Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:29598-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P.(PIL) No. 4389 of 2023
Asha Prasad, aged about 62 years, W/o Akhileshwar Prasad,
Residents of Village - Maghigawan, P.O -Lamipatra, P.S:- Pandwa,
Dist:- Palamau.
...
Petitioner
Versus
1. State of Jharkhand
2. The Secretary of Agriculture, Animal Husbandry and Co-operative
Department, Nepal House, Doranda, P.O. + P.S. Doranda, Dist.
Ranchi, Ranchi-834002.
3. The Secretary Department Of Food, Public Distribution &
Consumer Affairs, Project Bhavan, Dhurwa P.O. & P.S. Dhurwa, Ranchi-834004.
4. The Chairman State Food Commission, 2nd Floor Jharkhand State
Housing Board, Old Building, Harmu Housing Colony, P.O. + P.S.
Harmu, Ranchi-834002.
5. Deputy Collector Palamu at Daltonganj, P.o & Ps -Daltonganj,
Palamu.
6. District Supply Officer at Palamau, P.o & P.s - Daltonganj,
Palamau.
7. Block Development Officer, Block Pandwa, P.o & P.s -Pandwa,
Palamau.
... Respondents
--------CORAM:
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ PRASAD
--------For the Petitioner:
Mr Aman Kumar, Advocate
For the State:
Mr Vibhor Mayank, A.C. to A.G.
For the Intervenors:
Mr Pratyush Shounikya, Advocate
Mr Manish Kumar, Advocate
--------19/Dated: 01.10.2026
1.
Heard Mr Aman Kumar, learned counsel for the petitioner,
Mr Vibhor Mayank, learned A.C. to A.G. for the State and
Mr Pratyush Shounikya, learned counsel for the Intervenors.
2.
This petition, in the public interest, was filed to espouse the
cause of about 128 farmers, referred to in the report annexed at
pages 19 to 26 to I.A. No. 8137 of 2024, seeking recall/
2026:JHHC:29598-DB
modification of this Court’s order dated 10.07.2024 made in this
petition.
3.
The petitioner has pleaded that these poor farmers supplied
crops to the respondents (State authorities) against a valid
receipt. Further, these farmers have also been paid 50 % of the
amount due for such supply. However, the grievance in the
petition is that the balance 50% amounting to approximately
Rs. 1.71 crores was being withheld without assigning any
reasons or in any event for no good reason.
4.
On 9th July, 2024, learned counsel for the State sought an
adjournment to obtain instructions on the timeline within which
50% of the dues of the poor farmers could be paid.
5.
On 10th July, 2024, the Under Secretary, Food, Public
Distribution Department filed an affidavit on the issue of
payment of the balance amount to the poor farmers.
6.
On 10th July 2024, a Coordinate Bench of this Court, after
perusing the affidavit filed by the Under Secretary, made the
following order:“In compliance of the order dated 08.07.2024, an
affidavit has been filed by the Under Secretary, Food,
Public Distribution Department wherein paragraphs-4 and
5 states as follows:
“4. That the department of Food, Public
Distribution and Consumer Affairs, Jharkhand
vide their letter no.1613, dated 08.07.2024
directed Deputy Commissioner, Palamu to
submit an inquiry report regarding pending
payment to the concerned farmers and submit
the requisition related to the required amount to
the Managing Director, Jharkhand State Food
and Civil Supplies Corporation Limited, Ranchi
by 31.07.2024.
5. That the department of Food, Public
Distribution and Consumer Affairs, Jharkhand
2026:JHHC:29598-DB
vide their letter no.1612, dated 08.07.2024
directed Managing Director, Jharkhand State
Food and Civil Supplied Corporation Limited,
Ranchi to ensure that the payments are made
to the concerned farmers within 7 days of
receiving the report from Deputy Commissioner,
Palamu.”
2.
It is quite unfortunate that without understanding
the imputation of the order such affidavit has been
filed, therefore, we are not accepting this affidavit filed
by the Under Secretary and the same is rejected.
3.
Once the amount has been calculated and 50%
has already been paid, therefore, all the figures are
available with the department itself and 50% balance
amount is to be paid.
4.
At this point of time, learned counsel for the
respondent-State undertakes that the balance amount
will be paid by first week of August, 2024.
5.
If the amount will not be paid, as undertaken by
the
learned
counsel
for
the
respondent-State,
contempt proceeding will be initiated against the
Secretary of the concerned Department for noncompliance of the order passed by this Court.
6.
7.
Call this matter on 07.08.2024.”
Despite the above order, there was no compliance. The
undertakings given to this Court regarding payment to the poor
farmers were prima facie breached. However, on 13th
September 2024, the learned A.C. to A.G. submitted that I.A.
No. 8137 of 2024 had been filed seeking recall of this Court’s
order dated 10th July 2024 on the ground that, in the course of
enquiry, some irregularities had surfaced, and the report
suggested the complicity of some of the farmers. It is pointed
out that two F.I.R.s have also been filed in this regard.
8.
On 13th September 2024, the Coordinate Bench of this Court
made the following orders:Page 3 of 10
2026:JHHC:29598-DB
“Heard the learned counsel appearing for the
parties.
2.
The matter has been taken up out of turn
considering the predicament of the farmers who have
filed the present W.P(PIL) for issuance of a direction
upon the respondent-State for payment of the rest 50%
of the amount in their favour for the paddy crops
purchased by the State.
3.
Mr. Piyush Chitresh, the learned AC to the learned
Advocate General has submitted that one interlocutory
application being I.A No.8137 of 2024 has been filed for
recall of the order dated 10th July 2024 on the ground that
in course of inquiry some irregularities have been
surfaced and in the said inquiry it has been reported that
even there will be chances of the involvement of some
farmers. The reference of two First Information Reports
have also been made in the said interlocutory application.
4.
Let this matter be listed after a week so that the
response of the said interlocutory application, if any, may
be filed.
5.
9.
List this matter on 20th September 2024.”
Thereafter, from time to time, orders were made to expedite the
enquiry proceedings and to require the State to submit status
reports on the F.I.R.s that had already been filed. There has
been hardly any progress, and the status reports do not appear
to have been filed.
10.
I.A. No. 8137 of 2024, which is taken up for consideration today,
seeks recall/modification of a Coordinate Bench’s order dated
10.07.2024 recording an undertaking on behalf of the State that
the balance 50% amount towards supply of crops would be paid
to the 128 farmers, who had already been paid 50% of the
amount.
2026:JHHC:29598-DB
11.
The modification is applied for, inter alia, on the grounds set out
in paragraph No. 2 of I.A. No. 8137 of 2024. Therefore, the
contents of paragraph 2 of the I.A. are transcribed below for the
convenience of reference: “2. That respondents seek to modification/recalling of the
above order on the following grounds:
An inquiry report was sought from the Deputy
Commissioner, Palamu for the pending payment of
farmers through departmental letter no.-1613, dated
08.07.2024. A detailed report has been provided by
the Deputy Commissioner on the basis of the enquiry
conducted by the district & block level Paddy
Procurement Monitoring Committee for the pending
payment of farmers.
In the inquiry report, many irregularities have been
found in the paddy procurement process related to
Patra PACS.
The irregularities as per the inquiry report are as
follows:
(a) The procurement center did not have sufficient
storage capacity to store pending paddy of
8,356.80 quintal. The PACS has an estimated
capacity to store about 9,500 bags of paddy
whereas it should have the capacity to store
20,890 (estimated) bags for 8,356.80 quintal of
pending paddy.
(b) Generally, paddy purchase is done from 10:00
am to 05:00 pm on a working day. During this
period, a maximum of 200-250 quintal of paddy
can be purchased by the procurement center in
a day, whereas Patra PACS has shown paddy
purchase of up to 532.03 quintal in a day.
(c) 24 farmers sold paddy in much higher quantity
than the land they posses as per the average
productivity. For example, Shri Satendra Kumar
sold 68 Quintal paddy against 2.84 Acre land,
Smt. Kisha Devi sold 140.40 Quintal paddy
2026:JHHC:29598-DB
against 2.77 Acre land they posses which is
clear the case of irregularities/embezzlement.
(d) Paddy has been sold by more than one farmer
on the basis of the same plot of land. For
example, Shri Girendra Kumar Singh sold
128.00 Quintal paddy & Shri Ravindra Kumar
Singh sold 128.00 Quintal paddy against the
same piece of 1.50 Acre land.
(e)
It is clear from the inquiry report that in collusion
with Patra PACS President, Shri Yamuna Singh,
concerned purchase officer Shri Manoj Kumar
Mishra and some farmers, the purchase of more
paddy has been shown than the actual quantity
purchased, due to which the fake reported
quantity of paddy could not be sent to Rice Mill
by procurement Center.
(f)
8356.80 quintal of paddy has been embezzled
by
Primary
Agriculture
Credit
Cooperative
Societies (PACS). Higher quantity of paddy has
been reported than the actual paddy purchased
for the intension to grab Government Money.”
12.
The I.A. also points out that an F.I.R. was lodged against
Sri Manoj Kumar Mishra, Panchayat Sewak and then Purchase
Officer, Patra PACS. The I.A. also refers to the commencement
of departmental proceedings against said Sri Manoj Kumar
Mishra.
13.
For the above reasons, it is submitted that we should recall or
modify our order dated 10.07.2024.
14.
The IA mainly contains allegations against the Government
officials in general and Sri Manoj Kumar Mishra in particular.
Some allegations are levelled against some of the specified
farmers numbering about 24 out of 128. No FIRs are filed
against the farmers, but FIR is lodged only against Sri Manoj
2026:JHHC:29598-DB
Kumar Mishra. Proceedings for recovery of Rs. 1.71 Crore are
also initiated against him for losses allegedly caused by
overpayments or payments not due.
15.
Despite opportunities, we were not apprised of any progress in
the criminal and civil proceedings. Therefore, based on the
allegations in the IA, it would not be proper to deprive the
farmers, particularly those against whom no allegations have
been made, of their long-pending dues. Moreover, after the
State has given solemn undertakings that the dues would be
cleared.
16.
From the averments in the IA, allegations, yet to be
substantiated, have been made against about 24 out of the 128
farmers. Mr Mayank initially accepted this, though he later tried
to resile as this order was being dictated. Based on such
allegations, which are neither substantiated nor diligently
probed, the payments to the remaining 104 farmers out of the
128 farmers referred to in the list at pages 19 to 26 annexed to
the I.A. cannot be withheld.
17.
There are no allegations whatsoever against the remaining 104
farmers. Accordingly, no case is made out to recall this Court’s
order dated 10.07.2024 in its entirety. At most, the said order
can be modified, and the undertaking/direction for payment can
be restricted to the remaining 104 farmers, since there is no
dispute about the identification of such 104 farmers.
18.
Mr Mayank’s argument about unjust enrichment is untenable.
The State has already initiated recovery proceedings against
Sri Manoj Kumar Mishra. At least prima facie, the allegation
2026:JHHC:29598-DB
against Sri Mishra is that after receiving the grains/crops from
the farmers and paying them to the extent of 50 per cent, the
grains were diverted for sale in the open market by fudging
records and embezzlement. Therefore, even if such allegation
is accepted at its face value, no case is made out to wholesale
deny the farmers of their dues.
19.
Accordingly, the order dated 10.07.2024 is modified, and it is
clarified that the undertaking and the direction therein for
payment to all the farmers, i.e. 128 farmers, will now be read as
a direction for payment to only 104 farmers. This excludes the
24 farmers alleged to be complicit in certain irregularities
concerning crop supplies and receipt of payments.
20.
Even after the above modification, the respondents will have to
pay the balance 50% amount withheld from 104 farmers. This is
because these farmers have receipts for the supply of crops
and, admittedly, have been paid 50% of the amount for such
supplies.
21.
Since, at a belated stage, it is suggested that other farmers may
also be involved, we suspect that the State is avoiding
payments even to the farmers against whom there were no
allegations all this while by simply raising unsubstantiated
doubts. There is no explanation as to why such alleged
irregularities were never detected earlier, and the allegations
surfaced only after solemn undertakings were given to this
Court about payments. There is also no progress in the
investigations, departmental proceedings or the recovery
proceedings.
2026:JHHC:29598-DB
22.
Therefore, considering the above circumstances, we modify the
Coordinate Bench’s order dated 10.07.2024 only partially and
direct the State to deposit in this Court the amount payable to
the 104 farmers from the list of 128 farmers provided by the
State itself within 2 months from today. The deposit must be
made after giving due intimation to the learned advocate for the
petitioner.
23.
Regarding the balance 24 farmers, the State can complete the
enquiries after giving due notices to such farmers. If they are
found complicit, an order should be passed denying them the
amounts. The farmers are given liberty to challenge such orders
in accordance with the law.
24.
If the 24 farmers are not found complicit, the amounts payable
to them must be released. This entire exercise must be initiated
within a month from today and completed within a maximum
period of 4 months thereafter. If no proceedings are initiated
against these 24 farmers within one month, or if they are not
concluded within 4 months thereafter, the amounts must be
paid to these 24 farmers within a month of the failure to initiate
or, if initiated, within one month of the failure to conclude within
4 months.
25.
Upon deposit, the Registry must disburse the amounts to the
104 farmers by directly transferring the amounts to their bank
accounts and not through any other mode. The petitioner must
furnish identity and bank details to the Registry.
2026:JHHC:29598-DB
26.
The directions in
the Coordinate Bench’s order dated
10.07.2024, as modified above, are once again reiterated and
made absolute.
27.
This petition is disposed of in the above terms. Pending
Interlocutory Applications do not survive and are disposed of.
28.
Nothing in this order is intended to affect the proceedings
initiated against Sri Manoj Kumar Mishra or any other
Government official. Such proceedings must be disposed of in
accordance with the law and on their own merits.
29.
The Secretary, Department of Food, Public Distribution and
Consumer
Affairs,
Government
of
Jharkhand,
shall
be
personally responsible for implementation of this order. He shall
file a compliance report in this Court by 7th December 2026 after
giving an advance copy to the learned counsel for the petitioner.
30.
Though this petition is now being disposed of, place the matter
for examining the compliance on 10th December 2026 at
2:15 p.m.
(M. S. Sonak, C.J.)
(Manoj Prasad, J.)
October 01, 2026
N.A.F.R.
APK/VK
Uploaded on
07.10.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review