Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
W.P.(C) 13597/2025
ARVIND MOHAN DWIVEDI
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Akhil Solanki, Advocate.
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ANR.
Through:
.....Respondents
Ms. Arunima Dwivedi, Ms. Himanshi
Singh and Ms. Monalisha Pradhan,
Advocates for R-2.
Mr. Abhishek Saket, SPCG with Mr.
Manish Madhukar, Mr. Abhigyan and
Ms. Reya Paul, Advocates for UOI.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
%
1.
ORDER
21.04.2026
The Petitioner was appointed as a Senior Hindi Translator in
Educational Consultants India Ltd.,1 a Government of India undertaking, on
30th July, 1993. His service record at the initial stage was not unblemished,
inasmuch as his probation was extended by one year with effect from 15 th
September, 1994 on account of 47 instances of unauthorised absence.
Thereafter, on 25th September, 1998, a memorandum of charges containing
four Articles of Charge was issued to him, inter alia, on allegations of
furnishing false information and repeated absence without leave,
culminating in the imposition of a penalty of reduction in pay scale by four
stages vide order dated 15th September, 1999.
W.P.(C) 13597/2025
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 24/04/2026 at 13:24:43
2.
Subsequently, on 11th January, 2000, the Petitioner was placed under
suspension, and a fresh memorandum of charges dated 15 th February, 2000
came to be issued containing ten Articles of Charge. The said charges,
which arose from a complaint made by one Ms. Ritu, a former employee of
EdCIL, and forwarded by the National Commission for Women, inter alia
alleged suppression of a prior marriage, contracting a second marriage on
the basis of purportedly forged divorce documents, and submission of false
affidavits. The aforesaid allegations also formed the basis of criminal
proceedings initiated against the Petitioner, culminating in the registration of
FIR No. 600/2000 at P.S. Uttam Nagar.
3.
The disciplinary proceedings that followed were not founded on any
disputed evidentiary inference. The record placed before the Court shows
that, during the inquiry, the Petitioner made a written statement before the
Inquiry Officer acknowledging that he had gone through the articles of
charge and the statement of imputations, expressly pleaded guilty,
acknowledged that such plea could be used against him, and stated that there
was no need to proceed further with the inquiry because he had pleaded
guilty to all the charges. The statement bears his signatures as well as those
of the Presenting Officer and the Inquiry Officer, and reads as under:
“EdCIL”
W.P.(C) 13597/2025
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 24/04/2026 at 13:24:43
4.
After the inquiry report dated 27th April, 2000 held the charges
proved, the Petitioner submitted a further reply dated 23rd May, 2000. That
communication, on a fair reading, cannot be construed as a withdrawal of
the plea of guilt; rather, it constitutes a reiteration of the position earlier
adopted by the Petitioner. He stated that he had “not denied the fact of
committing mistake”, sought forgiveness, expressed regret for bringing bad
W.P.(C) 13597/2025
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 24/04/2026 at 13:24:43
name to the Corporation, referred to the settlement with Ms. Ritu, and ended
by asking for “one more chance”. That reply is inconsistent with the case
now sought to be developed before this Court that there had never been any
admission at all. The said letter reads as under:
“To
The Manager (P&A)
EDCL
Sector IEA, Noida- 201301
Subject: Submission of Representation against Inquiry Report
Respected Sir,
With due respect it is to state that I want to submit my representation
against the inquiry Report through the points given below:
1.
It is true that I had not denied the fact of committing mistake, but here it is
to mention that at the time of inquiry I have been convinced by the inquiry
officer that the conclusion of all the charges alleged to me “is marrying
another girl having a living spouse.” For this only I committed my mistake.
2. If we go through ….. inquiry from article I to article X of the charge sheet
given at Annexure, I have many points to place which are given below.
a) I have not produced any order of family court for any purpose. However,
a petition, seeking divorce from my wife Mrs: Neelam Dwivedi vide No
819/97 was filed by me and Ritu who was closed by me was aware of this
incident. Consequently she started living me and took the advantage of
getting marry with me. This order had been managed my Ritu in which her
parents and partner was involved.
b) Many times in the chargesheet city court Kanpur is mentioned. Here I
have nothing to say that my case for divorce was filed in the family court not
at city court.
c) In the article XI have been charged for leaving her. In this regard I want
to repeat it again that this separation was not mutual understanding
because Ms. Ritu and I were not in good family …. Since Ritu was having
contacts with many other persons like Kapil Singla, working in …..
Authority of India ltd. Bankehand Road, Auranchal building, New Delhi,
Yogendra Singh working in LIC M block Connaught place etc; so I had
objections on all type of such activities. Also, she was non corporative. All
theses circumstances made me realize that I was better enough wife (legally
wedded) Mrs. Neelam Dwivedi.
C-I:- ultimately we both Ritu and I decided to leave each other. But her
parents and brother lodged a complaint at NCW alleging the false charges
on me.
W.P.(C) 13597/2025
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 24/04/2026 at 13:24:43
C-II:- again, I want to clear that Mrs. Ritu is habitual of giving false
information and has checked many times to Government set ups also. For
example,
i) When she joint EDCL, she had not applied through proper channel timing
during 1995-96.
ii) She is presently working in EPFO organization Nehru place, New Delhi
as Asst. ….. Officer
iii) She was selected through open vacancy …. By UPSC “234 Vacancies of
AAO/ enforcement officer in M/O Labor.” She was interviewed for the post
mentioned above in the month of Jan-Feb 1999. At the time of interview she
was suppose to fill-up and attestation form in which a number of personal
and curriculum vitae entries were made by Ms. Ritu. In such attestation
form she declared herself unmarried. Is this not contradictory that one side
she has shown herself married w.e.f 26.5.98 and another side, to take
advantage of Reservation (as she belongs to SC …. She is showing herself
unmarried.
iv) Like UPSC, from 26.5.98 she has applied for PO in Bhopal and
Bangalore Region, in GIC, … etc every where she has shown herself
unmarried.
C-III:- The charge I have hurted her or done any fraudulent behavior
against her is also denied.
3. For any kind of Bad Name to the corporation I am extremely sorry and
nothing more to say in this regard that it all happened due to reverse caring
of my stars which have diverted me from the right path.
4. It is time that she has lodged a complaint in NCW against me. This
progress about the case I have been submitting from time to time to you.
Therefore, about the involvement of NCW I have nothing more to say that I
final statement has been sing between both the parties i.e. Ritu and me. In
permanance of the settlement I have deposited Rs. 50,000/- at NCW for
compensation to Ritu, and Rs. 10,000/- for legal consultancy fee. A final
amount would be provided to me with a copy to our office in EDCL within
15 days from the date of submission of this representation.
5. In pursuance of Final Settlement signed by above mention both parties,
Ritu had filed a petition at the court of ….. addl. District and Session judge,
Karkardooma, Shahdara, Delhi- 32, on this above mentioned petition the
judgment is annexed on the 22 day of May 2000 before both the parties
which is as under:
THE MARRIAGE BETWEEN ARVIND MOHAN DWIVEDI RESPONDENT
NO. 1 AND THE PETITIONER MS. RITU IS DECLARED NULL AND
VOID.
The decision may be verified from the above court giving the reference of
Suit No.- 77/2000.
1.
HUMBLE REQUEST
Lastly, you are kindly requested to forgive me for all kinds of my acts
W.P.(C) 13597/2025
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 24/04/2026 at 13:24:43
related to this case following “To ERR IS HUMAN and To forgive IS
DIVINE” or (KSHAMA BARAN KO CHAHIYE).
2. It is also well known hindi phrase “SUBHA KA BHULA AGAR SHAM KO
GHAR AA JAYE TO USE BHULA NHI KAHTE”
3. I assure you not to repeat any kind of activity which is unbecoming or
breaking the integrity. Kindly, give me one more chance in the interest of
social justice and in favor of me.
4.
Thanking you with kind regards,
Sincerely yours,
Sd/ARVIND MOHAN DWIVEDI
May 23, 2000”
5.
On consideration of the inquiry report, the record of the proceedings,
and the Petitioner’s reply dated 23rd May, 2000, the disciplinary authority
passed the order dated 18th July, 2000 dismissing the Petitioner from service.
The disciplinary authority specifically recorded that the inquiry had been
conducted fairly, that the Petitioner had been given full opportunity, that he
had pleaded guilty before the Inquiry Officer, and that the gravity of the
proved misconduct, along with his past record, rendered him unfit to be
retained in service. The said order reads as follows:
“I have carefully gone through all the records and facts of the case. Shri
Arvind Mohan Dwivedi was informed of the charges framed against him
vide chargesheet dated 15th February, 2000. A detailed inquiry was
ordered and held into the charges alleged. Inquiry Officer has submitted his
report vide his letter dated 27.4.2000. Copy of the inquiry report was
forwarded to Shri Dwivedi vide letter dated 7th May, 2000 giving him an
opportunity to make his submission against the inquiry report.
After careful consideration of the records, i.e., inquiry report, relevant
records of inquiry consisting of daily order sheet, correspondence, exhibits,
the submissions made by charge sheeted employee vide his letter dated 23 rd
May, 2000, I find that the inquiry had been conducted in a fair and
equitable manner. Delinquent employee was given full opportunity to defend
his case. Principles of natural justice have been adhered to while
conducting the inquiry proceeding by inquiry authority. My findings and
observations on the reply dated 23rd May, 2000 of Shri Dwivedi are as
under:-
W.P.(C) 13597/2025
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 24/04/2026 at 13:24:43
1.
The article of charges alleged against Shri Dwivedi was read over
to him during inquiry proceedings. He accepted before the Inquiring
Authority that he had gone through the article of charges including the
statements of imputation of misconduct and he pleaded guilty to the
charges.
2.
No comments.
(a) Shri Arvind Mohan Dwivedi had submitted an affidavit dated 20th May,
1998 to the Arya Samaj Mandir, West Patel Nagar, New Delhi declaring
that he is a divorcee and has obtained judgement dated 22nd April, 1998 in
his favour. He also produced a copy of the order of Family Court, Kanpur
dated 22nd April, 1998 purported to be an order granting him divorce from
his wife Mrs. Neelam Dwivedi to the Mandir authorities so as to marry Ms.
Ritu. Thus the intention of Shri Dwivedi was malafide. His explanation that
the order was managed by Ms. Ritu is not convincing.
(b) No comments
(c) Ms. Ritu in her complaint dated nil to the National Commission for
Women had clearly made allegations against Mr. Dwivedi for cheating and
fraudulent marriage. A copy of which was also sent to Ed.CIL by the
Commission for taking necessary action. There was no mention about the
mutual separation by Ms. Ritu in her complaint to the National Commission
for Women. Therefore, the contention of Mr. Dwivedi with regard to mutual
separation is not tenable. As regards contacts of Ms. Ritu with other
persons, this is not relevant to the present case.
(i) The complaint was lodged by Ms. Ritu to the National Commission of
Women and not by her brother and parents as stated by Mr. Dwivedi.
(ii) (i, ii, iii, iv) Does not have any relevance to the present case.
(iii) Shri Dwivedi got married to Ms. Ritu on 26.5.1998 in spite of the fact
that he had a spouse living. Thereafter he left Ms. Ritu who filed a
complaint against him in National Commission for Women for fraudulent
marriage and cheating. The above act on the part of the Mr. Dwivedi
clearly indicate his fraudulent behaviour and cheating.
3.
Shri Dwivedi has accepted the fact that by his acts he has brought
bad name to the Corporation and has regretted the same.
4.
Does not have any relevance to the present case.
5.
It has been proved from the evidences available that Mr. Dwivedi
who was legally married to Ms. Neelam contracted another marriage with
Ms. Ritu which is in violation of Conduct, Discipline and Appeal Rules
applicable to him.
After careful perusal of the inquiry report and the submission made
by Shri Dwivedi, I fully agree with the findings of the inquiry report.
I, therefore, conclude that all the charges alleged against Shri
Dwivedi vide chargesheet dated 15th February, 2000 stand proved beyond
any shadow of doubt.
W.P.(C) 13597/2025
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 24/04/2026 at 13:24:43
The past record of Shri Dwivedi show that he was awarded with a
penalty of reduction in basic pay at the minimum of the scale for five years
for the misconducts committed by him vide order dated 15th September,
1999. Considering the gravity of misconduct now proved viz. failure to
maintain integrity, commission of an act involving moral turpitude, act
subversive of discipline/good behaviour, contracting second marriage while
having a spouse living, acts unbecoming of a public servant and the past
record of Shri Dwivedi, the undersigned is convinced that Shri Dwivedi is
not a fit person to be retained in the employment in the interest of the
Corporation and I am of the opinion that good and sufficient reasons exist
for imposition of penalty of ‘Dismissal’ on Shri Dwivedi.
Accordingly in order to meet the ends of justice, I impose the
following penalty on Shri Arvind Mohan Dwivedi, Supervisor (Hindi) under
Rule 23 of Ed.CIL Conduct, Discipline and Appeal Rules:"Shri Arvind Mohan Dwivedi, Supervisor (Hindi) is hereby dismissed
from service with immediate effect."
Further since the charges alleged against Shri Dwivedi have been fully
proved and in accordance with the Clause 22 of Ed.CIL Conduct, Discipline
and Appeal Rules the period of suspension cannot be treated as duty. I
order that the period of suspension of Shri Dwivedi from 11.01.2000 to date
be treated as leave without pay. He will accordingly not be entitled for any
pay during the period of suspension. However, subsistence allowance to the
extent of 50%/75% of pay already paid to him will not be recovered.
(Y MEDURY)
DISCIPLINARY AUTHORITY”
6.
The Petitioner did not pursue the departmental remedies then
available to him. He did not file any appeal against the dismissal order. On
the contrary, he accepted the order and, by his own request, sought release
of his final dues, whereupon an amount of ₹22,949/- was released to him. It
is only after more than two decades that he addressed a representation dated
27th September, 2023 seeking reinstatement with arrears and consequential
benefits. That representation was rejected by a reasoned communication
dated 17th July, 2025, which reiterated the circumstances in which the plea
W.P.(C) 13597/2025
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 24/04/2026 at 13:24:43
of guilt had been recorded and correctly pointed out that the subsequent
acquittal in the criminal case did not undo the departmental action already
taken. The said order passed 17th July, 2025, which reads as follows:
“No. 11(142)/93-Adm. Date: 17.07.2025
To
Mr. Arvind Mohan Dwivedi
2A, Thakur Vihar Colony, Faridi Nagar
Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh-226015
Subject: Reference to Representation Regarding Reinstatement and
Related Claims.
Sir,
This is with reference to your undated representation addressed to the
Chairman & Managing Director, EDCL, in which you have alleged
wrongful dismissal from the post of Supervisor (Hindi), and have sought
reinstatement along with payment of arrears from the date of dismissal,
citing the judgment dated 27.09.2023 passed by the Hon’ble Dwarka Court
in FIR No. 600/2000 titled ‘State v. Arvind Mohan’. In this regard, it is
pertinent to place certain facts on record for your information.
A chargesheet dated 15.02.2000, containing ten articles of charge, was
issued to you (Annexure-A) on the complaint of Ms. Ritu, ex-employee.
Subsequently, the Inquiring Authority, Mr. S.R. Gera, issued a notice dated
27.03.2000 (Annexure-B), scheduling the preliminary hearing for
11.04.2000. The hearing was duly conducted on the said date, during which
you appeared before the Inquiring Authority and expressed your intent to
make a voluntary statement admitting to all charges. You were clearly
informed that any such statement could be used against you, to which you
affirmed your understanding. Despite this, you chose to plead guilty, stating
that your decision was made voluntarily and without any external pressure.
Your statement was then formally recorded and signed by you, the Inquiring
Authority, and the Presenting Officer (Annexure-C & D).
In your recorded statement, you confirmed that you had received and
reviewed the Articles of Charge and the Statement of Imputation of
Misconduct. You explicitly pleaded guilty, acknowledged the implications of
your statement, and declined to proceed further with the inquiry, citing your
admission of guilt. Relevant excerpts from your statement are as follows:
“Question: Have you gone through Articles of Charges and the Statement of
Imputation of Misconduct, copies of which have already been supplied to
you?
W.P.(C) 13597/2025
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 24/04/2026 at 13:24:43
Answer: Yes
Question: Do you plead guilty?
Answer: Yes
Question: Are you aware that this statement of your pleading guilty can be
used against you?
Answer: Yes
Question: Do you wish to proceed with the inquiry?
Answer: No, because I have pleaded guilty of all the charges and, therefore,
there is no need to proceed with the inquiry.
Question: Have you fully understood the implications of your statement?
Answer: Yes.”
Based on this confession, the Inquiring Authority submitted the Inquiry
Report dated 27.04.2000 (Annexure-E) to the Disciplinary Authority,
concluding that all charges were proved. The report was shared with you
for your response, and in your reply dated 23.05.2000 (Annexure-F), you
reiterated your admission of guilt.
Taking into consideration the gravity of the charges and your repeated
admission, the Disciplinary Authority imposed the penalty of dismissal from
service vide Office Order No. 11(142)/93-Adm. dated 18.07.2000
(Annexure-G). Following the dismissal, you accepted the order and, via
your letter dated 21.07.2000 (Annexure-H), requested the release of your
final dues. Accordingly, a final payment of Rs. 22,949 was disbursed to you
through Cheque No. 687408 dated 01.09.2000.
It is further pertinent to clarify that no appeal was preferred by you against
the order dated 18 July 2000. Therefore, the assertion made in your
representation that an appeal was submitted within the prescribed period of
60 days and was neither considered nor responded to is factually incorrect
and misleading.
It is pertinent to highlight that Ms. Ritu, in addition to lodging an internal
complaint with the organization, which led to the initiation of disciplinary
proceedings against you under the EDCL CDA Rules, also filed a police
complaint resulting in the registration of FIR No. 600/2000 at Uttam Nagar
Police Station, Delhi. The said criminal case has since been concluded by
the Hon’ble Trial Court vide judgment dated 27.09.2023. In this context, it
is important to clarify that criminal proceedings and departmental
(disciplinary) proceedings are distinct and operate independently of each
other. An acquittal in a criminal case does not automatically exonerate an
individual from charges that have been duly proved in departmental
proceedings. This legal principle has been consistently affirmed by the
Hon’ble Courts, including the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India. Notably, in
Ajit Kumar Nag v. General Manager (P.J.), Indian Oil Corporation Ltd.,
W.P.(C) 13597/2025
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 24/04/2026 at 13:24:43
(2005) 7 SCC 764, the Supreme Court reiterated that disciplinary action
can be sustained independently of the outcome of criminal proceedings, as
the two are governed by different standards of proof and serve distinct
purposes. Relevant excerpts from the above-mentioned order are
reproduced below for your reference:
“Acquittal by a criminal court would not debar an employer from
exercising power in accordance with rules and Regulations in force.
The two proceedings criminal and departmental are entirely different.
They operate in different fields and have different objectives. Whereas
the object of criminal trial is to inflict appropriate punishment on the
person who commits an offence, the purpose of enquiry proceedings is
to deal with the delinquent departmentally and to impose penalty in
accordance with service Rules. In a criminal trial, incriminating
statement made by the accused in certain circumstances or before
certain officers is totally inadmissible in evidence. Such strict rules of
evidence and procedure would not apply to departmental proceedings.
The degree of proof which is necessary to order a conviction is
different from the degree of proof necessary to record the commission
of delinquency. The rule relating to appreciation of evidence in the
two proceedings is also not similar. In criminal law, burden of proof
is on the prosecution and unless the prosecution is able to prove the
guilt of the accused ‘beyond reasonable doubt’, he cannot be
convicted by a court of law. In departmental enquiry, on the other
hand, penalty can be imposed on the delinquent officer on a finding
recorded on the basis of ‘preponderance of probability’. Acquittal of
the appellant by a Judicial Magistrate, therefore, does not ipso facto
absolve him from the liability under the disciplinary jurisdiction of the
Corporation.”
In view of the foregoing, it is evident that the disciplinary proceedings
against you were conducted strictly in accordance with the principles of
natural justice and the established EDCL CDA Rules. The penalty of
dismissal was imposed following your voluntary and unequivocal admission
of guilt after being duly informed of the consequences of your plea. It must
be reiterated that the departmental inquiry and the criminal trial are
independent proceedings governed by different standards and objectives.
Therefore, the acquittal in the criminal case does not, in any manner,
invalidate the findings of the departmental inquiry or the sanction imposed
thereon. Consequently, your request for reinstatement and payment of
arrears lacks legal or factual basis and, as such, cannot be granted. You are
advised to consider the matter closed from the organization’s perspective.
Regards,
Sd/U.S. Gaikwad
W.P.(C) 13597/2025
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 24/04/2026 at 13:24:43
General Manager (HR & Admin)”
7.
The first and immediate obstacle in the Petitioner’s path is the
extraordinary delay. The dismissal order is dated 18th July, 2000. The
present challenge has been mounted only after roughly twenty-five years.
That delay is not explained in any legally persuasive manner. In service
jurisprudence, stale claims are not revived merely because an employee
chooses, long afterwards, to send a representation. The Supreme Court has
repeatedly cautioned that writ jurisdiction is not meant to reopen such dead
claims after prolonged and unexplained delay, and that a belated
representation does not furnish a fresh cause of action.2
8.
The Petitioner seeks to overcome that difficulty by placing reliance on
the judgment dated 27th September, 2023 rendered in the criminal
proceedings arising out of FIR No. 600/2000. That submission, however,
does not assist him. The criminal court acquitted the Petitioner because the
prosecution failed to prove the offences beyond reasonable doubt, the
complainant was not examined, and the evidentiary foundation necessary for
conviction was not brought on record. That is a criminal law conclusion on
the standard applicable to criminal trials. It does not, without more, reopen
or invalidate a departmental order passed in 2000 on an altogether different
footing.
9.
The law on this aspect is settled that criminal proceedings and
departmental proceedings operate in distinct fields, are governed by
different objectives, and proceed on different standards of proof. Acquittal
by a criminal court does not ipso facto absolve an employee from liability
The Chief Executive Officer & Others v. S. Lalitha & Others 2025 INSC 565
W.P.(C) 13597/2025
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 24/04/2026 at 13:24:43
under disciplinary jurisdiction. In departmental proceedings, the test is one
of preponderance of probability, not proof beyond reasonable doubt. The
Supreme Court has stated this in clear terms in Ajit Kumar Nag v. Indian
Oil Corpn. Ltd.,3 and has reiterated the same distinction in later cases as
well.4
10.
In the present case, the Respondent’s position rests on a still stronger
foundation. The disciplinary finding was not based merely on a disputed
evidentiary record. It was preceded by the Petitioner’s own written plea of
guilt and followed by a subsequent representation which did not retract that
plea, but substantially acknowledged misconduct and prayed for pardon. In
such a situation, the contention that the inquiry is vitiated for want of
examination of witnesses is wholly misplaced. The insistence on proof
through evidence ordinarily arises where the delinquent disputes the charges
and the employer nevertheless seeks to establish serious misconduct without
leading proof. That, however, is not the position in this case. The record
discloses that the plea of guilt was accepted and acted upon by the
disciplinary authority, and that the Petitioner, having neither pursued any
departmental remedy nor questioned the findings at the relevant time,
allowed the order of dismissal to attain finality. His subsequent conduct,
including seeking release of terminal dues, is also consistent with an
acceptance of the disciplinary outcome.
11.
Further, this Court, in exercise of judicial review, does not sit as an
appellate forum over such findings. Once the record shows a voluntary plea
of guilt, acknowledgment of its implications, and a subsequent
(2005) 7 SCC 764
See: State of Karnataka v. Umesh, (2022) 6 SCC 563
W.P.(C) 13597/2025
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 24/04/2026 at 13:24:43
representation again seeking forgiveness, there is no warrant in law to
reopen the factual foundation of the disciplinary action after such prolonged
delay. Judicial review in disciplinary matters is confined to the decisionmaking process and not to a fresh reappreciation of facts as though this
Court were hearing an appeal.
Conclusion
12.
The Petitioner’s belated representation of 2025, and the order passed
thereon, did not revive a challenge that had become hopelessly stale long
ago. A dismissal order that had stood unquestioned for years could not be
drawn back into controversy merely by addressing a representation to the
employer after more than two decades. The petition, therefore, fails at the
threshold on account of gross delay and laches, and fails on merits as well.
The later acquittal in the criminal case does not alter that position. It does
not wash away a departmental order founded on the Petitioner’s own plea of
guilt, his subsequent request for forgiveness, and the distinct standard
governing disciplinary proceedings.
13.
The writ petition is accordingly dismissed. Pending application(s), if
any, shall also stand disposed of.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
APRIL 21, 2026
nk
W.P.(C) 13597/2025
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 24/04/2026 at 13:24:43
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review