The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
9. With this direction, the CRLMP is disposed of.
10. Urgent certified copy of this order be granted on proper application and copy of this order be sent to the Opposite Parties No. 2 and 3, by the Registry. (Savitri Ratho) Judge subhalaxmi /puspa Designation: PERSONAL ASSISTANT Reason: Authentication Location: Orissa High Court
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
CRLMP No. 1765 of 2024
Asarpi Meher
…..
Petitioner
Mr. Jagabandhu Sahu, Advocate
-versus1.State of Odisha
2.Director General of Police, Odisha
3.Superintendent of Police, Balangir
4. The IIC, Deogaon Police Station, …..
Balangir
Opposite Parties
Mr. A. K. Apat,
Additional Government Advocate
CORAM:
HON’BLE MISS JUSTICE SAVITRI RATHO
ORDER
27.02.2026
(Through hybrid Mode)
Order No.
03.
1.
This CRLMP has been filed for a direction to the Opposite
Party to register a case against Somkesh Nayak, the Additional
Tahasildar, Deogaon to investigate into the matter and to give
protection to the Petitioner.
2. That the case of the Petitioner is that her son - Bikash Meher
had applied for a caste certificate before the Tahasildar, Deogaon as
he required it for securing a job. But after repeated requests, he
remained rigid and refused to issue the caste certificate. On
19.11.2024 the informant with some women of her village had gone
to the Tahasil Office, Deogaon and asked the Tahasildar as to why
he is not issuing the caste certificate to them in spite of direction of
Hon’ble Supreme Court as well as State Government. The
Tahasildar refused to issue Caste Certificate to them and abused
them in filthy language referring to their caste and directed them to
leave the Tahasil Office. On 20.11.2024 the Petitioner submitted one
written complaint before the Deogaon Police Station /Opposite Party
No.4 against Somkesh Nayak. But when no case was registered, the
Petitioner with president of their caste namely Dhansingh Meher had
met the Superintendent of Police, Balangir - Opposite Party No.3 on
25.11.2024, complaining about the inaction of the IIC and submitted
the representation. But even then as case was not registered, they
have approached this Court.
3.
Pursuant to order dated 02.01.2025 of this Court, an affidavit
has been filed by the IIC, Deogaon Police Station, where it is stated
that on 19.11.2024 on receiving intimation from the Tahasildar,
Deogaon over telephone about gathering of 100 of people at the
Tahasil office, who were abusing the Additional Tahasildar in
obscene language for not issuing a caste certificate to one Bikash
Meher and Asarpi Meher(present Petitioner). The deponent reached
the Tahasil office and the crowds were abusing and threatening to
kill the Additional Tahasildar, Deogaon. The SDPO, Balangir also
arrived at the spot and rescued the Additional Tahasildar, Deogaon
and the mob dispersed. On 20.11.2024, on the written report of the
Additional Tahasildar, Deogaon, Deogaon PS Case No. 270 of 2024
was registered against Smt. Sarojini Meher and others for
commission of offences punishable under Section 189(2)/ 296/
329(3)/ 121(1)/ 132/ 351(2)/190 BNS, 2023. On the same day at
around 5.45 P.M., the Petitioner presented a written report alleging
that her son Bikash Meher had applied for caste certificate at Tahasil
office, Deogaon, which was rejected by the Additional Tahasildar.
She also alleged that on 19.11.2024, she and other female members
of her village had gone to Tahasil Office, Deogaon and demanded
the caste certificate But the Addl. Tahasildar refused to issue caste
certificate and abused them in obscene languages. On the basis of
her complaint, a General Diary entry 42 dated 20.11.2024 was made
and preliminary enquiry was conducted from which it was
ascertained that “Kulis” come under the Scheduled Tribe in serial
No.42 of the Law Department Notification No.2232/I/Legis-05/24/L
dated 20.02.2024 and there is no "Kuli" community added in the
Gazette Notification for which a clarification was sought for by the
Addl. Tahasildar vide Letter No.2394 dated 30.10.2024. The
deponent, IIC, Deogaon Police Station has also stated that he was
present on 19.11.2024 along with the other police personnel in the
Tahasil office, Deogaon and no such occurrence as alleged by the
Petitioner has taken place for which the preliminary enquiry was
closed as false and entry was made in General Diary i.e. GD No. 26
dated 05.12.2024.
4.
Mr. J. Sahu, learned counsel for the Petitioner submits that as
per the judgment of the Supreme Court in State of Orissa vs
Dasarathi Meher :AIR 2018 SC 4998, decided on 27.09.2018 the
Supreme Court has held that “kuli” has to be included in “kulis”,
otherwise a tribe will be deleted from the list of Schedule Tribes as
there is no community by the name of “kulis” in the State of Orissa,
for which the entries in the list have to be read in a manner which is
consistent with the intention of the parliament. Pursuant to this
judgment, the Commissioner-cum-Secretary to Government in the
Department of SC and ST Development, has issued letter to all
Collectors on 03.12.2018 enclosing the order of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court and also stating that there should not be any
inhibition on the part of the Competent Authority to issue caste
certificate in favour of a person belonging to the kuli community as
a member of Schedule Tribe. But even though the copy of the
judgment of the Supreme Court and the letter of the Commissioner
were produced before the Addl. Tahasildar, he refused to grant caste
certificate to the son of the Petitioner. Subsequently, caste certificate
was issued to him, pursuant to the order passed by the Collector,
Balangir. But it did not help him in getting a job as because by that
time, the Police had shown him as an accused in the case alongwith
the persons who had allegedly gathered at the Office of the
Additional Tahasildar on that day. He further submits that as the
Additional Tahasildar had abused the Petitioner and her son and
humiliated them by referring to their caste, as those were cognizable
offences, a case should have been registered against him . But the
police accepted his FIR but no case was registered on the complaint
of the Petitioner. He submits that the enquiry conducted by the
police is biased as there are a number of witnesses who were present
and have heard the words uttered by the Additional Tahasildar, Mr.
Somkesh Nayak.
5.
Mr. A.K. Apat, learned Additional Government Advocate
submits that since enquiry on the complaint of the Petitioner has
already been conducted and the allegations found to be false by the
IIC, Deogaon Police Station, and instead a case has been registered
by the Police on the information of the Additional Tahasildar , this is
not a fit case where any direction should be issued to the IIC,
Deogaon to register any case on the complaint of the Petitioner.
6.
In this CRLMP, this Court is not to decide whether the
Additional Tahasildar was right in refusing to grant caste certificate
to the son of the Petitioner. It has anyway been submitted that the
son of the Petitioner has been issued a caste certificate subsequently.
But a perusal of the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of
Dasarathi Meher ( supra), reveals that the son of the Petitioner was
entitled to be issued a caste certificate . Injustice appears to have
been done against the Petitioner and her son as he was first denied
caste certificate and thereafter a case has been registered as the
members of the community gathered in the Office and created
disturbance. As son of the Petitioner has also been arrayed as an
accused in the case, he has not been able to get a job, in spite of
being issued the caste certificate.
7.
As per the decision of the Supreme Court in the case Sudhir
Bhaskarrao Tambe Vs. Hemant Yashwant Dhage : (2016) 6 SCC
277, the Petitioner has alternate remedy as the Police has not
registered any case on her complaint. After perusing the averments
in the CRLMP and the affidavit filed by the Opposite Party No.4 and
hearing the learned counsel for the Petitioner and Mr. A. K. Apat,
learned Additional Government Advocate and considering the
developments which have taken place in the meanwhile, I am not
inclined to issue any direction to the Opposite Party No.4 to register
a case on the complaint of the Petitioner, as the Petitioner has
alternate remedy. The Petitioner is at liberty to avail the alternate
remedy which is available to her under law, to challenge General
Diary i.e. GD No. 26 dated 05.12.2024 and for other relief, if she so
desires.
8.
But what comes to my mind is that registration of a case
against the Additional Tahasildar will not help the son of the
Petitioner, who is unable to secure a Government job on account of
pendency of the case against him. In view of the peculiar facts and
circumstances of the case, I direct the Government to consider if
Deogaon PS Case No. 270 of 2024 can be withdrawn in accordance
with Section 360 of the BNSS against the son of the Petitioner, or in
toto. This in my view would serve “public justice”. Any application
for withdrawal would of course be subject to the consideration and
order of the concerned Magistrate/ Judge.
9.
With this direction, the CRLMP is disposed of.
10.
Urgent certified copy of this order be granted on proper
application and copy of this order be sent to the Opposite Parties No.
2 and 3, by the Registry.
(Savitri Ratho)
Judge
subhalaxmi /puspa
Digitally Signed
Signed by: PUSPANJALI MOHAPATRA
Designation: PERSONAL ASSISTANT
Reason: Authentication
Location: Orissa High Court
Date: 02-Mar-2026 16:07:12
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review