that
the
respondents
are
now
attempting
to
defeat
the
2026:UHC:2765
petitioner’s rightful claim by allotting all the rooms in the
building to other persons, which is not only contrary to the
agreement
but
also
defeats
the
very
object
of
the
rehabilitation scheme. On these grounds, it is argued by
the learned counsel that this Court may exercise its
extraordinary jurisdiction and issue a writ of mandamus
directing the respondents to allot and hand over possession
of three rooms to the petitioner in Building No.Q2/A and
restrain them from allotting the same to any third party.
6.
Learned counsel appearing for the respondents
has opposed the writ petition and submitted that the same
is misconceived and devoid of merit. It is contended that
the
rehabilitation
and
reconstruction
work
in
Shri
Kedarpuri has been undertaken strictly in accordance with
Government Orders dated 06.04.2015, 19.02.2018 and
22.01.2020, and the allotment of rooms has been carried
out in a transparent manner through a duly notified
procedure. It is submitted that as per the scheme,
agreements/affidavits were executed with affected persons,
including
the
petitioner,
and
the
construction
and
allotment of rooms have been done in accordance with the
approved master plan. Learned counsel points out that
Building No.Q2/A consists of a total of twelve rooms,
constructed as per standardized design and specifications
approved at the highest level, and no deviation or
partitioning is permissible.
7.
It is further argued by the learned counsel for
the respondents that a provisional allotment notice dated
18.12.2024
was
issued
inviting
objections
from
all
stakeholders, followed by a final allotment notification
dated
31.01.2025
after
considering
objections
and
conducting hearings. In the said final notification, three
rooms have already been allotted to the petitioner, and thus
2026:UHC:2765
the grievance raised in the writ petition is factually
incorrect.
8.
Learned counsel for the respondents submits
that due to structural and planning constraints, it was not
feasible to allocate rooms strictly in the manner claimed by
the petitioner, and therefore, a uniform policy was adopted
for all similarly situated persons. It is also contended that
where there is any shortfall or adjustment required, the
same is to be addressed through mutual consent or future
allotment in adjoining constructions, as per the scheme. It
is further submitted that the petitioner did not raise any
objection within the stipulated time provided in the public
notice process and has approached this Court belatedly.
Moreover,
the
petitioner
has
already
been
granted
commercial compensation as per applicable Government
policy, and therefore, no prejudice has been caused to him.
Learned counsel thus contends that no enforceable legal
right of the petitioner has been violated and the present
dispute, if any, involves questions of fact and contractual
obligations, which are not amenable to writ jurisdiction. It
is accordingly prayed that the writ petition be dismissed.
9.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and
perused the material brought on record, this Court finds
that the controversy in the present writ petition lies in a
narrow compass. At the outset, it is not in dispute that the
petitioner was an affected person under the rehabilitation
scheme formulated by the State Government pursuant to
the disaster of 2013, and that an agreement/affidavit dated
02.02.2023 was executed between the petitioner and the
competent authority. It is also not in dispute that under the
said Scheme and the agreement executed pursuant thereto,
the petitioner is entitled to allotment of three rooms in lieu
of the structure handed over by him for reconstruction
2026:UHC:2765
purposes. However, the principal grievance raised by the
petitioner is not merely regarding entitlement, but pertains
to the manner of its implementation, namely, non-delivery
of possession of three rooms in Building No.Q2/A and the
alleged attempt of the respondents to allot the same to
third parties. From the material on record, it transpires
that a detailed procedure for allotment was undertaken by
the respondents, which included issuance of a public
notice
dated 18.12.2024 inviting objections
from all
stakeholders, followed by consideration of such objections
and issuance of a final allotment notification dated
31.01.2025. The name of the petitioner admittedly finds
place in the said final notification and three rooms stand
allotted to him as per the record.
10.
In such circumstances, the dispute essentially
narrows down to whether the petitioner has been given
effective possession of the allotted rooms and whether he
can insist upon allotment in a particular building or in a
particular manner. This Court is of the considered view
that the issues raised by the petitioner involve disputed
questions of fact, particularly with regard to actual
possession, feasibility of allotment in a specific structure,
and implementation of the rehabilitation scheme on the
ground.
These
are
matters
which
require
factual
adjudication and verification, and cannot be satisfactorily
determined in exercise of writ jurisdiction under Article 226
of the Constitution of India. It is well settled that while the
writ court can intervene where there is arbitrariness,
illegality or violation of statutory duty, it ordinarily does not
enter into the arena of enforcing contractual obligations or
supervising the minute implementation of policy decisions,
especially where such implementation involves technical
and administrative considerations. In the present case, the
allotment process has been undertaken pursuant to
2026:UHC:2765
Government Orders and a uniform policy applicable to all
similarly situated persons. The petitioner has not been able
to demonstrate that the said process is vitiated by mala
fides
or
arbitrariness.
Moreover,
the
fact
that
the
petitioner’s name has been included in the final allotment
list and that three rooms stand allotted to him, militates
against the contention of complete denial of his rights.
11.
So far as the insistence of the petitioner for
allotment of specific rooms in Building No.Q2/A is
concerned, this Court is of the view that such a claim
cannot be enforced as a matter of right in writ jurisdiction.
The rehabilitation scheme is a policy-based exercise
involving multiple stakeholders, and the authorities must
be left with reasonable discretion to implement the same in
a workable and equitable manner. At the same time, this
Court cannot lose sight of the fact that the entitlement of
the petitioner to three rooms is not in dispute. Once such
entitlement has been recognized by the respondents
themselves, it is expected of the authorities to ensure that
the same is given meaningful effect and is not rendered
illusory. In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court is
not inclined to exercise its extraordinary jurisdiction under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India to grant the reliefs
as prayed for by the petitioner.
12.
Accordingly the writ petition stands dismissed.
However, it is observed that since the entitlement of the
petitioner
to
allotment
of
three
rooms
under
the
rehabilitation scheme is not in dispute and stands reflected
in the final allotment notification dated 31.01.2025, the
respondents shall ensure that such entitlement is duly
honoured in accordance with the applicable policy and
Government Orders.
13.
2026:UHC:2765
It is further provided that in case the petitioner
has not been handed over effective possession of the
allotted
rooms,
the
competent
authority
shall
take
appropriate steps to ensure that either possession is
delivered or suitable equivalent accommodation, in terms of
the scheme, is made available to the petitioner within a
reasonable period from the date of production of a certified
copy of this order.
(Pankaj Purohit, J.)
09.04.2026
SK
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review