Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:12097
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
A.B.A. No. 7285 of 2025
Arun Pati Tripathi, aged about 57 years, son of P.P. Tripathi, resident
of Qr. No. 1A, Street No.SPA, Sector – 9, Bhilai, P.O. Bhilai, P.S.
Sector – 6, Bhilai, District Durg, Chhattisgarh.
…
…
Petitioner
Versus
The State of Jharkhand through Anti-corruption Bureau
…
…
Opposite Party
--CORAM :HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANUBHA RAWAT CHOUDHARY
--For the Petitioner
: Mr. Shishir Prakash, Advocate
M/s Karuna Krishan Tharya
[Both through V.C.]
: Mr. Bibhash Sinha, Advocate
: Mr. Manish Kumar, Advocate
For the Opp. Party
: Mr. Sumeet Gadodia, Advocate
: Mr. Ritesh Kumar Gupta, Advocate
: Mr. Nillohit Choubey, Advocate
: Ms. Shruti Shekhar, Advocate
: Ms. Sanya Kumari, Advocate
--CAV on: 16.04.2026
Pronounced on 24.04.2026
This anticipatory bail application has been filed by the
petitioner who is apprehending arrest in connection with ACB P.S.
Case No. 09/2025 for the offence registered under Sections 61(2) read
with Sections 318, 336, 340, 316/45 and 49 of the Bharatiya Nyaya
Sanhita, 2023 and Sections 7(c), 12, 13(2) read with Section 13(1)(a)
of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 said to be pending in the
court of learned Special Judge, Vigilance, ACB, Ranchi.
2.
Arguments of the Petitioner
A. All the main accused and beneficiaries of this case have either
been granted bail or default bail or anticipatory bail. So far as the
petitioner is concerned, he is not a named accused and he is the
Managing Director of Chhattisgarh State Marketing Corporation
Limited (hereinafter referred to as CSMCL). CSMCL being a
Government Organization, the opposite party could not have
proceeded in absence of sanction in terms of Section 17A of the
Prevention of Corruption Act (hereinafter referred to as the P.C.
Act) as amended.
B. In Chhattisgarh, there was substantial collection of State Excise
2026:JHHC:12097
Revenue and therefore, the State of Jharkhand also started
consulting the State of Chhattisgarh, so that a similar model or
module could be adopted in the State of Jharkhand as well. In
terms of negotiation between the State of Chhattisgarh and State
of Jharkhand, it was agreed that CSMCL would be an advisor to
Jharkhand State Beverages Corporation Limited (hereinafter
referred to as JSBCL) in the State of Jharkhand, so that the excise
revenue can be increased in the State of Jharkhand as well.
C. The State of Chhattisgarh and the State of Jharkhand are
independent state and are competent to take independent policy
decision and both the States have acted as per their policy and
ultimately by virtue of policy decision of the State of Jharkhand,
CSMCL became an advisor to JSBCL. Since the petitioner was
the Managing Director of the CSMCL, he had a role to play in the
advisory capacity to the JSBCL.
D. The arrangement between the two states was penned down in the
form of an agreement which was akin to a policy decision and
CSMCL continued to be the advisor of JSBCL for a period from
04.02.2022 till 13.03.2022. As per the terms and conditions itself,
the CSMCL is not to be responsible for consequence any of its
advice in the capacity of advisor.
E. So far as the FIR is concerned, it starts with an allegation that the
bank guarantees, which were furnished in connection with
manpower agencies, were found to be fake and so far as the
petitioner is concerned, it is alleged that the petitioner had paid
Rs. Five Crore to Vinay Kumar Choubey, the secretary, excise
department of the State of Jharkhand, to be appointed as advisor.
F. Once the petitioner was the Managing Director of the CSMCL, he
had no option, but to act as Managing Director of CSMCL and
there was no occasion for the petitioner to participate in the policy
making of the Chhattisgarh State or Jharkhand State.
G. All the decisions have been taken by the State of Jharkhand and
their authorities and the entire transaction relating to the liquor
policy and consequential decisions are exclusively within the
domain of State of Jharkhand. The petitioner has no role to pay at
all and ex-facie no case is made out against the petitioner. The
petitioner is not at all connected with the State of Jharkhand.
3.
While explaining the reason for not appearing before the
investigating authority in the present case pursuant to notice issued
2026:JHHC:12097
under Section 35(3) of BNSS, the learned counsel for the petitioner
has submitted as under: i.
Similar FIR was lodged against the petitioner in Chhattisgarh
State and he was arrested and ultimately the matter reached the
Hon’ble Supreme Court and the petitioner was directed to be
released on bail in terms of the order passed in Cri. Appeal No.
1263/2025. He submits that as per the conditions of bail, the
petitioner was required to report before the Investigation Officer
of the case every day at 10:00 a.m. commencing from 10th April
2025.
ii.
The learned counsel has submitted that right from 10th April
2025, the petitioner is abiding the order of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court and is appearing before the investigating agency in
Chhattisgarh every day without any fault. The learned counsel
submits that once he is under the direction of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court to appear before the authority at Chhattisgarh
every day at 10:00 a.m., it was impossible for him to abide by the
notice issued by the State of Jharkhand under Section 35(3) of
BNSS.
iii.
In the present case, the notice was issued under Section 35(3) of
BNSS through e-mail, which is not as per the mandate of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court passed in the case of Satyendra Kumar
Antil vs. CBI and other cases. He has further submitted that the email was responded by the petitioner through counsel stating that
it was not possible for the petitioner to participate in the
investigation conducted by the authority at Jharkhand as he was
under a legal obligation to appear before the authorities at
Chhattisgarh pursuant to the order of the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
The learned counsel submits that on account of such a situation,
the petitioner is unable to leave the State of Chhattisgarh even for
one day.
iv.
He submits that it was for the opposite party herein to approach
the Hon’ble Supreme Court for appropriate orders, so that the
petitioner may participate in the investigation in the State of
Jharkhand.
However, the fact that the petitioner has been appearing
4.
pursuant to the order of the Hon’ble Supreme Court from 10th April
2025 on each and every day is not on record. To which, the learned
counsel for the petitioner submits that he can still produce
appropriate material to substantiate this aspect of the matter.
2026:JHHC:12097
5.
The learned counsel for the petitioner has also submitted that
the authority at Chhattisgarh has not filed charge-sheet against the
petitioner till date. He has also submitted that Binay Kumar Singh,
who is the owner of Mahindra Nexgen Showroom, Ranchi and who is
alleged to have good relationship with Vinay Kumar Choubey, has
been granted anticipatory bail by the learned district court, but the
order of anticipatory bail is not available with him.
6.
Arguments of the Opposite Party - ACB
(a) Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the opposite party-ACB
has opposed the prayer and has submitted that there was a seachange in the policy with respect to retail liquor vend. Earlier the
retail liquor license was to be given to individual persons and
JSBCL was primarily the coordinating authority. However, by
virtue of change in the policy, JSBCL became the whole sole
authority so far as the retail liquor vend is concerned, inasmuch
as, they owned the liquor shops and they simply appointed
manpower agencies to operate the liquor shop.
(b) The learned counsel further submits that all the placement
agencies, which were working at Chhattisgarh, were also
appointed for the purposes taking up the job of placement
agencies in the State of Jharkhand as well. He submits that the
modus-operandi, which was adopted in the State of Chhattisgarh,
was also extended to the State of Jharkhand, in which the
petitioner and three other co-accused persons, namely, Anwar
Dhebar, Arbind Singh and Vikash Agrawal have played major
role.
(c) He submits that in the month of January 2022, Rs. Five Crore was
handed over to Vinay Kumar Choubey who was the Secretary of
the Excise Department of the State of Jharkhand and that money
was handed over by the Arun Pati Tripathi, the present petitioner,
along with Anwar Dhebhar who visited the residence of Vinay
Kumar Choubey at Ranchi along with one Vidhu Gupta. The
learned counsel submits that following persons have got their
statement recorded under section 183 B.N.S.S :i. Case Diary No. 27 Navendu Shekhar
ii. Case Diary No. 56 Vidhu Gupta
iii. Case Diary No. 49 Amit Mittal
iv. Case Diary No. 55 Sanjeev Jain
(d) The learned counsel for the A.C.B. has produced the statement of
2026:JHHC:12097
Navendu Shekhar, Vidhu Gupta, Amit Mittal and Sanjeev Jain all
recorded under Section 183 BNSS and by referring to the same,
he has submitted that the entire modus-operandi with respect to
the involvement of the petitioner has been narrated by each one of
them. He has submitted that the statement recorded under Section
183 of Cr.P.C. certainly has great relevance and therefore the
petitioner is required for custodial interrogation.
(e) The learned counsel has also submitted that the statement under
Sections 161 of Cr.P.C. [equivalent to Section 180 of BNSS] may
not have much value, but the statement under Section 164 of
Cr.P.C. [equivalent to Section 183 of BNSS] has certain
evidentiary value, which in the present case connects the
petitioner with the alleged offence.
(f) The learned counsel submits that it’s a case of deep-rooted
conspiracy and therefore custodial interrogation of the petitioner
is required. The petitioner is required to be confronted with the
other co-accused persons during the course of interrogation and
therefore the petitioner is not entitled for anticipatory bail.
(g) The learned counsel has further submitted that the inability of the
petitioner to appear before the authority in Jharkhand does not
reflect from his statement made in the anticipatory bail
application. Further, the learned counsel has referred to paragraph
16 of the anticipatory bail application to submit that the only
excuse for not appearing before the authority in Jharkhand was
that in absence of any sanction for prosecution under Section 17A
of P.C. Act, he was not required to appear. In paragraph-16, a
reply was said to have been sent with respect to the aforesaid
stand of the petitioner.
(h) The learned counsel has further referred to Section 197 of Cr.P.C.
as it stood earlier dealing with required sanction for prosecution
and Section 17A of P.C. Act as amended with effect from
26.07.2018 and has submitted that the terminology used therein
are different. Section 197 of Cr.P.C. is much wider in purport as
compared to Section 17A of P.C. Act. He has submitted that under
Section 197 of Cr.P.C., the terminology used is “while acting or
purporting to act in the discharge of his official duty” and in
Section 17A of P.C. Act, the terminology used is “where the
alleged offence is relatable to any recommendation made or
decision taken by such public servant in discharge of his official
functions or duties”.
2026:JHHC:12097
(i) The learned counsel has referred to the judgment passed by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court reported in (2015) 13 SCC 87 [Inspector
of Police & Anr. vs. Battenapatla Venkata Ratnam & Anr.],
paragraph 7, 9 and 10 and has submitted that any act of taking or
giving bribe, as involved in the present case, does not require any
prosecution sanction. However, in the counter-affidavit, a
statement has been made that the A.C.B. has taken steps for
getting sanction for prosecution by way of abundant precaution.
7.
Rejoinder of the petitioner.
The learned counsel for the petitioner, in rejoinder, referred to the
judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court reported in (2020) 2
SCC 338 [Yashwant Sinha & Anr. vs. CBI & Anr.], paragraph 117
and submitted that without prior sanction, there can be neither any
inquiry nor any enquiry nor any investigation against a public servant.
The learned counsel has submitted that the entire action of the
opposite party is vitiated on account of want of sanction under Section
17A of P.C. Act.
8.
After hearing the learned counsel for the parties and
considering the materials placed on record, this court finds that the
case of the prosecution, as per the written complaint of Vinay Kumar
Ram, the Investigating officer ACB, Ranchi, which forms the basis of
FIR, is that in July 2023 Jharkhand State Beverages Corporation
Limited (JSBCL) engaged two placement agencies for the supply of
manpower at its retail liquor stores. It has been alleged that the said
placement agencies: (i) M/s Vision Hospitality Services & Consultants
Pvt. Ltd, and (ii) M/s Marshan Innovative Security Services Pvt. Ltd.,
submitted bank guarantees to JSBCL. Subsequently, on account of
some violations on their part, the said bank guarantees were sought to
be encashed, then it was revealed that those bank guarantees were
fake. Hence, FIR was filed against 13 accused persons which also
included Mr Vinay Kumar Choubey, who was posted as Principal
Secretary of Excise and Prohibition Department, Government of
Jharkhand at the relevant point of time along with other officials of
Excise Department and also the private placement agencies who had
provided fake bank guarantees at the time of submission of documents
2026:JHHC:12097
to JSBCL.
9.
After institution of FIR, during the course of investigation and
on the basis of the evidences collected, it was revealed that the
petitioner Arun Pati Tripathi had close links with the FIR named
accused and the main accused Vinay Kumar Choubey, Principal
Secretary of Excise and Prohibition Department, Government of
Jharkhand and the petitioner was found to be the key conspirator in
commission of the alleged offences causing great financial loss to the
State of Jharkhand. It also transpired that in the month of January
2022, Rs.5,00,00,000 (five crore) was handed over to said Vinay
Kumar Choubey and that money was handed over by the Arun Pati
Tripathi, the present petitioner, along with Anwar Dhebhar who
visited the residence of Vinay Kumar Choubey at Ranchi along with
one Vidhu Gupta.
10.
The opposite party has stated that the statements of following
persons have been recorded under section 183 B.N.S.S:a. Case Diary No. 27 Navendu Shekhar
b. Case Diary No. 56 Vidhu Gupta
c. Case Diary No. 49 Amit Mittal
d. Case Diary No. 55 Sanjeev Jain
The learned counsel for the A.C.B. has produced the statements of
Navendu Shekhar, Vidhu Gupta, Amit Mittal and Sanjeev Jain, all
recorded under Section 183 BNSS during the course of hearing and
for purposes of fairness, the learned counsel for the petitioner also had
the occasion to have a look at those statements.
11.
The opposite party has referred to the counter affidavit to
highlight the evidences that surfaced during the investigation, wherein
it has been stated as under: I.
One Amit Mittal in his statement recorded under Section 180 of
BNSS (corresponding of Section 161 of Cr.P.C) has stated that
Arun Pati Tripathi was Managing Director of CSMCL and during
the work in the State of Chhattisgarh, he met the Petitioner.
Thereafter the Petitioner was appointed as advisor in JSBCL.
Further the said witness stated that the Petitioner along with one
Anwar Dhebar paid a sum of Rs.5 crores to Vinay Kumar
Choubey as bribe, so that the Petitioner becomes advisor in
2026:JHHC:12097
JSBCL. The said fact is recorded at paragraph 491 of CD.
II.
Statement of one Siddharth Singhania was recorded under Section
180 of BNSS (corresponding of Section 161 of Cr.P.C) and it was
revealed that the Petitioner was appointed as advisor in JSBCL.
The said fact is recorded at Para 413 of CD.
III.
Statement of Gajendra Singh has also been recorded under 180 of
BNSS (corresponding of Section 161 of Cr.P.C), and, it was
revealed that the Petitioner being the Managing Director of
CSMCL along with one Janardhan Singh (who most probably was
Inspector in the Excise Department of Chhattisgarh) used to come
and meet the then Secretary namely Vinay Kumar Choubey, and,
due to good relations with Vinay Kumar Choubey, Petitioner used
to bully the officials of JSBCL. The said fact is recorded at Para
134 of CD.
IV.
One Sanjeev Jain, Rajeev Dwivedi, Manish Jain (all directors of
Prima One Work Force Private Limited) were recorded under
Section 180 of BNSS (corresponding of Section 161 of Cr.P.C)
and, it has been stated that during talks with Shiddharth
Singhania, it was informed that Vidhu Gupta, Arun Pati Tripathi
(Petitioner herein) and Anwar Dhebar met Vinay Kumar Choubey
at officials residence, where the Petitioner and Anwar Dhebar
handed over bag to Vinay Kumar Choubey which contained
money around 5 to 6 crores. The said fact is recorded para 521 of
CD.
V.
Statement of one Non-F.I.R accused namely Vidhu Gupta was
recorded under Section 180 of BNSS (corresponding of Section
161 of Cr.P.C) and the said witness stated that in the year 2022, he
came to Ranchi and Anwar Dhebar along with Arun Pati Tripathi
also came to Ranchi by road from Chhattisgarh, and the said
persons took the witness to meet Vinay Kumar Choubey at his
official residence. Further, the said witness also revealed that even
discussions were done in respect of the liquor policy and
thereafter Anwar Dhebar and Arun Pati Tripathi took out 4-5 bags
from their car which contained Rs.5 crores and the same was
handed over to Vinay Kumar Choubey and the said person
willingly accepted the said amount. Further the said witness also
stated that Vinay Kumar Choubey told that now onwards the
entire things would be looked after by Binay Kumar Singh who
owns Mahindra Nexgen showroom at Ranchi, and, good
relationship developed between the aforementioned persons, and,
when the work of supply of liquor was started, thereafter, on
2026:JHHC:12097
VI.
interval of 15 days or a month, Anwar Dhebar used to send money
to Vinay Kumar Singh. The said fact is recorded at para 506 of
CD.
Navendu Shekher (F.I.R. named accused) in his statement
recorded under Section 183 of BNSS (corresponding of Section
164 of Cr.P.C.), on 17.06.2025 has stated that Vinay Kumar
Choubey, Arun Pati Tripathi and Siddharth Singhania were the
master mind of entire liquor tender and the said persons got the
tender conditions altered so that commission of Placement
Agencies became higher and loss was caused to Government.
VII.
Even statement of one Non-F.I.R. accused has also been recorded
us 183 of BNSS on 25.07.2025 and in his statement, it has also
been stated that Arun Pati Tripathi along with one Anwar Dhebar
handed over 4 to 5 bags containing money amounting to Rs. 5
crores to Vinay Kumar Choubey at his official residence as
"Shagun" and Vinay Kumar Chaubey happily and willingly
accepted the same.
VIII.
Further even statement of another witness has been recorded
under Section 183 of BNSS on 16.07.2025, and even the said
witness has disclosed the role of the petitioner in the entire liquor
scam and has further stated that amount of Rs. 5 crores were
already handed over to Vinay Kumar Choubey at his residence
and the deal has been finalized.
12.
Statement of several other witnesses has been recorded under
Section 183 of BNSS on 24.07.2025 and in which the role,
participation and involvement of the Petitioner in the entire liquor
scam has been duly surfaced and revealed by the said witness.
13.
With regard to non-cooperation of the petitioner in the
investigation of the present case, it has been specifically stated by the
opposite party in the counter affidavit that even notice dated
01.08.2025, under Section 35(3) of BNSS was issued by the
Investigating officer to the petitioner directing him to appear on
08.08.2025. However, the petitioner did not appear on the scheduled
date and as such it would be evident that the petitioner is not
cooperating in investigation of the instant case.
14.
It is not in dispute that the petitioner is an accused for alleged
offence punishable under Sections 420, 467, 468, 471 and 120 B of
2026:JHHC:12097
Indian Penal Code read with Sections 7 and 12 of the Prevention of
Corruption Act, 1988 and his prayer for bail was rejected by the
concerned court in the State of Chhattisgarh. The refusal of bail in the
case at Chhattisgarh was challenged before the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Criminal Appeal No.1263 of 2025 by the present petitioner
and the Hon’ble Supreme Court vide order dated 07.03.2025 while
enlarging the petitioner on bail imposed certain conditions and
observed that the present petitioner will be enlarged on bail on
10.04.2025 subject to appropriate terms and conditions fixed by the
concerned session court and apart from that the following conditions
were directed to be incorporated:
(a) The appellant shall deposit his passport, if he is holding
a passport, with the investigating officer.
(b) He shall report to the Investigating officer every day at
10 a.m; and
(c) Till the charge sheet is filed, he will continue to cooperate with the Investigating officer for investigation.
15.
By referring to the said order of Hon’ble Supreme Court while
granting bail to the petitioner, it has been submitted that the petitioner
is bound to report to the Investigating officer of the case every day at
10 a.m., and therefore, he is unable to respond and participate in the
investigation conducted by the opposite party in the present case
instituted in the State of Jharkhand. Further, it has been submitted that
in the absence of sanction under Section 17A of the P.C. Act, the
entire investigation conducted by the State of Jharkhand in the present
case is void-ab-initio and non-est in the eyes of law.
16.
Both the aforesaid reasons cited for non-participation in the
investigation in the present case are devoid of any merits as is
apparent from the following discussions: A. Non-cooperation in investigation. It has been argued by the
learned counsel for the petitioner that the petitioner had
responded to the notice issued under Section 35 (3) of BNSS,
informing the opposite party about his aforesaid difficulty in
appearing in Jharkhand due to the directions of the Hon’ble
2026:JHHC:12097
Supreme Court, and is therefore not in a position to cooperate
with the investigation in the State of Jharkhand.
In anticipatory bail application, it has not been mentioned by
the petitioner as to whether the interrogation of the petitioner by
the Anti-corruption Bureau at Chhattisgarh has been completed
and whether even after expiry of about one year from the
directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, the petitioner is still
required to appear before the investigating authority in
Chhattisgarh on every day at 10.00 a.m.
Rather, it has further been submitted that it was for the State of
Jharkhand to take steps before the Hon’ble Supreme Court for
modification of the order with regard to conditions of bail
imposed upon the petitioner to appear before the Investigating
officer of the case at Chhattisgarh every day at 10.a.m. Such
arguments are devoid of any merits.
The anticipatory bail application filed by the petitioner does not
refer to any difficulty with respect to appearance of the
petitioner before the State of Jharkhand pursuant to the notice
under Section 35 (3) of the BNSS. Rather, the specific case of
the petitioner is that for want of sanction, the authorities in the
State of Jharkhand cannot proceed against the petitioner.
The plea taken by the petitioner for not appearing before the
ACB, Ranchi, Jharkhand as argued by the learned counsel for
the petitioner by referring to the order and conditions of bail
imposed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court is not acceptable.
If the petitioner was facing any difficulty in complying with
the notices issued by the opposite party under Section 35 (3) of
the BNSS, it was for the petitioner to take appropriate steps.
However, no such ground/difficultly has been mentioned in the
anticipatory bail application or even in the rejoinder to the
counter affidavit where the opposite party has alleged noncooperation by the petitioner in investigation.
B. So far as the plea regarding absence of sanction under
Section 17A of P.C. Act for proceeding against the petitioner is
2026:JHHC:12097
concerned, this Court is of the considered view that the learned
court, while rejecting the said plea, has rightly recorded that the
requirement of sanction under Section 17A of Prevention of
Corruption Act arises only when the act of the government
servant constituting an offence relate to any recommendation
made or decision taken by him in discharge of official functions
or duties. The present case is not covered by the circumstances
required for sanction under section 17A when seen in the light
of the allegations made against the petitioner. In such
circumstances, the judgement relied upon by the petitioner
reported in (2020) 2 SCC 338 [Yashwant Sinha & Anr. vs. CBI
& Anr.] does not help the petitioner in any manner.
C. The learned court also recorded that the petitioner was not the
member of any committee constituted by the Government of
Chhattisgarh for submitting proposals regarding amendments in
the Excise Policy, Acts or the Rules of Excise Department,
Government of Jharkhand. Further, the petitioner neither made
any recommendation nor took any decision officially for the
State of Jharkhand in discharge of his official functions or
duties. The allegation against the petitioner is of bribing the
government officials of the State of Jharkhand for illegal gain to
the accused persons and causing wrongful loss to the State
exchequer. Hence, there was no requirement of prior sanction
under Section 17A of Prevention of Corruption Act.
In the present case, the allegation against the petitioner is of
bribing the higher officials of Government of Jharkhand,
therefore, no prior approval or sanction is required to proceed
against the petitioner. However, the opposite party has
submitted that by way of abundant precaution, they have
applied for sanction against the petitioner under Section 17A of
the Prevention of Corruption Act.
17.
This Court finds that there are direct allegations against the
petitioner that the petitioner along with two co-accused paid Rs.5
Crores to Binay Kumar Choubey as bribe in the month of January
2026:JHHC:12097
2022 at the residence of Binay Kumar Choubey, then Secretary of the
Excise Department of the State of Jharkhand.
18.
This Court is of the view that there is direct and serious
allegation against the petitioner and incriminating materials have been
collected during investigation on the record show that the petitioner is
involved in conspiracy in the liquor scam involved in the State of
Jharkhand. This Court is of the considered view that the statement of
witness/co-accused
as
recorded
under
Section
BNSS
(corresponding to Section 164 Cr.P.C) stand on much higher pedestal
as those recorded under Section 180 BNSS (corresponding to Section
161 Cr.P.C) and custodial interrogation of the petitioner would be
necessary so as to confront the petitioner with the statement of the coaccused/witnesses during investigation to come to the truth of the
matter.
19.
This Court finds that on account of complete non-cooperation
from the side of the petitioner and non-participation in the matter of
investigation, the investigation in the State of Jharkhand in connection
with the liquor scam has not proceeded with respect to the allegation
made against the petitioner and also the corresponding allegation
made against Vinay Kumar Choubey. It has been submitted by the
petitioner that Vinay Kumar Choubey has been enlarged on default
bail in the matter.
20.
The details of the anticipatory bail applications of the co-
accused have been mentioned as under:
Name
Thakor
Case no.
Paresh
@
Paresh A.B.A.
Result
No.4597
of
Abhesing Thakor @ Paresh (dated: 14.10.2025)
2025 Dismissed
as
infructuous.
Thakur
Thakor
Vikramsing
Vikramsingh
@ A.B.A.
No.4595
Abhesingh (dated 14.10.2025)
of
2025 Dismissed
infructuous
Thakor @ Thakor Vikremsing
Jagan Tukaram Desai
ABA No.4954 of 2025 (dated: Rejected
10.12.2025)
Kamal Jagan Desai
ABA No.4949 of 2025 (Dated: Rejected
10.12.2025)
as
2026:JHHC:12097
Sheetal Jagan Desai
ABA.
No.4930
of
2025 Rejected
(Dated: 10.12.2025)
Sudhir Kumar Das (Regular B.A. No.8077 of 2025 (dated Dismissed
bail)
17.09.2025)
Asheesh Saurabh Kedia
ABA No.5390 of 2025 (dated: Rejected
as
withdrawn
13.11.2025)
Paramar Bipinbhai @ Bipin A.B.A.
No.4596
of
2025 Rejected
of
2025 Dismissed
Jadavbhai Parmar @ Parmar (dated: 10.11.2025)
Bipin Jadav Bhai
Mahesh Shedge @ Mahesh A.B.A.
No.4604
Sitaram Shedge @ Mahesh S (dated 14.10.2025)
as
infructuous
Shedge
Shyam Jee Sharan @ Shyam ABA No.6244 of 2025 (dated: Rejected
Sharan
04.02.2026)
Md. Tabarak (Regular Bail)
B.A. No.11166 of 2025 (dated Bail granted
04.12.2025)
Deepak
Kumar
@
Dipak B.A. No.11220 of 2025 (dated Bail granted
Kumar (Regular Bail)
04.12.2025)
Arun Lal (Regular Bail)
B.A. No.11219 of 2025 (dated: Bail granted
04.12.2025)
Naresh Kumar (Regular bail)
B.A. No.11221 of 2025 (dated Bail granted
04.12.2025)
Md. Israil Ansari @ Md. B.A. No.11165 of 2025 (dated Bail granted
Israel Ansari (Regular bail)
04.12.2025)
The records of the case further reveals that the anticipatory bail
applications of two accused namely Kamal Jagan Desai and Sheetal
Jagan Desai, were rejected by this Court in A.B.A. No. 4949 of 2025
and A.B.A. No.4930 of 2025 vide orders dated 10.12.2025
respectively. Notice has been issued in the case of the aforesaid two
co-accused by the Hon’ble Supreme Court with an interim order
directing that no coercive steps shall be taken till the next date of
hearing
subject
to
those
petitioners
co-operating
with
the
investigation.
It has also been placed on record that a co-accused namely Binay
Kumar Singh, has been granted anticipatory bail by the learned
Special Judge Anti-corruption Bureau, Ranchi in ABP No.1631 of
2026:JHHC:12097
2025 vide order dated 07.07.2025 by recording that the case was at the
stage of investigation as on the date of the order i.e. 07.07.2025 and at
that stage no direct and specific evidence and materials appeared to be
available against Binay Kumar Singh and anticipatory bail was
granted subject to the conditions mentioned therein.
21.
This Court finds that the grant of anticipatory bail to Binay
Kumar Singh by the learned trial court does not help the petitioner in
any manner in view of the fact that the materials have been collected
against the petitioner, but on account of complete non-cooperation
from the side of the petitioner, the investigation is not proceeding
against the petitioner and related co-accused including Binay Kumar
Choubey, the then Principal Secretary of Excise and Prohibition
Department, Government of Jharkhand.
22.
As a result of the aforesaid discussions, the prayer for
anticipatory bail to the petitioner is rejected.
23.
Let a copy of this order be communicated to the court
concerned through FAX/email.
(Anubha Rawat Choudhary, J.)
Date of pronouncement:24.04.2026
Saurav
Date of Uploading:24.04.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review