Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 10th March, 2026
Pronounced on: 24th April, 2026
Uploaded on: 24th April , 2026
CRL.A. 316/2015
+
ASAD ARIF
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Ravi Nayak, Mohd. Faisal and
Mr. Abhishek K. Tanwar, Advs. with
Appellant-in-person.
versus
STATE (GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI)
...Respondent
Through: Mr. Ritesh Kumar Bahri, APP with
Ms. Divya Yadav & Mr. Lalit Luthra,
Advs.
CORAM:
JUSTICE PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUSTICE MADHU JAIN
JUDGMENT
MADHU JAIN, J.
1.
The present criminal appeal under Section 374 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter ‘CrPC’) ) has been preferred by the
Appellant/Accused assailing the Impugned Order of conviction and order on
sentence dated 31st January, 2015 and 24th February, 2015 respectively,
passed by the ld. Additional Sessions Judge, Saket Court, New Delhi,
whereby the Appellant/Accused has been convicted in Sessions Case No.
94/14, arising out of FIR No. 490/2011, registered at P.S. Jamia Nagar under
Section 307 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter ‘IPC’), holding as
under:
“59. Thus I am of the opinion that the prosecution
has successfully brought home the guilt of the
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 316/2015
accused and I accordingly convict him u/s 307
IPC. He be heard on the point of sentence. Put up
for same on 10.02.2015 at 12.30 PM.”
2.
By the Impugned Judgement of conviction and order on sentence, the
Appellant/Accused has been sentenced to undergo Simple Imprisonment for
three years along with a fine of Rs. 1,05,000/- for the offence punishable
under Section 307 of the IPC. In default of payment of fine, he has been
sentenced to undergo Simple Imprisonment for a period of six months. The
ld. Trial Court further ordered that out of the fine proceeds, an amount of Rs.
1 Lakh shall be released to complainant/injured. The ld. Trial Court in the
order on sentence held as under:
“Furthermore, in regard to the compensation,
capacity of the convict to pay would certainly
involve a certain inquiry, however, time and
adjournments being given, no material in this
regard has been placed on record.
After considering the aggravating and mitigating
circumstances, convict Asad Arif is sentenced to
simple imprisonment for 3 years and fine of Rs.
1,05,000/- for offence U/s 307 IPC. in default of
payment of fine, convict shall undergo simple
imprisonment for a period of six months.
Out of the fine proceeds, if deposited by the
convict, an amount of Rs. 1 Lakh shall be released
to complainant/injured Ms. Muskan. Benefit of
Section 428 Cr. PC is extended to the convict Asad
Arif.
Part fine of Rs. 5,000/- stands deposited in the
Court.”
FACTUAL MATRIX:
3.
The case of the prosecution, in brief, is that in the intervening night of
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 316/2015
19th September 2011, at about 12:02 a.m., information was received at
Police Station Jamia Nagar regarding admission of one Ms. Muskan in Holy
Family Hospital in an injured condition. The said information was recorded
vide DD No. 3A and entrusted to the Investigating Officer for necessary
action. The Investigating Officer, along with accompanying police officials,
proceeded to the hospital and collected the Medico-Legal Certificate of the
injured.
4.
As per the statement of the injured PW- 4 Ms. Muskan, the incident is
stated to have occurred on the night of 18th September 2011 at about 10:45
p.m., when she had gone to the back room of her residence to take water
from the refrigerator. At that time, the Appellant/Accused, who was known
to her as a neighbor, was allegedly standing outside the window opening. It
is alleged that upon seeing her, the Appellant/Accused threatened her,
stating that since she had refused his proposal of marriage, he would not
spare her, and immediately thereafter fired a shot at her through the window.
The bullet struck the upper portion of her thigh, resulting in profuse
bleeding. Thereafter, the Appellant/Accused is stated to have fled from the
spot. The relevant portion of the complaint dated 19th September, 2011 is
reproduced hereinbelow:
“बयान िकया िक म यहाँ उपरो पते पर अपने प रवार के साथ
रहती ँ और पढ़ाई कर रही ँ जो कल 18, 19/9/2011 की रात
व
करीब 10.45 बजे म अपने घर म पीछे वाले कमरे म
ि ज से पानी लेने गई थी तो मने दे खा िक खड़की के बाहर
असद आ रफ नाम का लड़का खड़ा था जो मोह े का ही
रहने वाला है िजसको म पहले से जानती ँ उसने मुझे दे खते
ही कहा िक तूने मुझसे शादी करने से मना करके अ ा नही ं
िकया अब म तुझे िज ा नही ं छोड़ूँगा जब तक म कुछ समझ
पाती असद आ रफ ने मेरे ऊपर गोली चला दी और वह भाग
गया गोली मेरी दािहनी जां घ के ऊपरी िह े म लगी और जोर से
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 316/2015
खून बहने की वजह से मेरी सलवार खून से लथपथ हो गई |“
5.
It is the prosecution’s case that upon sustaining the injury, the
complainant/injured raised an alarm and was immediately attended to by her
family members, including her sister Safiara, who, along with others, shifted
her to Holy Family Hospital for treatment.
6.
The MLC bearing No. 24438 of the injured recorded a gunshot injury
on the right thigh, described as a lacerated wound measuring approximately
4.5X2X1 cm, and the injury was subsequently opined to be grievous in
nature. The said MLC bearing No. 24438 is reproduced here under:
“
“On Examination: Stable, conscious & oriented.
Vitals stable.
L/E (Local Examination) (R) Thigh post lat:
elliptical ~ 4.5 x 2 x 1 cm (R) Thigh. Laceration.
Investigations: X-Ray (R) Thigh - AP & Lat.
Diagnosis and Conclusion
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 316/2015
7.
Condition at discharge: Stable
Final diagnosis: GUN SHOT INJURY (R) Thigh
Nature of Injuries: Grievous (Circled)
Remarks: H/o attacked on her with unknown
object. Pt (Patient) was admitted foreign Body
(ONE BULLET) removed from (R) thigh and
discharged.”
The injured was initially not in a condition to give a statement due to
the influence of heavy dosage of drugs as the doctor had suggested surgery.
Subsequently her statement was recorded upon being declared fit. Based on
the said statement, a rukka was prepared and the FIR No. 490/2011 under
Section 307 IPC came to be registered at Police Station Jamia Nagar.
8.
Upon completion of investigation, the charge-sheet under Section 307
IPC was filed before the ld. jurisdictional Magistrate and the matter, being
triable exclusively by the Court of Sessions, was committed to the Sessions
Court. Thereafter, charge under Section 307 IPC was framed against the
Appellant/Accused on 18th January 2012, to which he pleaded not guilty and
claimed trial.
9.
In order to establish its case, the prosecution’s examined thirteen
witnesses, including the injured witness (PW-4), medical experts, police
officials, and other formal witnesses.
10.
The central pillar of the prosecution’s case was the testimony of PW-4
Ms. Muskan, who, in her examination-in-chief, reiterated the allegation that
the Appellant/Accused fired a gunshot at her from outside the window after
threatening her. She also identified the Appellant/Accused and attributed a
clear motive arising out of refusal of marriage. The relevant portion of her
statement and of the other relevant witnesses of the of the prosecution
witness are reproduced hereinbelow:
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 316/2015
Witnesses
Statement
In
Examination
Chief Statement
In
Examination
PW4 …I knew Asad Arif
Muskan
prior to the incident as
(Injured) he is resident of our
area (Mohalla). Asad
Arif ne mujhe dekhte hi
kaha ki tune mujhse
shaadi se mana karke
acha nahi kiya, ab
main tujhe zinda nahi
chodunga, itni dair
mein
main
kuch
samajh pati, usne mujh
par goli chala di, jo
meri dahini jaang ke
uppar lagi, usne goli
banduk se chalai thi, jo
banduk ko phechan
sakti hu. (Accused
Asad Arif after seeing
me said that you had
not do better for you
by refusing marry with
me and then he fired a
shot from his gun,
which hit on the upper
portion of my right
thigh). The accused
Asad
Arif
after
sustaining gun shot
injury run away from
there.
…After registration of
the FIR the family
member of the accused
Cross
…The
reason
of
animosity
between
accused and me is that
I had refused to marry
him. Safiara, my sister
is elder to me and I am
younger to Safiara.
…On the date of
incident, there was no
marriage proposal of
Safiara.
Accused
persons had brought
the proposal for my
marriage. It is wrong to
suggest that there was
ever any proposal by
the accused person for
the marriage of my
elder sister Safiara. I
was present at my
house
when
the
marriage proposal was
brought by the accused
persons. The marriage
proposal
by
the
accused persons was
given in the month of
21st October 2009. I
rejected the proposal
through my mother. I
also personally told this
fact to the accused.
XXX
…I had disclosed the
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 316/2015
and their relatives
used to pressurize me
and my family to
arrive at compromise
with the accused. In
this regard, a specific
complaint was also
lodged by my sister
Safiara in the PS
Jamia Nagar where a
DD No. 38-B was
recorded.
address and parentage
of accused Asad Arif in
my
statement
Ex.
PW4/A to the police. I
have knowledge as to
when the accused was
arrested by the police.
XXX
…I cannot tell how
much is the height of
the window of my room.
Sometime, I had stood
along side the window
in order to see outside.
The height of lower
side starting point of
the window from the
floor inside the room is
equivalent to the height
of my waist. There is a
chhajja
above
the
vertical end point of
window. I am 5'3".
XXX
…There was friendship
between
me
and
accused. I started my
friendly
relationship
with accused in the
year
2009.
Our
acquaintance initiated
through
social
networking sites.
…The accused had
never come to my house
to meet me on an
earlier occasion prior
to the incident, in my
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 316/2015
presence. My parents
had also not told me
about the visit of the
accused
at
our
residence,
in
my
absence, prior to the
incident. Accused had
not visited me at my
residence, or in the
hospital, even after the
incident. Neither me
nor my family member
had ever visited the
house of the accused
after
the
incident.
Before the incident,
neither me nor my
family member visited
the house of accused.
We met each other five
or six times in the
absence of our known.
Voln. The said meetings
were at a public place.
I never met accused on
a specific place or
occasion. I am aware
that accused also have
some friends.
…I had gone on an
outing with the accused
but in a group in which
other friends of accused
were also present.
None of my friend
(male or female) had
accompanied with me
in the said outing.
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 316/2015
PW- 6 Sh. On 18.09.2011, at
about 10:45pm, I was
Mustakeer
present at my house in
Ahmed
the drawing room. All
of a sudden, I heard
firing of shot (goli
chalne ki awaz aai)
from just behind my
house in the service
lane. I went backside
towards room situated
on the back side of the
drawing room. In the
room adjoining the
service lane, I saw that
my daughter namely
Muskaan was crying
and weeping. She was
nervous. I saw that her
salwar was soaked
with blood. On asking,
how it happened.
Muskaan told me that
a boy named Asad Arif
had fired a shot from
the backside window.
He caused injuries
with the bullet to her
and thereafter, had ran
away.
XXX
…I had participated in
the group photo shoot
at Agra. I do not
recollect whether I
participated in the
photo shoot uniquely
with the accused only.
… I have not told the
incident of 17.09.2011
to the police while
recording statement u/s
161 Cr.P.C. I have not
told the event to the
police
about
17.09.2011 because the
second
day,
the
incident has taken
place due to which, I
was mentally disturbed
and I could not tell the
police. I am being
treated for mental
tension till date. After
the incident. I became
mentally disturbed.
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 316/2015
XXX
On 17.09.2011 at
about 07:30pm, when I
was returning back
from the Mosque after
offering the Namaaz,
on the way, Asad Arif
restrained my way
(raaste main gher liya)
and told me that
Muskaan had refused
to marry him and
therefore, he would
enter her house and
fire a shot on her.
(Muskaan ne mujhse
shaadi karne se mana
kiya, woh ab ghar
main ghus ke goli
maarega).
11.
The medical evidence, as led through PW-3 and PW-11, established
that the injury sustained by the complainant/injured was a gunshot injury
and that a bullet was recovered during medical treatment. The nature of the
injury was opined to be grievous. The relevant medical opinion made by
PW- 3 Dr. Tirupati Ranjan Shukla and PW- 11 Dr. Vipul Sood are
reproduced hereinbelow:
Witnesses Statement In
Examination
PW3
Dr.
Tirupati
Ranjan
Chief Statement In
Examination
… I medically examined
Muskan
d/o
Mohd.
Mustaqeem Ahmed vide
MLC No. C11024438,
Cross
The salwar worn by the
patient was handed
over to the Police by
me, however; it was put
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 316/2015
Shukla
which is Ex.PW3/A,
bears my signature at
point-A. She was brought
to the hospital by her
sister
Samiara.
On
examination,
injuries
over right posterior
lateral thigh (elliptical
shaped) wound nearly
4.5 x 2 x 1 cm in size
lacerated type of wound.
Some ooze was there. Xray of relevant area was
done at causality. Some
radio opaque shadow
was found and therefore,
patient was admitted to
the hospital for further
exploration on 00:24
hours on 19.09.2011.
One bullet was found
which was removed by
the
plastic
surgeon
Doctor Vipul Sud. She
was
discharged
on
21.09.2011.
PW- 11 …I opined that injury
Dr. Vipul caused by Ms. Muskan
Sud
was not sufficient to
cause death in ordinary
course of nature.
12.
off by the attending
staff nurse. I had seen
some torn area in the
salwar. I cannot say
whether torn area in
the salwar was burnt or
not because it was
soaked with blood.
The prosecution also relied upon the recovery of the blood-stained
clothes and the bullet, along with the forensic examination reports, to
corroborate the ocular version.
13.
After completion of the prosecution evidence, the statement of the
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 316/2015
Appellant/Accused under Section 313 CrPC was recorded, wherein he
denied the allegations and claimed false implication. The defence set up by
the Appellant/Accused was that there was no such incident of firing and that
he had been falsely implicated due to personal disputes arising out of
matrimonial proposals involving the complainant/injured and her family.
14.
In defence, the Appellant/Accused examined four witnesses,
including himself, to support the plea that the relations between the parties
were cordial and that the alleged incident was fabricated. The defence also
sought to suggest that the marriage proposal was for the complainant’s sister
and not the complainant/injured, and that the present case was a result of
personal animosity. The relevant portion of the statements of the defence
witnesses are reproduced hereinbelow:
DW-1 Ms. The family of Asad Arif .
and my family are
Khansa
living in the same
Sadiya
building.
We
are
residing at the first
(Cousin
floor and family of
sister of Asad Arif is residing at
ground floor. I was
the
married 06.02.201.
accused)
DW-
3 …On
15.09.2011,
Muskaan had visited
Asad Arif
my sister Sadiaya
(Accused) Arif's house on the
occasion of birthday of
her daughter, where
we had met each other
after conclusion of
function. She took me
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 316/2015
aside and expressed
her desire to go out of
Delhi with her but I
refused to accompany
her. When she insisted
and forced then I
asked her to ask her
brother or cousin to
accompany, then I
would accompany her.
She was not ready and
asked me to take any of
my friend, who could
accompany us. She
agreed to that
XXX
…On the way from
Agra
to
Delhi,
Muskaan
inquired
from me, as to why I
was marrying with her
sister Safiara and
asked me to marry
with her. She told me
that
she
would
convince and make her
family
members
understand.
FINDINGS OF THE LEARNED TRIAL COURT:
15.
Upon appreciation of the oral and documentary evidence on record,
the ld. Trial Court came to the conclusion that the prosecution had
successfully proved its case beyond reasonable doubt. The testimony of the
injured witness was found to be credible and corroborated by medical
evidence.
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 316/2015
16.
The ld. Trial Court held that the testimony of PW-4 stood
corroborated by the medical evidence and by the testimony of PW-6. The
presence of the Appellant/Accused at the spot and his identity were held to
be duly established.
17.
The defence taken by the Appellant/Accused was rejected by the ld.
Trial Court as improbable. The ld. Trial Court also held that the absence of
recovery of weapon of offence was not fatal to the prosecution case in view
of the consistent ocular and medical evidence.
18.
On the aspect of intention, the ld. Trial Court held that the act of firing
a gunshot at the complainant/injured from close range clearly demonstrated
the intention to cause death, thereby attracting the offence under Section 307
IPC.
19.
Accordingly, the ld. Trial Court concluded that the prosecution had
proved
its
case
beyond
reasonable
doubt
and
convicted
the
Appellant/Accused under Section 307 IPC. The Appellant/Accused was
thereafter sentenced to simple imprisonment for three years along with fine.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT:
20.
The ld. counsel for the Appellant/Accused submits at the outset that
the present case arises out of what was essentially a personal dispute
between two young individuals, and the same has been given a criminal
colour far beyond its actual contours. It is submitted that at the time of the
incident, the Appellant/Accused was about 23 years of age and the
complainant/injured was about 21 years old, and the parties were known to
each other. Reference is made to the defence evidence, including
photographs placed on record, to submit that the parties shared a prior
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 316/2015
relationship and had even travelled together, which, according to ld. counsel,
indicates that the incident cannot be viewed in isolation as a grievous act of
violence.
21.
The ld. counsel draws the attention of this Court to the defence
evidence,
particularly
Exhibit
DW-4/12,
to
submit
that
the
complainant/injured herself is reflected therein, and the material on record
would show that the relationship between the parties had soured over time. It
is contended that once such relationships deteriorate, allegations tend to be
exaggerated, and therefore, the prosecution version ought to be viewed with
caution in that background.
22.
Without pressing the appeal on conviction, the ld. counsel submits
that the sentence imposed by the ld. Trial Court deserves reconsideration. It
is urged that the Appellant/Accused has been sentenced to undergo simple
imprisonment for a period of three years and has already undergone a
substantial part of the said sentence, approximately half. It is further
submitted that the Appellant/Accused is now married, has family
responsibilities, and has moved on in life, and these factors deserve to be
taken into account while considering the question of sentence.
23.
In this context, reliance is placed upon the order of Supreme Court in
in Sona Dhar v. State of Chhattisgarh, 2021 SCC OnLine SC 3683, to
submit that in cases involving fixed-term sentences, where the accused is
willing to accept the infraction and does not seek to challenge the
conviction, the appellate court may, in appropriate cases, dispose of the
appeal on the basis of the sentence already undergone.
24.
The ld. counsel further seeks to highlight certain material
inconsistencies in the prosecution case. It is submitted that the MLC, which
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 316/2015
is the earliest document, records that the injury was caused by an unknown
person with an unknown object while the complainant/injured was engaged
in household work. This, according to ld. counsel, is a significant
circumstance, as the name of the Appellant/Accused does not figure in the
first version.
25.
It is further submitted that the complainant/injured was brought to the
hospital at about 11:01 p.m., and though she was declared fit for statement at
around 1:10 a.m., her statement was not recorded immediately. The
statement
implicating
the
Appellant/Accused
was
recorded
only
subsequently, after a delay of approximately 22 hours. The ld. counsel
submits that such delay in naming the Appellant/Accused casts a serious
doubt on the prosecution case.
26.
The ld. counsel also refers to the DD-3 entry recorded upon
information from the hospital, which describes the incident as a “jhagda” or
scuffle. It is submitted that even at that stage, no specific allegation was
made against the Appellant/Accused, and the complainant’s companion,
who was present at the hospital, also did not disclose the identity of the
assailant.
27.
It is further urged that the nature and placement of the injury are also
relevant. The injury was sustained on the thigh and not on any vital part of
the body. The ld. counsel has drawn attention to the cross-examination of
the complainant/injured, wherein it has come on record that the window
through which the alleged shot was fired was at a height corresponding to
the waist level. It is submitted that even as per the complainant’s own
testimony, the alleged shot was directed at the thigh, which does not reflect
an intention to cause death.
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 316/2015
28.
It is contended that the medical evidence also does not suggest any
life-threatening injury, and the condition of the complainant/injured at
discharge was satisfactory. It is thus argued that the essential ingredients of
intention or knowledge required under Section 307 IPC are not clearly made
out in the facts of the present case.
29.
The ld. counsel submits that even if the prosecution version is
accepted in its entirety, the incident involved a single act and not a repeated
or brutal assault. The weapon was not used in a manner that would
ordinarily result in death, and the injury inflicted was limited in nature.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT:
30.
Per contra, the ld. APP for the State, along with ld. counsel appearing
for the complainant/injured, submits that the present case is not one
warranting any reduction of sentence. On the contrary, it is urged that the
facts and circumstances disclose aggravating features which justify
enhancement of sentence.
31.
It is submitted at the outset that the act of the Appellant/Accused was
not a spontaneous or isolated act, but a premeditated and deliberate assault.
In this regard, reliance is placed upon prior complaints made by the
complainant/injured, particularly Exhibits PW-4/C and PW-4/D, to
demonstrate that the Appellant/Accused had, even prior to the incident,
threatened the Survivor and attempted to harm her.
32.
The ld. APP draws attention to Exhibit PW-4/C, being DD No. 37-B
dated 14th May 2011, wherein the complainant/injured had specifically
complained that the Appellant/Accused had come to her residence armed
with a knife, attempted to harm her, and issued threats to kill her. It is
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 316/2015
submitted that the contents of the said complaint clearly establish a pattern
of conduct and prior animosity on the part of the Appellant/Accused.
33.
The ld. APP further places reliance upon Exhibit PW-4/D, being an
earlier complaint dated 31 March 2011, wherein the Appellant/Accused is
alleged to have repeatedly threatened the complainant/injured, including
physical harm. It is submitted that these complaints demonstrate that the
Appellant/Accused was persistently stalking and intimidating the Survivor,
and that the present incident was a culmination of such conduct.
34.
It is thus contended that the prior complaints assume considerable
significance, as they show that the Appellant/Accused was not acting in the
heat of the moment but had a continuing intention to harm the
complainant/injured. The incident in question, therefore, cannot be viewed
in isolation but must be assessed in light of this background.
35.
The ld. APP further submits that the defence sought to be projected by
the Appellant/Accused during trial is false and contradictory. It is pointed
out that in his statement under Section 313 CrPC, on being questioned
whether he wants to state something else, the Appellant/Accused in his
answer denied any relationship with the complainant’s sister. However, in
the course of arguments, reliance has been placed on photographs and
alleged prior association, which is inconsistent with the stand taken by the
Appellant/Accused during trial.
36.
It is submitted that such contradictory stands adopted by the
Appellant/Accused undermine his credibility and reflect an attempt to
mislead the Court. The reliance on photographs, it is urged, is an
afterthought and cannot dilute the gravity of the offence.
37.
On the aspect of delay in recording the statement of the
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 316/2015
complainant/injured, the ld. APP submits that no adverse inference can be
drawn. It is pointed out that the Survivor was brought to the hospital at about
11:40 p.m. and though she was declared fit for statement at around 1:10
a.m., the record clearly indicates that she was under the influence of
medication and was taken for surgery.
38.
Attention is drawn to the endorsement in the rukka, which records that
although the complainant/injured was declared fit, she was not in a condition
to give a statement due to the effect of medicines and was immediately taken
for operation. It is submitted that under such circumstances, the delay in
recording the statement is fully explained and cannot be used to cast doubt
on the prosecution case.
39.
It
is
further
contended
that
the
initial
absence
of
the
Appellant/Accused’s name in the MLC is also not fatal. The ld. APP
submits that the MLC is not expected to contain a detailed narration of the
incident or the identity of the assailant, particularly when the injured is in
pain and under medical treatment. The naming of the Appellant/Accused in
the subsequent statement is consistent and has been duly proved.
40.
The ld. APP also disputes the submission that the injury being on the
thigh reduces the gravity of the offence. It is submitted that the intention of
the accused is not to be determined solely on the basis of the situs of injury,
but on the overall circumstances. Firing a gunshot at a person, irrespective
of the exact point of impact, is an act inherently capable of causing death.
41.
In this context, reliance is placed on the judgment in Ratan Singh v.
State of M.P. And Anr., 2009 (12) SCC 585, to submit that intention and
knowledge are to be gathered from the totality of circumstances, including
prior conduct, the nature of the weapon used, and the manner of assault. It is
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 316/2015
submitted that the use of a firearm, coupled with prior threats, clearly
establishes the requisite intention.
42.
The ld. APP further submits that the Appellant/Accused has caused
lasting harm to the complainant/injured, who continues to suffer the
consequences of the incident even today. It is urged that the trauma caused
to the complainant/injured cannot be overlooked while determining the
appropriate sentence.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS:
43.
The Court has considered the matter.
44.
The central issue which arises for consideration is whether the
prosecution has been able to establish, beyond reasonable doubt, that the
Appellant/Accused had fired a gunshot at the complainant/injured Ms.
Muskan with the intention or knowledge so as to be sentenced under Section
307 IPC
45.
The prosecution case rests fundamentally upon the testimony of PW-4
Ms. Muskan, who is not merely an eyewitness but the injured victim herself.
Her testimony, therefore, occupies a position of primacy in the evidentiary
framework of the case.
46.
PW-4 has, in her examination-in-chief, given a clear and vivid
account of the incident. She has deposed that on the night of 18th September
2011, at about 10:45 p.m., when she went to the rear room of her house to
take water from the refrigerator, she noticed the Appellant/Accused standing
outside the window. She has further deposed that the Appellant/Accused,
upon seeing her, threatened her by stating that since she had refused to
marry him, he would not spare her, and before she could react, he fired a
shot from a firearm which struck the upper portion of her right thigh.
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 316/2015
47.
What is significant is that this version is not a mere bald allegation but
contains specific details including the location, the manner of assault, the
words of threat, and the immediate consequence. Her testimony remains
consistent on these material particulars even during cross-examination.
48.
The defence has attempted to suggest that there were prior
interactions between the parties, including outings and photographs, to argue
that the incident arises out of a personal dispute. However, such prior
acquaintance,
if
anything,
strengthens
the
identification
of
the
Appellant/Accused and does not dilute the prosecution case.
49.
This Court finds no reason to disbelieve the testimony of PW-4. There
is no material contradiction affecting the foundation of her version, nor is
there any indication of false implication motivated by any compelling
reason.
50.
The testimony of PW-4 stands fully corroborated by the medical
evidence on record. The MLC clearly records a gunshot injury on the right
thigh, described as a lacerated wound measuring approximately 4.5 x 2 x 1
cm. The medical evidence further establishes that a bullet was recovered
from the body of the injured during surgical intervention and that the injury
was grievous in nature.
51.
PW-3 Dr. Tirupati Ranjan Shukla has categorically deposed regarding
the nature of the injury and the recovery of the bullet. PW-11 Dr. Vipul Sud
has further corroborated that the injury involved the presence of a bullet in
the thigh, which was surgically removed.
52.
The ocular and medical evidence are thus in complete consonance.
There is no inconsistency between the two. The nature of injury, the situs,
and the presence of a bullet all support the prosecution version that a firearm
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 316/2015
was used.
53.
The testimony of PW-6, the father of the injured, assumes importance
in corroborating the prosecution case. He has deposed that upon hearing the
sound of a gunshot, he rushed to the rear room and found his daughter in an
injured condition, bleeding profusely. Upon inquiry, she immediately
informed him that the Appellant/Accused had fired upon her.
54.
This immediate disclosure is significant as it rules out the possibility
of concoction or false implication. The statement was made at the earliest
point of time, when the injured was in a distressed condition, and therefore
carries a high degree of credibility.
55.
One of the principal submissions advanced on behalf of the
Appellant/Accused is that the name of the Appellant/Accused does not find
mention in the MLC or in the initial DD entry, and that there was a delay in
recording the statement of the injured.
56.
This Court is unable to accept the said contention. The record clearly
reflects that though the injured was declared fit for statement, she was under
the influence of medication and required immediate surgical intervention.
The Investigating Officer has also deposed that the statement could not be
recorded at the initial stage for this reason. In such circumstances, the delay
in recording the statement stands sufficiently explained. The priority, quite
naturally, was to ensure medical treatment and save the life of the injured.
57.
The submission of the Appellant/Accused is that since the injury was
on a non-vital part of the body, namely the thigh, the offence under Section
307 IPC is not made out.
58.
This submission overlooks the principle that intention is not to be
determined solely on the basis of the part of the body where the injury is
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 316/2015
inflicted. The nature of the weapon, the manner of its use, and the
surrounding circumstances are equally, relevant. In the present case, the
Appellant/Accused used a firearm and fired at the complainant/injured after
issuing a clear threat to kill her. The act of firing a gunshot at close range is
inherently dangerous and is capable of causing death.
59.
The fact that the bullet struck the thigh instead of a vital organ
appears to be fortuitous rather than indicative of lack of intention. The act
itself unmistakably reflects the intention contemplated under Section 307
IPC.
60.
The Supreme Court in Jage Ram v. State of Haryana, (2015) 11 SCC
366, held that the nature of injury is not the only factor in determining
intention, and the surrounding circumstances, word used by the accused,
nature of weapon used and overall conduct of the accused must also be
considered. The relevant paragraph from the said case is reproduced
hereinbelow:
“12. For the purpose of conviction under Section
307 IPC, the prosecution has to establish (i) the
intention to commit murder; and (ii) the act done
by the accused. The burden is on the prosecution
that the accused had attempted to commit the
murder of the prosecution witness. Whether the
accused person intended to commit murder of
another person would depend upon the facts and
circumstances of each case. To justify a
conviction under Section 307 IPC, it is not
essential that fatal injury capable of causing
death should have been caused. Although the
nature of injury actually caused may be of
assistance in coming to a finding as to the
intention of the accused, such intention may also
be adduced from other circumstances. The
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 316/2015
intention of the accused is to be gathered from the
circumstances like the nature of the weapon used,
words used by the accused at the time of the
incident, motive of the accused, parts of the body
where the injury was caused and the nature of
injury and severity of the blows given, etc.”
61.
The prosecution has also brought on record prior complaints, namely
Exhibits PW-4/C being complaint letter dated 14th May, 2011 and PW-4/D
being complaint dated 31st March, 2011, which indicate that the
Appellant/Accused
had
been
harassing
and
threatening
the
complainant/injured prior to the incident. The relevant portion of PW-4/C
and PW-4/D are reproduced hereinbelow:
PW-4/C
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
PW-4/D
“िवषय - जान से मारने की कोिशश एवं धमकी दे ने के हे तु क ेन
असद आ रफ नाम के लड़के ने मुझे कमरे म अकेला पा कर
13.5.2011 की रात 9:15 pm के आस-पास मेरे कमरे के पीछे
वाले दरवाज़े पर दो बार प र फका व खंचकर दरवाज़ा खोला
िफर मुझे जान से मारने की कोिशश व धमकी दी। उसने अपने
हाथ म चाकू ले रखा था मेरे िच ाने पर वह जान से मारने की
धमकी दे कर भाग गया।
असद आ रफ रोज़ मेरे घर के आस-पास ही घूमता रहता है । मुझे
डर है िक वह मुझे व मेरे प रवार वालों को नुकसान प ँ चा सकता
है ।
मने पहले भी असद आ रफ के खलाफ 31 माच 2011 को एक
िल खत क ेन (क ेन नं. 56B) भी की थी। इसके बावजूद भी
असद आ रफ ने मुझे जान से मारने की कोिशश एवं धमकी दी।
मेरे घर के फोन पर फोन करके परे शान व धमिकयाँ दे रहा है ।
इस लड़के ने हम डराने के िलए मेरे, मेरी बहन सीमा व मेरे
सीिनयर सर आलोक कुमार पर झूठा F.I.R. भी दज िकया है ।
असद आ रफ ऐसे दोबारा झूठे आरोप म हम फँसा के झूठा F.I.R.
करा सकता है ।“
“िदनां क - 31 माच 2011
एस.एच.ओ. ओखला
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 316/2015
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
62.
जािमया नगर, नई िद ी
िवषय - कायदे कानून पर कारवाई की मां ग
िनवेदन है िक असद आ रफ (पता - 640/9 ए जािकर नगर, फोन
नंबर 0958994285) का रहने वाला है । ये लड़का रोजाना मुझे और
मेरे प रवार को जान से मारने की धमकी दे ता है । इसके अलावा
चेहरे पर तेजाब फकने की धमकी भी दे ता है । कृपया इस मनचले
युवक के खलाफ नीचे िलखे मामलों म रपोट दज कर कारवाई
की जाए। भिव म मेरे और मेरे प रवार के िकसी भी सद के
साथ िकसी तरह की घटना घटती है तो इसके िलए िज ेदारी इसी
लड़के की माना जाए...
24 माच को असद आ रफ ने मुझे मेरे घर पर आकर धमकाया
और मेरे साथ सरे आम हाथापाई की, मेरे घरवालों के सामने जान
से मारने की धमकी भी दी।
25 माच को मेरे इं
ूट म जाकर मेरे साथ दु वहार िकया और
रा े म मुझे मारने की धमकी दी, तब सुर ा कारणों के चलते मेरे
सीिनयर साथी मुझे घर छोड़कर गए।
ये युवक मुझे मारने के िलए हिथयार लेकर मेरे घर के आसपास
घूमता रहता है । िजसके चलते मेरे घर वालो को बाहर िनकलने म
परे शानी होती है और हम लोग भय के साये म जी रहे ह।
असद आ रफ नाम का ये लड़का खुदकुशी कर मुझे और मेरे
प रवार को फंसाने की धमकी भी दे ता है ।
ये लड़का मुझे बदनाम करने और घर वालों को मारने की धमकी
दे ता है ।
अतः आपसे अनुरोध है िक इस युवक के खलाफ स
से स
कारवाई की जाए, आपका सदा आभारी र ं गी।“
These complaints reveal a pattern of conduct including stalking,
intimidation, and threats which lends credence to the prosecution case that
the incident was not sudden but was preceded by sustained hostility. The
testimony of PW-6 also corroborates this aspect, wherein he has stated that
the Appellant/Accused had, on the previous day, threatened that he would
enter the house and shoot the complainant/injured.
63.
As regard to the submission of non-recovery of the weapon of offence
made by the Appellant/Accused, this Court is of the view that in the facts of
the present case, the same is not fatal. The direct testimony of the injured
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 316/2015
witness, corroborated by medical evidence establishing a gunshot injury and
recovery of a bullet, is sufficient to sustain the conviction.
64.
Upon a holistic evaluation of the evidence on record, this Court is
satisfied that, the presence and identity of the Appellant/Accused stand
firmly established. The act of firing a gunshot at the complainant/injured
stands proved and the injury sustained by the complainant/injured is directly
attributable to the said act, also the intention of the Appellant/Accused, as
reflected from prior threats and use of a firearm, squarely attracts Section
307 IPC.
65.
The findings returned by the ld. Trial Court are based on a proper and
reasoned appreciation of evidence and do not suffer from any infirmity
warranting interference.
66.
Insofar as the sentence is concerned, the ld. Trial Court has imposed a
sentence of simple imprisonment for three years along with a fine of Rs.
1,05,000/-, out of which Rs. 1,00,000/- was directed to be paid to the
complainant/injured.
67.
This Court finds the said sentence to be proper, keeping in view the
nature of the offence, the manner in which it was committed, and the
surrounding circumstances. No ground is made out for interference.
68.
It is further noted that pursuant to directions issued during the
pendency of the present appeal, the ld. Additional Sessions Court and the
State Bank of India, Zakir Nagar, New Delhi were directed to furnish the
status of the Fixed Deposit Receipt created out of the compensation amount.
69.
A report has been received from the ld. Additional Sessions Court
indicating that the FDR No. 34929864410, remains operative and the
accumulated amount presently stands at Rs. 1,93,746/- according to the
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 316/2015
report dated 2nd February, 2026.
70.
This Court further notes that the injury suffered by the
complainant/injured is of a serious nature involving a firearm, and the
trauma endured by her cannot be adequately compensated merely by the
amount awarded by the ld. Trial Court.
71.
Considering, the nature of the offence under Section 307 IPC, the use
of a firearm, the grievous injury suffered by the victim and the long-term
impact on her life, this Court is of the view that additional compensation
deserves to be awarded.
72.
Accordingly, it is directed that the Appellant/Accused shall pay an
additional sum of Rs. 2,00,000/- to the complainant/injured Ms. Muskan.
The said amount shall be deposited within a period of eight weeks from
today before the ld. Trial Court.
73.
Upon deposit, the same shall be released to the complainant/injured
without any condition.
74.
In case of failure to deposit the said amount within the stipulated
period, the ld. Trial Court shall take appropriate steps in accordance with
law.
75.
Further, it is directed that the FDR referred to above, along with
accrued interest and the enhanced compensation, shall be released in favour
of the complainant/injured Ms. Muskan, in accordance with law.
76.
In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court finds no merit in the
present appeal.
77.
Sentence of the Appellant/Accused was suspended vide order dated
6th May, 2015. Vide the present Judgment, the Impugned Judgment dated
31st January, 2015 and order on sentence dated 24th February, 2015 has been
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 316/2015
confirmed.
78.
As per the Nominal Roll dated 24th February, 2015, the
Appellant/Accused had already served one year, three months, seven days.
Accordingly, the Accused shall surrender before the ld. Trial Court on or
before 6th May, 2026, to serve the remaining period of his sentence.
79.
The appeal is, accordingly, dismissed. Pending applications, if any,
stand disposed of. The conviction and sentence of the Appellant/Accused
under Section 307 IPC, as recorded by the ld. Trial Court are upheld except
the fine amount, which is modified as directed above.
80.
A copy of this order be communicated to concerned Jail
Superintendent for necessary compliance and information.
MADHU JAIN
JUDGE
PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUDGE
APRIL 24, 2026/P
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
19:48:03
CRL.A. 316/2015
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review