Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3300 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(SPecial Original Jurisdiction)
TUESDAY, THE TWENTY FOURTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETIT ION NO: 32541 OF 2025
Between:
ARGOU TECHNOLOGIES PRIVATE LllvllTED, Represented by its Director,
'1
Manne Swathi, W/o.f\/alikarjun, Age.32 years' Occ.Director, O/o 1-1 4-359/1 ,
Siri Nagar Colony, Beside Redbucked LB Nagar, Hyderabad, RangaReddy500074.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. Divisional Railway [/lanager, office sanchalan Bhavan, Secunderabad
Division, South Central Railway, Secunderabad, Telangana-500025'
2. Principal/chief commercial fi/anager, office First floor of Rail Nilayam,
Secunderabad-500025.
3. Senior Divisional commercial Manager, Office 3rd floor of sanchalan Bhavan,
Sarojini Devi Road, Secunderabad-500071 .
4. Divisional Commercial lr'lanager, Sanchalan Bhavan, l st floor, Commercial
Branch,secunderabadDivision,southCentralRailwaySecunderabada500003.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the constitution of lndia praying that in the
pleased
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
toissueawrit,orderordirectionmoreparticularlyoneinthenatureofwritof
mandamus declaring the action of the 3rd Respondent issued Termination order
dated.16/10/2025 is illegal, highly unwarranted, highly arbitrary, unfair' unjust,
irrational, unlaMul and violative of Article 14 and 21 of the Constitution of lndia and
consequently set aside the same.
l.A. NO: 1OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circurr jtances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the writ petition, the High Court ma1 be pleased to grant
interim suspension of Termination Order dated.16l10l2o2l issued by the 3rd
Respondent pending disposal of the above writ petition.
l.A. NO: 2OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circurr ;tances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the writ petition, the High court ma7 be pleased to direct
the Respondents permit the petitioner to operate the BOC C z rs at Secunderabad
Railway Station pending disposal of the above writ petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: M/s. VLADIMEER KHATOON
Counsel for the Respondents: SMT N.V.R.RAJYA LAKSHM ,
SC FOR CENTRAL GOVT. repr :senting
SRI N.BHUJANGA RAO,
DEPUTY SOLICITOR GENERA . OF INDIA
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR THE STATE OF
TELANGANA
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION No. 3254L OF 2025
24.O2.2026
Between:
ARGOU TECH NOLOGItrS PRIVATE LIMITtrD,
Rep. by its Director Manne Swathi
Pctitioner
And
Divisional Railway Manager,
Secunderabad Division & others
Respondents
ORDER:
The case of petitioner, as pleaded, is that pursuant
to the e-Auction dated 26.07.2025 issued by the 3''t respondent
for provision, operation and management of three batteryoperated cars at Secunderabad Raihvay Station. petitioner
participated and was declared successful. Consequent thereto,
on line Contract Agreement was entered into on 31.O7 .2025 for
a period of Iive years commencing from 25.08.2025 and ending
on 24.O8.2O3O with an annual licence fee of Rs.33,OO, i 1 1/- and
a total contract value of Rs. 1 ,94,70,654.90. It is lurther pleaded
that the Earnest Money Deposit rvas paid on 26.07.2025 uide
Bank Transactron ID LM918647 57 with IRtrPS Relerence ID-
3109751 and that after commencement of the contract,
petitioner appointcd two supervisors and scvet drivers for
opcration of the battcry opcrated cars.
1- 1
.
It is statccl, pctitioncr admitted that ,r I 19.O9.2O25
an incident ocr:urred at I'latform No.1O whcn the operator
Mr. Anand, aftcr dropping passcngers, haltcd tl e vchicle lor
collecting cash and thc battery-operated car rollerl back ancl fell
onto the track. PeIitioner plcaded that apprehelrl ng danger in
the event of arrival of a train, the operator, u'i , the help of
persons present or-r the platform, repositioned tlr: vehicle and
drove it along the track to the end of thc rlatform ar-rd
thereafter, through a ramp to Platforms 6 and l. An enquiry
was conducted on 19.09.2025 by the 4tl) Respc,r denl, during
which the operator explained the circutnstances. rdmitted that
railway officials tvere not informed, assured th: I the incidet-rt
would not recur, arnd agreed to be permanently cmoved frorn
servicc. Pelitioner's supervisor requestcd that t.l: incident be
treatcd as a last u,arning stating that it was a ltr-'1 instance and
that thc petitioncr was ncw to thc contra.ct.
|-2.
Petitioner statcs that thereafter, thc 'l' Respondent
issued a temporary suspension order datcd 19.t 9.2025 citit'tg
thc safetl, incidcnt ancl anticipatcd heavS, passeng r r rush duritlg
Dussehra, Deepavali and Chhath festivals, suspt: Lding all BOC
operations frorn 20.O9.2025 to 28.1O.2025. Ft presentations
dated 23.O9.2O25 and 06.10.2025 were submitted seeking
revocation oI suspension, expressing unconditional apologr,
stating that thc incider-rt was accidental, and arssuring
implcmentation of corrective measures including clriver training
ancl strict monitoring, but the same were not considcrcd.
Howcver, without considcring the representations, tl-re 3.1
Rcspondent issued Termination Order dated 16. 10.2025
alleging violation of Clause 18. 1 of the Standard Conditions of
Contract, forfeiting the full security deposit of Rs.3,30,O11/
and directing immediate removal of all BOCs and ecluipment.
1.3.
Petitioner states that no passenger sustained any
inj ury in the incident and that the operator acted only to
prevent any untoward occurrence. The contract had commenced
only 23 days prior to the incident and was valid for a periocl of
live years titt 2O3O, and that a request was made durrng enquiry
to trcat the incident as a last warning. According to petitioner,
termination caused severe financial hardship as loans u'cre
taken to start the busincss, vehicles rvere insured, salaries errc
bcing paid to drivers and supervisors despite stoppage of rvork,
zrnd the petitioner's family is entirely dependent on the said
busincss.
2.
In the counter filed on behalf of Respondents, it is
stated, the contract for operation and maintenance of three
.1
battcry-opcratr:d cars at Sccunderabad Railwav
ar,,,ardcd to l)ctltioner [or a pcriod of hve
itation u'as
years fro;t 25 08.2025
to 24.O8.20'',O .rt zlll ett'ltluzrl licensc fce of R" 33'("
.111/-, vidc
Agrcemcnt No MSS SC-SC-BCA-26 23- 1
31.o7.2025.
Pursuaut to tllc arvartl o[ thc contract' the
dated
licensei: raid the first
quartcrlv liccusc fce of Rs 8'25'O2S/- and
operatiotls rvitl'r thrcc battcry-operatcd cars
cornmetrccd
from ! 5 08 2025 It
is stated that on \9 (\g 2025 at about 16:45
hourI ' intbrmation
wasreccivedbytlrcRailrvayautlroritiesthatab:Ltery-operated
car was drivt'tl on the railway tracks at
Secundr t ebad Railway
Statiott
2.1.
It is stated that a preliminary repr'; t was soLlght
from the Chtcl Comrnercial lnspector'
Secunderr rad (CCI/SC)'
and as pel 1[ie said report' it rvas conhrmed
operated ('zl rt was rlriven on the railway
operator Mr. Anand . Cor-rside ring thc
tt I t the battery-
tracl: by the BOC
gravity of tir incident ' oral
instructions rvcrc issucd to the Chief
Commc t :ial [nspector'
Sccundcraba<l (CCI/SC), to immcdiately
operatcd car opcratiot'rs at Secunderabad
ccas: all battcry-
Railu I 1' Station' and
accordingll' all BOC services werc stopped'
O I 18 09'2025' a
Cautionlraclerlrca<lybecnissuedtothesulervisorolthc
a i the incidcnt
licensce rcgarciing safc opcration of BOCs
occurred otr the very next day' i'e'' 19 O9'2021i
an<I in rriew of
)
the heary passenger rush anticipated during the ensuing
festival season, it was considered necessary as a preventive
measure to suspend such unsafe operations and enforce strict
compliance with safety norms.
2.2.
It is further stated that an interim joint inspection
was conducted by the Station Manager (SMR)/ Gaz/ SC, Chief
Commercial Inspector (CCI)/SC and Assistant Sub-Inspector
(ASI)/RPF/SC. As per the inspection report, on 19.O9.2025 at
16:45 hours, the BOC stationed on Platform No.10 near the
main portico fell onto the track while the driver was reversing
the vehicle after de boarding passengers. Upon being informed
by onlookers, the on-duty CCI, Sri B.K. Sinha reported the
matter to the Station Manager, Gaz/SC, who immediately
contacted the RRI cabin'and instructed that train operations on
the affected track be halted to ensure safety of passengers and
Railway assets. It is stated that although the toppled BOC was
stabilizecl with tire help of catering vendors, OBHS stalf and
parcel handling staff, the operator, without seeking
authorization or guidance from Railway ofTicials, drove the BOC
on the railway track towards the pathway, an eLct witnessed by
passengcrs.
lt is also stated that riding an unauthc -ized vehrcle
on raihvay tracks, thercby endangering pass lngcrs and
2-3.
intcrfcring with train operations, is illegal and
protL. rited. Be fore
taking action, the liccnsee was provided a fair c
portunity to
explain the inciclent and its repe rcussions' Durin I
the enquiry,
the licensee admitted that the incident occurre(
due to the
mistake of the operator Mr' Anand and acknowlecl
ed that such
lapses could have serious consequences affect
g passenger
t
safety and train oPerations' The operator ac I
independentll' without informing
litted acting
any Railwa I
admitted seeking assistance from other contractl
authoritY,
i I staff on the
platform, ancl admittecl driving the BOC on the
rack without
permission. It was admitted that had authorities : :en informed'
proper guidance could have been provided' el d that
conduct could have led to derailment if a train hz 1
such
approached
the track.
2.4 .
It is stalecl furthcr that the licenset admitted that
submitted
the recluired insurancc was still awaited lt is ful :rer
that Exhibit P9 at page 5O is mislcading, as C't use 22 of the
Special Conditior-rs of Corltract mandates insurar ce
coverage of
at least Rs.23O lakhs for four passengers, whe- as Exhibit P9
reflects only Rs-25 lakhs under Public Liabilitl' z nd not for the
strpulated purpose, resulting in non-complianc t with Clauses
O and 22 ol tt,e Special Conditions of Contract. Ciause 10 of
the Special Conditions of Contract mandates adequate safety
training to drivers and places sole responsibility for provision,
operation and maintenance of BOCs on the licensee.
2.5.
It is statecl that the letter dated 18.09.2025 was
issued by the office of the Senior Divisional Commercial
Manager to the licensee regarding safe operation of BOCs, and
counselling was conducted by CCI/SC for all operators on the
Joint Procedure Order. Despite such counselling a day prior, the
operator acted negligently, showing disregard for safety. The
licensee admitted failure to fulfil contractual obligations
including issuance of ID cards to operators and providing
insurance coverage for unnamed passengers. It is stated that in
vierv of the enquiry report, personal hearing and paramount
consideration of passenger salety and Railway assets, the
Railway Administration was constrained to terminate the
contract undcr Clause 18.1 of thc Special Conditions of
Contract, '"vhich empowers termination without notice for
violation of contract terms or serious misconduct, including
violation of the Railways Act, 1989, with forfeiture of full
trMD/ Security Deposit.
2.6.
After following due proccdure .r d
affording
opportunity of hearing, the contract was terminat rd u,ith effect
from 16.1O.2025 and a termination letter was issr.r :d. Accordrng
to re spondcnts, termination was necessitated c r c to serious
lapses by the licensee and operator and to enst re passenger
safety at Secunderabad Railway Statron, which hz.r dles lakhs of
passengers daily- It is stated that driving a vehic c on railway
tracks without authorization constitutes an l Ience under
Section 161 of the Railways Act, 1989, and driviri; dangerously
endangering public safety is punishable under li :ctior-r 184 of
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 as atnended it 2019. The
L
terminatton was a punitive measure strictly in acr ordance with
Clause 18. 1 of the Standard Conditions of Contra : and Lhat the
full EMD/Security Deposit was rightly forfeited. r s per Clause
22 of t!;,e Indian Railway Standard General lonclitions of
I
Contract, the petitioner ought to have invoke: thc dispute
resolution and arbitrzrtion mechanism, which was rot zrvailed.
3.
Hcard Sri Vladimeer Khatoon, learn: 1 counsel for
petitioner and Smt. N.V. R. Rajya Lakshmi, 1ea r red Standing
Counsel for Rcspondent No. 1
4.
.
The contcntion of the petitioncr that no passenger
was injured does not dilute the gravity of thc mis<:r nduct. Safety
jurisprudence mandates that preventive action i:, justified even
in absence of actual injury. The respondents have demonstrated
that train operations had to be halted and that the incident
occurred during peak hours with heavy passenger movement.
The plea that the contract had commenced only 23 days prior
cannot override contractual obligations expressly undertaken by
the petitioner, particularly Clauses 10, 18.1 and 22 of the
Special Conditions of Contract.
5.
The record further establishes that petitioner failed
to comply with mandatory insurance requirements and failed to
ensure proper training and supervision of operators. The
enquiry conducted on 19.O9 .2025 provided an opportunity to
the petitioner, during which admissions were made regarding
lapses. The temporary suspension order dated 19 .O9 .2025
clearly recorded reasons relating to safety and anticipated healy
passenger rush during Dussehra, Deepavali and Chhath
festivals. The termination order dated 16. 1O.2O25 was issued
after considering the enquiry, admissions and contractual
violations, hence invocation of Articles 14 and 27 is
misconceived. The termination was based on objective material,
contractual provisions and safety considerations and cannot be
termed arbitrary or irrational. Courts exercising jurisdiction
under Article 226 d,o not sit as appellate authorities over
contractual decisions taken by expert bodies unless perversity
IO
or mala fides are established No such grounds ar(r made
out in
the present case.
6.
Interference by thc High Court irL contractual
matters is limited only to cases where the action o the
State or
its instrumentalities is shown to be patenl F arbitrary'
provisions
discriminatory, mala hde, or in violation of statut: y
or constitutional manclates Mere breach of contr I lt'
erroneous
t
interpretation of contractual clauses' or harsh onsequences
flowing from contractual enforcement do not' t' themselves'
warrant invocation of writ jurisdiction'
The plea of financial hardship' tl ough noted'
cannot override pubiic safety and contrac[rr Ll disciptine'
7.
Railway Administration handles lakhs of passen[:rs
daily and
cannot adoPt a lenient approach in matters ill'olving
safety
violations. Petitioner also failed to exhaust .l e alternative
dispute resolution mechanism providcd under Cir
rrst: 22 of the
Indian Railu'ay Standard General Conditions o Contract'
In
view of the admitted facts, contractual prov: ions enquiry
Act' 1989
findings and statutory obligations under the Railvays
andtheMotorVehiclesAct,lg88,thisCourtfir:<snoillegality'
arbitrariness or constitutional inhrmity in the ter
nination order
dated 16.10.2025. The writ petition is devoid of r: :rit'
1l
8.
Accordingly, the Writ petition stands dismissed. No
COS tS.
9.
Consequently, the miscellaneous Applications, if
any shall stand closed.
S
//TRUE COPY//
o/ . L. VIJAYA LAX
R
ST ANT REG
ECTION OFFICER
To,
Advocate OP cl
One CC to tril/s VLADIMEER KHATOON'
ITOR GENERAL OF
N.BHUJANGA RAO, DEPUTY S
2 One CC to SR I
at HYd era ad [oPUC]
lNDlA, High Cou rt for the State of Telangana
3. Two CD CoPies
BSq
YV
CC TODAY
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2410212026
^::::.-;-1",
.,i
.,:.
...1'ri'
ORDER
I
WP.No.32541 ot 2025
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITION,
WITHOUT COSTS
^ee,\
() (9Y,
k"'
_,
,,_-o.,t i: /.. _
t: Hl,'i
'-
ei
l" \1.
.. .
2[2fi
i
,\."
,..'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review