Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:15303
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P.(S) No. 2662 of 2026
-Arvind Thakur, aged about 50 years, son of Late Harihar
Thakur, resident of Village & P.O.- Rondiyah, P.S.Saraiyahat, District-Dumka
......Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand
2. The Divisional Commissioner, Santhal Pargana Division,
Dumka, P.O. & P.S.- Dumka, District - Dumka.
3. The Deputy Commissioner, Dumka, P.O. & P.S.- Dumka,
District - Dumka.
4. The Deputy Collector (Establishment), Dumka, P.Ο. &
P.S.-Dumka, District - Dumka.
5. The Circle Officer, Saraiyahat Circle, P.O. & P.S.Saraiayahat, District - Dumka.
...Respondents
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK ROSHAN
For the Petitioner(s)
For the Respondents
02/27.04.2026
: Mr. Kumar Harsh, Advocate
: Mr. Arun Kumar Dubey, A.C to G.P.-III
--
The instant writ application has been preferred
by the petitioner for quashing the order of dismissal dated
29.03.2025; whereby the petitioner has been dismissed
from service. The petitioner has further assailed the
appellate order dated 21.10.2025 which has sustained the
order of dismissal. The petitioner has also prayed for
consequential benefit including the back wages.
2.
Briefly stated, the petitioner while posted as
Nazir in the office of Circle Officer, Saraiyahat was
suspended vide order dated 3.10.2017. The petitioner was
issued charge-sheet vide Memo dated 08.02.2018 and he
filed his response to the charge-sheet.
In
the
meantime,
the
suspension
of
the
petitioner was revoked vide order dated 14.07.2020 as
2026:JHHC:15303
contained in Order No.95/2020. Thereafter, the petitioner
was issued second show-cause notice dated 16.07.2024
along with enquiry report dated 29.6.2020 finding the
petitioner to be guilty. The petitioner filed his reply on
20.07.2024 to the first and second show-cause notice. The
petitioner was again issued second show-cause dated
01.10.2024, against which the petitioner filed his reply on
08.10.2024. For the third time, the petitioner was issued
show-cause finding the previous replies to be unsatisfactory
vide last show-cause dated 18.03.2025, against which the
petitioner
filed his reply
on 21.3.2025.
Finally, the
petitioner has been dismissed from his service vide order
dated 29.03.2025 as contained in Memo No. 245.
3.
Thereafter, the petitioner preferred an appeal on
the ground that no oral witness was adduced to prove the
documents and therefore it is a case of "No Evidence". The
appellate authority vide order dated 21.10.2025 passed in
Service Appeal No. 17/2025-26, without application of
mind and in complete non-determining the issues and
points raised by the petitioner has summarily dismissed the
appeal
of
the
petitioner
and
affirmed
the
order
of
punishment.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that
neither any oral inquiry was conducted by the I.O.; nor any
witness was produced by the prosecution department to
prove the documents, and neither any of the documents
2026:JHHC:15303
were exhibited, which makes it abundantly clear that it is
case of "No evidence". The documents, which have been
relied on by the prosecution has never been exhibited nor
tendered during departmental proceedings. Only on pen
and
paper
process
was
adopted
in
departmental
proceedings. During the period of suspension, starting from
03.10.2017 to 17.07.2020, i.e. during the departmental
proceeding, no subsistence allowance; nor any salary was
paid to the petitioner. Neither any complainant was
deposed, nor any witness was produced by the department
in
the
departmental
proceedings,
and
therefore,
the
opportunity of cross-examining the witnesses does not
arise.
5.
The
contention of learned counsel for the
petitioner by pointing out the Inquiry report that no oral
witness has been examined in this case in order to prove
the charge; this Court is of the considered opinion that now
it is a settled principle of law that, save and except any
document which is kept in ordinary course of business, the
Inquiry officer has to take oral evidence in order to prove
the charge against the delinquent and he should not
become departmental representative.
6.
This issue has been decided right from the
judgment of Roop Singh Negi vs. Punjab National Bank1
followed by State of Uttar Pradesh vs. Saroj Kumar
(2009) 2 SCC 570
2026:JHHC:15303
Sinha2 and then in the case of Satyendra Singh Vs. State
of Uttar Pradesh and Another 3 deciding the same
principle that any charge is to be proved by oral evidence.
Recently, also in the case of Jai Prakash Saini vs.
Managing Director, U.P. Cooperative Federation Ltd. 4
the same issue has been re-deliberated.
7.
Learned counsel for the respondents defended
the impugned order and submits that the petitioner has
been charge-sheeted for a grave offence; however, he was
unable to point out from the Inquiry report that any
witness has been examined on the question of examination
of oral witness in order to prove the charge has already
been settled.
8.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and
after going through the documents available on record and
also the Inquiry report, it is crystal clear that there is no
any reference of list of witness.
9.
The Hon’ble Apex Court in the catena of
judgments right from the celebrated judgment of Roop
Singh Negi (supra) then in the case of Saroj Kumar Sinha
(supra) has dealt the importance of Inquiry Officer and oral
evidence.
(2010) 2 SCC 772
2024 SCC OnLine SC 3325
2026 SCC OnLine SC 505
2026:JHHC:15303
Recently also, in the case of Ram Prakash
Singh (supra) and also in the case of Jai Prakash Saini
(supra), the same issue has been re-deliberated.
In the case of Ram Prakash Singh (supra) there
is an observation of the Hon’ble Apex Court that since the
judgment
of
Saroj
Kumar
Sinha
(supra),
still
the
departments are committing the same mistake which is
observed at para 16 of the said judgment. For brevity the
relevant paragraphs of the aforesaid judgment passed by
the Hon’ble Apex Court is extracted hereinbelow:
“13. In Roop Singh Negi v. Punjab National Bank, it was held
that an officer conducting an enquiry has a duty to arrive at
findings in respect of the charges upon taking into consideration the
materials brought on record by the parties. It has also been held
therein that any evidence collected during investigation by an
investigating officer against the accused by itself could not be
treated to be evidence in the disciplinary proceedings.
14. What follows from a conjoint reading of the above two
decisions is and what applies here is that, ‘materials brought on
record by the parties' (to which consideration in the enquiry ought to
be confined) mean only such materials can be considered which are
brought on record in a manner known to law. Such materials can
then be considered legal evidence, which can be acted upon.
Though the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 is not strictly applicable to
departmental enquiries, which are not judicial proceedings,
nevertheless, the principles flowing therefrom can be applied in
specific cases. Evidence tendered by witnesses must be recorded in
the presence of the delinquent employee, he should be given
opportunity to cross-examine the witnesses and no document
should be relied on by the prosecution without giving copy thereof to
the delinquent - all these basic principles of fair play have their root
in such Act. In such light, the documents referred to in the list of
documents forming part of the annexures to the chargesheet, on
which the department seeks to rely in the enquiry, cannot be
treated as legal evidence worthy of forming the basis for a finding
of guilt if the contents of such documents are not spoken to by
persons competent to speak about them. A document does not prove
itself. In the enquiry, therefore, the contents of the relied-on
documents have to be proved by examining a witness having
knowledge of the contents of such document and who can depose
as regards its authenticity. In the present case, no such exercise
was undertaken by producing any witness.
15. We may further refer to the decision of this Court in State of
Uttar Pradesh v. Saroj Kumar Sinha17 where disciplinary
proceedings were drawn up against the respondent, Saroj Kumar
Sinha, under the 1999 Rules itself with which we are concerned.
Paragraphs 26 to 30 and 33 of the said decision being relevant are
quoted below:
“26. The first inquiry report is vitiated also on the ground that
the inquiry officers failed to fix any date for the appearance of
2026:JHHC:15303
the respondent to answer the charges. Rule 7(x) clearly
provides as under:
‘7. (x) Where the charged government servant does not
appear on the date fixed in the inquiry or at any stage of
the proceeding in spite of the service of the notice on him
or having knowledge of the date, the inquiry officer shall
proceed with the inquiry ex parte. In such a case the
inquiry officer shall record the statement of witnesses
mentioned in the charge-sheet in absence of the charged
government servant.’
27. A bare perusal of the aforesaid sub-rule shows
that when the respondent had failed to submit the
explanation to the charge-sheet it was incumbent upon
the inquiry officer to fix a date for his appearance in the
inquiry. It is only in a case when the government servant
despite notice of the date fixed failed to appear that the
inquiry officer can proceed with the inquiry ex parte.
Even in such circumstances it is incumbent on the inquiry
officer to record the statement of witnesses mentioned in
the charge-sheet. Since the government servant is absent,
he would clearly lose the benefit of cross-examination of
the witnesses. But nonetheless in order to establish the
charges the Department is required to produce the
necessary evidence before the inquiry officer. This is so
as to avoid the charge that the inquiry officer has acted
as a prosecutor as well as a judge.
28. An inquiry officer acting in a quasi-judicial authority
is in the position of an independent adjudicator. He is
not supposed to be a representative of the
department/disciplinary
authority/Government. His
function is to examine the evidence presented by the
Department, even in the absence of the delinquent official
to see as to whether the unrebutted evidence is sufficient
to hold that the charges are proved. In the present case
the aforesaid procedure has not been observed. Since no
oral evidence has been examined the documents have
not been proved, and could not have been taken into
consideration to conclude that the charges have been
proved against the respondents.
29. Apart from the above, by virtue of
Article 311(2) of
the Constitution
of
India the
departmental enquiry had to be conducted in accordance
with the rules of natural justice. It is a basic requirement
of the rules of natural justice that an employee be given a
reasonable opportunity of being heard in any proceedings
which may culminate in punishment being imposed on
the employee.
30. When a departmental enquiry is conducted
against the government servant it cannot be treated as a
casual exercise. The enquiry proceedings also cannot be
conducted with a closed mind. The inquiry officer has to
be wholly unbiased. The rules of natural justice are
required to be observed to ensure not only that justice is
done but is manifestly seen to be done. The object of
rules of natural justice is to ensure that a government
servant is treated fairly in proceedings which may
culminate in imposition of punishment including
dismissal/removal from service.
***
33. As noticed earlier in the present case not only the
respondent has been denied access to documents sought
to be relied upon against him, but he has been
condemned unheard as the inquiry officer failed to fix
any date for conduct of the enquiry. In other words, not
a single witness has been examined in support of the
charges levelled against the respondent. The High Court,
2026:JHHC:15303
therefore, has rightly observed that the entire
proceedings are vitiated having been conducted in
complete violation of the principles of natural justice and
total disregard of fair play. The respondent never had
any opportunity at any stage of the proceedings to offer
an explanation against the allegations made in the
charge-sheet.”
(emphasis ours)
16. It appears that the appellant is yet to take lessons
despite the admonition in Saroj Kumar Sinha (supra). The
same kind of omissions and commissions that led to setting
aside of the order of punishment imposed being upheld by
this Court were repeated in the present case.”
(emphasis supplied)
10.
Having regard to the admitted position; the
impugned order of dismissal and appellate order, both are
quashed and set aside. The respondents are directed to
reinstate the petitioner in service forthwith, but in any case
not beyond the period of 6 weeks from the date of receipt of
a copy of this order.
The matter is remitted to the stage of enquiry
proceeding from the stage of examination of witness.
Thereafter, the disciplinary authority shall pass a fresh
order after following natural justice and settled proposition
of law.
11.
It goes without saying that so far as back wages
is concerned; since the matter has already been remitted,
the petitioner is not entitled for the same and the same is
dependent on the fresh order.
12.
So far as consequential benefits are concerned,
the same shall be decided by the respondents and this
court has not given any finding with regard to merits of the
case or about the back wages.
2026:JHHC:15303
13.
Accordingly, the instant writ application is
allowed. Pending I.A(s), if any, stands closed.
(Deepak Roshan, J.)
27th April, 2026
Jk
Uploaded on
21/05/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review