The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
07. 01.2025; that Hon’ble Single Bench in and vide impugned order made it clear that if the post of Special Public Prosecutor is not available on the relevant date i.e., 08.07.2022, State shall create a super numerary post of Special Public Prosecutor for appointing R-3 in that slot; that while modifying impugned executive order, Hon’ble Single Bench had made it clear that it is not quashing the impugned executive order implying that it is only modifying the impugned executive order; that the writ petitioners filed captioned WA i.e., intra Court appeal along with MC(WA) No. 54 of 2025 thereat and in and vide an interim order dated 25.07.2025 the impugned Single Bench order has been stayed by predecessor Division Bench; that this interim stay is operating; that under such circumstances, P a g e 5 | 11 captioned WA is heard out today with the consent of all afore-referred learned counsel and senior counsel. [5] Before proceeding further, this Court deems it appropriate to record that captioned MC(WA) No. 80 of 2025 has been taken out by R-3 with a prayer to dismiss the captioned WA as not maintainable solely on the ground that the impugned order is a consent order. [6] In the hearing today, learned counsel for appellants contended that there was no consent, consent was not given and R-3 is now continuing as Additional Public Prosecutor cum Additional Government Advocate (District) co…
08. 07.2022. The impugned Single Bench order further makes it clear that if no Special Public Prosecutor post is available, State shall create a supernumerary post and appoint R-3 in that super numerary post. Be that as it may, for the sake of further clarity, we deem it appropriate to make this order by way of an adumbration with specificity and the same is as follows: (i) The impugned executive order being order dated 08.07.2022 bearing reference No. 5/30/2018-Case/L/1 is set aside in so far as it regularizes R-3 as Additional Public Prosecutor cum Additional Government Advocate (District); (ii) Direction qua impugned order of Hon’ble Single Bench directing State to regularize R-3 as Special Public Prosecutor with effect from
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
KHOIROM KHOIROM
BIPINCHAN BIPINCHANDRA
SINGH
2026.03.11
DRA SINGH Date:
18:57:38 +05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
REPORTABLE
Item No. 28 - 30
W.A. No. 24 of 2025
1.
Akoijam Bobby Singh, aged about 52 years, S/o Late Ak.
Shyamkishore Singh of Wangkhei Koijam Leikai, P.O.
Imphal & P.S. Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur –
795001.
2.
Leimapokpam Bimol Singh, aged about 49 years, S/o
Late L. Mangi Singh of Athokpam Mayai Leikai, P.O.& P.S.
Thoubal, Thoubal District, Manipur – 795138.
3.
Khomdram Anupama Devi, aged about 47 years, D/o
Late Kh. Suresh Singh of Kwakeithel Bazar, Opposite
Kwakeithel Girls High School, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal
West District, Manipur – 795001.
4.
Thounaojam Bandana Devi, aged about 47 years, W/o
Mutum Okendro Singh of Heirangoithong Makha Mutum
Leirak, P.O. & P.S. Singjamei, Imphal West District,
Manipur – 795008.
5.
Meitankeishangbam Jamuna Devi, aged about 50 years,
W/o Ng. Romson Singh of Chingmeirong Mamang Leikai,
P.O. Porompat & P.S. Lamphel, Imphal East District,
Manipur – 795005.
6.
Rajkumari Bhubaneshwori Devi, aged about 56 years,
W/o Thingom Mangi Singh of Sagolband Tera Sapam
Leirak, P.O. & P.S. Lamaphel, Imphal West District,
Manipur & 795004.
.… Appellants
- Versus 1.
State of Manipur represented by the Commissioner
(Law), Government of Manipur North Block, P.O. & P.S.
Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur – 795001.
P a g e 1 | 11
2.
Shri Asem Neelakumar Singh, aged about 51 years, S/o
Asem Nimai Singh of Pishum Bazar, P.O. Imphal & P.S.
Singjamei, Imphal West District, Manipur – 795001.
…. Respondents
3.
The Manipur Public Commission (MPSC) represented by
the Secretary, MPSC, North Block AOC, P.O. & P.S.
Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur – 795001.
…. Proforma Respondent
With MC(WA) No. 54 of 2025
With MC(WA) No. 80 of 2025
B E F O R E
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M. SUNDAR
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. BIMOL SINGH
For the appellants
:
Mr. Amarjit Naorem, Advocate.
For the respondents
:
Mr.
Phungyo
Zingkhei,
Deputy
Government Advocate, led by Mr. RK.
Umkanta, Senior Advocate for R-1.
:
Mr. L. Raju, Advocate for R-2
:
Ms. Paonam Beti, Advocate led by Ms.
Momota Oinam, Senior Advocate for
MPSC (R-3)
Date of hearing
:
Date of judgment & order:
10.03.2026
10.03.2026
P a g e 2 | 11
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(ORAL)
[M. Sundar, CJ]
[1]
Captioned ‘writ appeal’ (‘WA’ for the sake of brevity) is an intra
Court appeal assailing an order dated 27.12.2024 (made in W.P.(C) 540 of
2022 along with MC[W.P.(C)] No. 207 of 2023 thereat) by a Hon’ble Single
Bench (hereinafter ‘impugned Single Bench order’ for the sake of
convenience and clarity). There were 10 writ petitioners before the Hon’ble
Single Bench that the impugned Single Bench order was made; 6 (six) out
of 10(ten) writ petitioners have filed the captioned WA assailing the
impugned order.
[2]
Mr. Amarjit Naorem, learned counsel on record for all the
appellants, Mr. Phungyo Zingkhei, learned State counsel led by Mr. RK.
Umakanta, learned senior advocate for ‘respondent No. 1’ (‘R-1’ for the sake
of convenience and brevity), Mr. L. Raju, learned counsel on record for
‘respondent No. 2’ (‘R-2’ for the sake of convenience and brevity) {private
respondent} and Ms. Paonam Beti, learned counsel for ‘respondent No. 3’
(‘R-3’ for the sake of convenience and brevity) led by Ms. Momota Oinam,
learned senior advocate are before this Court.
[3]
Captioned main WA was heard out with the consent of all the
afore-referred learned counsel and learned senior counsel.
[4]
Factual matrix in a nutshell is that an ‘order dated 08.07.2022
bearing reference No. 5/30/2018-Case/L/1 made by State’ (‘impugned
executive order’ for the sake of convenience and clarity) was assailed by
P a g e 3 | 11
writ petitioners before Hon’ble Single Bench; that in and vide impugned
executive order, State had regularized contractual appointments of one Shri
Moirangthem Raichand as Special Public Prosecutor and one Shri A.
Neelakumar Singh as Additional Public Prosecutor (District) [to be noted,
Shri A. Neelakumar Singh is R-2 before this Court and was also R-3 before
the Hon’ble Single Bench]; that the case of writ petitioners is that they are
now working as regular Assistant Public Prosecutors since 2016, they are
eligible and entitled to be considered for promotion to the post of Additional
Public Prosecutor (District); that as per ‘Recruitment Rules’ (‘RR’ for the
sake of convenience and brevity), Additional Public Prosecutor is a
promotional post and feeder post for promotion to the post of Additional
Public Prosecutor is Assistant Public Prosecutor, promotion is first option
and only in the absence of suitable candidates for promotion, direct
recruitment can be resorted to; that owing to impugned executive order
made by State, the promotional prospects of the writ petitioners have been
blocked; that in the writ petition, writ petitioners have made a limited
challenge to the impugned executive order (order dated 08.07.2022) i.e.,
‘in so far as’ it regularizes R-3 as Additional Public Prosecutor; that as
regards regularization of Shri Moirangthem Raichand as Special Public
Prosecutor, the same has not been assailed as it does not affect the
promotional prospects of the writ petitioners; that the State contended that
R-3 has been engaged as Additional Public Prosecutor cum Additional
Government Advocate (District) on contract basis on and from 23.10.2019;
that thereafter R-3 was regularized vide the impugned executive order but
P a g e 4 | 11
this regularization was kept in abeyance by an order dated 01.08.2022
bearing reference No. 5/30/2018-Case/L; that owing to regularization of R3 as Additional Public Prosecutor being kept in abeyance, the State is unable
to consider R-3 for being regularized as Special Public Prosecutor; that R-3
contended that there will be no grievance for R-3 if he is regularized as
Special Public Prosecutor instead of Additional Public Prosecutor; that on
these contentions of the parties, Hon’ble Single Bench heard out and
rendered the impugned Single Bench order; that in and vide the impugned
Single Bench order, Hon’ble Single Bench has modified the impugned
executive order i.e., order dated 08.07.2022 directing the State to regularize
R-3 as Special Public Prosecutor with effect from 08.07.2022; that in the
impugned order, the date reads as 18.10.2022 which is a typographical
error and the same has been corrected by a subsequent order dated
07.01.2025; that Hon’ble Single Bench in and vide impugned order made it
clear that if the post of Special Public Prosecutor is not available on the
relevant date i.e., 08.07.2022, State shall create a super numerary post of
Special Public Prosecutor for appointing R-3 in that slot; that while
modifying impugned executive order, Hon’ble Single Bench had made it
clear that it is not quashing the impugned executive order implying that it
is only modifying the impugned executive order; that the writ petitioners
filed captioned WA i.e., intra Court appeal along with MC(WA) No. 54 of
2025 thereat and in and vide an interim order dated 25.07.2025 the
impugned Single Bench order has been stayed by predecessor Division
Bench; that this interim stay is operating; that under such circumstances,
P a g e 5 | 11
captioned WA is heard out today with the consent of all afore-referred
learned counsel and senior counsel.
[5]
Before proceeding further, this Court deems it appropriate to
record that captioned MC(WA) No. 80 of 2025 has been taken out by R-3
with a prayer to dismiss the captioned WA as not maintainable solely on the
ground that the impugned order is a consent order.
[6]
In the hearing today, learned counsel for appellants
contended that there was no consent, consent was not given and R-3 is
now continuing as Additional Public Prosecutor cum Additional Government
Advocate (District) construing the impugned Single Bench order as one that
has not quashed/set aside the impugned executive order.
[7]
As regards R-1 State, learned senior counsel very fairly
submitted that State has not filed any appeal i.e., intra Court appeal against
the impugned Single Bench order. As regards the implementation of the
impugned Single Bench order, it was submitted that the matter is subjudice,
captioned WA is pending, interim order is operating and only this has
deterred and detained State from implementing the same.
[8]
As regards R-2, learned senior counsel very fairly submitted
that Manipur Public Service Commission (‘MPSC’ for the sake of convenience
and brevity) is a formal party, State has the option of consulting the MPSC
if it chooses to do so and beyond that MPSC really does not have a say in
the captioned WA.
[9]
As regards R-3 (private respondent) as already alluded to
supra, Mr. L. Raju, learned counsel on record for R-3 very fairly submits
P a g e 6 | 11
that there is no grievance for R-3, if R-3 is regularized as Special Public
Prosecutor instead of Additional Public Prosecutor.
[10]
In the light of narrative thus far, it emerges clearly that the
impugned Single Bench order is not a consent order. The reason is, prayer
of the writ petitioners is very clear that writ petitioners have assailed the
impugned executive order i.e., 08.07.2022 order only ‘in so far as’ it
regularizes R-3 as Additional Public Prosecutor (District). Hon’ble Single
Bench has only considered the limited prayer of the writ petitioners and
answered the same. Hon’ble Single Bench has only recorded stated position
of the writ petitioners that they have challenged the impugned executive
order only with regard to regularization of R-3 as Additional Public
Prosecutor cum Additional Government Advocate (District) and has
recorded the sequitur that the petitioners do not have any grievance if R-3
is regularized as Special Public Prosecutor. To be noted, learned counsel for
appellants makes it clear that this continues the stated position of the
appellants. Therefore, the impugned order cannot be considered as consent
order much less can the contents of paragraph No. 12 thereat be construed
as consent as it only records the stated position of the writ petitioners and
sets out the sequitur. To put it differently, the impugned Single Bench order
has only considered the limited prayer of the writ petitioners and answered
the same. In this view of the matter, MC(WA) No. 80 of 2025 pales into
significance and the same can be given a closure.
[11]
Reverting to the main WA and captioned MC thereat, the
entire matter turns on a very narrow compass. The State has given quietus
P a g e 7 | 11
to the impugned Single Bench order. The State has not been able to
implement the impugned order only owing to the appeal, pendency of the
appeal and owing to the interim order operating in the captioned WA.
[12]
The difficulty if at all and if that be presents itself in the form
of paragraph No. 17 in the impugned order as Hon’ble Single Bench has
observed that it is not inclined to quash the impugned executive order which
regularized R-3 as Additional Public Prosecutor cum Additional Government
Advocate. To be noted, paragraph No. 17 of impugned Single Bench order
reads as follows:
‘[17]
In the peculiar facts and circumstances of
the present case, this Court does not incline to quash the
regularization of the respondent No. 3 as Addl. PP-cumGA(D). Accordingly, this Court modified the regularization
of the respondent No. 3 to the post of Addl. PP-cum-Addl.
GA(D) as that to the post of Spl. PP wef 18.10.2022. If
post of Spl. PP is not available on the relevant date, State
respondents may create supernumerary post of Spl. PP.
With this direction and observation, the writ petition is
disposed of. Interim orders merge with final order and
misc. application, if any, are disposed of.’
In this regard, for the sake of specificity, we clarify that the
impugned Single Bench order does not uphold the regularization of R-3 as
Additional Public Prosecutor cum Additional Government Advocate
(District). On the contrary, it has modified the impugned executive order
making it clear that R-3 should be regularized as Special Public Prosecutor.
This means that impugned executive order has been modified in so far as
P a g e 8 | 11
it regularizes R-3 as Additional Public Prosecutor (District) making it clear
that State can regularize R-3 as Special Public Prosecutor with effect from
08.07.2022. The impugned Single Bench order further makes it clear that if
no Special Public Prosecutor post is available, State shall create a
supernumerary post and appoint R-3 in that super numerary post. Be that
as it may, for the sake of further clarity, we deem it appropriate to make
this order by way of an adumbration with specificity and the same is as
follows:
(i)
The impugned executive order being order
dated 08.07.2022 bearing reference No.
5/30/2018-Case/L/1 is set aside in so far as it
regularizes R-3 as Additional Public Prosecutor
cum
Additional
Government
Advocate
(District);
(ii)
Direction qua impugned order of Hon’ble
Single Bench directing State to regularize R-3
as Special Public Prosecutor with effect from
08.07.2022 is confirmed;
(iii)
Further direction of Hon’ble Single Bench
directing State to regularize R-3 as Special
Public
Prosecutor
by
creating
a
super
numerary post of Special Public Prosecutor if
no Special Public Prosecutor slot is available is
also confirmed;
P a g e 9 | 11
(iv)
We add that the aforesaid directive of the
Hon’ble Single Bench shall now be complied
by the State within a period of 1 (one) month
from today i.e., on or before 10.04.2026;
(v)
We further direct that as regards Additional
Public Prosecutor, the vacancies shall be filled
up by State as per RR by resorting to
promotion by considering for promotion,
existing Assistant Public Prosecutors who are
eligible. This exercise shall also be completed
by the State and the same shall be done
within a period of 1 (one) month from today
i.e. on or before 10.05.2026.
(vi)
We also make it clear that R-3 shall not be
disengaged as the clear directive is to
regularize R-3 as Special Public Prosecutor
and this directive has been given vide the
impugned Single Bench order which has not
been assailed by the State. To put it
differently, State has given legal quietus to
the impugned Single Bench order being order
dated 27.12.2024 made in W.P.(C) No. 540 of
2022 together with MC[W.P.(C)] No. 207 of
2023 thereat and therefore the State shall
P a g e 10 | 11
only
regularize
R-3
as
Special
Public
Prosecutor and shall not disengage him in any
manner.
[13]
As the writ petitioners are in intra Court appeal vide captioned
WA, we have also given further directive to the State to complete the
exercise of considering for promotion of Assistant Public Prosecutors as
Additional Public Prosecutor as per RR within the time frame indicated
supra.
[14]
Captioned WA allowed in part and disposed of in the aforesaid
manner. Captioned, MC(WA) No. 80 of 2025 is dismissed, captioned
MC(WA) No. 54 of 2025 is disposed of as having been subsumed by the
order in the main WA making it clear that the interim order operating in the
main WA now stands vacated. There shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Bipin
P.S. I :
Upload forthwith.
P.S. II :
All concerned will stand bound by web copy uploaded
in High Court website inter alia as the same is QR
coded.
P a g e 11 | 11
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review