Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 7th May, 2026
%
Pronounced on: 4th August, 2026
#
CNR No :
DLHC010798882018
RSA 57/2018, CM APPL. 6551/2019
+
ARUN BIRLA
S/o Moolchand Birla
R/o 2nd Floor, C-1/E, Green Park Ext
New Delhi-110016
Through SPA
Nidhi Newar Biral
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Kunal Kalra, Advocate.
versus
1.
2.
NIRMAL SINGH
S/o Late Shri Khajan Singh
Upper Ground Floor,
C-1/E, Green Park Extension, New Delhi.
YASHWANT JAIN
S/o J.M. Jain
G-6, Aashirwas Complex
D-1, Green Park, New Delhi.
Through:
.....Respondent No.1
.....Respondent No.2
Mr. Prashant Manchanda, Mr. Angad
Singh, Mr. Rohan Pratap Singh and
Mr. Varun, Advocates for R-1.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
The Second Regular Appeal under Section 100 read with Order XLII
of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as „CPC‟), has
been filed on behalf of the Appellant against the Judgment and decree dated
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 57/2018
11.12.2017 of the learned District and Sessions Judge, New Delhi, who has
set aside the Judgment dated 20.07.2017 of the learned Civil Judge, Delhi,
who
had
restrained
the
Defendants/Appellants
from
creating
hindrance/obstruction in the use of the space on the lower Ground Floor, to
park the car by Plaintiff/Respondent No. 1.
2.
The Plaintiffs, Mr. Deshraj Saluja and Mr. Arun Birla, had filed a
Civil Suit No. 26/2016, for directing the Defendant No. 1 to restore the
guardroom and kitchen on the lower Ground Floor; to remove the
construction/encroachment from the parking space in the lower Ground
Floor; to restrain the Defendant No. 1 from using the lower Ground Floor
portion for any other purpose than for guardroom and parking; to remove the
Third Floor of the Property in question; to restrain the Defendant No. 1 for
carrying out illegal and unlawful construction in the Property in question; to
restrain the Defendant No. 1 from permitting installation of a huge
transmission tower on the roof of the Third Floor of the Property in question
and to restrain the Defendant No. 1 from creating any hindrance/obstruction
in using the parking space of the Plaintiff marked as „P-3‟, in the Lower
Ground Floor and further to restrain the Defendant No. 1, from using the
parking space of the Plaintiff.
3.
The facts in brief are that Sh. Som Dutt vide Sale Deed dated
19.11.1958, had purchased a freehold plot bearing No. C-1/E, admeasuring
360 Sq. Yds., situated at Green Park Extension, New Delhi. He sold the plot
to Sh. Khajan Singh vide Sale Deed dated 20.05.1961, who raised the
construction. Sh. Khajan Singh died on 28.01.1988, leaving behind the
registered Will dated 22.05.1980, bequeathing his property to his three sons,
namely, Sardar Pritam Singh, Sardar Balwant Singh and Sardar Nirmal
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 57/2018
Singh (Defendant No. 1). Sardar Pritam Singh died on 15.10.1995 and his
share was transferred to his wife, Smt. Surjeet Kaur. The Property was
divided amongst the three brothers, through a registered Family Settlement
dated 09.07.2004, by virtue of which, the Defendant No. 1 became the
absolute owner of the portion admeasuring 120 Sq. Yds.
4.
The Defendant No. 1, Sardar Nirmal Singh, demolished the old
construction and reconstructed his portion wherein the lower Ground Floor
was kept for parking three big cars, as well as, guardroom with a toilet and
kitchen was constructed. The Defendant No. 1 executed the Sale Deed dated
12.07.2006 in respect of First Floor, in favour of Smt. Abhilasha Jain. In
addition to the portion on the First Floor, the Defendant No. 1 also
transferred one separate car parking on the lower Ground Floor to her. The
Plaintiff No. 1, Sh. Deshraj Saluja, purchased the First Floor from Smt.
Abhilasha Jain, by virtue of registered Sale Deed dated 29.06.2007.
5.
The Second Floor of the Property along with one individual car
parking in the lower Ground Floor, was sold by Defendant No. 1, to Smt.
Kavita Jain vide registered Sale Deed dated 12.07.2006. She sold the Second
Floor to Smt. Anita Lubhana, through the registered Sale Deed dated
27.06.2007. The Plaintiff No. 2, Sh. Arun Birla, purchased the Second Floor
from Smt. Anita Lubhana, vide registered Sale Deed dated 11.07.2008
whereby he became the owner of the Second Floor and one individual car
parking on the lower Ground Floor. Although the Defendant No. 1 agreed to
sell the upper Ground Floor to the Defendant No. 2, but certain inter se
disputes arose between them and the sale documents have not been executed
as the upper Ground Floor is in the possession of the Defendant No. 1.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 57/2018
6.
It was claimed that the Defendant No. 1 got tempted to make unlawful
gains for himself by illegally permitting use of guardroom for commercial
activity. He allowed the Guard Room to be used for commercial use to M/s
Maruti Courier. He also unauthorisedly covered one car parking space,
which was meant for upper Ground Floor occupant and allowed it to be used
by one Tantarik. When Smt. Anita and the Plaintiff No. 1, raised objections
about this misuse, the portion given to the Tantarik, was taken back by the
Defendant No. 1. However, it has now been given to M/s Natural Hair
Weaving Centre, who are running their Hair Treatment Clinic, from this
portion.
7.
The Plaintiff claimed that the lower Ground Floor was agreed to be
used for three car parking spaces, with one car parking given to each Floor
owner. The Defendant No. 1 has no right to use the guardroom and the
kitchen, for the commercial purpose.
8.
It was claimed that the persons using these commercial spaces, were
not educated and most of them used filthy and abusive language even while
talking to themselves and making indecent gestures towards the women and
when they were requested to behave, they picked quarrels.
9.
Since the Plaintiffs were repeatedly demanding from the Defendant
No. 1, to remove the encroachment and to stop the commercial use, the
Defendant No. 1, in retaliation, started giving threats to cause interference
and obstruction in the parking of vehicles of the Plaintiffs and their guests.
The roof of the building is meant for common facilities such as T.V.
antenna, Dish Antenna, Water tanks, drying of clothes etc. However, the
Defendant No. 1 is in the process of allowing M/s Reliance Communication,
to install a huge transmission tower on the roof of the Third Floor. The
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 57/2018
generator is also installed at the terrace, to provide non-stop electricity for
running this Tower. It is further claimed that the Third Floor has been raised
illegally, but the foundation is not strong to take such erection of
transmission Tower or the illegal construction.
10.
The Plaintiffs thus, filed the present Suit seeking to restrain the
Defendants from illegal use of the lower Ground Floor, to raise
unauthorised construction and to restrain the Defendant No. 1 from creating
hindrance/obstruction in their using the car parking space in the lower
Ground Floor.
11.
The Suit was contested by the Defendant No. 1, Sh. Nirmal Singh,
who took the preliminary objections that the dispute in regard to the subject
matter of the Property, is under consideration before the learned Arbitral
Tribunal, constituted pursuant to Arbitration Agreement dated 13.04.2005
between the Defendant No. 1, Sh. Nirmal Singh and the Defendant No. 2,
Sh. Yashwant Jain. The present Suit is, therefore, liable to be dismissed.
12.
It is further claimed that this suit has been filed by the Plaintiffs at the
behest of the Defendant No. 2, to overreach the proceedings pending before
the Arbitral Tribunal. The material facts have been in deliberately concealed
by the Plaintiffs, who are not entitled to relief under the Specific Relief Act.
13.
It is further submitted that the Plaintiffs have no locus standi to
maintain the Suit, against the Defendant No. 2. There is no cause of action
disclosed in the Plaint. Furthermore, the Plaintiffs have no personal interest
in the subject matter inasmuch as, the Ground Floor of the building has been
in the exclusive ownership/possession/control and use of the Defendant No.
1. The Suit has been filed mala fide and is not maintainable.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 57/2018
14.
On merits, the contents of the Plaint, were denied. It was claimed that
the Plaint has not disclosed any cause of action and is liable to be dismissed.
15.
The Defendant No.1, Sh. Nirmal Singh, in his Written Statement
explained the background of the dispute in regard to the allotment of one car
parking space in the Lower Ground Floor. He stated that Defendant No.2,
Yashwant Jain who is in the business of real estate, had approached
Defendant No.1 Nirmal Singh in March, 2005 through a Property Dealer for
an Agreement with respect to the share of Defendant in property bearing
No.C-1/E, Green Park Extension, New Delhi and offered to raise four floor
building on the said property after erasing old construction existing and in
occupation of the Defendant No.1. The Defendant No.1 and 2 stated that the
whole process of construction of four floors, would take not more than nine
months to one year from the date of commencement of work. The estimated
cost of construction of the building with average modern amenities were
estimated by Defendant No.2 as approximately Rs.30 lakhs. Defendant No.2
agreed to pay the estimated cost of construction to Defendant No.1 and also
advanced sale consideration for the purchase of flats @ Rs.23 lakhs per
floor.
16.
Thereafter, it was agreed that construction would be at Defendant
No.1‟s cost and that the construction would be carried out under the joint
supervision of both the parties.
It was further agreed that the balance
amounts towards the sale of each floor, would be payable on completion of
construction, handing over of physical possession and on execution and
registration of the Sale Deed, after obtaining permission from the concerned
office in favour of Defendant No.2 or its nominee. It was specifically
agreed between Defendant No.1 and 2 that Ground Floor would be used for
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 57/2018
commercial purpose by Defendant No.1, his nominee/assignee and shall not
be subject of sale transaction between the parties.
17.
Based upon these terms, Defendant No.1 entered into an Agreement
with Defendant No.2. However, the Defendant No.2 who is in the trade of
real estate, etc. fraudulently obtained signatures of Defendant No.1 on
various papers and documents from time to time, by wrongfully persuading
Defendant No.1 herein that all the documents were in accordance with the
terms and conditions as agreed above including the Agreement dated
13.04.2005.
18.
The Defendant No.1 claimed that he, being an uneducated person who
could not read and understand any language except Gurumukhi, became a
victim of fraud of Defendant No.2 and his associates. Defendant No.2 on
the basis of misrepresentation that payment of balance amount would be
payable on the registration of Sale Deed, completed the construction of flats
and also modified the same, as suggested by Defendant No.1 from time to
time. The extra facility of lift and genset on 50:50 basis of the total cost was
subject to the mutual consent.
19.
The sale conditions and terms were only for raising four floors on the
entire area of land, in the possession of Defendant No.1. There was no
Agreement between the parties in respect of three individual car parking
sites for three big cars on the Ground level that was to be sold by Defendant
No.1.
However, Defendant No.2 got prepared an Agreement dated
13.04.2005 which does not reflect the real and true terms of the Agreement
between the parties. The Defendant No.1 came to know about these facts, at
a much later stage.
At the time of execution of Agreement dated
13.04.2005, Defendant No.2 only made a payment of Rs.7 lakhs, out of
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 57/2018
which Rs.5.50 lakhs was paid in cash and Rs.1.50 lakhs was paid by way of
cheque. No subsequent payment ever was received in cash.
20.
The Defendant No.1 started the work at site and in the whole process
of construction, Defendant No.2 illegally created another Agreement dated
01.07.2005. With intention to defeat the claims of recovery of Defendant
No.1 arising out of two Sale Deeds, executed in terms of Agreement dated
13.04.2005, Defendant No.2 first wanted the execution and registration of
Sale Deed with respect to the Upper Ground Floor of the property in
question and even got a Sale Deed dated 05.12.2005 prepared.
When
Defendant No.1 insisted for payment in terms of the Agreement, Defendant
No.2 failed to make payment and under these circumstances, the registration
of Sale Deed dated 05.12.2005, was put on hold.
21.
However, Defendant No.2 started exerting undue pressure on
Defendant No.1 and indulged in illegal Complaints and Notices. During this
period, Defendant No.2 was also in touch with Defendant No.1 and had been
assuring that the balance payment was being arranged and would be paid on
production of proposed Sale Deed for registration and handing over of
physical possession of the flats in question.
22.
The Defendant No.1 thus, agreed to execute the Sale Deeds with
respect to First Floor and Second Floor and further agreed to rescind the
Agreement with respect to the Upper Ground Floor. Under the misleading
assurance of Defendant No.2, the Sale Deed was executed in favour of Smt.
Abhilash Jain and Smt. Kavita Jain on 12.07.2006 respectively, being
nominees of Defendant No.2 who got the Sale Deeds registered for First and
Second Floor respectively. The Defendant No.1 claimed that he had never
agreed to execute any Sale Deed with Parking, as the same was never in the
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 57/2018
terms of Agreement and there was over writing in this regard in the original
Sale Agreement.
23.
It is submitted that after the execution of Sale Deeds in respect of
First and Second Floor, Defendant No.2 failed to clear the outstanding dues
of Rs.16,84,000/- with respect to First and Second Floor of the building,
having fraudulently got executed and registered the Sale Deeds. He kept on
deferring the payment of the balance amount on one pretext or the other.
Defendant No.2 was left with no right, title, interest in the Upper Ground
Floor of the property.
24.
The Defendant No.1 accordingly issued Legal Notice dated
05.07.2007 to Defendant No.2 and his nominees demanding payment of the
balance amount, as well as seeking appropriate Undertaking as to no claim
and rights in the alleged Parking space on the Ground Floor. Defendant
No.2, however, failed to comply with the Legal Notice, but gave a false and
frivolous Reply.
25.
Although, burden of all misc. expenses and for taking steps for
registration of Sale Deed on the purchaser, yet the Defendant No.2 failed to
discharge his obligation of paying the balance amount after execution and
registration of the Sale Deeds, in respect of First Floor and Second Floor of
the property in question.
26.
Defendant No.2 filed a Suit No.123/2006 against Defendant No.1
and his family members, around September, 2006, before the District &
Sessions Court. The Defendant appeared in the said proceedings and filed
an Application under Section 8 Arbitration and Conciliation Act, which was
allowed vide Order dated 14.12.2006. The Suit was dismissed.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 57/2018
27.
Defendant No.2 filed RFA No.235/2007, but this Court vide Order
dated 09.09.2008, referred the parties to the Sole Arbitrator. The Defendant
No.1 filed his Counter-Claim for recovery of sum of Rs.16,84,000/-, as
being the balance amount of the agreed sale consideration of the First and
Second Floor flats; to declare those Sale Deeds executed in favour of
nominees of Defendant No.2 as not conferring any ownership in the Parking
space as incorporated in the Sale Deed dated 12.07.2007 and to declared the
Agreement dated 01.07.2005 as forged and fabricated document.
The
Defendant No.1 also moved a separate Application for correction of
typographical error in the description of the date of Sale Deed, which was
mentioned as 12.07.2007 instead of 12.07.2006.
28.
The representative of M/s Reliance Infratel Ltd. M/s Shruti Chandra
made a statement in the Court on 03.03.2009 informing that the Company
was no longer intending to install Telecommunication Tower on the roof top
of the property in question. She stated that the Company had abandoned the
site. Plaintiff No.1 Deshraj Saluja thereafter, filed an Application under
Order XXIII Rule 1 CPC withdrawing his Suit with liberty to file a separate
Suit as he had a distinct cause of action. The learned Trial Court permitted
Sh. Deshraj Saluja to withdraw the Suit with liberty to file a fresh one by
Order dated 27.11.2012.
29.
The Suit was thus, continued only in the name of Sh. Arun Birla, the
Plaintiff/Appellant. Furthermore, the original Suit was amended to add an
additional prayer to seek Permanent Injunction for restraining Defendant
No.1, his employees etc. from causing hindrance/ obstruction in the use of
parking space of the Plaintiff and to refrain Defendant No.1 from using the
Parking space for his personal use.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 57/2018
30.
The Plaintiff in the Replication reaffirmed the assertions as made in
the Plaint and denied the allegations made in the Written Statement.
31.
The Issues were framed on 18.04.2016, which are as under:1.
Whether the plaintiff has no cause of action against the
defendant number one for filing the present suit? OPD
2.
Whether in the present suit is not valued properly for the
purpose of court fees? OPD1
3.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to decree of mandatory
injunction against the defendant number one as prayed in
the clause (a)? OPP
4.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to decree of mandatory
Injunction against the defendant number one as prayed
in the clause (B)? OPP
5.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to decree of permanent
injunction against the defendant number one as prayed in
the clause (C)? OPP
6.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to decree of mandatory
injunction against the defendant number one as prayed in
the clause (d)? OPP
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to decree of permanent
injunction against the defendant number one as prayed in
the clause (e)? OPP
7.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
8.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to decree of permanent
Injunction against the defendant number one as prayed
in the clause (f)? OPP
9.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to decree of permanent
injunction against the defendant number one as prayed in
the clause (g)? OPP
10.
Relief.
RSA 57/2018
32.
The Plaintiff examined PW1 Bharat Sawaria, Record Keeper, from
office of Sub-Registrar, who produced the original sale deeds Ex. PW1/1 to
Ex. PW1/6.
33.
The Plaintiff examined himself as PW-2 and tendered his evidence
by way of Affidavit, Ex.PW-2/A.
34.
The Defendant No.2 did not lead any evidence.
35.
The Defendant No. 1, Sh. Nirmal Singh, appeared as DW-1 and
tendered his evidence by way of Affidavit of evidence, Ex. DW-1/1.
36.
The learned Civil Judge in the impugned Judgment dated 20.07.2017,
denied the relief for removal of encroachment/ construction from the
Parking space on the ground that the Plaintiff had nothing to do with Lower
Ground Floor, except the Parking space as indicated at Mark P3 in the Site
Plan. Likewise, the relief of removal of unauthorized construction carried
out by Defendant No.1 was denied, as there was no substantial evidence in
respect of the alleged unauthorized construction. Additionally, the relief for
restoration of the Guard Room and to remove the commercial use of the said
room was denied, on the ground of absence of evidence in this regard.
Moreover, the MCD had already sealed the Guard room and it was held that
no Order of Restoration as prayed by the Plaintiff, could be passed. This
relief was also declined.
37.
However, the learned Civil Judge noted that in the Sale Deed dated
12.07.2008 Ex.PW1/6 vide which the Plaintiff Arun Birla had purchased the
suit property from the erstwhile owner Ms. Anita Lubana, clearly provided
that the Plaintiff was entitled to one Car parking space. It was also observed
that the Defendant No.1 in his cross-examination had admitted his signatures
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 57/2018
on the Sale Deed Ex.PW1/4, wherein it was recorded that the Second Floor
flat along with one individual car parking on the Ground Floor had been
transferred to Kavita Jain. DW1 had acknowledged the incorporation of
sale of Car Parking in the document Ex.DW1/4.
38.
It was also the evidence of Plaintiff that Defendant No.1 was creating
hindrance/obstruction in the parking of the vehicle by the Plaintiff at Point 1.
Consequently, relying on the Sale deed of the Plaintiff Ex.PW1/2 to
Ex.PW1/6 it was held that the Plaintiff was entitled to the Car parking
space at Point P3 in the Lower Ground Floor. Consequently, the Suit of the
Plaintiff was decreed in respect of the Car parking and the Defendants were
restraint from creating any hindrance/ obstruction in the Parking space at
P3 of the Plaintiff
39.
Aggrieved by the partial Decree of the Suit in respect of Car
parking in favour of the Plaintiff, the Defendant No.1 Nirmal Singh
filed RCA DJ No.71/2017 challenging the part Decree in favour of the
Respondent Arun Birla.
40.
The learned District Judge in the impugned Judgment dated
11.12.2017, observed that there was an inter-se dispute between the
Defendant No.1 and 2 in respect of inclusion of Car Parking in the Sale
Deeds and also in their inter-se Agreement. It was also noted that in the
Sale Deed Ex.PW1/4 the words “individual parking on Ground Floor” was
written by hand which was a clear interpolation. When this Sale Deed itself
was under challenge, no reliance can be placed on this document and the
subsequent documents/Sale Deed executed to recognize the right of the
Plaintiff to any parking slot. It was observed that these photographs had
been filed only on 09.03.2016 while the Suit had been filed way back in
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 57/2018
2008.
The photographs were held to be non-contemporaneous and the
Plaintiff could not derive any advantage from these photographs.
41.
It was further noted that Defendant No.1 in his testimony had deposed
that he did not know what was written in the Written Statement or the
Affidavit, but his statements made in the cross-examination were ignored by
the learned Trial Court, when it concluded that Defendant No.1 had admitted
his signatures on the Sale Deed Ex.PW1/4.
Furthermore, DW1 had
explained in his evidence that there is something over written at point C,
which was not a cutting but words written in hand referring to individual car
parking.
Therefore, Sale Deed Ex.PW1/4 had formed the basis for
recognizes any right of the Plaintiff qua the parking space. The photographs
Ex.DW1/P4 and P5 were also referred to which show that when Plaintiff and
Deshraj Saluja had tried to park their cars to see whether their cars could be
parked in the said spaces, in consonance with the Mediation proceedings and
they had immediately thereafter removed the same, which could not have
been brushed aside by the Trial Court.
42.
These events transpired subsequently when there was a mediated
settlement dated 11.11.2013, but it was not acted upon. There could not
have been a mention of this mediated Settlement in the pleadings, as it was a
subsequent event.
43.
It was thus, concluded that the Plaintiff could not have claimed a
right to car parking in the Lower Ground Floor, on the basis of Sale Deed
Ex.PW1/4 when it was under a cloud and the issue of its authenticity and
credibility, was pending before the competent Court. Consequently, the
Appeal was allowed and the Suit of the Plaintiff decreed partly granting
relief of right to park the car in the Lower Ground Floor at Point 3 and
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 57/2018
restraining Defendant Noi.1 from creating any hindrance/obstruction in the
use of space, was set aside.
44.
Aggrieved, the Plaintiff / Appellant, Arun Birla has filed the present
Regular Second Appeal under Section 100 read with Order XLII of
CPC, against the Judgment and Decree dated 11.12.2017 of the learned
District & Sessions Judge, dismissing the Suit.
45.
The grounds of challenge are that the facts and the evidence, have
not been appreciated in the right perspective. It has not been considered that
there was no cutting in the Sale Deed executed between Arun Birla and
Kavita Jain and the words “individual car parking on Ground Floor” which
had been hand written in the Sale Deed, had been counter signed by
Defendant no.1 who had admitted in his cross-examination that Appellant
Arun Birla had nothing to do with the dispute between Defendant No.1 and
Defendant No.2 and also that Plaintiff was not even in the picture at the time
when the inter-se dispute between the Defendants arose.
46.
There was no evidence led by Defendant no.1 to show that he had
never sold the car parking to the erstwhile respective owners, from whom
the property had been purchased by the Appellant.
Furthermore, the
Defendant No.1 had admitted that his Counter-Claim “of not selling the car
parking to the erstwhile owner,” was rejected by learned Arbitrator in the
Arbitration Award. The Respondent No.1 had challenged the Award under
Section 34 Arbitration and Conciliation Act and has already availed the
remedy available to him under the law, which had been dismissed and the
Appeal preferred before this Court, had also been rejected. His subsequent
Suit for Declaration, was barred under law.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 57/2018
47.
Furthermore, the admission of Defendant No.1 in his cross-
examination that he had sold the parking area to the erstwhile respective
owners from whom the Appellant had purchased the property, has also not
been appreciated.
The Defendant No.1 further admitted in his cross-
examination that he had converted the Guard Room, Kitchen and one Car
parking and had given them to the tenants, who were carrying on
commercial activity.
48.
Mere pendency of the subsequent Civil Suit by Defendant No.1 ought
not have been the basis to conclude that the parking area had been
transferred. Furthermore, this Suit for Declaration was filed in the year
2016, only to create confusion and to obtain favourable orders.
The
Appellate Court thus, erred in law by setting aside the Decree by relying
upon a subsequent Suit which is barred by limitation.
49.
It is further submitted that the Sale Deed executed in favour of the
Appellant, was well within the knowledge of Defendant No.1 since the year
2008, a fact admitted by him in his cross-examination. The subsequent Civil
Suit filed by Defendant No.1 is hopelessly barred by limitation and also by
law.
50.
The only fact for reversing the Judgment of the learned Civil Judge in
the Appeal was that the subsequent filing of Suit for Declaration, which
finding is perverse and the Plaintiff/Appellant could not have been nonsuited on this ground especially when the subsequent Suit for Declaration is
barred on the principle of res judicata and constructive res judicata.
Furthermore, the Defendant No.1 had never challenged the Sale Deed of the
Appellant from 2008 till 2015 and such objection cannot in any way stand in
the way of recognition of the right of the Appellant to the car parking.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 57/2018
51.
Furthermore, without any evidence, the learned District Judge has
come to the conclusion that the photographs of the Car of the Appellant
being parked in the dispute space, was taken at the time of Mediation. It has
not been considered that Defendant No.1 had never taken this stand that the
photographs pertains to the time of entering into the Mediation Settlement.
Moreover, the Defendant No.1 had admitted that Photograph Ex.DW1/P3
reflected the motor-cycle of the Appellant being parked in the Parking area
of the Ground Floor.
52.
It is submitted that the findings by the Appellate Court which rest
essentially on the Suit for Declaration filed by Defendant No.1 in 2016, is
perverse and baseless and is liable to be set aside.
53.
The proposed Substantial Question of Law in the Regular Second
Appeal are as under:
(1)
Whether the Appellate Court was wrong in
relying upon the subsequent suit filed by the respondent
No.1, as the said suit was never become part of the
pleading before Ld. Trial Court?
(2)
Whether the Appellate court was wrong in
relying upon the subsequent suit filed by the respondent
No.1, as the said suit is barred by law of limitation and
Appellate court ought not to have considered the said
subsequent suit?
(3)
Whether the Appellate Court is wrong in coming
to the conclusion that the title of the appellant is under
cloud, irrespective of the fact that the title document has
been proved in a court of law as a credible document?
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 57/2018
(4)
Whether the appellate court have overlook the
jurisdictional fact that the respondent No.1 never
challenged the sale deed of the appellant during the
pendency of the suit filed by the appellant and hence
subsequent suit filed by the respondent is barred under
order 2 Rule 2 CPC?
(5)
Whether the Appellate court was wrong in
relying upon the subsequent suit filed by the respondent
No.1, as the said suit is barred by principle of ResJudicata and Constructive Res-Judicata?
(6)
Whether the Appellate court can go into the
question and record its finding on the fact, when there
were no pleading in respect of it and during course of
trial, evidence was not led with the object of meeting such
plea?
(7)
Whether the Appellate court had failed to
consider the valuable material on record and has failed
to discharge its judicial obligation having substantial
impact on the rights of the appellant?
54.
It is, therefore, submitted that the impugned Judgment and Decree
dated 11.12.2017 of the Appellate Court may be set aside.
55.
The Appellant in his written submissions has relied on the grounds as
stated in the Appeal.
56.
The learned Counsel for the Respondent in the written submissions
has submitted that the First Appellate Court being the final Court of fact,
had done a comprehensive re-appreciation of the oral and documentary
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 57/2018
evidence and has set aside the findings of the learned Civil Judge on three
fundamental and inter-related aspects, which go to the root of the matter.
57.
The first is the absence of possession, as the Plaintiff had failed to
establish lawful continuous and settled possession over any specifically
identifiable car parking space on the date of institution of the Suit. The
material including photographs were found to be insufficient and unreliable
to prove the possession at the relevant time.
58.
The second ground is that there was a cloud over the title since the
claim of the Plaintiff was based on the recital in the Sale Deed which was
not free from cloud. The competency to convey exclusive rights in the
Lower Ground Floor area was seriously disputed thereby rendering the
claim of the Plaintiff legally uncertain and incapable of being accepted on
face value.
59.
Thirdly, there was an active and bona fide challenge to the Plaintiff‟s
title which was not illusory or superficial, but was consistent and bona fide
challenge by the Defendant through counter-claim and independent
proceedings. On the cumulative consideration of the aforesaid aspects, the
First Appellate Court has rightly interfered and set aside the partial Decree
granted by the learned Trial Court.
60.
It is further submitted that this being a Regular Second Appeal under
Section 100 CPC, the scope of consideration is confined to Substantial
Question of Law arising from the impugned Judgment. The findings of the
Appellate Court unless shown to be contrary to law or unsupported by
evidence, ordinarily do not want interference.
The conclusions of the
Appellate Court are based on due appreciation of the evidence on record and
legal principles governing the grant of injunction.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 57/2018
61.
The Respondent has asserted that institution of a separate Declaratory
Suit by the Defendant, constitutes a legitimate exercise of substantive civil
rights and cannot be treated as a procedural impropriety. It is settled that
where a document relied upon by the Plaintiff creates a cloud over the rights
of another party, such party is entitled to receive affirmative relief by way of
Declaration in the independent proceedings.
The mere fact that such
proceedings were initiated, does not disentitle the Defendant from contesting
the Plaintiff‟s entitlement to Injunction in the present Suit.
62.
It has been further explained that in the Counter-Claim filed before
the Arbitrator in the year 2008 against Defendant No.2, the Respondent/
Defendant No.1 had specifically disputed the validity of the Sale Deed and
the alleged incorporation of Parking rights therein. The learned Arbitrator,
however, declined to adjudicate upon the said Counter-Claim on the ground
of lack of jurisdiction and no relief was granted in this regard.
63.
It clearly demonstrates that the Respondent had consistently and
bona fide disputed the Plaintiff‟s alleged entitlement at every stage and the
inability to secure adjudication was only on account of jurisdictions
limitations and not on merits. The institution of independent proceedings,
thereafter, were thus a legitimate exercise of his legal rights and cannot be
construed as disentitling the Respondent to contest the present Suit.
64.
It was further submitted that the Declaratory Suit filed by the
Defendant, was dismissed on account of deficiency of Court Fee which was
procedural in nature and was not an adjudication on the merits of the
challenge raised to the Plaintiff‟s claim. The Defendant/ Respondent being
a Senior Citizen suffers from multiple medical ailments and has limited
financial means and was unable to comply with the requirement of payment
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 57/2018
of additional Court Fee within time. Such dismissal, however, neither
invalidated the Plaintiff‟s alleged title nor precluded the Defendant from
continuing to dispute the legal efficacy and scope of the purported transfer
of exclusive parking rights.
65.
The burden continues to be on the Plaintiff to establish a clear
enforceable entitlement as well as lawful possession on the date of
institution of the Suit.
The Respondent has relied upon Balkrishna
Dattatraya Galande vs. Balkrishna Rambharose Gupta & Anr. Civil Appeal
No.1509 of 2019, wherein it is held that the Suit for Permanent Injunction
under Section 38 Specific Relief Act, the Plaintiff must establish actual and
physical possession over the Suit property as on the date of institution of the
Suit.
66.
The Supreme Court in Ramji Rai vs. Jagdish Mallah (2007) 14 SCC
200 reiterated that possession as on the date of filing of the Suit, is a sine
qua non for grant of Decree of Permanent Injunction.
67.
The Supreme Court in Anathula Sudhakar vs. P. Buch Reddy (2008) 4
SCC 594 has authoritatively laid down the general principle that a mere Suit
for Permanent Injunction is not maintainable in the circumstances when a
Declaratory relief or recovery of Possession is mandatorily required in the
facts of given case.
68.
The mere filing of a Permanent Injunction when there exists a
substantial and genuine cloud on the right of the Plaintiff to seek Parking
rights exists, simpliciter Suit for Permanent Injunction was not maintainable.
69.
Similar observations were made by the Supreme Court in S. Santhana
Lakshmi & Ors. vs. D. Rajammal, SLP (Civil) No.18943 of 2024 and
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 57/2018
reiterated by the Supreme Court in Jharkhand State Housing Board vs.
Didar Singh (2019) 17 SCC 692.
70.
The learned Appellate Court has re-appreciated the evidence and has
correctly observed that the learned Trial Court had misdirected itself in
treating the inconclusive documentary recitals and post dispute photographs
as determined to prove of entitlement and possession. The findings are well
reasoned, evidence based and do not suffer from any perversity or
jurisdictional error.
71.
The re-evaluation of pure findings of fact and substitution of
conclusions as sought by way of this present Regular Second Appeal is not
permissible and is not within the limited scope of interference in the Regular
Second Appeal. It is claimed that no substantial question of law survives for
consideration and the Appeal deserves to be set aside.
Submissions heard and record perused.
72.
The Substantial Questions of Law were framed by this Court on
09.10.2018, as under:
(i)
(ii)
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 57/2018
Whether the respondent/defendant No.1 was
entitled to, instead of in his defence to the suit of
the appellant/plaintiff taking a plea impugning the
documents on the basis of which the
appellant/plaintiff was claiming a right, file a
separate suit therefore and whether the
appellant/plaintiff could be deprived of the relief
in the suit merely for the reason of institution of
the other suit.
Whether the First Appellate Court was justified,
for the reasons given at internal page 17 of the
judgment, to interfere with the findings of fact of
the Suit Court.
73.
This Suit pertains to a dispute in regard to one car parking space on
the Lower Ground Floor of the Property in-question, which the Plaintiff, Sh.
Arun Birla, claimed to have purchased vide Sale Deed dated 11.07.2008. It
is not in dispute that the property in-question was owned by Defendant
No.1, Sh. Nirmal Singh, who entered into an Agreement with Defendant
No.2, Sh. Yashwant Jain, for demolition of the existing construction on the
said plot and for reconstruction of the entire Property from the Lower
Ground Floor till Third Floor.
74.
Defendant No.1, Sh. Nirmal Singh and Defendant No.2, Sh.
Yashwant Jain, entered into an Advance Receipt-cum-Agreement to Sell and
Purchase dated 13.04.2005 Ex.DW-1/1, wherein the entire terms of
construction and the purchase of the floors were agreed and determined. In
the said Agreement, it was noted that Sh. Nirmal Singh had agreed as under:
“And whereas the First Party has further agreed to
sell, convey, transfer and assign to the Second Party / his
nominee and the Second Party / his nominee has agreed to
purchase the Upper Ground Floor, First Floor, Second
Floor portions, each consisting of furnished three Bed
Rooms, Drawing / Dining, Kitchen, Toilet-cum-bath along
with all fittings, fixtures & proportionate undivided, right to
use common entrance, passage, staircase, services &
facilities provided in the building and individual space for
three car paring on ground level & easement attached
thereto on the said property, with all easements, rights and
appurtenance attached thereto, (hereinafter referred to as
the said Property) unto the Second Party and the Second
Party has agreed to purchase the said property, for a total
sale consideration of Rs.69,00,000/- (Rupees Sixty Nine
Lacs Only).
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 57/2018
And WHEREAS upon the aforesaid assurance of this
First Party / First Party and the Second Party has agreed to
purchase the said property from the First Party, on the
following agreed terms and conditions of this Agreement.”
75.
Defendant No.2, Sh. Yashwant Jain, invoked arbitration in respect of
this Agreement to Sell. Undeniably, Defendant No.1 Sh. Nirmal Singh,
executed the Sale Deed dated 12.07.2006 Ex.PW-1/4 in the name of Smt.
Kavita Jain, Nominee of Defendant No.2, in respect of Second Floor of the
Property in question. In this Agreement to Sell, while describing the Suit
Property, i.e. unfinished Flat on Second Floor, it was described that it
comprised of three Bed Rooms, Drawing / Dining, Kitchen, two Toilet-cumbath, Balcony with proportionate, undivided, indivisible rights in the land
underneath together with the right to use common entrance, passage,
staircase, submersible pump facility as provided in the building and the
easements attached thereto. The words ‘one individual big car parking on
the Lower Ground Floor’ was inserted with pen. The entire claim of
Defendant No.1 was that there was an interpolation in the Sale Deed
executed in favour of Ms. Kavita Jain, as he had never agreed to sell one big
car parking space on the Lower Ground Floor. He asserted that he was an
illiterate person and the Clause had been inserted fraudulently.
76.
It is not in dispute that the construction of the property was carried out
in terms of Agreement to Sell, but thereafter, disputes arose between
Defendant Nos.1 and 2 and Defendant No.2 invoked the Arbitration, before
whom Defendant No.1 Sh. Nirmal Singh, filed a Counter-claim challenging
that there was no Agreement in respect of the three car parking, in the Lower
Ground Floor.
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 57/2018
77.
The said Counter-claim of Defendant No.1 was dismissed by the
learned Arbitrator, and Defendant No.1 failed to succeed in his objections
under Section 34 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, and further in
the Appeal, preferred against the dismissal of the objections under Order
XXXIV CPC.
78.
Not succeeding in the Arbitration proceedings, Defendant No.1 filed a
Suit for Declaration to claim that there was no Agreement of Selling the car
parking along with the three individual Floors. However, it has not been
denied that this Suit had been filed much in 2016, after the dismissal of the
Appeal to the Arbitration Award, to challenge the Agreement to Sell dated
13.04.2005. However, this Declaratory Suit has also been dismissed.
79.
Defendant No.1 though asserted that he never agreed to sell a big car
parking space and there was an interpolation in the First Sale Deed executed
by him in favour of Ms. Kavita Jain, and that, being an illiterate person, he
been taken advantage of, however, as already noted above, all his
endeavours to challenge this Sale Deed, met with no success.
80.
Furthermore, in the original Agreement to Sell dated 13.04.2005
Ex.DW-1/1 between Defendant Nos.1 and 2, it was specifically agreed that
the three Floors, i.e., 1st, 2nd and 3rd Floor, would have one big car
parking space each in the Lower Ground Floor. When this was the original
understanding and the Agreement between Defendant Nos.1 and 2, it was
wrongly asserted by Defendant No.1 that there was an interpolation in
regard to mentioning of the car parking in the Sale Deed executed by him in
favour of Ms. Kavita Jain / Nominee of Defendant No.2.
81.
Learned Civil Judge had rightly appreciated the documents and
held that in fact, this Sale Deed in favour of Ms. Anita Lubana had been
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 57/2018
duly signed on each page by both Mr. Nirmal Singh as well as Ms. Anita
Lubana and only much later, he had tried to unsuccessfully challenge the
Sale Deed.
82.
It is significant to observe that the property had been purchased by
Ms. Anita Lubana vide the Registered Sale Deed dated 27.06.2007 Ex.
PW1/5 from Ms. Kavita Jain and thereafter, by the Plaintiff Mr. Arun Birla
vide Sale Deed dated 11.07.2008 Ex.PW1/6. In the Sale Deed of Ms. Anita
Lubana and Mr. Arun Birla, it has been clearly typed in running in their
respective Sale Deed, that sale of the flat was along with one car parking in
the lower ground floor.
83.
Therefore, learned Civil Judge has rightly held that the Plaintiff
was entitled to car parking space in the Lower Ground Floor.
84.
However, the learned Appellate Court heavily relied upon the
challenge of Defendant No.1 to the Sale Deed before various forums and the
pendency of the challenge to the Sale Deed before the Court and also the
pendency of the Civil Suit. However, all ligation including Civil Suit have
been decided against Defendant No.1, thereby establishing Plaintiff‟s right
to have one car parking in the Lower Ground Floor.
85.
In view of these findings and also the subsequent events, it is evident
that the findings of learned District Judge in the impugned Judgment were
patently perverse and there was no reason to interfere with the wellreasoned Judgment of the learned Civil Judge or deny the car parking space
to the Plaintiff.
86.
In light of the aforesaid discussions, impugned Judgment and decree
dated 11.12.2017 of the learned District and Sessions Judge is hereby, set
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 57/2018
aside and the Judgement and Decree dated 20.07.2017 of learned Civil
Judge is restored.
87.
Accordingly, the Appeal is allowed and disposed of, along with the
pending Applications.
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
JUDGE
AUGUST 04, 2026
RS/VA
DigitallySigned By:RITA
SHARMA
17:18:37
RSA 57/2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review