Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Crl.R.P..No.1775/2013
2025:KER:31367
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE G.GIRISH
FRIDAY, THE 11TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 21ST CHAITHRA, 1947
CRL.REV.PET NO. 1775 OF 2013
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 27.08.2013 IN C.MP.NO.2088/2013
IN SC NO.568 OF 2012 OF SESSIONS COURT, KOZHIKODE DIVISION
REVISION PETITIONER/PETITIONER/ACCUSED:
ASHARAF, S/O.KOYA, 55/11 PULAPARAMBIL HOUSE,
MEEMBALAKKUNNU COLONY, KOTTOOLI, KOZHIKODE DIST
BY ADVS.
ADV. K. PRAVEEN KUMAR
R. BINDU (SASTHAMANGALAM)
RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT/COMPLAINANT:
SUB INSPECTOR OF POLICE
MEDICAL COLLEGE POLICE STATION, KOZHIKODE DIST-673004
STATE OF KERALA REP BY PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
HIGH COURT OF KERALA, ERNAKULAM
KERALA STATE ELECTRICITY BOARD
REPRESENTED BY SUB ENGINEER, ELECTRICAL SECTION,
KOVOOR, KOZHIKODE IS IMPLEADED AS ADDL.3RD RESPONDENT
AS PER ORDER DATED 26.11.2014 IN CRL.M.A 7310/14 IN
CRL.R.P 1775/13.
BY ADV SHRI.B.PREMOD, SC,
KERALA STATE ELECTRICITY BOARD
THIS CRIMINAL REVISION PETITION HAVING BEEN FINALLY
HEARD ON 10.04.2025, THE COURT ON 11.04.2025 DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
Crl.R.P..No.1775/2013
2025:KER:31367
ORDER
The order dated 27.08.2013 of the Additional Sessions Court-I,
Kozhikode, in C.M.P.No.2088/2013 dismissing the discharge petition
filed by the accused in S.C.No.568/2012 on the files of the said court,
is under challenge in this revision. The petitioner herein is the accused
in the said case, who filed the discharge petition under Section 227 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (in short, ‘Cr.PC’) before the
learned Additional Sessions Judge. The prosecution in the said case is
for the commission of the offence of electricity theft envisaged under
Section 135 of the Electricity Act, 2003 (in short, ‘Act’).
2.
An inspection conducted by the KSEB officials at the
industrial establishment of the petitioner on 23.09.2005 is said to have
revealed theft of electricity. Accordingly, the Sub Engineer in charge
preferred a complaint before the local Sub Inspector of Police on
03.10.2005, on the basis of which the Police registered a crime as
Crime No.302/2005 of Medical College Police Station, Kozhikode. The
petitioner thereupon filed Crl.M.C.No.3980/2005 before this Court for
quashing the above First Information Report [FIR]. A learned Single
Judge of this Court disposed of the above Crl.M.C. along with W.P.(C)
Crl.R.P..No.1775/2013
2025:KER:31367
No.22972/2006 and 23 other Criminal Miscellaneous Cases by a
common judgment dated 10.11.2006.
The above said W.P.(C)
No.22972/2006 was for quashing the proceedings in C.C.No.183/2005
on the files of the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-I, Palakkad. In
the above writ petition, the learned Single Judge passed the order
holding that the cognizance taken by the learned Magistrate in the
case C.C.No.183/2005 on the files of the Judicial First Class Magistrate
Court-I, Palakkad, was without jurisdiction and accordingly, restrained
the learned Magistrate from proceeding with that case. It was further
directed in the above said writ petition that the KSEB or its authorised
officer may file a written complaint before the learned Magistrate in
the light of the materials in the report filed by the Police, and that in
the event of such written complaint being filed, the learned Magistrate
shall take cognizance of the offence and proceed with the case. It was
further observed in the judgment of the learned Single Judge, referred
above, that the above said directions will govern the Criminal
Miscellaneous Cases wherein cognizance of the offences has been
taken based on Police report.
In respect of the other Criminal
Miscellaneous Cases considered by the learned Single Judge, it was
observed that the contentions raised thereunder are kept open, and
Crl.R.P..No.1775/2013
2025:KER:31367
that the petitioners concerned can raise the same before the Trial
Court. Therefore, the contentions of the petitioner in the present case,
wherein the learned Magistrate had not taken cognizance, was left
open as per the aforesaid judgment of the learned Single Judge. In the
meanwhile, Section 151 of the Act was amended with effect from
15.06.2007 empowering the Court to take cognizance of an offence
punishable under the Act upon a report of a Police Officer filed under
Section 173 Cr.PC. Thereafter, in the year 2012, the Police filed a final
report in respect of the electricity theft involved in this case, which was
taken
on
to
files
by
the
Sessions
Court,
Kozhikode,
as
S.C.No.568/2012. The petitioner, thereupon, filed C.M.P.No.2088/2013
before the learned Additional Sessions Judge-I, Kozhikode, who was
considering the aforesaid Sessions Case, under Section 227 Cr.PC for
his discharge from the said proceedings stating the reason that the
Police was not empowered to investigate the case and to file final
report before the Sessions Court. It was contended by the petitioner
in the above discharge petition that the amendment brought out to
Section 151 of the Act, with effect from 15.06.2007, empowering the
Court to take cognizance of the offence under Section 135 of the Act
upon a Police Report under Section 173 Cr.PC, was having no
Crl.R.P..No.1775/2013
2025:KER:31367
retrospective applicability, and hence, the final report filed by the
Police in this case in respect of the incident said to have happened on
23.09.2005, was nonest in the eye of law.
The learned Additional
Sessions Judge dismissed the above discharge petition holding that as
per the notifications of the Government of Kerala in S.R.O.No.703/2005
& 229/2005, the Sub Engineers of KSEB were notified as empowered
officers to submit a complaint in respect of the electricity theft
conducted within the areas of their local jurisdiction. It was further
observed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge that since no
prejudice has been caused to the petitioner in connection with the
filing of the final report in the case, the prayer for discharge cannot be
entertained.
It
is
the
aforesaid
order
of
dismissal
of
C.M.P.No.2088/2013 by the Additional Sessions Court-I, Kozhikode,
which is under challenge in this revision petition.
3.
In the present petition, the petitioner would contend that
the registration of crime, the conduct of investigation by the Police and
the filing of the final report are invalid in the eye of law, since the
Police were not empowered to conduct the investigation relating to the
electricity theft under Section 135 of the Act. According to the
petitioner, the amendment brought out to Section 151 of the Act with
Crl.R.P..No.1775/2013
2025:KER:31367
effect from 15.06.2007 has no retrospective applicability, and hence,
the investigation done by the Police in respect of the incident
happened in this case on 23.09.2005, is nonest in the eye of law.
4.
Heard the learned counsel for the revision petitioner, the
learned Public Prosecutor representing the State of Kerala, and the
learned Standing Counsel for KSEB.
5.
The learned Standing Counsel for KSEB pointed out that
the contention of the petitioner that the amendment brought out to
Section 151 of the Act with effect from 15.06.2007 has no
retrospective applicability, is no longer sustainable in law, in view of
the dictum laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Vishal
Agarwal & Anr. v. Chhattisgarh State Electricity Board and
Anr. [2014(1) KHC 390]. As rightly argued by the learned Standing
Counsel for the KSEB, the Hon’ble Apex Court has made it clear in the
aforesaid decision that there is absolutely no fetter for the Police in
registering a crime, conducting investigation and filing final report in
respect of the electricity theft, as in the case of any other offences
covered by the general law of criminal jurisprudence, and that the
mere fact that some special provisions are provided under the Act for
filing complaint by the officers designated thereunder in respect of the
Crl.R.P..No.1775/2013
2025:KER:31367
offences under the Act, will not divest the powers of the Police to
conduct investigation and to file final report as in the case of any other
offences. Overruling the decisions rendered by various High Courts,
including the Kerala High Court, and upholding the view of the Delhi
High Court in Abhay Tyagi v. State NCT of Delhi and Anr.
[(2009) ILR 3 Delhi 610], and that of the Jharkhand High Court in
Ashish Kumar Jain v. State of Jharkhand [2010 KHC 7086], the
Hon’ble Apex Court held in paragraph No.23 of its judgment as
follows:“23. Thus, the clear principle which emerges from the aforesaid
discussion is that even when a Magistrate is to take cognizance
when a complaint is filed before it, that would not mean that no
other avenue is opened and the complaint/FIR cannot be lodged
with the police. It is stated at the cost of repetition that the offences
under the Electricity Act are also to be tried by applying the
procedure contained in the Code. Thus, it cannot be said that a
complete machinery is provided under the Electricity Act as to how
such offences are to be dealt with. In view thereof, we are of the
opinion that the respondent's Counsel is right in his submission that
if the offence under the Code is cognizable, provisions of Chapter
XII containing S.154 CrPC and onward would become applicable and
it would be the duty of the police to register the FIR and investigate
into the same. S.135 and S.138 only prescribe that certain acts
relating to theft of electricity etc. would also be offences. It also
enables certain persons / parties, as mentioned in S.151, to become
Crl.R.P..No.1775/2013
2025:KER:31367
complainant in such cases and file complaint before a Court in
writing. When such a complaint is filed, the Court would be
competent to take cognizance straightway. However, that would not
mean that other avenues for investigation into the offence which are
available would be excluded. It is more so when no such special
procedure for trying the offences under the Electricity Act is
formulated and the cases under this Act are also to be governed by
the Code of Criminal Procedure.”
6.
In the light of the law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court
in the above regard, the argument advanced by the learned counsel
for the petitioner that the Police was not empowered to file a final
report in respect of the offence involved in this case, is totally
unsustainable.
7.
The learned counsel for the petitioner argued that, since
this Court had already held in the judgment rendered on 10.11.2006 in
W.P.(C)No.22972/2006 and 23 other Criminal Miscellaneous Cases,
including Crl.M.C.No.3980/2005, that the FIR registered by the Police
in respect of the offence under Section 135 of the Act is invalid in the
eye of law, it has to be found that the subsequent decision of the
Hon’ble Apex Court in Vishal Agarwal & Anr. (supra), cannot
validate the above FIR which this Court had already found as invalid.
With regard to the above argument, it has to be held that this Court
Crl.R.P..No.1775/2013
2025:KER:31367
has not invalidated the FIR in this case as per the judgment rendered
on 10.11.2006 in the aforesaid WP(C) and 23 other Criminal
Miscellaneous Cases, including Crl.M.C.No.3980/2005. The aforesaid
judgment of this Court referred by the learned counsel for the
petitioner, has been reported in Paramasivam M. v. Union of India
& Ors [2007 KHC 5029]. As already stated in paragraph No.2
above, W.P(C)No.22972/2006 referred in the aforesaid decision was
filed challenging the proceedings in C.C.No.183/2005 on the files of
the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-I, Palakkad.
The decision
rendered in the above W.P.(C), contained in paragraph No.24 of the
aforesaid
judgment,
is
extracted
hereunder
for
the
sake
convenience and easy reference.
“24. In the result, the Writ Petition is disposed of with the
following directions/orders: (i) The cognizance of the offences in this
case taken by the learned Magistrate without a written complaint by
the K.S.E.B or its authorised officer is without jurisdiction and
therefore, void. So, the learned Magistrate is restrained from
proceeding with the case. (ii) The K.S.E.B or its authorised officer
may file a written complaint before the Magistrate, in the light of the
materials in the report filed by the police and also other materials, if
any, available with it, In that event, the learned Magistrate shall take
cognizance of the offences and proceed with the case. It will be open
to the Magistrate to proceed with the trial from the stage where it
was stopped. Unless prejudice is found to have been caused to the
of
Crl.R.P..No.1775/2013
2025:KER:31367
accused, de novo trial need not be conducted. (iii) The challenge
against R.11 and 12 of the Electricity Rules, 2005 is repelled. (iv)
Until Special Court is constituted for the area, the Judicial First Class
Magistrate I, Palakkad can proceed with the trial of CC No. 183/2005,
provided a complaint as mentioned in direction (ii) above is filed.
Crl. M. C. Nos. 79, 1104, 2029, 2073. 2074, 2083, 2908, 2910. 3621,
3623, 3660, 3852, 3855, 3952, 3980, 4041, 4063, 4324 &
4385/2005, 34, 116, 1500 & 1704/2006:”
8.
In paragraph No.25 of the said judgment, the learned
Single Judge of this Court had observed that Section 379 of the Indian
Penal Code, 1860, is not having any applicability in respect of the
offence of electricity theft, since the electricity cannot be classified as a
movable property. In paragraph Nos.26 & 27 of the said judgment,
the
learned
Single
Judge
had
dealt
with
the
facts
of
Crl.M.C.Nos.2910/2005 & 1500/2006 and had made the relevant
observations related to the said cases. In paragraph No.28 of the said
judgment, the learned Single Judge ordered that the directions in
paragraph No.24 of the said judgment will govern the Criminal
Miscellaneous Cases wherein cognizance of offence has been taken
based on the Police report. As regards the remaining cases, it has
been observed by the learned Single Judge in paragraph No.29 of the
Crl.R.P..No.1775/2013
2025:KER:31367
said judgment that the contentions are left open to be considered by
the Trial Court.
9.
It is pertinent to note that when the learned Single Judge
rendered the above judgment on 10.11.2006, no cognizance was taken
in respect of the crime involved in this case by the learned Magistrate,
since the case was only at the crime stage at that time. Therefore, the
directions in paragraph No.24 of the judgment rendered by this Court
on 10.11.2006 are having no applicability in the instant case, since it is
already made clear in paragraph No.28 of the same judgment that the
directions thereunder in paragraph No.24 has got applicability only in
respect of Criminal Miscellaneous Cases wherein cognizance of the
offences has been taken based on Police report. As already stated
above, going by the contents of paragraph No.29 of the said judgment
of the learned Single Judge, the contentions in all other Criminal
Miscellaneous Cases, including the present one, were left open to be
considered by the Trial Court. Therefore, the argument of the learned
counsel for the petitioner that the decision rendered by this Court in
Paramasivam M. v. Union of India & Ors (supra) has invalidated
the FIR registered in this case, and that the subsequent decision of the
Hon’ble Apex Court in Vishal Agarwal & Anr. (supra) cannot validate
Crl.R.P..No.1775/2013
2025:KER:31367
the above FIR, is totally baseless. It has to be stated that, at the time
when the Police filed final report in this case in the year 2012, the
contentions were remaining open as per the directions in paragraph
No.29 of the judgment dated 10.11.2006 of the learned Single Judge.
Thus, the decision rendered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Vishal
Agarwal & Anr. (supra) is squarely applicable in the facts and
circumstances of this case. Needless to say that the prosecution
launched against the petitioner, in the crime involved in this case, is
perfectly in order, and it cannot be said that the amendment made to
Section 151 of the Act empowering the Police to investigate the case
and file final report has no applicability to the incident involved in this
case since it was prior to the aforesaid amendment. Accordingly, I find
no merit in this Criminal Revision Petition filed by the petitioner
challenging the impugned order passed by the learned Additional
Sessions Judge-I, Kozhikode.
In the result, the petition stands dismissed.
(sd/-)
G. GIRISH, JUDGE
DST
Crl.R.P..No.1775/2013
2025:KER:31367
APPENDIX OF CRL.REV.PET 1775/2013
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
Document
Certified copy of judgment in Crl.M.C. No.
3980/2005
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review