Judgments
LegalFirms.in Judgments · legalfirms.in/judgments/ashabee-lalsab-daroji-and-ors-vs-the-state-of-karnataka-and-ors-20260204/ · Printed 19 Nov 2026
Constitutional

Ashabee Lalsab Daroji and Ors vs The State of Karnataka and Ors

Add to a compilation

Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans

Court
Karnataka High Court
Date
4 February 2026
Case No.
WP 202899/2024
Result
Dismissed
Bench
Pradeep Singh Yerur
Cite this judgment
Citation
Link for your website or blog
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.

Full Judgment Text

Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs, CC BY 4.0). The court's own copy is the authoritative text.

-1- ! # $ !" % ! & '$( ) & '$( *) & '$( * & '$( ' ' Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA ! " % # # && ! && " # " # ! $ " & # &% # # $ -2- # # "& ! " ! " # % ' $% # # %% # ! %%' &! ' " # ! ! " # # $ ! "%& # # " ## '% ! # " " # & ## # ! %" " # # ! " -3- # % # ' # # # # ! ' ' " # " # ! !% ! !& " # " & # & # # # # # # # ! $"' " # " # ' # # & # # ! " '" ! # "& ! " " -4- # ! $ # # $% # ! & ! " ! " % &! " % # # # % %% # # %" # ## # ! # "" # %& # "! # % ( "! # # # ! # % ## " " & "& -5- # %' ! ' " # # & # # %! %$ ) '" ## # # ! " ' % * # " # ! " ! & " # # # " ! " !"% # # ! !' " # " # ! $ "% # " "" # # ! " -6- # "& ! "% " ! " # % # % " # " # ! "$ ! ! " # " # ! ! ! $ % " # # ! "' # "! "$ # # # " # & ! ' " -7- "! # ! '' " & ## "$ # ! " !"" # ! " ! % &% " &" ! && # " # # ! " # & # ' ! " # & # # % # &' ! % " # % -8- ! " # &! ## % # &$ ! ! " ## ! " # % " # ! %& ! " # % " # ! %' ! "" " # " # % " ' # -9- ! " # # ! # " ' # # # ! # ! " ! " ! ' # ! # & ! " ! % " # " # ! ' # $ # - 10 - # " # ! ! ! $" " # % " ## % ! & # " & # # ! $ " ! " # % " # ! % ' ! " &! ' # - 11 - # % $ ! %% " # " # ! %"% ! % $ % ' # ! ' ! %& " # ! %" " # ( &" '% # &! ! # " % '" # # '& ! % ! # & " # - 12 - ' ! % ! " # " # ! % $ # ' # % ! %$% " # " # ! "% '' '! # # ! " $ # " '$ # # ! ! &% " ## # "% # ! # ! && # % " # - 13 - !% # # "! # ! &'' " !" # ' ! ! # " !& # '% ! $ " # # ## ! & " ! " ! $ " # ! # & # ! # # !' & # !! # && - 14 - ! "! " # " # ! !! !$ ! $ # # && ! " ! & " # $ % # $% # # & ! % # " $" # "% ! $ " ! %' " # $& # # &! # $ # &! - 15 - " # ! &' ! ! " # $ # $' # # " # ! $ ! !& " # $! % # $$ # & # # # ! $ # " # # ! # " ' # ## # # % # ! '% " - 16 - % # " ! '%% " # " # ! '% # # # & # % # # ! '& " # # # ! " ! '!$ " ' # "% # # ' # ! # # ! !"' " ! # " # ! !&% " - 17 - $ ( # # ! !! " # # $ # # ! !$' # " # # # # % ! $ " " # # & # " ! $ ! " # " # ! $ $ # ' # & # ' # ! # " $ # & # ! " - 18 - # $ % # '% # # ! $ " " ' # # ! " # $ ! $ ' " # ! $ $ " # ! & # $ % # % ## % # # % # ! $%& " # # ! $% " $ # # %% # # # - 19 - ! $%$ " # " # ! $" %" &! # %& # # & # ! " ! $&& " # ! $&' " # ! $ ! " # % # % # % # %' # # # %! # & # # %$ ! !$ # & " # # $&" - 20 - # " ! $!% " ! $$ " # & # # " # # # $ ! " ! " # "% # # % "" # ! ! " # "& # # % ! # " % " ! # " " ' # # - 21 - ! % " ## # # "' % ! " %& # "! # ## &! ! " "& # "$ # &! ! " "' # & # # % ! & # & " # ! " &" # &% # &$ # &" # ! " &' # - 22 - ! # " &! && ! " ! " ! " # & # &! # & # % # # &' # $ ! " # $ # ! " '& &! & &$ # # &% # ! ' " - 23 - &! ! " # # ! # % " % # # # ! % " " # & # ! # & # " " # # % # ! & " ! " " # # "! # ! " &'" - 24 - ' # # &' ! & # ! " # # # &$ ! " &% # $ # # # ! & " ! " # # # % # # ! # % # " ' # # ! " # # $ " # # ! " - 25 - # & '& # & ! # " & # " ! " # ! " "' # ' # # ! " &% # ! ! " # $ ## ! # # ' ( & ! " '% - 26 - # ! " '& " # ! ' ( # ' %% '% & # '" ! " '' ## %! '& # ! ! " # ! " !' # ! " $$ # ! ' ! # ' # &! # '' ! " ' ! # # & - 27 - # ! " '%% # ! " ' ' # ! '" # ! " ' ' '! &! '$ # ! " ## %! ! # # "& # ! " ' & # ! " ' ' !% # # %! !" # # ' # # !& ! ' ( " # - 28 - % # # ! '' " # ! " '$& # ! " '$$ ! " ! "% !' # # % # !! # ! ' " # %! # # !$ ! " ! % ( # &' # # $ # ! " ! " # "& # # ! " ! & # - 29 - $ # " # # ! ! # $% " # # ! " !%& # $" # # % ! !% # $& " # # # ! !& " # ! " !&! $ % $ # ' ! # " ! $' # & # ! " !'% - 30 - $! # # ! " !'! # $$ ## # # & # ! $"$ " % # # % ! " !!' # % # # # " ! $ # % % # # " ( # # ! # " !" % " # # & # ! # " ' + ) ## * # - 31 - , # # # # # , # # % , # " ! # , ! % $ & # # ,, , # # # ! # # # ! , + ) # # % )%* # % " # # ) , # , # , # * , $ $ # # " % " # # , , # # # ## ( # # # # # &* # %% , # % - , # # # %&" # %&" ## ( , * # # , # , # # - 32 - # # # # , # * # # , # # # # # # # # , % %$ # # * # # # # # % %& # , , # , # % )%*) # * # # # # # # # & , # # # # # , , # # ) ' # & , # , ! # %! % &$ # , , # ! %!" " " " , # , # ! " " " & %! # , , ! " " # - 33 - # " & # "& # , , # ! " $ " ## # # & , # , ! # " " ' &! # , , ! # " " ! ! # , , # $ ! "!" # " # , # , # ! "$% " # % # , , # ! "$' " # & # , , - 34 - # % " # &$ # # , , # " ! & ! ! &" " # # ' # , , # ! &" " & . $ # , , # ! &" " # %$ # , , # ! %% " & , # , # ! & " ' ! # , , # ! % " - 35 - ! # '% # , , # $ # ! ! " # # & # , , ! " # % # # "! # , , ! " # % # # # & , # , # ! $ " %% # # & # # , , # ! " %%& %" "& # , , # ! " "&% - 36 - %& " , # , # ! " " " % "! # , , # ! " " & % # &% # , , # ! "' " %' , # , # ! &%% " %! & , # , # %$ ! &% " # # & # , # , - 37 - ! &' # " " # # " , # , ! %! # " " # # & # , , ! " # "% # # $ # , , ! " %& # "" %! # , , ! " # " "& "' # , , ! " # " # "$ # , , - 38 - # ! '%" " " # " # # , , ! '" # " "' &$ # , , # ! '& " "! , # , # "$ ! '& " ## # , # , # ! '&! " & # "! # , , # ! '$ " & # , # , - 39 - ! # &% # " ! # &! # , , ! # " $ &" # # & , # , ! $ ! # " && # " # # , , # ! &"" " & # . , & # , ! $" # " & ! # , , ! " # &' # % , # , - 40 - ! # " " &! , # , ! # &$ " $ ( # %$ # , , ! # " "! # " , # , ! # " && # ) # # * , # # # # , # # # % # " % , ! & # , - 41 - ! # # ,, # ! " , ( # , ,, , ! " # ) # # , / * # # %%' , , # # # # # # # # # # # # # ## ( %% , , # # # # * , # # # # # , # # # # # # # * # # % )%* ) # # # # # *)' # , # * # # # , # # # # , ## ( # , # # # , # # - 42 - ## & # , ! # " " $ % & , ! "$ # " " # # " , ! "& # " & # % , ! # " ' # ! , # ## ! ' ! " - 43 - &$ , ! # ' " ! # " # , # ! %" " ! " ! '! , # ! # ) # # * , # # # # , # # # % # " , ! & # , % - 44 - ! # # ,, ) ! * " , ( ,, ) ! * " # ) # # , / # , # # # # ## ( %% * # # %%' , , # # # # # # # # # # * , , # # # # # # , # , # # # # # # # # # * # % )%* ) # # , ## ( * ' # # # , # , # * # # # # # # # # # # # , , # - 45 - % # %! # %$ # " % &% " & & # & # " ( # " # % # & # ' ' &% # ! # & # $ ' # & ) # # * - 46 - # ! # & # $ ## &% # % ' # # && # '% # '" " &' & # ## # ## # % # !" # % # !& # # % # ' #) ! # & # * - 47 - # ! $ # # # $ $ # # % $& # # ## # # ' # % $! # ## ! # %% %" # # $ # % # & %& # ) # * &' # "" % ) & # " # * - 48 - % # ) # * &" # %' " # &$ # "$ %! ) # %$ * & # # # ' # &" # &' # &! " " # %! "% ## ) * ## ) * %& # "" # % # &$ - 49 - "& # "& # " & # &% # " && # "' # " # & # & "! &! # "$ # # & # % # ' & "% # &% # # ' - 50 - "& # '% # ' &" " && # # # &% # & '! # # # && # & '$ # # "% # ! &' # "& # ! &! # "! # !" &$ # & # !& # % # - 51 - # $ # "! # $' % # & # " # &% $$ # # # % & ) & # % % # % " # % & &! ' ## "' # ! & % & * - 52 - # % $ # # &" # % ' # # # " # %%% # # " # %%" % ) ' # %%& # %%! # %"! # %"" " %$ & "' # "$ # & # %"& * - 53 - ' # %" # %"$ ! # " # $ %& # # # %&' # # ) "" ' # # & # % " ' # &" # % & '% # # # & # % '" # # '& # " % $ # # % # * - 54 - ' # # ' # ' % " # # # % ' '' ) # %'" '! # '% '$ # %' # %'! # ' ! # # # # # %! # %!% # %!" ! &' !% &$ !" ## * - 55 - % # !& %!& # # # %! # %!! # %!$ # %$ ! ! " !' !! # $ # !$ %$% # '% # %$& $ # ' # $ ## ' %$& - 56 - $% # %$! # " ! # "" $" #) # * #) # * " # "%! $& " # $ "%$ ## "! # # "" # ""' # ""! $ "$ $' "$ $! # & # $$ &% "&% - 57 - # "&" # &" # "& # & # "&$ % # & # " % " # &' # & " " # # # &! # " ! # " &$ ) # ' " % # # " " * - 58 - ! # # # # " $ # % # " ' # " ! % ( # " # % # "' # # # "'& " # # "' ) & ( # "'$ # "!! # ! * - 59 - # # $ # "$ ' # $ # ! # "$ # # "$" # & & $ % % # " # & # & ' # & $ % & %% %" # # # # ' # %& # # & # # ## - 60 - ! # % # & ' # # ! # & ! # &% # &%" % $ %' " %! # ## &" %$ # &%! # &%$ # & " # ## &' # &" # &"% " "% # ## - 61 - # &"' "" # "& # &"$ # # # &&% # # ## % " # %! # # " # ## &&" # " "' # # &&& # # # & ' # & $ & "! &! # "$ & # & &'% # ## - 62 - # &!& & ## % # &! &% ) # &" &!! # & # # && ## &$ # # &! # &$' & # # &$! & # % # &$$ &' & # &! # # # * - 63 - &$ # # ! # % # # " # & # " # % # # "' # " ' # # ## %' # # & "" # ## %$ # "& # # ## " # # " # "" # # " # ' ## # " ! # # "' # "' # # # "! ## ## - 64 - $ &' # &" # &$ # && # # " # "' # &! # &$ % ' " $ & # # " # # &$ # " ' # # ! & # %$ # # $ ## - 65 - $ " # ' $ # ## "! # $% # $& # $ # $ ' & '% "& '" " '& # # " # ' # "' ## # ' $! # & # # "' # '' "! # '! "" # '$ # ' # - 66 - &% # ! # # # &% # # ' # ! # %" ! &" !% && # !" # & # " !& # & # " # "% # "" # " ! &' ! # &' !' &$ # !! &$ # !$ # "' # # - 67 - $ # "! # "$ # $ # " # # & $% # # $" # % # # $& ' # $ # $ # $ # # $' # $! # # " # $$ & ' - 68 - # ' # '" % & % # # ' # ' ## # % % % " # ' # % & ! # # ' # ( % ! # # ! # % !% # # $ # % ' ! # " % ! % $ # !' # !! ## "' # &" # # $ - 69 - % # ## & # $% # $ % % % # ' # % " # ' # # $ # ' % # ' " # ' & # ' ! % & % " % % % ' # # ! % ! # ' $ # ' # ' % # # "% % $ "& - 70 - %% # # # & %% # && %%% # ' # # # ' ! # ## &! # %%" '% # % ## # '%% # '%& # '%$ # '"% %%& & %% " %% & %%' # # &% # '"" # %%! && %%$ %" ( # '"& # '" # "% # # - 71 - "& # '"' # '& # '&& # '& # '&' # '&$ # ' # ' " # ' & %" & %"% # &! %"" %"& & %" # # %" ! %"' # & %"! # &% # %"$ # && # %& & ' - 72 - # ' ' # ' ! %& &! %&% # # ' $ # ' % # ' " # ' & # ' ! # ' $ # '' # %&" %&& # # # ! %& # # %& " %&' # "' %&! # "$ %&$ # # & % # # # '' # ''% # &" - 73 - % # & # ''" # '' # ''' # ''$ % % % " # " % & ' # % $ % % ' % ! # '! # '!% # # %' # # '!& # '! # %$ % $ # " # '! # '!' % "" - 74 - % # "$ % % # # # '$ # '$ # '$& # & % " # & % & # # # %' # % '$' # # " # % % ' # # "$ ! # # ! & # ! # &" % ! # # & # ! ' # % $ &$ # %' # # %' ! $ # ! # - 75 - %'% # ! % # ! & # $ %'" # # ! # ! $ # !% # !%% %'& &$ %' # # %' %'' # # %'! !%" # % # !%& # !% %'$ ! %! # # ' # # %! ! # !%! # - 76 - %!% # !" # !" # & %!" # &$ # !"" # !"& # !"! # !"$ # !&$ # ! # ! % # ! %!& % %! %! # " %!' ( ' %!! # ! %!$ " %$ " %$ # # # "" # ! # - 77 - %$% # "& # ! # ! %$" "& %$& # " # %$ ! % # " # ! " # ! %$ " %$' # " # # ! # ! ' # ! $ # !'% %$! "' %$$ "! " # "$ " # &% # !! - 78 - " % &" # !!% " " # # !! " & # , # !!' # !$ " " # # # ' # " ' !$ # '! # !$ # $ " ! ! " $ # &$ # $ # " # " # # # " % $ & # # # $ ## # - 79 - " # " " $ ' # # '% # $ # $ & # $%' # $" " & '! " " " # # "' " ' # "! # " ! $"! # # "$ # $& " $ # & # $&" # "% &% # $&! # $ "% &" "%% & # - 80 - # "%" $ & # & ) # $ # $ # $ ' # $ "%& & "% & "% # "%' # % # $'" # "%! # % # $' # # # $! $& "%$ " # "" "" "%$ # # # # &$ # # "" " # # "" * - 81 - ""% # &" # !& # !$ # $& # """ # &' # # ""& "" # " # # # # & "" # ""' ""! # # && # % # ""& # "" # # # # &%! # &" # & & # ""$ % - 82 - "& # ) # & ' # & ! * # "& ! "&% # # "&" & $ # "" # # &' # ""& # "&& "&" ) * & "& # # &'$ # &! # &' "& # # # &$ "&' # &! # &!% # ) "&! * " # "&$ # &! ## ) #* - 83 - # " &! # %' # # " &$ # , # "$ # " % "" # % " " # " & # # % # " ! # '! # ' " # ! # # ' # "&& " # #) " ' & # " ! % ! # * - 84 - # " $ # " # & " ' " # % # % # % # # '% " % '& " " # # # ' " & # " # # # "" # # ! " # %$ # " # "$ # & # & " "" # " ' " # " ! " # - 85 - " $ # " # &' "' "' # "' "$ # "'% # ) # ## & # $ # "'" # & # "'& ! # & # # $ # " ' "'& "' & # $' # $! "' & "'' & # "'! ( ' # # # * - 86 - # ' % "'$ # %' # "! "! # " ' " # # # ' # ' $ ( "$ "!% & # ' # "' # "!% # # % "!" # # "!& # %' # # ' & # # ) # ' # "!" # # "!& # , "! "" # ' ! # "! # # # &$ # * - 87 - # '%! "!' # # # '%$ "!! # '" # "! # "!! # "!$ &$ # '"$ # '& # "$ "$ & # # ' # "$ # "$% ' # ' % # "$" $ # ' " # "$& '% # ' & "$ - 88 - "$ # '& # "$ # ' # # '! # "$' "$! # %$ # ' $ # # # ''" # ''& # '' # " "$$ "" & # # " ) # & '' # # " # # '!' # "$% & # # & % # " # '!! # & " "' # & & ## # '!$ # # * - 89 - "' # & ( '$ # # "! # '$% # '$ & & # & ' & & ! # &" # '$ # ! " # & $ ## & # & ! ! ## & # # ! $ # & % & # & # # &$ # !&% # & % # & " % - # "% # # '%' # - 90 - & & &$ # # # & # & ! ' # & ' ! $ # # !% # !%" # !% # % & ! " & $ # , " # !%' # !%! # !"' # !& &% & # # ' &% &%% &%" # # $ # # !& - 91 - &%& # " &% # # ! # ! " # # & &% ## & &%' &%! ! & # ! # ! ' # ! ! # # # &%$ &" # # # ' # &" # ! $ # & &" # # # ! # ! & # ! $ &"% " &"" "' - 92 - # !' &"& # & # !'% &" # &" &" # !'" # !!% # !!" # !!& # !! # !$& # !$' # !$! # $ # &"' " &"! # # %% &"$ && # " && &% &&% && &&" # # &! - 93 - &&& # " # # $ # $ ' && "% && # &% # # # $ " # &" && # # ) # # * , # # # # , # # # % , # " ! # , ! % $ & # # # ,, , # # ! # # # - 94 - ! # , # ) # , # # # , # % )%* ) * , , # # % " # # # # # &* # %% , % , # # $ $ # # # " % # " # - %&" - , # , , %&" # # ## ( ## ( # # # - # * , # # , # * # # # # # , # # # # # # # # # # % %& % %$ # # # # , # , # , # % )%*) * # # # , # # # # , # * # # , # # # # # # # , & # # - 95 - # # # #, # #1 # 2345 6234725 89:7;26 <94 =>2 ?2=@=@9724; 375 6234725 55@=@9736 9A247B27= <94 =>2 = @; ;:CB@==25 =>3= =>2 2628=@97; =9 =>2 98@2=D 42;?97527=; % >3A2 364235D 52863425 5A983=2 =3=2 C227 89786:525 =>2 42;:6=; 5:6D 7524 ;:8> 8@48:B;=3782; =>2 ?42;27= ?2=@=@97 592; 79= ;:4A@A2 <94 <:4=>24 897;@5243=@97 ;@782 =>2 A9=2; 9< =>2 ?2=@=@9724; E242 5:6D =3F27 @7=9 3889:7= 5:4@7G =>2 89:7=@7G ?4982;; 375 =>2 42;:6=; >3A2 C227 3779:7825 388945@7G6D " 7 A@2E 9< =>2 3C9A2 =>2 ?2=@=@97; ;=375 5@;B@;;25 3; >3A@7G C289B2 @7<4:8=:9:; +' & ! % # # %! (

This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.

Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review

All Karnataka HC judgments →
LegalFirms.in Directory
Find an advocate for this matter
Dealing with a similar case? Find an advocate who handles this kind of matter on LegalFirms.in.
Find an advocate →